Any respect for the law . With all the changes and the delays hes making to obama care, some are asking this important question. Does he have the legal right to do it . A top constitutional scholar is calling foul on all of this and he is going to join us tonight. All those stories and much more coming up on the kudlow report, beginning right now. First up, this evening lets talk earnings. How will the quarter shake out . Cnbcs own bob fa is asani has details. It was a risk day, with major outperformance from transportation stocks and Home Building stock, material, energy, financials were strong as well. And even though a lot of people are convinced this will be another lackluster quarter for Earnings Growth, you know the s p 500 is within roughly 1 of a historic high. Now, my take on earnings this quarter is pretty simple. The estimates are for Earnings Growth of 1 to about 3 . They vary. But the final number invariably is three points higher than the initial number for start of the quarters so earnings are likely to be up 4 to 6 . Thats below the historic average. The average is 8 growth. But its not disaster. What about the flat top line growth everyone is worried ab . I dont like it either. But if we get better economic growth, thats going to change too. Now remember, larry, just like nobody believed in the stock market rally for the last years, nobody believes the u. S. Economy can stand on its own two feet with the fed behind it but that may be another fallacy. Many thanks to our friend. Heres our quick take. Stocks discounted the feds de facto policy tightening at 100 basis point rise. In a lightning bolt. In fact, stocks are moving up with rates together. That could be a really good growth signal. I like golds stabilizing, which takes the heat off some deflationary worries at least for now. Were going to be tested again later this year. Investors, keep your eyes open. When the fed moves to end bond buying and the treasury goes up another basis points to 3. 5 to 4 , i say to investors keep your eyes open. But for right now, enjoy the summer fun. This story is turning out better than many people thought. Now lets welcome alec young, from s p capital i. Q. Michael holland chairman of holland and company and ron kashefski. Michael, you said the cycle is going to take the dow to 20,000. Before i go see my optometrist, tell me about dow 20,000 if you would. Well, no predictions here, but i dont see why 20,000 is a particularly daunting number for where we are right now and all of the things that you and bob fasani just said. If we get a move in earnings you get two or three price earning points on the s p. When we continue to have lessening of the fear that is caused by the fiveyear bull market, when you have those things come together, thats that is a 30 move. That is a dow 20,000. Its not a crazy number. In fact, i think its eminently doable. On this show not that many years ago, you and i talked about dow 15,000. And were here. We are here. We are indeed. 15,300. Ron, you heard the distinguished michael holland. Whats your take on his dow 20 . Well, you know, look, larry, i think this has been an equilibrium rally and my take is as that fair value, the tenyear about 3. 5 and the s p 500 at 11 151750. And when we get there well need Earnings Growth. We will get Earnings Growth. Look, i think 110 next year, stocks are undervalued. You know, some of the Earnings Growth numbers are pretty optimistic. All right, alec young, in order for this rally to continue this summer rally, before we look down the road at fed actions and higher Interest Rate, you have to have earnings. I thought bob gave a good account. They come in at 6, 6 may not be fabulous, but were in the fifth year of an economic recovery. Whats your earnings take and i want to particularly ask you about the stellar performance in the transport index which kind of tells me the economy and e n earnings may be better off than we think. We think were transitioning to a more fundamentally driven market, so its great to see the economy showing signs of life in terms of how that translates into earnings, the consensus for this quarter as bob mentioned i think he got that data from us at capital i. Q. Is 2. 9 for this quarter. Companies have been beating it by about 3 for the last couple of years so were expecting 5 or 6 this quarter. In the second half, they have it ramping up to 7 in q3 and then again another double digit gain for next year. We are being a little more conservative and were looking for maybe 7 or 8 over the next 12 months. But you have to get it. If you dont get it youre in trouble. Is that fair . Absolutely. Absolutely. But earnings have been the backbone of this rally going back to the very beginning, people say its about the fed, i have never believed that. I felt it had so much to do with earnings. Along with the fed. So if you dont get your 7 to 8 then what happens . Well, then you have a big problem. Especially now that were transitioning towards the fundamentally driven rally. Their participation is key. Theyre stepping away. Earnings become that much more important. We think the consensus in the low double digits for next year, we think 122 for 2014. That may be a bit high, but we think 115 is doable. If you put a 15. 5 type multiple on that you can get the s p into the 1800 range over the next 12 months and especially given the emerging melt down that were starting to see in a lot of areas of bond land, we think stocks are definitely the place you want to be. Bonds may be stabilizing, but i think youre quite realistic. I believe you talk about the 3. 5 or 4 Interest Rate. Thats my number so thats roughly the growth of the overall nominal gdp of the economy. Stocks continue to rise as Interest Rates rise. Thats been the pattern now. Can it continue . Well, absolutely, larry. The reason that stocks are going to rise while Interest Rates rise is because Interest Rates are rising because the economy is Getting Better. This isnt hard stuff. The question will be is when we get back off of the fed ventilator if you will, we need Earnings Growth. But today, right now, today, stocks are still under value. Right now. Right now. All right. My let me go. You have some interesting stuff besides transports. Home builders booming today. Fedex had a big day. Amazon, honey well, starbucks had a big day. What do you like here . How do you leverage your dow 20,000 into specific picks . Theres no way you have that pleasant an outcome over the next several quarters, larry, if you dont have techs and financials in the forefront. The banks are up 24 year to date and you have stock less than ten times earnings with nearly nearly a 3 yield. In the blue chip tech stocks theyre ridiculously beaten. You have an earnings of less than ten times, you have intel, google, ibm. Ibm getting hit. Intel getting hit the last couple of days. These stocks are really cheap. Even if you dont get the everyonings growth you were talking about earlier, we dont have a lot of down side with these companies because theyre so cheap as they are right now. What about youre a china expert. Youre a China Investment director. What about the china story . The the imf downgraded a lot of the emerging countrys economies today. It downgraded the usa a little bit. I dont particularly agree with that. But china, how big a factor might china be . So far i heard all positive sweet tunes from you. Any negatives out there . Yeah, its a short term negative. That is if the new government always comes in every ten years theyre going to slow things down a little bit because theyll put in the financial reforms, but the slow down is down to like 6, 7, 8 , maybe 7 this year. Thats down from 10 the last year. Im not an expert, but what i have learned is listen to the companies. We just had a company today, alcoa, tell us their business in china is looking pretty solid. Now, thats a very good indicator. The companies im listening to see things have slowed down, but there are still solids so that gives me hope that japans increase in the outbreak will offset some of the slowdown in china. Japan was upgraded by the imf. I thought that was interesting. Its kind of funny, this was supposed to be a bad summer. Bad summer season. A lot of catastrophic things, but as we said at the top, the whole bond market thing was discounted. Whos running the american economy, whos the key driver that we should be listening to and looking at . Clearly the fed is playing a smaller role. We think that private sector is capable of filling the shoes. So we have always watched the economic data, but i think that becomes even more important as we start to enter the tapering phase which we think happens in the fed is moving out. Bernanke said were pulling out of town. Well see that in the next 6 to 12 months. How about this, how about business . How about business . I will argue that business in spite of washington, in spite of the fed, in the main has run this economy during this, you know, sub par recovery, but theyre still eking out 2 to 3 . Its business we should be looking at and yet, its profits because profits are the mothers milk of stocks and business. Yep. I think people are looking in terms of the second half recovery to see business, you know, be better, take it up. Take a better role. One thing to throw out there in terms of how to play the thing, we are looking at domesti domes cyclicals. We think the bond proxy stocks have had their heyday. We want to focus on the u. S. Not as convinced that china isnt something thats going to continue to be a head wind. Ron, i want you to comment on my thought, that it is business running this country. Washington may not like that. The president right now is bogged down in a lot of problems of his own. Were not seeing much from him. Were not going to see a lot of policy activism from washington. Which i think is absolutely terrific. And boys, would you add banks to business as the real drivers of this economy . Well, banks need to, you know, provide credit. This economy is still missing credit or credit creation. But look, larry, entrepreneurs are the ones that create jobs. Not government. So, you know, its that way. Ill end with this thought for you. The market is figuring out when the fed does taper, its good. Yeah. Theres what the market is figuring out. Otherwise were japan. Do we want zero Interest Rate for the next ten years . No, i dont think so. The fed will stop all the tampering and the tinkering and its confusion and all of these reserve Bank President s when they start yapping and yelping wont be that important anymore. I cant wait for the day. Its a hallelujah day. But would you be buying financials, ron . I give you the last word. Absolutely. Financials, remember, as rates rise, banks make more money on the equity, the financials, okay. So rising rates help financials. Theyre a place to be. I hope its rising rates for me. Rising economy and not rising rates from some sort of weird move. But we will see. That wouldnt be good. Investors, keep your eyes open. Alec young, mike holland, ron, the voice of reason. What about the economy . Guess what . Theres a pro growth swing in economic policies coming out of washington, d. C. Believe it or not. I can count seven potential pro growth policies. The kudlow report the night of optimism continues and free market capitalism is still the best path to prosperity. These new policies are all about more markets and less government. Im kudlow. Well be right back. Vo traveling you definitely end up meeting a lot more people but a friend under water is something completely different. I met a turtle friend today so, you dont get that very often. It seemed like it was more than happy to have us in his home. So beautiful. Avo more travel. More options. More personal. Whatever youre looking for expedia has more ways to help you find yours. Im gonna have to ask you to power down your little word game. I think your friends will understand. Oh. No, its actually my geico app. See . I just uh paid my bill. Did you really . From the plane . Yeah, i can manage my policy, get roadside assistance, pretty much access geico 24 7. Sounds a little too good to be true sir. Ill believe that when pigs fly. Ok, did she seriously just say that . Geico. Just a click away with our free mobile app. Weve been hearing for months that our economy was headed for trouble. But one key factor behind the improving stock market and the 2 to 3 steady economy is the hope that better pro growth policies are coming out of washington. I say hope, but nonetheless, here are my thoughts. First, the sequester stays. Second, new spending cuts are going to come with a debt ceiling deal. Third, thats a repatriation tax reform out there. Fourth, the Keystone Pipeline is going to get approved. Fourth, more brainiac Immigration Reform. And then obama obama care pull back. And no new tax hikes. I happen to like all of those. Thats kind of what im thinking. Joining me from illinois, joining me on the set, we welcome back to michael pento. And the author of the coming back bond market collapse. Thats not a good thought to start on. But i will go to you first because you may be skeptical. But i think that things are changing in washington, d. C. I think the president s political power has been weakened by various scandals and what not. And i see these straws in the wind about good Immigration Reform and budget cutting and you saw in the paper today the deficit and the spending share of gdp are coming down. Are things Getting Better . The main point, the fed is about to taper. Thats going to send Interest Rates rising. The view on my part is that theyre going to hit 4 . Thats where they were in the spring of 2010. I agree with that, by the way. I just said it in the last segment. The if the Interest Rates go to 4 and ben bernanke stops buying assets from banks which is what this country needs, but this countrys rebound was predicated on rebuilding asset bubbles, namely the stock market and the real estate market. And rebuilding a consumption bubble by issuing 6 trillion, 6. 9, since 2008. When that ends its for the Long Term Health of the country, but in the interim it will be very pernicious. Brian west bury, michael is going right to the fed. I actually see a 4 Interest Rate out there towards the end of the year. Sure. Do you think that if qe and bond buying ends, which is what bernanke is signaling is that the end of the world . No, absolutely not. In fact, we have been consistently saying stocks are undervalued but bonds are overvalued. In our stock market models, we actually use a 4. 5 tenyear treasury yield. We have agreed that the bond market is in a bubble, so we put a 4. 5 discount rate in and it still says the market is undervalued. I think stocks are in great shape. I think earnings are going to keep going up. But back to your point about these great things happening in washington. I do think there are great things happening. This oneyear kind of cancellation of obama care, okay, guess what . You dont have to pay a fine, you dont have to have all of your workers on health care. I think it signals the demise of obama care. It was never a workable law. And i think were going to slowly but surely see it fall apart over that would be great news, but is that what caused the credit crisis in 2008 . You hering for a lot of good things youre hoping for a lot of good things coming out of d. C. Im looking forward, not back. Let me tell you why its not over. What i want to know, just for the moment, just to focus on these particular issues if you have Smaller Government and lower spending, if the sequestration goes through, okay, if you do have this pull back of obama care, which appears to be the case. If you get better Immigration Reform. Im all for it. Getting the brainiacs and better visas for more legal immigrants. Slap the green card on the diploma. All those things are so pro growth that markets will look forward, theyll look forward with favor. I love your enthusiastic and i love your optimism, larry. Thats why youre captain america in my view. Heres the point. The total debt to gdp in 2007, december 2007, was 350 . Its the same level it is today. It was 49 trillion in december of 2007. Today its 54 trillion. You are optimistic but missing the main point. Brian, before you jump on me i want to say one thing. I want to tell you this. Interest rates started to rise on may 22. That was when bernanke went before the joint Economic Committee and testified. And that is the reason. It is not because of growth. And now we have a 3. 5 trillion Balance Sheet that has to be unwound. Youre not pricing in whats really happening in the economy if you were ignoring whats going to happen with rates. Brian, what about those excess reserves can evaporate. I never understood this argument. Those reserves were never even used. The socalled money supply is growing at 7 . The gdp growth at 1. 8 . Which is the same as it was in the 1990s and early 2000s. M2 hasnt changed the growth rate in 25 years. The inflation rate is going down, not up. Exactly. I hear parade of people coming on your program talking about earnings. Hang on. One of the saddest things that i think investors have had to face is this constant going back to 2008 and saying that it was the crisis to end all crises, that the world almost came to an end. That the government saved us. I dont buy any of it. I believe mark to market accounting is what caused the crisis. Once we fixed it, the recovery happened. And it happened in march, april of 09. And we have been recovering ever since. And larry, you are 100 right. Its the entrepreneur, its the private sector. Its business. The smartphone, the tablets, all of these things. When the government has to pay a trillion dollars on the debt service payments, are you youing to blame that on what, brian . Youll say that has something to do with what . Interest rate increases, right . Im not sure why thats an issue. The deficit for this year is 750 billion and obama is doing victory laps. Wait, wait. Right. Lets define our terms. The deficit is coming down by a couple of hundred billion dollars. From over a trillion. I understand. The likelihood is that the deficit in the next couple of years is going to be 2 of gross domestic product. Thats a fantasy world. Coming out of washington. Theres what the numbers are showing. Actually this year is going to be 4. 5. If you get another round of spending cuts, brian, what im hearing in washington is not only the spending cut sequester will last, in order to make a debt limit deal theres going to be a second round of spending cuts. I hope so. And spending spending is a share of gdp which is the true tax burden on the economy, keeps coming down. Obama you can punch away and flail away at obama, but the actual numbers on spending and deficits and debt as a share of the economy is coming down. And how much right. I think you can add to your list and it was in there, but was the failure of the farm bill. Oh, my. When the farm bill failed it was a basket case. It was spendaholics in washington, republicans and democrats, and the tea party defeated them. And thats the new america. The pendulum has swung. Government spending has fall. Fran 25 has fallen from 25 to 22 . I believe in the next few years, i dont know if its five or ten, were actually going to deal with entitlements. And this stock market could go to 35,000 if that happens. I hope so. You guys are making me feel really good. Heres the point. How much of the gdp and earnings that you crow about all the time were based on levitating a consumption bubble . You guys totally missed that. Day in and day out. Thats where you and i disagree. I spent the last segment i think the most powerful force in the economy is not the federal reserve, but business and the entrepreneur. And i think its the profitability of business which came out of the blue back in 2009 that has driven this stock market and the economy in the face of a lot of governmental opposition. Consumption. Credit card account up 20 billion, its predicated on borrowing money. Theres nothing on the gdp 17 million. Go ahead. Let me say this a different way. Ben bernanke did not invent hydraulic fracturing. He did not invent the cloud. He did not invent the iphone. 3d printing. I understand. Thats not what happened here. These new technologies why have we lost 50,000 brian, why have we lost 50,000 manufacturing jobs year over year if this is a viable economy . Why is the trade deficit still soaring . Why . By the way, i have to get out. I cant get in. Theres a manufacturing renaissance. Why are we losing jobs . Its called energy. We are producing more with fewer workers. Its amazing. By the way, not only are we importing less and less energy, we are going to be exporting more and more energy and it will bring the trade deficit to almost nothing which will give me a strong dollar, king dollar is going to look great. The inflation rate which is now 1 will go to 0 and youll worry about deflation. Then were going to start 3d printing gold. It will plummet even faster. Gold is about 1,000 bucks an ounce. Thank you, gentlemen. We appreciate it. All hail the state of south dakota. Cnbc has just named it as the number one state for business in america. And the man who puts that list together, cnbcs scott cone joins us live from the foot of Mount Rushmore. Hell explain. Hey did you know that honey nut cheerios has oats that can help lower cholesterol . And it tastes good . Sure does wow. Its the honey, it makes it taste so. Well, would you look at the time. Whats the rush . Be happy. Be healthy. [ lighter flicking ] [ male announcer ] youve reached the age where giving up isnt who you are. This is the age of knowing how to make things happen. So, why let erectile dysfunction get in your way . Talk to your doctor about viagra. 20 million men already have. Ask your doctor if your heart is healthy enough for sex. Do not take viagra if you take nitrates for chest pain; it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Side effects include headache, flushing, upset stomach, and abnormal vision. To avoid longterm injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. Stop taking viagra and call your doctor right away if you experience a sudden decrease or loss in vision or hearing. This is the age of taking action. Viagra. Talk to your doctor. [ male announcer ] some things are designed to draw crowds. Others are designed to leave them behind. The allnew 2014 lexus is. Its your move. Well, the secret has been revealed. Cnbcs annual survey of the best states to do business and this year south dakota is number one. Thats why our friend scott cone is at Mount Rushmore for us this evening. Good evening, scott. Hi, larry. Good to be here. All right. So tell me, south dakota, why . Well, south dakota, no state comes close to south dakota when it comes to low cost and low cost this year is something that the states are talking about more than they have in years. Businesses are talking about that as a criteria, a major point for why theyll locate in a particular state. And south dakota does very well on this. Its not just the tax burden which is one of the lowest in the country youll be happy to know. But its also all the other costs that we looked at. We look at utility and wage costs and the cost for industrial space and commercial space and things like that. South dakota does very well with that. Its not just cost. South dakota also does very well in its economy, the one problem with the economy is theres a workers shortage here. That is an issue. That hurts them a little bit in the work force category. They also do very well with quality of life. I mean, how can you argue with that . Okay, its a little thin during the wintertime. In fairness to south dakota. But it is interesting to me, are they participating in the great fracking revolution which is centered more in north dakota and montana, but does south dakota get a piece of that . Well, what theyre hoping to do, they dont have the kind of shale resources that their neighbors to the north have, but theyre hoping for maybe a little bit of a halo effect where they can do some of the servicing of the Shale Exploration thats going on in north dakota. They know that theyre not going to have the kind of direct benefit that north dakota gets, but maybe they can get some of the sort of the spilloff from that. Thats something theyre hoping for. And there is some possibility with that. One of the things we found with north dakota which did come in third this year theyre having some growing pains. You know about that. Thats one of the things thats holding them back from being on top. South dakota maybe getting a little bit of the best of both worlds. I see texas ranked number two. I think last year was number one. So theyre still pretty darn competitive. Governor perry is on to something. Oh, absolutely. Texas has always been strong in our rankings. Texas has never finished below number two. But ill tell you, larry, they do have some issues with cost and, yes, they have no corporate tax, they have no personal income tax. But they do have the business franchise tax, they have property taxes that a lot of folks are complaining about. They have a sales tax on the high end. They have high utility costs. So looking at the cost of doing business, that hurt texas. Texas and north dakota, the number three state, were separated by one point. So texas is hanging on to that number two spot, but by the skin of the teeth. So one or two biggest gainers, you know, states that really made a big jump in the ratings this year . Well, lets see. We have massachusetts has done well, i believe, in the most improved states. We have put some of this by the way on our website. Top states. Cnbc. Com. Which has a look at the biggest winners and losers. They did well. Im blanking on some of the others but go to the website and look for the stories that we have written about the most improved states and least improved states. The state that dropped the most is my home state of illinois. You have talked about the horrible Financial Issues that they have here. Governor pat quinn signed a big tax increase into law when he took office. That was to rescue the states disastrous pension system. It hasnt really worked. Illinoiss bond rating was lowered by moodys. So they have a bit of an issue here and again, i keep talking about this cost issue. But illinois has that problem. At the same time, illinois is still an economic power house with lot of Big Companies located there. But they have that state finance issue that hurts them in our economy category which is right behind cost of doing business as the major ratings. On the west coast, california, very near the bottom. Number 46. Nevada, number 47. And then disappointingly, scott, new jersey, connecticut, west virginia, rhode island, all of these sort of northeastern states, golly. Why cant we do better up here . Well, again, i keep harping on the cost thing and thats part of the issue. You know, obviously Chris Christie has talked a lot about improving the Business Climate in the garden state. Hes not there yet. Hes not there yet on cost and its not just the tax issue. But there are other issues going on in new jersey with things like quality of life. Education i believe. I mean, theres things that new jersey has to deal with that they havent yet. Rhode island is another state thats had disastrous state finances. Their economy is not there yet. So again, you have these states in the northeast that should do well and just because of where they are, because of the great, you know, Critical Mass of Economic Activity in the northeast and theyre just not doing it. Not yet. All right, scott cohn framed by Mount Rushmore. That looks Like Washington and jefferson and i think i see lincoln also. Thank you, buddy. Appreciate your work on the whole rating system. Now, what was it to cause a surge in fedex shares today . Bertha coombs has that story and the latest on what the workers will be baking when they make the twinkies. Thats right, the twinkie is coming back and you should too. So. [ gasps ] these are sandras homemade yummy, scrumptious bars. Hmm . I just wanted you to eat more fiber. Chewy, oatie, gooeyness. And fraudulence. Im in deep, babe. You certainly are. [ male announcer ] fiber one. Welcome back to the kudlow report. Tonight in the gulf of mexico, an oilwell is leaking. Bertha coombs has that story and much more. Good evening. Its something we have been watching all afternoon. The coast guard is looking into the leak off the coast of louisiana. The well is owned by a subsidiary of taos energy. Oil rose on the initial headlines that it was an oil leak. But most of the afterhours spike due to an Industry Report of a large crude inventory draw down. Well get the governments report tomorrow morning. Meantime, the twinkie is coming back next week. The people making it are earning less than before according to the wall street journal. Theyre earning 11 an hour, less than the final offer to the unions, but the Union Rejected it. Hostess went into liquidation and the private equity firm that bought them is planning to bring them back to stores on monday. Fedex was a big gainer today, up more than 4 . Thats speculation billionaire bill ackman will make a big investment in the company. That send the shares to a fourmonth high. Well see. Mr. Ackman on the loose. Thank you. Now, is president obama breaking the law by delaying or tinkering with obama care . Joining us is a legal scholar who wrote an informative piece in todays wall street journal, Michael Mcconnell. Hell be up next on kudlow. Vo traveling you definitely end up meeting a lot more people but a friend under water is something completely different. I met a turtle friend today so, you dont get that very often. It seemed like it was more than happy to have us in his home. So beautiful. Avo more travel. More options. More personal. Whatever youre looking for expedia has more ways to help you find yours. announcer at scottrade, our clto make their money do more. Re ann to help me plan my next move, i take scottrades free, inbranch seminars. Plus, their live webinars. I use daily market commentary to improve my strategy. And my local scottrade Office Guides my learning every step of the way. Because they know i dont trade like everybody. I trade like me. Im with scottrade. announcer scottrade. Ranked highest in Customer Loyalty for brokerage and investment companies. Shes always been able its just her way. Day. But your erectile dysfunction that could be a question of blood flow. Cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be Ready Anytime the moments right. You can be more confident in your ability to be ready. And the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently or urgently. Tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medications, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sexual activity. Do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Do not drink alcohol in excess with cialis. Side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. To avoid longterm injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. If you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or if you have any allergic reactions such as rash, hives, swelling of the lips, tongue or throat, or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. Ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a 30tablet free trial. Welcome back to the kudlow report. Im Bertha Coombs. Larry has fallen under the weather and hes needed to take a break. We hope that hes feeling better any minute. For a moment im going to pinch hit. So bear with me. We were going to talk now about health care. It seems another day, another costly delay for obama care. The white house now quietly notifying smokcompanies to limi smokers numbs for a year. Now the Small Business exchange provision was delayed until 2015 and last week the white house unexpectedly delayed the major employer mandate. A move which House Republicans sharply criticized today. Take a listen. The president s actions on obama care last week were stunning. We think strongly that the president s actions were unfair, that we ought to also remove this mandate from the individuals. Because its just not fair to sit here and impose on the people of this country this mandate while letting business off free. Republicans have also asked the health and Human Services to respond to them by next week, an investigation into what went on into eliminating or postponing that mandate, but does the question have the legal right to tinker with the law passed by congress . Here now is stanford law professor and former u. S. Court of an peoples judge Michael Mcconnell who wrote the oped today in the wall street journal. You think that they have really majorly changed the law by postponing this mandate. Thats right. This law had a mandatory starting date, set by congress and the legislation. In our system, the president does not have the authority simply to decide which laws hes going to enforce and which ones hes not. He has to enforce them all. But they argue that theyre enforcing the law. They are going to bring forth the exchanges or at least they plan to. By october 1st, when theyre supposed to begin open enrollment and that coverage will begin on january 1st. They are just tweaking some of the glitches that have appeared. Well, undoubtedly there are a lot of glitches, but one of the provisions of this law, in plain language was that the employer mandate would begin on a particular date. And theres no waiver provision in the statute for that. Theres no Authority Given to the president to change that. That is a statutory requirement. And yet, the Business Community had actually lobbied for this. One of the things that they said at treasury was they had listened to what the Business Community had said, that they werent ready to implement a lot of these procedures. Well, bertha, im not arguing the policy here. Undoubtedly, the Business Community is happy not to be saddled with enforcement of this now and probably its good for the economy as well. But thats not the question. The question is a legal one. Which is whether the president has a unilateral authority simply to decide hes not going to enforce a statute duly passed by congress. Maybe in this case its a good policy idea, but think of the precedent it sets because if president s are able simply to dispense with the enforcement or to waive enforcement for of any law for a particular period of time, for a year say, this is something this is a precedent thats going to apply across the board. Not just in cases where it may seem to us to be good policy. But across the board. Its a major an unprecedented shift in power from the elected representatives of the people to the presidency. Judge, you were on the bench and someone brought an appeal of this to you, would this mean throwing out the entire law . Well, no. First of all, its by no means clear this is something that can be remedied in court. Remember the Supreme Court just about a week ago held in the samesex marriage case out of california that individual citizens do not have standing to go to into court when the executive declines to enforce the law unless they have a concrete personal stake in the matter. So its not clear that this will be going to court. If it did go to court, the remedy would not be to throw out the law. It would be to enter an injunction requiring the president to enforce the law. So it would be basically forcing the administration to go ahead and enforce the employer mandate . Thats right. Or to go to congress, as he should have done, and get a postponement in the proper way. At which point he might have to talk to congress and think about what other portions of the law would likely need postponement as well. The republicans have said that theyre going to try to introduce a bill to try to postpone the individual mandate given it seems unfair that employers should have a postponement. Could congress have standing to bring this complaint against the Obama Administration . I dont think that they have standing to go to court. The only person that i can think of who would have standing would be an employee who would not receive the coverage that he was intended to receive from his employer. There are several serious technical problems with such a lawsuit, including a couple of Supreme Court decisions from maybe 20, 25 years ago that limit the right of people to sue to enforce tax liabilities on other taxpayers. Its this is probably not a dispute that can be resolved in court. Its one that has to be resolved politically. What i would emphasize, it shouldnt be just republican members of congress who are alarmed about this because th this this sets a precedent that republican president s in the future will be able to use as well. Any member of congress thats concerned about the Constitutional Authority of the legislative branch should want to find a resolution for this that would be legislative and not one just involving unilateral executive decision making. Judge, thank you so much for joining us this evening. So sorry larry couldnt be with you. Judge Michael Mcconnell. I hope hes feeling better. Me too. Meantime, are higher Mortgage Rates cooling the housing recovery . Theyre not hurting the home builder stocks. They all soared today. Well look at that and talk about why renting is still very hot with cnbcs diana olick. Its a brand new start. Your chance to rise and shine. With centurylink as your trusted technology partner, you can do just that. With our visionary cloud infrastructure, Global Broadband network and Custom Communications solutions, your business is more reliable secure agile. And with responsive, dedicated support, we help you shine every day of the week. [ male announcer ] you wait all year for summer. This summer was definitely worth the wait. Summers best event from cadillac. Let summer try and pass you by. Lease this cadillac srx for around 369 per month or purchase for 0 apr for 60 months. Come in now for the best offers of the model year. Stubborn love by the lumineers did you i did. Email . So what did you think of the house . Did you see the School Ratings . Oh, youre right. Hey babe, i got to go. Bye daddy have a good day at school, ok . But what about when my parents visit . Ok. I just love this one. And its next to a park. I love it. I love it too. Heres our new house. Daddy youre not just looking for a house. Youre looking for a place for your life to happen. Welcome back. Im Bertha Coombs in for larry kudlow. Higher home prices and possibly higher Interest Rates have reinvigorated the rental market. Diana olick has more details. Rentals are hot. Yes, they are, bertha, but analysts and investors have been down on the rental apartment sector, due to the rise in home sales and prices. The rush to rent that we saw during the housing crash was now shifting back to homeownership. Well, rising Mortgage Rates may change all that. Take a look. Rents went up, both asking and effective. Now the growth is slower than a year ago, but thats due to weak Income Growth and this before the rate jump even happened. Vacancies were flat nationally at 3. 4 , but 4. 3 is well below the peak of 8 in late 2009. The vacancy declined largely due to more supply coming on. Over 26. 5,000 new apartments were completed compared to the previous quarter. While they have been moderating lately, the rise in Mortgage Rates can turn up the heat on them again. Starts had been low for multifamily, but now theyre running above normal levels. I takes a lot longer to build an Apartment Building than a house, so this supply wont hit for another two years or so. For now, especially with the rents that rates are throwing in the housing, apartments are a good play. Does that mean if youre looking to rent youll find rents will stay reasonable, wont continue to move up . They seem to be jacking them up every month. They are in apartments because theyre able to do that now, they cant raise them higher than Income Growth of course, because people cant pay. What its saying is when youre looking at apartment reits and investors in the space its a good play. Investors were starting to shift out of it, thinking that housing recovery was booming. Well, rising rates are definitely changing that so you want to look at that sector. What about the rising recovery . We have the rates moving up, just here at the tail end of the spring housing season. Do you think its going to really curtail that, buying interest . Absolutely. Its been kind of a terrible cocktail, the rise of rates as well as the rise of home prices. Its not what home buyers wanted. We have low inventory which continues to push prices higher. But you dont want to see rates rising, especially this fast, up 45 in barely three weeks. Its a little bit crazy. Well, i have to tell you, i was thinking about moving and buying something new. And as those rates shot up, i certainly got a lot more nervous about it. Youre definitely not alone. Thats exactly what the Real Estate Agents are telling me. We were at an open house today, some people are walking away, saying they cant pay the higher rates. All right, diana olick, thank you. Not great news if you want to buy. Thats it for tonights show. Again, larry feeling under the weather. Thanks so much for watching. Tomorrow morning, be sure to tune in to squawk on the street when Eliot Spitzer will be here to explain why hes running for new york city controller. Tomorrow night, join us here on the kudlow report when we have another new york city controller candidate, kristin davis. She knows spitzer very well, because shes a former madam in the prostitution scandal that forced spitzer to step down. Ion. Who is healthier, you or your car . I would say my car. Probably the car. Cause as you get older you start breaking down. I love my car. I want to take care of it. I have a bad wheel i must say. My car is running quite well. Keep your car healthy with the works. 29. 95 or less after 10 mailin rebate at your participating ford dealer. So you gotta take care of yourself . Yes you do. You gotta take care of your baby . Oh yeah Norfolk Southern whats your function . Hooking up the country helping business run trains they haul everything, safely and on time. Tracks they connect the factories built along the lines. And that means jobs, lots of people, making lots and lots of things. Lets get your business rolling now, everybody sing. Norfolk southern whats your function . Helping this big country move ahead as one Norfolk Southern hows that function . And then another. And another. And if you do it. And your friends do it. And their friends do it. Soon well be walking our way to awareness, support and an end to alzheimers disease. And that . That would be big. Grab your friends and family and start a team today. Register at alz. Org since aflac is helping with his expenses while he cant work, he can focus on his recovery. He doesnt have to worry so much about his mortgage, groceries, or even gas bills. Kick kick. Feel it feel it feel it nice work you got it you got it yes aflacs gonna help take care of his expenses. And us. Were gonna get him back in fighting shape. [ male announcer ] see whats happening behind the scenes at aflac. Com. [watch ticking] its just takeyourbreath away type explosions, shake your body to the core explosions. Mike williams was the chief Electronics Technician on board the deepwater horizon, one of the last to escape the inferno after the blowout in the gulf. He believes a series of mishaps may have led to the catastrophe, and his story has been critical to the investigation, a story he first told on 60 minutes. All the things that they told us could never happen happened. What hes saying is very important to this investigation, you believe. It is