Of steel and china dumping fast amount of steal all over the united states, which essentially is killing our steelworkers and steel companies. We have to guard our Energy Companies. We have to make it possible. The epa is so restrictive that they are putting our Energy Companies out of business, and all you have to do is go to a great place like West Virginia or places like ohio, which is phenomenal or places like pennsylvania and you see what they are doing to the people in the energy business. It is a disgrace. Mr. Cooper your time is up. Thank you sir. Mrs. Clinton, you have two minutes. Clinton donald trump is buying these deal to build his buildings, putting american steelworkers and steel plants out of business. That is something i fought against as a senator and i would have a trade prosecutor to make sure we do not get taken advantage of by china on steel or anything else. You know because it sounds like you are in the business or aware of people in the business. Theknow we are now for First Time Ever energyindependent. We are not dependent on the middle east but the middle east still controls a lot of the races. The price of oil has been way down the e. M. s that has had a damaging effect, right . We are producing a lot of natural gas which serves as a bridge to more renewable fuel and i think that is an important transition. We have to remain energyindependent. It gives us more power and freedom than to be worried about what goes on in the middle east. We have enough or is ever there without worrying about that. I have a comprehensive Energy Policy and it includes fighting time i think that is a serious problem. I support moving toward more Clean Renewable Energy as quickly as we can because i think we can beat the 21st Century Clean Energy superpower theireate millions of jobs in businesses. But i also want to be sure we do not leave people behind. That is why i have nearly candidate from the very beginning of this to have a plan coal countryalize because those coal miners e. M. s their fathers and their grandfathers, they done that out. Their lives. Lost they turned on the lights, they lost their lives. Roadrice of coal is down wide. We have to look at this comprehensively. Mr. Cooper your time is up. Sec. Clinton i hope you will go to my website and look by policy. Raddatz we ms. Have one more question and it comes from carl becker. To both ofy question you is, regardless of the current rhetoric, would either thing name one positive that you respect in one another . [applause] raddatz mr. Trump, would you like to go first . Mr. Sec. Clinton i certainly will. I think that is a very very and important question. I respect his children. His children are incredibly able and devoted and i think that says a lot about donald. I do not agree with nearly anything else he says or does but i do respect that and i think that is something that as a mother and a grandmother is very important to me. Electionieve that this so become in part conflictoriented, so intense because there is a lot at stake. This is not an ordinary time and this is not in ordinary election. We are going to be choosing a president who will set policy just eight years, but because of some of the important decisions we have to make here at home and around the world from the Supreme Court to energy and so much else, and so there is a lot at stake. It is one of the most consequential elections with had a hand that is why i tried to policies andcific plans. To get enough of the personal and put them on to what it is i want to do as president. That is why i hope people will check on that for themselves so they can see that yes, i spent 30 years actually may be a little more, working to help kids and families and i want to take all of that experience to the white house and do that everyday. Ms. Raddatz mr. Trump. Trump i consider her complement to my children to be a compliment, i dont know if it was meant to be a compliment but it was great. I am proud of my children. They have done a wonderful job and they are wonderful wonderful kids so i consider that a compliment. I will say this about hillary, she does not quit. She does not give up. I respect that. I tell it like it is. Fighter. I disagree with much of what she is fighting for. I do disagree with her judgment in many places but she does nott hard a. M. She does quit and she does not give up and i consider that to be a very good trade. Ms. Raddatz thanks to both of you. [applause] mr. Cooper i would like to thank everyone here, the university, and Washington University and everyone who watch. In raddatz please tune october 19 for the final debate at the university of nevada las vegas, good night everyone. [applause] announcer and so ends the wild and will lead 2016 president ial debate. Hello, im john heilemann. In the spin room with my partner mark helprin for postgame coverage of the history you just witnessed tonight. Were going to talk about a lot of things. Mark, give me your first. Mark a lot of the early moments went to the recent allegations both sides. Ons on here you see donald with his family. Family was front and center tonight. Debate mention of Donald Trumps children. It started with some top back and forth between the two. It is interesting. A lot of supporters of donald trump and some neutral observers thought donald trump had a strong nine, stronger than the first debate and a night they thought had strong moments. Many people believe that Hillary Clinton took advantage of trunk costs lack of coherence at some moments and that she had a much better night and trump did not do anything like what he needs to get back in his race. I am still digesting it, but i lean towards the latter. I dont think he gave nearly enough of a strong performance. My headlines were the donald trump performed well enough that they potential of a complete meltdown in the Republican Party tomorrow has been staved off. I think he performed poorly in many respects, especially in the first half hour where many republicans were commenting on what they saw as a meltdown in the first 30 minutes. To bewhen he seemed menacing, glowering at her, this nothing continued, there was a moment when he threatened to something i never have seen before in a president ial debate he find her with jail time. It was not based on 30 minutes. She spent a large part of the next hour or so on defense and that part of the debate allowed trump to salvage something. We talked before about whether he could win the debate or the goal was survival, think he survived but i do not think anyone will say he gained an additional votes, he probably lost some. You saw briefly their Chelsea Clinton greeting of all control. The two of them are friends. You heard some of the harshest rhetoric on both sides. Probably more from mr. Trump but from both candidates during the debate. A strange situation. The clintons famously attended Donald Trumps wedding. They had a positive relationship before this campaign. You can see their daughters are still friendly but you can see how much they have turned into pretty harsh negativity. Very few people in the audience got to ask questions. Only a handful and almost all of them will get souvenir photos with the clintons and the tribes. He criticizes the moderators relentlessly throughout the debate for being unfair, for interrupting him too much, at one point he said it was three on one. Has had various times suggested there was a conspiracy against him. They were wisdom and so on. You could see him laying a predicate down for this debate was tilted against him. He spoke a lot in shorthand. Hes a lot that was on his mind will stop he came better prepared without a doubt than in debate but our general consensus view here, and initial take is good enough to try to maybe stop the absolute damage in the Republican Party but probably not good enough of a performance to change the dynamics of the race. He went into the week being 2448 and had a hellish hours of news coverage. We will be back throughout the next half hour. We will take a break now but have more coverage on bloomberg televisions and twitter. We will show you the top tweeted moments of the debate and have some guests from both sides to tell you how their candidate did. John and i will be back here and tell you some statistics about tonight right after this. Crohns welcome back to Bloomberg Politics coverage of the second debate live on bloomberg tv ian twitter. People have been meticulously tracking the top tweeted moments of the night. Tonight marks the mosttweeted debate of all time. Lets take a moment. Aroundt tweets came 10 11 p. M. Eastern when both candidates talked about what they would do about the refugee crisis as well as the war. Will be attacking muzzle within three weeks or four weeks. A lot the bad leaders are leaving. Why cant they do it quietly . Why cant they do the attack . Make it a sneak attack and after the attack is maidenform the American Public with knocked out the leaders, we have had a tremendous success. People leave. Why do they have to be saying we will be attacking muzzle within the next that attacking muzzle mosul withinxt the next 46 weeks. The clinton i dont think american trip should be Holding Territory which is what they would have to do as an occupying force. I do not think that is a good strategy. I do think the use of special the use of na blurs and trainers in iraq has had some positive affect. It is very much in our interest. Drags the runnersup of top tweeted moments was when tribes and he was a gentleman. Let clinton answer first. Also when trump said clinton should be in jail. The highest league of twitter into theas an hour debate. The top three issues twitter discusseditter users was terrorism, foreign affairs, and the economy. We will send you back out to the debate spin room in st. Louis work may get murphy is standing by. Macon thank you. I am joined in the spin room with two of our reporters. With you. Ant to start you were at the extraordinary press availability earlier today. Where donald trump called that of clintonsting chief accusers. What surprised you tonight . Do think he did well enough to stave off some of the crazy criticism . Macon, this was donald trump going nuclear. Thead his backup against wall. It came out just on friday. It really set the tone and decided be rest of the candidacy. We have seen over the past 24 hours, the conservative movement with republican after republican backing away from his candidacy. Out overeen this play the past 24 hours. The bottom line is this, we walked in less than two hours before the start of the debate having no clue what we were walking into. Literallyaccusers sitting next to the candidate himself. His tone was dark, his tone was serious, and his tone was on. Ially, ring in whether that is enough to bring back the republicans who left them, i do not think so. Talking to some of them, quite candidly they are frazzled and scared. Talking to sources in the trump world, they feel this is a rattled Hillary Clinton and this will give them enough momentum to move forward. We will talk about whether or not it rattled her. The first 30 minutes, they really smash mouths. Really nasty. Many of us in the room did not know whether they would actually get through the debate. They did not shake hands, they started right out with a battle. It was a different tone for the rest of the hour, focus more on policy. Clinton really take her opportunity to effectively and the campaign . I do not think that. I think it was a tie. I think she couldve hammered him on the impact and consequences of the tape as a woman herself. The first woman ever who stood on a stage like herself and pointed out how that affected her. She is in a unique position. Mention several dozen republicans who abandoned him. At one moment she seemed a little rattled when he kept interrupting her and she said, donald you are just upset that a bunch of republicans are leaving you. She couldve done that more methodically. In the first debate, her strategy was to rattle him. Gets white is temperament. She did not do this and this debate. But in policy, she demonstrated more of a knowledge of the issues. Was a moment tonight, kevin, where donald trump admitted he had actually not been in discussion with his own running mate, governor pence, about their strategy on syria. Talk to themnot and i disagree with his strategy on syria. See overwe likely to the rest of the week . We have not heard from mike pence possible world. They need to prove whether or not they are with or against donald trump. That is a moment of division this campaign will have to answer for. On the flipside, i think trump had a strong moment on the email server. This was not a moment he was able to capitalize on cohesively. Her talking about lincoln, the movie, was arguably one of his most strong debate moments. First timeht be the we saw a president ial candidate throw his Vice President under the bus on live tv. I am never seen anything like that before. I know they disagree on a lot of things. Refutedy was to flatly it. The thing he refuted mike pence on was russia and their aggression. Theyve already had that argument that trump was too close to them. I want to make that argument because many people who watch this debate, the takeaway is options. Hese are two i think that is really going to be the broad take away from the tone. Both of these candidates for very Different Reasons put your word and this display what we just watched. Priceless get to the breast tax. Is overrump whether he 40 , how high her unfavorable list. How high they both are. And say,ook at this did anyone actually gained voters tonight . Did anyone say, i am shifting my opinion because of what was said . I do not think she made a of the womens card either. Did anyone actually change in my . I doubt it. I doubt it midday whole lot of voters. I dont think Hillary Clinton needs to expand her appeal. She has the numbers. I dont think she lost a. She needs to keep them and make sure they turn out. Donald trump doesnt need to expand his appeal. He is losing ground, he has been losing ground even before the tape came out. This will not help with white, collegeeducated women. Trump needed to expand his appeal and he did not do that. He was on offense all night. He drove to messages home, she a liar,nest, she is here is a change agent. She has been at this for 30 years, she is not achieved anything. Outside the bubble, i think that resonates. So you know, well see what happens. Thank you for joining us. Were going to take another break and we will be back with more from the second president ial debate from the spin room after this. Grants welcome back. Politics, live coverage of the debate in st. Louis. Us, how did your man do tonight . He knocked it out of the park. Strong, resolute. 101 he won this debate. He was great on why he should be president and prosecuting the case against Hillary Clinton on her emails, her failures, or whole history. Ofsurprised by the impromptu parents by some of the Clinton Accusers just moments, just two hours away from the debate. Tell me about these psychology of that. Trying to rattled Hillary Clinton . Trying to move on from the video . These are some of the women, just some of the women whose lives were brought by the clinton machine. A case of the accusers, Hillary Clinton shamed those women. Those ase rapist the rate bestnded of those women. Lets break down the facts. We have friday night the release of the video which shows them using words that anyone would describe as vulgar, demeaning. Which es apologize for. Completely fitting of the president and the united states, did he actually doing up to separate himself . You said he apologized. I did not hear that. I heard him say, im a different man by thy did not and say, this is a different kind of rhetoric. He defended his locker room banter. He apologized twice on friday. Crosstalk] of course it was locker room banter. Billy joking around with bush on access hollywood. He apologized for the language. Is ready tod she move on. This country is to move on to issues that matter. National security, economy, Foreign Policy. Hillary clinton has failed this , syria,on a rant benghazi, on hand on. She has ever done. Donald trump said on camera he actually did not listen to his own Vice President ial syria. About in that he had not heard mike pences comments on the issue and did not know the strategy and disagree. How will mike pence respond to that . What governor pence was something theyas were agreeing about. The trunk to get has been conservative. Once to defeat isis first. 85 of the People Killed by isis have been killed in the last three years. Andeed to defeat isis first then deal with us on. This mass accidents of senior republicans, this call for action to have him leave the ticket. Did he do enough to come back with a campaign that many people of said is dead in the water . 100 . He did amazing today with the voters. 14 million voted from the primaries, tens of millions support him now. Tonight was great for mr. Trump, well move on here from here to las vegas. He showed himself to be the man i know. Someone who is determined, who loves this country. It was not a liar like Hillary Clinton will work for all americans. Do you think you will attract women voters . Did he do enough with women voters . Women in ohio, pennsylvania . People who want a Better Future for their children, Better Future for not only little girls but little boys. Look in the comments friday night and say, that is too much. Women, men, all americans. They want to be protected. They want americans to work. It is clear that Hillary Clinton and her 40 years of public doinge has failed protection. Look at her politics. She wants to raise taxes. Americans care about that. Not locker room banter from 11 years ago and that is why donald trump will be elected on november 8. Thank you. I am sure you will be talking a lot tonight about the victory. It will be a fun night, i am excited. Coming in, mr. Heilemann. Thank you megan murphy. I am back. The senator from missouri. What did you think . There were a couple of moments that were shocking to me. I think maybe the most shocking was, where ill could be that donald trump is not listening to what anybody. I am pretty sure his advisers said it was not a good idea to go after Miss Universe at 3 00 in the morning and ask people to look up sex tapes. But i thought he might be listening to mike pence. Visit knowledge meant that he and mike pence had not even discussed an important Foreign Policy issue and more portly, him and saying, i have not talked to him and i disagree with him. There was a guest in the room. P in the room. Gas and of republicans, the main question is what donald trump meltdown completely and would we havent completed conflagration tomorrow. Do have the sense cap has survived the debate . Do you feel he is done enough . You will still be the person who Hillary Clinton is running against a week from now . I think he is definitely going to be the person she is running against. The expectations were so low for donald trump. Especially on top of the weekend he had. You have a