as chancellor resisted that, said it was the wrong policy. eventually they came in with an energy profits levy. but it had so many holes in it it meant that shell didn't pay a penny of that energy profits levy last year. so i said that labour would fix the holes in that, get rid of those loopholes and we believed it could raise another £10 billion and we would use that to help people said the cost of living. the government, i welcome the fact that the government said yesterday they will freeze gas and electricity bills for a further three months, but instead of funding that through tax receipts or through borrowing, they could have funded it by asking the energy giants, who are making windfalls of war to pay more. so that is a different choice that labour would make compared with the conservatives.