Watford and aston villa manager, Graham Taylor. Our top story at 5pm. Mps are debating whether or not to grant the Prime Minister the power to trigger article 50, the clause which will begin the process of pulling the uk out of the European Union. Theresa may wants to give formal notification of britains intention to leave by the end of next month. Lets cross over to ben brown whos in westminster for what is a rather historic day. Its been a day of powerful and impassioned speeches on both sides of the debate. Lets take a closer look at some of todays Key Developments the Prime Minister has confirmed shell publish a white paper outlining the governments Brexit Strategy tomorrow. Downing street says it will reflect the priorities mrs may has already set out, but it will give mps a chance to debate her approach to negotiations with the eus 27 other member states. Meanwhile right now the House Of Commons is debating a separate question on the question of whether to give the Prime Minister the power to trigger the eu withdrawal mechanism known as article 50. Youll remember last week the Supreme Courtjudgement giving mps a say in whether she should have that power or not. Well, shes likely to get it. The commons is expected to vote comfortably in favour of that bill in around two hours from now. While that debate has been going on, interventions from some senior figures from times past. The former chancellor, george osborne, has said the government is prioritising the desire to control immigration over the needs of the economy. And the former labour leader ed miliband said he opposed a referendum but will vote in favour of triggering article 50 so that the public feels it is being heard. But not everyone in his party agrees, and there are fresh divisions in labour tonight. Jeremy corbyn has of course demanded that his mps vote with the government in favour of triggering article 50. But some who represent pro remain constituencies are flatly opposing the bill. There are reports that dozens of labour mps could defy mr corbyn on yet another key issue. Lets go back to some of the views being voiced in the House Of Commons this afternoon, from alex salmond of but first former chancellor, george osborne, voicing their concerns about coming out of the Single Market. The truth is that while britain is seeking the maximum possible access to the Single Market for goods and for services, and while we hope that the fact that we have a Trade Deficit and a very important Financial Centre will count in our favour, the government has chosen, and i respect this decision, not to make the economy the priority in this negotiation. They have prioritised Immigration Control and that was a clear message from the Referendum Campaign and theyve also prioritised removing European Court ofjustice jurisdiction from the United Kingdom and in that sense asserting parliamentary sovereignty. Of course, it wasnt the case that a withdrawal from the European Community means a withdrawal from the Single Market place. I had the pleasure during the campaign of debating with Daniel Hannon mep who said nobody is talking about threatening our place in the Single Market. Of course, its possible to honour the result of the referendum and stay within the Single Market place and even if you think there will be an exit from the Single Market place, it is madness in diplomatic negotiating terms to abandon that position now. You should keep the place in the Single Market place and allow the other European Countries to negotiate you out of it. Not give it away before the first word is spoken. Alex salmond speaking there. Just a flavour of what is happening in the commons. With me now is the labour mp Heidi Alexander whos voting against this bill. Fundamentally, i cant reconcile myself with voting to trigger article 50 when i believe it will do damage to the economy for many years to come and reduce opportunities for future generations. In the last few weeks, theresa may has set out her vision of brexit, paul asked out of the Single Market, reducing immigration over the National Economic interest, and she has threatened other countries with, in effect, a trade war if she doesnt get her way. I dont agree with her priorities, nor the manner in which she is seeking to negotiate. There we re she is seeking to negotiate. There were certain stances under which i could have voted to trigger that article, but when she set out her strategy, she killed off that prospect for me. Arent you being and fundamentally un democratic . You are going against what people have said . 17 Million People voted to leave, 16 Million People voted to stay. 13 million didnt. Democracy is also a Political Party standing by what is in their manifesto. The conservative party, h 72 of their 2015 mandate said they would protect the Single Market. The Customs Union didnt come up in debate before the referendum. Instead, we had a misleading, and at times toxic debate, which inflamed rather than informed the electorate. So while i acknowledge the result, i cant respect the process that led to it. You are saying the british people got it wrong . I believe that mps and possibly the british people should have a direct say about whether we should withdraw from the Single Market. They are two different things. You can come out of the eu and still remain in the Single Market. You want another referendum . I think people should have a direct say. I deign think it is good enough for the Prime Minister to sit in number ten and determine the shape of brexit. And that is precisely what she has done. So you are saying that the british people need to vote ain . That the british people need to vote again . I think they were failed last year by politicians, and i include myself in that, for the debate which preceded the referendum, though i do think that is the reality of coming out of the European Union emerges, weve already heard businesses like hsbc, lloyds of london, toyota, saying that they are reviewing their operations in the uk, that i think it is right that the british people have the ability to determine our economic future. As i say, the Single Market was not on the Ballot Paper InjuneSingle Market was not on the ballot paper in june last Single Market was not on the Ballot Paper Injune last year. Its a Nag Agonising choice agonising choice for people, and lots of my collea g u es for people, and lots of my colleagues will take the decision to night, but its a complicated issue and in my heart of hearts, i cant vote to do something that i do believe in all likelihood will be damaging the economy in years to come. Thank you, Heidi Alexander. A labourmp come. Thank you, Heidi Alexander. A labour mp who will vote against the motion, along with. Well we will wait and see how many labour rebels vote against that. We reckon around quarter past seven is when we will get that vote this evening. And a big night it is, then. Mps debating a bill for the second day, which gives theresa may the atmospheres been tense, and the exchanges heated in the European Parliament today, where meps have been debating the us travel ban imposed by President Trump. He was described as a nightmare, a joke and the leader of the fight against the free world. It was left up to among others, the former ukip leader, nigel farage to defend the president. We can discuss this afternoons lively scenes with our europe correspondent, Damian Grammaticas who many in ep s dissatisfied with trump . A real back and forth between them in parliament. His travel ban, his Executive Order was debated here. The official eu position was put first by the eu Foreign Policy chief. What she said was that the e you would increase tensions and divisions in europe. This is what she said. No one, no one can be deprived of his or her own rights cause of ethnicity, Place Of Birth Oi cause of ethnicity, place of birth or religion. It is written in our constitutions, both in europe and in america. This is who we are. This is oui america. This is who we are. This is our identity. This is something we cannot forget. Our european history has taught us to celebrate when a wall is torn down and a bridge is built. We learn from our great but also tragic history that every human being is first and foremost a person with fundamental rights that cannot be put into question. We then heard from the biggest groupings. Many said that they thought trump was going to be a joke but has turned out to be a nightmare. He went on to say that trump and his ban had gone on to target muslim countries but left out those where he had business deals. There were cries to resist nationalists and populists. It is how nigel farage responded. It seems to me that with all the anti trump rhetoric, the nature of this logic is anti american is. Trump is motivated by protecting the United States of america from islamic terrorism, whereas what has happened here is youve welcomed these people into your own homes. But can we please, just for a moment, look at the facts. Amongst all the hysteria, all that donald trump has done is take in seven countries that were identified by president obama as posing a risk to the usa. He had already put in place extreme betting. He has put in 90 days to see if that betting from obama is good enough. What we are seeing here is the divisions in how to respond to the policies coming from the us president. And its a real challenge for european leaders. There were calls to those leaders to meet at the summit to issue their own response to the policies we are seeing coming from the new white house. Thank you, damian. Teresa may has insisted she didnt have any prior warning from the white house, that President Trump was planning a ban on refugees entering america, or that restrictions would be placed on travellers from seven mainly muslim countries. She told the commons today that the policies are wrong and divisive. Tom bateman reports. In a week when the opposition to President Trumps travel ban came to the Prime Ministers door, the pressure has built on ministers. The government said the policy is divisive and wrong, but that has not gone far enough for its critics. Will you roll out the red carpet for trump, Prime Minister . Mrs may left for the commons ready to face more questions about the ban. Crucially, did she find out during her trip to the white house . Was the Prime Minister told about the ban during her visit, and did she try to persuade President Trump otherwise . If hes asking me whether i had advance notice of a ban on refugees, the answer is no. If hes asking me if i had advance notice that the Executive Order could affect british citizens, the answer is no. As mrs may spoke of maintaining the relationship with mr trump, anger grew from some labour mps. The president of the United States has advocated torture, misogyny, racial discrimination, sexual assault, isolationism. The leaders of canada and germany were able to respond robustly, but your response was to jump on a plane as soon as possible to hold his hand mr speaker, doesnt this country deserve a leader who is willing to stand up for British Values . And the labour leader said President Trump had incited hatred against muslims. Just what more does President Trump have to do before the Prime Minister will listen to the 1. 8 Million People who have already called for his State Visit Invitation to be withdrawn . Lets just see what he would have achieved in the last week. Would he have been able to protect british citizens from the impact of the Executive Order . No. Would he have been able to lay the foundations of a trade deal . No. Would he have got a 100 commitment to nato . No. He can lead a protest, im leading the country. The government says it disagrees with the travel ban, even that it could be exploited by extremists. But some ministers believe some of the criticism has been alarmist and even overblown. And they have made a calculation too. That building a close relationship with mr trump and his team will prove more important to britains long term interests. But labour want ministers to go further, to call for the travel ban to be scrapped. So far they seem unlikely to get their way. Tom bateman, bbc news, westminster. Donald trump has made one of the most significant decisions of his presidency, Nominating A Conservative judge to fill a vacancy on the Supreme Court. Neil gorsuch is 49 and currently a federal appealsjudge, and his appointment would restore the courts conservative balance. Democrats however are threatening to block his confirmation, because of his record on womens rights, and they fear hed be too conservative on issues like abortion to gun control. Richard lister reports. A prime time announcement on one of the biggest decisions of his presidency, Donald Trumps pick for the Supreme Court will influence american lives long after he leaves the white house. Today i am keeping another promise to the american people, by nominating judge neil gorsuch. The judge and his wife were brought To Washington In Secret and another potential candidate was later sent home. Mr trump clearly relished the game show theatrics. Wasnt that a surprise . But also the reputation of his nominee. Judge gorsuch has outstanding legal skills, a brilliant mind and has earned bi partisan support. At a9, he is the youngest appointed and its a job for life. But he needs some democrats support to be confirmed. He stuck to a carefully neutral script. It is for the congress and not the court to write laws. It is for the judges to apply and not alter the work of the peoples represntatives. A judge who likes all the outcomes he reaches is very likely a bad judge, stretching for the result he prefers rather than as the law demands. Since the death ofjudge Antonin Scalia last year, the court has been split down the middle. In an ideological grounds. On ideological grounds. He was a conservative so some see this as restoring a right leaning status quo. We do not know how future Justice Gorsuch will vote on every issue. Some say he will be more conservative than Justice Scalia in some areas. What does that mean . On gun control cases, judge gorsuch is likely to protect the historic american right to bear arms. On abortion rights, is expected to take the position that all human life is sacred. Same sex marriage may also come before the court. There, his position is unclear, but President Trump approves. There were protests outside the Court Last Night and the democrats leader in the Senate Charles schumer said judge gorsuch has repeatedly sided with corporations over working people and demonstrated a hostility to womens rights which makes me sceptical he can be a strong, independentjustice. It is not clear the democrats can defeat the nomination and there will be other battles. With two justices now over 80, President Trump may get the chance to set the courts direction for decades to come. Donald trump is attempting to push forward a majority vote. With us is our correspondent. When president obama nominated garland, republicans shot down the nomination process, so some democrats want to do the same for the confirmation of this man. They are spoiling for a fight. Some of them are calling it intolerable and hostile, one senator saying that emma kratz showed the same courtesy to republicans, as was shown to them largely. Gorsuch has maintained a neutral tone. He has to do that. We know what donald trump wings they should do. Press the red button. Is the leadership in the senate of the republicans, are they indicating that might be a possibility . Its certainly a possibility. Its called the nuclear option. It would include changing the rules if the democrats try to filibuster the nomination. We had democrats boycotting confirmation meetings and Committee Confirmation meetings and Committee Confirmation meetings and Committee Confirmation meetings that the secretary of treasury, of health. Usually it requires one democrat to be in the Committee Meeting for the nominations to be approved and go to the senate, so republicans changed roles there, so certainly tensions are rising, but the controversy will remain over gorsuch. Thank you, outside washington. The inquests into the deaths of 30 british people who were killed in tunisia have heard how three generations of the same family were murdered in a Terror Attack at a hotel beach in 2015. Owain richards said how he held his grandfather s hand. Weve heard quite a bit today from this young man . Its been a day of very, very harrowing evidence. Its come from a teenager, and also from his mother who lost three very close members of theirfamily in who lost three very close members of their family in the attack in tunisia, two years ago. The bodies ofa tunisia, two years ago. The bodies of a father, his son and grandson arriving back in britain after an attack in tunisia targeting british holiday makers. The lives of three generations of the same family destroyed by a loan gunmen trained by so called Islamic State. The three men had all gone on holiday together, but was shot dead just 12 hours after arriving at the tunisian resort. Today, the surviving Grandson Owen and his mother came to give evidence at the inquest. Mrs richards gave moving tributes to each of those killed. She read moving tribute to each of those killed. She read moving tributes to each of those killed. Mrs richards described how herfamily had been very close and loving. Her Voice Breaking with emotion, she said part of her had died when she said she learned her son joel had been killed. He was a bright, shining star, she said, who had a promising future as a football referee. One of the best things i did in my first year of refereeing. This was joel speaking about refereeing just a month before flying out to tunisia. His mother told the inquest he had already achieved more than many people achieve in theirfull lifetime. When the gunman began his rampage through the resort in sousse two years ago, joel, his brother owen, his grandfather and uncle tried to run and hide. Owen, who survived the attack, provided evidence describing how his grandfather kept falling. They picked him up and eventually reached the indoor swimming pool, but the gunman was behind them and opened fire. Of the four of them who went on holiday together, to celebrate owen finishing his gcse exams, it was just owen returned home. At the end of the evidence this morning, the coroner traipsed owain Owen Richards for his Bravery Intro to save his grandfather. Neutral new train fares will start in may. We have this report. Its been a long time in coming. Trust to get rid of old practices which mean you can pay too much for a ticket. At the moment, it relies on websites to find the best ticket and complicated fare system. One of the targets is travelling the length of the uk costs over 340 pounds, but just 80 pounds if you buy different sections of the journey separately. So, the trials will involve cheaper multi legged beds, more good Value Singles where they cost as much as a return, and other things mps have been calling for. Whats been happening is outrageous. And people have been paying over the odds for journeys, not being told what the cheapest journeys are. When they purchase from machines they arent getting equity, machine sells various prices. There are many different rail fares various prices. There are many different railfares so various prices. There are many different rail fares so its not surprising that they often pay too much. They are not warned beforehand that if they wait a few minutes, they might get a cheaper option. So, this huge frustration among travellers. Its challenging, isnt it . This so many different ways of purchasing them now. Are likely to be cheaper and easier to navigate, clearer, really. I would like. This trial is only for a small number of companies but we need to see this right across the country. We wa nt see this right across the country. We want to see things improving on the railways. Cheaper, more understandable tickets are welcome, but there are also calls for Rail Companies to follow a simple rule, just to sell the cheapest ticket in all circumstances. And now you weather. Such a dry january but its all gone wrong. One band of rain after another. Friday is looking potentially very stormy, so if you have plans, stay tuned. Its a damp there are crossed wales. Through the evening and overnight will push further north, but more rain to follow. The winds are strengthening. They will be a notch up strengthening. They will be a notch up tomorrow and indeed overnight. It wont be cold except for in the east of scotland. It means well have some brightness. Gale force winds, possibly some severe gales for a time. Certainly not wintry in the fa ct time. Certainly not wintry in the fact that it will be mild. We can see winds notching up even higher as we head into friday. I will have more details for you here in half an hour. The this is bbc news at five. The headlines. Mps are making their final pitches in a momentous debate, on whether theresa may should begin the formal process of taking britain out of the eu. The government has chosen, and i respect this decision, not to make the economy the priority in this negotiation. The inquest, into the deaths of british tourists in tunisia, has heard a statement from a teenager who survived, but lost his brother, uncle and grandfather in the attack in june 2015. Four people, involved in fraudulently selling puppies kept in poor conditions at a travellers site in essex, have been given suspended sentences. The European Unions Foreign Policy chief Federica Mogherini has expressed concern about the Travel Restrictions imposed by us president donald trump, saying his policies are sowing tension and mistrust. Leader of the main eurosceptic group, Nigel Surridge criticise what he called andy tromp rhetoric. Nigel farage. Sport now, heres olly foster. Englands cricketers signed off from their tour of india with a whimper. They lost the t20 series 2 1 after an incredible collapse in bangalore. Chasing 203 they lost by 75 runs. Tim hague reports test series lost, one day series loss, surely not any more, but from deciding to bold, they had a big breakthrough, they kohli went walkies and paid the price, but while that silence them, it was only for a moment. They brought back of the noise. We would not be seen that ball again. He reached a half century along with ms dhoni. It meant england had to find 203 for victory and that would help reverse sweep for six, the modern game gone mad and while there were more maximums, when they both out, england unravels and the bowler that got them both, got six in total. The tourists losing eight wickets for eight runs. No wonder when is a match with statistics like that, test series, one day series, t20 series gone. Time to come home. Manchester united tonight face hull for the third time in a little over three weeks. Hull are propping up the Premier League table, while united are pushing for a Champions League place. Theyre five points behind fourth place liverpool with a game in hand. One man mourinho is unlikely to pick tonight is Antony Martial after comparing him infavourably to henrik mkhitaryan. He has to perform better than the others that are competing with him for the same positions. His position isa for the same positions. His position is a position where we have lots of options. Do you want me to leave the qatari out after him being the Man Of The Match and playing so well . I cannot. The players have picked themselves. There are two other matches. Also tonight west ham minus Dimitri Payet welcome manchester city, and therres a midtable clash between stoke and everton. Chelsea defender Branislav Ivanovic hasjoined Russian Premier League side zenit St Petersburg for an undisclosed fee on a two and a half year deal. Chelsea Captainjohn Terry paid tribute to his now former team mate, describing ivanovic as a legend, going on to call him an unbelievable defender for us over the years and a great and big character and presence in the dressing room. Premier League Spending reached £250 million, but for the first time, they made a net profit and a large pa rt they made a net profit and a large part of that has been down to the financial power of the Chinese Super league. They bought oscar for around £50 million and even a playerfrom watford commanded £25 million. He had not heard of the team. When the offer came in, i had to google the team. I say why not, it is a small town in china. I thought why not. Let me go and try and do my best there. The funeral of the former england manager Graham Taylor has taken place in watford,where he had his greatest success at club level. Taylor died of a suspected heart attack last month at the age of 72. Sir alex ferguson, Luther Blissett and john barnes were amongst those who attended the service at St Marys Church in watford. As much as we know that he is mr watford through and through. In was more interesting. Notjust the superstars, to show how much people hold him in regard. The players who played alongside him and the people who knew him. A lot of people who we re who knew him. A lot of people who were there would not have known the Graham Taylor that we grew up with. The players were there because they we re the players were there because they were his children if you like. Thats all sport for now. You can keep up to date with all those stories on the bbc sport website. Ill have more in sportsday at half past 6. Thank you. Lets get more now on the latest controversy to surround President Trump. Hes appointed a conservative neil gorsuch as a nominee to the Supreme Court, and has called on the us senate to speedily approve his nomination. The court has the final legal word on many of the most sensitive us issues, from abortion to gender to gun control. But democratic senators, who can delay or even block the nomination, have raised questions about judge gorsuchs attitudes towards womens and workers rights. With me now is Kevin Russell a Supreme Court practitioner who also writes for the Supreme Court of the United States blog. It is good to see you. Thank you for joining us. My pleasure. Is it right for democrats and progressives, to be worried about neil gorsuch taking up be worried about neil gorsuch taking upa be worried about neil gorsuch taking up a seat on the court . Sure. I think liberals and democrats have to be worried about anybody that President Trump will put on the court because that person is going to very likely rule on important issues in the way that liberals and democrats will not like. That is interesting. Mightnt he be a so called swing and i mean that in the best possible sense, we know justices do not always act according to type, anthony kennedy, a Reagan Appointee and he is seen as the main swing it justice, he appointee and he is seen as the main swing itjustice, he comes rule in a liberal or conservative way. Could neil gorsuch be such a man . The republican legal establishment has gone to Great Lengths over the last 30 years to make sure that does not happen any more and that is one of the reasons why the pics are coming from the courts of appeal is like neil gorsuch, or you can see over a long period of time how he has ruled ina lot long period of time how he has ruled in a lot of cases and have a great degree of confidence that he is not likely to change his fundamental outlook. Could he be more conservative than anthony skilling. For principled reasons, because of his commitment to other reasons, he could across the aisle and the width liberals on some issues, he had some quirky views as well. It is possible that neil gorsuch would do the same. He has some of the same commitments to how you interpret statutes and how you interpret the constitution that could lead him down the same path. I am interested in you as a Supreme Court practitioner, someone who has dealt cases in front of the court, how will you tailor your submission, taylor at your address to the court. Do you focus on those justices who you think might swing your way or is there a general appeal to all of them . In your way or is there a general appealto all of them . In most your way or is there a general appeal to all of them . In most cases in the Supreme Court are not decided 54, in the Supreme Court are not decided 5 4, they are not buy clothes and an argument that is good for the liberal justices argument that is good for the liberaljustices might argument that is good for the liberal justices might also argument that is good for the liberaljustices might also do the conservative justices. You would be afful not to recognise that someone like Justice Kennedy will be the deciding vote and to think about what is important to him and tailor your argument is the degree to him. Going back again to the suggestion that he might at some point be a swing voter on the court, justice roberts, impeccable republican credentials, appointed by george w bush, but he staunchly defended, some say went out of his way to defend obama care. |j some say went out of his way to defend obama care. I dont know if i we re defend obama care. I dont know if i were go that far. He certainly voted to uphold a portion of it in one case. Differentjudges have different ideas about how fast and how aggressively the court should move on certain issues, the chief justices, conservative in the way of not wanting them to move too fast, we will see where neil gorsuch will end up in that spectrum as well. Anotherjudge has been on the court for several years now and there is going to be at some point potentially over the next four years and if he gets re election, eight yea rs, and if he gets re election, eight years, and other vacancy. Is this a chord that you believe is going to be firmly entrenched on the conservative side for many years to come potentially . Certainly, if President Trump gets to replace one of the liberals, we will have a solid five vote conservative bloc, the oldest of whom is 68 right now and that block could be together for 15 or 20 years controlling the court. Thank you. Good to talk to you. Thanks for your analysis of the workings of the Supreme Court. My pleasure. Police in germany have arrested a tunisian man on suspicion of recruiting for the Islamic State gioup of recruiting for the Islamic State group to carry out a terrorist attack. He was taken into custody in frankfurt during raids involving more than 1000 officers. Mosques, flats and officers were targeted. Three women and a man who sold hundreds of dogs kept inside cages on a farm have been spared jail. The group advertised the pets which they sold to unsuspecting members of the public for an average of £450 as home reared. They handled about 750 puppies as part of the Sophisticated Enterprise which was worth up to £500,000. Live to our correspondent ben ando who is outside Basildon Crown court. Just describe some of the conditions these puppies were reared in. The jury these puppies were reared in. The jury at this trial, because there was a jury trial briefly before the defendants chose to plead guilty, they were shown a video. Sentencing today, thejudge they were shown a video. Sentencing today, the judge told the accused they would all have received Prison Sentences but for the fact that two of their number were suffering from serious personal and Health Problems and for that reason he sentenced 57 year old trees away to 21 months in prison, suspended and made subjective to a night time curfew. He sentenced victoria montgomerie to 14 months in prison, suspended and Roxanne Montgomerie and tony hammond We Re Roxanne Montgomerie and tony hammond were both given a nine month suspended sentences and told they would have to serve 120 hours of community service, and paid. This all came from a scam where they were telling people via the internet to go to houses in east london to buy a home reared puppies who should be in good health, happy and friendly with children, but they had been bred on a farm children, but they had been bred on afarm and children, but they had been bred on a farm and when the rspca raided it, they found that the puppies were keptin they found that the puppies were kept in terrible conditions. The animals were kept in cold, dark cages. They were dirty, with little water or food. For five forfive puppies. For five puppies. Rspca forfive puppies. Rspca inspectors found 76 dogs and puppies when they raided the farm two years ago. The animals had been sold as home reared forup to animals had been sold as home reared for up to £750 a time. Theresa wa and her co accused advertise them online and sold them from houses used as france in east london. Going to the house, you would not have thought that they could be from a puppy thought that they could be from a puppy farm, there were children there, toys in the room, tv on, you would not have thought they were adults from a puppy farm. I carried my puppy out of the car but before i got there she was sick. I went back, knocked on the door, they would not answer the door. So i just put her in the car and brought home. She was sick about three more times in the car. Once at her new home, wilma urgently needed bathing as she was covered in fleas. It was then that they realised how malnourished she was. |j then that they realised how malnourished she was. I think they are malnourished she was. I think they a re low malnourished she was. I think they are low lives to do that to an animal, everything they get, they deserve. Ijust dont know how they do it. I dont know how they have got it in their hearts to do something so cruel. Money, that is all it is, money. Wilma is now two and a half years old, a happy dog but she does have ongoing Health Problems and her owners have been warned by the bet that that is something they will have to get used to. Others were not so lucky, several people who gave evidence acord described how their puppies died soon after coming home. The rspca admitted that they may never know just how many rspca admitted that they may never knowjust how many puppies were bred and sold by the gang. Just to put this ina and sold by the gang. Just to put this in a wider context, the rspca says that in 2012, they received around 1500 calls to their Cruelty Hotline from people worried about Puppy Hotline from people worried about Puppy Training trading. Last year that figure had more than doubled to 3600 calls from people concerned. They say this is clearly a growing problem and one last point about this case, two of the defendants, there are ongoing Animal Cruelty charges to be dealt with but they will be heard at a Magistrates Court because in law Animal Cruelty is less serious than fraud that was dealt here today. Thank you for that. An algerian woman ran up a 6 figure bill for nhs treatment after giving birth prematurely to quadruplets in london. She was taken ill on a flight from america to nigeria via heathrow. The news comes asa nigeria via heathrow. The news comes as a group of mps urge the government to take urgent action to recover more money for treating foreign patients. Here is our health correspondent. These tiny babies illustrate a challenge for the nhs. One of the quadruplets did not survive the premature birth and a second died at the weekend. They have needed intensive care. There are nigerian mother went into labour at three months early were travelling home from america via london. I have journeyed for two days to get here. When i got there, they said i was not able to attend they said i was not able to attend the us. The Hospital Hospital looking after her has to recoup the cost of care for overseas patients and ina cost of care for overseas patients and in a bbc documentary tonight, she is giving news about her mounting bill from the nhs, it quickly reaches six figures. The thing is, the Hospital Bill is going to be quite high. I understand that. It isa to be quite high. I understand that. It is a very difficult time for you. We do need to talk about the charges for the treatment. The next stage is to let her know. Those invoices are going to be huge. 20 grand a week for each baby. Mps say the Department Of Health must get better at recovering costs from foreign visitors who end up as patients, because a ha rd pressed visitors who end up as patients, because a hard pressed nhs is missing out on vital funds. The government says it has set a target to collect half £1 billion per year from overseas patients by 2018, but it is currently only managing to collect under £290 million. One of the biggest areas of concern is getting money back from European Countries were agreements are in place. The latest figures show the uk recovered £50 million from these countries, but paid out £675 million. Overall the nhs budget is much less than not. 1 and every pound counts and every pound that comes in will be spent on patient care but the key thing is that the government has not set up a system for hospitals and other Health Providers to collect the payments that overseas patients oh. Priscilla sees her to surviving babies every day and is being helped bya babies every day and is being helped by a charity. Her medical bills are currently doctors say that an update on the Market Numbers for you heres how londons and frankfurt ended the day. And in the the United States this is how the dow and the nasdaq are getting on. There have been there have by Israeli Settlers and police. The Israeli Settlers and police. The Israeli High Court had ruled that the settlement was built on private palestinian land. In the last few days, the Israeli Government has approved 3000 new settler homes, the fourth such announcement in less than two weeks. Our middle east correspondent has the story. Settlers scuffles by Israeli Settlers and police. The Israeli High Court had ruled that the settle m e nt high court had ruled that the settlement was built on private palestinian land. In the last few days, the Israeli Government has approved 3000 new settler homes, the fourth such announcement in less than two weeks. Our middle east correspondent has the story. Settlers tried to block and barricaded themselves in their away by police many had to be dragged away by about 50 families were living in this outpost some had been here for 20 years, but had been told to some had been here for 20 years, but had been told to it is a very sad what can we the verge of tears right i am on the verge of tears right i am on the verge of tears right now. And man watch and the israelis were moved from his land. Israeli satisfaction has been short lived. Actions to remove this outpost are being rapidly expanded. Lets return to debate at the commons about whether theresa may is allowed to trigger article 50. Our chief Political Correspondent is there. Everyone is trying to get their two pennies in. A lots of passion has been shown. The result of the vote in a couple of hours isnt in doubt, is it . Of the vote in a couple of hours isnt in doubt, is it . No, it isnt. Particularly the 48 of people who thought Parliament May block this. They might be bewildered and disappointed. The majority of mps in the House Of Commons were in favour of remaining, but tonight, they will vote overwhelmingly to allow this process to continue. The government is very confident it will go through and on their timetable, and so, theresa may will be able to trigger to call 50 and start those negotiations when she wants before the end of march. There will be a few d oze n the end of march. There will be a few dozen labour mps who defied their leader. Jeremy corbyn has said we we re their leader. Jeremy corbyn has said we were on the remains side, we made and lost the arguments and we had to respect the result. But there are many saying they cant bring themselves to vote for something that will make their constituents poorer. The government is confident it will get its way. Its really about the process of starting britains procession out of the European Union. But theresa may tomorrow will publish the white paper giving more detail, and thats when we could get the kind of amendments s, such as those from the snp and labour. There are conservatives who wanted this white paper. Its a formal Government Document and we are told it will be published tomorrow. It will be based on theresa mays speech where she outlined what she saw as the 12 the areas of priority, and the fact that the uk has to leave the Single Market. An interesting intervention from george osborne, saying that he felt the government had prioritised Immigration Controls over the economy, quite significant from him. We heard from sir ivan rogers, the top bureaucrats in brussels, and he was outlining the difficulties. Tonight is the easy bit, hes suggesting that the other 27 eu countries are drawing up a brexit bill. He thinks it will end up costing 60 billion euros. The idea ofa costing 60 billion euros. The idea of a trade deal could though on that very we have the six oclock news coming up we have the six oclock news coming up and we will have that vote coming up up and we will have that vote coming up as well. Now it is time for a look at the weather. I wish i had good news. We are focusing in the atla ntic good news. We are focusing in the atlantic for a potential storm. It is not what we want. That will have a knock on effect. There is uncertainty for the weekend as to where that storm will end up. Either way it will bring ferocious weather across the uk and the north of france. This is how the atlantic looks, we have had a quiet spell of weather through january, barely any weather fronts, but we had one today and one yesterday and one is lining up for tomorrow, this mass of cloud and this is the friday one. It has not developed yet, it is a leaf of cloud just waiting, ready to be engaged by the energy of the atmosphere. In amongst all that talk of storms, we have had decent weather here. Lovely pictures coming in of sunshine. Some good news and there will be brightness between the bands of rain tomorrow, but if you are out on the roads in the next few hours, there is this rain heading into the midlands, it is not particularly pleasant for the team rush hour. That brain as it heads into the north, it tends to diminish and then we have another one coming in and for tomorrow morning, the combination of heavy rain and hill fog and gale force winds, it will not be pleasant. It will not be cold, except in the north east of scotla nd cold, except in the north east of scotland and the clear skies here could bring A Touch Of Frost but at least there will be brightness in the morning. It will not last because the strengthening wind will blow the cloud further north, gales are likely and severe gales are possible in wales, england and northern ireland. Nevertheless, a notch up on today and enough to cause issues with the odd branch down. The winds are likely to escalate another notch into friday, but the commute Computer Models disagree whether they will head into france or the uk. It could cause disruptive weather with storm force winds. That was enough to bring down trees, heavy rains as well. The debate is whether it goes across the north of france and the Channel Islands and causes disruption or its lands into the South Of England and gives us some nasty weather to end our week. To the north, it looks set fair, a bit wintry, that weather into the north of england and the south of scotland. The concern at the minute, warnings are already out for the winds. Tonight at six. One hourfrom now mps will vote on the brexit bill. It will give theresa may the power to start talks for or against biggest passion on both sides of the argument. To vote against the Majority Verdict of the largest democratic exercise in british history would risk putting parliament against people. History has its eyes on us today and heres my answer. Can no more vote for this thani my answer. Can no more vote for this than i can vote against mike conscience. The former British Ambassador to the eu warned that talks could descend into a verbal fistfight. Also tonight. Three men, three generations an inquest hears how they were