Also a little later on in this hour the U.K.'s highest court to rule on whether the Prime Minister's decision to suspend Parliament ahead of bricks it was on more follow the government says the suspension or progress is not matter but critics argue it was intended to limit scrutiny of the Prime Minister's Brix it plans now the decision is in the hands of the judges a little later on we'll hopefully find out what happens and I'm interested to hear from you do you hope the government wins or loses the court case today. Is the number of your call if you want to get involved. First to think people have the right to complain about the sound of children playing a nursery is hoping to overturn a decision limiting the number of under 50 allowed to play outside altogether after neighbors complained about the noise the children are now only allowed outside in groups of 5 or less following a decision by children barrack Council the nursery wants to raise the cap to 12. But this is not the 1st time this issues come up a couple of years ago there were similar concerns raised with local authorities in both Leighton Buzzard and in Cambridge my question to you Do you think people have the right to complain about the sound of children. Do you find the sound of children playing annoying Have you have a complaint about it maybe you live near a family whose children play very noisily out in the garden does it bother you is it very frustrating noise to listen to have you ever gone had your say or do you think to be honest the sound of children playing it is just a totally natural and normal thing. And anyone who does get annoyed about the sound of children playing needs to get over themselves Here's the telephone number if your call for your reaction. You can text as well 13 double 3 Start your text. Right you can e-mail me here at the b.b.c. J.b.s. Show at b.b.c. Don't don't you k. She think people do have the right to complain about the sound of children play l.a. It's a late one. Show b.b.c. Operable or whether. Look at it out there is at the salute really terrible terrible weather oh Our can't stand it anyway at 11 I will deal with your consumer problems take all of our minds of the weather also a little later on I'll bring you the news as it happens with the Supremes Court ruling on the suspension of Parliament a decision is expected after half past 10 today and I'm interested to hear from you do you hope the government wins or loses that court case if you want to have your say our age how it won double. First though have a listen to this. Do you like that noise or not the reason I'm asking is because a nursery is hoping to overturn a decision limiting the number of under 5 who are allowed to play outside together this is after neighbors complained about the noise the children are now only allowed outside in groups of 5 or less following a decision by Chelton bar a council the nursery wants the cat raised to 12 it's not the 1st time this issues come up a couple years ago there were similar concerns raised to elope with local authorities in both Leighton Buzzard and Cambridge well very interested to hear how you feel about this to think people have the right to complain about the sound of children playing shocking to one of my colleagues and she said that she and her husband once looked at buying house near a school. And she quite wanted to buy the house because she loves the sound of children playing there you may be listening to this thinking Oh God No Oh the thought of living near a school and listening to children shouting and squealing in the playground driving up the mad maybe you have neighbors who let their children play very noisy out in the garden do you like that sound all not and if not do you think you've got the right to complain about it you think you have the right to say to parents could you could I just ask that your children don't make so much noise in the column when they're playing Would you mind. Think people have the right to complain about children playing. Rachel what you love is a child care expert Good morning to you Rachel good morning turning and turning this Father's Day Do you think people have the right to complain about the sound of children playing and know not the sound of children playing and I think we've based particular cases come in we're talking about nursery children and I think we're talking about the time between 10 in the morning and 3 in the afternoon and I think it's really important children are able to go outside and run about. And not having to be kept inside all day I think you know a little children Kaito cried to fall over and cry and things but I think no I don't think people should be complaining because it's not we're not talking about 24 hours a day John. So people should just put up with it is a normal sound if you don't like it put up with a or move so I think I mean I think we should be a little bit more tolerant of each other I think that's you know of too much happening in society we just think we or have the right but this to me are and I think that you know what we're not as tolerant as we used to be. And I know that obviously people are living very close together but you know there is as I say they're not I'm sure they're not all out all the time and actually with the winter coming on they probably won't be out as much as they have been joining stomach No but can you imagine just for a 2nd just just use your imagination your next door neighbors move and a new couple move in and they decide they want to run their own nursery from the house and day every day will have a number of children staying at the house and the children will be playing in the garden in the summer months now you might find yourself I don't know how much you enjoy sitting in your garden Rachel but you may find yourself on a daily basis sitting in your garden that used to be quiet suddenly having the sound of children running around screaming and shouting Do you have a right to say that's that's annoying Well I think obviously you could just ask if that maybe you know if there's a huge amount of noise you could just ask if they could be a little bit quiet but I think it was a nursery school and I think the other thing Jonathan today is that I didn't know that there would that many people around at home all day you know we hear that people are out of their houses all day people and the rest fit and they're not at home that they used to be so happens every child's even even then you're not more time here you take go out but then we've we've had no today's difficult to remember but we have had a pretty good summer haven't we we've had some very nice past this year have and and it's lovely to have a sit out in your garden if your neighbors have children who are playing very loud . Les and their squealing and you know children can make a lot of noise can't they when they get excited do you have to have the right to find that annoying or do you think frankly it's just it's a totally normal and natural noise and if it bothers you then there's something a bit wrong with you well I just think that we need to be more tolerant and we're talking about little children who need to be running around and being outside so I think this is crap Scott. Going to a little bit over the top where the and I do think tolerance comes into and I'm quite sure that neighbors are going to be sitting in my garden from morning till night if we say listening to the children over the fence I mean this very few people in the nation he'll be doing that I would have thought John No but if you feel that your garden is a no go area I mean isn't it a bit like dogs barking I mean a dog barking it's a natural normal thing for the dog but if your neighbor suddenly gets a dog that's in the garden barking all the time and start to then dread being in your garden because you know you're going to have to listen to that noise Yeah you've got a right to complain that different I think that's different because I ordered the children the children showed a human being part of their growing up a dog shouldn't be barking all the time so I think you know this is perhaps being taken a little bit far really but then surely people have the right to enjoy their garden and if children are playing for a long time outside in the garden making a lot of noise and irritating to you Do you not have the right to complain in the same way as if your neighbor leaves a barking dog in the garden. I think with children it's different because actually I'm quite sure the same group of children are going to be out in the garden all day and we are talking about between 10 and 3 not from 9 till 6 o'clock at night. Good structure thank you very much indeed Rachel Rachel Ward. She's a child care expert it's a normal noise people need to be more tolerant how you feel about has anyone ever complained about your children playing and the noise of age. Mickey and Hatfield Good morning to you Mickey Hi Good morning morning do you think people have the right to complain about the sound of children playing. Yes send them as I mean it's no secret. I'm not big fan of children I can tolerate into an extent but there's something very unique about that particular frequencies and the little monsters create that just seems to throw my brain in instantly make me angry so I try my best to not be in the presence of children as much as possible and in terms of moving into a house I mean if I moved into a house and then a nursery opened up after I'd moved in I would be all right I would be here men but it's not a lot for I mean that sound I played a little earlier you know. That I think. It's not a nice noise making. My own toenails or. Horrendous as some think about the noise of children that really does hear Ted I don't know why because I think I'm going to turn into one of these you know old man Mike that still has the balls of children and they're too scared to come and get them back. Can't stand that noise I mean I even I had to change my gym schedule just because I can't bear to lay in a spot a half an hour at the same time the school gets assuagement because I get resonates across the building I mean it really does drive me part and I could not live next door to where I would end up in sleeping pills and cookies and chuck him over the fence I'm sure you mean that really you know just being you know your being extreme in your various for comedic effect. No I don't condone child abuse by me. Or drugging Joe but you may well find yourself in a position where you know your neighbors might move and a big family moves in next door with 5 kids and the children are very outdoorsy and they get a trampoline you know and you've suddenly got the children every day bouncing on the trampoline and playing and squealing and shouting and making lots of noise and you might have that in the house next door make a. Quite honestly I think that really really would have an extremely detrimental effect on my wellbeing and I think I would probably put quite extreme measures in place to ensure that I could hear as minimal as possible from the garden I mean I know I don't like the chaps in the house anyway and I don't very much for talking somebody that sits in the studio listening to the same little music over and over again for hours and then perfectly fine but there's just something about children's noises that really gets me angry so you if your neighbor has changed and you suddenly had children in the garden do you think that would actually genuinely affect your your health and your wellbeing absolutely 100 percent irritate me beyond belief and I would have to have a look at sound currency no one in the house or quite literally I think I'd have to lay flat have to leave the property I mean I don't think I could live with that especially if I was at home all. Day So you'd have to move if your neighbors moved and you got a family with children playing in the garden you'd have to mate I can tolerate that mess a nightmare that would be equal to living next door to an electric one an electric poles that buzzes all day long the 2 things would drive me cry. But results from the sound of children playing is a completely natural sound this now mean you were child once I'm sure when you used to play with your friends you probably used to make a racket Mickey isn't it something that's just in a natural a normal sound it's like the sound of the wind is something just natural you have to deal with it. I don't know I had quite a military upbringing I consider night a single parent mother actually actually done a very good job of keeping me quiet where we were yeah we was always taught to be choli and not make noise and I don't if I hear children making a noise in scream and shout I just think that's not been has not been brought up those children this sound. They tortured me. Screaming and shouting all day they just miking children in noises it's just playing noises all night. Which is why there's a been a school not in a private house you can you can't put this upon other people this is a maze annoying the frequencies of that noise is to gain some baggage straight to the brain and it really does irritate me maybe I should look at maybe they should have an obligation soundproof the garden create some sort of large barriers like they do at the side of my way so that the frequencies can't get out really never once a day you you might find if your neighbors do move you might find anybody here the children playing but when they get the trampoline you might have neighbors the children of whom they like to on every hour put balance look over the fence and try and talk to you in your garden I sort of feel like you're being a bit sinister and you're trying to create some sort of. Mental health issues for me at the moment you wouldn't you know like that every every time the head pops over the fence a lie I make a down it goes No I think of a struggle financially and in the next 100 grand to live by myself and. I don't think I could do this I don't mean you know what you're speaking to a time in my life when all of my close friends and family all haven't baby and our lovely it's become a real home a little want to come around with all the children touching all your stuff I had to hold a baby to have a day and I had about so many people taking pictures because a call is so amazing how could I looked really you know not up to him and imagine mine imagine when all those friends come around and their children they want to touch all your windows and touch the glass and touch the t.v. Screen with their little fingers Well I think they will learn not to come I saw a play not so long ago and some cup on the floor without cause doubt and I lost it and if one actually late say nobody comes around anymore. Making I think you are even less tolerant the me in life I think this is Gary thank you very much indeed right now families do not buy the house next door to make a because one of you is going to end up going David Milton Keynes says I just can't believe people would complain about the sound of children playing there really isn't a better sound than happy kids I live 2 doors down from a nursery and when I'm off work I can hear them play and it really doesn't bother me these people need to get a life with everything happening in the world and then complaining about children playing is an absolute disgrace you should be ashamed of yourself why don't you move away you got no somewhere where you got no neighbors whatsoever and you can lead a lonely life by yourself. Gosh Dave you're Texas becoming and the whole bit angry and yet Christian Bedford have a grace good morning good morning Grace do you think people have got a right to complain about the sound of children playing a little. Something to sponsible And Chris I don't know what's going on with your phone it sounds terrible Can you not a good oh no that's prejudice hold an Aussie got black Al play perfectly still I grew up. To believe it sprang to mind the front of all here it says the old There's no way that came from with who was made up but that's true that's people like he can't stand it. Well in some help to be honest there are. Questions too. Much. You don't do that with your noisy job you do that with a hammer and chisel and I don't have the right to say Ok we'll. Just let the 75 children play any one time it's ludicrous why. Oh well when we. Don't. You know if I was yeah but I guess the problem the problem is if you've got children playing outside you can't necessarily plan your day around the Chris thank you will leave my ball is a bit rubbish but thank you anyway Jan checks to say compared to the miserable selfish couple that used to live next door we now have 4 lovely little boys there and it's lovely to hear them playing children a cooped up too much inside with computers etc It does them no good to stop being miserable people to get you run around playing well received a evening from 6 on b.b.c. 3 counties radio then non-league. Anything was absent even after that and it just made me think you know what I want the part that fit the community again I want to be back to where I used to be old it was my club and it was well she didn't feel right by him for another club then non-league with. You must have been. Funny if I'd got 2000 pounds in just from people you never met and you are now you just appreciate what you're doing and what you're trying to save them on the game give some one they will be on the. Summing up and not bringing you all the schools and stories from. That. Every Tuesday evening from sake's on b.b.c. 3 counties radio. And. B.b.c. 3 counties radio spots and box truck. That still really sold the m. Force he had him down from stark contrast towards Chloe wake him that is flooding affecting the cellphone carriage way in the outside lane highways have have set the right lane closed because all about flooding so that's why we're still very slow down towards the highway can we can see all the cameras. And one that's very slow still in the south other option for you from junctions 10 mins annoying and it also down to the junction $7041.00 for exit just out of the volume of traffic and the weather conditions south but I want to add Stephen it's still very slow for the down pops I feel through how feel tunnel has eased off a nicely good news for. The southeast and right is now open it was blocked earlier following a crowd. And it's. Better now between so I think awfully still slow actually at all Station because of those 2 sets of 3 lights it's very busy only a full $13.00 jobs still a short queue nothing like as bad as it was earlier but a short few cell phone on the back of the a 413 traffic by the way Roman cleans both of moving while no one on the trains no reports of delays. The recount is ready of a current standard for hearts and barks 3 radio. Hits 1030 I'm Simon Oxley the highest court in the u.k. Is publishing in Cyrillic on whether Boris Johnson's decision to suspend Parliament for 5 weeks was lawful ministers say the suspension is not a court matter but critics argue it was intended to limit scrutiny of the Prime Minister's Bracks it plans if the judgment goes against Mr Johnson parliament could be reconvened immediately based Easyjet is offer discounted flights to people who had booked trips with Thomas Cook following criticism of increased prices in the wake of the firm's collapse Easyjet is offering a 15 percent discount Meanwhile the Civil Aviation Authority is planning to bring planning to bring another $17000.00 Thomas Cook customers back to the u.k. Today 2 men from Bedfordshire in Archer are among 23 people arrested around the u.k. As part of an investigation into suspected people smuggling follows a number of illegal crossings of the English Channel in small boats and drivers have been Want to take extra care this morning following the heavy rain bucks fire and rescue so they've been called to car stuck in flood water in the south of the county the weather rain continuing with some heavy and thundery downpours in places but it will clear the softer known for maximum temperature at 19 degrees Celsius those are the headlines the next full bulletin is at 11 Jonathan Bannon seen in these cities b.b.c. 3 counties radio and it's still a station that beds hearts and yes good morning if you've just tuned in coming up at 11 today I'll deal with your consumer problems also I will bring you the news at how. Happens with the Supremes Court ruling on the suspension of Parliament a decision is expected very shortly they've just started. Well I would imagine there's likely to be a bit of a legal preamble before we get any kind of decision on it but of course as soon as we do we will go straight to it 1st though we've been talking about the sound of children playing. And I've been asking you whether you think it is reasonable for people to have to complain about the sound of children playing nurseries hoping to overturn a decision limiting the number of under fives who are allowed to play outside together after neighbors complained about the noise the children are only allowed outside in groups of 5 or less following a decision by Chapman bar accounts of the nursery wants to raise the cap to 12 it's not the 1st time this issue has come up a couple of years ago there were similar concerns raised with local authorities in both Leighton Buzzard and Cambridge I've been asking do you think people have the right to complain about the sound of children playing Vincent Dunstable says I hate the shouting and screaming and squeaky voices all in the same key when I'm sitting in my pub garden for a quiet pint don't even get me started on Sainsbury's says fame it's crushed there's a loss or grumps out there I was grabbed hit here are not allowed Helen and flipped it callow Helen. Good morning do you think people have the right to complain about the sound of children playing. Too so I just I mean yes it can be horrendous it can absolutely drive you up war but I think it's a cop lie and I alone freeplay and they do if you know if you live next door to a school with their 1st is like the chicken or the egg when you move in knowing you were going to be next door to a school or was that school them Bill off to you you moved into your heart. Well I guess there will be instances where both of those things can be true you know kid children can be horrendous I mean the school we live in and the challenge I mean we were all young Yeah we were young but then I seem to recall I seem to recall there were times when my mom would you know come out into the garden and tell my brother I had to stop squealing or shouting a lot of because I've been strictly my son and he never bought me a dice Bubba and if I thought he was upset in the night with a get told to shut up and get in you know I've always been strict with him he's no one Jane now he's a take charge is piano teacher Bob Yes a lot of it comes down to that parent in thing where the children. They're not polite they're not well mannered or some of them all but some people parents I don't care what they do in the way they're not announced at all in them on here but you say but you see what was interesting was I played this 'd. Now that to me is not the sound of children misbehaving or scream. Mickey earlier. I mean that noise might put him on age and he said that if children moved in next door and he had that sound over the garden fence he'd have to move because it would make you Mom Well well that's going a bit beyond and I mean you know I would say in our main understand that you're going to get noise from dogs you're going to get noise from traffic you're going to get noise children yes but if a nursery I prince knew you well they fit a open Nate you and it's open since you've been lived there for x. Amount years and you're not used to the noise yet going to grate on you know but it sounds like that nurse is doing everything they can. To. You know. It could happen Helen you could find that your next door neighbors move and someone moves in next door and they were childcare and they've got a few children coming to stay every day and they let the children out in the garden you know that could happen to you. Of course like the children play in the garden next door to me I mean doesn't bother you there might be 12 or 14 children. Do make a racket you know they've got big claw I mean frames everything and sometimes you know if horrendous bar at the end of the die they are playing in the garden it doesn't happen all the time if it happens all the time it would try to match by New York Times that they do play children of thought play of an eye but I guess with a nursery or with child minders that kind of thing it's probably going to be a noise etc guy when the weather is good be every day yeah it could be horrendous if you're trying to relax in the garden you've got good screaming yes yes they drive you to destruction probably Ok Listen really good talking to you thank you very much indeed for your call. Passing Milton Keynes Hello Pat I like Jonathan Good on and good morning Pat what do you think and of people got the right to complain about the sound of children playing both. Live not too far from the primaries when the children are outside being. Think it's absolutely wonderful So you like the sound you know. Can you understand why people don't have a Mickey who suggested that it would make him feel ill to hear children playing every day in the garden How do you react to that I think you stroke it really thinking straight it was childish so. So it's a nice noise it's not something annoying. It doesn't know it may I mean I've got 2 great grandchildren as well and I live in a flat so that I've got a chance to go after play and to take out of there so that I managed. No no problem at all All right Pat thank you very much Luisa inclusion Hello Luisa Hello Jonathan good morning to you to talk to you nice to talk to you gee what do you make about people complaining then about the noise of children by Wow What is wrong with people you know I mean I agree with most of your callers because you know they love children and the sound of children you know but it was I you know I don't understand why people who dislike the noise of children it is like just say oh look children mustn't have phone make a noise it is just like dogs mustn't bark who're. Yes but don't I mean I have a dog. Ok but if my dog was barking it would be very annoying now there are some people who just become used to the barking. Went to Norfolk recently and there was a woman standing in the carpark with her dog and her dogs barking and barking. And she burst just standing there with barking a way that would do my haid in the sound of a not a dog barking and I would never expect my neighbors have to put up with my dog if it just barked. Surely it can be the same with children there's nothing wrong with children playing in the garden from time to time but if you've got say 10 or 12 children every day playing outside for hours squealing screaming making noise Surely that can be annoying. To people to try and understand totally you know. You know it is just lovely to hear happy children I just love happy it just makes a little bit different but but however you know the people there who doesn't like the noise you know they should be kept them too. Ok. You cannot stop that you cannot. Stop. Barking I know. What. That train the dog. Louisa thank you very much this person text as I do put you names on each excellent being able to credit you it's nothing more annoying than a normal mistakes anyway this person says I get annoyed with my neighbor's little boy I can kind of signal. To. Them that's he doesn't play in the garden never use them strange how if I you hear him running around the house knocking into the joining walls and shouting it sounds like he is sometimes on a toy with wheels you he had the toy going over the wooden flooring it can go on for hours as Anonymous. Children are a part of life although. They annoy it's the j.b.s. problems. But it has just been announced that the u.k. Super Supremes Court has ruled that Boris Johnson suspension of Parliament was unlawful. Government had said to the suspension purgation was not to court matter but critics argue it was intended to mimic scrutiny of the Prime Minister's Brix it plans while the decision has now been released and we now know that all 11 judges reached a unanimous decision that Boris Johnson suspension of Parliament was on Norful. Pretty pretty groundbreaking ruling that and was an earth happens now what an earth happens let's try and find out because Rupert Meyers is a writer and a barrister Good morning to Rupert's. And I'm stuck on a train but I hope you can hear me Just about yes let's hope this continues 1st of all your reaction then to the fact that it's being found Boris Johnson's decision to suspend parliament was unlawful Are you surprised. Well not entirely No I think I think the question if you were watching the case the question of whether it was justiciable was pretty obvious from the outset the arguments clearly in favor of the court having some power to determine whether or not this was lawful as to whether or not it was it was unlawful not about the degree you know I think that the government failed to provide a witness statement or any evidence to suggest that there was a proper reason or proper motivation behind this production and I think that the only thing that any prime minister with any decency could now do having unlawfully advise the moment to do something that they shouldn't have done is to resign so he says that the in layman's terms is that the conclusion of this then that Boris Johnson according to the law told the queen untruths about Palm and. The prime minister advised the Queen to do something that was unlawful and given that it is his job as prime minister to advise he has done so and in so doing failed he must resign it's a bit if you had. Told early that report was on a train unfortunately to pay he's gone through a tunnel we've lost him I think it's pretty pretty groundbreaking pretty groundbreaking the prime minister misled the queen regarding parading parliament Rupert saying that in normal circumstances this must mean that the prime minister resigns will this prime minister resign though Professor Antony Gleason is a professor of politics at the University of Buckingham Good morning to you and say good morning Jonathan good morning your reaction then to they say to this court finding. Well this is a very very important finding my personal reaction was one of huge relief because if the prime minister supported by Nikita cost legal advisor here had got the Supreme Court to agree what he had was lawful it would have meant to people like myself who be looking at this very carefully that the power of parliament the sovereignty of Parliament which lies at the very heart of our democracy of this country could be overturned and overthrown by a prime minister if they were minded to do so so I have been saying to people have begun enough to ask me I could not see how the Supremes court could allow Boris Johnson to Nikita cost. To go forward with this I could not see it and the fact that Levon the 11 judges the maximum amount of judges allowed to sit on the case have you nana mostly concluded that the advice that Boris Johnson the prime minister gave her majesty the queen to Perreault parliament was unlawful is not only you know whatever happens to Boris Johnson we can't know but it stains the fundamental principle by which we live in this country whether we're leavers or remain as which is that Palmer is suffering and you cannot have a prime minister suspend parliament what does it mean for Boris Johnson I mean Rupert miles just before we went into that tunnel where he was suggesting that this in any other circumstance would mean the Prime Minister would have to resign there is pressure on him to resign what the position he has put the queen in is unacceptable if she's resigning matter do you think Boris Johnson will be a prime minister who will resign over this. I think it will be very very difficult for him to stay in office not just him clearly Nikita cost who provided him with the advice I should think she should be sacked forthwith that's perhaps his best hope to sack Nikita Koester and sack Dominic got meetings and hold up his hand and said Sorry I've been a bad boy I listen to advice that was poor advice but I did it with the best of intentions I suspect that is how he will try to wriggle out of this but just imagine what her majesty the queen must be thinking she must be seething in Balmoral along with all of the royal family she's been totally traduced by somebody whose advice she is bound constitutionally to follow and the Supremes Court has said that advice was dishonest and disgraceful and should not be given so the mind boggles at how this will pan out as I say it is much better that Boris Johnson should continue as prime minister except that he has done wrong that that the court would have found in his favor because anybody could have done it he could prove a rogue parliament the day off during the election and not summons it again until the day before an election you could have government without Parliament but all if they the Supremes courts had allowed this and Boris Johnson could do it Jeremy Colby could do it so this is a really important principle I think it Boris Johnson were a man of all he would immediately resign end of story but I don't think he is a man of on that track and what for text to say is this treason. I mean is it is the trees 90 I don't think it is I don't think it is trees and I think that. You know the Treason Act has fallen into disrepute I would not would would not be used but surely it raises the question not just of the probity of the prime minister but of his ability to lead this country out all 'd of a constitutional. Sense of arrangements with us in the European Union that has guided us for better or for worse for the past 40 years people like me except there was a vote to break and if we don't like it too bad that's what we've got to do but there was never a vote on how to breaks it and that's really what this debate was about was whether or no deal would be acceptable so what Boris Johnson has failed to do is to. Get parliament to agree to a no deal parliament has was there for prerogative and he wanted to rule this country without Parliament watered down poem and then said to the poem and starts eating again I mean will they be back at work the softer new ice thing as sharpening their pencils already sharpening their pencils already there may be a vote of confidence who knows as I said right at the start Jonathan I think Boris Johnson's own future depends now on what those people who put him in Number 10 Downing Street effectively I'm talking about M.P.'s in the Conservative Party not the 90000 Tory members of whom I was well and who voted the 100000 who voted in the election does he still have the confidence of people like Ian Duncan Smith Does he still have that confidence because they will be tarred by the same the same brush if they don't say this is completely unacceptable their futures will also be in doubt this is a very very major turning point in our nation's history just his days and it will be it will be amazing to see what happens later on today I mean it she's absolutely . What it's remarkable what has happened sad sick remarkable but I don't I don't think you know I've just come out of Germany talking to a German learned society about those in Germany because they've got a written constitution and their mouths open when they heard of what was what might happen but there's another aspect to this ritual and they remember when almost a 100 years ago at all fit they did exactly the same thing with the German parliament in the manner but I don't know that is necessarily helpful to bring out of the room when talking about Boris Johnson was seized on I mean we're talking about the power of a political leader who may be popular remember 37th. The Sayers should surely then surely then the similarity ends there of course no I'm not so I'm not saying that the Boris Johnson is a hit nobody equally those who advised Boris Johnson that it would be Ok to suspend parliament and to give her majesty the queen that advice should have been mindful of not just Hitler also mostly all those people who tried to suspend parliament because they knew that parliament would disagree with what they were trying to do so that is something that is very important historical been a bit better but I'm not thinking it was very good talking to you Professor Antony Green is Professor of Politics at the University of back in the Right Honorable John Bercow speaker of the House of Commons a has said I welcome the Supreme Court's judgment that the purgation of Parliament was on the wall for the judges have rejected the government's claim that closing down Parliament for 5 weeks was merely standard practice to allow for new Queen's speech in reaching their conclusion they have vindicated the right and duty of Parliament to meet at this crucial time to scrutinize the executive and hold ministers to account as the embodiment of all parliamentary democracy the House of Commons must convene without delay to this and I will now consult the party leaders as a matter of urgency. Where. The latest twist in turn. In the current political situation in this country. It's the j.b.s. . Your local from top to much b.b.c. 3 counties radio. With the still stood. consumer problems 3 counties radio spots travel. Still slowly in full see heading down from slow contests to High Wycombe junctions 5 to 4 cold small the outside lane is closed because of flooding so that's causing delays. She delays unfortunately still to junction 1111 a rather the I 5 had very heavy downs junctions 741 for the street rather about that's cute. Each way they're looking at his feet sensors and the a 40 gyros crosses polyglots off with flooding there to both roadway them still very heavy if using that stretch to be a full on SUV the train's great more than the same 10 minute delays up tools when the stone because of flooding the pole is very poorly pvc 3 counters Radio thank you very much indeed for more travel news in half an hour's time coming up in the final hour of the j.d.s. Show then after the news I'll deal with your consumer problems phone lines are open now if you're having a bit of a battle you need some help with 08081 double 0 double a double 0 that's a number to call. Digital radio and to be on b.b.c. Sound and on your small. Town. It's 11 o'clock am Simon Oxley in the past half hour the Supremes Court has ruled that Boris Johnson suspension of Parliament was unlawful in a unanimous decision the judges said the prime minister's decision to advise the Queen to prorogue had the effect of frustrating or preventing the ability of Parliament to carry out its constitutional functions the president of the court lady Hale said m. Pais could return to the common so soon as possible the prime minister's advice to her majesty was unlawful void and. The preservation was also void and of no effect parliament has not. This is the unanimous judgment of all 11 justices and the m.p. For Bakken scale Dominic Grieve has accused the Prime Minister of gross misbehavior he's the one who has been pushing the envelope of our Constitution to the point where he's prepared to breach it was perfectly obvious. But the reasoning and the motivation for the purgation suspending parliament was bogus and untrue and the reasons given and I'm delighted that the Supreme Court has stopped this unconstitutional act in its tracks the National Crime Agency says it's found no evidence of criminality after investigating a series of allegations against the Breck sic campaign group leave dot e.u. And its founder Aaron banks the electoral commission had raised concerns about 8000000 pounds of funding for the e.u. Referendum campaign. You're the guy. Coming up in this hour today Helen's holiday problems linked to Headline News. So we decided to go with the ballots and with the holiday. Come pick up yes unfortunately it was Thomas Cook that she booked a holiday with what's the latest on the case we'll find out very shortly also forest not far is he's got his own problems to deal with today but Michael is applied for a real card for his daughter 7 times so he's still not come through for varying reasons motives. Could both look at my application but I should reapply again because. I put the paper probably and don't meet James in this hour my team tell me wasn't given the full picture when he bought a new bed frame but Howells's a television one of those.