Data Protection confidentiality and human rights and taking this approach I hope and believe we have resolved the information shooting controversy at the heart of named pension the Supreme Court has finished its hearing into whether Boris Johnson's decision to suspend parliament was a lawful The judges have said they hope to publish their reeling next week summing up his case against the government's large Pernik said the suspension should be left a decision as possible the remedy we seek from the courts is a declaration that the prime minister's advice to her majesty was unlawful and we would respectfully ask the court if you do use enough faith to make such a declaration as soon as possible but the government senior advocate in Scotland Lord King said the court should not be dragged into politics the applicants and the petition those are an advice in the courts into forbidden territory and then to what is essentially a minefield. An ill defined months old at the courts and not with the greatest of respect properly equipped to do. Source at Buckingham Palace has suggested there's an element of displeasure at David Cameron's revelation that he sought the Queen's help during the vote on Scottish independence Mr Cameron said he'd hoped for the raising of an eyebrow but he's told the b.b.c. He certainly didn't do anything unconstitutional right didn't ask for anything improper at the time Alex Salmond was saying that the Queen would be a proud monarch of an independent Scotland and there was a sort of frustration that that was being put in and nothing else was and so I had to talk to some of the aides of the Queen about that afresh Minister Nicola Sturgeon has told the Scottish Parliament to Mr Cameron's admission shows the panic of the heart of Westminster over the issue that the government has sent documents to the e.u. Setting out what ministers want from Bracks that they'll be discussions tomorrow about rules concerning customs and manufactured goods and in straight says it has nothing to do with the Finnish prime minister giving Boris Johnson 12 days to set up his ideas residence on Loch Lomond are going to explore the idea of a community by its of a bt sport after a developer with to withdraw its plans to build a 30000000 pounds to just resorts reporter Cora Gillis has the details more than 55000 formal objections were previously submitted against the Flamingo Land Development on the home and site the proposals which included a hotel craft brewery leisure center and restaurants were removed earlier this week after officials for the last moment and Chaucer's National Park Authority previously recommended its board reject the bed to the team behind it I'm not real date submitting a fresh application at a later date campaigners are now asking Scottish Enterprise who would most of the land to ally locals the charts digs explore order ship 1st Minister Nicola Sturgeon today said hard government will always consider proposals around community buyouts and visitors could soon be able to walk to the top of the 4th bridge if proposals from Network Rail are approved the operator submitted a planning application to install a bridge walk visitor hub. Were details from John Dickerson this is one of the world's most famous railway bridges and it's a $5000.00 visitors a year could be making the walk to the top Network Rail wants to build a bridge walk leading to a viewing platform on the bridges South Council leaver a visitor reception hub would be created at South Queensferry there are longer term plans to build similar facilities on the Fife side of the bridge it's a UNESCO world heritage site and a planning application is no with Edinburgh City Council let's get a little sport I with John Barnes thank you good afternoon Rangers will pay tribute to their former captain Fernando Ricksen and i Books this evening with a minute's silence ahead of the opening Europa League group match with Feyenoord Rickson digest of the after a 6 year battle with Morton you don't disease at $5.00 to $6.00 Celtic in Utah police action their way to the French club ran coverage of both much his own sports and on b.b.c. Radio Scotland it will be Jimmy now but the manager Democrat says he's experiencing the worst injury crisis next time for tawdry The latest to be handed to the lengthy injury list as fans or Joe who will be sailing for the next 3 months while fellow midfielder fielder Craig Bryson has also been for a month the world record holder the Bubba one of Laura Muir's main rivals in the $1500.00 metres has pulled out of the World Championships at the end of this month with a 13 jury and on the opening day of golds p.g.a. Championship at Wentworth scored Jamieson's a leading scorer and 4 under 3 shots off the lead which is held by England's Mike Wallace another scoreboard McIntyre is 3 under par Well that's a sport. This trouble comes from Theresa Talbot Thanks John good afternoon a 9112 love it and we'll deal with that accused in both directions through the board works Aberdeenshire the b. 97 for that c. Struck into bridge of die strange that are cues both ways you know I think that a roadworks just getting this check died I didn't get a 15 minute delays waistband and fatal and that's from Leith to Golden acres playing fields. And on the Edinburgh city bypass waste buying delays at the shade of whole roundabout so traffic's buying to the a 68 and a global West Bank just little 15 times head to 18 Channing cross and settle a mix of the a 73 through Robertson is close for resurfacing works and on the Fed's calm I call tidy ferry Council for the rest of the day because of technical reasons as b.b.c. Radio Scotland travel Scotland where they are staying dry for most with spells of brightness and sunshine to end the day however close your skies in the Northern Isles could produce the odd sports of drizzle and clouds will increase again in the Western Isles later temperatures reaching 152174 most of us highs of 18 to 20 Celsius in the east we're listening to b.b.c. Radio Scotland 7 minutes past the hour and this is news Dr with Gillian marls a source of Buckingham Palace suggested there is an amount of displeasure David Cameron's revelation that he sought the Queen's help during the vote and Scottish independence Mr Cameron said he took for a reason of an eyebrow but he told the B.B.C.'s Jeremy fine he didn't do anything unconstitutional I certainly didn't ask for anything improper to happen I was trying to explain the frustrations there were when you had one side in the referendum saying we're going to have a queen of an independent Scotland and everybody's fine and dandy with that and that was a frustration so I tried to upset that in the book but I said I'm not sure said you were to but you you put her up to something and that's not how I certainly did to give you a caring 1st Minister's Questions at Holyrood Nicholas sturgeon gave her reaction. Revelations if I can call them that from David Cameron to say more about him than they do anybody else and really demonstrate I think at the panic that was in the heart of the u.k. Government in the run up to the independence referendum 5 years ago when our Westminster correspondent David Porter joins me now on David this is to say the least caused a bit of a rumpus has not I think that is a bit of estimate Julian. There is a phrase that all publishers He is good publish they not necessarily sure with the reaction that we've had whether David Cameron agreeing with that if we can start minds back 5 years about a week before the independence referendum the queen was overheard when she left the church a week before the independence referendum saying she hoped people would think very carefully about the referendum and everything that was happening at the time that quite rightly got huge publicist see it now transpires that earlier on David Cameron Not personally but through his intermediaries his private secretary speaking to the queen's private secretary had basically asked the Queen to intervene David Cameron has defended himself saying he believes there was nothing unconstitutional about what he had done politicians have been reacting but they have been choosing their words very carefully as we've just said littlest I would imagine though that there will be some in the hours ahead who may be should we say a little bit more transparent in their reaction to it I would imagine Jeremy called when he was doing a series of b.b.c. Interviews the softer noone will be making his views on this perfectly clear and what kind of reaction have we had from the palace so far that well as you mentioned in your introduction the palace have suggested that there is an amount of displeasure I think that is coded language for saying that they are angry the way that Buckingham Palace works is that it does never ever comment on discussions the queen house with politicians and it expects politicians to abide by that by not speaking about any of the conversations that they have had with the monarch the queen has been on the throne for more than 60 years now she has worked with many prime ministers she does not expect. Any conversation she might have or her intermediaries would have with politicians would be to come into the public domain and of course it is not just this case that we've got the Queen and Buckingham Palace will be watching very closely the case in the Supremes court which against her will she has been embroiled in because Boris Johnson and his ministers went to ask for the purgation of parliament and now the Supreme Court is being asked to decide whether that was for or not never wishing to 2nd guess what the palace might be thinking I don't think at the moment they will be too impressed with politicians let's put it that way well yeah and you do wonder about the implications of all this these 2 cases as you said. Very much might change the relationship between politicians and the palace might yeah I suppose so the palace much you know is always It pains not to try and get drawn into these things and quite frankly I think they will be horrified that they have been politicians tend to come and go the queen and her advice to prime ministers and the really advice she gets from them remains constant but yeah I think there may be some quiet words hand in hers over the next few days and weeks saying look we just remind you that this is as far as we see it the way that things work we do not want the queen to be involved in this and of course David Cameron has form on this he had to apologize to the prime minister after the Scottish independence referendum when he was overheard on microphone saying she purred down the line when I told her the result of the independence referendum he had to apologize then and again in the interviews that he has been giving today he has said that that from his point of view was a misjudgment a terrible misjudgment in his words I think there's nothing more the palace and the queen. I would like for this all to go away as quickly as possible David Porter I'm sure it's not going to do that with our Westminster correspondent thank you 12 minutes past 4 Well today was the 3rd and final day of the hearing at the Supreme Court to determine whether the prime minister actively lawfully in the poor a geisha a parliament and evidence today the court heard that Boris Johnson suspension of Parliament was motivated by a desire to stop M.P.'s enter fearing in Brecht's that when the government argues purgation is not a matter for the courts under to collectors in law Glasgow Caledonian University Good afternoon to you thanks for coming in well I'm sure you are fascinated by this and on the face of it it doesn't look quite dry doesn't it the whole case but then when you hear it's about whether the prime minister misled. The monarch and whether he undermined parliament is extraordinary isn't it that the evidence that we've heard over the past few days yeah certainly the most the arguments about why this is happened it's a very dramatic constitutional case when this 1st started I thought it had a snowball's chance in hell of succeeding but as we've seen over the past 3 days there actually are quite strong arguments on both sides of the government the u.k. Government has really put all of its eggs in one argumentative basket their argument is effectively it's not just the Chabal which is just a pretentious legal way of saying it's not for the courts to intervene here it doesn't really matter why Boris Johnson asked the Queen to prove parliament it doesn't matter whether it was a good reason or a bad reason that judges should push out of it that's effectively what the u.k. Government as argued across today on the past 2 days I see they're putting all their eggs in one basket because I think there's quite a good chance the court does not accept that and thinks that really it's appropriate for the Supreme Court for judges following the rule of law to say Ok fine prime ministers have the power to parole parliament but that doesn't give them carte blanche to do it for whatever reason they fancy particularly if the reasons they've done so as was argued today by John Major's intervention are improper or unconstitutional reasons if they're effectively. Trying to stay me as Lord President Carlos described the petition as we have 2 different arguments there saying firstly it is just as should all judges should not be reluctant to step in in these particular scenarios and secondly that argument has Barossa Johnson has acted in a way which is unconstitutional temporal power and therefore following very traditional judicial review lines the courts are entitled and must intervene yet Lord Keane who is a government senior advocate in Scotland argued today that the court should be dragged into this because it's an ill defined minefield yet that was his arguments his argument is there really are no legal criteria by which courts are able to judge these questions for myself I don't find that terribly convincing and judicial review which has been developing since the turn of the 2nd World War is courts have become more active in scrutinizing and holding the executive to account uses a range of different concepts such as reasonable MOUs one of the core classic formulations of judicial review is a reasonable decision which has been taken another critical area as it is basically the factors which have been taken into account by decision makers are the appropriate factors sort of the to get something and appropriate into account that's really the core of what this case is about the argument is Boris Johnson has the power to prove parliament has been long recognized he can ask the Queen to do so but in the exercise of that discretion that power Lord panic argues he has take into account relevant and proper factors he has to prove parliament for a new Queen's speech for example of 4 so you know bringing on a new session over the course of a week his argument is here in this case we don't have those factors in play and it's very notable that the u.k. Government's lawyers over the past 3 days I've made no effort no attempt to lean on not justification we heard from Boris Johnson and his ministers this is all about the Queen's speech the arguments from Lord keen on the arguments from the other you can government lawyer effectively says it's none of your business judges it's not for you to call whether this is right or wrong you have no tools to do so and there is a suggestion that if this case does go again. The government that bars junction Johnson could just sign a new for a geisha in order immediately I would not go down and then would that would presumably end up in the courts Well I think would depend I mean I suppose what the purpose would be of that probation so if we got to that stage the court would have to accept one that they can have a c. And these circumstances about procreation Personally I think they will hold by I think that's quite likely that the court will see we can legitimately judge whether a probation is lawfully undertaken simply on the basis that we do this all the time and respect of all sorts of decisions made by ministers made involving political kind of associations and secondly is it for a proper purpose so we have to ask ourselves of any 2nd provocation Well what is the prime minister trying to achieve the circumstances had changed and others in the family yes circumstances have changed here I think the strongest argument which I must admit for me got a bit lost in some of the arguments that we've heard is critically the Boris Johnson's reasons for doing this for approving Parliament were simply improper that they were an attempt to Stamey to prevent M.P.'s scrutinising Breck's it and as I see we haven't heard any better explanation from the u.k. Government they were asked to provide affidavits the provided some documentation which provided a tiny window into the thinking of the cabinet into the thinking of Boris Johnson's government for doing this but we haven't had really any good explanation through all of these long 3 days of judicial process about why 5 weeks why this length of time and I think for me that's the critical weakness of the government's case it's all of its eggs in this basket of saying well it's not for judges to decide and if and when the dust settles or when and if the defendant think it should be Andrew do you think there will be long term implications of this whole case possibly certainly we're looking at a situation with bricks that were the 1st Miller judgment which was all about the royal prerogative and we seem to be ending and reaching the conclusions maybe a break sir with another discussion of both about what the scope of ministers powers are I said was It does raise fundamental questions which often slumber through British public life. But what kind of constitution do we have it's often said I think often rather pretentiously rather pompously that the British Constitution is the envy of the world having talked to people around the world I haven't found many people who are deeply envious of this way of working but it's inevitable given the vagueness given the conventionality given the lack of clarity but were powers are distributed given the reliance on often rather record political processes to hold the Government to account the you are going to have crises moments where the government will do something which is apparently lawful on the face of it which causes great political and in this case judicial ructions So I think there is an awfully likely to be an argument in the years to come in Britain do we have to look again at the basic law of this country and instead of relying on Victorian kind of good manners and gentleman government and all of that flummery and nonsense which really covers the fact that Britain very frequently has a constitution which gives power to the executive who is able to adopt and use that power whatever way it likes and historically the courts have been reluctant to intervene whether it's on national security whether it's an exercise of the royal prerogative to chop she got Sea Islanders out of their country in the name of the colonial rule of Britain abroad all of that is don't to the Constitution of this country and I think there will be people in the wake of this who are beginning to think much more seriously about whether the Basic Law Britain needs brought up to do under to cow thank you very much from Glasgow University. News drive on b.b.c. Radio Scotland as the main story is that 20 past 4 as we've been hearing the Supreme Court has finished its hearing into whether Boris Johnson's decision to suspend parliament was lawful The judges have said they hope to publish the ruling next week also this afternoon the Scottish government has scrapped its controversial plan to appoint a name person to safeguard the welfare of every child in the country and a source at Buckingham Palace has suggested there is an amount of displeasure of David Cameron's revelation that he thought the Queen's help during the vote on Scottish and. Pendants Celtic and Rangers have made it to the only group stage the . 'd Celtic players to the group stages and both teams will be keen to start the campaign which always. Sports and brings you live coverage of brand press and Celtic. Followed by updates from Rangers this is fine you know for sure there is a subset of today's some spiced r.c. On digital radio and each one only deal with. The b.b.c. Radio Scotland now Devon ems has won a high court battle to push through a plan which will close 50 stores and cut thousands of jobs Devon elms collapsed into it ministration earlier this year and announced it was launching what's called a c.v. 80 something that allows retailers to push through dramatic cuts in a desperate bid to stay afloat but that was challenged by a landlord backed by the Sports Direct Order Mike Ashley I've been hearing more from Emma Simson our business correspondent I think Devon him will be breathing a huge sigh of relief the soft and then been a huge distraction for them and few expected this action to succeed it was brought by a commercial property landlord who owns 6 Debnam stores and crucially the case was bankrolled by Mike Ashley the founder and c.e.o. Of Sports Direct and it all centered on this restructuring deal that Debnam did with its creditors earlier this year and it's called a company voluntary arrangement have been so many of these in retail over the past 18 months it's a form of insolvency proceedings which means in practice that landlords end up taking a big hit and in Devon in this case he had to rent cuts of up to 50 percent and at least $22.00 store closures not this got voted through but this legal action claimed that they the land. Lords were treated less favorably than other creditors like suppliers not was a number of it and it got highly technical But basically today the court rejected the challenge on 4 of the 5 grands So that means that Devon arms cannot push on with his turnaround plan which will include those store closures early next year and out of the challenge have been successful Deben ims would have appealed but it could have led to the unwinding of this restructuring deal almost certainly pushing Deben ems into administration so that's one less thing for them to worry about right now except they still have to worry about the trading conditions under suppose the big question is whether they can survive for the rest slimmer group can survive Oh that's right I mean you know trading conditions are incredibly challenging and there is a huge amount riding on Devon and this Christmas the big question mark still whether this c.v.a. Agreement was just a sticking plaster or whether they really can turn this business around and I think the jury is still out Christmas is going to be really crucial and also not just for Devon arms we had some financial figures from next today and it's finding things quite difficult as well I think it's said that it's autumn trading was quite disappointing what's going on there because at one point it was wasn't at the darling of the high street but I think Next put in a pretty solid set of results today in many ways they are defying the retail gloom I think they are a bit of a bright spot they had sales up by about 4 percent a harf year profits up nearly 3 percent and I think that's because it's a well managed businesses still got hundreds of high street stores but most of it sales and I want a line and it seems to be managing unlike a lot of other businesses managing this huge shift. Rather well so is saying today that high street stores are still really important because most people when they're shopping online do clicking collect So it's saying the rule of the store is changing it recognizes that trend of declining sales in physical stores is going to continue but it think that's going to be more than offset by the shift online a business is adapting and it's got its online platform no selling a lot of other brands because it will make as much money from selling other people's stuff but it sinks it does have a winning strategy that will see it through this incredible shift transformation and lethal that we're seeing that sent a sense in our business correspondent there 25 past 4 more sport with John Thank you Julian there's a big night of Europa League action in store with both Celtic and Rangers beginning their quest for progression from the group stage Celtic our 1st stop when the take on rain in France 5 to 6 u.k. Time that's kick off and the b.b.c. Radio Scotland commentator Paul Mitchell is already in place and the resign state resign park. Good afternoon what can we expect from Celtic this evening good afternoon John I think you can see Celtic's a 2 are going to come here with every confidence they've scored all 40 much easy played in the season of The One but defeat that defeat in the qualifier against clues but they recovered since then they got a good win against Rangers they come here a good form quite frank think it splits as well and of course with Celtic having a few French players in their ranks still no don't want to do well been back in the in the homeland it's an opportunity to present everybody's been impressed by the way the actors are Julianna settled in itself to get really looks the part of the backs of the chance for him to come to his homeland it sure. Will be a really good one for him I think he's proved to be a very shrewd Sonny by Celtic and of course you godson Eduardo who would be the main man up front we would expect to see any musical it goes in. Ripping competition the school into the last the journey really has amounted for its goals a season Sarajevo collusion a i.k.a. Really Celtics go to guy this season when it comes to go scoring in Europe but there's a lot of goals around the team who steals forces we discovered 5 consecutive European games for the 1st time and what about from any Airlie team news can you give us an indication at this stage Celtic are expected to be roughly along the same lazy been in the last couple reinvests physic is it 8 of their players have started all 5 league games like in mind they've changed the goalkeeper a couple of times as few players were expecting to see including Eduardo come of England 16 it's taken French football by storm he was the youngest ever League Player of the month which he was in August is an absolute sensation he gated them to victory against p.s.g. The same p.s.g. Say that Real Madrid last night to some delight to where we were and rain so he really is a key figure even at 16 years old he's not currently yet a French citizen he's of Congolese descent but I can tell you they're working very hard to get the citizenship through very quickly he's one for the future for the very near future for the national team as well as for Rand Paul thanks very much indeed that's Paul Mitchell there in France and their live commentary coming your way fine through 6 is the kickoff time for that one sport sones on the air from 530 and later on Rangers will pay tribute to their former captain Fernando Ricksen and I broke this evening with a minute's silence ahead of their opening Europa League match with Feyenoord Rickson digest of the after a 6 year battle with motor neuron disease and other news the Aberdeen manager Dan McInnes says sense he's experienced in the worst injury crisis and is time at Pittodrie elitist about it till influenced his fins or Joe and Craig Bryson is also ruled out for a month in Gulf News in the opening day of the p.g.a. Championship at Wentworth Scott Jamieson is the leading scorer he's. On 4 under par from Rome 68 that's 3 shots off the leader who's England's Mark Wallace another school ball McIntyre's on 3 under after a 69 Thanks John. Reason has the travel Thanks Gillian a 9112 loving will toward the accused in both directions through the road writes No the queen's for the crossing queues on the m 1000 north by and approach this is heading toward Fife your bike to the a 90 here Edinburgh a 15 minute delays westbound and Ferry Road from leaf through to the golden acres playing field and on the bus there the bypass West find Elise at the shit hole roundabouts your back to a 68 West in Barsetshire just getting used to have a breakdown on the 2 great western roads is causing the spine queues at boiling spines affecting traffic heading toward old Patrick and the m.e. Glaus go west by just little 15 time heads to 18 chatting trolls and on the ferries just a reminder cow Mike's culti sailing cancelled for the rest of the day because of technical issues 1900 $95.00 is our number that's b.b.c. Radio Scotland drive or looking at this to this proposal on top of the 4th a rail bridge in the next half hour trees that you'll be up for that you are named on a are titled a little the time now is half past 4 a summary of the news with Angela car Thank you good afternoon judges at the Supreme Court will rule early next week on whether Boris Johnson's decision to suspend parliament in the run up to Bracks it was lawful government documents submitted to the courts have revealed that the prime minister could decide on another suspension even if it finds against him a Scottish court has already ruled the propagation is unlawful although the government is fighting the controversial plans to appoint a named person to safeguard the welfare of every child in Scotland have been scrapped the scheme which was branded a snoopers charter by opponents was due to be introduced 3 years ago it was delayed when the Supreme Court ruled parts of the plan breached human rights laws it's often in the education secretary John Sweeney has confirmed it wouldn't go ahead a source that backing him. Palace says said David Cameron has caused displeasure by revealing he what that he sought help from the queen during the Scottish independence referendum and comments that were Whitely reported at the time the queen later said she hoped voters would think very carefully before making up their minds Mr Cameron has insisted that he didn't do anything improper but conceded he may have said too much or Westminster correspondent David Porter told us more about the palace is reaction the queen has been on the throne for more than 60 years now she has worked with many prime ministers she does not expect any conversations she might have or her intermediaries would have with politicians to be to come into the public domain the head of counterterrorism policing in the u.k. Has warned that far right extremism is the fastest growing problem his officers face Assistant Commissioner Neil Basso says a 3rd of the terrorist plots foiled in the last 2 and a half years have come from the far right here's the B.B.C.'s Home Affairs Correspondent Daniel Sandford it was the murder of the m.p. Jo Cox 3 years ago that 1st suggested that the risk of violent political acts from the far right was on the rise then 2 years ago Darren Osborne drove into a crowd of worshipers near a mosque in the fins re Park area of London killing micro Mali today Assistant Commissioner Neil Bass who said that far right terrorism has gone from 6 percent of his officers caseload to 10 percent in just 2 years since last year the security service m I 5 has been working closely with counter-terrorism detectives to tackle the threat police investigating the murder of p.c. Andrew Harper while he was responding to reports of a burglary have dropped the charges against one of 4 people accused of involvement dead Foster he's 20 has been in custody for a month 2 boys of 17 and 18 year old Henry longer appeal appearing at the Old Bailey on murder charges Scottish airports are edging ministers to dedicate a portion of the tax paid by passengers to tackling climate change the proposal put forward. The meeting last week is a significant u. Turn from the industry which until recently argued your departure tax should be scrapped when Hollywood takes control of the power environmental campaigners remain skeptical of their motives Alan Thompson is from friends of the earth Scotland seems like a conversion turn violent or activism as a card overnight Devon Strangely many of the airports opposed 80 it does seem strange that some are now supporting it. And I think we just need to be very careful about how that money is spent because we don't want the government to come to rely on a long term if we want to reduce the amount of flights we take daily Giants Miller has confirmed it's waning down operations at its Aberdeen deputy with the potential loss of $45.00 jobs the company says the distribution model for fresh milk has changed on the site is no longer viable and says the change will result in the creation of $22.00 new jobs in central Scotland where possible affected employees will be offered the opportunity to relocate and a man has gone on trial accused of using a fake a lottery ticket to claim a jackpot of 2 not half a 1000000 pounds in 2009 Edwards potman who's $54.00 and from Hartford share claimed the price just before the deadline he denies fraud b.b.c. Radio Scotland use the money it's about all the money spent by Angela thank you now let's get the weather forecast Christopher blanch at is here I was told I was reading that didn't pack we'll your summer clothes because we have an Indian summer which is part happening or for one day Scotland on Saturday is going to be nice weekend it's not technically an Indian summer you need various things to happen before you get there so you need more than one day or 2. Well actually you need you need a widespread hard frost to occur 1st before you get what we classify as new Indians so it's not hard not to listen and you know actually we're still in astronomical summer until Monday that's the official astronomical start of autumn so you know it's not too bad actually this weekend some sunshine and temperatures well into the . Twenty's and tomorrow is going to be pretty decent as well as it has been today lots of sunshine around temperatures are currently sitting up to around 20 Celsius across parts of the northeast but no matter where you are with temperatures in the mid to high teens and light winds feeling pretty good through the course of this evening and overnight it's dry with some clear skies tan a city temperatures down to around 5 to 8 Celsius some rural parts we cool in that around the West Coast holding at around 9 or 10 now with clear skies and light winds we're likely to see some mist and fog patches forming so could be a bit of a foggy start to Morrison into parts of central and southern Scotland some of those fog patches dense at times but they will clear and lift certainly by mid to late morning and then it's a dry and fine day on Friday plenty of sunshine around light winds and temperatures once again on the rise we're looking afternoon highs around 19 to 22 Celsius perhaps some parts of the northeast up to around seasonable 24 As for the weekend Saturday dry and 5 Most plenty of warm sunshine Sunday starts Ok but rain will edge in later in the day from the southwest that's the forecast. Digital radio f.m. Needy in wave and b.b.c. Sounds b.b.c. Radio Scotland time is 24 minutes to 5 the former 1st Minister Alex Salmond has accused David Cameron of totally improper behavior after he did feel that he'd sought help from the queen during the independence referendum in 2014 Mr Cameron said he had no quested anything unconstitutional merely a raising of an eyebrow Well this revelation certainly has raised a few eyebrows the B.B.C.'s royal correspondent Julie Diamond joins me now thanks for joining us we're told that there are certain monk told of displeasure from the palace what does this mean well I think you can probably Di code an amount of displeasure as. Cold fury I think think people are very happy at all Buckingham Palace about the David Cameron revelations he says of course that it was because Alex Simon was going around saying that the Queen would be proud to rule an independent Scotland and so he asked the Queen to raise an eyebrow in his own words . But the problem is of course for David Cameron you simply don't discuss the relationship between the prime minister and the Mona you don't discuss the week your audience is you don't discuss the relationship you have the whole thing is meant to be kept confidential and on top of that of course this now looks. May or may not be true but it looks as if David Cameron 1st of all I asked to use the queen in a political role which again we don't do under our system of government and it looks as if what she did say which you remember she said I think in about inches she said I hope people think very carefully before they vote it looks as if she said that because she was asked to you know it may have been that she was going to say that anyway we know she's defended the union in the past in 1987 she spoke both as the parliament. And spoke about the benefits of the Union she is queen of the United Kingdom it wasn't the most surprising comment in the world that she defend the Union but it now looks at any rate as if she did it to serve her prime minister and again that is not what we have traditionally thought the Queen would do so it's not just David Cameron then if this is the case if she did respond to David Cameron It's not just David Cameron breaking the rules the queen is breaking the rules as well then I mean you know I think questions do get asked about the role of the Queen about the kind of advice that she got from a private secretary about these gray areas of the Constitution I mean it's not just this it's also that the Supreme Court case is throwing a light on to these areas which have traditionally gone rather unspoken and have stayed in the shadows and suddenly it's sort of right how much discretion does she have how is she meant to speak how is she meant to act all of these things have been put to one side under our system of government this sort of strange constitutional system we have and suddenly these questions come up you know you you would imagine that the palace will act very cautious just in future with politicians you would imagine more the whole I mean this is again was a point that someone in the palace put to me which is the whole system of openness on which the relationship is based especially the relationship in the weekly audience between the prime minister and the queen the whole system of openness between the 2 of them is based on the rocks or knowledge that it will stay confidential and you spend as I have down time going through the memoirs of prime ministers and the big histories of the monarchy and you will find nothing or almost nothing about the relationship between prime ministers in the Queen because neither side writes about it or talks about it and here comes David Cameron saying exactly what he asked the Queen to do so it's a very different territory now yeah I mean do you think it was an unconscious. A slip up by a mortgage did you think you knew exactly what he was doing David Cameron that it would provoke this kind of reaction Julian remember it's not the 1st time he's managed to breach confidentiality with the queen because after the referendum he revealed to The New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg that the queen in his words heard down the phone him she was so happy something that she subsequently apologized for so he's got form on this one I don't know whether he said on purpose I don't know whether he said it's try and sell his books but he's done it before and he seems awfully casual with that rather precious relationship between Prime Minister a modern thanks very much indeed for your time this afternoon the B.B.C.'s royal correspondent there Johnny Diamond It's 19 minutes to 5 now in the u.k. Government says it submitted what it calls technical documents to the e.u. On what it wants from a bricks it deal but it says These don't amount to written proposals It comes after Finland's prime minister said Boris Johnson had 12 days to set out his breakfast plans to Brussels in which shirt his Bloomberg breaks it and European politics reporter Good afternoon to you good afternoon and how much do we know about these documents then not a great deal other than they don't seem to be much more than just sort of a sort of set of discussion points and ideas and probably just the sort of thing that have been discussed already in the talks in Brussels over the last couple of weeks basically fall into 3 categories or we're all talking about the Irish border and the backstop and it's what they call s.b.s. Checks which is all about how do you have an all Ireland zone for food and agriculture and then also customs and also about the flow of manufactured goods and what the British government wants to do is try to make make it easier for those checks to be done to the new checks are done on the Irish border but at the same time not to have this much to write a backstop within within the brakes in the. So their technical documents the proper proposals there are the proper proposals but they're just very technical it's a very good question it's a question that the e.u. Side have been arcing as well what the British government says is that we're not ready to give you those proper proposals now what is the reason for that 1 May speculate and some people think it's because they don't want things to be to be leaked into the public domain leaked to the other $27.00 capitals only for them to be shot down more importantly it looks like the British government wants to play the hand when they want to play it and that's probably very close to the e.u. Summit which is coming into the middle of October so there is far little time to think to talk around the subject to negotiate and it's very much this is take it or leave it you accept these proposals that we're giving to you otherwise it's a no deal and I think that's the game that they're all playing yeah well as I said the villains prime minister has given Boris Johnson 12 days to set out his Brecht's their plans to Brussels all real support. Or else water or else nothing very much really I think we can all sort of safely ignore what the prime minister of Finland this saying I mean it's it's it's a problem that has dogged the BRICs it talks all the way throughout the process almost 3 years now or deadlines have been set and deadlines have be missed and actually what's the repercussions of the deadlines being missed not very much at all so I think what the finished prime minister after his meeting with the manual macro on the French president said yesterday was we want you to present these formal written proposals by the end of September because they want to put some pressure on the British side not to do what I said it looks like their strategy is to do which is to come very late in the day with a take it or leave it offer but at the end of the day what's the alternative what if they don't come up with these proposals by the end of September probably not a lot really there's only one deadline is what some. The European Commission said to me last night there's only one deadline and breaks it and that's the 31st of October yen especially given there is such a breakdown in trust that nothing will be leaked ahead of that would would you imagine that is is another motivation for a keeper for the British government keeping its cards very close to its chest Yeah of course I mean you know Brussels is one of the leakiest cities in the wold in terms of intelligence and diplomacy and you know as a journalist here is very easy to find out what sort of things have been said and what documents have been passed around so there's an element on both sides I think Dick to at this very late very tense stage to keep things confidential and for them not to leak for them not to go into the public to meet demand because we know that you know everybody from politicians in Berlin to M.P.'s in the House of Commons to people in Northern Ireland will shoot those proposals down very quickly and once they've done last so you've got a month still to go where you go from there so I think both sides really think they've only got one shot at this to get a change of the brakes a deal that will be acceptable to all sides in Wishart thank you joining us live there from Brussels Bloomberg Breck's at and European politics reporter. News drives on b.b.c. Radio Scotland and the headlines at quarter to 5 controversial plans to appoint a named person to safeguard the welfare of every child in Scotland have been scrapped the Supreme Court hearing into whether it was lawful for the Prime Minister to ask for parliament to be suspended for 5 weeks has concluded and a decision is Jew early next week a source at Buckingham Palace has said David Cameron has caused displeasure by revealing that he sought help from the queen during the Scottish independence referendum. A travel update now from Theresa the 9 paras 15 minute delays southbound approaching the Broxtowe I'm going to buy it slow too in the north by. And m. 90 here Edinburgh the 8 Glaus good old West Bank solid from angles and through to new bridge solitude in a 71 called a road from Gore good old right through to the bypass and west and Barton showed a breakdown on the 82 day western road still causing east bank use it bawling and a wee bit slow West going to hear a Don glass roundabout that's b.b.c. Radio Scotland travel the Scottish government has you turned on its controversial named person policy it's to repeal the legislation after it have you found it wasn't possible to make it work without breaching privacy laws the news was leaked ahead of question time at Holyrood where the Scottish conservatives reiterated demands for the policy to be dumped here as our political correspondent Kirsten Campbell the Scottish government wanted to introduce a name to person for every child a teacher or a health visitor who could share concerns about a child's wellbeing with other agencies for example social workers speech therapists or policeman counselors but critics argued it amounted to a snoopers charter and the courts ruled that some of the legislation breached human rights law news leaked in the morning ahead of a parliamentary statement in the afternoon that the government to decided to repeal the law the Scottish conservatives interim leader Jackson Carmel said the policy was discredited everybody from teachers to social workers and most crucially of all parents have made their case against it patiently and coming and rather than listing the response of ministers has been to stick their fingers in their ears they've refused to budge and as a result the ordinary taxpayer has been life of a staggering legal bill of 800000 pounds and teachers and parents have been left as usual in the dark but the 1st minister stressed that the government had the child's best interests at heart what we're talking about here issues of child protection and all of us want to make sure that we have the systems in place in this country that give children particularly children living in vulnerable circumstances the greatest pretty. In that it is possible to give them the education theme continued turn the Scottish Labor leader Richard Leonard raise concerns about cuts to university funding we used to be proud of the international reputation of our universities but the European but the European universities Association's cold Scottish higher education and I call them a declining system under pressure he called for the real terms increase in the sectors budget Chanda 1st Minister explain why our universities have been de prioritized by her government Nicholas sturgeon insisted she was still proud of Scottish universities over universities are performing strongly we have more top 200 universities prepared of our population than any other country bar Switzerland we're setting repeated records for students going to university from Scotland and we see more people going to university from the poorest by going with massive progress in widening access the Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Willie Rennie also stuck with the topic of education he created twice the government was pressing ahead with testing in primary one despite a parliamentary vote to stop it Xperia out against the tax teachers have spoken out against the tests parliament voted against the tests I know he's not having a good day but well the 1st minister finally lesson and tell John Sweeney he's got to scrub the test on the 1st ministers at the assessments for proportionate and right we will continue to take the action to ensure that we have the information that teachers have the information about the performance of children so that they can help those children who need extra help and make sure that children are performing the levels we should be that's the right way to proceed and we will continue to do so it emerged overnight that the former prime minister David Cameron sought help from the queen ahead of the independence referendum amid mounting panic he may lose the queen later. There are people outside Kathy Carrick to think very carefully about the future 5 years on the Scottish green Co convener Patrick Harvey wondered if the queen would be asked to intervene again we've seen the u.k. a Lot from crisis to crisis we've seen the promises about protecting our place in Europe broken and we've seen the u.k. Government treat devolution with utter contempt. Another referendum is coming we all know that does the 1st Minister think that we can trust that the head of state won't once again be invited to interfere in a vote of the sovereign people it's understood Mr Cameron's remarks led to an amount of displeasure at the palace the 1st minister who had an audience with the queen bomb model airily or this week wasn't amused either I think they revelations if I can call them that from David Cameron and. See more about him than they do anybody else and really demonstrate I think at the panic that was in the heart of the u.k. Government in the run up to the independence referendum 5 years ago Nicholas Turgeon said Scotland's future was for the people of Scotland to decide we know that support for independence is rising demand for another independence referendum is rising she insisted that when the time comes Scotland to choose independence Kristen Campbell reporting there the time 9 minutes to 5 fast food chains have been coming under a lot of pressure to cut back on the use of unnecessary plastic things like straws lids and cutlery Burger King has been giving away plastic toys with some of its children's meals since the 1990 s. Its rival McDonald's does the same thing 2 sisters from Southampton started a petition to get them banned and it's no good over half a 1000000 supporters well this morning Burger King announced it was stopping the practice in a separate announcement McDonald's said it will cut give customers the option of swapping plastic toys in its Happy Meals for fruit bags or books well so how significant is this in the fight against plastic Steve Hind is campaigns manager of the environmental group city to see this is really just the most wonderful news there where you cannot see this morning how inspiring that we've got to junior school aged girls in Ellen Caitlin. Who've managed to launching their petition and campaigning on this to change the policy of an multinational than a zation like Burger King I mean it's wonderful nice and it's really an inspiration to us all yeah it does prove doesn't it the public purse suasion in the in the form of these 2 sisters that can have a big impact counter Yeah and in this case I think it's course huge impact in 2 ways 1st of all the king estimates that this will save them 320 tons of plastic every year and secondly it's as you say it illustrates the consumer led campaigns are really working with young people increasingly speaking out about the importance of climate change about the importance of plastic pollution I think Biz business big businesses like Burger King are looking at future markets and they're making changes or like she said it saves what $320.00 tons of waste Angele That's the estimate now it does sound a lot but in the great scheme of things it's probably fairly tiny isn't it. I mean we should make no mistake 1st who shouldn't belittle how much 320 tons of plastic is it's a big big saving but you're right to say that there are a 1000000 tonnes of plastic entering into our oceans every year and so the problem is very very big but the reason I'm so excited and the reason I'm so optimistic I'm fine food alone Kaitlin for this is that I think it also marks a shift because what we need is in every industry we need people to look about how they can reduce the amount of plastic that's currently in their supply chains and then to switch to reuse to go containers if you can't reduce them reduce plastic in the 1st place and this campaign shows that that's perfectly possible in the fast food industry and really we can see that across the different industries how this is working so if I can give another example Marriott Hotels the biggest hotel chain in the world announced a couple of weeks ago that it was going to cut out this tiny little bottles of shampoo that you get in your and your hotel bathrooms now this well move is going to save half a 1000000000 plastic bottles a year this is really exciting as I say it's business from across different sectors are looking to shift on this because it's being led by young people well yes and it's young people in this instance that did persuade Burger King to to think again that really you want to get to the position where it's companies thinking for themselves don't you know how do you do that. I think this is this is a tea fold step so we've got consumers illustrating that there's that there's a real demand out there for businesses and government to look to see how they can reduce the amount of plastic that's currently being used and then I think businesses own creasing be looking to take proactive steps and part of what we're doing is if you see if we're working with businesses to to to make sure that they are that they're going on this journey with us with consumers to try and reduce the amount of pointless plastic that they're producing and that they're flooding us with no consumers so I have to admit that I was one parent who used to take my children to particular fast food restaurants because of the plastic toys because I was under pressure to do that you have to things have changed but you've got to persuade consumers that they don't want those plastic toys they don't want these little mini bottles of shampoo haven't you. Absolutely that and I think what Burger King of done today I mean they wouldn't have rushed into this decision you know like their bottom line is what's important to them and what they're saying through this announcement today is that they're confident that they can give a really positive really fun experience for young people and for parents if you go into their restaurants and want to eat their food and said This doesn't necessarily have to and tayo flooding them with pointless bits of plastic that we know break easily and will be flown away by the end of the day mostly another question for McDonald's is why can't you Well exactly and I was going to say you know the pressure is now on other companies isn't it to do something. Absolutely that and others saying before this isn't just about McDonalds or Burger King it's not just about fast food place about across the whole wheat Alex perience about how we've completely normalized single use plastic and we need to be moving away from that and we need business to be leading that change that Steve Hind from city to see how would you like to go for a walk more than 100 meters in the air along the top of the 4th rail bridge Network Rail has submitted a planning application to install a bridge walk and visitor how the operator hopes it will attract tens of thousands of brave souls a year we can speak now to Nick King from Network Rail Good afternoon to you often you can count me out for a start I have got a head for heights but it is a glorious structure tell us more about the plans. Well as I You see our wonderful structure in our world famous one and we're very confident there's one a lot people would like to visit and obviously we completed a few restoration renovation of the bridge back in 2 $1011.00 and as part of that process we were able to install lamp scaffolding and what we've gone she's told this Lee gained access the structure and from out we obviously got the idea that it may be something that we could do on a permanent basis and open up to the public over the last few years we've been walking up those plans and looking at the kids grow up I don't have a bridge walk experience similar to the one even begin in Sydney and would like to do it maybe able to submit response to the council so is that a claim up the way then quite a steep climb up the way up a lodger's or or whatever and essentially what we're looking at doing is building a visitor's hub on the South Koreans pretty saint of the of the branch and then and taken groups up what we would call the safe contra leader of the 3 can of large triangular toes on the bridge the Solomons one of the Lucy would walk up through seas of catwalks and staircases that we would build into and the steel structure Turgeon platform at the top What's it like at the top of the bridge of you beat up it's. The Edge I don't think you can quake grasp the scale of the bridge from the grain I have been lucky enough and to be out of the talk of the structure previously and you do lose all sense of scale that this just your work is so huge that you feel you're standing the talk of a building rather than talk of a bridge and you want to get a sense of scale when you look down and see how small the small house is nice small boats and even the cruise ships in the war Below is an absolutely unique view and a unique place to be and we're very constant as you see tens of thousands of people want to experience it yeah you're hoping is that it's a 5000 visitors a year that you're estimating and that's what you're going to trust that's forward estimating and obviously it's hard to know. I'm actually successful and such a scheme would be at this stage that working out what's wrong elsewhere and what can I put it with Rick says we all charities that we think that's the reason waste and we're on the job at the moment to the general public. Charity events who take people to the talk of the North Tower who we've got a good left for to come. And we do that quite a charity more to that this weekend so we are chord structure will be a very popular Ok will not King thanks very much indeed I'll just rely on the photos and videos he's from Network Rail. On digital radio a family medium wave am the b.b.c. Sons b.b.c. Radio Scott. Good afternoon it's 5 o'clock this is news Dr with Julian Morrow tonight displeasure at the Palace after David Cameron reveals he tried to involve the queen in the independence referendum I certainly didn't ask for anything improper to happen judges at the Supreme Court in London retire their decision June next week the remedy we see from the courts is a declaration that the prime minister's advice to her majesty was unlawful and the online travel sites pressurizing us into booking rooms the truth was they were for it for I'm still available Barrie tell 10 of which were actually available lower cost. News now with Angela car Thank you good evening the Scottish government has scrapped its controversial plan to appoint a named person to safeguard the welfare of every child in a statement to parliament the education secretary John Sweeney said an expert panel had not been able to come up with a workable could of practice and. He now intends to repeal the legislation a political correspondent Kirsten Campbell reports the Scottish government wanted to introduce a name to person for every child a teacher or health visitor who could share concerns with other agencies like social workers speech therapists or bereavement counsellor as the scheme branded a snoopers charter by critics should have come into force 3 years ago but the courts ruled some aspects breached human rights law and I expect panel couldn't come up with a workable code of practice so the education secretary has been forced to been the policy and will repeal the legislation the conservatives described the U.-Turn as a complete humiliation Boris Johnson is a facing an anxious wait is the Supreme Court decides if he suspended Parliament's unlawfully The justices will come back with their reeling in this extraordinary appeal case early next week leading member of the cross party group of politicians who are opposed to the suspension say they're cautiously optimistic when a political correspondent Andrea care has been in court 2 cases are being appealed at the Supreme Court the Scottish one which time for sport one hears John Barnes Thank you Angela The Celtic manager Neil Lennon has stopped by the same starting line up the beat Hamilton Accies at the weekend for their opening Group match in the Europa League against ren kicks off in France in 15 minutes time and sports and we'll have live coverage from 530 Rangers will pay tribute to the former captain Fernando Ricksen i Books this evening with a minute's silence ahead of their opening Europa League group match with Feyenoord Rixon died yesterday after a 6 year battle with Morton your own disease the reminder that McInnes says he's experiencing the worst injury crisis in his time apart or dream the latest a reality the infelicities phones or Joe who will be sidelined for the next 3 months while fellow midfielder Craig Bryson has also renewed from one thing and the new opening day of goals p.g.a. Championship at Wentworth Scott Jamieson is a leading scorer on 4 under par 3 shots off the leader England's Mark Wallace. No the scoreboard McIntyre is 3 under after a $69.00 as a sport. Which has trouble with trees of Homer thanks John a 9 to Aberdeen Western peripheral route an accident blocking a lane just at least on Haven roundabout so this is causing south by inches on the in 1000 to right back to Stone Haven Golf Club in one parent still single and 50 minute delay southbound approaching Broxton roundabout slow 2 in the north by into .