Word she also calls for an extension to Article 50 or the exit period to a low time for a 2nd referendum Jenny Davidson from Hollywood magazine says the Commons could be moving towards a 2nd fault I think Nicholas or is it right that that actually asked a 2nd referendum to see whether people still actually want Reg's it to go ahead given that they've seen what's happened over the past couple of years and now has become more likely obviously next week and this possibility of different amendments when trees are me comes back to parliament the chairman of the Labor Party in lovably has insisted there's a chance the reason we could lose a vote of no confidence in her government the c evening the Labor leader Jeta make or been tabled the motion in the immediate aftermath of M.P.'s rejection of to these amaze breaks a deal the government's expected to survive because the D U P and conservative rebels have pledged their support Mr Levy says Mr Corbin was right to act we believe that it's the optimum trying to secure which are to the Tory of Page and hope but we'll see the need for a general election the German chancellor Angela Merkel has said there is still time to negotiate ahead of the U.K. Shared job departure from the E.U. On the 29th of March Mrs Merkel says she's waiting to see what today's a me proposes and other news inflation has fallen to its lowest level in nearly 2 years the Office for National Statistics says the rate as measured by the Consumer Prices Index dropped to 2 point one percent last month from 2.3 percent in November Kenya's president has said that a siege in a luxury hotel in Nairobi is over and that all the attackers have been killed at least 14 people have died with the U.K. High Commissioner to Kenya confirming that at least one was a British man from Nairobi the B.B.C.'s Africa chorus. Under an under Harding reports president who can Yetta went on national television to announce the end of the scene some 1000 hours after it began the sound of gunfire and explosions had continued well into the morning here in Nairobi a number of ambulances arriving at the scene overnight dozens of civilians were brought out of the upmarket hotel and business park in all the Kenyan government says 700 people were rescued some have been texting relatives from their hiding places President Kenyatta concerned about the country's precarious tourism industry said it was safe for foreigners to visit Kenya but said the nation remained on the highest alert there's been a fire to train jurors A.F.C.'s training center in Middle Eastern bar to ensure a number of crews attended the scene at all can have a complex and extinguished the police on the ground floor support and here's Phil Good luck Christine thank you get a turn saying this name 3 uncapped who curse in Scotland squad for the 6 Nations which begins next month less this chick can cherry from Edinburgh and Glasgow Grant Stuart join Stuart McAnally in the national group for one cup players include New Cassel flanker Gary Graham they've been recalled as has former Edinburgh forward John Harvey who's no with Newcastle the American doubles player Bob Bryan believes Andy Murray can come back from help surgery and resume his career at the highest level but I've had the same head priest surfing operation that Murray is considering I just returned to Grand Slam tennis earlier today with a fashion victory alongside brother Mike at the Australian Open doubles you had a Continental is the only British player remaining in the Australian Open singles but after Dan Evans and Katie bolter both went out there's plenty more at our website on not just the Scotland squad announcement but on those comments from Bob Brown who has gone through the same operation that Andy Murray is contemplating you can get that. At B.B.C. Dot com dot U.K. Forward slash sportscotland. Such a sport 1st or Wednesday morning let's get your travel Good morning to Victoria launch them good morning on the Isle of Lewis the 859 is partially blocked by a collision and traffic is queuing emergency services are there the route is not possible it had been closed but opened around an hour and a half ago in the highlands the 89 as slow traffic both ways around the to Martin distillery turn off the road works in Tempe lights here in Aberdeen in 156 Wellington road is partially blocked by a shed load south by and around the Charleston junction emergency services are there too and in Edinburgh traffic a slow one for Harry Lauder road heading out of town on the approach to the A one Milton Road and that's B.B.C. Radio Scotland travel Scotland's whether the Met Office has issued a yellow warning to be prepared for snow and ice from noon today across central Scotland Teesside and Fife Grampian the Highlands and Islands Orkney and Shetland and Strathclyde several centimeters of snow expected over the Highlands and Grampians whilst at law levels snow cover will be smaller and patch shared in nature with some places especially coastal lady has seen little lying snow conditions will also be windy and icy stretches out expected where the snow doesn't settle B.B.C. Radio Scotland news are you serious Christine I know you it's awful isn't it we were a lot of I know a little dog that they kept telling it was getting cold it was all the Met Office that did that just in the past day or so Be Be aware be prepared to snow come out of what you want to stay for the whole of the old me. Never seen anyone look so unhappy with a little corner or is seriously let's just beside ourselves. Was. I was just complaining about the shape of the hoof though my lord you're listening to B.B.C. Radio Scotland there with me K. I was still to come before 12 the leaders of. Yeah that's the message from the new it's bold but it has received quite a backlash with more negative likes on the video the positive so is it an attack on men or a change for good some days come into clear the studio in advance of boundaries hula hooping attempt and self placing traders have been unveiled by a major sports where. Do we need them and we return to the action after the meaningful vote last night about where we are the bricks it approves says Tell us how you feel about it give us a call wait a week 59295 to follow your calls your story mornings with key items on B.B.C. Radio. But I don't know how these things happened we were talking about scales that you had lost in one minute we're talking about hospital corners and then on reports up and says well onto the scale I have lost is to do a hula hoop and so we said you know. Always this girl Oh well can anyone here. Go and say Our lives are. You doing this yes stay where you are. And very delighted that we have managed to procure a hula hoop she thought that we wouldn't be able to do it said Christine and I'm see Phillips on one season. Didn't realize he was as resourceful yet you find a hula hoop in the B.B.C. Well there you go there you go to a particular place and so we are going to reintroduce you to your hula hoop all due to know is she in the right position because good news to get your Daily Mail gets better and better because we're able to film this and puta on our Facebook page. You know you see the day after the breaks it didn't any of us expect and maybe to be doing a hula hoops with the. Kind of what the nation needs we live in interesting times what the company says I think you feel like we have a bit harsh please could we have a bit of dark and I used to give thanks when I used to give I think saying well get on a T. Shirt to go it's going to be rubbish so yeah. Well yes I can not was rubbish. Going to have a show and come on like I did we are in goal or it's like what is it is it be that bad it's there we go right it's a been told no we have a right you're ready yes here we go you're going to do with your thing right here with my clothes oh well you do you. Do you know that well it doesn't it wasn't bad to be honest I think you have to taint it was it was my keyboard that's what the old kind of that is my thing I want to go get up go up here and I want. To know what's hot then I got a moment of trying to fail Kay here we go Kat is taking the hoop and she's doing it with her ankle people she's decided to go for an alternative view oh I'm just on the right. Well. The funny thing is the camera is never going to pick up steam you just took it up. Or she was doing was doing it with a food lover's achieve Kristie. The most awful your injured a moment of clarity mine was. Telling me. Come on you can have some. Sort you're going to reason be all be doing the same a couple of hours just to cheer yourself on the East Coast which particular interesting little. Girl really. Well oh I think we can relate I'm still going. That's what I'm saying here head says it was not covered in butter doesn't use the rubber things. Right we better get back to work well yes you can go thank you very much a good sport there's nothing on the. Bike or. To be honest I was never able to do it I could never did I model but as I said I used to be able to go quite far with it and my fit and the rest as well. You know. We get back to what you were blooming here for I know. Well you know just where. The old you. Are right restated look at lots of people get in touch so basically Facebook has and I know that you can use your birthday to fundraise so you can pick a charity that you like and you can set up your own little page set a target choose an N.D.A. Tell people why you're doing it and if you just click the Create button all your friends your Facebook page will have this thing saying it's my boss the and here's the charity reason money for and we were just asking the question is it a bad thing because some folks are a little bit prickly about it they're not keen on but asked for money and some folks think it's a good idea which. Basically results money for a good cause it is so and so what kind of response of we have actually has been mostly positive good which I didn't expect so there's a couple of people that remain so of need they need convinced So start with absolute no I'm from Glasgow said no I defended the birthday thing at a minimum of a fiver so I think and said no because she's been told what you have to do you know you have to give more than a fiver M.J. Via text he's not convinced he said I can't help feeling in some cases trade funding is just a euphemism for begging Although however he concedes I do accept that when awareness and or funds for a charitable cause are raised it can reach a lawful can therefore it can do some good so that there they still need a little bit of persuasion and that's what I am a great kick from the D. The whoever he's got to do what he did a Facebook fundraiser for the chaste Heart and Stroke Scotland and Amy said to been a massive help in my life after my wife had a stroke and $26000.00 so what he did was he put up in Facebook if you would buy me a pipe from a birthday normally then stick that fiver on he'd instead and he made $270.00 quid do you know that I mean who could argue with that could argue with that will grant Gallacher could Good morning draw. Your morning good morning who could argue with that. I think I probably did I think I probably could go on then I'm not all that keen on having a socially Cherry muggers or getting the street being dropped into my Facebook feed is the worst part is that it's not even just enough basically judging a notification when money or friends don't charge $1.00 of these things up so I think I've got checks or something dollars and some really good like 2 natures church members and I just all I just I just of I just like I also can't help but think that maybe just maybe this is trying to make themselves seem a little bit better after fundamentally undermining our democracy so I'm not a normal human and I think a lot of the poor. It would make for teeth to think and can make your friends seem mellow but check me I'm very wordy you know like a good thing for them today artist I do think so but part of me when I was talking about this last name part of me does worry that that's just because I'm certain there is a shared soul no especially turns into a grumpy old man so I don't know whether this is just me like just get angry at the kids with their music these days and things like that it does I think it seems a little bit. I don't know if you know about holier than though well I did when I turned 40 and believe it. Youthful youthful face with. A 75 when I turned 40. 2 what is on the Facebook page we're putting out to worry about that ground. My 40th birthday I actually had a party and what I said on the advice was a Sade I was just going to have a bucket on the night and people could just fight and some money didn't matter if it was 50 pence or whatever and I gave it to the Tartan Army chosen strategy and on the night at least $1500.00 quid that went there because that was very much a case of when you're physically come into a party people will give you a graphic here on the idea that it's a lovely because those are real friends you're going to die real friends to a party whereas we all know that that particular platform you know the word friend you know get straight to it doesn't it yeah absolutely subregion going really I mean I look I don't know I mean I'm kind of what you got in that there's just something about that kind of. Me I mean I've got absolutely loads of people get in touch with music do with everybody Oh sure I'm doing this Ron for the charity I'm doing this or whatever you know I mean I'm absolutely right about that yeah if I want to. Will the day and most times hopefully but it's the attachment to the past the thing that just feels a bit. Stream of my friend to do exactly what you've done when I had a party for it and as you say possible nature because you're on your own when the table anywhere you're on you know buying drinks in one origin and present it was easier to put money and was I think just a very slightly good everyone and you don't like how the money is spent So if you choose the charity know all charities are created equal and you don't really get to you know you have to tax and just as you rightly said it just comes across as a bit condescending but isn't the point though that your friend has chosen that charity so they've you know it's obviously meant something to them in the 1st place . National nation where the national word your friends are stretched to breaking point so. You know your friend you are not going to college but I do think the whole time you know what a little bit annoying I've got the message from Katie via takes and she just says in a society that we all have more than enough given to charity donations to help those with nothing is an excellent idea unless we all feel it's more important to physically receive bath salts and candles Yeah I mean yeah I get that I absolutely get that but the thing is I wouldn't put a label on anything that I mean I completely nor my birthday I only have one every 10 years and I. Know that you're expecting gifts or wanting gifts toll but I don't know I don't I mean that's right I mean who can complain about giving to charity except John and me. Need some of those so you can go to stress to think about a little money and I think that basically inclusion is you know to let's say you did a if you feel inspired to and don't if you don't yeah yeah I know but you feel guilty because you don't want to be the horrible person do you not think because maybe you feel a bit so a boxed into a corner you know because it's also very public isn't it because somebody so I'm done doing the Madison and I'm going to do it 1st thing you get in the mail and you make a decision whatever but it's like your show to doing it and also the person who is setting up it's like a marvelous person and you're an absolute Well I hate that just giving when you can see what people have donated and you know like you are only going to give them a tenner and like all your friends of getting them there to question your own you know you don't want to be that person and. Want to no matter how charitable a person you are. It gives you like not guilty conscience feeling that you. Should mention issue about even if you even if you do need plenty of other charities and I think you have to watch that about it so what can. Solution than just think very much what just said there don't let it bother you just so much you know what old at the moment don't let it bother you if you're friend as a close friend and you maybe give them a birthday present normally then yeah give the money to the charity if you don't fancy if it's not for you just don't press that click on there you go grow we've been given a by there by. You are you. See another one from Hazel Have you spotted that one cannot yet. Say my daughter was diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis earlier this year to draw awareness to this life changing disease I asked for incidentally to. Told us our society on my birthday through Facebook I set a target which was exceeded within a few days and doubled my original target Also every time I buy from the tinny to the rheumatoid arthritis so I see that see that's brilliant and I want to mention barely remember I said I've given 20 pounds to the Spanish dogs yes I said Mickey but Alison income Martin has been no one and she said it's an amazing charity this one because it's cruelty to hunting dogs over there so the fact that my friend was so passionate about it I actually I was delighted to give them that money as I knew it meant something to him and it's going to do some good as well but there are so many charities out there if you want any Dinny don't feel guilty to feel pressure Well that's good advice I'm feeling very She thinks everything you know. You read a textbook you didn't read to say is going back to Andrea's Hula-Hoop. She's talking about giving and didn't want to get because it was a 5 and she's also I cannot pick up a MUCH box off the floor with my teeth which is an all party trick from my youth. I got much more you probably did not get back up from a. Cat thank you very much that is very lovely saying I had never heard of the. Birthday fundraiser so never knew all about it so I'll be a bit more generous in future faking it good thanks very much nice to speak to you . For the dreamers it's been a challenge to make it this. Going home for the common for the playoffs with all the no good one but that's good and it's only sad to get Scotland's top flight teams and to the competition this is where the cultural barriers to those given small clubs like this are great occasion but will there be any shocks in store as the 4th rank get some to weigh players such as a cut in the Scottish Cup on the B.B.C. Catch all the action right across the weekend kicking off with prices ranging. From 6 up to him to reveal no medium wave B.B.C. Radio Scotland get in touch with B.B.C. Radio Scotland call our free phone number on only to wait by 9295 you can text on to 95 network charges apply mornings on B.B.C. Radio Scotland. Yeah it's 1121 this is. Up until 12 will be taking a Coles before 12 or in your reaction to where we are with bricks it how you feeling about it I'm just kind of scanning the T.V. Screens there to resume a promising and a new proposal by Monday and Nicholas sturgeon is speaking at the moment looks like in this is live from the central lobby at Westminster saying a 2nd round referendum is the only credible option to end the impasse so we will get your thoughts. In a wee while before 120-808-5929 extension 5 double 0 is the number to call and we have a clamor wanting to know is the Hula Hoops thing going to be on social media well we've got one text actually but never mind so I would call a comma and yes it will it will be on the K. Adams program Facebook page just as soon as we can get it out there so if you just so. K. Adams program on Facebook and you can see we don't bring you an eclectic mix conure with Gore and Marie hula hooping on Facebook and we want to know what you think about pricks it wait 59295 W. And we also want to know what you think about this after its release on Sunday the new Gillette short film has amassed over 2000000 views. Which backs the hashtag me to movement as well as calling out and includes toxic masculinity and bullying amongst men and boys and the Gillette bosses say that their aim is to show a positive attainable inclusive and healthy versions of what it means to be a man but this has proved very very controversial Here's a little clip is this the best a man can get. Is it. Still we probably can't hide from actual was. His pay going on far too. Many go there just a taste of his nearly 2 minutes long the fool advert for broadcaster Piers Morgan for one is not tall impressed by it but you know what benefit of this they are fed up with being told how awful we are all day and I was sorry sorry ladies we don't think with our full what you might think I am a line right but we're not actually as a breed men are not all leave all well there you go is it an attack on men or is a step in the right direction as I say this kind of pull arised opinions this one we have with the NY all me 1st good morning to you know me. Morning hi hi hi see strategy you start there are straight the I'm a strapping careerist thank you SCOTUS children's book all that and also Stefan Drew who's the marketing magician and advertising expenses on hi there Stefan Good morning good morning because a lot of people have also been Colman thing about whether or not delay is kind of stepping aside it's bulk and creating an obviously is that you know about a heck of a lot more than just razors and the reaction 1st of all. PIERS MORGAN They say men are absolutely thet but they're fed up being told that they're horrible. And you know clearly takes great offense to this odd. Yes. Makes me no trickery of interest here for you to commit range of pain typically opposite you to him. I just I don't understand why men like him again and the life from southwest over us of him. Is just a large notion you know oh my God and Mississippi are saying all men are evil nonsense is not helping and anyone. Is pointing the finger at all men or saying all masculinity is part is completely admission. To tell us we are still on you know what open about ourselves so he's obviously but the underlying point was just a point there is an element of ash are just part of what we should call it so so what was the enemy you started to get into there but what was your interpretation then all of what the ad was trying to say. Was to to gauge initially into 2 things 1st of the meeting which I shall resort. To make money such a way particular show huge passion no doubt shot a suggestion. See the word used to mean points take home a horse that she trains there just to make sure no not again their owners. You know to be creepy and intimately women. Most of the stuff not just about some. Stuff and in harm's way to protect vulnerable people ponderable people you know believing in an annoying Asian or voice so you oppose your possession to speak to the famous it will cost us very subtle of a unique piece in violent situations where you've got you know the ability just to stand stand in opposition and all this but I took a nose like. That the kids the reason they're protecting the parties because some of these and you see that as an example of the understanding that doesn't between good and Bob's and and to the point of use of strain and masculine thing I think that's like a trauma but demand needs to be told that I mean that you know Piers Morgan clearly takes a stand that you know he says it isn't a some use in their own inference there that may need to be told to play nice battles a lot of those in an assumption of influence of I think the point is that there are some main you clearly do need to be told you know. You don't have to look at choppy views you know charged recently and in terms of the video was in there and caused all of the techno women. Anyone who suggests that there's not a problem on the points that are just me it's a time I believed in a sound as noise suggesting all intellect are told in this place just I think is that some in a like a lot me if you're not like top in standup and all you people who are like me can all be bailiff you know if there's anyone who gets the fame by the association that we can do things pale as part of the problem in my opinion now I mean what did you make of it. Well I mean and thank goodness to come along to demonstrate to all of us how we should live our lives and you know what is what is good and right I mean where would we be without you know razorblades showing us how how we should live. You know I completely understand why a lot of men are. You know really put their backs up is extremely patronize ing it does you know you have all these clips of boys pulling each other having a fight while the dads just watch on doing nothing leering at women sexually harassing women and there certainly is a kind of message of this is you know this is generally what men do men men are bad but don't worry because you know at the end of the ad that you've got these sort of enlightened few I assume they're the Gillette users who come along and you know show the other men the right way how to behave I mean it's so patronize ing in here and. To. Be giving any kind of morality lesson. You know to men in general to society can absolutely on the family so many people are so annoyed really isn't isn't their place and I don't think anyone really thinking or really should get some you know good life advice from from my razor blade manufacturer and yet she as a man is no annoyed by it. Well then you know that's great for him but I mean as you can see on the You Tube video I mean I looked this morning it's got around 200000 likes and around nearly 600000 dislikes so I think they are you know annoying a good amount of their target market there some not show it was a particularly smart move. Well so let me to movement which is clearly very powerful at the moment on the back of some pretty serious allegations being made against particular individuals and also kind of fleshing out some. Behaviors that I think we would all find represent reprehensible you don't think on the back of that actually it's a positive thing to sort of take the momentum in the direction that we all address unacceptable behavior. That's that's the place of a brand selling razor blades a tool and so I tend to weigh the fact that it's to let. The message offend you if we could take that. The point is that it that it isn't I that this is a public service announcement yet it's kind of portrayed as one they are doing some kind of service to all of us that just trying to sell their cars by then as you point out there's a number of serious real issues that all brought up in the ads but is a 2 minute ADFA the best medium to be addressing those issues who are the right people to be definitely I don't think it's a huge company trying to sell us stuff so I think it kind of in a way it will say it takes away some of the answers on the important issues that are brought up in it because it trivializes them to a razor blade advice. Pretty offensive hey you know you are saying that is the message you find a positive one but does it rankle with you it comes from you know a saving coming. Together in a century or 2 I mean I can absolutely apply only doing this to TERRY MILLS I can trying to because I think most of the hard because you know how you make a cause I think they are doing it to me 20 years later the and it's causing a conversational split if you take the show you know I think you have to in the same sort of the starting conversation with us are starting conversations between the hard conversations when I call these Muslims or Jose and I can point to even if it comes from a place of you know technically want to be crushed just as I recall is that we as a society stopped how this conversation more and more they're not suggesting because you know plenty of people who are famous guys who you know and below guilty of doing evil acting in ways that can be can be can be bought or sold and things like this give us a chance to talk about it and to call the or to feel that something munge we can all do as good as it gets could make us all of us the opportunity to bring out until the moment I mean well and that is the biggest lesson thaws own you know where those places to lead and staff will speak to in just a minute just gotta catch up. With travel and things and and also there is a choice of listening here on B.B.C. Radio Scotland you can stay with me all night to 2 to 95 F.M. For more discussion about this and other topics but Meanwhile over on one of the media wave and digital radio it is Scottish questions. OK thank you very much a good morning this is under care live at Westminster indeed with our live coverage of Scottish questions the Scottish secretary David Mendell will be taking questions from M.P.'s in the House of Commons and what a couple of days it has been here at Westminster later tonight the government faces a motion of no confidence after that historic defeat last night on the prime ministers a brags the deal where it was are really quite incredible scenes actually yesterday and then of course the prime minister will indeed of course 1st of all this afternoon just at midday after this program here be taking questions from the Labor leader Jeremy carbon who has proved indeed to forward that motion of nor confidence and just a short time ago actually the 1st minister of Scotland Nicholas Sturgeon was speaking in the lobby of the House of Commons and she was saying the only credible option is to put this back to the people this is for a fresh referendum on the brig's deal but she was also pointing out the starting point has to be the extension of Article 50 that's the process which in a way delivers Bragg's it's Or she was wanting that to be extended Of course of the N.D.P. We have at the moment is the 29th of March so we're just waiting for dinner and they want to appear in the House of Commons for the latest round of Scottish questions set to be a pretty lively a fear here and a very busy time Western So with a vote of confidence about 7 o'clock that's expected in the government this evening but they've been there will be facing the questions from the S.N.P. And of course from Scottish Labor. To just asking a boat there's Bragg's a deal you know where the 1st government minister of the day to face these difficult questions the prime minister was saying yesterday that she stretched seeking to build consensus around this deal but the vote was so severe so dramatic last night that that would be a real struggle for her I think really seeking to come back to the House of Commons for a 2nd vote. Now we're just waiting for the House of Commons to begin Here's the speaker John Boehner. All calling us that as the recently issued guy to the rules of behavior and purchases of the house makes explicitly clear and I quote Members must not use any device to take photographs film or make recordings in or around the chamber unquote I well understand that yesterday's events were exciting and that these days many people regularly take photographs which they feel compelled to share with a wider audience but members featured in these photographs have not given their permission and to that extent this represents an invasion of privacy I hope I have made it clear that this practice should cease. Questions and listen to. The grass in the division of yesterday after that historic vote 6 questions now to the suggested Mr Speaker this has being a momentous week for the Maori so I'd sure you will agree that it's appropriate that this Scottish question is that we acknowledge in this house and these extraordinary contribution to British sport ideas Pearsall resilience and how to age and I express our hope that we will once again see Andy Murray on court. Mr Speaker with permission I will answer questions 147-810-1214 together I am in regular contact with the Home Secretary on a range of issues of importance to Scotland including future immigration policy after the U.K. Leaves the utopian Union apart from his enormous talent and I agree with the socialist state more widely about and even. He is the important of guts and character and the most terrific ambassador for Scotland for tennis and for sport. His mother Judy must be the proudest mother in the world you Martin day like it was to speak of the Tories obsession with slashing immigration to the came to functions to see Scotland what King age population declined by 4.5 percent that's 150000 people by 2041 is the 2nd G.S.T. Happy standing over such a policy that will cause economic harm to our country yesterday's message this week . At the audible gentleman does not directly cataca drive the situation the immigration white paper which this Government has set out is an undertaking to embark on a year long engagement process across the whole of the U.K. To enable businesses and other stakeholders to shape the final details of a post a break through immigration policy and process because there's. A history I saw with your comments on the secretary of state regarding on your body in order to. Encourage all members to sign my E.D.M. Recognizing his achievements immigration Hard's been and continues to be good for Scotland and Scottish Government modeling suggest that breaks it driven reduction in migration will see real G.D.P. Drop 6.2 percent by 2041 to the monetary value about $6800000.00 under $2000000000.00 pound cost to the government revenue does the secretary of state believe that this cost to Scotland is a price worth paying for his government's breaks at mess and immigration falling. I don't want to end up repeating my 4 stance on 7 occasions but I want. To me clear that the immigration white paper which we have published is a consultation it's an undertaking. A year long engagement process across the whole of the U.K. Including Scotland I expect Scottish businesses Scottish to call doesn't get the Scottish Government to play an active part in that process to fill the bill which I did recognize same as your speaker scrapping freedom of movement will meet recruiting staff for any test Scotland harder and despite being paid the real living wage lab technicians admin staff and social care workers anywhere close to $30000.00 so what did he do to try and convince the Home Secretary to take into account Scotland's needs Yeah Mr Speaker I am not going to take any letters from the honorable lady on Scotland's needs in relation to the N.H.S. From an essay P. That has put up tax in Scotland so that doctors and nurses and Scotland pay more tax than anywhere else in the year. 3 brass because interested to hear these extra states comments about Scottish businesses C.B.I. Scotland said that the proposals outlined in the White Paper don't meet Scotland's needs and were Suckerpunch isn't it the case that this hostile immigration policy proves the Tory government is anti business Yeah listen speaker I'm really pleased to hear the honorable lady supporting the C.B.I. Because the C.B.I. Couldn't have been clearer they don't want a separate Scottish immigration policy they want one immigration policy for the whole of the United Kingdom and I agree with them on that. This is absolutely. You can if you park you who might use that. We should meet people to come and look after the folk who are people in the sector of the absolute if not just like Jack to understand Scotland some equations and find us in London centric policy but you but that's British government here OK Mr Mr Speaker I understand very well the issues. That face Scotland I don't believe that they would be better served by having a separate immigration. Policy in Scotland and I don't believe that immigration into Scotland is well served by a Scottish government who puts out a tax has a poor record on infrastructure and housing Aryans original purchase and I just wish it was an awareness of the many discussed Federation of Small businesses it's said that you take government opes to approach to education is actually a threat to look communities making it knowing impossible for the 1st majority of Scottish firms to get their living skills they need to grow and sustain their businesses are part of that could be answered statement with the secretary of state here to just list yeah I've set out in my previous answers that the immigration white paper is is a consultation and the F.S.B. And others are contributing to that and we will listen to it I am clear that Scotland benefits from a U.K. Wide immigration policy but I also believe that there are things that the Scottish government could do to make Scottish Scotland more attractive for people to come to . You and I simply members are following the disgraceful Christmas video in the E.U. Nationals and then the cat's catastrophic defeat for his government last night we'll hear a vein will he know urges government to aid in the hostile approach E.U. Trade ins neighbors and calling it's vital to the Scottish economy and community so yes I agree I agree that E.U. Nationals have played an enormous part in the Scottish Khana me I'm more widely in civic society and I wanted to give them SAF to last night in relation to what their position would be and that's why I voted for the deal. Itself just because the sickest so I secretary of state aware that on the 10th of January this year The Times reported a study conducted by one of Britain's leading social surveys which shows that Scots do not want immigration to. B. Devolve Does he agree that is a hammer blow to the coals of the S.N.P. And that the biggest danger to Scotland is their drive for another independence referendum which people wanting to come for. Mr Mr Speaker. It's certainly clear that the S.N.P. Does something to put off people coming to Scotland last night I read that Boy George was going to be moving to Scotland this morning the 1st minister of Scotland engaged with him and now we hear he's not coming I. Mean David you know much as the concept of my old friend confirmed that the Home Office and the government in general are will continue to engage and have been engaged and will continue to engage with Scottish businesses in consultation of the immigration bill . And. Mr Mr Speaker we will continue to engage the White Paper is an engagement process and I know that my honorable friend is at the great champion of the fishing industry that he is has already brought forward issues in relation not just to fishing vessels but to fish processing. Graham he's from abuse out just this week I welcome the Government's move to guarantee E.U. Citizens rights here in the United Kingdom unlike the S.N.P. In 2040 who threatened species since with a 166 straight rights remain in Scotland national going to see this given insistence by the assembly in 2014 but it is by this government so Cam I will find clarified the direct communication this government is having with E.U. Citizens in my constituency and when stop to make sure they are welcomed by the party community Mr Speaker that the government is engaged in a process of not just engaging with you E.U. Citizens but setting out very clearly for them how they can proceed in the process of settled status. You and Steve in certain. The speaker of the Borderlands area on both sides of the border needs to attract more people to come and live and work in that area with the minister agree with me that the way to do that is through investment both private and public and create the business environment for it for that investment you by increasing taxes and regulation. Because have to beg me to speak I absolutely agree with my colleague in this he knows this government fully supports the that borderlines initiative it is investment it is improving infrastructure and housing that will bring about making ice the south of Scotland north of England more attractive not putting up taxes. But you Mrs Levy accept a tax divergence by the Scottish Government is damaging my golden constituency struggling to attract overseas workers to have the royal family in the oil and gas industry with the sexy state agree this is economic madness which makes Scotland unattractive. Mr Speaker I've said many times before in this chamber I remain an absolute loss to understand why the S.N.P. Think making Scotland the most highly taxed part of the United Kingdom is an attractive proposition to bring people to Scotland. To Steven less a space for me because I'm just I asked a member of Parliament for Dunblane large my admiration for surrounded body and indeed for his mother only issue of the white paper and future immigration just one I told of a friend agree that the salary floor of their 3000 pounds makes it difficult for Scotland to retain international graduates when the average graduate salary is 21000 pounds there has to be the office set of London waiting doesn't that. I think my honorable friend makes a very good point and I'm sure that that's one that will be taken very much. Into account as we move forward the engagement process with the white paper outing. Whose wait a moment Mr Speaker the 2nd ship States government have been responsible for pursuing an agenda where immigrants are demonized we saw over the last year with a hostile environment policy we saw over the Christmas break when almost 2nd to the clear the national crisis when a handful of refugees made the perilous journey across the channel and we know you see it in black and white in the form of the immigration white paper so my question is simple Will the secretary of state apologize for his government's demonization of immigrants and its harmful consequences for the Scottish economy here Mr Speaker Of course I don't accept the honorable gentleman to characterize ation of events Scotland remains a place which should be welcome for migrants wherever they come from the white paper sets out a basis for a consultation for developing a new immigration policy post recognizing college everyone to take part in that consultation. So I know we're not gains enough to speak of. Minister thank you Mr Speaker at the Ministry of Defense spending nearly 1600000000 with British Scots coach businesses in 2617 supporting some 10500 jobs I think that this really does demonstrate the vital contribution of the workforce in Scotland to defending the U.K. From the growing threats that we face from across the globe. It's a question of as the defense sector in the law is a discussion coming from one of the Minister's speech questions on 26th of November I raised concerns about the desperate shortage of Royal Navy coastal defense systems that read just 3 of them in a problem according to the minister it is also the cases Scottish shipyards have suffered from A to cause and effect fools have with the government now brought both these wrongs by. OK To you all this is the coast of the French business from Scottish shipbuilders here Kevin Hopkins and the kind you know me asking the question for gentlemen we have security 20 years' worth of work on the Clyde with the shipyards there I think we would be hard pressed to find any industry in the U.K. They could say that they've secured 20 years' worth of work that helps their workforce for the future. So by Stuart the defense minister is no less the shadow scholar such a horse's peers now in my constituency of Angus and across Scotland warmly welcomed the government's intervention last year to mitigate the Scottish government's income tax increase come on all Frankenstein in fact he government will seek to continue this misconception to ensure our armed forces personnel are not pockets of Scotland's here so I question here from the concept of M.P.'s my own will friend is absolutely right to raise this very important issue and the Ministry of Defense is reviewing the Scottish Government's plans for next year's tax and we await the final are come and rough because shouldn't from the Scottish Parliament we will review the situation and determine whether the impact of the U.K. Armed forces warrants and all 4 of financial mitigation and wants a decision has been made and announcement was made to this house and to those personally affected. Happy birthday Mr Sweeney here I gather is for certain if we can place 36. Congratulations to positive for liver so we want to. Hear Mary thank you very much I know it's all going to you Mari the labor sake it is critical for the Scottish economy but sort of our sectors like financial services higher education food intake and indeed fisheries so would the minister have a chat with the secretary of state to make sure that cabinet a 2nd state is insisting that a new deal is ruled over here. And I think I did my bit on what gender was ingenious way of putting the issues around defense industry in this way but I would say that my right. Befriend this constantly fighting for Scotland around the Cabinet table and he will continue to do for a long into the future. Chris Stevens I wish I was both traditional We like him so you pointed out that his keys when he contracts with a long clock or with some other sums of real money tells her what streets which of Scotland has a good share of the jewels one form contracts for Stevens I simply Glasgow so it will stay with you there as I say tonight but earlier you know in terms of the ministry of defense we are trying to build in a good ship building program so that actually shipyards around the country know what the energies requirements are going to be for the next 30 years so they can plan accordingly but we also want to be incredibly competitive so that they're able to compete for competition for commercial lines not just in this country but for opportunities that drift around the world. For the impact of the breakup of the Union on I defend supply companies face to Scotland is a catastrophic. Fire the shutters go seculars the list Thank you Mr Speaker I would just like to start by adding my sentiments to those expressed by the secretary of state on I wonderful sportsman Andy Murray Mr Speaker the secretary of Steve has turned his back on Scotland's great ship building tradition by putting the solid fleet solid support contract out to international tender the secretary of state will no doubt the line that these are not warships However the minister of state for defames Lord tail responded to a written question thing that we are not on complex warships Well I grew up in a ship building community a warship caddied weapons explosives and munition which is exactly what the ships do. Still if these are no more ships Why are they. Make this point consistently The Honorable a bee will know that the national ship building structure you can start to farm for ships as frigates destroyers an aircraft carrier is the primary role of the F.S.S. Ships is the replenishment of naval vessels with both stores they are not combatant naval killer score ships and therefore they will grow to international competition but I'm delighted to say is that there is a British paid for by competition. Well can I suggest to the 60 of state that he might want to go and visit a shipyard as I'm sure there's plenty of what Chris there that would like to give him a different kind of thought strategy these are highly skilled high paid jobs that could return 2300000000 of revenue to the Tracy providing sustainable employment and shooting communities continue to thrive Instead the secretary of state is chirpy doing Scottish shipbuilding in favor of bargain basement deals still will he allow that this prime minister to continue the destructive legacy of. Our Will he support the Scottish Labor Party and the Labor Party and by our plans to finally stand up for the Scottish shipbuilding and to protect and create jobs in the industry. With the scary very honorable ladies attention that I'm not the secretary that's Ross the Tory M.P. For Morrison the vice pay tribute to my friend for the work that he's doing they feel I know that he takes a very keen interest did it and so does the Ministry of Defense. In terms of surplus land being released at Forsyth as part of the Sterling deal and I think he is right that as a local employer we are an important player in NY area and I can confirm that the 8 which shocked he's wrong as I've been to nothing to do with this ugly self-defeating but except last night change Scottish tooling. To defy the constituents Christa of the city would think something much much watch for Scotland What should the Scottish people therefore do to ensure that there suitably democratically toward it here. Mr Speaker we're not sure we're not taking lectures from who repeated Lee defies the democratic will of the Scottish people by ignoring the outcome of the 2014 independence referendum ace when Sir A Mr Little Democrats just recently we were in different ways last night I appreciate that the sexiest stakes genuinely felt the Prime Minister's deal was the best way forward but he can read the ruins of how likely it is that that deal or any reincarnation of it will get through this house this is what Castle commitments equipped to take this process forward in Scotland but he makes the argument for me yeah that given his refusal to engage properly in discussion about alternatives given the fight feels so out of step with opinion in Scotland at every level we'll you know do the decent thing and resign step aside so that someone else can take that freedom was leave our coverage of Scottish question is this is TELL ME shepherd this same P.N.P. Saying given Dale should resign but now the radio sculls in this time for the John Beattie program I know 1995 I think each one of the media with the V.C. Video stuff. They thank you good afternoon it is 12 o'clock. Junkies he on B.B.C. Video Scotland we will be crossing the line. To Westminster the prime minister's questions among many just time for U.K. And European politics and later the kids who never take holidays in the help available to them plus it's tax return time and focus on what you have to do and do it quickly. Yes we're living through extraordinary times only last night the prime minister lost her meaningful vote and now she faces a vote of no confidence. There are a few options available we will be waiting until to reason Me is on a feat to take questions a couple of options mean one the could be no deal if nothing else happens before position would be a no deal Breck's If the U.K. Due to leave the E.U. On the 29th of March to the could be a major renegotiation the government could propose to negotiate a new Bracks a deal this could require an extension of Article 50 to delay BRACKS It could be option 3 another referendum the government could instead choose to have another referendum of though there would have to be a new piece of legislation to make that happen the could be a general election Mrs May could decide that the best way out of the deadlock would be to hold an early general election to get a political mandate for the you should need 2 thirds of M.P.'s to support that move other possibilities the U.K. Deciding unilaterally to revoke Article 50 to cancel Bracks it or Mrs May resigning which would trigger a Tory leadership campaign so let's go through this vote we're about to go to Westminster the vote will be later on this evening if the government wins it and the government presses on the plans if the government loses 2 alternatives is there a clear alternative government if it's yes then Mrs May resigns they'll be a new prime minister appointed if the option is no can any government win a confidence vote within 14 days of the answer to that is yes the government continues perhaps with modified policy of the answer's no a general election that's what's happening let's cross live to the House of Commons we've just seen the end of the Scottish question is which.