On the banks large scale the scale the same 5 I. Want to talk about 5 while I was rejoicing by the B.B.C. Local radio stations across the U.K. Local radio listeners Raja the main 5 Live U.K.'s allies expelled dozens of person diplomats and in sport one of Australian cricket is most respected voices says Darren Lehmann must have been complicit in the ball tampering. And on the 5 Live website the highs and lows of Robbie Savage just for the way football challenge. Is B.B.C. . The B.B.C. News on 5 live here Charlotte Bombala a number of countries are expelling dozens of Russian diplomats of the poisoning the from a spa in Salzburg Boris Johnson praised what he called the extraordinary international response by the allies the president the European Council is don't ask 14 members states have decided to expel Russian diplomats additional measures including further expulsion is within the government a new framework to be excluded in the coming days and weeks 60 diplomats have been ordered to leave the U.S. And the Russian consulate in Seattle is closing our correspondent Chris Buckley is in Washington the reason it is being closed in Seattle according to the White House is because of his proximity to the submarine base is on its proximity also to the farm that gives you a sense that America is concerned about intelligence gathering that is happening it is also worth reflecting that in recent weeks there have been deep concerns about cyber attacks that have taken place Australia has become the latest country to expel Russian diplomats to have been told to leave the country. Labor politicians have joined Jewish groups protesting against anti semitism within the party the demo was held outside parliament and followed an apology from Jeremy Corbyn. Over his from the center Jury Studies at Durham University I would think the water would have we've definitely further in Gage no and with Jewish communities and again Jewish communities over Britain are of them fairly extreme Lee They via phone ma it Valleyfair what it would be really deeply engaged them and with a different Jewish congregation the White House has strongly denied allegations that don't trump had sex with a porn star Stormy Daniels in an interview on US T.V. Last night she claimed to have slept with the president in 2006 the Home Office is agree to continue funding the Scotland Yard investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann She was 3 when she went missing on a family holiday in Portugal in 2007 more than 11000000 pounds has been spent so far there are calls for better protection for victims of sexual harassment at work the Equality and Human Rights Commission says employees should be legally obliged to prevent it happening the group says it's found truly shocking examples of how recent it is claimed grammar schools in England know better than Ellis state funded secondaries research at Durham University suggests results are largely down to privileged intake they develop for Education says most grammar schools already prioritise admissions for disadvantaged children. All U.K. Police forces and are using body counts undersigned please is the last word don't them research suggests people are less likely to be violent if they know they're been recorded Silkie Calos from the civil rights group Big Brother Watch we would be reassured if the police were to bring forward some really clear guidelines or on how and when they use body worn cameras rather than advising that police merely rely on their own judgments that really opens the door for the kind of Intel IT potential intelligence gathering that we're worried about with these cameras with this boner dumbass be the Australian cricket commentator Jim Maxwell has told 5 Australian coach Darren Lehmann had to be complicit in the ball tampering He also told the tough as a cricket show bad news will come out of this to satisfy the $25000000.00 Australians screaming for blood Gareth Southgate says there is still time for Jack Wilshere to break in his World Cup squad the Arsenal midfielder withdrew from the latest score due to a knave problem he hasn't played since Euro 2016 but Southgate says Wilshere remains in contention Wales fullback Chris going to says there are very many positives to take from Ryan Giggs 1st 2 games in charge as despite losing one nil to Euro guy in the final of the china cup this season's women's F.A. Cup semifinals will be showed on the B.B.C. For the very 1st time in the competitions 48 year history Everton face Arsenal at $1230.00 on the 15th of April which will be shown on the B.B.C. Red button and online whilst Chelsea against Manchester City will be live on B.B.C. 2 from 330 on the same day and Johan a concert has been knocked out of the Miami open after losing her full Fran match in 3 sets to Venus Williams But this is B.B.C. 5 Live on digital on Law and smartphone unsober but the rain gradually pushing east of the next few hours turning sharply in the West and quite windy plan throughout the day the most rain lingering in the East potentially a little dry and. In the southwest. The European Union and we are traveling across the U.K. To find out if Britain is ready. In the U.K. On digital and online. Making the United States safer was the official White House line on Monday after the 60 Russian diplomats and their families of 7 days to leave the country the US Canada Ukraine Albania Norway in Australia joined 14 E.U. Nations in solidarity with Britain which gave 23 Russian diplomats until last Saturday to leave the country. Johnson praised what he called extraordinary international response by U.K. Allies and there may be more in a note European Council president. Said there could be additional measures. And what's clearly a coordinated response to the poisoning of a former Russian spy in Salzburg more than $100.00 Russian diplomats are being expelled from countries around the world over. 20 countries are acting in support of the U.K. Including the United States which announced that it would be forcing 60 Russian diplomats to leave and closing the consulate in Seattle is thought to be the largest collective expulsion of Russian intelligence officers in history Moscow's ambassador to the United States on a totally on tone of had this response force to deal with she would never said you knew English but I mean again what the United States of America are doing today is destroying what little remains in terms of Russian American relations the battle I'd like to add to that the entire responsibility for the consequences of the destruction lies on America prime minister Trey's I'M A says this sends a strong message I have found great solidarity from our friends and partners in the E.U. North America NATO and beyond over the past 3 weeks as we have confronted the aftermath of the Soulsby incident and together we have sent a message that we will not tolerate Russia's continued attempts to flounce international norms and undermine off audience. While Russia continues to deny any role in the attack on Sergei scree Paul and his daughter Yulia this month with us as the washer push national security correspondent John Hudson Hello John. To be here. I wonder if if the United States has ever expelled this many Russian diplomats No it hasn't and this is a question I was looking into your earlier today because there's been a lot of shit for tat expulsions ever since Trump took office in the wake of allegations of election interference. But this is singularly the the largest expulsion if you go back to the 1986 in the Reagan administration there were 65 or so so the speech that I thought I had. And it wasn't Mr Trump himself who announced this but it was the White House. Is is there any doubt that the White House is now is taking a tougher line on Russia after after a year of people demanding tough lines for other things and not very much happening Well you know I would argue that the story of this administration has been a complicated mix of pretty hawkish policies toward Russia that just are not reflected by the rhetoric of the president I mean people forget that tramples ministration the president also signed. Antitank missiles to Ukraine and they closed the San Francisco camp for last year there's been a number of you know tough positions that the tradition has taken towards Russia but. It's never reflected in the words the Trump speaks and obviously the most recent example was the phone call with President. Just happened a week ago where he congratulated him on the election and didn't raise. The poisoning in. Kerry as his aides urged him to do in the briefing documents. That the United States now is completely closing one consulate in Seattle and shutting it for the time being it's expelling 60 diplomats Presumably all of the stuff from Seattle how much of an impact. On the Russian diplomatic presence in the U.S. . i mean is it's very good significant because you know is this is there in they're going to be expelled or america terror pay have to lee and serve presumably data lot of intelligence officials to laugh who have developed an cultivated an expertise in their craft is a united states and a lot of that is going to than the man akon at the operating in that environment anymore obviously we're talking about thier paykel worlds of spy craft i'd be lying yes i survey a leo exactly the expertise that mass cal is now going to lack as a result of the 6 balls and but the number speak for themselves a to lot of person they are particular reshipping al of the united state have a says a being duplicate a little number of countries around the world an are those names good be published will will you and your your colleagues be able to check the lists and see who's actually departed that's a great question and that is you know of one of the many assignments that m. Sort of add into my list is the questions that are the and varied at this point and i have a little bit skeptical good mask i was given be forthcoming with that the and time a more her casket topple who has the trample ministration will be forthcoming with that but who will certainly be the working and were will be trying to figure that out because there is there is a published list as an there is an official diplomatic list of people who are a admitted us as diplomats to the the us or to any other country i mean you can get and the you have to be able to look top somewhere i think Of course of course a lot of embassies. To varying levels of transparency post their personnel read on the Web site of course you know when you're talking about spies that. If this is transparent and so those those are those are going to be names that are tightly guarded this is a yes this is where I was going of course because there are those who who are publicly node and then that are all those. Who are less a less high profile to put it mildly Let's go back to the Seattle thing for a minute because Seattle you've already reminded us that San Francisco is severely DOD I mean no coincidence that they've chosen Seattle I said diplomatic tog. Yes certainly there's a lot of you know. You know officials have raised the point. That Boeing is there and touch certainly provides a lot of opportunities when we're talking about aerospace technology in aerospace. Espionage opportunities if you know people said the same thing about when it came to San Francisco because that's. Really you know the hub of America's innovative technological sector. And. Many many stations for years that. Was a target for Russian espionage and yes all of these things have a very. Practical dimension. Sort of where American prized espionage assets are John we'll leave it there for the time big Very many thanks indeed. Of course going to be with you thank you thank you John Hudson Washington Post national security correspondent I apologize to John for adding to his already long list of homework questions. That expulsion the death toll in the fire that swept through the upper stories are a shopping mall in the Siberian city of Kemah off which lies about 800 miles east of Moscow is now thought to have risen to $64.00 that's the figure according to the Russian situations Minister Vladimir Putin charge of an investigation has been opened Igor's down of from R.T. Russia Today is there hello Eagle. Thank you for for your help in the story is so awful isn't it about children playing in this crash on the on the top floor of the mall and that seems to have to have hurt children almost more than anybody else hopes How long will it be before people know the list of casualties. Well it is a horrific tragedy for the whole city and there's a lot of children as you've rightly mentioned in the dissin both in the deceased and in the missing list the fire the rescue services are continuing their search operations for the bodies the fold the missing list I think consists of some 11 people so far and some people's some bodies have already been recovered but identifying them is a challenge in itself because apparently they are so badly burnt and mutilated that only a D.N.A. Test will do the job in certain cases like yesterday we've seen absolutely devastated relatives coming to the morgue to identify their loved ones and truly heartbreaking scenes here. Now there is already talk about a sort of ground for tower style fire and in which the cladding caught fire and any word on that yes there's a lot of word on that and a lot of people are outraged and this is exactly what the Russians investigative committees looking into because the fire has highlighted a lot of very gross highlighted the gross negligence I should say all of the fire safety floors because there was 1st and foremost there was no fire alarm so people did not get an early warning those inside they didn't hear any sirens we've talked to people who managed to get out safely out of the fire and they told us that actually security guards came up to them telling about the fire even only after they could already smell the smoke also there were no sprinklers or at least even if they were something European to not work to melt function so none nothing there and even when people rushed to fire escapes sound fire escape some fire exits were lost and this is something that the investigation by the Russian investigative committee concerns as well they are saying that's one of the guards there suspecting one of the security guards actually shutting down deal holes fire prevention system but this is still to be confirmed this is not this is not yet official that's why people are not actually to break doors and jump out of the windows to try to save their lives really and for example one of the children as young as 11 years old he got a lot of bone fractures you broke a lot of bones when he was falling out of the window so yes the Fire Safety says system did not work and this is what causes all the outrage here and you're saying that the children actually leaped from the 3rd floor yes at least one of the children I think the boy is 11 years old he's at the hospital right now and the medics are trying to save his life really there are some truly restricted shortage of that line. Ward What difference is this going to making or the safety of places like this going forward as well as some new some Russian cinemas and like large cinema networks have already announced that they are going to come to conduct their own fire safety checks fire drills so to speak so this is something this is definitely is going to be a hot topic both in Russia and we already know Belarus and Belarus some cinemas have announced that there are going to be taking measures as well but really people are questioning here whether or not it should have come to this to you know to highlight the problem although it's not yet clear if the receive a larger problem you know only whole country wide scale but this is the again going to be a very hard and sensitive topic for a while. A Go or some reports are saying that had been a move to roll back some fire regulations because you know operators of malls and similar places who are objecting to having to comply with them as is that right and one well frankly I don't I don't have any information on that I could look into that for you if you want me to but unfortunately I don't have any information on that from yeah yeah so in terms of Kremlin response what's the actual official government response be this is the the Welsh this is the I'm sort of the intrigue right now because I'm outside of this shopping mall and people were flocking here yesterday all day bringing flowers toys this is self and revoiced. Just outside the shopping mall but now that area has been cordoned off and the rumor is Letterman told in is would be a arriving in any minute now to make a speech we have really we don't really know what the purpose of the visit will be productions. We to come Florence who have lost their loved ones in the been affected by this tragedy do you know that vitamin spokesperson has already somewhere here from the site of the tragedy so off throughout all the indicators that. That the Russian president is coming to the scene of the blaze. And what kind of a place has its chemical or I mean is it sort of medium size like Milton Keynes in England or I mean it's not terribly big but it's not terribly small is it that's that's precisely right it's its population is about half a 1000000 people but we've talked to talk to the citizens here and of course since even if it's no even though it is a regional center it's a regional capital it's a capital of the Kember of a region still people are somewhat dissatisfied as often or with the way things are here and they're saying that a lot of people are trying to move move elsewhere mostly of ironically enough many of them cite weather as one of the one of the biggest. Causes for people to migrate to move to warmer places so it is not as you said it's not terribly big Not terribly small some 500 people but still it makes it the city of such a size that a lot of a lot of people would be affected by this tragedy on a personal level they would even if that if they don't have any relatives any media relatives as well you know victims in the fire but when they would know someone or someone who knows someone and so really the whole city staking it's very personally and they're standing shoulder to shoulder together that's what we saw yesterday with the vigil and everything was so people all day flocking to limit this to the shopping mall to bring slippers and candles and everything else and we left the scene at Round Midnight and people were still standing there at the crowd they were doing there were no signs of the crowd shrinking. Many thanks and thoughts are with you thank you thank you for your time Facebook is to be investigated by the US Federal Trade Commission after the revelation of the personal information of millions was gathered by the data firm Cambridge analytic on Facebook which had previously subject to an F.T.C. Inquiry and 2011 says it welcomes the opportunity Facebook shares fell roughly 5 percent on that news having fallen already at Goldman as co-director of the hi tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University School of Law in California Hello Professor Goldman Yes hello hello. Sign a bit like a like a show done for for Facebook is this really the worst crisis that the company has ever faced. In my opinion this is a garden variety problem for Face Book This is straight down the middle what they normally do and it as. Kind of controversy that they've weathered in the past pretty easily but it's possible maybe this is the one where people will decide that Facebook is no longer trustworthy and needs to be changed my goodness so why the Federal Trade Commission what's what's their interest well the Federal Trade Commission has assumed a very significant role in privacy related issues here in the United States we don't have any other commission that handles privacy issues and if I don't say commission views itself as that leading privacy regulator in the United States so any privacy related issues is automatically to me something they're interested in they have course also had made it brought in for some action against Facebook in 2011 so they already have some super sized responsible you know oversight. On Facebook. So will they focus on the question of consent and whether or not these these 50000000 users went impacted and whether or not they gave their consent many farm. Absolutely what users had agreed to and when and what controls user had and when will be essential to every legal regulatory battle and is there a regulation that Facebook would then have breached and if so is there a set fine for this kind of behavior. There is a statutory fine a Facebook violated its 2011 agreement with the with the F.T.C. . But I don't really think that's all that helpful the odds of that fine dictating the amount of Facebook widow is pretty low but there could be substantial damages to the F.T.C. Or to other enforcement agencies or plaintiffs so there is a lot of money on the table that Facebook has to be considering what it would an F.T.C. Ruling in fact make it easier for somebody to bring what they know as a class action suit possibly. That's actually complicated question so it's not necessary for the private plaintiffs to win and it could be helpful but it isn't necessarily so. And do you anticipate something like that I mean is it just a matter of time before a number of lawyers start to work on this it's not a matter of time at all there are already have been multiple lawsuits filed against Facebook and I'm sure many more coming So one possibility in fact is that the private lawsuits work faster than the F.T.C. In which case we might get a resolution to those questions before the F.T.C. Is resolved the matter. And we know about the market that date on on Facebook shares I mean at least as far as it's gone when it started we were told that is our cupboards passing a wealth of followed by 7000000000 dollars But that was OK because he still had another $90000000000.00 to to burn through it is it is it something you've already told us that you think this is something Facebook and whether I mean Facebook's pockets of that deep are that they could stand making payouts and get through this and you know put it behind them. In the end there's really 2 questions when there be a regulatory intervention that fundamentally changes Facebook such that it's no longer useful to its users and that strikes me as unlikely that even if there are regulatory interventions they won't be that broad reaching the real existential threat to Facebook is the possibility that users just decide that are trustworthy in that they side to take their marbles and go somewhere else or just give up on social media and to me that's a much bigger threat and the reason why I would discount this that Facebook shares and that's obviously something that the company has to prioritize is to win back the trust and to continue to earn the trust of its users otherwise we just stop using it. You know we're already hearing of course people walking away from it notably Elon Musk but other people severely restricting the privacy settings that would have an impact on the usability of their data in the future wouldn't it exactly in other words Facebook doesn't have to die because every single person goes through and deletes their account in a fiery blog ball of glory it could also with their away as people just stop using it as much or set their privacy settings in a way that makes it seem less important tool to them on a day to day basis does or Facebook doesn't have to just have a cataclysm in order for people to become more apathetic or less engaged all of those are accidental threats to Facebook about passive aggressive I may have you changed your privacy settings since the phone. You know Facebook doesn't make it easy to figure out what your privacy settings are and what they mean so every now and then I do go in and configure my Facebook fans and almost always they are to make them more restrictive about what Facebook can do but in the end I'd principal use Facebook for a very limited set of purposes and for those purposes I have less concern about the implications but you know every person really does have that that question that they're facing Do I still trust Facebook and if I don't what could I do about it. Goldman from Santa Clara University School of Law Thank you very much indeed Gemma pleasure thank you thank you. It is how fast one. Image is a long long smartphone and tablet is B.B.C. 5. News. The Kremlin has described the expulsion of more than 100 Russian diplomat spy U.K. Allies as a perverted show of solidarity more than 20 countries is sending people back to Moscow following the nerve agent attack in Salzburg. A number of Labor M.P.'s have joined a protest in Westminster against anti semitism within the policy Jeremy Coben has written a letter to Jewish leaders to apologize he says he urgently wants to meet them. Russian officials investigating a fire to Siberian shopping complex say a security guards turned off the alarm system at least $64.00 people died at the mall in the city of Cameroon. New research claims English grammar schools are no better than other state funded secondaries term University says results are largely due to privileged intake and the grammar schools should be phased out the sport now is John Busby The former England captain Michael Vaughan has been elaborating on the Australian bolt tampering scandal the futures of Captain Steve Smith vice captain David Warner and the coach Darren Lehmann all hang in the balance after the tourists admitted Bolton bring in the 3rd Test against South Africa and Vaughan says this particular episode is just another thing to add to a very long Australian rap sheet want to punch Joe Root and you've got the pay to speak our share with their own cricket board they held their own cricket broad suit to ransom for the good of the game that's what we all read the more you read into that it sounds like it wasn't always about the good of the guy had not been for the hire and to get a few more quid the biggest abuses on the on the cricket field of personal abuse Gary Southgate says Jack Wilshere can still make his World Cup squad despite missing both Friendly's against the Netherlands and Italy will she withdrew from the current squad with a knee injury and hasn't played for his country since the defeat to Iceland in euro 2016 but Southgate hasn't ruled him out I don't think it's too late for anybody it's obviously more difficult because this couple of guys that have been in scores haven't had the chance to play with force but we'll still be monitoring everybody between now and the disease and because there's probably a squad of 3132 players that will be in in contention and none of us know what's going to happen over the next 8 to 10 weeks the Scotland manager Alex McLeish says he expects a more direct approach from hungry when the 2 sides meet but also says he wants a performance from his players so they can see for themselves they're on the right track they lost one nil to cost. On Friday and after 2 games in charge it's won one last one for the Wales manager Ryan Giggs and Edison come Vonnie goal so Wales lose one nil to your require in the final of the china cup but the Wales defended James Chester says he's been impressed with what he's seen from Giggs so far seen over the last couple decades I don't believe a player in and professionally was and it was seen in the sauce shop space of society how. You know the city success is in the holder still or elsewhere in football the London mass of the Khan has met with the West Ham vice chair Karren Brady for the 1st time to discuss issues around the London stadium Saturday's a Premier League game with Southampton will be the 1st match up the ground since 20 people were arrested following ugly scenes at the home defeat by Burnley on the 10th of March Chelsea have signed chronic Sanders teenage striker George Nunn according to B.B.C. Radio Stoke the 16 year old has yet to make a 1st team appearance and it's understood the League 2 side will receive 300000 pounds in compensation from Chelsea. The Hazelton National Golf Club will become the 1st American venue to stage the Ryder Cup twice the Minnesota course which hosted the 2016 event will states the competition again in 2028 and Anthony Joshua believes Joseph Parker will face an overwhelming experience in a unification bout which will go down in history on Saturday that's the latest from B.B.C. Sport. For a 6. 6. 666666 . Liga it would signal maybe sometimes I. Feel like. This is a circus. Yes. The U.K. This is B.B.C. 5. With. Him and hundreds of protesters gathered outside Parliament yesterday evening to accuse Labour's leader Jeremy carbon of using pain of causing pain in heart by not doing enough to root out what they see as anti semitism in the party Mr carbon wrote the leadership of the British Jewish community yesterday seeking an urgent meeting to discuss their concerns it's also been criticism of the leadership approach to the matter from some of its own M.P.'s and from some many previous members of the leadership tonight former leadership contender David Miliband tweeting it's terrible that the leadership has brought our party into such gross disrepute at least the veil of anxious denials whitewash reports divestment attacks has been breached now we need actions to haul ourselves out of the depths our Political Correspondent Chris Mason joins me to discuss the the hail of criticism Mr carbon is facing. Rod let me paint you a picture of what happened in Parliament last night around about 7 o'clock in the evening I was standing on the committee car door of the House of Commons the wrong side of a fake wooden door the other side of which was the parliamentary Labor party meeting for its weekly private meeting and reporters were often large or outside in the hope of having conversations private conversations with M.P.'s afterwards and you might occasionally hear a round of applause or by any of the desks you could very very rarely hear what is actually being sad and yet we heard rather a lot curiously that as that meeting was going on there was too demonstrations going on in Parliament Square outside one against Jeremy Corbin and one for him on this whole issue of anti Semitism within the labor movement and a couple of floors below was in the chamber of the House of Commons the prime minister and the leader of the opposition talking about Russia and a Labor M.P. John Woodcock being very very critical of his leader now he is a longstanding critic of Mr Corbin but being very very critical of its instincts about Russia all of which by get packaged together reveal that there's been this kind of reemergence of a real public anxiety being expressed by Labor M.P.'s about their leader yes we were talking about this it felt every day of the week a couple of years ago but now. It's back again having been closed off the paint in resealed after the general election and pays even his biggest critics recognising it done much better than many predicted things went quiet publicly and yet now particularly around this issue of anti Semitism the real anxiety and nervousness about him and his instincts and those around him as Absolutely. Well I'd say let's look at this anti semitism issue there. For the moment because. I mean the genesis. Is what Mr carbons failure to properly criticized Mueller all what's the basis for this I think the mural is seen by his critics as just the latest case study at least prior to yesterday of him being willing to tolerate or turned a blind eye to anti semitism So pretty much ever since he's been leader there's been some anxiety amongst particularly some Jewish groups but also others who are Jewish themselves but have a keen ear for anything that is seen to be and he semitic that germy call been. Raised just a bit tired and deaf to either surrounding himself or spending time in the company of people who are and he semitic or not being willing to be as vociferously in condemning it as some would like him to pay not particular incidents around the mural was a curious one because it related to a Facebook post that Jeremy called and had commented on 6 years ago and this was a row about a mural widely seen to be deeply offensive and anti semitic which germy Corbin hides talked about on Facebook and joined a campaign that had been started to try and ensure that this mural wasn't painted over wasn't whitewashed now over the weekend mystical been said that he regretted suggesting that he supported this artist and that what he meant to do was express a desire for freedom of speech and that you haven't paid this mural sufficient attention and if he had he would have realized that it was deeply offensive but that particular incident if you like was the straw that broke the camel's back of anxiety amongst a lot of Jewish people Jamie Colby hadn't been doing enough hadn't been strong enough in his condemnation and it led to this relatively hasty. The arranged protest at Westminster last night not protest at Westminster happened the whole time but you know usually the base that people have is with the government not with the opposition not yet all of it was swarming with protesters and then the added and very odd twist to all of this was there was a counter demonstration from supporters of Jeremy Corbyn some of them Jewish themselves saying this was a orchestrated attempt to attack Germany Corben that he isn't anti semitic has never been on the Semitic doesn't have an anti semitic bone in his body and that it's completely and utterly UN fat so very heated and vociferously exchanges in Parliament Square Yeah all of them about the official opposition which is very disorientating is a political reporter who's worked there must be just a few years you know a day goes by when he that was possible I suppose during the some sort of protest even if it's just located a handful of people with a plaque out that of course is part of the parliamentary and democratic process and to be expected and to be cherished and to be welcomed but almost all of them I can't really think actually of a another demonstration where Alternately it wasn't the government that was the source of the. They were the targets of the being expressed by the protesters not yet it was a big it was a big demonstration we've also got this letter though Mr carbon has written to the board of Jewish deputies and he's talking about a kind of intellectual past of the Labor Party and the answer says the idea of Jewish bankers and capitalists exploiting their workers of the world as an all the anti semitic conspiracy theory this was long ago and rightly described as the socialism of force he says and then goes on to talk about the myriad says I'm sorry for not having studied the content of the mural more closely. It. Is the Labor Party and embroiled in some kind of the session or or are some kind of dreadful Toyin zing which I suppose few outside it would have realized was necessary Yeah I think it's having to have a very public conversation about something that is deeply deeply uncomfortable to plenty within the labor movement and entail these letters and this protest last night hadn't been confronted had all and as you say this latter that Jeremy Corbyn wrote to the chair of the Jewish leadership council of the presidents of the Board of Deputies of British Jews is extraordinary is extraordinary in its detail as you say it touches on history he repeatedly says that he won't tolerate any form of anti Semitism that exists in or around the Labor Party or the labor movement he says that anti semitism is an evil that led to the worst crimes of the 20th century as you say he talks about these long established almost dangerous about the idea of Jewish bankers and capitalists and exploiting the the workers of the world describes it as an old anti semitic conspiracy theory I think he has recognized the scale of the problem in terms of the criticism that's coming his way and didn't want to do that kind of you know standard letter where he says sorry and wraps up within a couple of paragraphs but really explore this as you say in a in a quite theoretical and academic way in terms of the the the history of the Labor Party in the history of of some within the sort of broader socialist tradition and that's because you know any leader of the opposition however school does Jeremy Corbyn is in facing no shortage of flak from from critics particularly given the sort of early months and years of his time as Labor leader can't really doing anything other than face up to the kind of. A protest from outside of his party which happened outside parliament and within his party amongst amongst his M.P.'s for a strike you needn't give any interviews yesterday he wouldn't talk to us or newspapers or any of the broadcasters communicating instead via these letters but I think it's inevitable that you know this is something he's going to continue to face questions although I think he'll have gone quite a distance yesterday rod with these letters in answering quite a lot of the criticism as the criticism they're coming is why about not being willing to talk about the specific issue of anti-Semitism directly but the be others Tony Blair former Labor leader of course on Newsnight last night making the argument that given the scale of the criticism coming his way he absolutely have to follow it up with with actions and not just words and the challenge of course for leader of the opposition is that oppositions are in the business of words governments are in the business of actions So what can he do in a practical side is beyond language to try and ensure to his party and thing he's critiques that this isn't a problem and of course David Miliband who so easily could have been the Labor leader is talking about the video of unk surest denials and whitewash reports and diversionary attacks being breached so it's it's as if everybody as you might say ganging up on Mr carbon Yeah and there are some of his supporters and there was callers to Phil Williams his program last night making the argument that a lot of the critics that you're hearing within the Labor Party of Jeremy called me on this issue of anti Semitism are bluntly the usual suspects those in the center those who might be described as the the better on the side interest yesterday's men and women of the labor movement and you know David Miliband in the. Of many supporters of Jeremy Corbyn would fall into that category but when you hear his language and you're quoting some of it there I'll just read the whole tweet from former foreign secretary now. The leader of the International Rescue Committee says it's terrible that the leadership has brought our party into such gross disrepute at least now the veil of denials whitewash reports diversionary attacks has been breached now we need actions to hold ourselves out of the depths a stronger language that's the kind of language you expect the politicians use about an opponent not the leader of their own party. Chris Mason Westminster CORRESPONDENT Well. Have you heard the one about the rude waiter we're all acquainted with that type I would have thought one way to the bank Hoover who was so aggressive with his colleagues that he was sacked has filed a complaint with the human rights tribunals saying he wasn't being rude he was just being French I speak to Marie Seidler who's reporter for C.B.S. C.B.C. . Over how Mary's Hello Rod say well this is a good defense isn't it. I do we have any do we have any kind of yardstick to judge the waiter's rudeness who. And what was he accused of sig and doing well his name is Aggy I'm Ray and he was some he know that there was a one major incident that led to his being sacked but there were a few incidents leading up to this according to the documents filed with the tribe you know where there were a few incidents where he was seen as being aggressive or a little too direct with his with his call week so the incident that led to his being sacked wasn't the only time that he was. Reprimanded for being rude to his colleagues and I think it's also important distinction here that it was just called exact He was called out for being rude for not the customers the customer actually had glowing reviews from his customers and he was seen as being a fantastic waiter he was in fact often put in as as you know shift supervisor the shift to lead so he was in his actually quite seen as a good waiter but it was his colleagues who fact that he was seen as being aggressive Well right so he wasn't wasn't sacked for telling people to do things when they told him there was a fire in their super anything like that and I actually. Well so. Again what what does this go to I mean what was he doing to his colleagues that was so that was so bad was he very difficult to work with according to the restaurant. The particular incident he says he was he was very direct with his colleagues in the particular incident that led to his being sacked was he was working with other servers and he asked one of the other servers to finish their duties and you know that 2 different you know accounts here the vet the server the French server He says that he just you know was direct with those colleague and said Make sure you finish your work before you go and that colleague apparently was went to the manager who was on duty at the time borderline in tears as the way it was described and said that he was in fact quite rude with him and quite direct and a little too direct and so that was the official kind of incident that led to him being sacked but you know whether or not he was rude or whether he was just in fact you know telling his colleague to finish up his work and finish up his duties that's that's really what was at question and they both have their own accounts of these of this event and they both have people who support them and were a friend then the letters in support of each version of the events as well well I did see so many sons and of course the fascination in this is that he says he wasn't being rude he was being French Do you really see that. did jacket that he said you know he was often according to a waiter and you know this is disputed by the their restaurant but according to the waiter he said you know is manager often said you know might just be because of your french but you're seen as perhaps a little aggressive or a little direc so i'm your whether he was or nod it's that will be determined in the core the the cases been allowed to go forward no decision was made but i think one other things that action it's really interesting here of been monitoring the comments on those who people are really weighing in on both sides keep in mind in kading culture we are very polite and we're not harry direct now i also grew up and france and i know the others side of things so it's a campy quite a clash there and we are seen as as quite clay and we are quite clay here in canada i were spoke with someone who works but the company here who works directly west french people to help them integrate into canadian culture and he said absolutely this is this is a big culture clash for us french people coming to canada you known in canada when you give feedback or someone they they called the sandwich you know you say something nice and then you say what you actually want to save the see back and then you say something nice to close it off so you know a lot of people sided with the waiter and single good for him for being direct with his colleagues an and not dancing around the issue we could maybe use a little bit more of that in canada and you know obviously all the people on the other side and saying while he he should adapt a canadian culture in and you know we all know how french the root can the you know so on and so forth to it's not it image that we have really of restaurant says i'm thing about it sounds neighbor die the kitchen confidential and a rough tough wife of somebody walking in a restaurant kitchen do you don't expect off the you claude no off to use astral all with type do you At the Safari What was that well you don't expect people to be so charming and. Polite and a restaurant kitchen of all places well especially behind the scenes you know and again we're talking about French work culture and again I would remind you it's not with the customers that he was seen as being rude it was behind the scenes with his colleagues and certainly you know I've worked in a few kitchens myself growing up and yeah that can be you know a bit rougher behind the scenes but you know if he did contravene according to the company it's the company's respect in the workplace and Vironment and he was seen as being too too direct in this particular case so or you know whether that was because he's French or just because he's director because you know he wasn't Canadian enough for our placating culture I think is what's really at stake here and where does his complaint go legally from here so from here as you mentioned Kara operation the milestones restaurant supply to dismiss the complaints and that application was denied so that means that paves the way forward for this complaint to go to the human rights tribe you know on be heard there the trial member will make a decision and I mean the. Companies like milestone have to take serious look at those decisions and if they don't agree with it at that point they can take it to Supreme Court and have the decision reviewed but it's a months long process and in this incident happens and some are 2016 so it's a pretty slow process it could take another easily few months for this to be resolved by race Thank you very much indeed thank you Roger. Cal and serve in the USA Today Hello Carolyn and Iraq how are you well thank you and another week Luers. Who knows where will be end of this week with the top White House but someone who used to live there is weighing in who is that right this is former President Jimmy Carter if you'll recall he was a peanut farmer and former governor of Georgia and he has been known in recent years as a wonderful Elantra post and somebody who helps build homes for the poor and has worked to bring about peace in the in the world and he has a new book out tomorrow and ahead of that our Susan Page our bureau chief in Washington sat down and spoke with them about you know things that are going on right now and he is telling Susan that that President Trump may have made one of the worst mistakes of his tenure right naming John Bolton to be national security adviser so Matz that's a pretty strong statement and he calls Bolton a warlike figure and really is critical of the the appointment. Does he say Look into his crystal ball if he does he have any predictions because of this. Well he's you know still hopeful that the diplomatic efforts with North Korea can you know can succeed batt you know there is always the possibility that it would get us into a war if those if those efforts fail and I thought this was interesting he talked about. President Trump and you know we've got all this Stormy Daniels controversy going on about the former earth or in star who has claimed she had a relationship with the president back in 20062007 he this is a wonderful quote he said in the November elections we have our midterms coming up in November he said we'll see the adverse impact of the revelation of immorality and his violation of his sacred oath before God to be loyal to his wife and that's coming from Jimmy Carter who is also a Sunday school teacher most Sundays down in Georgia yes who got into political trouble once for for being just too honest and saying that he had one salute to the woman with lust in his heart. And that that really hurts him with the religious right fun see that I know and it seems so quaint now doesn't it I mean now we have 9171000 women accusing President Trump a sexual assault or abuse or you know various things and having affairs with them and in the evangelical Christian segment of the voters is sticking with them so you know what a difference 40 years can make I guess. And I I know that you've been very good in your reporting from person recall and you kept on sending your reporters in there to talk about a very slow the the rebuilding isn't as complicated because the was just so much damage off the high command but what are you reporting no. Yeah this this really is a sad story Rick Juris from our Miami bureau has gone back to Puerto Rico and he is looking at how depressed and how. How matches thought of suicide there is on the island nation after the I'm not Island which is the territory of the United States after Maria went through about a little over 6 months ago and it's looking like according to the statistics down there suicide attempts have climbed 50 percent to about $1000.00 a month and they have. Social suicide really calls to the hotline have more than doubled to most like Already $600.00 in one month I mean it's very very dire and people you know after you go 6 months without any electricity if you've had mental health problems or struggled with depression before you can just imagine what that that our continuing struggle can do for your psyche. These are people who are who are forced to rely on generators if they have even that and it's very difficult for them right and you know a lot of people live in very very remote very mountainous areas and so it's you know it's really a very very dire situation over there and we've talked briefly about this but Facebook is no facing an inquiry from the Federal Trade Commission. Right I mean and you guys I'm sure have covered a lot of this about this story because analytic is based there in London and because European regulators they have a lot more only 5 think that what we have are read here and and probably more will to do something about it but our Federal Trade Commission is. Going to investigate what happened to Facebook and how all all that information about us got to you know be used in the election and it misused in. You know without any of us knowing where our information was going to be used so the stock took a beating today and so it looks like we've got 37. States that are going to look into it so you know this is going to be a pretty serious investigation of what happened there and it could lead to good leads and more regulation will see. Karl Rove very most.