And the showers may be heavy near northeastern coast Later on however many western parts will avoid the showers or together Friday will be much the same but then we'll see a change in the weather for the weekend with more rain and more wins than we've had recently there were some sunny interludes too and it will become slightly warmer 192295 f.m. 198 longwave and digital radio this is b.b.c. Radio 4. It's 10 o'clock Good evening this is the world tonight way to. The u.s. And Russia to resume negotiations about the crisis in Syria at the weekend but what can the talks deliver the future of a side has to be on the table there stirring huge gaps between the Russian and American positions we want Assad to go the Russians want them to stay Tesco is said to be running short of Unilever products such as Marmite because of a round about pricing between the $2.00 firms Ministers insist they won't share details of the government's breaks it plans before talks with Brussels despite growing pressure for a Commons vote also in the program the main suspect behind last November's Paris attacks has lost his legal representation as he refuses to talk we speak to one of the survivors we hold that the truth will come out with or without said understand his silence won't be a problem for the Justice Center for the truth and what it's like to be the Western parent of a jihadi I don't care who's in prison so much sun they need to be reprogrammed that broken That's all after the b.b.c. News read by David Miles the United States and Russia have announced that they will resume talks in an effort to halt the bloodshed in Syria Washington and Moscow broke off negotiations when a ceasefire failed prompting mutual recriminations and Middle East analyst Annan Johnston reports the last Syrian ceasefire had barely begun before it collapsed in acrimony Washington froze all negotiations with Moscow but now there to talk again Russia's foreign minister Sergey Lavrov and his u.s. Counterpart John Kerry will meet in Switzerland on Saturday the key regional powers Saudi Arabia Turkey and Iran are also expected to attend these are. States that could do much to restrain the men on the front lines but they each have their own interests in Syria and they will bring to the table very different ideas about The Way Forward Russia has criticised the foreign secretary Boris Johnson for calling on people to protest outside the country's embassy in London because of its actions in Syria the Kremlin said Britain had a duty to guarantee the safety of Russian diplomats on its territory. The supermarket chain Tesco is in a dispute with the Unilever one of Britain's biggest grocery manufactories the Rao is understood to have developed when Unilever which faces higher costs because of the fall in sterling attempted to increase wholesale prices Tesco now says it's running short of brands including Marmite and p.g. Tips they're no longer available on the retailers website industry sources say Unilever has made the same demands of other big retailers. To reason may has resisted calls from Labor and some within her own party to allow M.P.'s a vote on the government's negotiating strategy for breaks it the demand was made repeatedly in the Commons this afternoon during a labor debate calling for proper parliamentary scrutiny of the government's approach to leaving the e.u. Political correspondent Ben Wright reports during a boisterous debate the shadow Bracks it Secretary secure Starmer said Parliament should be presented with the basic terms of the government's negotiation plan before it triggers divorce talks with the e.u. a Process to resume a says should begin by the end of March next year labor also argues parliamentary approval is needed for talks to start a number of senior Tory backbenchers including Ken Clarke in the former attorney general Dominic Grieve suggested M.P.'s should get a vote on the government plan to but most of their party colleagues disagreed and the brakes Minister David Davis insisted the government had the right to trigger exit negotiations the government has been warned that it risks losing access to vital intelligence unless it signs up to new powers for Europe whole the e used law enforcement agency the deputy head of the National Crime Agency David Almond said an immediate decision was needed his own home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw police a Europe whole plays a vital role combating drug gangs trafficking and terrorism but the National Crime Agency says the u.k. Is the only e.u. Country not to have signed up to a new regulation giving the organization greater powers David Arman says unless the government sin by Christmas it will have to withdraw from Europe whole next year leaving Britain without access to e.u. Intelligence and a database of suspects he says staying in Europe poll until bricks it will give ministers time to find alternatives the Home Office says a decision will be made in due course one of Britain's most senior police officers has told the b.b.c. There could be at least $100.00. 1000 Men in the u.k. Who regularly view obscene images of children online the previous estimate made 3 years ago by the National Crime Agency was half that. Leaked n.h.s. Documents seen by b.b.c. News suggests that struggling g.p. Surgeries in England could be allowed to close a letter from a senior n.h.s. Manager to G.P.'s in the Yorkshire and Humber region suggests failing practices could be left to with or an h.s.a. England said it didn't agree with the comments and had pledged half a 1000000000 pounds to support vulnerable surgeries Dr Paul Wilding runs a practice near Huddersfield which he says is in danger of closing I cannot point to one example of something that somebody has done or can say no new investment into our bottom going budget we are in an emergency we are a sinking ship you know it is no good promising us a life boat in 3 or 4 years time. 3 West Midlands Police officers have been charged with perjury and perverting the course of justice following an investigation into the death of a man in custody in 2011 Kingsley Burrell who is 29 died 4 days after being detained by officers under the Mental Health Act His Fil makea last year an inquest jury found that Mr Burrell was subjected to unreasonable force prolonged restraint and inadequate medical treatment the Independent Police Complaints Commission referred a complaint made by his family about the 3 officers to the Crime Prosecution Service which was eventually passed to the Director of Public Prosecutions campaigners have welcomed the decision to prosecute constables Paul 80 Mark famine and Paul Greenfield will appear at Birmingham Magistrates Court on the 31st of October they've all been suspended from g.t. a Film production company has been fined wind 1600000 pounds after the actor Harrison Ford broke a leg while making the most recent Star Wars film in the u.k. The actor was crushed by a hydraulic door at Pinewood Studios in Buckinghamshire Daniela Relf reports Harrison Ford was reprising his role of Han Solo while filming Star Wars the force awakens during rehearsals in June 2014 a metal door from the set of the Millennium Falcon spaceship fell on him the 74 year old with hit hard in the pelvis pinned to the floor and had to be airlifted to hospital in Oxford the court was told that the incident could have killed him. Earlier this year fiddles production Ltd which is the owned by Disney pleaded guilty to 2 charges brought by the Health and Safety Executive for the 1st time in more than 30 years Britain is to host the road cycling world championships the 2900 vent will take place in Yorkshire which successfully beat off bids from Germany Italy Canada and Colombia Thank you David you're listening to the world tonight with Ritalin. At least 15 people including children have been killed in Aleppo today according to activists an airstrike hit a marketplace in the rebel held part of the Syrian city President Assad's forces backed by Russian airpower launched an all out assault to take control of Aleppo last month and the fate of the city has become central to rising tensions between Russia and the West an attack on an aid convoy blamed on Moscow the rising civilian death toll and the destruction of medical facilities have provoked calls for Russia to be tried for war crimes 9 days ago Washington broke off all negotiations with Moscow amid extreme tension over the failure to secure a cease fire in Syria but now both sides of announce their resume talks in Switzerland on Saturday Well Nancy Soderberg is a former u.s. Ambassador to the u.n. And served as a deputy national security advisor under Bill Clinton I asked her if negotiations are so begin again what could possibly be up for discussion the future of a side has to be on the table in order for any peace to be lasting I fear the there's a huge gaps between the Russian and the American positions we want Assad to go the Russians want them to stay the same I went in the room is Iran which very much wants Assad to stay. Those 3 powers and perhaps the Saudis come together and agree on at least in the short term what's going to happen to Assad which most likely that he would have to stay any peace is going to be extremely fragile those are the specifics but what about the question. Trust even round the table after all that efforts to get some kind of joint u.s. Russian ceasefire failed spectacularly The problem is that the not just in trust but in the basic positions of the key players are very vast and I don't see any movement My hope is that President Obama will do one grand gesture for his successor who's likely to be her Clinton and agreed to move to recognize that in the short term Assad stay work with the Iranians and put in he still together which will enable the forces to come together rid the country of ISIS and. The politics of Assad later that does not appear to be emerging in the near term and the people of superior going to pay the price you mentioned the issue of trust there is no trust anymore between the u.s. And Russia you may have noticed middle of the very heated campaign here with the Russian government come from. F.b.i. Sources. Actively supporting Donald Trump actively seeking anti Hillary information that does not bode well for building up a relationship of trust in the next few months but most go has its reasons to be suspicious of the West too many want it back to the u.n. Resolution that authorized the air campaign in Libya something that the u.n. Something the Russians agreed to and then later felt that they were hoodwinked because they had never agreed necessarily to the overthrow of Gadhafi I don't think it's the doing that situation unfold in ways that the u.s. Did not expect with tragic consequences but it does make the Russians extremely wary about agreeing to any 1st resolutions at the United Nations what would be the most optimistic that you would be about what might come out of. Initial meeting at the weekend I think they're trying get another ceasefire with stronger protections for the population particularly Aleppo I think everyone is shocked by the pictures coming out of that area the only way forward is to have a strong agreement on the future of Assad but there he goes or that he stays I think the most likely deal be that he stays in the short term I would not be. An agreement on the future of Assad in the status of. Any ceasefire is going to be anything other than a stop gap measure Nancy Soderberg an apologies for the quality of the lying in Syria details have emerged of a secret internment camp for former Islamic state militants and their families it's understood that some $300.00 defectors and captured combatants including many Europeans are being held at a camp operated by the rebel group Jaish al therea one of the groups in the Free Syrian Army the b.b.c. Hasn't been able to get into the camp but it has obtained material from inside the mail is a former fighter with so-called he traveled to Syria from his native Netherlands 2 years ago he says getting into Syria was much easier than leaving but life inside I held territory wasn't what he expected. Through those very very big special people from another country it's very hard for us to live there. Our lifestyle because we are used to to a lot of things. And then we come there and. They directly start to do true true hard. You give your life to them so they're going to start. To control your life they'll use you for bad stuff. From the Netherlands it's estimated that more than $4000.00 Europeans have traveled to join the jihad to fight in Iraq or Syria Carolina is the founder of fate families against terrorism and extremism her 18 year old son Lucas left his home in Copenhagen in Denmark in the spring of 2014 he went to Turkey without telling his family and only found his mother once he'd arrived Lucas suffered from a spurge is a needed rules and structure Carlina believes this was part of the appeal of Islam to Lucas she told me what happened he went. So we're trying to get a hold of him and I couldn't he call me a couple of days later from a Turkish phone when did you realize that Lucas had converted to Islam when he was 15. He was going through a kind of a bitch period her when she married as they sleep or they don't really so when when you ask something. And want to eat and when night praying he was out of his Raman drinking tea and stuff and just don't touch me. We went through the Ramadan and that your ears are just ask them you haven't said yes you know who converted him or how he was drawn in by yeah yeah when he was around 13 ish he had an internship a couple of weeks shop they were guards there and one of them was in my opinion more strain then the others were and Lucas to be extreme most of them this was just because he was autistic that's what we thought so aged 18 he went off to Turkey without telling you what point did he get in touch with you when did you 1st hear from him 2 days later he told me that he had gone to Turkey and he wanted to help us but sister. In camps and what did you think when he told you that I was shipped I was so. I was in shock that he literally had left the country that he was lying so I asked him why didn't you send the following and he just says well I was afraid you would stop me did you realize all suspect at that point that he planned to go and fight for us I didn't think that he would plant 6 frightful i-s. And fact he did it my son didn't go to Syria. He didn't my son left to help us but since this camp to fight as a Syrian fighting can be fighting for people to have better the chanst you know and they camps and he worked in the 8 counts for 4 months so well what happened he worked in the camp for 4 months how much contact to do you have with him and did anybody else try to get in touch with him several times a week sometimes that would. Contact with each other through hype and he was he was so away he was just my ball was very loving and when we texted each other it was kind of strange but he went over a smidgen of my did you know I had to persuade him to come back oh yeah. Every time I spoke to him I asked him when he coming back or are you coming to the point are you going to tell us what you're doing and what would he say when you asked that he would then you would say that he has been boxing packages for the government then or he had been prepping clubs for the winter that was going to come what help did you get from New York authorities whatsoever when I talked to them on the phone so maybe that when kids have gone for at least 4 months they're probably. Well you know that if he did come that he might face you know I couldn't can't listen. That comes back from this will obviously need to be prosecuted and what way rather there is a consequence of what we do but you want at least be alive I don't care if you sin prison still my son they need to be reprogrammed that broken when they're gone and if they come back that broken what happened to your son a what do you believe happened to your son I found out. That he was blown up. Screen us quote sure bombs hit the building and. That was that how do you feel about everything this happened and about the fact that you didn't get to say goodbye in any sense well I'm still I'm still really I'm still broke every day I still cry because I miss them so much you know mothers and fathers we haven't. We haven't brought our kids up to be terrorists we haven't. Carolyn Hall that's the experience of a grieving parent but what about Jihad these who change their minds and decide they'd like to come back home Peter Newman is director of the International Center for the Study of Radicalization at King's College in London and author of radicalized new jihad this in the threat to the west Good evening good evening Caroline Carolyn of there said she wouldn't have cared if her son had ended up in prison but what is likely to happen to someone who's disillusioned and decides to try to come back home why it's not a future scenario we are estimating that about a 3rd of people who have traveled to Syria have already come back some of them are still dangerous some of them are disturbed because of what they went through in the conflict and some of them indeed are disillusioned and when they come back some of them are being prosecuted some of them are going through government run intervention programs to de radicalize and deprogram them some of them are just to bring integrating back into into their communities and and are not drawing a lot of attention to themselves other concerns about deterrence about actually making sure that those who come back is somehow made an example to ensure that others don't do the same sure I mean a lot of people are being prosecuted however in many cases it's not that easy because in many trials you need to prove that someone was a member of the Islamic State in many cases it is very difficult to actually. Find out what exactly they did was they were members of his arming state and so as a result of that some of the trials that we've seen across the continent have resulted in very light sentences so people go to prison for maybe 2 or 3 years which means that they might be out in the year and a half and how accurate is the information about who is actually out there who is in Syria who is in Prague I think it's the numbers that have come from different sources are marching up and so we are estimating that of the 30000 people in total from 100 different countries that have gone to Syria maybe 10000 are still left within ISIS territory of those 10000 maybe up to 2000 are from western Europe maybe 3 to 400 Brits are still left in ISIS territory and when ISIS crumbles when the Caliphate crumbles of course the concern is that these people will return to Britain however I personally think a lot of them will 1st of all return to Turkey from where they entered into Syria and then some of them will stay that and I don't think that suddenly 400 people will knock at Britain's door some of them will go to other conflicts some of them will over time try to return to it how fearful should we be about those who might choose to knock on Britain's door I think it is a concern I do think that numbers of people will over the next 5 or 6 years turn up back in Britain and I think that's why it isn't right to think that just because ISIS is on the defensive in Syria and Iraq that Islamic state or the terrorist threat is over I think paradoxically in counter-intuitive lay perhaps in the short term the defeat of ISIS in Santa Iraq may actually increase domestic terror threats in Europe patient human thank you very much concern is growing for the health of the Thai king 88 year old king. Paan adenoid it is the world's longest reigning monarch on Sunday the palace announced that his condition was unstable after he'd been through dialysis treatment during his 7 decades on the throne the Kings intervened when events have threatened to plunge Thailand into crisis but the country's strict lesson in jest laws mean public discussion of his health and succession plans are permitted and there punishable by lengthy jail terms and regret that Marshall is a journalist who has lived in exile from Thailand for the last 5 years after writing critically about the royal family he explained the significance of the end of the reign of this king for Thailand it's a mentors time because comparables been raining for 70 years and in many ways he's held Thailand back in particularly tight democracy has been rather stunted Pons often supported military regimes and this kind of inch and Thai culture of deference to royalty of prostrating on the ground a law which means you can't even say anything critical but the Royals all these kind of through back to the past have survived. And now that he's dying it looks like this all culture of tightness and the anti democratic elements of them are dying too so we're going to see Thailand suddenly I think you are facing a huge amount of culture shock he is incredibly loves he is a man who is revered isn't he yes but. The Royal propaganda will tell you that all Thais unquestioningly love the king and it's true that many too many Thais do love him that's partly because you know b. Think he's done some genuinely good things it's also because there's been a huge amount of propaganda throughout you know his his reign pre-treating him as an almost god like figure but a lot of Thais don't buy the propaganda and especially in the last decade since the military coup in 2006 we've seen an increasing number of people questioning the more Akiane. Questioning me point so he is generally revered you will see many Thais in the streets weeping when he dies but it's not quite true that everybody loves him how much power does the royal family have which you say. Formally they have no real power the constitution accorded Constitution their pure research moony all the reality is really different they have immense power and it comes from 2 main sources the 1st is the kind of secret aura of loyalism know many ties they believe in spiritual power and that certain and militants are statues and certain people have more power than others and the Tyrrells are right at the top so just by the fact that they are the senior royals tires have immense kind of social influence because of their so-called secret power the 2nd source of power is much more prosaic they have a vast amount of money we don't know how much the credit property bureau has but it's been conservatively estimated at least $50000000000.00 That's the biggest draw fortune in the world the biggest fortune of anybody in entire land so this money allows them to exert immense influence because they can spread it around amongst their allies helps them you know create a network or a network monarchy of companies and businessmen who support them given that it's impossible to speak critically about the Thai King you can't ask people's opinion about the monarchy in Thailand How do you judge what may happen with this exception you're quite right I mean it's illegal for ties to talk about any of this and succession is hugely controversial in Thailand because the delegate here is crowded Prince where you are a long corn and quite frankly he's widely hated and feared that this kind of one the worst kept secrets in Thailand there are many powerful Thais who oppose the crown prince and the small possibility that we might see conflict or some kind of attempt to block him but what you will see if the crown prince becomes king is that . All this sacred reverence all reverence for the monarchy that we saw acting preform that's all going to disappear now what was able to help you know the military's rule often in dictatorships because since he supported it a lot of Thais accepted it now the crown prince won't be able to you know use been a benevolent or a to support dictatorship so you'll see much of a rule by fear and in my view that kind of thing can't last particularly long sooner or later you'll see a big change in Thailand because people won't accept people ruled by a princely heat by a prime minister who seized power with the military and sooner or later elected to want change and democracy the views of journalist Andrew McGregor martial student protests are spreading across South Africa as demonstrators demanding free college education shut down universities in the final weeks of the academic year they have been violent clashes in Johannesburg Cape Town Durban and today in Pretoria where students marched through the streets of the capital burning tires before being dispersed by the police our correspondent Alison Leith head has been following the protests from the prestigious university of its Fatah strand in Johannesburg to the streets of Pretoria. The was. The 1st children to be born after the end of apartheid a coming of age the right. Looks police helicopter buzzing overhead as a public saw 300 students were marching through the streets. Of high stakes and signs the Rolling Stone is about you together pulling the rug. While the police just my decision to break up the crowds and so I think I would get a bullets but again just overall we are. Covering a foot. In what looks like a space where students. To be making some arrests but it was quite disturbing they were the police were very very close and were just firing round after round of books and to people who were just trapped behind a car really just in the police not by this a private college don't try and I was going to be in charge and all the things the protests and moving from the university campuses to the streets there's been violence and because it in the tile Cape Town of Johannesburg with some of the worst clashes at the University of its waters run Ovitz as it's called one of the most prestigious colleges in the country. Protesters smashed concrete slabs into pieces ready to be thrown at the security guards at the front door of the great hall the university has vowed to stay open for those students who want to set their final exams everyone's away and new graduates means new doctors new training teaches the country will suffer but protest leaders like Mrs c.y.c. Abbott see that as leverage it's all about making some of the much better schools at the school versus a conifer to pay fees that's kind of what accommodation will have full potential to be protesting we're not going to be about it's about that. But this is about more than just demanding. Free university education this link is indicative of a much bigger issue such in South Africa 22 years after the end of apartheid it's about this lack of equality in the country and to a large extent it is about race. People are really just saying that we don't think that what's being done to redress the past or to try to really build a new South Africa is adequate system be better is a political analyst a particular a university any of the ones who are leading the per test who are 2122 those young people who were born in 1995 so they cannot and the stat was a they are still fighting these battles in a supposedly free democratic South Africa that's the stuff that was supposed to be settled with democracy. Police firing rubber bullets at students the scene is reminiscent of another time that parents fought the authorities for freedom but this generation wants more decolonized education as they call it the columnist indication men we are both the beings. From the country not this being of us living the textbooks from outside countries the examples that we have from overseas and if we don't get to know exactly what's happening in the old context is it worse not finishing the year and then protesting ahead of the next year no we cannot afford to protest again next year who's willing to protest like you do think it's not should be shot at West children and everything we had to study this is not what are your flaws but now the thing is let them just give us exactly what we want and then we'll go back to close up my bed with me I've seen here everything calculators I just want to go to class but let them just give us exactly what. Was. In 17640 years ago it was students who stood up against the apartheid government and the so what. Uprising perhaps encouraged by history the young of 2016 expressing their dissatisfaction over inequality lack of change corruption and the waste of money they feel should have been spent on education. Alister least head reporting the headlines so far in the world tonight a fresh attempt to end the bloodshed in Syria will be made on Saturday when Russia America and for regional powers meet in Switzerland and the governments resisting calls from Labor and some conservatives to allow M.P.'s a vote on its negotiating strategy for BRICs it popular products including Marmite and pot noodles have been disappearing from Tesco shelves amid a dispute between the supermarket and the supply unit lever business editor Simon Jack joins me now what's going on Simon Well about 3 to 4 weeks ago Unilever maker of all those brands you just mentioned hits all the major grosses with a 10 percent price rise saying blaming Bragg's it in the fall in the value of the pound they are an angry Dutch company they're saying because the fall in value the pound they need to make up the revenue fall in the u.k. By upping these prices now they've all been mulling it over Tesco is the 1st one to have said actually we're not going to do it we're going to refuse that price demand and therefore Unilever have stopped delivering leading to the shortages you just talked about now it's very interesting that Tesco are the 1st person to basically draw a line in the sand here because the boss of Tesco Dave Lewis used to work at Unilever and so he knows better than anyone else exactly what their business looks like what their margin pressures are and from what I've heard from industry sources they're saying look some of this stuff is made in the u.k. Well Marmite someone pointed out what made the u.k. Well Quartus and so basically blanket 10 percent on all products I think they're trying it on just a little bit and they're saying you know we're not going going to do it now it's going to be very interesting to see where the other supermarkets come out of they going to get behind Tesco because privately they're delighted that Tesco have taken the stand but they're also quite enjoying Tesco being out there not having Mum item at shelves that's a horrible place for a supermarket to. So whether they fall in line behind or let Tesco sweat this one out on their own will be interesting what they're saying is yes there are reasonable price pressures that suppliers face when you've got you know the pound falling 17 percent since Briggs it but this across the board 10 percent rise is not the way to play it we're prepared to have reasonable conversations this they didn't think was reasonable and they test for one will see what there was to have said we're not having it so Tesco has broken ranks but the other supermarkets presumably we hoping that their tills kind of go to Ching in the next few days but presumably there's going to have to be some give and take here somewhere will be interesting I mean this is a real power struggle isn't it Unilever incredibly mighty in terms of the broad you know them and Procter and Gamble party responsible half the stuff and most people shopping basket so they've got enormous power but that is Tesco is by some distance still the biggest retailer in the u.k. One in every 8 pounds is the famous you know equation we do about how much is spent there so Tesco feel they've got a lot of power something's going to give it'll be interesting to see it to see who does and but it is there Paul Polman the boss of Unilever warms he said a few months ago that if we leave the European Union some import prices will go up and this will happen it's beginning to happen I just don't like the way it's been presented but I think this will be the 1st of many sort of price disputes prosper as we see in the weeks and months to come Simon Jack thanks very much. 130 people were killed in the last November's Islamist attacks in Paris all bar one of the attackers died in suicide bombings are under police fire now lawyers acting for the main surviving suspect say they can no longer represent him because he won't speak frank Betar and span Mary told French television that they had hoped their clients up to Saddam would eventually talk but they said it had become clear that he gone downhill mentally and would maintain his right to silence Mr Bear toll said constant surveillance in prison had taken a toll. Seems to salaam Singh from month to month while being monitored every instant 24 hours a day with an infrared camera even at night such treatment drives a person crazy and that is a consequence of a political decision Mr Murray said those who cared about the victims would lose out as they had a right to know the truth. This last year makes. For silent but the real victims in all of this at the end of the day are the victims the actual victims of the Paris attacks because they have the right to know the truth and to try to comprehend the incomprehensible. Emmanuel Domino who was in the battle plan concert hall on the night of the Paris attacks on November 13th last year he gave me his reaction to the lawyers decision to withdraw their professional support. Because we're on that just as the same right then every guy who is arrested in a democratic country so he has a right to have a lawyer has the right to defend himself in another hence it was a little bit expected because he doesn't speak for like 3 or 4 months now the law is also to say that they believe his silence is detrimental to people like you to families who lost people in that those attacks because the truth won't come out is that how you feel we hold that the truth will come out with or without set up the system because we think that the trend Justice is doing a good job and actually we have proved that the justice is getting more and more information without the help offset out this time so we hope that his silence one be a problem for the father justice and for the truth the other point that his lawyers make is that he's not speaking because he's under 24 hour surveillance which they say is causing him real psychological stress what do you think about that you have to understand that it's not a punishment to 20 forest recording it's it's to avoid that he killed himself we want don't want to lose him but he's not a reason to feel but it's the only way we found to protect him from himself he has many ways to to claim his case and ask for the avoid the discovery and seek in even go to do European Court of Human Rights and ask for this but we feel like it's a blackmail you know Ok if you stop to regard me I would speak and this is not Ok but do you understand the point that perhaps he's not willing to speak because he can't speak His lawyer is in conflict. Because there's always somebody watching that's a problem all of course and we are aware of that this soon won't be a condition to him for speaking to the judges because when he speaks to the judges there is no camera there is just the judges his lawyers and that or so in one hand I'm Ok to say that maybe that we have to think about how he's treated in jail but in the know where and it shouldn't be a condition for him to speak it's coming up to a year since they said Paris attacks what are you memories of that night. Lots of suddenness and bloats and screaming in different you know number I lost my innocence I was just like a young Parisian. Getting to a concert in this thing rock music and in a few seconds I was in the war theater we have people in Journey people are dead around is so I lost a lot of things in there I won't never be the same no when I get to a venue when I get to have cinema I don't know I'm always rushing into the emergency exits I'm scared when there is a noise so that's a sadness and. I'm not so confident for the future it's something that is profoundly changed your life yes of course because. I didn't think that it can happen in Paris with this violence completely blind violence we've people of who had my age who are French like me in I didn't think it was possible in friends and no. Everywhere I go every transport facilities I take everything I am always saying to myself Ok if someone can come now and with a gun he can kill a lot of people so change a lot of things yes. Do you think if there is a court case then that will help you to come to terms with what has happened yes of course. I hope. It will be something really important for us it's one. Thing but in one way we'll have justice and we'll have the truth maybe not all the truth but at least we have some elements and some explication about what happens and then we hope about how they can manage through French security you can check your routine you know things so. We hope that this truth will help us. Emmanuel dominant. India is a land of many gods and goddesses a country where ancient spirituality and modality can exist and in that spirit Kolkata has been celebrating its largest Hindu festival the rig up which are thousands of temporary temples spring up across the city for the celebration of the 10 handed goddess slaying a demon but this year Israel turned reports the authorities have been trying to deal with a modern day problem that they say is a safety hazard the selfie. I've come to the house of the same family and called like millions of others at the moment they're praying to the 10 God is this is a festival like no one there in India. Has come back from London to enjoy it this is one occasion which draws everybody into it. You can hear the enthusiasm of the people it is something out of this is something that. Which is one where there is no difference between the poor and the rich everybody is the seat. But these small family budgets have now been replaced by much bigger ones thousands of temporary temples. Spring up across this city the main ones can attract up to 200000 people on the main nights of the festival they all have different themes some this year dedicated to social media others to the iconic yellow ambassador taxi this one I've come to in north called color along with thousands of other people as Shakespeare is its theme Alan gamble the director of the British Council is here along with some back pipes. Hundreds of thousands of people are excited to see this I'm absolutely sure if Shakespeare were alive today he'd be writing for Bollywood and the people in this part in this district as we look at the thousands of people that are going to experience this she experienced elation I'm absolutely sure they connect with. Your 1st real Puja I mean what do you make of this it is sort of religion meets culture everything else but it is absolutely everything from top Indian Bollywood stars advertising every possible product to tens of thousands of people wondering are paying their respects but also paying their respects to the goddess but also paying their respects to our top designers to craftspeople and that's why we're here bringing Shakespeare bang up today. The sound of the dark the name for the local drum here beating tells you the goddesses come to Calcutta. But her arrival now means at the end Tara he is having to deal with a modern day problem this selfie is leading to safety concerns if there is a way people taking them in front of the goddess it could lead to a stampede the police want them banned during the festival and many planned this year have set up special selfies. She bunch or is a government minister here and one of the organizers of the door festival I don't endorse he's too much it appears that you know our attention is kind of distracted to being so self-centered when they persist. Instances of self-pity Ok fine it was tolerable but it went if you don't video and then you actually have to have zones that just don't do it don't block that area come to a particular zone like a no smoking zone so I think that's a better idea to restrain. So want to some of the youngsters make of the attempts to stop their selfies. And let's go and find out we were just going to guess I'll feel I don't see why it's a bad idea it is a bit of an obsession nowadays for me. Yeah I think it's a good initiative I thing they should be very nice about this they've been some selfie accidents but then again I mean some people just want to have fun and that should also be allowed on the. Net Not reports from Rahul Tandon just time for tonight's main headline the United States and Russia say they'll resume talks in an effort to halt the conflict.