In dense legislative language this bill reminds us of some of the aspects of the withdrawal agreement that have caused such a controversy over the last few years within the Conservative Party It details how the financial settlement or divorce Bill will be paid by the u.k. To the e.u. It confirms that the European Communities Act which took the u.k. Into the e.u. Will be repealed only to be reintroduced immediately for the duration of a post breaks it transition period and it sets out how the withdrawal agreement a treaty with the e.u. Will in many respects have supremacy over much of u.k. Law other issues stand out as potential flash points for M.P.'s the language on workers' rights is pretty vague because Boris Johnson's deal moved the strongest obligations out of the withdrawal agreement into a non-binding political declaration The bill also suggests that if the government doesn't ask for an extension of the transition period beyond the end of 2020 Parliament won't have a say in changing that even if a free trade deal isn't ready in time there's not that much detail in the bill itself in the proposed new economic arrangement for Northern Ireland but in accompanying impact assessment sets out some of the extra costs and bureaucracy that companies doing business there will have to face it's an awful lot for M.P.'s to take in in just $3.00 days British police officers will travel to the United States to interview a woman who left the u.k. After being involved in a car accident that led to the death of a motorcyclist and sickle it was driving the car which hit 19 year old had it done outside I r e f crouton in Northamptonshire She's the wife of an American diplomat and returned to the us claiming diplomatic immunity Duncan Kennedy reports. In statements issued through her lawyers and Securitas has already admitted driving on the wrong side of the road before the collision that killed Harry dumb last night the foreign secretary Dominic Robb told the Commons the Foreign Office tried to stop her leaving the u.k. But were told by the American authorities that she had diplomatic immunity and was protected from prosecution now the family has been told that offices Northamptonshire police will travel to the United States to interview Mrs a coolness although the family spokesman Robert Seeger said they are confused they thought the investigation was already complete. Sunday family liaison officer told the police's file had been handed to the Crown Prosecution Service suggesting that their investigation was complete here tonight that you don't have to cheer police are now traveling to the United States to interview and it is confusing and perplexing later today the chief constable of North London will give an update on the inquiry. The Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau has won a 2nd term in office but he's lost his majority in parliament and will need support from smaller parties to carry on governing with almost all the results now declared in the country's general election Mr Trudeau's liberals are well ahead of their main challengers the conservatives in terms of seats despite winning fewer votes our North America Correspondent Chris Buckley reports from the Liberal Party's headquarters in Montreal. At the Liberal Party's headquarters they chanted his name but this election saw Justin Trudeau in a fight for his reputation his position and perhaps even his political career however he has emerged from his vote as Canada's prime minister once again the relief as much as the joy of his supporters catch the. Canadians rejected division and negativity. They rejected cuts and are staring and they're voted in favor of a progressive agenda and strong action on climate change a this was a tough campaign for Mr Trudeau personally with the emergence of old photos showing his face blocked up and claims that he interfered in a corruption scandal on the success has not come without losses the liberals no longer have a majority in parliament a more seem like uniform a minority government which means they will have to work with other parties to push through their policies. Violence has broken out in Bolivian cities after the election authorities announced that the incumbent President Evo Morales had narrowly won the country's election counting resumed last night after being suspended on Sunday when early results suggested there would have to be a 2nd round of voting Mr Morale istic had to get special permission from a constitutional court to stand for a 4th Tam angering many voters. Electric vehicles would be fitted with green number plates under government proposals to encourage more drivers to abandon petrol and diesel models ministers say the scheme could also lead to incentives like free parking for electric cars our transport correspondent Tom Barrett reports if every electric vehicle in Britain was given a green number plates that they could easily be identified as 0 emission sometimes automatically via cameras it would the government police allow local councils to introduce more incentives such as free parking or allowing electric vehicles to drive in bus lanes in cities abroad like Oslo where a large proportion of cars are already electric these type of incentives have helped encourage more drivers to make the switch in the u.k. Last month electric vehicles accounted for 2 percent of new sales fresh incentives are likely to help but the broader affordability of electric models and the speed and availability of charging infrastructure a widely considered to be more critical factor is a man has been arrested on suspicion of murdering 217 year old boys who were stabbed at a house party in Buckinghamshire the 21 year old suspect is also being questioned about the attempted murder of 2 other people Japan's emperor Naruhito has formally ascended to the throne in an elaborate ceremony at the Imperial Palace in Tokyo the 59 year old head of state officially began his reign in May but his ascension is formalized only after he completes a series of rituals to put Winfield Hayes reports from the Japanese capital dressed in heavy orange robes and Bernard Hito ascended the imperial throne for the 1st time reading from a wide scroll the emperor made his promise to devote his life to serving the Japanese people outside can and fired in salute. Thousands of dignitaries are here including Britain's Prince Charles and Royals from Spain to Belgium to Bhutan tonight there will be a lavish state banquet but the celebrations have also been overshadowed by disaster this afternoon there should have been a grand procession with a new emperor and empress riding in an open top car that is not happening out of respect for the 80 people killed when Typhoon Haggis tore through Japan last week Rupert Winfield has reporting. It is now 10 past 8 just imagine you've been searching for a new home for 3 long years evolve about where you want to move next what your new place should look like about whether you really want to move at all you're bored you're tired you want to talk about almost anything else and then finally your offer the chance to get it done there is just one problem the seller tells you you've got to decide before you've had a chance to look around their words allow you a survey because they tell you after all the benefits of the deal are self evident it is in other words pretty much take it or leave it after all you're told Didn't you want to get on with it that in many ways is the essence of the government's pitch they need to publish their legislation for last night a 110 pages of it with even more pages of explanation but they want to M.P.'s to vote on it in 3 days will talk to the housing minister Robert general in just a 2nd 1st though our political correspondent Ross Hawkins a man paid to read dead pages of legal text and are also and what a joy it is simple in the sense your metaphorical house purchase is simple your just buying a house we're just implementing here Boris Johnson's deal in u.k. Law it is complex in the enormous amount of detail in there in the different bits of public life it will affect in over hundreds of pages of law and notes and the key for the Rouse of the coming days will not just be the amendments we've heard so much about and the timing of it but what is actually in that text Yeah and what is in the text is not just what we called a divorce but also a text about our future relationship in many ways it's that the often causes more trouble for ministers this is the crucial part of many of these roles this sets the ground rules for the coming huge decision not how we leave the e.u. But how we deal with the e.u. In the future a future relationship now says the objectives in that negotiation must be consistent with what Boris Johnson has agreed in his deal of Boris Johnson vision of Bret's it and yet m.p.c. . Need to approve those objectives before negotiations begin you can see how that growing things to a halt and there are already concerns about what happens if we don't do a long term deal M.P.'s would need to approve the government asking for an extension of this standstill period after this vote but they're worried they can't see a way to demands that extension and many opposition M.P.'s fear that that could lead the government in the driving seat to if it chose leaders to a version of no deal the end of 2020 Now one thing opposition M.P.'s will have been doing when they read it is thinking can we find something anything on which people with very very different views can all agree to make trouble for the government is earning all visit the people across the road from us are not bow Wiggs lawyers or worthy academics they are trying to defeat their political opponents they are looking for technicalities some of them to d. Rail Boris Johnson's plans and some of them are just looking at this bit of law which says the European community is at the bit of law that set up European law in this country the seventy's will be got rid of but the effects of that will continue and they are just wondering some opposition M.P.'s How could we point out how could we highlight it how could we do anything to drive a wedge between Boris Johnson and the Brits it is who he thinks he now has on site get back to the starting Ross thank you very much indeed Robert generally as I say is the center of state for housing communities and local government and joins us in a chilly tent on college very morning to you good morning you've got in front of you I see European Union brackets withdraw agreement Bill you've read it I have had a good look at it overnight Do you really believe it is possible to digest 100 years of complex legal text in the time that M.P.'s have been given I do and you got to remember that we've been discussing this for 3 and a half years the House of Commons I believe has had 500 hours of debate on break that many of the issues in this bill of course are very familiar to M.P.'s because they've been known for a long time that they are in to resume a deal such as the provisions on citizen. Living within the u.k. And as you just heard for Ross you have to remember the purpose of this bill is purely to put into u.k. Law the deal for our exit from the e.u. It isn't to determine our future relationship with the e.u. That we've committed will be subject to debate and vote in parliament later on once we've left well I don't pretend that I've read it but let's just give you one bit I have seen Should you all 5 a or tickle a teen a minister mis make a statement to the effect that all of the ministers on able to make a statement of Northern regression Her Majesty's Government nevertheless which is the house to proceed with a bill this is about protection for workers' rights if you have no idea what that means you know we've been very clear we have absolutely no intention of rowing back on the very high standard of workers' rights that we enjoy in this country this government certainly doesn't we've just said that we intend to increase the national living wage to 10 pounds 50 now no government would say that unless they cared about the rights of working people so we've said that if there's any suggestion that the government is going to be rowing back for workers' rights then the minister needs to come to pan make a statement and of course parliament can have its say on that if it's a wish is so truly they said just want to do that Lou and human the complex legal means there's no guarantee that workers' rights will not be watered down we don't give you a guarantee despite what the prime minister has said in public but we will come to Parliament and tell you if we're going to water down what we're saying that parliament will decide and that's the point of taking back control isn't it trusting of Parliament to make important decisions on workers' rights or the environment why would you trust a member of Johnston who said in the polls the weight of employment regulation is now back breaking given that he said that given that the home secretary has said that the cost of the regulation is 4000000000 pounds and she could cut regulation create 60000 jobs why would you take it on trust this man really doesn't want to cut regulations of workers' rights because you look at the record of this government is creating the national living wage it's cutting taxes for 32. 2000000 people you see the long term track record of this country you know we have better maternity arrangements for example than the e.u. Dictates to us so we've always been a mystery in the whole we thought he was a ranting minister working people we have no intention of changing that the whole point of getting out they told us was to change the economic model to break free from Brussels in order to make our own rules or regulations but when you need a vote what you say is No no no don't worry it is all going to say no what we're saying is that it's absolutely right that this country should be able to determine its own future that's the point of leaving the opinion as you say and we're going to trust parliament and government of the future to do that and we know that punk can hold governments to account we've seen of course very vividly over the last couple of years short on workers' rights and the environment you've seen that with the environment bill that we've just announced in the Queen's speech we have no intention of falling behind your I suspect we're going to go further and faster than our European friends well let's give you another example that we saw the BRICs secretary asked yesterday whether they would be there would be customs forms for businesses to fill in when they want to export from Northern Ireland to Great Britain No he said until he said the opposite just a few minutes later the truth is you're making this up as you go along no that's the this is a piece of legislation which simply puts into effect in u.k. Law what the Prime Minister's managed to negotiate you know confounding his critics with the European Union all those regulations look like the more northern Ireland business is a critical quitting use that the future relationship will be subject to a negotiating mandate that will be debated and voted on in the House of Commons So those M.P.'s who have concerns about issues such as that or the Customs Union I don't I don't want the u.k. To remain within the Customs Union they will have the ability to discuss and to vote on that later on once we've left the years when you need to be there when you'll say forgive me but to be clear what you're saying is it isn't clear now you're admitting but it doesn't need to be clear now because that will be clarified . No I'm saying that it is clear now but it also is clear in the secular state for breaks in peace disagree with the future relationship then that is a debate for another day unless they actually just want to frustrate breaks it and that's the litmus test I think for the debate is going to come today those M.P.'s who actually want to deliver breaks it will be voting with the government today you see again and again you're saying trust us trust us on workers' rights trust us that we'll get this regulation right now the chancellor said in something that I think is completely without precedent trusters only economic impact also for a standard thing that is produced by governments of all colors by the civil service an economic impact assessment and that was the Treasury's forecast of what this will mean he said no no no we're not going to do that because the benefits are quote self evident Well look there wasn't a specific economic forecast prepared for the last deal it to reason may produce there was a set of forecasts produced across government after the Checkers announcement by the prime minister then Prime Minster to resume a some time ago so this isn't an unusual thing for the chancellor to say the governor of the Bank of England has said that this deal will be a net economic positive you've seen the markets rightly in the nose for gives an idea not so he said it would be a positive to have a deal compared with not having it he also repeated that we work for Britain than series amazed and worse than staying in the European Marconi has always been clear about that but businesses that I speak to want us to secure a deal so that they can have the certainty to move forward you know I'm the housing secretary I look at the housing market there is you know the housing market is slowing as a result of this uncertainty we want to get this deal over the line and then I think you'll see investment coming into the country you'll see the country being able to move forwards that brings me back to my metaphor with you as the housing secretary you would never buy a house on those sorts of turn and simply say I'm so exhausted low. At least it's a house forget that we don't have a survey done forget that we call tell whether we better or worse in its you would possibly would you Minister regularly but to buy a house on those days I had been thinking about buying that house for 3 and a half years if I had been debating it with my wife and family for 500 hours I think I might be able to move quite quickly when the opportunity arose and I think they would have ministers good also most of the questions of those M.P.'s who are going to vote this down today I suspect will be M.P.'s who would not have voted for this even if they had had until Christmas to debate this the Labor Party Front Bench for example said that they were against the bill long before it was even published if you want Bragg's done vote with the government today and we can by the end of October find a question we hear from behind the scenes that if you do lose one of the vote particularly this one of the timetable Boris Johnson might say let's forget it let's just pack it in and have an election and give the country a real choice well we've been trying to get an election for a long time now and you know we're always without precedent the Labor Party has been refusing to subject themselves to the public vote we don't want to compromise the integrity of the deal that we've negotiated with the this is a good deal it's a win win for the u.k. If people are lending you know and forgive me to interrupting I'm just trying to be clear if you do have it amended in a way that if I don't satisfactory pull the whole thing that Parliament come up with his own Well that would be a decision for the prime minister but we're not going to compromise on this deal because it's a good deal it delivers on the outcome of the referendum and it is the only deal that out there a deal that both the e.u. And the u.k. Consider a good one that can take the whole of Europe forwards Robert general minister for housing sector state communities locum. It's 21 minutes past 8 could the glory of the dawn chorus overtaken by the sound of artificial births that's the idea behind a new work of art. See . If it's. It's just it's. Just. Such a sound of a red start followed by a song thrush narrowboat copies part of an installation at London Somerset House the artist behind that recording Alexander Daisy Ginsburg joins me now good morning good morning and the inspiration in a way is to draw attention to the threat to bird song and the impact of our modern environment on them exactly I am not only thought of just on the more I learned about the effects of noise and light pollution on birds I decide I really wanted to make something that sort of started to tease apart that problem because they're really insidious effects that we don't really think about so much so for example even the shape of buildings affects how birds can communicate birds will sing at a higher pitch near buildings so that the lower pitches are lost through Echo and all these things affect the way that birds can mate and find and defend their territory I remember I used to live was a little street lightning and a poor black bird would be singing all through the night what exactly is a near Apple its back that's been found saying 23.8 minutes earlier at the AKC raft sound and all of this affects their ability to function and to communicate and we don't really think that we think more of habitat loss as a way that birds are being disappearing and that's why you came up with this idea of creating robot bird voices using the same kind of technology people used to create deep fakes of the project it was a commission for an exhibition at Somerset House in London which opens next Thursday could 247 and the show is looking at the effects of modern life on humans and I wanted to think about other species which is what a lot of my work does and to find a way to bring attention to this problem and then I learn more about generative adversarial networks which is a kind of Ai and with the help of a company called faculty. He we had an amazing string there a physicist help us build a genitive adversarial network so kind of Ai which we fed thousands of somewhere codings of birds into and out came these creating the lifelike buttons and so what kind of experience will people have if they're able to hear this 247 they will step into a room with 16 suspended speakers and the sound will begin with a natural bat and then increasingly the machine beds take over and they will be a full story company as a light installation and by the end of the experience they will live experience an artificial dawn and hopefully think about the effects of a city without pads horrible prospect thank you very much Alexander Daisy and Burke and as I was saying the show opens next week on the 31st of October says something else is happening today it's a. Great relief for everybody it's 24 years post a time for the sport there's something else happening there is well of course rope there is no make yes things have to get can Tottenham recover from that 72 home or in about Munich the last time they played Champions League football and Manchester City really good enough and strong enough to finally win the competition as manager Pep Guardiola says will both are at home tonight city to Atalanta and Spurs to Red Star Belgrade clues if not answers to questions on 5 Live this evening Meanwhile that search from Glasgow University demonstrating that former footballers are 3 and a half times more likely to develop dementia than people of the same age in the general population has been endorsed this morning by the California based Dr Bennett Amal to a leading specialist in brain trauma he agrees that heading the ball can have serious long term consequences and wants fundamental changes to the junior game. For soccer my position has always being. There should not be an me had you know be a ball before the age of 18 your brand becomes all slid a lot at about 18 to 25 years old before it remains that the loping brain that should not be any had enough to ball out that have little level however I dogs are free to do whatever they want to do as long as it does not pose a need Try thought danger to some of the press and like for children whenever we identify any reasonable risk danger we put tech children from such risk a danger using your had to stop an object traveling out the infinite speed does not make any sense given while we know today but don't carry on as surely football's a lighter these days than they were before it's not about they like football is about the dynamics of fall force your brain slows surely insight you know that is a whatever you use it to stop any object traveling at the high street what I'd like or not is not a body like most of the bar but if the last thing I know recommendations about excluding heading from junior football in a gaining traction anywhere in the United States with in the United States I think the last 2 years ago their bond had been anybody young got on the age of 12 but that is insufficient we need to make $818.00 because 18 is the edge of attainment of adult traditionalists where then football us or soccer as you call it would say that heading is intrinsic to the game itself that these recommendations would strip the game of one of its fundamental and in the case of goal scoring spectacular skills well a lengthy 7 to 6. John or said it is full for all of us to continue to cause brain damage and just from that excitement that's what we need to waste you know ourselves a body a value judgment systems of society which is more important the valley of lights all supports is that decisions presidents need to make so this is not health and safety gone mad then no it's not it's the intelligence probably 21st century I don't think we're moving had to inform Sako will mix up the lesson that let's fun we can still make it fun put the delights of human beings out it's all arms thank Dr Bennett our knowledge thank you very much indeed thank you so much and so that takes us to this morning's tips Newcastle free to number 2 stacks to Yarmouth 5 o'clock number 7 agent to Fortune thanks Rob now to tell us about this morning's edition of the live scientific his Jim Clearly my guest today is a neuroscientist although it might be more accurate to say that he is quite literally a mind reader Adrian Owen has spent his career scanning the brains of patients with disorders of consciousness looking for signs of awareness people he refers to as being in the gray zone he's pioneered techniques to map which parts of their brains like Tom when they're questioned on the carefully controlled conditions in doing so he's lifted the veil of silence for a surprising number giving them the opportunity to communicate once again with the outside world that's Adrian Owens last scientific after the news at 9. If the sun is coming out here at Westminster but it is very cold let's look at the weather for the rest the country driver in the world with sunny smiles spells absorbed but Scotland adore Vollard will be mostly cloudy smells that residents never mind her listening to the day old Radio 4 with Martin County and Nick Robinson It's half past 8 and now some of the news from Susan Rae M.P.'s have reacted angrily to plans to fast track bricks at legislation through the Commons a vote will be held later on the timetable to debate the withdrawal agreement Bill speaking to this program the housing secretary Robert Gen Rick said that Parliament had already debated Bracks at length and would have the ability to discuss and vote on details in the future British detectives a Jew to travel to the us to interview the American diplomats wife who fled the u.k. After being involved in a fatal car crash and sickle this was driving the car which hit the hit the teenage motorcyclists had it done Northamptonshire the Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau has told ecstatic supporters that the country voted in favor of a progressive agenda by reelecting him in yesterday's general election with almost all the results in the Liberal Party have won more seats than their conservative rivals but will fall short of a majority the government has unveiled plans to fit green number plates to electric cars ministers hope that the special plates will make 0 emission vehicles easier to identify and could pave the way for incentives such as free parking. Thank you Susan it's 29 minutes to 9 could Russia help Turkey to become a nuclear power plant amid Putin is meeting Richard type head on today to discuss the Turkish invasion of northern Syria but they may be more on the agenda recently President dead on declared that his country shouldn't be forbidden by the West from having nuclear weapons and Russia is helping Turkey with a civil nuclear program let's talk now to speak to west McCourt the U.K.'s former ambassador to techie Good morning good morning so the kind of friction that we've been seeing over northern Syria between Turkey and the United States is obviously being seen by Russia as a kind of opportunity. I think the relationship between President of Turkey and President Putin of Russia has been pretty cozy for a while now and of course before the Turks began their military operation across the border into northern Syria there was a green light from the Russians and the 2 presidents obviously get on well there are personal links their energy links their political links there's a lot of things that are going on and Russia is already involved in helping Turkey develop a civilian nuclear energy program so there is that possibility equally I like to think that the talk of nuclear weapons is no more the matter because one of the reasons why we were all so actively engaged in trying to stop Iran developing nuclear weapons was that we really did not want a regional nuclear arms race in the Middle East so I hope very much that this is talk out of frustration and difficulty in the relationship between Turkey and their estates or Turkey a NATO rather than a real threat although it's not the 1st time is it the president at all in has talked about breaking free of the kind of restrictions on countries that have signed the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty no one's quite sure what he's up to well that is true in Turkey as you say is indeed a signatory of the n.p.t. He has talked about it before and of course there's a certain sensitivity in Turkey that now that President Trump has now put it out in the open. America does store perhaps as many as 50 nuclear weapons of its own in a military base at a place called injured or killed in eastern Turkey and so people say well if America's going to get weapons why should we have I do think that if another power in the region like Saudi Arabia for example or Iran develop nuclear weapons that there would be quite considerable pressure on Turkey to do it but hit the 2 It hasn't been a real problem because everyone has known that in the event that Turkey as a member of NATO was threatened by nuclear weapons there was always that guarantee of the American you treat it errant being based in Turkey which would look after Turkey security interests they will of course be the primary purpose of the summit is discuss what's been happening in northern Syria what do you think is likely to come out of meeting. Well we honestly don't know the moment it's striking that over the last few months that Turkey and Iran and Russia seem to have turned out to be the big power players in what's happening in Syria President Trump is largely walked away from having a role that the Europeans unfortunately don't seem able to do much about and even a slaughter and reinvigorating political track so we have to see what happens there but I think from Turkey's point of view they really will want to keep the Kurds the Kurdish groups which America has been supporting and arming and training to deal with the terrorism of ISIS that want to keep as Turks if you like in a box they'll want to rip off their own national security interests and they will be looking to their friends in Russia to ensure that the southern border is secure against what they think is the risk of terrorism I would like to think that they'll be looking for a political plan or a path towards a settlement in Turkey in Syria excuse me which looks after the interests of all the different minorities in all the different ethnic groups that make up like complex society supposed to Westmacott thank you for talking to us. It is 20 minutes and how should children be taught about relationships some sort of teaching shouldn't take place at all that's the debate which is group schools in the end with a continuing controversy involving parents teachers and painters from next September relationship education will be compulsory primary schools across England and Wales one school in north east London is inviting people different faiths into classrooms to tackle the subject. Reports. What do we mean when we say l.g. Bt What does it mean to you that we get to learn about teacher Baca Whitaker costs of 10 an 11 year old me I was just think it's really good that we get to learn this stuff in school so that everyone knows that it's Ok to be gay or lesbian sometimes if you don't know about. You might like to go against it and be like. Do that Queensbridge primary the school believes it's paramount to that children are taught about diversity in society and that includes different relationships and faiths what type of religions do we practice in our country Hindu Islam. Islamic Judaism and Christianity here they learn about him from adults with experience like did. I was brought up as a Hindu so we practiced Hindu religion and some of you mentioned some of the festivals that we would celebrate so as part of the diversity mantra people of various faiths come in to tell their stories as a teenager I knew I was different because. We didn't talk about it it wasn't people telling is that it was Ok to be. To be gay or to be a lesbian and be Hindu so it was very very hard for me by doing this the school argues it's sending out a few. Message embrace difference and don't be frightened of it we get so much hatred and I think it's really nice when in a school the school can embrace people's differences and create joy do you think the children need to be aware that there are people of various faiths who don't think homosexuality is morally wrong and you know unfortunately I think our children already aware of those perspectives I think I hear them so equally they should have the opportunity to hear another perspective. I am a Christian and I think throughout all of this divested discussion relationships hold us together and that is the very center of the Christian faith that's Jennifer best and and she wants to conjure up to date a discussion rather than shy away from control to say I think feel young children to him. And better prepared to be the adults in the world that they will live rather than basing their lives on has a fair. Protest they have genuine encounters with people and what unites people more than what divides us that there has been push back with some parents demanding that children don't take part in lessons about relationships Savva Bailey is the head teacher community is made up by very many different cultures and ethnicity What do you say to parents who don't want my children to be in those classes we are building them up for British values and most it means to be a citizen in our society the government recently said it was keen on schools to have discussions with people of different faiths in the light of the recent protests outside schools in Birmingham but views a passionate and often entrenched I'm what could work in one classroom might not in an alpha I've done it's always always important to suspect someone no matter who they match what religion it is and that people have different religions and that's nothing to make a fuss about. Reporting there is no 20 war but when it started to look the. Scrupulous business practices gets in Ken Loach's latest film called Sorry we missed you he told the story of a young working class couple living in Newcastle. Struggling to balance the demands of the children with the need to earn money the veteran film director says it's a companion piece to his Bafta award winning film from 2016 Ari Daniel Blake which sort of middle aged job seeker constantly thwarted by a bureaucratic system that was supposedly there to help it all rot said it's a will go on puts Beckett offices to talk about this new movie. After. Country plumbing. Oh do I give it up. Why do you tend not to cast Hollywood stone finding people to bring a story to life is the 2nd most important decision you have make in film direct filmmaking 2nd to the script which is the most important and the camera can see see who you are how you stand how the quality of your skin depends on your diet every mannerism that you're not aware of and you've also got to believe that people can do the job they say that they can do in the film reach the character absolutely reach the character and absolutely have the capacity to draw the audience in and we were really lucky to find Chris playing wrecking his began as an actor and returned as an actor but was a plumber in between and drives a van and Debbie Honeywood lovely woman. Got a caring job as a teaching assistant with the kids who are then finally learning easy but has done a bit of television and the better thing but they connect make them a state they can look at 6 other people look. At what he got them all that practiced. Have not time for the. You see there's a risk in this rookie actor might not be able to do what you need him or. It sounds demeaning I mean they've got to bring it to life. Come Cutter nice and absolutely creating a fictional situation in front of a camera with total belief if that's not acting then the way it is talked about having imposter syndrome crying on the 1st day of filming thinking she couldn't do it there is a pressure on the actors there is pretty you know you'll get through it I knew she could do and it was only a matter of you know the 1st data was banksias but those things. Don't work for us to work with us you are content to get paid for them to say keep this really serious. This film is a companion piece to Daniel Blake because of course in the bureaucracy of the Social Security system and this is a family court in the world a precarious working where they get into really so this family could be around the corner from the new place in a way Abby the mother the care worker the wife she's given a doubly difficult hand because she also is working but she's also got to deal with her husband's choices which sometimes aunt great yes and she's falls on most women just to be the primary care so she's out working. Giving her head to the people she has to look after very properly but they can have the kids and he she can get she said to do it over the phone and I think a lot of working women will find this a will understand this they're on the phone saying look get it in the fridge don't spend all know in the computer get to bed as a reasonable time a little bit see when I get back what I've been living with this level of stress. You know. I just want things to. Eat him all for me and you know I don't. You worry about filmmaking now that I'm saddened by the way filmmaking is gone by the ownership of cinemas which he gets more and more concentrated the irony of the thing the where we're holding the screen to view cinema does not pay the London living wage that should not be and get if you want to put it in a cinema in the West End There's nature ways or not you can put up or you can't my home well I'm afraid they'd be an itsy pleaser that really they'd say great if we can get another American blockbuster in for next week maybe not in a position of strength what's next No I didn't. Order $83.00 now $83.00 Yes And well I think I think you know when you get sick and age you have to be like the football that's in and take each game as it comes really. That was Ken Loach talking to Iran said it's a welcome puts it 60 minutes to 9 drivers of electric cars could be given green number plates which would mean they could have free parking and other kinds of perks the new plants in the government follow schemes in Norway in Canada in a moment we'll get reaction from the r a c But 1st let's talk to Martin Norman he's senior climate and energy advisor at Greenpeace Norway Good morning good morning and how low if you had these green number plates also so that. We're talking about almost 20 years now since we 1st started and it started very small but of course has become a very big thing lately and what kind of incentives do these car owners with the green plates get. You know the good driving bus lanes they had free parking and free charging and and also electric cars do not pay Vietti or or any other road tax so they're quite cheap compared to other cars in Norway so what kind of difference would you say Did it make when people were deciding whether to buy an electric car or not. Well in the beginning I had a lot of things I clearly remember having an electric car 20 years ago and all my neighbors laughed at me and now they're all driving electric cars so so as a 1st step it was very important. But nowadays I think that even without the incentives I think Norwegians will would buy electric cars actually Well let's bring in Rod Dennis now from the r.a.c. Good morning good morning and we heard the way it works in Norway that these ideas from the government here are being put out to consultation What's your response well we're not massively impressed I think drivers don't seem to be particularly keen on these plans either the question is whether they really achieve what the government wants to achieve this is about getting more people into clean of a course switching out of petrol diesel vehicles and will the sight of a green number play in the possibility of free parking and driving a bus lane for leisure vehicles really drive up usage drive as we spoke see recently at the r.a.c. Didn't seem too impressed that seems quite an incentive there to be able to go in bus lanes or get free parking particularly if you live in a busy area I think on the face of it yes in the short term PAP's it would encourage some people but clearly that's not something that's sustainable over time as we get more electric vehicles which we can see a huge explosion in Evey's in the course of the next couple of years clearly councils are going to have to end those incentives probably pretty much as soon as they bring them in because if we have electric vehicles clogging up our bus lanes taking free parking it does nothing for congestion in terms in city so yes in the short term it could make a difference but over the longer term there are incentives that drivers simply can get used to and I suppose most Norman people look at many considerations whether when they're deciding whether to go for an electric car or not a lot but in particular as the charging points the infrastructure. Yes definitely and that's been continuing is discussion here in Norway all over the country is the amount of charging station in the states and so you see that that is sort of the crucial point to get in place particularly countryside imagine yellow such solutions in Norway now almost 50 percent are on your cars our electric car we can see it even in big cities that they have problems we don't get enough tarting stations out and presumably road Dennis you would agree that having sufficient charging points is absolutely crucial when it comes to widespread adoption of electric vehicles Yabsley this is the thing about today's announcement you know in itself is not necessarily a bad thing but is it going to achieve what we want to achieve in this country get people into clean of a course quickly we much prefer the government looks at things like bring in the right financial incentives we talk about Norway They've been some really strong financial incentives that to get people out of petrol diesel cars and into electrics and that's the sort of thing we need to see the government taking seriously over here if we really want to change things quickly and I suppose am giving people green numberplates is is you know giving them praise in some ways but schemes in some countries say that the biggest gas guzzlers today actually have read number plates What do you think about that or something we could consider but you have to remember that the majority of people don't necessarily choose to have vehicles that emit more that might be the case for a small proportion population but for a lot of people they drive used petrol and diesel vehicles that's the case for the majority of the people in the majority of people in the u.k. And we don't think setting one driver against another is really the right way for people on side encourage them into clean of a cause and what do you think about that idea Martin Norman of having as scheme where cars which use the most petrol diesel are branded in some ways I think some French cities have already adopted an emissions based window sticker scheme using a range of 6 colors and so that you get a car the idea of the range going on. Well I think Carrot is a much better getting people to chase than a stick actually and they also have to agree with the former point here that electric cars is not going to solve anything I mean electric public transport is the one thing that is going to you know help the big cities with. Getting cleaner air and not necessarily on electric cars Ok we'll leave it there Martin Norman road Dennis thank you both very much indeed and now at 11 minutes to 9 and we're going to hear from Dominic because we work was going to be the next big thing from Silicon Valley that said a service office company apparently was going to change the way everybody worked well it hasn't turned out quite like that they could be at humbling end to its high hopes so Don what's going to happen well tomorrow morning we expect that we works one of its big backers an investment company called Softbank which is run out of Japan is going to take we work over it won't be a complete full stop to we work in its plans for world domination but just about we work you might remember was a service office company with Silicon Valley pixie dust sprinkled over in its biggest single occupier of office space in central London for example expanded all the way around the world and it was going to give big companies a new way to employ people there was a whole bunch of other stuff attached to it like we were with lots of stuff and it was going to float need a lot of money to to keep all this going it was going to float on one of the New York Stock Exchanges earlier this year at a valuation of $47000000000.00 Now she says and we've already seen $1000000000.00 Now tomorrow Softbank is expected to take over control of the company but the deal will value we work just $8000000000.00 So just in a couple of months the high hopes have come from a $50000000000.00 down devotion valuation down to about $8000000000.00 It's not clear what the future if we work will be soft bank is going to inject money into it so to be able to keep trading so I think we work will still be around but those giant hopes of this enormous valuation with public investors putting their money in behind this juggernaut of a company has now come to an end I suspect will keep running it and then look for a buyer. At some stage in the future it really is a morality tale for tack isn't it and wrote it up for him of had a few of these now because of the the big floats are becoming this year we've had a lift and a few others the ones that did get away like uber left have not gone very well so really be a lot of people saying that they were having a kind of a sick a dot com boom Number 2 maybe not quite as big a bust but reality finally is actually coming to some of the Silicon Valley valuations dominate many thanks. It is now 9 minutes to 9 here at Westminster people are all over wary proclaiming that this will be a big crunch day in the history of bricks and yet it might be for this reason does look set to back. For the very 1st time that of course does not mean that that will become law or indeed that we will leave on October 31st one here to explain the political editor of The Sun Tom Newton Dunn and the chief leader writer at The Observer. Should we pause just for a 2nd and say according to the. M.p. Vote score there is going to be a majority for Boris Johnson's deal at least we expect on the 1st vote Well I think this is a significant moment you're right Nic when we look at to resume a this is something that she tried to do 3 times with parliament get support for back city you know she couldn't get it 3 and this is Boris Johnson and she succeeded on the sort of 2nd attempt so it is significant we shouldn't get too carried away there and the reason for that is that once the legislation gets published which it did last night there's a lot of detail for a 3 that's when it might all start to fall apart and we've already had a few signals about what some of the flashpoint in that legislation might be so it's a significant moment there is momentum that it certainly means that the government when there are problems with the legislation over the coming week perhaps longer if parliament votes against the program mation the timetable the government will be able to say to M.P.'s but they still in principle and that there is a momentum that comes with that but long way off this getting 3 parliament Yeah how significant do you think that sort of moral victory if you like would be the political victory will allow papers like yours the sun and others to say look you said he wouldn't get to do. And he did and now parliament is given at least majority backing what occasion to just get on with it went yeah it is a big moment and it's a significant progress since where to resume a was and I think it's happened because there has been a shift in mentality not just across the nation but in Parliament there is a resolution now to keep on saying get this thing done the devil is of course hugely in the detail and your papers a double page spread the sun today breakfasting sion or a Bentley now you still think is it puts on the front page of a revel rebels I'm sorry a plotting and might succeed in holding that you know and look this is all about numbers this is always all been about numbers went through way the Tories majority in 2017 the game has been number one rule of politics l.b.j. Learned how to count so what we think is going to happen today is there is going to be a majority to defeat the program motion which is the timetabling vote after the 2nd reading off the person gets his great Pyrrhic victory of getting a deal through the 1st hurdle we think the timetable is going to fall the 3 days he's going to use to rush this through is going to collapse and what's interesting is there's a whole of different reasons why people are going to vote to collapse and some people a general interest in scrutiny some M.P.'s want to do the right thing and spend more time on this others are going to use is a recognition except for the other one rule it is the the personal animosity towards Boris Johnson is quite fascinating because although he has won the Tory leadership he's won his new deal he's got rid of the backstop there are a good 2030 Tory M.P.'s who do hate his guts some he defeated in the Tory leadership and some just don't want to see him get his picture of October 31st there are always better versions of it not just people's own who want to stop Boris Johnson succeeding at least for a matter of days or weeks but rivalries amongst the opposition parties that they want to let the other party over there remain a vote on the pro referendum vote and so on. Absolutely and we've seen that play out in recent weeks there's been a lot of squabbling among the opposition parties about tactics when should we go for a vote of no confidence should we go for a referendum fester a general election for us there is certainly divisions within the opposition but there were also I think big issues of principle in this bill and this is why it's going to get difficult for Boris Johnson he's trying to hold together a tight coalition you know the numbers are very tight as Tom just said it includes a hard year a skeptics in his party who are going to be unhappy for example about the fact that European law continues to apply in the u.k. During the transition and he's also a Labor M.P.'s he's hoping to count as part of that coalition now there on any guarantees about workers' rights and he found guarantees about workers' rights in the text of the legislation so it's going to be more and more difficult I think as the bill gets examined to hold that coalition of M.P.'s together now we see on the front page of The Telegraph today the briefing the latest briefing from number 10 which is a version of If we don't get we will take our Butterball who effectively say if this bill gets amended we'll just scrap the bill and have an elections that a credible threat no I don't think so there are several things that could happen I remember that he could they could lose the timetabling vote which means they'll have to come up with a new timetable which almost certainly means we'll miss October 31st and we'll have to get what's called a tech who extension or the truth is there is only one type of extension and that's taking the longer so there's losing on some of the points of the play that the rules of the game but then there's losing on substance so if a substantial amendment passes a customs union or a 2nd referendum that I do think that would consider beyond the pale something that couldn't be sorted out by a few weeks of extension and then he would pull the bill and try and force a general election but he's tried to force an election before and the opposition parties with that have to make their minds up do they really want warm are they worried about looking nervous of an election or do they want to approach the. For him watching the clock take day by day as he's missed his deadline that's that's right and that's very much been the thrust let's just keep Boris Johnson a hostage in Downing Street and make him look increasingly uncomfortable the thing is fair labor is that they always said that they would move to a general election as soon as an extension has been agreed with the so I think they probably will still continue to try to resist for a bit perhaps until the new year but it becomes more and more difficult for them you know they had a principled reason for wanting to wait for general election if an extension is being got but that principle reason disappears so it becomes trickier and trickier for them to articulate this argument and I think Boris Johnson's argument well you don't want this well come on I'm game for a general election are you scared of a to start a bit more I think yes and Brazil's I'm a feel that having proved people wrong about his ability to get a deal that missing a deadline by a week or 2 isn't that serious I suppose the difficult question is Will Sun readers and those are the people who needs to get off and will some readers by that I think they can live with the what the nation is yearning for does appear is to come to some resolution if that happens in a couple of days later that's going to be a problem the issue will become not in the timetabling and the process of all this but if Brussels and he's constructed an incredibly tight majority it's failed previous promises of 3 years he's got a tiny way for the majority Secondly part of the way if he has to give ground on one side of the for example to rural Stude he wants control over transition control over future trade agreements then that upsets the pants of the e r g The hardcore your sketches they say oh hang on a minute we're not allowing that and all of a sudden it starts to crumble so noisy prediction in 5 seconds does he get his deal by October 31st No not quite does he get. By the end of the year potentially yes there we are nice and quiet sort of the observer top of the sun a good morning from a very chilly day Westminster That's all from us to Ed is this day when a man wearing and Tom Smith art. B.b.c. News at 9 o'clock many M.P.'s have reacted angrily to the government's plans to rush its bricks that legislation through Parliament a vote will be held later today on a proposal to speed the withdrawal agreement bill through all its common stages by Thursday night if M.P.'s reject the timetable Boris Johnson will struggle to get his deal approved in time for Britain to leave the e.u. By the end of the month speaking on today the housing secretary Robert general denied that the bill was being forced through without proper scrutiny we've been discussing this for 3 and a half years the House of Commons I believe had 500 hours of debate on brags that many of the issues in this bill of course are very familiar to M.P.'s because they've been known for a long time that they are in to resume a deal such as the provisions on the e.u. Citizens living within the u.k. The European Council president Donald told m e P's and Strasburg that he was consulting e.u. Leaders about Britain's request for a possible.