Question got to know our neighborhood people we understand their interests and demographics i want to speak in support of adus it is a reasonable effective and quick solution to some of our worst problems most importantly the affordability in the City District 3, of course, enincumbrance a lot of possibles polk street 19 and is home to the citys vulnerable populations that are negatively impacted by the affordable problem and adus can help to ease the stress in addition one the most densely Populated Areas in the city and 11th hour objections to the adus that we have learned about are really kind of spurus given the car over is low in the region and the needs for parking is not urgent as the need for housing see but also sorry im losing my yep and okay. Back track the adus have been successfully implemented in other cities theres would be minimum negative impact and also, we really care about the city thriving and not having to play catch up like nashville who are moving quickly to grow their cities okay. Im sure im leaving something out you get the gist i hope the Planning Department seize this as very positive step forward. Thank you. Good afternoon. Im paul webb a resident of district 3 and im here today on behalf of Telegraph Hill dwellers we have only one issue about the program that is although the legislation was filed in early june we found out about it last monday and the only action weve taken to date so send a letter copies im san bruno to the commissioners asking the matter be taken off calendar there be Public Outreach and that at a point if the supervisors want to come back with presentations with the benefit of Public Outreach the only one excluded that was no outreach in district 3 i cant speak for district 8 so as i say im not here to comment on the concept it is okay. But here to request it go off calendar be returned to the people with the outreach from the districts thanks very much thank you. Good afternoon, commissioners rob pool that the Housing Action coalition speaking on behalf of hundred and 70 members that cant be here its exciting we got meantime on adus we have a adus handbook and were trying to expand the program were in the middle of a severe housing crisis it make sense a much cheaper types of housing to be built and more affordable low impact on the environment weve seen it done in seattle that is kind of going to the same thing and they embrace them it is time to expand to other neighborhoods it is exist to see district 8 to embrace it and hopefully district 3 and keep that going were not supportive for a continuance of district 3 we know this concept works and adus are good for San Francisco different variety of housing for San Francisco thank you. Thank you. Edward mason i basically oppose this housing is a city responsibility not not district please resolve the airbnb issue for housing that turns our neighborhoods into hotels the cumulative effect is not considered growth should Fund Infrastructure growth and the market rate establishes the reversal for the rentals and the parking impact Plan Development areas p are in process the Treasure Island and ooermdz were trying to shoot more additional unit please resolve the airbnb there is no guarantee this unit will not become an airbnb the cumulative effect is not considered in one square block of 24th street and Church Street light 17 units that have been shoed into the neighborhood that is done with variance and the 0 response they can take the 48 of the j line the point is that growth should Fund Infrastructure growth their Transportation Sustainability fee program is already too years behind schedule there wont be new funding for muni muni it planning to add additional fees and what do they do we need another 500 million bond the growth should fund the growth necessary for this now the Transportation Sustainability fee only applies to greater than 20 units u units that augment to apply to everybody paying the freight for the Infrastructure Requirements now the market rate is going to establish what the rent control floor is going intoxicate on the initial rent charged noah valley that is 15 percent of the bus activity in the city so will the south bay tech workers occupy the new units and when will the city reverse being a Bedroom Community for Silicon Valley i have no father in this community for the desire for the projections that are out there because in noah valley you know weve got 25 commuter buses an hour going up and down 24th street street and parking you are going to remove the Parking Spaces anticipate have to plant a tree regarding this and noah valley families rely on the automobile for the children to school thank you. Will or while the next speaker comes up Richard Allen. Good afternoon, commissioners lisa president of the liability Hill Association that encompass district 8 and 9 but district 89 i want to reiterate what mr. Web from will Telegraph Hill said we got in notice the first time was today so theres been no outreach whatsoever in district 8 ill reiterate his suggestion that you take this avenue of calendar until we get a handle on whats going on and discuss that amongst the residents and then come back when we can have sufficient input thank you. Thank you, commissioners my name is Richard Allen the housing in district 3 and other places it really much worse when i sit down on the park and the coffee shop they buy a newspaper they dont look for the news he look at the rentals and jobs now i urge you pass the in law apartment and make that legal to the owner gets the rent and the renters have a unit that they are safe, you know fire and health twice is a winwin and the city will collect some taxes and relieve the people that have to move to oakland or elsewhere it is the way it should be done taking care of our laborers i urge you to pass this in law apartments thank you. Indulge commissioners my name is Tracey Tilly Chang my family and i have gone through hell in the past two years we were sued by your tenants on renting the illegal units we had to spend 30000 on the lawyers fee our tenant were rent scams that tried to imitate and scare my family and damage my property in order to make us pay them ransom on lawsuit settlement and the increased fee lukely we paralyzed but had to demolish the legal unit and never rent those spaces out again from the adu law was in place and we were able to get a legal unit in the ground floor space before we rent it out the rent scammer wouldnt have come to sue us and we can still provide affordable and nice unit for many renters to come so i support the adu law thank you. Can you speak into the microphone thank you. Thank you i support adu law thank you. My name is alex i support the adu law this is the most important revision and modification of the proposal passes and not in 1978 in 1978 San Francisco passed something quote and regulate each district for rh1 and rh2 and rh3 and 3 zoneat a time and increased the jobs so the will not apply in the modern day the adu is the best way to help this and help the people to find a place they can afford to live in the low income and middleincome people i know that San Francisco right now you cant rent an apartment for less than 3,000 for 3 plus bedrooms the landlord is resistant to refuse to rent because the tenants power is so much right now i urge you to pass the ab law and make the law and to build more houses for the protecting and middleincome people thank you. Hi, im laura with grow sf a pro Housing Organization well to urge you strongly to pass the ab legislation throughout the city it is vital the only way to increase the Affordable Housing in the city rent controlled users dispersed throughout the city we really need it were in a housing crisis i urge you guys to think that the fact it is happening at 3 oclock on a thursday all the people that cant be here they work to please beg you for more rent control housing in the city thank you very much. Good afternoon, commissioners my name is jessie i rented out a legal unit it was scary i couldnt collect the rent well not rent it out again, if any inlaw unit waltz legal i wouldnt have been show much trouble i support this adu law thank you. My name is lee im a landlord for San Francisco and we always have an issue with the limit in San Francisco and also airbnb has had increases with the job displacement and more San Francisco residents no families forced to leave the city so please increase our belief there is good landlords like me wanted to rent a house with allow price to a family. Yes. I support the adu. Hi, good morning all the commissioners and the supervisors im here to support the audi although im not living in the district 3 or district 8 im living in district one but this impact can solve San Francisco short housing thank you all of you and supervisors. Good afternoon, commissioners rose hill son i have nothing to say about specific district 3 or 8 after hearing all those people some people didnt get notification as far as process if people dont get notification and not here they may have a job or not know i didnt know much until gave me a call i didnt come down here to talk about that but having everything vested prior to be agendized maybe there were certain groups that were communicated but as part of Public Participation i think all the district need to be involved im getting a funny feeling is not just district 3 and 8 but citywide more input it needed the previous speaker said people dont drive or own cars thats true but they can get the car share im wondering if a study is done the potential of cars i didnt say i didnt see a process. Hello commissioners thanks for having us im with the association of realtor we represent realtor we are here to speak that on support of this legislation weve been tracking this legislation for many months it was drought to our attention in district 3 and 8 who heard about this version theyve not seen the outreach but we deeply support this legislation and building that should be recommended by the Planning Commission we talked about the housing balance and the number of rental uni on the market the only opportunity to have on our agenda the number of rent controlled unit in the city when we look at cost effectiveness the cost to add a adu unit is fractional compared to Housing Units in the city this is complicated to address the deep housing crisis this represents a solution that provides incentives for rent controlled units we hope youll support this today. Good afternoon, commissioners im a building manager of an older 20 unit Apartment Building in district 3 in my Apartment Building 4 large storage room that has been vacant for decades ill be able to convert into two dwelling units and in addition because in my neighborhood there are less cars i have two garages that have been vacant for a year which again, i convert into a dwelling unit in a 20 unit building i can add 3 units without expanding my building envelope i urge you to pass this pending ordinance thank you. My name is jose 10 president of the bed policy. Org one thousand mileperhour in district 3 and 8 are existed to hear about this when we read it over the Chinese Press on one hand people live in illegal unit adu our threequarters membership legally privately secretly rent out their space to afford a house theyve been sued or going through the trauma of renter unit people have heard the Horror Stories thousands of people have long up the space and leave them as storage forever adus allows everyone to have a fresh start creating for housing without a negative impact protects the Property Owners to provide affordable and safe and nice new units to candlelight the housing crisis please support the legislation thank you. Sue hester i think you need a little bit more information im not opposed to this legislation in concept but how is the city going to reaccess properties and where are they going to reassess im an economic i live in the real world theres enormous value other than the Property Owners the career our is not notified of tax i ask you to get the City Attorney to tell you where in the legislation exactly the assessor is notified when you add additional unit after the purchase of property the value goes up the value wont be recorded on city records certain legalization are exempt from the increased operational it needs to be explicitly in here the city explicit do a good job right now secondarilyly the Environmental Review came yesterday at 2 oclock but only half the pages it was the because i told them they sent the second half of the Environmental Review every other page came at 9 oclock this morning have you read it i was looking at the Environmental Review last time last night trying to see how it talked about district 8 thats been rezoned in recent history eastern neighborhoods andand market octavia the Environmental Review was not in existence and secondly people will have been trying to get the legislation ive been knocking on doors trying to get the legislation if varies people i got it a week ago and where is the amounted to the Housing Element came really late you need to ban shortterm rentals where is it in here if you dont band them where is the incentive for a owner not to get as much money i want to building is rent control equals affordability if didnt once a unit is vacant they can charge anything the traffic will bear and hidden units are ideal candidates for airbnb and shortterm rentals get those questions answered this is a big protective step please ask questions oh this is the boundary boundaries that are effected ill pass them in so if you see a political boundary not a regular bound. Is there any additional Public Comment. Okay. Not seeing any more Public Comment is closed. And commissioner antonini. I think this is excellent legislation and asking a few questions he assume this was notice as any other issue we have theres been some comments about the noticing being inadequate. Correct all ordinances are to be noticed 20 days prior to be heard and agendized on the parklet agenda. Certain people have had no problems hearing about this and others have with exception of a couple of comments i did not hear anyone with a valid noticing i will ask staff there will be a way ill assume in the unit is added legalized it will count as a unit ill expect to be forward to the assessor and there will be tax on that unit. Thats mite my assumption i forwarded that to the commission so i assume adding a unit and thats something is more the maker of the motion as it goes forward to the board of supervisors make sure the city gets the revenue and also in regards to comments about shortterm rentals those units will be under the same lay any other units within the city whatever the laws in place refer to those you dont need to isolate a case for a policy thats the same throughout the city a few things that are good first of all districts 8 and 3 are probably among the density in the city along with district 5 and 9 their probability some of the density in the city and parts of 6 are dense but that make sense this be there and those things are affordable by design relatively low cost for the pertain to establish new units or build within the existing envelope no additional parking and also instances where owners of smaller situations where they maybe two or three United Building and able to add another unit to keep the owners in the city and in the unit because sometimes you know with the restrictions on the amount of rent you can be charged it becomes difficult for owners to generate enough income to keep the building theyll have another means of the revenue weve heard all of those particular in district 3 but also in 8 under rent control and also, because youre in the existing nephew you, you have no concerns with the historical issues because the building will not have exterior changes or minimal ones and the other thing that is very important as a lot of these units now exist sort of a in the shadows and not safe and healthy this will allow those units now become under the restrictions for health and safety but theyre not required its not requiring anyone to create the unit i favor the staff recommendation islam ill assume the supervisors supervisor wiener is okay with that id like to hear but i it sounds like