Okay morning everybody welcome to the board of supervisors Budget Finance Committee meeting meetings i should say this is wednesday, june 24, 2015, my name is supervisor farrell im joined by vice chair supervisor katie tang and supervisor norman yee i want to thank Jennifer Lowe and others for clovrg this and mrs. Clerk linda wong a rescheduled meeting for in wednesday as well as the recess meeting for monday, i want to welcome supervisor eric mar and the 905 recess meeting from monday so madam clerk it you would call were going to take care of a few things and back into recess the Fire Department. Yes. Mr. Chair item 5 ordinance amending the fire code to increase the fees forces Departments Services and making environmental finding. Okay. Thank you colleagues that is part of Fire Department we have the gentleman here. Good morning marsh here to speak on would item the first was approved last week this piece of legislation for changes to the San Francisco fire code with a minor fee for permits and inspections the increases is needed for the cost of recovering the fees for the department those fees are not raised for the last few years but we need 4 percentage to recover costs ill be happy to answer any questions. Seeing none that anybody wish to comment on item 5. Item 5, sir. 5 oh, i move 5, 5, 5 i got a okay anything else wish to comment on item 5 seeing none, Public Comment is closed colleagues id like to entertain a motion to accept this and send to the tots july meeting i make a motion. Motion by supervisor tang and seconded by supervisor mar well take that without objection. Okay. And were going to now go to our 905 recess meeting mr. Clerk well take a Public Comment on the housing bonds madam clerk teams one and two and providing for a special election on tuesday november 3rd for the purpose of submitting two voters a in dent not to exceed 250. 02 for the special election to be held in the city and county of San Francisco on tuesday november 3rd, 2015, for the purpose of submitting two voters the proposition for the bonds not to exceed 500 million. Thank you madam clerk members of the public those are the resolution weve talked about the two housing bonds the hope well have one moving forward but before we have a discussion we want to take Public Comment on items one and two anybody wish to comment on any of those items. Items one or two. Yes. I have a question about this meeting for a few seconds one the bonded in debtedness improvement we have a situation for Affordable Housing improvements and related costs necessary for our you are for going residential tenants under the code chapter 47 and the taxpayers to pay principle and interest on the bonds incorporating to make sure the code will make ignition bonds where the bonds requirement for an action and finding under the quality act for the bonds from enforcement if policy of planning code i spend the money 240 come a 00 for the financial plan. Is there anyone from the public that wishes to speak seeing none, Public Comment is closed colleagues at this point, were going to go into resolution on both meetings well have when we come back well take action on the dbi fee item from the 9 oclock meeting our two and three from the regular meeting and the housing bonds from the 905 good afternoon everyone at this point i will come back to our two meetings of the budget and finance committee at the San Francisco board of supervisors. Were coming back from recess on our 9 am and 9 05 am from wednesday, june 24, 2014. My name is mark farrell. Im sharing this committee i also want to welcome back kitty tang as Wells Committee member Norman E Scott Wiener and eric mart and so colleagues, are now wrapping up our budget process this year. I want to thank everyone whos been involved in this process. Im extremely happy that once again we broken the timing record and coming to a budget this year that will be a consensus budget once again for 20152016 and 20162017. It is never an easy process. It is always easier said than done given our diversity of opinions and perspectives here at the board of supervisors, but were very proud working together once again with natalie members of the board of supervisors but members of the community. All the Department Heads and the staff to get this done. I want to thank in particular, my Committee Members for the past few months of work vice chair tang, supervisor mar yee. I want to thank the mayor for his budget that he committed to us on june 1. A budget approaching 9 billion for the first time in her citys history, and something that i believe just so many concerns did a great job of addressing semigreat concerns we face here as a city from affordability, to Public Safety housing, expanded services of public works and Recreational Park. Funding for our schools and some any other priorities. Im particularly once again want to thank the mayors budget team, kate howard who does such an amazing job. Ms. Howard, thank you for your hard work. To your entire team, that is there supporting you at all times, i drove some you i see a lot of them back here. Thank you everyone for your hard work at either the long hours, weekends that nobody sees over the last few months, so thank you for all your hard work during the process. I will say, i guess ive only been budget that you chair in my time but i couldnt imagine a better team to work with on the mayors so thank you to all of you and thank you ms. Howard for your partnership in this. In terms of our committee work, we could tactic is to get rid hearings around themes with the Recreational Park or families or affordability and Public Safety. I think we were able to do a lot in those hearings and bring up some of the concerns that we had as a board and hear from a community as well. I want to thank all the people i work so hard with us at the board of supervisors on this budget as in every year. First of all, to a Controllers Office , ben rosenfield, thank you, ben. Todd is right there, michelle, lisa is there to your entire team, both you that are here your administration and supports up everyone that is back upstairs, thank you so much good to her budget and legislative analyst, mr. Rose, 41st year of the citys budget, i believe . To mr. Rose to dan, your entire team has been here working for the department, thank you for all your hard work. You get a great job again this year and we simply cannot do without a view, the board of supervisors. So, thank you. The City Attorney john giving her thank you mr. Given her for all your hard work it to our Committee Clerk window long, thank you for all of your long hours here. I think victor young, to them for spelling you to the times and other members of the clerk staff i know rick to john prebudget website accept the tv sfgtv file be stated since early to our Department Heads and their staff for the time they took to it with a budget analyst to work through their budgets into their commitment only two working varsity but in this process in terms of the package that weve come up with, from my perspective its historic on a few fronts. First of all, Record Number of actual dollars that were bringing back to the budget over 66 million in this twoyear budget cycle, for the first time. In particular, when excited about is the highlight of the 25 million of Affordable Housing there were going to be adding to the budget this year. It will finance the Housing Trust fund as weve done in years past, and were going to be able to not only in year two, but hopefully anyone increase Affordable Housing as we face the affordability crisis that we face as a city today. In terms of other savings and highlights from oliver for my perspective we have over 3 million dedicated to increase funds for Homeless Housing here in the city of San Francisco for families in particular, seniors, single adults in youth. Over 1 million for increased for Food Security. Including, get lunch bills for seniors, Home Delivery groceries, over two halfmillion dollars for childcare and Family Services in over 2 million for Workforce Development programs here in the city of San Francisco. Not to mention, the additional funds on top of what the mayor put into the budget around Public Safety, mission zero, funds for different communities such as seniors, lgbt and traditional transitional age youth and around our Recreational Park system. I do want to thank lastly, i staff, to catherine who who just who helped out quite a bit in the budget process. To michael, thank you for all your hard work. To the staff not only my Committee Members but everywhere the board of supervisors, you do a lion share of the work hearing and your out so thank you all for all your hard work. We cant get this done without you. Ultimately, for my perspective is a budget we can all be very very proud of how i think everyone for the hard work. Its been an honor to be the budget and finance chair. Once again for a third year in a row now. Ill see the challenges never get old, but its something that every year we can be excited about and very proud of what we will, should this year. So, colleagues will open up any comments and once we get past comments, we will go to those we refute administrator rate admission of items to knockout the next, supervisor meter. Thank you very much mr. Chairman. Should chairman, if i may, i want to thank you and congratulate you for really phenomenal work. Its not your third year as budget chair or member your first year when he told me that he had done earlier and will graduate smoothly, and i completely dismissed your prediction. You are right. Every year you chair this committee the process has gone smoothly and we got out earlier than we would have normally got out. I think its because of you and your staff and really superbly managing the process. The appellee before that, if you ever decide that politics isnt for you i think being an mediator is probably your next gig because you do a great job, i think, being an arbiter for all parties involved. So, thank you. I also want to thank my staff. Jeff green, adam taylor and particularly, ms. Howard for really doing a great job on our and for budget priorities. Im really excited. When we look at what funds some which no longer gets any press because over the last number of years with the mayor and board working together medical director of the job making certain priorities associates are pretty boring and basic part of the budget. Lets not forget, for now i think the third year in a row we are fully funding street resurfacing out of the general fund, the mayor has proposed that each year. We have, i never cut up any, from that amount. I think anyone remembers a time when the mayor and the board ever funded fully funded, will resurfacing out of the general fund, and we are doing that yet again. We continue to fully fund hiv services, including backfilling every penny of federal cuts for the sixth or seventh year in a row. We are accelerating Police Hiring by finding a Police Academy classes over the next two years. I want to thank the mayor mayor for his leadership on that funding and the sport for supporting it. Once again, were increasing support for nutrition access for our most vulnerable residents and making sure that no one in San Francisco goes hungry. We have increased our investment in transit because of the support in this building but also because of the generosity of voters and adjusting the mcas baseline for public transportation. I work very hard to secure funding in the budget for youth and senior programs, particularly at risk youth in my district. If too many youth who are homeless or at risk of being homeless in the upper market area. Every year that is a priority for me to support services for those youth and weve done so again. I am also thrilled that we were able through this budget, to implement several recommendations of the lgbt aging force. We went passing legislation as recommended by the task force, but their budget needs as well. We are able to secure funding in the budget for lgbt seniors at risk of isolation and to finally start addressing the specific needs of lgbt seniors suffering from dementia. We also were able to find funding to complete the funding for the future no valley town square. This project will proceed up later this year and i look forward to seeing everyone at the opening next year. Finally, colleagues, i want to note, we talked about this in more detail with respect to item number four, we are creating a Code Enforcement reserve fund at the department of building inspections. We do not do nearly enough Code Enforcement and the city with respect for Building Code and housing could. Too many people in the city i live in conditions that no one should have to live in. So, we are creating a fund of nearly 4 million bill be dedicated to Code Enforcement. Im very very excited about that. So, colleagues, again, thank you. Thank you to the controller and the Budget Office and to everyone once again has allowed this to be a successful budget. Supervisor tang i do want to echo all the thanksgiving earlier to everyone who worked so hard on this process. Especially chairman ferrell mac. I didnt do it my share of budget processes whether through the Mayors Office side to stopping my predecessor on the committee as well and i feel like every urges become more and more refined to the fact that were here at before 3 00 pm talking about this. So thank you for that. I definitely do want to thank the Mayors Office because i think that this is one of those years ive noticed a lot was really taken care of at that mayors during his budget submission on june 1. In some sense, made our work easier in some and made it harder. Because now were at this phase were scrambled to figure out what else do we want to put back into the budget. So, i want to thank the Mayors Office, his old team. All the city determines work hard to identify what were the priorities to make sure we can find are Critical City Services here. I know that in looking at her at pax list here before us today are so many neighborhood and citywide priorities there were able to come to agreement on. Finding, making sure were putting our Childrens Services services for seniors the homeless, to serve our immigrant community. Community based programs and even augmenting some of the Department Services that were potentially going to be cut off from the budget. So, i can want to thank all our City Department because we are here trying to fight for dollars but youre the ones working very hard to actually help us carry out all that work. Then, of course, i know there are a number of Community Advocates and stakeholders here today who have year after year after year made sure that you hold us accountable to make sure that were funding again the critical services, but some of our most vulnerable populations need from our city. So, again, thank you to the Budget Committee to chairman fontenot for making a smooth process and i look forward to approving all this and for final approval i guess on august 1. Thank you. Supervisor yee i went thank you for your leadership on this committee. This my first year serving on this committee and its been really a privilege to see you work and see the magic you done the last few years. I also want to thank my colleagues in the rest of the people on the committees. I also especially want to thank my colleagues and the staff that stayed last night to not quite midnight, but close, and they were running around the halls and try to get this thing done them. They eventually got it done. Of course, i also want to join the chorus here to thank kate howard and her staff and then rosen, and his step. Harvey rosen and his step. Without them, this process would have been very difficult. It just this partnership we have between legislative branch and the people that actually do the real work that makes things functional in San Francisco. Its one point first to note its been a good budget year, and its our opportunity to do some, carve out some funnies for new initiatives as much as possible. Maybe even refine some of things that we cut in previous years. Theres many things that the balance in the city. As much as we grew our budget, there is always there is never enough funding to do everything you want to do. So, thats where we step in and try to make these type of decisions with the mayor to say, well, given what we have, given the additional funding, which should we do with it. I think what we did this year was strike of real good balance between all the different elements and everybody seen him whether its about the pedestrian safety, signing for vision zero that was added in. Many items that funded Childrens Services, whether its the fully funding of the afterschool programs, or the summer programs. And then the Early Education piece, again it wasnt exactly the amount that one would want but asking for more than we could give. I think we could do each of the categories seem to have got their fair share. Whether its the Senior Services homeless issues and i think its never a big winner for me but maybe it is. We been talking about it for the last two years in regards to housing and will say more about it, but it seems like a big winner in here for this year, and try to catch up for many years is housing. So, its been an issue for all things at all income levels and we need to start addressing it and i think this budget really does that. So i want to thank everyone for their efforts. Supervisor mar thank you chairman fontenot. I didnt think it could get done and i just have to say that its been a team effort but especially with our pitcher, quarterback, chairman fontenot you did a great job and your staff, catherine and justin simi folks from your staff really were transparent. I know sometimes you couldnt get stuff printed out as fast as we wanted it with the controller and the mayors Budget Office, but i do feel that you are extremely transparent. I do want to say that the Budget Justice Coalition and many different organizations that were, up until the very last minute today, but also until midnight last night, in the halls, i want to thank him for keeping the the focus on human needs in our community could i think theres a lot of contradictions in his nine the focus on human needs in our community could i think theres a lot of contradictions in his 9 million budget. I think the contradiction of Unchecked Development purses displacement and addictions, and the goal of equity and social Justice Committee of the coalitions were really focused on. So i thank them for keeping my office focused on that. I also want to say that, just think kate howard, ben rosenfield, harvey and his team and so many others for helping us through this process. As my colleagues have acknowledged different pieces that they worked hard on, i wanted sega Food Security task force were really great. I feel positively didnt get everything that we wanted, but the large amount for the congregate meals of seniors eating together instead of an isolated situation, the home delivered groceries and home delivered meals, poor seniors safe streets for seniors and senior meals but also money for decrease staffing and aging with Disability Resource Centers will go a long way for the vulnerable in our communities. I want to thank pres. Breed are working with my office up with a lot of arts organizations and artists that arts equity was built into a lot of district budgets but also on a citywide level is what struggling and potentially displaced arts communities within our city. I want to say that years ago when i start on the board goes across is called the peoples budget on and i think what jenny freedom box and my brother gordon mar put together with Justice Coalition with some of the labor groups insured we did not last minute fake items that people were trying to work together. Though there was still big gap last night, but many of the Human Service organizations and special Justice Groups work hard to whittle down their different suggestions. Im hoping we have more revenue coming to this city and this board in the future, so that a lot of the priorities that were left off the list could be considered at some point, but i want to thank those coalitions for working together from the beginning to the end as well. Lastly, i think we dont have a budget thats going to solve housing and homelessness and transitional age youth and families but its a good start am very proud of the work that nick for my staff who spearheaded our work and racquel and formally here we did a lot of work with my office on the budget but i want to say, for district 1, the richmond district, i feel that we have a lot of great things within our budget for our communities but also citywide as well. So thanks to everyone and looking forward to proving this budget unanimously. Thank you. Supervisor kim i just wanted to know all the thank yous are regarding inmate. To the Mayors Office, controller, cla, and of course all the witnessing of staffers that work in each of our office to make this a reality every year. I also want to recognize the Many Community groups that campout at city hall on our marble floors on my good im sure we understand what the budgetary needs are, and really help us refine the cost as we continue to negotiate through the budget hours. Under the budget Budget Justice Coalition past the traditional age youth coalition, are transgender community, and many of our immigrant rights advocates were here last night along with their Supportive Housing folks in my office, i do want to recognize april august to gaming at the end to the budget cycle. Most important, ivy league who spent the last several months starting early, working on what our budget requests were coming from district 6 and how to prioritize that by meeting with Community Stakeholders through the last couple of months. First, i want to recognize the mayor for funding a number of things that are important to our office. When of course, the minimum wage increase which started on mayday, may 1 12. 25. Those increases that have been impacted by the city were included by the budget along with dollars for minimum wage enforcement which is just as important as passing a new minimum wage. What do think the mayor also for including the cost of doing business increase for a nonprofit workers. Putting them in line with what we see in our forprofit contract. I also want to thank his office for funding three of our district 6 initiatives. One that weve been working on the department of Public Health for the last two years, funny nurses and our adult homeless shelter system. We start with to. We will expand our residents that live in our streets are finally going to get the care that they need and are shelter system. Even larger than that, were excited about the 6. 69 to finally find a 24 hour expanded medical respite shelter which will fully staffed by nurses, clinicians, and psychologists and will actually be a place Homeless Outreach teams workers will be able to bring our sick residents off the street. Finally, an Initiative Initiative started in july initially dubbed the tenderloin pitstop, so that we can actually have a place for individuals to relieve themselves with dignity instead of on our streets. The program thats been incredibly successful in the tenderloin on loan using a 60 decrease in steam cleaning request. This enabled that used to have number one complaint for human feces on our sidewalk. Along with that, on a side note we been saving over 2000 gallons of water every month from these reductions of steam clean request. Not only is unable it cleaner, a residents have a place to go with dignity were also saving water in this time of drought. In the budget, in the board of several supervisors technical adjustments, i am happy to see our district will be supporting our immigrant communities and empowering them to develop leadership with the language and cultural specific organizing and outreach particularly in our latino arabic filipino and community. We also look forward to bringing those communities together so we can play together around tenant issues, Public Education and schools, and of course Public Safety issues. Along the lines of Public Safety, were happy to see funding to do a