And then i carry my groceries back and this way i am not having data about me put in a database because the only data the only personal data. That isnt just about you that isnt a threat to you is the data that hasnt been collected is a distraction to talk about protection of data in the databases because the real way to protect your privacy is make sure the data isnt collected about what you do or where you go or who you talk with or what you say to them. So were going to be talking all the progress whether people should be choosing between safety and privacy but let me just. Not a choice privacy is part of safety remember one of the biggest dangers these days is political safety safety for instance from governments that are repressive or thora tarion and cruel and if the more they know about what people are doing the more dangerous they are collecting data is part of their technique for repression and then there are the movements anti Truth Movement such as you can find many governments supporting and they benefit from Digital Systems to targeting a adds to people is dangerous and its based on knowing a lot of things about people well facebook doesnt know very much about me because ive never been a sucker. Ok you know i see your point about facebook but i still want to hear your opinion for instance about Something Like zoom or face time a lot of people around the globe where able to keep their jobs by communicating and doing meetings and brainstorming and just working once the all those. That they didnt use Free Software you know there is Free Software freedom respecting software is what that means i dont mean its gratis thats not the issue that society issue. But it. Is not a freedom respecting program it does what the company decides and the users can take it or leave it but unfortunately in especially since march many users have been put in a position where the option of leaving it means giving up their jobs why would you know i never used zoom i dont use non Free Software i dont the loud onto my computer if someone says to me id like you id like to speak with you but it has to be with zoom i say that is out of the question i suggest the following other program we could use a freedom respecting program thats controlled by the users not by some one powerful entity and if theyll accept that then i can talk with them but those that dont accept that i cant talk with and i declined because im protecting my freedom and my freedom is part of my safety. With what the record is turning the United States into i dont think people here will be very safe ok here is another question that concerns the Bigger Picture coming out of endemic so the partnership between corporations and the governments has grown and closer as a result of the common effort to keep things functional in abnormal times so when governments develop an Even Closer Partnership with lets say google right. And will use googles resources for Public Services will you stop using Public Services as well because i mean theyd be contaminated by the data no although it does cause me concern you know there are some reasons why governments need to know some things about people the government needs to know my income and your income in order to tax us properly now the u. S. Government doesnt try to operate fair taxation it taxes most people too much in rich people far too little but even if that were fixed government would still need to know how much money each 1. 00 is making and how much money each company is making if it is the government were to try to taxis companies properly it would need to know data so its not always wrong that the government gets data about people but each saying that it gets has to be justified in fact governments especially for their repression agencies are collecting a lot more data about people over and over weve seen the United States government and i presume the russian government collect data systematically on dissidents protestors and so on and its this is been happening for decades so the most Sensitive Data about you are where you go who you meet. And what you and the other people say to each other these are is a saying that must not be spied on and any systematic attempts to spy on them must be stopped so consider for instance clearview ai which has a Face Matching Service is collected photos of hundreds of millions of americans i think and then it will match photos you take a photo on the street. Itll match it another set next 2nd you take another photo suppose its a video camera its taking photos all the time and you could match every photo that shows up and the government could be doing this im sure some agencies are agencies that dont hold our freedom in very high esteem so this should be absolutely illegal people must be allowed of course to take photos from time to time you know suppose you watch agents of the state arresting somebody and cracking sticks over his head a well you should be able to make a video of that but to do this systematically. In lots of places all the time that has to be illegal because it will lead to is a society where no one can meet anybody else in private and we see what thats like we see it in on where the waiters are being oppressed in this complete fashion so fundamental freedoms are at stake when we limit the collection of data by Digital Systems and so no i dont think that those systems are helping people. Free Program Since the users dont control what it does youve got to assume its designed to do nasty things and in so many cases we have evidence specific evidence that the one free program is designed to do specific nancy things if you want to see hundreds of cases look at good new dot org slayer malware. Right now were. Talking with Richard StallmanDigital Privacy activism the founder of the Free Software talking about whether we should be choosing between safety and privacy statement. Is your media a reflection of reality. In a world transformed. What will make you feel safe from. The isolation community. Are you going the right way or are you being led. By the way. What is true was his fate. In the world corrupted you need to descend. To join us in the depths. Or a maybe in the shallows. Wall street financial engineers look up the krauts divert the money printing into their pockets at a rate that according to the Rand Corporation equals more than 50. 00 trillion dollars so that is your god thats why we have social unrest thats why we have incredible all wealth and income gap thats why we have such a distorted economy thats why wages are not keeping up thats why weve got inflation raging thats your smoking gun and the story. By social class. People. If youre born into a poor family if youre born into a minority family if youre born into a family that only has a single parent that really constrains your life chances people die on average 15 years. Generational poverty. By every day to meet your needs and the needs of your family. And were back with Richard StallmanDigital Privacy activist and the founder of the Free Software movement talking about the fact whether wish should be choosing between privacy and safety so richard there are calls for trust busting in washington aimed against a big tax in the most radical scenario do you think the tech giants should be broken up i mean how can this be done and want to damage the Digital Ecosystem will ready god in place. I dont see anything you know most of that Digital Ecosystem is unjust and id like to get rid of it and i dont use it so i have i dont think its doing any good i wont use it because the impositions are unacceptable the terms of service are often unjust controlling and i say no to them i never agree to such a thing without reading it you know and often it requires you to run a non free program and i wont ever run a non free program on my computer so there are websites i cant talk to and. We need to do more than just break up Close Companies im not convinced that you know breaking up the Largest Companies would reduce their power to that extent it would be a good thing and we need to do that in all fields in the past 20 years or so we have seen enormous consolidation of businesses in the us often there are just 2 main businesses in a field and those your choices and. I think we should amp up antitrust to the point where weve got 20 or 30 substantial businesses in each field if thats if theyre not that many its starting to be in all of gospelly and thats too much domination by business if we Want Companies like google and amazon and so on to stop collecting data about what people were doing. Just breaking up is not enough you know if we had 100. 00 Smaller Companies in place and each one collected data at each one contributed to the misuse of that date by several competing Ad Tech Companies it would still be unjust and the government could still collect all that data silently at any time with National Security letters so we wouldnt be safe either from targeted ads or from government tracking of dissidents so what we need is to prohibit designing systems so that they identify people and people do. New projects the operating system project i started in 1983. We have developed a program for anonymous payments called good new tollar now the payer is anonymous but the store that youre paying thats identified so taler cant be used for tax evasion that was one of its goals but you can pay for something and the store youre paying cant tell who you were so as long as the rest of the system also doesnt identify you and we need lost and new protocols to make sure it cant youll be able to buy something digitally anonymously and if you buy Something Else tomorrow it will be impossible to tell that you were the one who bought both but heres the funniest thing. It really seems like its only now during the corona time step people have become seriously aware and concerned about their Digital Privacy i mean its been there forever you could have thought of officer and there are people who thought of looking but not in masses and i wonder why havent we traded our personal data for a conference a long time ago and more inquiry in. Presence has increased times fold because of the pandemic isnt it too late to worry. What you mean we white woman i want. People privacy for conveniences. I have been rebuking people for this terribly foolish practice for decades. But i couldnt get people to listen to me. I went around saying this is an abomination you must stop and people mostly ignored me and some people understood my arguments you know im not tasking people to take this on face you can check points and recognize the validity of what im saying but the companies have engineered situations where the inconvenience of saying no for one person is so high that most people say no and its the fact that others are not saying no that keeps almost everybody in line you have to be willing to go against that pressure as i do and then you can say no so when they claim theyre not actually forcing you well literally speaking thats true youre not being forced to have a facebook account youre not being forced to have a google account youre not being forced to have a microsoft account all over you want to buy a new windows machine and log on it youre almost forced to have to make a microsoft account but you can say no to all of these things. But we need to make it easy for people to say no thats the reason why i developed the good new operating system because it was you know to say no to non Free Software in 1983 you had to have no computer well in 1983 most people had no computer but of course Computers Became more and more common and normal to own and but by then we had the good new plus Linux Operating System which made it not too to run a computer and say no to all that non Free Software thats the point making it easier to say no less of an inconvenience to say no so more. People will say no but since tooth since 2000 or so mobile computing has developed and its unjust from the very roots you cant install any free operating system on and on monster or on most Android Devices is just impossible the hardware is designed so that you cant so once you accept those devices there are a few Android Devices that are possible to liberate i should point out. But then you cant run the non free apps that people use to do most things with them so. Its going to be hard to reclaim freedom and were going to have to work at it but as people recognize from examples like john. What repression Digital Systems lead to i hope people will start fighting and saying we wont tolerate systems in our streets in our homes that cant possibly track what were doing who we talk with who we go see. We have to have laws against those systems. Heres another question of course when i start to think about my personal data being collected yes i dont like the fact and i understand that it can be used to manipulate my behavior and influence my opinions i know that and so it can be used yes absolutely and some thinkers that i spoke to during this uneasy times told me that they may be ok with their data being collected as long as they know for what do you think transparency could work here i mean wouldnt you be ok with giving your personal data if you knew exactly how it is going to be used. Well how could i know such a thing i could hear what somebody tells me its going to be used for how do i know that it wont in fact be used for other things thats a much harder problem in many cases i would accept the collection of certain data for certain purposes but i would always ask the question why should we trust you there are not very many governments i would trust to know things about me and trust them to use that data only for the good purposes that theyve stated because i know that so many governments are tracking people and trying to pretend theyre not and repressing some people. You know theres this comic con demick is actually only spitting out what we already have and that is that utilization of everything and in many for us as gas stations you cant even seal up a tank without a credit card anymore its hard to be in touch with people if youre not on ses and whats worse is you dont have an email so heres the question are we having into a reality where using Digital Technology would be sort of mandatory not by law but by a spirit of time. There is a danger of that of course i think its an exaggeration to call that digitalisation of quote everything unquote but certainly many things and enough to make it dangerous and i call for the laws against that i dont think it should be lawful for a gas station not to accept cash i dont think it should be lawful for a food store or restaurant not to accept cash so you know you know what youre talking about basically is the reversal of the trend absolutely if the trend is dangerous we must reverse it but how can it be done on praxis now that everyone sort of jumped on that and its going and we know how to stop it you know its so easy to look at how hard this task is and give up. But i succeeded it supposedly impossible tasks before when i started developing the new operating system some of my friends said oh yes this is what we need but its hopeless its too late the jobs too big i give up they didnt even try to help because they gave up fortunately some of my other friends and some strangers said yeah i want to help and we got it done thousands of us and it is possible therefore to reverse dangerous trends that there are a lot of dangerous trends in the world one of them is. Greenhouse gas emission you know if we dont reverse that trend and pretty damn fast then civilization may collapse under all the fires droughts crop failures floods diseases civil wars you know globalized manufacturing may not work anymore because a 6 a civil war over there and one place you dont normally think about prevents the production of food widgets and theres no way to make any any more for 2 years but and meanwhile during that time 5 other things cant be made and suppose no computers can be made and nobody knows how to live without computers so it could all crash but even bigger than that theres an even bigger trend that we also must defeat and that is putah corsi the tendency for the rich to control governments such that democracy is a sham now this is the situation in the United States a study determined that since the late ninetys Public Opinion no longer correlates with the federal Government Policies they seem to be determined entirely by 2 things what rich people want and what the special interests in any particular issue want well thats not democracy and thats why weve been unable to get things like a National Medical system a green new deal. And various other things that people almost all want but the politicians keep opposing and one other at one aspect of to talk or see is of course the influence of money in politics the ease of destroying a candidate with false rumors distraction campaigns. Theyre all tools of to talk recy you know. Some people worry that russia will manipulate the us election through facebook and twitter why im sure its trying to but im even more scared of the rich americans who are doing even more of that so. You know we have these horrible trends and we have to reverse them somehow and the paradox is the only reason its hard is because each of us thinks im alone what could i possibly do or even i in my 10 friends what could we possibly do. But if you try sometimes your effort grows and grows so you must try. Richard on that optimistic note i want to thank you for this wonderful chat that we had means you gave me a lock to ponder about and i hope that our viewers will also. Have something to think about and decisions to make up for this from you in this talk of our spank you so much and good luck with everything. Thank you very much. Cas calendar is dark alfonzo along during his darned this changing take changed hard served our. His 1st words were added i will see youre a challenging post youve got 2 years to live. I have no doubt that what happened was criminal. Offense concentrate market is a 1000000000. 00 industry these companies have a huge financial motivation to sow these problems there are numerous stocks showing that doctors were keen to chest x. Ray concentrates for insights of its own that Patients Want gives them doctors the wrong to play golf term the stuff why they would give me consecutive doses day. And people still die and im always question or so i tried being hard to live when so many have. Is your media a reflection of reality. In a world transformed. What will make you feel safe. Isolation for community. Are you going the right way or are you being led so. Direct. What is true what is faith. In a world corrupted you need to descend. To join us in the depths. Aura made in the shallowness. Seems wrong when old rules just dont call. Me. Yet to shape our disdain become educated and in games from it equals betrayal. When funny find themselves worlds apart we choose to look for common ground. So what weve got to do is identify the threats that we have its crazy for him to let it be an arms race in his own spearing Dramatic Development that only mostly im going to resist i dont see how that strategy will be successful very critical time time to sit down and talk. Parties Headline News a military plane crash lands on a highway in peace to new cry at least 22 people are dead 2 others are critically injured. Machete attack near the former paris headquarters of the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo is now being treated as a terror attack the incidence left 2 people injured and comes as the after the magazine recently republished controversial cartoons featuring the prophet muhammad. Also in france a new covert infection record with 16000 cases recorded in a single day but the latest restrictions on life designed to stop the virus are really spreading out. There well thats a good questions are raised over reports that volunteers in the u. K. Could soon be deliberately infected with