In the hood immunity Extinction Rebellions professor richard reid explains the u. K. Catastrophe with kobe the 19 plus the most lethal terror attack in u. K. History did britain conspire to cover up of a mole could be involving u. S. Intelligence libya and iran we told you so lets try more on more about winning an Appeals Court hearing what some call the worst miscarriage of justice in u. K. Legal history all of them all coming up in todays going underground fast lets go straight to hospital in modern up where were joined via skype by dr giovanni growled the Infectious Disease specialist was at the forefront of the italian fight against corona virus thank you so much giovanni for coming on what is the Current Situation in northern italy where your boy will of this equation is pretty odd because of course hundreds of people that go to. Try to cool it all of course of this is feasible weve got it. So a situation to try. Understand which kind of tree arch we need to do so that to 2 q. People that whole when possible and with. Just patients who got rescued after a distress and so of course its a difficult situation sometimes we ask the patient to step or line in couple of days they will come anyhow because they are getting worse their hospital a stoli change because of it i doubt that they will because at least emergency we had to change in this structure and so far in my hospital there is more than 100 beds just for positive cases waited near morning and we got to close all the zoo drew in order to a larger they tend to care unit where tori i need a daughter to take care of a younger population of course with regard to rape all the population this is not seasonal and we are trying to use non invasive procedure tory technique just get can i get on to the respiratory techniques here a few weeks ahead of us here in britain i understand or see over here were appealing in britain for manufacturers to come out with ventilators i understand the use of ventilators is something youve been particularly wary of you have to be careful clinically about the use of ventilators yes we need to up to 2 i did find a patient what got best opportunity to survive using their due date on that one but that will not because i experience is that whenever you need that information with mechanical ventilation but you seem beat it in later and actually this is need it for quite a long time and most of the time more than 2 weeks time i know of course that this is very difficult if you are old if youve got many cool b. T. S. Because it may happen that you die because other people were p. T. S. Rather than crowing about it a bit star particular kind of hasta the cool abilities because this disease produces a huge england nation burden and of course of this made people with high cut about sort of a risk of people you mention inflammation the National Health service here in britain has been criticized. Advising people to use ibuprofen and is it your understanding that its paracetamol youre supposed to be taking her to see that will like a group that is obvious and thank sought this kind of all and Group Laboratory drugs to do a lot of things to to not seems to work for coronavirus so actually what we are it you would say its a let me say it 2nd level and it plummet or it drugs which are all of the body but this is not going to do with this let me say calmly use under an arbitrary truckstop should not be yours that you can use and are suitable in order to go well if you but but also reminded most of the time its even coronavirus your morning is not that high and if anyone thinks that washing ones hands is a seems like an odd response all the Mathematical Modeling does show it will save millions of people from being infected yes of course if it did anything we grew up the birth to be very clear that didnt meet a root of transmission ease through droplet i do know that quoted droplet then most effective intervention is lost sheep hands 2nd is using mask this works theres no doubt the editor of the Peer Reviewed british medical journal the lancet says the response here in britain was wrong and that the outbreak has been entirely preventable what did you make of what you were hearing from britain when the chief scientific science advisor heres a Patrick Vallance who formerly worked at j. F. K. Said herd immunity is the path to go down we now know that entails the deaths of quarter of a 1000000 people if you are already in a situation in which its a cool muni acquired the only way that we need it to do is a tool up for conduct this is a general principle and its i just see this to our all white court act were getting reports of a lack of testing kits of protective again. For frontline medical stuff hit in london the epicenter of the pandemic in britain how can we learn from what happened in italy where thousands died about the need for testing which of course the World Health Organization has advised britain to get a move on with according to the level of it yannick you must concentrate on testing or rather just food to eat or quantity because they now isolation nowadays so be it i make this. High that actually we relied more on net symptoms rather than our test set also because we would never have become passive to test all the population regarding how to treat expression how to treat the toll that there is still cause that a difficulty in providing whole care providers to all they protective measures i would sell for any intensity in the intensive care unit we use of the same towards that the same im asked for one single chair 9 we use the surgery must on the top because we dont have it i predicted mastic to be changed every patient and many doctors especially the territory says that we had a normal ask for we cannot go to visit the patient at whole but of course and this is a biggie ship for us because otherwise all the patients we come too close to go out and we will not have the capacity to treat them all ok just finally in very briefly obviously a lot of repercussions of that of investment in the italian Health Service and Health Services across the European Union have that you had any cases of those who have been infected by covert 1000 who have recovered from covert 1000 and then have been reinfected not so far nevertheless and there is a lot of uncertainty about how much is protected they even junichi provided by 1st grown up iris to take ships because of their product we are just testing if the virus is present we are not testing which antibodies are predictable or with cellular immunity is protected but lots of research ease ongoing. And the course of this will be crucial as soon as it will be available in order to pass the level of protection that will be provided by but its crucial to dog how much we will be able to buy absolutely it local a should and to what extent that the spots will be in order to avoid this. Huge will to be a suitable disease like employment for giovanni growled a thank you might wish well while the Global Pandemic may threaten millions it is billions who are threatened by another catastrophe arguably not being properly prepared for by earth richest nations joining me now is Extinction Rebellions dr richard reid rupert welcome back to going underground youre not directly for Extinction Rebellion here youre wearing a hat and i get demick hat and before we even start when it comes to this crisis youve effectively been criticizing the same of the b. B. C. Coverage of the Boris Johnson administrations response presuming it is Public Information is going to be vital in this crisis absolutely the government has not been publicizing its models they are now emerging very late in the day thats not acceptable we need full transparency we need a lot more information about corona virus than we have because were hardly doing any testing in this country similarly in the United States the numbers that we have on the pandemic theyre all massive underestimate because of the incredibly low number of tests and because so many people who have coronavirus are asymptomatic for quite a while while they have and while theyre infectious to which the volunteers. Chief scientific advisor subject valens will say well you dont know that because we havent had the testing and this is just an academic competition when people like the editor of the lancet making extraordinary claims that somehow this was entirely preventable because of the herd immunity response look we know for sure that the numbers are a hell of a lot higher than the official numbers mean. I know exactly what they are but we know there are a lot higher now in terms of the province ability of this Richard Horton the editor of the lancet is exactly correct many scientists have been mourning for some time and i come at this from the perspective of the precautionary principle the idea that when we dont know something we want to protect ourselves against what we dont know in the case of this emergency this virus its unprecedented we dont know what effects it has we dont know for example whether it might have neurological effects where that might leave permanent lung damage we dont know a great deal about how its transmitted yet were gradually finding out but theres a lot we dont know ok but hellbent on the living to let me just finish the point when we when we dont know that kind of stuff we need to on the side of safety thats what it is to be precautious and that is exactly what the u. K. And u. S. Governments have not been doing they havent been keeping us safe all the provinces father surely georgia says that he will still go to the bulb in any case but i think the government would say they were earning on the side of caution when they saw that a herd immunity response would kill courtroom 1000000 people in britain this term herd immunity i think it was a very honest to be using their idea was lets let this pandemic rip through the population and try to control it from hitting the most vulnerable to try to keep them cocooned this had the likely consequence as you say that we could have hundreds of thousands of people dying in this country now why would any government do that let me put something quite controversial here i believe that the only way it could make sense for somebody to think of doing that is if they didnt enormously think of themselves as part of this heard that was going to be knowingly infected with the disease knowingly recklessly endangering the population and i would claim thinking that they themselves would be part of that percentage of the population that were not going to be infected ok well the Harvard School of public health. How did seem to agree with you think it was it was but why is it that the b. B. C. Certainly is reporting new the science is changed thats why Boris Johnson has changed his advice to the British Population as regards going out of doors so the imperial results that the government is changing your goal of Building Material college. They are new in themselves but the substance of what theyre saying is precisely what the lancet was saying 2 months ago is precisely what nassim taleb and i have been saying for weeks on end a back of an envelope calculation shows that hundreds of thousands are at risk from this virus if you let it hit most of the population are the same and data brokers are the main broadcaster in this country is wrong about the science having changed the problem with the b. B. C. Coverage is that theyve been and the i. T. V. Coverage is that theyve been far too deferential towards the state they said things like for example well Boris Johnson is for only following the scientific advice because of course he goes out there flanked by the chief medical officer and the chief scientific adviser but that doesnt mean theyre making the policy the policy was very influenced for example by the Knowledge Psychology unit that is close to 10 downing street who were saying look youre not going to be able to convince people to socially isolate the long periods of time therefore youve got to wait before you impose that those kinds of restrictions but that was groundless what weve actually seen wonderfully over the last week is the British Population moving ahead of the government and saying look its just not good enough were not convinced that youre keeping us safe anymore we are bringing the government into line and we are bringing the broadcasters into line actually the science all the way along different scientists been saying Different Things the safe thing to do the precautions thing to do was never put the whole population into a kind of massive uncontrolled experiment no where else in the world was. Do this im here in london with us and there are still flights taking off from from london airport from city airport except for those flights because london is an epicenter now those flights are spreading the virus around this country as we speak just finally very briefly i know that Extinction Rebellion occurring some of the plan made a demonstrations i understand theres a whistle blowing project in case anyone watching this program was to give you information that could help not only regarding corona virus but on fossil fuel emissions globally yeah so we had the site its called truth teller thought life w w w talk to thelma dot life and the idea is if there are secrets that are lurking in any Pharmaceutical Company in any bank and any Insurance Company whatever it might be in government get them out the public need and deserve to know about threats to their safety on this or any issue professor richard reed thank you after the break whos really just blame for the low could be bombing that killed 270 people on british soil we speak just a lister our own words working to clear the name of the only man ever to be convicted for the ukase worst terror attack all the small going up about to have going underground. The world is driven by shaped by one person. Who dares thinks. We dare to ask. Welcome back in the past few days as the Coronavirus Crisis began to dominate International News the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission made a decision about the biggest of a terror attack on british soil the bereaved have been campaigning for justice for over 3 decades since the lockerbie bombing which killed 270. 00 people after pan am flight 103 crashed the only man ever to be convicted as libyan Intelligence Officer mcgrath he but now there is to be a posthumous appeal joining me now from our studio in glasgow is an astronomer unwearied lodged an appeal on behalf of mcgrath his family and has described his conviction as the worst miscarriage of justice in british legal history thank you so much on my for coming on just before we get to lockerbie ive got to ask you because corona virus is obviously in the ed lines you helped arguably put the murdoch news of the world out of business its successor the sun on sunday came out thats the chosen output by one of the top scientific adviser on coronavirus to Boris Johnson what do you make of using Murdoch Outlets for information i think as a little pool boy most people would find that shocking i think the fact that the government is repeatedly using. One particular newspaper. Called the Health Sector just a few days ago used to telegraph a pay wall in order to put Public Information is simply not acceptable all newspapers all t. V. Stations should be get exactly the same information should be given favoritism to one but i think its its outrageous and i and the process and the result of course is that they are cutting off parts of society that refuse to buy such papers but also means the information is not getting gates and in a uniform fashion and it is scaring people i have older parents who are scared reading what they see and tippets in the news and tabloids is simply unacceptable is not the way a reasonable rational well informed government should be behaving that shocking in fairness of our sons and government. Sure they say they are rectifying some of the problems before we obviously invite the barclay brothers owners of the telegraph and Rupert Murdoch on the show but lets get the lockerbie a lot of people are going to think that this case was done and dusted over 20 allez deal with the late more margaret daffy what exactly is this case and why are you were pressing it given that al mcgrady has been convicted of this case he was of course 1st accused by a cia asset in libya back in the days when great get halfway around the one of the richest countries in africa per capita while it on the 21st december 1988 pan am flight 103 exploded over lockerbie the town of lockerbie and 270 people from 21 countries lost their lives this was the as you said its a tale he was the greatest terrorist atrocity to take place in u. K. Soil and what it means as many people have said to us why 30 or over 31 years later should be trying to take this back to the appeal court and its as simple as this if there was a reversal of the verdict it would mean that the britain and britain and the United States and the Security Services have been living a monumental life for some 31 years they incarcerated an innocent man and they punished the libyan people for a crime they did not commit and many people have for a long time pointed the finger of blame at the to run. And stated that they were responsible that they carried out a revenge attack when the americans murdered some several 100 iranians on an air bus 6 months before the lockerbie attack and yet for some reason the finger of blame then shifted when the 1st gulf war came along and it seemed an opportune moment to treat libya which was a pariah state and to point the finger of blame at that when they needed support from syria and from iran for the 1st gulf war no the bottom line here remains that mr mcgregor he did actually started as a people there was strong grounds of appeal on the pro. Started and then in 2009 when he was diagnosed with cancer pressure was placed upon him and he reasonably believed that unless he gave up his appeal he would not be allowed to return home to die with his to die in the presence of his family that was an unfortunate that was a horrific way to deal an individual who had already been incarcerated for a crime he did not commit and then he subsequently died and people for that was the end of the chapter in 2014 i met with the british relatives who are unique in legal history anywhere i can see in the world have supported the victims you know as victims family members have supported members of the accused the convicted and the mcgrath the family agreed on in unison decided that we should try to take this case back to the court so its been nearly 6 years of work we submitted an application to be getting that was refused on this time round the application succeeded and the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission said that it was on the basis of an unreasonable decision any jury would have taken and also did nondisclosure of evidence and you know the fingerprints all over the american Security Services the british Security Services the u. K. Government and the British Government are all over this i dont really have hidden the what to actually took place and then the only place to decide the guilt or innocence of mr magara elmaghraby is of course in the Scottish Appeal Court where we will be going and you cause ok i want to get also to the reprisal allegations concerning iran of course the United States killed 290 people on a civilian airliner the u. S. S. Vincennes attack but this thing to what you just said because some people are going to be asking we cant get m i 5 and my 6 officers on the show unless why on earth then would mamma get up have accepted that mcgrath he did the deed and it was just to unfreeze back youve got to leave sanctions and get a privatized british beeping to get an oil deal well i mean i i cant i cant answer for this to get happy i am what the bottom line here is that there had to mean much disclosure over the years of the show. Not against of the british and the americans who have always been desperate to get their hands on oil whove been desperate to tie up arms and weapons deals you know tony blair the deal in the desert and at the end of the day if your country has been subjected to economic sanctions and your people are suffering and you see a way out of it then of course a sacrificial lamb will be offered up thats the way that the immigrant family and many people both the british shelters on the libyan people see it and 31 years later the question the questions that remain of this case must be unset i think its pretty obvious that for anybody whos viewed how the british and the americans have acted with regards to the middle east and i still continues to this day one only needs to look at whats happening in iraq when you need to see whats happening with iran how. These authorities are these regimes in britain and america deal with that when it comes to you know the profits when it comes to the hands of oil or gas lines well there will be willing to do anything or not that bought the topic not applies to the question of lockerbie ok britain did support the United States bombing of iraq killing iraqi soldiers and police and civilian just last week but surely the last time around when mcgregor he was convicted the evidence was unheard of f. B. I. Agents there u. S. Helicopters of the law can be seen a violation of the integrity of the crime scene as alleged by the lawyer actually who now represents julian assange. Has evidence of a cia operative on the flight all this evidence wasnt at the time before a verdict on the ground hes guilty as may well one of the crucial pieces of evidence that the man and im just quite wide range would be impossible for me to explain you know we had 451 pages delivered to my office last week by the scottish criminal kuwait cases review commission so that found the basis of it we have pieces we have evidence that would fill 2 floors of a building but if you look at one crucial piece of evidence which was not disclosed to the defense of the time and as the evidence of mr gates a man who owned a shop who fingered the pointed the finger of blame mama mcgrath. And said that he was the person who brought the call vic in his shop some 10 years later 12 years later he pointed them in and subsequently what we find out once a clase is closing ones guilty pronounced is that this man was offered in the region of 2000000. 00 money offered also to his brother to identify mr. Mr mr mehlman groggy and that he got this wrong on a number of occasions he was shown photographs he was shown magazines he was wined and dined and he was brought to give evidence now in any other normal murder trial if it was revealed to the defense that an individual has been told on the basis of their evidence if he points at the right person and accuses them of murder then them that trial would be flown out and there would be an inquiry an investigation into the police the security says anybody that i dont try to offer a bribe or in juice me to a witness yet in this case the worst case of mass murder on u. K. Soil none of that happened there was no disclosure and the the a Decent Commission delivered a damning indictment of the role of the crone and others who were involved in this piece of evidence not just one crucial piece of evidence that we hope to take back to the appeal court and of course there are there are many other a piece about this is a present some of them to some of the witnesses that you might desire to have in the appeal stage presumably some of them have died i mean for instance theres a man called ma increase that too was a bomb maker reputedly again according to the lawyer because it worked with the militant group backed by iran the disrespected he was an undercover jordanian intelligence agent apparently jordans Intelligence Services link to the cia what will you be able to get him i mean is going to develop as a solicitor to get any of these people to testify on behalf of that thats true enough it terms of that but what we need to remember is that the appeal is not a rerun of the trial you know we have several groans of appeal that we would wish to launch the commission appointed to but some many of the grounds have been incorporated into question of an unreasonable verdict but in the case of mr gates hes dead however we still have what. But as he gave him the question for the commission the question for the appeal court would be to decide is it reasonable to have allowed the evidence Critical Evidence of an individual like this on the answer we suspect would be no that is why the commission has referred it back to the appeal court so you dont much need to resurrect the date to even to come to court but we wont be going to court to stand up and produce evidence that lets say another country was responsible or that this was all we required to show is that the verdict was unreasonable that the nondisclosure of the evidence meant that this conviction was unsafe and as a result of which you know mr Allan Mcgregor he should have a miscarriage of justice and that conviction should be overturned and that would also apply to the people of libya and the libyan people you know and the country that have suffered so much as a result of this you know the pariah state always when you mention the name of god when i speak to their family the name is always one of attached to the lockerbie bomber when you speak to libyan people they say they always they are attached to the lockerbie bombing this is important its about rett its about rectifying history and he said by actually asking the questions of the british and americans why did you do this you know why did you lie to your own people why did you like to 21 countries why did you conduct such a cover up still has reverberations through the globe tool today and its about making sure that those policies are corrected and people are held to account do you have to prove that the evidence not being disclosed was because of a a money line motive or could it be accidental im just thinking that they will be looking for a motive surely and the most you know it is been floated is that mrs thatcher was told by george w. Bush George Herbert walker bush sorry to keep the lockerbie investigation low key even after they had already got suspects for the for the terror attack well i dont think is a case of that we need to require to find a motive they dishy was if there is non disclosure then its critical to the defense if the crown failed to tell the defense a crucial piece of evidence that might clear the accuser. Theyre not thats thats all that counts it doesnt matter about their motivation but of course youre quite right and i even today when last week 451 pages landed on my desk and i opened the you know the documents and i skimmed through them and all of a sudden i saw a black redacted pages and i asked the Commission Whats this and what we find out was that even to today that the United States government the British Government the federal republic of germany and Security Services had refused to disclose information that they relate to the commission and i got them to give an undertaking to say that would that would not be disclosed to defense so whilst information was provided to the commission as a result of which the Commission Said no we believe there is a serious risk of a miscarriage of justice and this should be referred by to be oh we were not given privy we were not given access to the information of course we will fight for that information but thats we can put that to the site because a bottom line really comes down to this if theres a piece of information its relate to court as evidence on the 3 judges are not able to see the information and therefore you know come to a considered decision in the same way that judy what then not means that there is a miscarriage of justice and that is all that is required to be done in that courtroom all night day saying that that not almagro he should never ever have been convicted of the worst act of murder on british soil dahmer and i thank you thank you as if in a show we were back on saturday for a special edition of going on the ground with the man who inspired the war figures from malcolm x. To john lennon Garrick Utley 17 years after the u. S. U. K. War in iraq that left millions killed maimed or displaced until then join me on the ground by following up on you tube Twitter Facebook instagram and time. When else so seems wrong. Why dont we all just dont call. Me while yet to see how it does come as a whole and in games people trail. Once a month and find themselves worlds apart. Just on the common ground. European union shuts its external borders for a month in a bid to limit the spread of covert 19 us france enforces a nationwide lockdown correspondent there experiences what its like. Anybody leaving there is also peace whole thing. Its so disturbing. The. World Health Organization urges countries to take a leaf out of beijing sport and impose tougher restrictions to fund the pandemic because the situation in china itself begins. With the world distracted by covert 19 a controversial bill that critics say would practically and privacy online makes a