The Martha's Vineyard Times
We understand why some clerk magistrateâs hearings are private. Accusations are easy to make. Providing evidence to back up those accusations is more difficult, and you donât want to sully the reputation of an individual with a baseless claim.
Bagnall was investigated by the Edgartown Police. A detective spoke with Bagnall. He also spoke with Bagnallâs neighbor. And he examined evidence, including a videotape.
We petitioned clerk magistrate Liza Williamson for access to a clerk magistrateâs hearing involving Bagnall â and were denied.
We think Williamson got it wrong. Her reasoning just doesnât work in this case.