Transcripts For MSNBC Way Too Early With Jonathan Lemire 20241004

Smith. Well dig into that blockbuster new document and what prosecutors are saying about trumps efforts to overturn the 2020 election. Plus well bring you the latest from the Middle East as israel continues to launch Air Strikes targeted at Hezbollah Facilities in lebanon. And also ahead president Joe Biden visited the carolinas to survey the Storm Damage left in the wake of Hurricane Helene. Well take a look at the ongoing Recovery And Cleanup efforts. Good Morning And Welcome to Way Too Early on this thursday, october 3rd. Im jonathan lemire. Thanks for starting your day with us. And we have a lot to get to this morning, and well begin with the new filing from special Counsel Jack Smith that lays out the case for why former president Donald Trump should still be held accountable for his actions on January 6th despite the Supreme Courts ruling on immunity. Nbc News Justice and Intelligence Correspondent Ken Dilanian has all the details. Reporter special Counsel Jack Smith fighting to keep the January 6th case against Donald Trump alive. In a new filing with new evidence, smith tailoring his criminal case to survive the Supreme Courts ruling that president s cant be prosecuted for carrying out official acts. Writing that although trump was president during the charged conspiracies, his scheme was a fundamentally private one. Smith also laying out new details about Trumps Conduct and conversations in the days and hours before his supporters stormed the capitol on january 6, 2021. After trump began claiming fraud even as votes were still being counted, the Special Counsel quotes a Trump Aide as saying, make them riot. But the bulk of new revelations involve trumps interactions with Vice President Mike Pence based on five pages of notes by the Vice President. The Special Counsel saying pence gradually and gently tried to convince the defendant to accept the lawful results of the election including a private lunch in december where pence encouraged trump not to look at the election as a loss, just an intermission. Smith arguing Trump And Pence were political Running Mates discussing private acts, not office holders contemplating official ones. After pence decided not to stop the Certification And Trump denounced him in a tweet, smith recounts aides allegedly telling Trump Pence was in danger. As trump sat in a white House Dining Room watching the Capitol Riot on tv, smith wrote, an aide told him pence had been rushed to a secure location. Smith says trump looked at the aide and said only, so what . In a statement a Trump Campaign Spokesman called the filing unconstitutional and another attempt by the harrisbiden regime to undermine american democracy and interfere in this lection, adding the case should be dismissed. Joining us now msnbc legal analyst and former Deputy Chief in the criminal division for the southern district of New York, kristi greenberg. Kristi, good morning. Thanks for starting us off. First, tell us what jumped out at you from this filing . And in your assessment, how strong is Jack Smiths argument that former President Trump should be held accountable for his actions on January 6th . So what really jumped out at me was looking at those buckets of interactions with Mike Pence. A lot of that detail was new. And so in looking at those, the Supreme Court has said theyre talking about official responsibilities, thats official conduct, but you can still even with respect to official conduct rebut a presumption of immunity attaches if you can show theres really no intrusion here on the executive branch. While looking at these interactions with Mike Pence, its hard to see how anybody could see this as really having any kind of danger on the executive branch. You have discussions about the certification on January 6th. And with respect to those communications, hes really just trying to bully Mike Pence to go along with this. And the executive really has no role whatsoever in that process. So i think those interactions, you know, leading up to January 6th about the certification are really safe. And then you have a whole other bucket of communications with Mike Pence, where theyre really talking to his Running Mates about whether or not Donald Trump lost. And even then Mike Pence kind of doesnt want to say he lost. As you said in the introduction, more like an intermission. A lot of kind of Mike Pence really dancing around Donald Trumps ego here. But really trying to get him to concede that, yes, this is a loss, theres no more process here, we have to stand down. Thats really discussions between two Running Mates, that has nothing to do with their responsibilities as president and Vice President. I think the Special Counsel does a good job of getting into the nittygritty, going into the details, and showing why each of these buckets of communications should not be immune from prosecution. Certainly tailored with the supreme Court Decision in mind. Kristy, talk to us about what happens next on who wins this case . Is it completely dependent on who wins the next election . Hes asking for more time, not surprising he wants to delay here. But i assume that brief will be filed before the election. At least its scheduled to at this point. But once the election happens, youre absolutely right. If Kamala Harris is elected, this case proceeds. If she is not, then Donald Trump would certainly instruct his Department Of Justice to dismiss this case. If Kamala Harris is elected and this case proceeds, what i expect after briefing is Donald Trumps lawyers have said we need to be able to confront witnesses. We want to be able to have a hearing, so i think at least with respect to some of the individuals, not all of the 70 some odd witnesses that are identified in the indictment but at least with respect to some, there may be a hearing where the judge has more Fact Finding questions about whether or not the acts here are official or unofficial. Ultimately, this will get appealed. It will get appealed likely all the way up to the Supreme Court once gep. Former Deputy Chief for the criminal division for the southern district of New York, thank you. Well talk to you again soon. Well have much more in this filing including the political fallout ahead of novembers election. Now, though, we turn to the Middle East. Eight israeli soldiers have died fighting inside lebanon. Its not known exactly how it happened, but israeli officials are saying the soldiers were killed in three separate incidents in close combat. These are the first reported casualties since they started the operation earlier this week. It comes as israel launches Air Strikes targeted facilities. A Strikeover Night killed at least six people in beirut. Meanwhile, the White House is looking to prevent a Wilder War following irans massive Missile Attack against israel. The united states supports Israel Retaliating in some capacity, but President Biden says he does not want them to attack tehrans nuclear facilities. Tell us anything about iran and israels possible retaliation. Yes, look, i called the meeting in the g7 today. Were working on a joint statement All Of Us agree on from japan to france to germany to et cetera. And what were doing in that record is were making clear that theres things that have to be done. And obviously iran has gone way off course. Were going to put together a joint statement, that hadnt been done yet. And theres going to be some sanctions on iran. The answer is no, and i think theres things well be discussing with the israelis what theyre going to do, but all seven of us agree that they have a right to respond, but they should respond in course. Joining us live from beirut is foreign correspondent for the wall street journal. Good to see you this morning. Give us the latest there on the state of fighting including the deaths of these israeli soldiers. Whats happening now . What more do we know . Yeah, we saw yesterday some engagements inside of lebanese territory between hezbollah and israeli forces that began entering late monday night. The israelis announced eight casualties, eight deaths among their soldiers soldiers and officers. And hezbollah talked about a trap they had set and explosive followed by gunfire in a couple of towns on the border. That was Last Night. That was yesterday. Over the course of the day theres engagements. Hezbollah said this morning its continued to launch Cross Border rockets and missiles at the locations just across the border inside northern israel. And of course overnight as you mentioned there were some strikes inside of beirut, strikes across the country. Yesterdays strike in beirut, one of them there were several in the southern suburbs, which has been targeted repeatedly. For just the second time in the past few days there was a strikeouticide the southern suburbs, which is sort of the central part of the city. So certainly we just heard the president there saying he does not support israel as part of its retaliation striking an iranian nuclear site. Ive got new reporting this morning. The u. S. Really trying to urge israel to keep it proportional. They understand theyre going to encourage him to respond in limited ways. Military facilities and proxy groups. Stay away from population centers and major economic installations. But we know that prime Minister Netanyahu, frankly, doesnt listen to President Biden that much. And the president has run up against his influence there. Whats the latest on the ground as to how and when israel will launch its retaliatory strike . Yeah, the region is on Edge Waiting for the israeli response to iranians sending more than 100 ballistic missiles by israel a few nights ago. Its unclear what their response will look like. Of course there was a similar Episode Back in april where iran sent drones and missiles towards israel, most intercepted. The response from israel after that was quite limited, but were in sort of a different space now, and the expectation here on the ground is that the response from israel this time will not be as limited, and thats driving concerns that this could spiral into an even broader conflict across the region. Yes, something the u. S. Has tried to avoid. Certainly right, the u. S. Has momentum and theres a israel wants to push this further. Were following efforts across the south following surear Storm Damage from Hurricane Helene. Former President Trump is getting a show of support from National Security Experts. Well take a look whos backing him but also notably whos not. Those stories and a check on sports and weather when we come right back. Sports and weather when we come right back Power E trades easytouse tools, like dynamic charting and riskreward analysis, help make trading feel effortless. And its customizable scans with social sentiment help you find and unlock opportunities in the market. E trade from morgan Stanley Pain hits fast. So get relief fast. Only Tylenol Rapid release gels have laser drilled holes. They release Medicine Fast for fast Pain Relief. And now, get Max Strength topical Pain Relief precisely where you need it. With new tylenol precise. Vicks vapostick provides soothing nonmedicated vicks vapors. Easy to apply for the whole family. Vicks vapostick. And try new Vaposhower Max for steamy vicks vapors. Craig here pays too much for verizon wireless. So he sublet half his real Estate Office to a pet shop. Theres a smarter way to save. Comcast business mobile. You could save up to an incredible 70 on your wireless bill. So you dont have to compromise. Powering smarter savings. Powering possibilities. Switch to comcast Busines Internet and mobie and find out how to get te latest 5g Phone on s with a qualifying tradei. Dont wait call, click or visit an xfinity store today. Welcome back. President biden will visit nra and Georgia Today as communities there try to pick up the pieces by the widespread devastation inflicted by Hurricane Helene. The Death Toll from the Monster Storm has now claimed at least 190 lives, and hundreds of other people remain missing. The president surveyed the damage in the carolinas yesterday, first taking an aerial tour of greenville county, south carolina. And then hard hit asheville, North Carolina, where entire communities in that region were swept away by severe flooding. The president posted a picture on Social Media from inside the helicopter over western North Carolina calling the devastation he witnessed there heart breaking. Later biden visited the emergency Operations Center in raleigh alongside North Carolina governor Roy Cooper where he announced more federal aid for four states that includes deploying up to 1,000 active duty soldiers to reinforce the North Carolina national guard. I dont have to tell this group that Hurricane Helene has been a storm really of historic proportions. The damage is still being assessed, but many people are still unaccounted for. So im here to say the united states, the nation has your back. The nation has your back. Were not leaving until youre back on your feet completely. Meanwhile, a large number of National Security Experts have released a letter endorsing Donald Trumps bid for reelection. The group was organized by trumps fourth national security advisor, robert obrien, and includes over 300 signatories including u. N. Ambassador nikki haley. The Letters Release comes amid multiple global conflicts and claims that securing peace is the legacy of trump. Notably this letter was not signed by trumps first secretary of state, rex tillerson, her his secretaries of defense, james Mattis And Mark esper. Next up well turn to sports and well bring you the latest from a great day of major League Baseball Playoff action. Well have highlights from all four wild Card Series including three sweeps. Those stories and a check on the Weather Forecast when Way Too Early returns. N Way Too Early returns it wasnt hard with cologuard®, i did it my Way Colohuh . Cologuard cologuard is for people 45 at average risk, not high risk. False positive and negative results may occur. Screen for Colon Cancer in your home, your way. Ask your provider for, cologuard ask your provider for, have you always had trouble losing weight and keeping it off . Same. Discover the power of wegovy®. With wegovy®, i lost 35 pounds. And some lost over 46 pounds. And im keeping the weight off. Wegovy® helps you lose weight and keep it off. Im reducing my risk. Wegovy® is the only fdaapproved Weightmanagement Medicine thats proven to reduce risk of major cardiovascular events in adults with known Heart Disease and with either obesity or overweight. Wegovy® shouldnt be used with Semaglutide Or Glp1 medicines. Dont take wegovy® if you or your family had medullary thyroid cancer, multiple endocrine Neoplasia Syndrome Type 2, or if allergic to it. Stop wegovy® and get medical help right away if you get a Lump Or Swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, or an allergic reaction. Serious Side Effects may happen, including Pancreatitis And Gallbladder problems. Wegovy® may cause low Blood Sugar in people with diabetes, especially if you take medicines to treat diabetes. Tell your provider about Vision Problems or changes, or if you feel your Heart Racing while at rest. Depression or thoughts of suicide may occur. Call your provider right away if you have any mental changes. Common Side Effects like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea may lead to dehydration, which may cause kidney problems. With wegovy®, im losing weight, im keeping it off. And im lowering my cv risk. Thats the power of we. Check your Cost And Coverage before talking to your Health Care professional about wegovy®. woman look i got the new iphone 16 pro at verizon. Apple intelligence is pretty awesome. man nice. woman you can get it when you trade in any phone. man whoa, whoa, whoa vo at verizon new and existing customers can get iphone 16 pro on us. When you trade in any phone in any condition. Only on verizon. Oh. Stuffed up again . So congested you need Sinex Saline from vicks. Just sinex, breathe, ahhhh what is wow sinex. Breathe. Ahhhhhh your memory is an amazing thing, but sometimes it can start to slow down. But did you know prevagen can help keep your memory sharp . The secret is the powerful ingredient, apoaequorin, originally discovered in jellyfish and found only in prevagen. In a clinical study, prevagen was shown to improve memory in subgroups of individuals who were cognitively normal or mildly impaired. Stay sharp and improve your memory with prevagen. Prevagen. In stores everywhere without a prescription. He swings and drives one out towards right center. And its gone. Garret mitchells tworun homerun gives the Milwaukee Brewers a late lead over the new York Mets Last Night. Mitchells go ahead shot in the 8th Inning came after Jackson Torrio tied the game as the brewers who were trailing late beat the mets 53 to force a decisive game three of their national league wild Card Series. Heartbreaker there for the mets. The winner of Tonights Contest in milwaukee will go onto face the Nl East champion Philadelphia Phillies in the best of five national league division series. To San Diego now. Kyles Solo Homerun sparked a five Run Rally for the padres the second inning. Mannie machado and then Jackson Merrill following with a two run triple. They hold onto beat 54 for a two game sweep. They did leave their pitcher, james musgrove, to injury. To the American League now. The Baltimore Orioles have been swept out of the playoffs for a second year in a row. Bobby Wit Jr. With another hit Last Night beating out an infield single. The Second Baseman should have flipped. Royals beat the os 21. The royals will now face the Al East Champ wherein, the New York yankees. Which means as of right now the Kansas City royals, americas team. And then to houston. The Detroit Tigers have ended the rup of consecutive appearances. The cinderella tigers sweep the astros with that 52 win. The astros are out. The tigers will take on the Al Central Champion Cleveland guardians in the best of five. We want to mention week five of the Season Kick off in atlanta with the falcons hosting the Tampa Bay buccaneers on Thursday Night football. Time now for the weather and bring in Meteorologist Angie Lassman with the forecast. I was in detroit this past weekend. It is electric. Its been long since we had a little Playoff Baseball there. Big bickture look, looks kind of nice across the country. We dont have a lot of rain from Coast To coast. Just a couple showers and maybe a few thunderstorms across the state of florida. Boy, do we have warmth. Weve got 90s for albuquerque today, 105 for phoenix. The impressive Heat Streak continues there. Even into chicago above normal in the mid70s. Its going to be like that for the next couple of days running above normal for this time of year. Then we turn our attention to this broad area of low pressure sitting in the gulf of mexico. Whether it develops or not, thats the question. It has a low chance right now, 30 . But either way it will bring some additional rainfall to folks across the gulf coast. Louisiana specifically through today and out into the florida panhandle. As we get through the day tomorrow, well see more of this impacting folks across the state of florida too as ongoing cleanup happens there for the West Coast of florida and pick up maybe an inch or two inches. As the big Picture Look for your friday, again, not a whole lot going on. It remains fairly quiet for the country. Otherwise for the rockies and points west, weve got really nice conditions across the great lakes. That takes us into your saturday. Again, really gorgeous conditions. Plenty of Sunshine Coast to coast. If were looking at cooler highs, maybe emore autumnlike conditions, weve got to look to the Northern Plains for that. Otherwise its the warmth that continues for most. Thats the best forecast in a while. Angie lassman, thanks so much. Next up here we turn back to politics and new polling shows Kamala Harris and Donald Trump are still in a dead heat when it comes to the all important Battleground States. Well dig into the very latest numbers when we come right back. T numbers Whene Wcome right back. Latest Weight Loss Fad join over 5 Million people that have switched to golo as a better way to lose weight with golo you simply take one Release Supplement with each meal and follow the golo for Life Plan the seven natural plants and three key minerals in release helps Support Weight Loss by targeting Body Fat and combating the stress of Dieting Golo is the effective affordable Weight Loss solution get started today at golo. Com thats Golo Dot Com sounds like you need to vaporize that cold. Dayquil vapocool . Its Dayquil Plus A rush of vicks vapors. Vapocooooool woah. Dayquil vapocool. The vaporizing daytime, coughing, aching, stuffy head, power through your day, medicine. Protect against rsv. With arexvy. Arexvy is a vaccine used to prevent lower Respiratory Disease from rsv in people 60 years and older. Arexvy does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients. Those with weakened Immune Systems may have a lower response to the vaccine. The most common Side Effects are injection site pain, fatigue, muscle pain, headache, and joint pain. Arexvy is Number One in Rsv Vaccine shots. Rsv . Make it arexvy. Heres to getting better with age. Heres to beating these two every thursday. Help Fuel Today with boost high protein, complete nutrition you need, and the flavor you love. So, heres to now. Now available Boost Max why choose a mobile network built for places youll probably never be. Instead of for where you are most of the time . Xfinity mobile was designed for where you need it most. Xfinity internet customers, ask how to get a free 5g Phone and a second unlimited line free for a year. Welcome back to Way Too Early. It is just before 5 30 a. M. Here on the east coast, 2 30 out west on this thursday morning. Im jonathan lemire. Thank you for being with us. And we turn back to politics now, and new polling from the Cook Political Report finds Kamala Harris leading or tied with Donald Trump in all but one Battleground State. According to this new survey of likely voters, harris leads trump by 2 points in arizona, the same as a poll that was conducted back in august. In georgia, cook does find trump leading by 2 points after he and harris had been tied there previously. In michigan, the Vice President leads by 3 points, which was identical to august. Shes also flipped a 3point Lead for trump in nevada into a 1point Margin of her own. North carolina, the race is tied. Harris was up by just one point back in august. In pennsylvania the poll shows harris maintaining a 1point lead. And in Wisconsin Harris leads by 2 points. Thats down from the 3 points from the margin back in august. We should note as you can probably guess, all of these results are within the Polls Margin of error. Joining us now Politics Reporter at semafor, cadilla goba. Big picture take, boy, the race is close. Virtually every polling from every outlet and were seeing it here from cook every Battleground State within the margin of error. Do you think the Vice President ial debate from a couple nights ago, which is certainly not reflective in these numbers, do you think itll make any difference at all. Most republicans saying vance won and democrats saying that walz won, so i dont think it quite moved the needle so much. But i think i want to turn my attention to North Carolina specifically. Most people say that is a pathway for each candidate to win the electoral votes that they need. And we see republicans there sort of struggling especially at the top of the local ticket for the Governors Race with mark robinson. We all know that a lot of people saw that the scathing report from cnn. And what were seeing now is his democratic candidate, you know, running away with the election of sorts. Now, whether or not that impacts the top of the ticket with Donald Trump is an open question, but most republicans ive talked to on the ground and in congress say as long as trump is distancing himself, hell be in a better position because typically in North Carolina voters split the ticket. Now the Storm Storm Helene has impacted that as well, so Voter Turnout is going to be important here as well and i think for other Swing States as well. I think youre right. At least this poll suggests robinson is under water but hes not dragging down trump. The margin very small right now. Gop advantage, and like it did in 2022 the control of the house this time around may also come down to some tight races in a Deep Blue state, New York. Tell us about some of those youre watching . Yeah, so definitely paying attention to those western New York New York 17, New York 19, Mark Molinaro whos defending his seat, mike lawler, a republican defending his seat who flipped those districts. Also long island, the whole district of New York and anthony deesposito. Looking at reporting right now, it seems harris hasnt caught up to the lead that biden had in 2020, but shes definitely higher than he was when he was in the race, so i think thats interesting to see what this month will bring. I think its going to be very close, so like you say its a blue state, and its not clear what well, it wont impact the electoral count especially for the president ial race, but it could damage democrats or democrats trying to win back the house. And lastly, kadia, very briefly, turn to the upper chamber in the senate. Democrats, a lot of pessimism picking up on their chances in montana, Senator Tester in danger there. They lose that, theyd have to pick up somewhere on the map to maintain control. Whats the latest youre hearing . Yeah, i mean it is i do not hear a lot of positive stuff coming out of montana, but i think people are looking at arizona right now with representative guillego. And i think youll see a different Spending Pattern Change in the last few weeks of the race as well. We appreciate the reporting. Kadia, thank you again. Next up here well go live to cnbc for an early look whats driving stocks this morning. Plus, analysts say that the Market Value of the Social Media site x, ie, twitter, has dropped by nearly 80 . Well talk about what this could mean for the companys owner, Elon Musk, when we come right back. Owner, Elon Musk, when we come right back what do people want more of . More oh yeah more laughs. More hang outs. More mmmmm, so good yeah, give us more of all of that little stuff that makes life so great. But if youre older or or have certain health conditions, you also have more risk from flu, covid19 and rsv. But vaccines help keep you from getting really sick. And that, is huge. Time now for business, and for that lets bring in cnbcs carolin roth, who joins us live from london. Good morning. Stock futures are In The Red today as investors are looking ahead to the Jobs Report due out tomorrow. Give us a sense as to where the market is going. Look, obviously theres some sense of trepidation ahead of that all important Jobs Report. We know the fed now favors the Jobs Outlook over the inflationary outlook. Its made it very clear. So were expecting a figure about around 150,000 when we get to that Jobs Report. Today we get the jobless claims. Also were going to be digesting teslas numbers. Well talk about that in just a second. Yeah, lets move into the Elon Musk portion of our Segment Starting with tesla, which posted an increase in sales for the first time all year, but its shares dropped as investors were hoping for. Tell us what this says writ large about electric cars, or was this a specific concern about this brand . Look, the numbers and such werent bad. Actually the uptick in terms of revenues or deliveries of 6 was an improvement over past quarters. However, i will say the stock has had a really good runup over the past couple of weeks because the of Robo Taxi Event taking place next week and whether that will be the key Growth Driver going forward. A lot of analysts i talked to said theyre still skeptical saying before the Robo Taxis become reality. The real expectations when it came to deliveries the past quarter, that was a lot higher. So i think maybe a bit of Fatigue Selling and maybe a bit of profit taking here, but actually deliveries were strong. They werent bad. All right, lets talk about another musk enterprise, which is x, formerly known as twitter. And estimates from the investment giant, fidelity, show it is worth significantly im talking significantly less than when elon bought it. Tell us more. Yes, 80 less than when Elon Musk bought it roughly two years ago for 44 billion. Obviously hes taken the company private. That would be a big drop for him, for his wealth, obviously, and for all the backers. Obviously a lot of backers here when it comes to loans that were offered to Elon Musk when he bought that company. The major concern around twitter or now x is obviously the advertising clients. Theyre were aetd about the Content Moderation given some of the content that were finding on the platform right now. So a lot of work to be done here on that front. The importance of Content Moderation particularly as we barrel into an election. Cnbcs carolin roth, live from london, thank you as always. Next up here back to politics, and j. D. Vance is changing his tune from Tuesday Nights Vice President ial debate. He was civil then, yesterday mocking. Well play for you the republican senators comments during a Campaign Event in michigan when we come right back. Campaign event in michigan when we come right back why choose a mobile network built for places youll probably never be. Instead of for where you are most of the time . Xfinity mobile was designed for where you need it most. Xfinity internet customers, ask how to get a free 5g Phone and a second unlimited line free for a year. Republican Vice President ial nominee j. D. Vance returned to the Campaign Trail Yesterday and immediately dropped the cordial tone he adopted during Tuesday Nights Running Mate debate. Who could have ever predicted that . At a rally near Detroit Vance mocked vp nominee Tim Walz for misspeaking on the Debate Stage the previous night. Its funny because, you know, we did this debate, and then i talked to the president afterwards, and we talked a little bit about, you know, what actually happened, and, you know, some of the points that i made, some of the points that Governor Walz made. And he made this observation. He said that Tim Walz said that he was friends with School Shooters twice. And i said that was probably only the third or Mourgt Miscomment Tim Walz made that night. Walz of course meant victims of school shootings, but no blow too low. Vance was also asked by reporters why he refused to say trump lost the 2020 election while he was pressed by walz on that subject during the debate. Heres how walz justified the response. Heres the simple reason. The media obsessed with talking about the election of four years ago. Im focused on the election of 33 days from now, because i want to throw Kamala Harris out of office and get back to Common Sense economic policies. But i also think you can believe that america needs to have secure and free elections but also talk about the fact that just a couple of weeks ago democrats in the u. S. Congress blocked a piece of legislation that would have ensured illegal aliens dont vote in our elections. If you believe american democracy, if you believe in our constitutional republic, you should be trying to strengthen Election Integrity and not weaken it. Illegal aliens already dont vote in american elections. Joining us now author, columnist and conservative writer, matt lewis. Matt, youve been thinking about writing about this subject on the vp candidates after the debate the other night. It was it was strikingly cordial, but that was clearly a tactic from vance to disarm some potential attacks. Yesterday we saw him revert to the real thing. Yes, i think it was sort of a bait and switch. If you were Tim Walz and you were showing up ready to take on j. D. Vance and hes going to attack me on my Military Record or whatever, that j. D. Vance didnt show up. And so it really was a different j. D. Vance. In one sense i think we maybe want to applaud the civility. It was a little refreshing, but i also think theres some phoniness there, you know, where these guys maybe talk tough about the other guy when hes not around but in Person Act nice. So, you know, maybe a little a little Phoniness And Authenticity there, and i think it may be part of Vances M. O. Anyway. Yeah, there was certainly a sense among the Pundit Class that vance look, he was smooth. In terms of Performance And Style points, he was very good. The idea he won the first 88 minutes of the debate what lost the last two, and that was the moment he was asked about there, where he refused to say if trump lost in 2020, the Harris Team already turned that into an ad, do you think thats whats going to resonate in the days and weeks ahead . Well, look, at first i thought it was so funny, right, vance refuses to answer whether Donald Trump won in 2020, saying he doesnt want to relitigate the past. Then his next very next thing he said was and what about Kamala Harris in 2020, or something to that effect. So obviously his boss, Donald Trump, has no problem being obsessed with relitigating the past. Its not like a its a small thing. Indeed, i think the question of whether Donald Trump or Joe Biden actually won the 2020 election, may be one of the defining questions of our time. As to whether he gets away with it politically, i think if we were just if people just to watch the debate, he would, right . Because it came very late in the night. A lot of people had turned the channel. I think the real question is whether Kamala Harris campaign can make people see it by virtue of advertisements and Social Media. And if she cant do it, i think its pretty devastating. In coincidence that moment was followed up the next day by this Jack Smith filing being unsealed which unfazed Mike Pence was in danger during the January 6th riots and the like. This is, i dont know it qualifies as an October Surprise, but it certainly was a moment Trumps Conduct was going to be in the headlines again. Do you think its going to matter here as were now about a month before Election Day . On one hand im tempted to say its baked into the cake of people who think its bad what happened on January 6th are going to continue to think its bad, and Donald Trump supporters are going to continue to rationalize it. I have to tell you this anecdotally. I spoke to a friend in West Virginia Yesterday whos a Trump Supporter and asked him very earnestly why werent Mike Pence why isnt he the Running Mate, and i explained they wanted to kill Mike Pence, and so maybe there are some folks out there who that this could impact. Yeah, certainly the fundamental question about this campaign. Author, columnist, and conservative writer, matt lewis, thank you as always. Up next here were going to, ohio, and what he plans to do if he is reelected. Then, coming up on Morning Joe, weve got more live reporting from beirut, as israel continues its Ground Inflation in lebanon and weighs a response to irans massive Missile Attack. Plus, a panel of legal analysts is standing by with their takeaways from special Counsel Jack Smiths new filing in the January 6th case. Plus, former White House aide, cassidy hutchinson, who was a witness in the congressional investigation into the capitol attack, well weigh in on that, as well. Also ahead, were joined by Transportation Secretary pete buttigieg. Hell be a guest as the Dock Worker Strike enters its third day. Morning joe just a few moments away. And the engine finally roars the thing you care about most is a job well done. But when you get your tools from Harbor Freight Something about the job feels a little different your wallet. Because we believe no matter what youre working on you need high quality tools at a great price. And thats what were all about. Whatever you do, do it for less, at harbor freight. woman look i got the new iphone 16 pro at verizon. Apple intelligence is pretty awesome. man nice. woman you can get it when you trade in any phone. man whoa, whoa, whoa vo at verizon new and existing customers can get iphone 16 pro on us. When you trade in any phone in any condition. Only on verizon. Welcome back. In an interview with news nation, Donald Trump said if he wins in november, hed revoke the Temporary Protected Status granted to haitian migrants in springfield, ohio. In springfield, whats happening there is horrible. You have a beautiful community, 52,000 people. About 30,000 people were put into that community rapidly, and the community is so nice and they want to be so politically correct. You have to remove the people. You cannot we cannot destroy our country. You had a beautiful, safe community. Everyone is in love with everybody. Everything was nice. It was like a picture community. All of a sudden, in a short period of time, they have 32,000 more people in there. In my opinion, its not legal. Its not legal for anybody to do. Its not even on a human basis, its not acceptable. To the people that are there and certainly to the people that are in springfield. Springfield is a beautiful place. Have you seen whats happened to it . Its been overrun. You cant do that to people. They have to be removed. Lets be clear what this is. Trump is saying he is going to deport legal immigrants. Joining us now, Msnbc Contributor Mike Barnicle. Mike, thanks for being here. Lets talk about trumps rhetoric on immigration. Most of what he said there simply not true. Despite being told by fellow republicans, including the republican governor of ohio, he just will not let up his relentless bashing, relentless and, frankly, racist bashing of these immigrants. When we were showing the clip we just saw and listened to it, it causes me again to wonder, how many people, how many americans out there are going to shrug their shoulders and say, you know what . Im exhausted. This guy is exhausting me. This guy has been impeached twice. This guy has been Adjudicated A Rapist by a New York judge. This guy is a felon. Hes got five or six Felony Counts against him. This guy cannot tell the truth. This guy twists everything, a reality into something of his own concoction. I cant do it anymore. Im not going to vote for him. I voted for him in 16. They say voted for him in 20. How many americans are out there saying, no, i want to talk about my children going forward, their schools, the safety of the schools. I want to talk about grocery prices. I want to talk about Gas Prices. I do not want to listen to him. The exhaustion factor, i think, is real. Certainly, the Harris Campaign hopes it permeates the ballot box. At the same time, polls suggest that nearly half the country still on board with this, and Donald Trump has a one in two chance of winning. What does that say about who we are . Thats a great question, jonathan. I keep thinking that, you know, 10, 20 years from now when historians try to capture this period of time culturally, politically, what happened in this country, Theyll Look at what has happened and what is happening right in front of All Of Us right now, and theyll say, what was wrong with those people . What that they did not see, did not recognize . Such an indictment. Speaking of potential indictments, lets talk about Jack Smith. Yesterday, Unsealing A filing that had a lot of new details about Trumps Conduct, his efforts to overturn the 2020 election and his conduct on January 6th, particularly when it comes to Mike Pence, when it seemed that he was completely unmoved that his Vice President s life was in danger. Does this qualify as an October Surprise . No, i dont think so. I think it qualifies as recognizing that Judge Chutkan is saying to the Supreme Court, take this. No one agrees with the ruling you people concocted, that declared that every president has immunity from nearly everything. Take this. Its just a kernel of what Jack Smith has found, apparently. I dont know whether it has an impact or not. I dont think it is an October Surprise. The October Surprise will happen out of the Middle East. Lets revisit that in a second. On this, theres also an unnamed Trump Campaign Staffer who even said, make them riot, when there was some disturbances at a local campaign office. How much if you were counseling the Harris Campaign right now, how much would January 6th, defense of democracy, be one of your close arguments . It worked for democrats in 2020 and 2022. President biden drove that. Do you think its still that this time around . I do. I think every day, he will give you something else. Trump will give you something else. He will give you another gift in terms of running against him. Depends on how the Vice President packages it. Okay. Lets go back to the Middle East. Were awaiting what israels response will be to the iranian attack earlier this week. Its jewish new years. Maybe itll wait until after that. You eluded to it, that this could be something that changes the calculation domestically. Think thats what prime Minister Netanyahu has in mind . Given his behavior towards this administration, both outwardly and what you certainly hear in washington from people, what you pick up in terms of sources between netanyahu and President Biden, yeah, i think netanyahu has it in his mind that were going to attack iran. Were going to wipe out their oil refineries, which will cause Gas Prices to jump up here in the next two or three weeks. I dont care what Joe Biden thinks. Thats what he thinks, okay . But when you look at it on paper, youve got to ask yourself, realistically, seriously, his country was attacked by a nextdoor neighbor. If we were attacked, we would strike back very, very hard. I mean, i would hope we would. Thats what the israelis are doing. Its a tough balance, i think, to figure out both emotionally and politically for the united states of america. Well have live reporting from the Middle East in a moment on Morning Joe. Well see you on Morning Joe, as well. Really . Youll ask me on . You have to stay. It was a good booking for us. Wow. Msnbc contributor Mike Barnicle making his Morning Joe debut in a few moments. Wont Want Toiss that. Mike, thank you. And thank you for all of you getting up Way Too Early on this thursday morning. Morning joe starts right now. I dont believe that we have the luxury of writing in candidates