Economy. A source of frustration for voters nationally, even as a huge number of those same americans say their own financial situation is actually pretty good. So whats the Biden Campaign supposed to do with that . Well talk about it coming up. Plus, israels apologies, doing nothing to stem the global fury over the killing of seven aid workers. The white house calling for accountability are from netanyahus government, but are harsh words all there is, or will World Leaders actually act . And Donald Trumps last ditch attempt to get the judge in his Hush Money Trial to throw himself off the case. Could it work . We begin with whats both the most obvious key to winning in november and also the biggest conundrum. The u. S. Economy. We have brand new polling that gives us important insights into just how important it is. Even as joe biden focuses his Campaign Message on abortion and health care. And donald trump is stoking fears about migrants at his campaign stops. Its a border blood bath, and its destroying our country. Its a very bad thing happening. We will stop the plunder, rape, slaughter, and destruction of our american suburbs, cities and towns. Theyre not humans. Theyre animals. We dont want them coming into our country with contagious diseases and they have it. Trump also said hell have a statement on abortion next week to which biden respond, you already made your statement, donald. Both of those issues, the border and abortion clearly appealing to decided voters, but the new Wall Street Journal poll shows as much as a third of the electorate is undecided about how theyll vote, and thats where the conundrum comes in. While those voters are overwhelmingly unhappy with the national economy, when theyre asked about it in their own states, their own lives, theyre pretty happy. And statistics show theyre spending money, so whats going on . Inflation seemed untameable, 9 a few years ago, war in the middle east, war in europe, and we have these two candidates, trump and biden, who many people find uninspiring, and when we asked people how do you feel about the economy, how do you feel about things in general . Theres kind after general you could almost say malaise, and people are being asked to pick a choice at a time when the world seems unsteady and uncertain and neither of these candidates seems sure footed and able to guide us into the future. So there you have it. Well, results from four state primaries yesterday also show how the candidates have left voters as the Associated Press puts it underwhelmed. So garrett, donald trump doubling down, triple down on his rhetoric. I guess the question is when we look at those polls and how close it is, is the belief that is going to resonate with these swing voters . Well, chris, i think there are a couple of parts to this. First, for donald trump, that rhetoric is what has worked for him throughout his political career. Its very similar to the way he was talking when he first became a political candidate back in 2015, and he believes both it is exactly how he feels about these issues. He is speaking his true feelings on these matters and he thinks its going to to work a certain extent to basically try to scare voters back into his camp. I have reported on this show before that youre not going to see donald trump trying to reach out and kind of, you know, coddle the nikki haley Voting Segment of the republican party. Hes not going to try to build a bridge for them to come back across into the maga universe. What hes going to try to do is lower their opinion of joe biden and his policies so far that they feel like they have no choice but to come back to him. And on immigration, an issue in which hes the most comfortable going that dark and deep, you see that kind of rhetoric on the campaign trail. Chris, if you look at the polling included in that Wall Street Journal poll, it is to a certain degree working. Voters are saying they trust donald trump more than joe biden to deal with border issues. I mean, is that the problem really when you think about it, matthew . Because so far theres no indication in the polling that what biden is saying about immigration is working, and even when donald trump says things that are arguably racist, that are provably untrue, when you look at this, 52 to 32 , voters think hes best able to handle immigration and border security. Well, in my mind, the strategy of the biden effort is not to win on immigration. Its just to cut the margin that theyre losing on. He doesnt need to win on immigration. Hes not able to be beaten by 20 points on that issue, and so cut the margin, undercut donald trump to some degree. I think in the end as we examine these polls and were in april of 2024, and we look at this election landscape, the fascinating thing to me is nobody that is willing that it will give a prediction today should have any confidence in what that prediction will be because at this point in time it wouldnt be surprising if donald trump won the election and simultaneously it wouldnt be surprising if joe biden won this election when you look at all the polls in all the key states and nationally in the course of this, and this is interesting dynamic of this race to me and it talks about immigration is who is this race going to be about . I think the Biden Campaign wants to make it about donald trump, and i think the Trump Campaign wants to make it about joe biden. So theyre each going to be pointing their fingers across their chest saying this race is about that person and what the country is. I think right now this is a Coin Flip Race in the president ial race, and we dont normally have those kinds of race when is we head in six, seven months before election day. In fact, nancy, that Wall Street Journal poll does show biden and trump neck in neck in every swing state. The editor told msnbc it reveals that highly unsettled electorate, i mean, is the thought theyre going to settle down between now and november. He thinks that at least the indications in the poll are that those who say theyre undecided or Voting Third Party will ultimately come home to one of the major parties. I think this is a race and garretts going to have his job ahead of him, give a prediction for that, is that this is a race where moments in the next seven months are going to be more decisive than any political advertising thats done by the campaigns or any speeches done by the campaigns. Its going to be moments and their impact. It could be a Court Trial Result for donald trump. It could be an international event. It could be a sense that the economy is doing better or is doing worse, and then finally, if we have them, the debates could be exceedingly important. So to me this campaign is going to be the pivot on this Campaign Going from a dead even race to a four or fivepoint advantage race on either side is going to be decided by many of the unknown moments. Garrett, feel free to say whether you think thats what youre hearing as well. We do know for democrats, right, theyre putting a lot of their eggs in november into the abortion basket. Last night donald trump was asked about floridas sixweek ban. Mr. President , do you support the sixweek abortion ban that the Florida Supreme Court just upheld . Were going to make a statement next week on abortion. Were going to make a statement next week. They booed the reporter obviously in case theres any confusion about that. Trump said hes going to put it off until next week. Its not exactly an issue that has snuck up on them, so whats that about . Two things, first of all, i agree with matthew on the idea that this election could be decided by moments. Its one of the reasons you see trump trying to bait that might be enough for them to make a significant inroads and open up this race a little by on abortion specifically, this has long been an issue in which trump has been all over the map. He has taken almost every conceivable position on abortion over the course of his political and private career in business as a sort of Business Celebrity who remarked on just about everything prior to his political life. Of late his campaign has signaled hes probably going to land to try to leave this issue to the states. Which is not exactly a position on the issue of abortion at all. As we sauchb with him when he was President Trump and would push things off several weeks at a time. The reality is the abortion politics are not going to change here dramatically, and at some point hes going to either have to make a much more specific set of what his policies are on abortion or have the issue defined for him as the Biden Campaign has tried to do by pointing out that he appointed the justices who overturned Roe Versus Wade and bragged about it. Unless and until donald trump says something different, that will likely be the albatross hung around his neck by the Biden Campaign. Garrett haake and matthew dowd. Matthew, remember when being a flipflopper used to be a bad thing in american politics. Thank you both for being here. Abortion specifically and health care generally is a Driving Issue for democrats, and today even more specifically Prescription Drug prices, and this is interesting. It wasnt just the president in the treaty room of the white house talking about this today. He was joined by Bernie Sanders, the vermont senator is someone who progressive voters follow carefully and who is often pushing biden to go further to the left. But on lowering the cost of Prescription Drugs, they are on the same page. The very high cost of Prescription Drugs is not just an individual issue, what you pay. It is a taxpayer issue. It impacts all of us. Bernie, you and i have been fighting this for 25 years. Finally, finally we beat big pharma, finally. Joining us now the Domestic Policy Adviser to President Biden. Thanks for coming on neera. Look, in a country as divided as ours, the one thing a lot of folks agree on that the drugs cost too much, that big pharma makes too much. We just heard the president declare a win. Talk about where the white house believes the progress is and what do you say to voters who wonder, okay, the costs of some drugs are down, but when are you going to get to my drug . Were focused to getting to more and more drugs and more and more drugs that americans really rely on. Thats what the president s goal is is to reduce drug costs for all americans. So far we have made significant progress. The president talked about this today with Senator Sanders, the inflation reduction act, which democrats passed and no republican voted for, gave power to medicare to negotiate drug prices. They are negotiating ten drugs, some of the costliest drugs seniors face, and also theyve already reduced the price of insulin 35. That legislation is the law of the land. As i said, republicans want to rip it away. What the president talked about today with senator senator sand because of the action with this administration, other legislation weve passed and investigations launched by Senator Sanders, today we now have three of the four companies that produce inhalers committing to inhalers for asthma, 27 million americans rely on inhalers for asthma. Consumers pay 35 per inhaler when they buy it at the counter. So this is a big accomplishment, but its really from the pressure the president , his administration, and others like Senator Sanders have placed on pharma because they know they cant just get away with inordinate prices any longer. This is something youre doing. Look, the Washington Post, however let me just fact check. Republicans did not vote for this, but the Washington Post says polls have shown that most voters are unaware of democrats efforts to lower drug prices, so i mean, look, you have an event today at the white house and arguably Bernie Sanders might draw the interest of some progressives, but why hasnt what youve been saying, the president , democrats, have been saying resonating and do you have to change your messaing on this . Well, i think most importantly weve held a series of events over the last two weeks to get the message out. Thats also why its important for us to talk with reporters, to engage with you and others to really demonstrate the impact. The president had a person introduce him today, chris garcia. Chris garcia pays 160 for one inhaler and 60 for another inhaler a month. Those inhalers cost basically 5 to make. Thats just too much cost for people. They dont have the Breathing Room. The president really focuses on Prescription Drugs because he knows this is a cost people are bearing. Sometimes seniors are taking one pill instead of two. He understands the pressure that is, the lack of Breathing Room people have. Thats why were going to keep talking about these issues because we know they matter. We hope that reporters will keep covering them because we know they matter, and thats how we get the word out to the country, and of course im sure there will be a campaign. Im not speaking to the campaign. Im im detained by the hatch act here, but i know the campaign, imagine the campaign will be running plenty of ads on this issue going forward. Neera tanden, thanks so much, appreciate you coming on the program. In 60 seconds, will israel do anything as global outrage grows over the deaths of seven humanitarian aid workers in those air strikes. Will President Biden . Were live in tel aviv. Will President Biden were live in tel aviv youll never truly forget migraine, but zeromigraine days are possible. Dont take if allergic to qulipta. Most common side effects are nausea, constipation and sleepiness. Qulipta. The forgetyougetmigraine medicine. vo if you have graves disease. Qulipta. And itchy eyes, the truth may be even more uncomfortable. People with graves could also get thyroid eye disease, or ted, which may need a different doctor. Find a ted Eye Specialist at isitted. Com. My names dan and i live here in san antonio, texas. I ran my own Hvac Business and now im retired. Im not good being retired. Im a pain in the neck. I like to be able to have a purpose. About three or four years ago, i wasnt feeling as if i was as sharp as i used to be. I saw the prevagen commercials. After a short amount of time taking prevagen, i started noticing a difference that im remembering this, im remembering that. I stopped taking prevagen and i found myself slacking back so i jumped right back on it. Prevagen. At stores everywhere without a prescription. From World Leaders to the halls of congress to everyday americans, outrage is building over israels air strikes that killed seven World Central Kitchen workers. Seven dedicated humanitarians apparently now galvanizing opinion in a way that even the deaths of more than 200 other aid workers and as many as 32,000 palestinians hasnt. Part of it may be the outright rejection in many corridors of israels claim that the strike was a tragic mistake. This is really tragic and not normal. I think we had to say that. I heard Prime Minister netanyahu in his statement say these things happen in war, no, they dont. World central kitchen founder jose andres who nancy pelosi nominated for a nobel prize, echoes the skepticism. He writes Prime Minister netanyahu has said of the israeli killings of our team, it happens in war. It was a direct attack on clearly marked vehicles whose movements were known by the Israel Defense forces. The oped, by the way, is also in an israeli publication in he hebrew. For joe biden it adds pressure to put conditions on aid to israel even as the Administration Pushes to send more military assistance, including 15 fighter jets. Joining us now nbcs Raf Sanchez Reporting from tel aviv. Geoff bennett is coanchor of pbss news hour and an msnbc political contributor. Hagar chemali is former spokesperson for the u. S. Mission to the u. N. And former syria and lebanon director at the white house. Its good to have all of you here. Raf, they have done a preliminary investigation into what went wrong. What do we know, and what questions are still unanswered . Reporter a lot of questions still unanswered, chris. Heres where things stand right now. The head of the Israeli Military, the Chief Of Staff of the idf says that this preliminary investigation niends what happened here was a case of misidentification, that israeli aircraft believed that these humanitarian vehicles posed some kind of threat. He said this mistake, repeating that word mistake, happens at night in a complex wartime environment. He says he is committed to a transparent investigation, and that the Israeli Military will publish its full findings once that probe is completed. The big question, though, still outstanding, how can it be that world Central Commission communicated the movements of that convoy to the Israeli Military ahead of time and yet was still struck, those seven aid workers still killed. Our Unbelievable Bli Courageous Crew Inside Of Gaza went to the coastal road, and they went to each of those three ruined vehicles, the kind of charred remains still lying there. What they found is that this was three separate air strikes. They took part they happened over the course of a 1. 5mile stretch of that road, and so what did not happen here is a case of these vehicles being in the wrong place, wrong time, all bunched together, they somehow got caught in the cross fire as the israelis hit a hamas target. Each of these vehicles appears to have been struck very precisely by israeli aircraft. If the israelis believed it was some kind of hamas vehicle they would strike it. Precisely what is not clear is what happened that led them to believe that. That is one of the many questions being asked by the white house, by World Central Kitchen and by the families of those aid workers. Theyre bodies just crossed over from gaza into egypt beginning the long journey home. Chris. So hagar, that really is the key question so many people are asking, right . How did this happen. How cause the same organization that was able to do what they did in syria, taking out the Iranian NationalRevolutionary Guard members, very sophisticated operation, extremely targeted, do this to . Whats your question and will israel get to the bottom of it . Well, israel might get to the bottom of it whether we see the full details of that investigation is another story, how much they publicly share is another story. The fact is that democratic governments and professional militaries are supposed to have the communications and Protocol System in place to prevent these types of trageies or accidents or however whatever happened, theyre supposed to have a system in place to prevent it. When netanyahu came out and said this happens in war, listen, i handled the syria war at the white house. This does happen in war, but it should not have happened in this war, and the reason for that is that youre not dealing with a murderous dictator or brutal regime. Youre dealing with a democratic government with a supposedly professional military. What this all tells me is that the idf is utterly sloppy, lacks values and discipline and clearly has significant disfunction to the point where the left hand doesnt know what the right hand is doing in moments of emergencies or where somebody who has a trigger doesnt know whats going on. When youve got Something Like what happened in damascus, that was clearly very planned, very targeted. They had an opportunity that presented itself and a reason for which they went after that iranian top commander. Youve seen this in the gaza war already. Part of it is the as you mentioned, over 200 humanitarian aid workers who have already died, but you also had, for example, the story where three hostages were killed by accident, by a troop on the ground. That, again, it reflects a sloppiness, a lack of discipline, a lack of values, and just dysfunction that shouldnt exist this a professional military under a democratic government. We are hearing, geoff, as you know, from leaders all around the world, President Biden has said he is outraged and heartbroken by this incident. It is also some people critically point out, not the first time weve heard him Say Something along those lines related to gaza, but as Richard Haass pointed out on morning joe, so far that hasnt resulted in a change in policy. Heres what he said. At some point the words become empty and the Biden Administration is very close to having reached a point where their criticism of israel is too much for the same people who criticized chuck schumer, but its not nearly enough to affect the course of what is going on. That is the worst of all possible worlds. Is there any sign from the white house on capitol hill that this incident could be a Turning Point in the u. S. Approach to israel . Not yet, chris. Not at least as it comes to applying conditions to u. S. Aid to israel with some democratic lawmakers have suggested. Weve seen President Biden criticize israels handing of the war, to Implore Israel to stop the civilian casualties. The relationship between President Biden and israeli Prime MinisterBenjamin Netanyahu is as complicated as it is long. These two men have known each other for some 40 years back when joe biden was the junior senator from delaware and netanyahu was actually here in this country working his way through leadership in the Israeli Embassy here in washington, d. C. , and the two rose to power through parallel tracks. So the reason i raise that is because President Biden is someone, hes an old school politician who believes that the personal relationship accounts for a lot. And so over the last few weeks and months, there has been this question of is his level of influence limited . How much sway does he actually have where the Israeli Government is apparently ignoring his pleas and protestations. It has as much to do with netanyahus long willingness and calculated willingness to really ignore his american counterpart rather than accommodate him, chris. To follow up on that point, within israel were seeing massive protests against netanyahu. Last night police used Water Cannons to break up a riot. Today families of the hostages disrupted a meeting of the ka ka nus set. Does any of this from what President Biden has to say, to what were seeing to canesset on the streets of israel and frankly, the comments in the last 24, 48 hours from World Leaders any indication you see Benjamin Netanyahu cares about what anybody has to say or do . I dont want to sugar tote cote it for you, chris. I dont expect a lot to come from this pressure, which is going to reach a fever pitch for an immediate cease fire, even if its temporary. What youre going to have in gaza immediately unfortunately is that the hunger crisis is going to get worse because World Central Kitchen and many other Aid Organizations have suspended their operations. You have as you pointed out, you have the families of hostages who have been really quite have been increasing pressure on the government for a while now and have been very unhappy with netanyahu and his priorities and his lack of prioritizing the release of hostages. So this pressure is now going to reach fever pitch, especially you saw it from the white house yesterday with President Bidens statement. What i have seen in my experience in working with the Israeli Government and i worked very closely with the Israeli Government, is that international support, while they are very grateful for international support, the psyche of the Israeli Government is not one that feels that it exists because of of international support. It feels it exists because theyre out there on their own and that is a psyche that has been built in since world war ii. I dont blame them for that psyche. When you hear President Biden and you heard former President Trump say this to israelis, you risk losing international support, i dont believe that that will be a very compelling Talking Point. The Talking Point that needs to be made is we care about your longterm stability and security, and were telling you this because we care and because the United States is an important friend to israel, and israel does know that and values that, and the aid that we give to israel could become conditional, and the Biden Administration doesnt want to risk Congress Going down that path. So for israels sake, netanyahu needs to listen to that pressure and both sides hopefully the pressure will increase to the point where both sides reach a cease fire, even if temporary, immediately. Hagar cemali and geoff bennett, thank you both so much. Heres another one to file under theres never been anything quite like this. What our experts are saying about the trump legal teams new efforts to delay his Hush Money Trial and the special prosecutors blistering response. Youre watching Chris Jansing reports only on msnbc. Watching reports only on msnbc the fuel you need to take flight. Cirkul is the energy that gets you to the next level. Cirkul is what you hope for when life tosses lemons your way. Cirkul, available at walmart and drinkcirkul. Com. You know whats brilliant . Boring. Think about it. Boring is the unsung catalyst for bold. What straps bold to a rocket and hurtles it into space . Boring does. Boring makes vacations happen, early retirements possible, and startups start up. Because its smart, dependable, and steady. All words you want from your bank. For nearly 160 years, pnc bank has been brilliantly boring so you can be happily fulfilled. Which is pretty unboring if you think about it. christina with Verizon Business unlimited, i get 5g, truly unlimited data, and unlimited hotspot data. So, no matter what, im running this kitchen. vo make the switch. Its your business. Its your verizon. Business. Its not a ninetofive proposition. Its all day and into the night. Its all the things that keep this world turning. The gotos that keep us going. The places we cheer. And check in. They all choose the advanced Network Solutions and round the Clock Partnership from Comcast Business. See why Comcast Business powers more Small Businesses than anyone else. Get started for 49. 99 a month plus ask how to get up to an 800 prepaid card. Dont wait call today. Donald trumps lawyers are undaunted trying once again to stop his Hush Money Trial before it even starts. Theyre launching a new legal bid to get the judge off the case and push the trial off indefinitely. Trumps legal team arguing that judge juan merchan has a conflict because his daughter has worked for a Political Firm linked to joe biden. This is the second time theyve tried this, and it did not work last summer, so its unclear how it might work now. Paul butler is a former federal prosecutor, Georgetown Law Professor and msnbc legal analyst. Lisa rubin is an msnbc legal correspondent. Okay, lisa, can you explain the trump teams argument here and whether theres anything to it . So i can do my best, and ill play an advocate for them right now as to why theyre renewing this. They did move last year for judge merchans recusal, on the basis that judge merchans daughter is the leader of a political Digital Strategy firm that among other clients has the Biden Harris Campaign and done work for congressman adam schiff. Their argument at the time was that historically that firm had made a number of arguments that were sort of antithetical to President Trump, that it had advocated for people who were his political enemies and as such, there was a conflict between her and them, such that the judge himself needed to recuse. Thats because new york statutes call for recusal where somebody whos a sixth degree relative, not just a first degree or a second degree, up to a sixdefinitely relative has an interest that would be substantially affected by the case. The ethics board of New York State said there was not a problem. They are now saying they have new information about her Political Activities from that point to date. However, in the premotion letter that think sent him earlier this week, they are still not drawing a direct nexus between her work and any campaigns that the firm has been involved in that have created digital fundraising solicitations, for example, premised on this manhattan indictment. If they do that on the other hand, i think they will have been able to show changed circumstances. Will it be enough to show that she has an interest thats substantially affected by this case. Its a different argument than the one they made last year. Trumps lawyers tried this last august and failed. The judge checked with the state ethics board. Everythings okay. Trumps lawyers say again, as was just pointed out, that things have changed. The d. A. Says they really havent. What do you say . The Ethics Committee said that no reasonable person could think that the judges daughters job would bear any influence on trumps case. That was true last year and it remains true today, so there is zero chance that the judge will recuse himself. This is nothing but a doover, but again, nothing significant has changed. It seems like a bunch of effort to throw a bunch of paperwork at the prosecutors to distract them for preparing for trial which is less than two weeks away. So just so we understand what happens now, is it solely up to the judge whether this warrants recusal or not . Yes, not only is it solely up to the judge, this isnt even a motion for a recusal. They already made that motion, so theyd have to get special permission from the judge to bring a new motion. I think hes likely to deny that. Chris, this is another example of Trump Lending his criminal cases and president ial campaign, his trial will be over in early summer. There will be months to go before the election. If trump is convicted, he will need to explain himself as the first Convicted Felon whos a major candidate for president. He will probably use the judges refusal to recuse himself as a Talking Point and claim that the judge was biased based on his daughters job. The gag order is going to expire when the trial is done so trump would then be free to attack the judges daughter at will. Paul butler, lisa rubin, to be continued as we always say. Thank you both. And coming up, the three major hurdles now confronting former President Trump in arguably the most crucial battleground state. Steve kornacki standing by at the big board for us to break it all down next. D for us to breakt all down next. Restaurant Noise introducing allisons Plaque Psoriasis. She thinks her flaky gray patches are all people see. Otezla is the 1 prescribed pill to treat Plaque Psoriasis allison over here otezla can help you get clearer skin and reduce itching and flaking. With no routine blood tests required. Doctors have been prescribing otezla for nearly a decade. Otezla is also approved to treat psoriatic arthritis. Dont use otezla if youre allergic to it. Serious allergic reactions can happen. Otezla may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. Some people taking otezla had depression, suicidal thoughts or weight loss. Upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. With clearer skin girls day out is a good day out. Live in the moment. Ask your doctor about otezla. Ohhh crap. Now we gotta get france something. Wait we can use etsys new gift mode alright. Done. Plateau de fromage oh la la dont panic. Gift easy with gift mode, new on etsy. psst psst ahhh with flonase, allergies dont have to be scary. Spray Flonase Sensimist daily for nondrowsy long lasting relief in a scent free, gentle mist. Flonase all good. Also, try our Allergy Headache and nighttime pills. My frequent heartburn had me taking antacid after antacid all day long but with prilosec otc just one pill a day blocks heartburn for a full 24 hours. For one and done heartburn relief, prilosec otc. One pill a day, 24 hours, zero heartburn. If youre living with hiv, imagine being good to go without daily hiv pills. Good to go off the grid. Good to go nonstop. With cabenuva, theres no pausing for daily hiv pills. For adults who are undetectable, cabenuva is the only complete, longacting Hiv Treatment you can get every other month. Its two injections from a healthcare provider. Just 6 times a year. Dont receive cabenuva if youre allergic to its ingredients or if youre taking certain medicines which may interact with cabenuva. Serious side effects include allergic reactions, postinjection reactions, liver problems, and depression. If you have a rash and other allergic reaction symptoms, stop cabenuva and get medical help right away. Tell your doctor if you have liver or kidney problems, Mental Health concerns, and if you are pregnant, breastfeeding or considering pregnancy. Some of the most common side effects include injectionsite reactions, fever, and tiredness. With cabenuva, youre good to go. Ask your doctor about switching. reporters kev kev kev with cabenuva, reporter 1 good to go. Any response to the trade rumors, we keep hearing about . kev we talkin about moving . Not the trade, not the trade, we talking about movin. No thank you. reporter 2 you could use opendoor. Sell your house directly to them, its easy. kev . I guess were movin judge levins out, the city council in eed any, oklahoma, who was revealed to have White Nationalist ties. Not only did voters given him the boot, judd blevins lost by 19 points. More people turned out for the recall vote than the initial election last year. Thats according to unofficial results from the oklahoma election board. Blevins will be replaced by cheryl patterson, a former teefrm who campaigned on a term to normalcy. Its the Tipping Point state, wisconsin, arguably the most important of all the battlegrounds for joe biden, at least according to jim messina, the guy who helped barack obama win reelection. Donald trump held an event there last night. His campaign billed it as the launch of his general election effort. Easy to understand why when you look at the last two president ials, when wisconsin was decided by less than 1 . But can trump do what he couldnt do the last time he ran against biden, which is win it . Nbcs Steve Kornacki has been looking at the political geography of the state. I know youve identified three big hurdles confronting trump in wisconsin. Youre right on the significance, a lot of Electoral College scenarios run straight through wisconsin. Just as a reminder, joe biden did win the state in 2020. Look how narrow it was. 6 10 of a point, thats about 20,000 votes. The difference between biden and trump, and while this was a difference overall from four years earlier when trump won it, it wasnt a huge difference. Take a look at that map from 2016 when trump won. It was razor thin, 7 10 of one point was it was about 23,000 votes. There was a net shift of about 43 excuse me, about 43,000 votes between 2016 and 2020. That was the difference between trump carrying it and biden carrying it. So the three areas were talking about here where trump kind of lost the state for trump in 20, he needs to make improvements in at least some of them if hes going to have a chance. Lets take you through them quickly. The biggest barrier hes got and the hardest one hes going to have making any progress with is right here, dane county, the state capital, University Of Wisconsin is here. This county is getting bigger by population, and its getting bluer and bluer in its politics. You can see in 2020, biden won this by over 52 points over trump. Compared to 2016, still overwhelmingly blue. That was 47 . Democrats are squeezing more and more, bigger and bigger margins out of dane county and demographically it just fits the profile of the antitrump voter. You can expect, if anything, i think, democrats have a chance to do even better in dane. That puts the pressure on trump to find other improvements elsewhere on the map. Where might he look . One area thats critical to him, we talk about the suburbs, we talk about how trump has struggled in the suburbs given away a lot of ground there. This is a big one outside milwaukee. Trump won it by 21 points in 2020. Look at the trajectory. This is 2020, heres 2016, trump won it by 27. Mitt romney was winning this county by nearly 35 points in 2012, all the way down to 21 in 2020. So this is a big suburban county, and with trump, republicans are winning it, but theyre not winning it by the margins, nearly the margins they used to in the past. This is the kind of place where trumps got to improve. I think thats critical if hes going to flip the state. Critical for democrats if theyre going to keep him from flipping the state. A number of small midsized cities. Brown county where green bay is, lacrosse county, places that donald trump made big gains in when he won the state in 2016. Ill show you brown county here. Lets go inside. Donald trump in 2016 won this county by 11 points. That was a big shift in the republicans direction. This is where green bay is. This a big part of the reason trump was able to win wisconsin in 2016. Trump won it again in 2020. He only won by seven points. Doubledigits down to 7 points. This was a place of growth for trump in 16, Regression In 20. Again, theres a number of counties like this around the state, and they start to add up. Again, for trump, hes got to stop the slide and move closer to his 2016 levels in counties like that, brown county where green bay is, suburbs of milwaukee, midsized cities, small cities. Those are the places trump has the opportunities to reverse the result in 2020, thats where democrats need to stop him. Fascinating stuff, Steve Kornacki, thank you. When your boss calls after hours, do you feel like you have to pick up . And will california make it so that you can ignore the boss. Well explain that next. And in our next hour, a Disaster Scene in kentucky, tornados tearing through the state, ripping roofs off of homes and where Cleanup Efforts now stand. Thats coming up. S now stand. Thats cinomg up i know what its like to perform through pain. If youre like me, one of the millions suffering from pain caused by migraine, Nurtec Odt May help. Its the only medication that can treat a migraine when it strikes and prevent migraine attacks. Treat and prevent, all in one. Dont take if allergic to nurtec. Allergic reactions can occur, even days after using. Most common side effects were nausea, indigestion, and stomach pain. Relief is possible. Talk to a doctor about nurtec odt. With Schwab Investing themes™, its easy to invest in ideas you believe in. Spot a trend in electric vehicles . Have a passion for Online Gaming . Or want to explore the Space Economy . Choose from over 40 themes, each with up to 25 stocks identified by our unique algorithm. Buy it asis or customize to align with your goals. All at your fingertips. Schwab investing themes. 40 customizable themes. Up to 25 stocks in just a few clicks. vo if you have graves disease. Up to 25 stocks in just a few clicks. Gritty eyes could be more than a rough patch. People with graves could also get thyroid eye disease, or ted, which may need a different doctor. Find a ted Eye Specialist at isitted. Com. Sara federico at st. Jude, we dont care who cures cancer. We just need to advance the cure. The heart of st. Jude is to take care of children with catastrophic diseases and to advance their cure rates. But we need to be able to do that for everyone. Its a bold initiative, to try and bump cure rates all around the world. But we should. It is our commitment. [music playing] when you put in the effort, but it starts to frizz. You skipped a step. Tresemme silk serum. Use before styling for three days of weightlessly smooth hair that frizz cant beat. New tresemme keratin smooth collection. We are now a step closer to an Appeals Court decision on whether texas can enforce the controversial Immigration Law that gives state and local Law Enforcement the power to deport undocumented migrants. An attorney defending the rule admitted on the record texas lawmakers may have gone too far when passing it. Nbcs ken dilanian is following this story. So, ken, what are the other takeaways from today, and What Happens Next . Chris, that same lawyer for the state of texas also is accused of rewriting the law from the lectern when he put forward the idea of instead of deporting migrants, texas police could send them back to u. S. Customs and Border Protection facilities at ports of entry thereby complying somewhat better with existing Supreme Court precedent. It was kind of a mess for texas. These same judges had already raised constitutional questions about this law in the injunction phase, now theyre hearing it on the merits. Theres one conservative judge on this threejudge panel that appeared sympathetic to texas. The other two did not. What happens next, assuming that this Appeals Court declares that this law is unconstitutional, it undoubtedly will be appealed to the Supreme Court which ruled back in 2012 that immigration is a national function, not a state function, but this does give the conservative Supreme Court another chance at the issue to tinker around the edges and modify, and see if theres things that states could do. The general argument from the u. S. Government, the Biden Administration, you cant have 50 separate immigration policies, the federal government needs to enforce Immigration Law. A Texas Plant At Cal Main Foods which is the countrys largest Egg Manufacturer is shut down today after chickens tested positive for bird flu. The virus is wreaking havoc elsewhere too. Last month, a baby goat contracted it on a farm in minnesota after living with infected chickens. It spread to entire cow herds in texas and kansas, and usda found more sick cows in idaho yesterday. What does this mean for people . Right now, there are two confirmed human cases in the u. S. And the cdc says the risk to humans remains low. Now to a major new Bill Proposal Out of california. A democratic lawmaker is pushing for a disconnect for workers from their bosses when theyre not on company time. Nbcs emilie ikeda dug into the movement and the politician behind it. Reporter as the digital age blurs workplace boundaries, theres a push to give employees the right to ignore emails, texts and calls after hours. Calling me on my day off is beyond me. Reporter while similar laws have already been enacted in some other countries, california could become the first u. S. State to require employers to give their workers the right to disconnect during nonworking hours, unless explicitly noted or in the case of an emergency, violations could be punishable by a fine. It would be nice to not even have the stress of thinking someone might call you. It would be probably good for your Mental Health. Reporter California Assembly member matt haney penned the bill. You shouldnt because you have a smartphone be expected o work 24 7 without consenting to that. Reporter the overlap of work and personal life has been turbo charged by the pandemic. Pew Research Reports the majority of workers respond to messages outside of their normal hours, at least sometimes. 28 do so often. I understood what i was signing on for. Reporter john ferrari makes himself available on the clock for a tech start up in silicon valley, but says he gets flexibility in return. Im contacted on a regular basis, often multiple times a day, and we operate our company like a family, so im available whenever my family needs me. Emilie ikeda with that report. Thats sure to spark the lot of discussion. You know, theres always the, oh, my battery died excuse. Coming up, tragedy overseas, taiwan got rocked by the strongest earthquake it has seen in 25 years. Weve got an update on the desperate search for survivors ahead. Survivors ahead. Limu emu and doug hello, ghostbusters. Its doug. Of doug and limu. We help people customize and Save Hundreds on Car Insurance with liberty mutual. Anyway, we got a bit of a situation here. Uhhuh. Uhhuh. [ metal groans] sure, i can hold. Only pay for what you need. Liberty Liberty LibertyLiberty Ghostbusters frozen empire. In theaters now. You know whats brilliant . Boring. Think about it. Boring is the unsung catalyst for bold. What straps bold to a rocket and hurtles it into space . Boring does. Boring makes vacations happen, early retirements possible, and startups start up. Because its smart, dependable, and steady. All words you want from your bank. For nearly 160 years, pnc bank has been brilliantly boring so you can be happily fulfilled. Which is pretty unboring if you think about it. Im adding downy unstopables to my wash. Now ill be smelling fresh all day long. [sniff] still fresh. Get 6x longerlasting freshness, plus odor protection. Try for under 5 [stomach growling] its nothing. Sounds like something. When you have nausea, heartburn, indigestion upset stomach, diarrhea pepto bismol coats and soothes for fast relief when you need it most. Nice to meet ya. My name is david. Ive been a pharmacist for 44 years. When i have customers come in and ask for something for memory, i recommend prevagen. Number one, because its effective. Does not require a prescription. And ive been taking it quite a while myself and i know it works. And i love it when the customers come back in and tell me, david, that really works so good for me. Makes my day. Prevagen. At stores everywhere without a prescription. Youre probably not easily persuaded to switch makes my day. Mobile providers for your business. But what if we told you its possible that Comcast Business mobile can save you up to 75 a year on your wireless bill versus the big three carriers . You can get two unlimited lines for just 30 each a month. All on the most reliable 5g Mobile Network nationwide. Wireless that works for you. For a limited time, ask how to save up to 830 off an eligible 5g phone when you switch to Comcast Business mobile. Dont wait call, click or visit an xfinity store today. Its good to be back with you on this second hour of Chris Jansing reports. At this hour, new accusations after that Deadly Strike on aid workers in gaza. What were now hearing from World Central Kitchen including the emotional comments from its founder, chef jose