Transcripts For MSNBCW Ana 20240704

Out for tiktok . The new plea from tiktoks ceo as a bill that could ban the app moves from the house to the senate. Plus, Jury Deliberations under way in the historic trial of James Crumbley. Could the father of a Michigan School shooter also be found guilty . And later, Weather Extremes. A Big Winter Storm Wallops colorado, and the east sees record warm weather. Thanks for joining us. It is 10 00 eastern, im Ana Cabrera Reporting from new york. We begin with the Breaking News out of florida this morning where former President Trump has just arrived at a federal courthouse. Hes there in a bid to get his maralago classified documents case dismissed. There are no cameras at this hearing, but we have a team inside ready to report out the details as we get them. Joining us from outside that courthouse, nbcs dasha burns. Also with us, msnbc Legal Correspondent lisa ruben, former new york assistant attorney general tristan snell, and former federal prosecutor michael zelden. Thank you for joining us. Dasha, trumps lawyers have filed all kinds of motions to dismiss in this case, in others. But todays hearing addresses two of those motions. What are the arguments . Reporter yeah, thats exactly right. Two motions. The first has to do with the president ial records act which governs the preservation of information during and after presidency. The second has to do with a rule called unconstitutional vagueness. So when it comes to the president Al Records Act The Trump Team is going to argue that trump had, quote, Unreviewable Discretion when he was president to designate certain materials as personal, and trump says that the materials found at maralago he did designate as personal while he was in office. Now Special Counsel jack smith says that those records are undisputably president ial, so thats likely the thrust of the argument youll hear from the other side. Now in the second motion, the trump team will argue that the main statute used against trump here is unconstitutionally vague. And thats a constitutional rule that requires criminal laws to state explicitly and definitely which conduct is punishable. And jack smith here again argues this is a basements claim on the baseless claim on part of the trump team, that this law is clear regarding unlawful and willful detention of documents. Ill let our legal team get into the details of what this all means and the implications here, but ill tell you the scene on site, weve got a lot of media here, Trump Supporters this direction, this direction playing two different sound tracks that are reminiscent of a trump rally. Weve got ymca on on one side and folks out to show support, a few dozen or so people with trump flags and trump paraphernalia to show support for the former president. With all that noise, you stayed focused in explaining what todays hearing is about. Thanks. Michael, i want to get your assessment of these two motions to dismiss the charges against trump here. So one, his lawyers say hes protected by the president ial records act. And they argue that he designated the records at maralago as personal. Now in the second motion, they claim the main statute that the Special Counsel is using here against trump is constitutionally vague as it applies to president s. Do you think trumps team has valid arguments for either of these . I dont. I think that the president ial records act is pretty clear on its face as to what is official records of the United States and what can be designated as personal records. And if you remember that what was in the contents of the box, there were a lot of newspapers and Wrestling Belts and all that stuff is personal. But when it comes to classified documents, those are government documents, and he cant designate them as personal. He can while president try to declassify them, but that doesnt make them personal either. Similarly, with respect to the vagueness claim, this claim i think also doesnt bear scrutiny because i think the law is pretty clear on its face what is it intending to allow, what can the defendant know in order to defend himself on it, and just as we saw in georgia yesterday where they dismiss on counts for lack of clarity, i think this does not reach even that standard which could be cured. So i think that he loses on both. And tristan, a reminder of the contents of these documents that were found there at maralago. Jack smith says that they include weapons capabilities of both the u. S. And foreign countries, u. S. Nuclear programs, potential vulnerabilities of the u. S. And its allies, and plans for possible retaliation in response to a foreign attack. And trumps trying to argue that these are personal . Who among us does not have these kind of personal records lying around our apartments and houses . I mean, i often have Nuclear Records stashed away as personal mementos. This is insane. So i really feel like that argument i hope that that gets treated with the derision that it decision. I dont know that it will be, but i really hope that thats the case because thats just an absolutely insane argument. Is the constitutionally vagueness argument, lisa, more murky to you . I think it has some facial appeal, but the parts of it that hes claiming are unconstitutional vague, when you look at the case law and look at the statute as its been applied, that doesnt hold water either. For example, one of the phrases in this statute that he says is unconstitutionally vague is what it means to have National Defense information. It may be that there is some vagary about what constitutes National Security defense information, ana, but the charges here that hes trying to dismiss, counts one through 32 of this indictment, involve classified documents. I think we could agree that any document that has a topsecret or sci clearance here, as many of these do, and all of them are some level of classification, are inherently National Defense information. Especially if its related to u. S. Nuclear programs, satellite. So as applied, i dont think that that argument really will carry weight. I want to go back to the statute, the argument that tristan was talking about about the president ial records act because theres a different barrier there. Theres a factual issue, too. Donald trump is saying i cant be held criminally responsible because i designated all of these records as personal. Thats an issue of fact that should be left to the fact finder at a later stage of criminal proceedings. Thats not an appropriate issue for a motion to dismiss which is really supposed to be just about the law, meaning assuming all the facts alleged by the government are true, is there a crime that has been sufficiently alleged so as to warrant a trial. Whereas here hes saying i designated all of these as personal, theres no proof that happened. Hes asking court take my word for it, assume i am telling the truths. Thats not the way a motion to dismiss in a federal court is supposed to work. Tristan, were told this could take all day. The judge told both parties be ready to spend the day here in court. Trumps there voluntarily. He doesnt have to be there. Do you see a legal reason for him to be there . Theres really never a legal reason for him to be there at any of these things. He is there to we have to remember that hes there because the people bankrolling all of his legal fees are his base. So he needs to show up, look like hes being the victim and being persecuted. s this whole selfpitying act that hes been doing for months and months now at all of these trials and hearings. Thats why hes there. Hes there for crowd funding. Michael, cnn just spoke to a longtime maralago employee who says hes a witness in this case. Nbc news hasnt confirmed that. He declined to speak to us. Heres hay bit of what he told a little bit of what he told cnn. You noticed that he had boxes. They were the boxes that were in the indictment the white bankers boxes. Thats what i remember loading. Reporter did you have any idea at the time that there was potentially u. S. National security secrets in those boxes . No clue. No i had no clue. I think the American People have the right to know the facts that this is not a witch hunt. Michael, how damaging could that be to trumps case . Well, whats more damaging i dont think that that matters to his case so much substantively. What is more damaging is the fact that he came forward because theres a fear that judge cannon is going to release the names of all these government witnesses, and theyre going to be subject to the types of true persecution by trumps fans. He comes forward to say, look, im fearful the judge is going to out me, and id rather get out in front of it before. Thats what smith is really worried about. Not whether his testimony bears some Material Impact on his ability to obtain a conviction. But rather that these witnesses are now going to be intimidated, and thats at the heart of what smith is calling plain error on the part of the judge if she releases it. And that if she does, that will be subject to an appeal to the 11th circuit by smith, im sure. Lisa, does this employee speaking out now have any impact on the Special Counsels strategy i dont know about the strategy, but i want to go back to something that michael said because i think its important. The Special Counsel has asked judge cannon to reconsider an order that shes already issued that calls for the unsealing of multiple witness or potential witness names as well as information about the contents of the prospective testimony. Theyve asked her to reconsider the order. In she denies them, and she hasnt ruled yet, that information goes in the public domain. The argument is these folks who are known to each of the three defendants because theyve received materials in discovery would then be subjected to harassment by people who support the former president. When someone like brian butler identifies himself as trump employee number five and goes forward, he is undermining the Special Counsels argument that the rest of the witnesses need to be protected. Now, his argument was im doing this because i know its coming. But nonetheless, you could see how judge cannon, if shes leaning against the government, and by all indications she is from the Oral Argument that she had on this motion, you can see how she might use his interview to say theres no indication that witnesses here are uncomfortable, you know, to the contrary. Trump employee number five has spoken out publicly on a Cable News Network where he spoke for 30 minutes at length with the host about that experience. But it should be their choice. Yes. Right . Butler chose to come forward. He shouldnt get to speak for or think for the other couple of dozen people. Thats the thing that would really be a travesty here. Again, you raise a very important point that i think needs to be really emphasized. Trump and his lawyers have this information. Thats the thing that due process really requires is that the defendant had the information with which he is going to be tried. Quickly. When do you think well know a trial start date here . Originally it was set sort of just out there in may, like it wasnt a firm date. So then the Special Counsel came back at the last hearing and said can we get this going in july . Trumps team throughout a date in august. Do you think this is going to happen in the next few months . I dont. And this is because the argument that were having today is on two motions to dismiss. Trump has filed a total of seven motions, some of which are under seal because they pertain to classified information. There are two other defendants here, they also have motions on the table. Judge cannon saying shes going to hold an Oral Argument to two motions that the parties should expect to last all day, i think shes going to go through the motions and see if shes going to toss the case before setting a trial date. In the interim eventually that allows the Supreme Court time to consider the president ial immunity case where Oral Argument is scheduled for april 25th. My thanks to all of you. When were back in 60 seconds, will the senate pass a bill that could ban tiktok . And how the apps ceo is trying to stop it. Plus, bidens Rustbelt Swing as he looks to build a blue buffer against trump in november. Then chaos in haiti. Inside the harrowing efforts to flee the countrys Gang Violence and what it could mean for the u. S. Were also tracking tornadoes in the midwest, temperatures 15 degrees above normal in the northeast, and the biggest snowstorm colorado has seen in three years. Youre watching ana cabrera reports. Were back in one minute. Were e [car door shuts] [paparazzi taking pictures] introducing, neds plaque psoriasis. Ned, ned, who are you wearing . He thinks his flaky red patches are all people see otezla is the 1 prescribed pill to treat plaque psoriasis. Ned . Otezla can help you get clearer skin, and reduce itching and flaking. With no routine blood tests required. Doctors have been prescribing otezla for nearly a decade. Otezla is also approved to treat psoriatic arthritis. Dont use otezla if youre allergic to it. Serious allergic reactions can happen. Otezla may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. Some people taking otezla had depression, suicidal thoughts or weight loss. Upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. With clearer skin movie night, is a groovy night live in the moment. Ask your doctor about otezla. Welcome back. Tiktoks future in the u. S. Now in the hands of the senate. The house overwhelmingly approving a bill requiring tiktoks Chinese Parent Company to sell the platform within six months or face a ban. The companys ceos been Lobbying Lawmakers on capitol hill and had this message overnight this bill gives more power to a handful of other social media companies. It will also take billions of dollars out of the pockets of creators and Small Businesses. It will put more than 300,000 american jobs at risk, and it will take away your tiktok. We will not stop fighting and advocating for you. We will continue to do all we can, including exercising our legal rights. Even though the bill had strong bipartisan support in the house, it does face an uncertain path forward in the senate. Nbc has more from the hill. Julie, whats the latest thinking in the senate right now . Reporter well, uncertain is exactly the perfect word to describe the situation in the senate because Majority Leader Chuck Schumer released a tepid statement saying they will evaluate the bill when it comes from the house. He previously said he will instruct the Relevant Committee chairs to look at it. When you look at the Vote Breakdown in the house, its interesting. Its not so much by party but by age. You see that on your chart there. You had some progressive House Democrats even the only genz democrat, maxwell frost, voting against this bill, speaking out with creators the day before. Really rallying around influencers there, as well. And then you had older members of the house, like nancy pelosi, for example, leader jeffries, the House Democratic leader now, they voted in support of this ban. And all of this comes down, lawmakers who are in favor of it say to National Security concerns, and that is why the house defends their process of rushing this through, of Fast Tracking this bill through the house. The senate, though, poised to take its time. All right. And senator Maria Cantwell has emerged as a critic of the bill. Were learning that a former aide of hers is lobbying on behalf of tiktok. So talk to us about the pressure here both from lobbyists and from the millions of tiktok users here in the u. S. Reporter certainly there is so much pressure, theres no doubt about it. In fact, the ceo of tiktok was trying to get meetings up here on capitol hill with senators. Its not clear if he met with any of them. Of course many were reluctant to do so. When you talk about senator cantwell, she didnt just come out opposing this bill. Shes been long trying to find an alternative to this ban that she saw coming down the pike from the house. She sits as the chair of the commerce committee. This is really notable because certainly schumer said he will listen to his Committee Chairs in this process. She released a statement in part saying she is concerned about the exploitation of data from the chineseowned company, but she said she wants to evaluate the bill carefully. Concerning her aide, i want to be careful to say this person only worked for her for a short time before going to other event tires. Now working for tiktok, according to what our colleague dug up. Not only on the democratic side of the aisle is there pressure. Former President Trump speaking in opposition to this saying hes concerned about metas rise if its only tiktok that is singled out here, can certainly add to some of this. Republicans overall, though, saying that they were not swayed by the former president s concerns, and you see that in the Vote Breakdown yesterday with just 15 republicans voting against that bill. All right. Thanks for staying on top of it for us. Next, were on verdict watch. The historic trial of a father accused of his sons school shooting. Ahead, who took the stand in his defense, and what victims Family Members are saying. Plus, the rodeo of wild weather across the country including socalled gorilla hail which cracked this guys windshield. I really thought all the glass would shatner my truck. Ulk with nurtec odt, i can treat a migraine when it strikes and prevent Migraine Attacks, all in one. Dont take if allergic to nurtec. Allergic reactions can occur, even days after using. Most common side effects were nausea, indigestion, and stomach pain. Ask about nurtec odt. ella fashion moves fast. Nausea, indigestion, and stomach pain. Setting trends is our business. We need to scale with customer demand. In real time. jen so we partner with verizon. Their solution for us . A private 5g network. ella we now get more control of production, efficiencies, and greater agility. marquis with a custom private 5g network. Our customers get what they want, when they want it. jen now were even smarter and ready for whats next. vo achieve enterprise intelligence. Its your vision, its your verizon. If your moderate to severe Crohns Disease or Ulcerative Colitis symptoms are stopping you in your tracks. Choose stelara® from the start. And move toward relief after the first dose. With injections every two months. Stelara® may increase your risk of infections, some serious, and cancer. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flulike symptoms, sores, new skin growths, have had cancer, or if you need a vaccine. Pres, a rare, potentially fatal brain condition, may be possible. Some serious allergic reactions and Lung Inflammation can occur. Feel unstoppable. Ask your doctor how lasting remission can start with stelara®. Janssen can help you explore cost support options. Business. Its not a ninetofive proposition. Its all day and into the night. Its all the things that keep this world turning. The gotos that keep us going. The places we cheer. And check in. They all choose the advanced Network Solutions and round the Clock Partnership from Comcast Business. See why Comcast Business powers more Small Businesses than anyone else. Get started for 49. 99 a month plus ask how to get up to an 800 prepaid card. Dont wait call today. The case is now in the hands of a jury in the historic trial of James Crumbley. He is charged with Involuntary Manslaughter for failing to safely store a gun that his 15yearold son used to kill four classmates in 2021. Just a reminder, crumbleys Wife Jennifer was already found guilty on the same charges last month. She was the first parent in the u. S. Ever held criminally responsible for their Childs School shooting. Nbc news has more from out the courthouse in pontiac, michigan. This trial went fast. James crumbley, he never took the stand, unlike his wife. What was his defense . Reporter the defenses strategy was shifting accountability. His Defense Attorney blamed school leaders, specifically highlighting testimony from two of the prosecutions witnesses. Were talking about the former dean of students and the Guidance Counselor, sean hopkins, saying if they didnt perceive Ethan Crumbley as a threat and theyre trained professionals, why should James Crumbley . You may remember the Guidance Counselor called james sool and hours before the shooting played out. They were concerned about this Math Worksheet that Ethan Crumbley had. On it was the drawing of a murder scene. Meanwhile, the Defense Attorney also telling members of the jury if the prosecution had evidence that James Crumbley knew what his son was planning to do, they would have shown it to members of the jury. Her defense was that James Crumbley had no knowledge of his sons intentions. By contrast, the prosecutors say James Crumbley was the only person who knew calling it foreseeable and preventable. Ana . You spoke to some Family Members of that school shooting, victims from that shooting. How are they looking at this trial . Reporter theyve been inside of the courtroom here at the Oakland County courthouse multiple times. They say every time they step inside of the courtroom it doesnt get any easier. The hardest part was seeing that key piece of evidence the Surveillance Video from Inside Of The School on the day of the shooting. Heres more of what they told me just can be really difficult to see how they interpret the evidence and its its hard. To actually go through it and hear it and process it. Weve heard it so many times that each time its a little bit harder to process because it just makes it a little bit more real. You want to go through like it is the unimaginable pain. Reporter and like so many around the country, those parents are waiting to see what this jury decides. Theyve been deliberating for about 2. 5 hours, and they are left with the final images and messages from the Prosecuting Attorney who also said on the day of that shooting there were about 1,800 students inside of oxford high school. More than 100 911 calls it. There was only one call from James Crumbley. Thank you so much. We are tracking Weather Extremes across the country this morning. Here in new york city, unseasonably warm temperatures, around 70 degrees expected. A major winter storm is bearing down on colorado. Look at this. Some parts of the state expecting up to four feet of snow. Nbcs dana griffin joins us from boulder, colorado. Looks cold, it is snowy. Im sure its slippery. Talk to us about what you are experiencing there. Reporter so good morning. Weve been seeing the steady rain excuse me, steady snowfall over the last several hours, and what makes this storm different is take a look at the snow. Its not the fluffy stuff that easily breaks apart, it is heavy, it is dense, its weighted down with so much water. And the concern here is that this could down trees and power lines, so officials are working around the clock to clear the sidewalks and the roadways, and they say despite all of this snow, they are ready. The biggest storm to hit colorado in three years arriving like a thief in the night. Quickly shifting from rain to heavy, wet snow, falling at a rate of two to three inches per hour. Forecasters predicting when its over the snow will be measured in feet, not inches. The heavy snow creating treacherous roadways, Stranding Dozens of cars under blinding conditions on senate 70. Interstate 70. And leaving semi trucks completely stuck. Denver city officials calling this a rare tierfour storm. The tierfour level is heavy accumulation, major drifting potential. Reporter and with hundreds of Flight Escalations at Denver International escalations at Denver International, both skbecht united are offering free rebookings for passengers flying to colorado this week. While colorado gets hammered with snow, california facing its own problems, a massive Landslide Destroying Homes in this los angeles neighborhood. Collapsing roofs and decimating yards. Fortunately there were no injuries reported with several people evacuated. Other parts of the country are dealing with wild weather, too. Overnight South Central and midwestern states facing severe thunderstorms, tornadoes, and golfsized hail. The socalled gorilla hail creating dangerous conditions on the road, even cracking this trucks windshield. I was fluttered. I flustered. I thought all the glass was going to shatter in my truck. Tornado on the ground. We got tornado on the ground. Reporter these Storm Chasers capturing this massive Tornado Douching down in alt touching down at alta vista, kansas. From oklahoma to new england an unusual warmup with temperatures more than 15 degrees above normal with many hoping its a sign that spring may be around the corner. And i was just talking to some of your crew in the control room there. I mean, its so hard to even make snowballs because it just compacts into this like a chunk of ice. You cant really throw the snow at anyone. Youre going to seriously hurt someone. Officials are asking people to stay home, stay off the roads, and stay safe. Ana . Okay. Take that advice, stay safe. Dana griffin, thank you to you and your crew. Up next here on ana cabrera reports, building the blue wall. The stakes of President Bidens visit to michigan and a specific county viewed as a major bellwether there. The first signs of the rncs makeover after trumps takeover. [dog whimpers] [thinking] why always the couch . Does he need to go to puppy school . Get his little Puppy Diploma . How much have i been spending on this little guy . When your questions about life turn into questions about money. Theres erica. The virtual financial assistant to help you spend, save, and plan smarter. Only from bank of america. Tourists tourists that turn into scientists. Tourists photographing thousands of miles of remote coral reefs. That can be analyzed by ai in real time. So researchers can identify which areas are at risk. And help life underwater flourish. Businesses go further with 5g solutions. Thats why they choose tmobile for business. Pga of america and tmobile are partnering on 5gpowered analytics to help improve player performance. Tmobiles Network Helps aaa stay connected nationwide. To get their members back on the road. And Las Vegas Grand Prix chose tmobile to help Fuel Operations for one of the Worlds Largest racing events. Now is the time to see what americas largest 5g network can do for your business. With nurtec odt, i can treat a migraine when it strikes and prevent Migraine Attacks, all in one. Dont take if allergic to nurtec. Allergic reactions can occur, even days after using. Most common side effects were nausea, indigestion, and stomach pain. Ask about nurtec odt. psst psst ahhh with flonase, allergies dont have to be scary. Spray Flonase Sensimist daily for nondrowsy long lasting relief in a scent free, gentle mist. Flonase all good. Also, try our Allergy Headache and nighttime pills. Shop etsy until april 15th and get up to flonase all good. 30 off thoughtful pieces made by real people to brighten your home. Get extraordinary items that complement your style and help bring your vision to life. Order until april 15th for up to 30 off lighting, furniture, gifts and more. When you need just the thing to make your space feel like new. Etsy has it. vo if you have graves disease. Gritty eyes could be more than a rough patch. People with graves could also get thyroid eye disease, or ted, which may need a different doctor. Find a ted Eye Specialist at isitted. Com. Were back with Breaking News. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer speaking right now there in the senate and giving a major address related to the middle east, whats happening in israel and gaza. Lets listen. Real meaningful step forward, but regrettably theres no reason to believe Prime Minister netanyahu would do that. He wont disavow minister smotrik and ben davir in the call for israelis to drive palestinians out of gaza and the west bank. He wont commit to a Military Operation in rafah that prioritizes protecting civilian life. He wont engage responsibly in discussions with a dayafter plan for gaza and a longer term pathway to peace. Hamas and the palestinians who support and tolerate their evil ways, radical rightwing israelis in government and society, president abbas, Prime Minister netanyahu, these are the four obstacles to peace. And if we fail to overcome them, then israel and the West Bank And Gaza will be trapped in the same violent State Of Affairs theyve experienced for the last 75 years. These obstacles are not the same in their culpability for the present State Of Affairs, but arguing over which is the worst sometimies our ability to achieve peace. Given the complexity and gravity of this undertaking, many different groups, many different groups have a responsibility to see it through. The Palestinian People must reject hamas and the extremism in their midst. They know better than anybody how hamas has used them as pawns, how hamas has tortured and punished palestinians who seek peace. Quite frankly i havent heard enough palestinian leaders express anguish about hamas and other extreme elements of palestinian society. I implore them to speak up now. Even when it may be hardest. That is the only true way to honor the lives of all these lost, by transcending the enmity and bloodshed and working together in good faith for a better future. We will continue to monitor this speech from the Senate Majority leader Chuck Schumer. I want to go to nbcs julie serken joining us from capitol hill. I think the big headline there, netanyahu no longer nits the needs of fits the needs of israel, Senator Schumer said. Reporter exactly, this is notable coming from leader Chuck Schumers mouth in part because he is the highest ranking jewish official, also the first jewish Majority Leader in the senate. He has a very long relationship with israel. He was there on the ground almost immediately after the october 7th attack. So this coming from him, this strong criticism of Prime Minister netanyahu is very, very notable. I want to point out some other things he said in his ongoing speech. Again, this was billed as a major address on israel. Its a moment in which, of course, there are many issues taking place, in terms of those on the left being frustrated with President Biden and his response to israel. Israel aid being held up also in part because progressives are frustrated about its lack of conditions attached to it. So schumer using this moment to appeal really, and he said in part, of course, that the four obstacles to peace, one hamas and the palestinians to support and tolerate their evil ways. Two, the radical rightwing israelis in government and society. Three, president abbas, who is the president of the state of palestine, and number four which he spent perhaps most part of his speech talking about is, of course, Prime Minister netanyahu. He says of these four if these four obstacles are not changed, it could be the end of israel and the end of a twostate solution for palestine, as well. Wow. Okay. Julie tsirkin, thanks for the highlights from, again, this major address by Chuck Schumer, the Senate Majority leader. Meantime, President Biden today is stopping in another battleground state. Hes going to make hisses way to michigan this afternoon looking to shore up that allimportant blue wall. This is his first visit to michigan since the significant protest vote we saw against him in the states democratic primary over his handling of the war in gaza or the 100,000 people voted uncommitted in that primary. Nbc has more from saginaw, michigan, also with Us Democratic strategist basil smikel, and republican strategist susan dell percy. Michigan was key to President Bidens win in 2020. We saw in that primary he could be vulnerable there in michigan. Whats the goal today . Reporter yeah. You mentioned how this is the president s first time back in this state since the primary late last month when over 100,000 people voted uncommitted. Many of them in protest of the president s handling of the israelhamas war. Thats concerning considering he beat the former president by 154,000 votes. And the Arab American Community makes up 300,000 voters in this state. Many of them leaning democratic. As far as we know of the president s schedule today and what he will be doing while hes on the ground here in saginaw, the Arab American and Muslim Community is not going to be his focus while he is on the ground here. The president is going to be holding this event at a saginaw home with organizers and supporters, focusing on lowering prices for michiganders. But we do know that senior white house officials are going to be having a private meeting with leaders of this community, but it will be in chicago where there is a very large palestinian community. We have talked about those protests that have followed the president in recent months, arguing that his handling of the israelhamas war is unfair. Those protests still present in saginaw today. We expect the Protest Presence here at this counsel square behind me shortly. And so hes back in michigan two weeks after the primary there. What does President Biden need to do to prove that he sees these voters who may be unhappy, that he is listening to Voter Concerns . Well, you had portions of Chuck Schumers speech earlier, i think that goes a long way toward trying to communicate with voters in the way that the president mate not be able to do directly from his mouth. But to have Chuck Schumer with his leadership in the senate, with his stature within the jewish community, particularly here in new york, to be able to make those kinds of comments, it is an acknowledgment that those voters do mean a lot to the president s aspirations to to win reelection. And that that path significantly goes through michigan. Look, i think there are other constituentsies that are going to be important to him, as well. He met with the teamsters other day, the leadership and the rank and file, seems to be supportive of him. So theres certainly a lot at stake in michigan. But i i would say that for Chuck Schumer to make those comments today is an acknowledgment that those voters are going to be key to a democratic victory. Those comments coming from Chuck Schumer are not the same as coming from theyre not the same. Coming from the president. Susan, you look at where the president has gone since the State Of The Union address. Michigan today, hes been in wisconsin, pennsylvania, these are three important states, right . Could he win reelection without winning those states . Well, theres some math that can be done. Maybe he can lose one or two of them. But theres also that shows him not necessarily holding onto georgia likely did last time or arizona. So he absolutely needs to campaign in all the swing states. Michigan right now looks like he should be able to hold it. If he keeps going on the path he did. By holding the meetings, even if its in private with administration officials, and members of the Arab American Community, it shows were listening. Thats what the message hes trying to do. And hes not trying to do it in september. What is looking good for the president right now is his outreach is to broaden his base of support. Whereas all weve seen from donald trump is all he wants to do is focus on his base of support and not growing it beyond that. So the president s doing what he has to. Its a lot of work, and hes going to have to keep going. These trips to michigan arent going to stop. Were going to be having these conversations every other week about where he was. But its the right move right now. Allie, Vice President Kamala Harris is going to be visiting a planned parenthood today that provides Abortion Services. This is a first for a sitting Vice President. What can you tell us about her trip . Reporter absolutely. Vice president Kamala Harris expected to really make History Today when she becomes what is believed to be the first president or Vice President to visit a planned parenthood facility, providing Abortion Services in minnesota. Were told she will speak with providers while there, possibly also speak with patients. This is all part of her fight for Reproductive Freedoms Tour that she kicked off in january to speak out against restrictions on reproductive access in the aftermath of the reversal of roe v. Wade. The Vice President as weve seen become really the face of the white houses messaging on this issue. And susan, abortion we know has become increasingly more and more challenging of an issue for republicans. What do you make of the Vice President s visit . I think its so important because for decades and decades people, politicians have been afraid to say abortion and be prowomens reproductive care and talk about the needs, the Health Reasons for some women needing abortions, or just having the right to choose. By Vice President harris going to one of these clinics, its putting it out there to show its its there for everybody. It is Womens Health care. It shouldnt be stigmatized. This is an issue of euro generation. Basil . Ive always said that Kamala Harris is the special weapon of the administration. Shes shes the one person that can really go out there and pull all of these threads together. Im glad shes doing that, im glad that shes going to College Campuses and sort of kicked off, you know, the College Students for biden, if you will. Pull all these threads together, it these are mobilizing issues, particularly womens reproductive rights, particularly black Maternal Health care. You know, get her out there talking about it. And hopefully well all cover it because it is so incredibly important. Were conching it. We are. Thank you. Basil, susan, and allie. Up next, the collision of violence, hunger, and politics in haiti as gangs plunge that island into chaos. We are also seeing, you know, patients who suffer from Gunshot Wounds the previous day who are only able to make it to our facility 12 hours later when they feel safe. Th unresolved sy . It may be time to see the bigger picture. Heart failure and seemingly unrelated symptoms like carpal tunnel syndrome, shortness of breath, and Irregular Heartbeat could mean something more serious, called attrcm a rare, underdiagnosed disease that worsens over time. Sound like you . Call your cardiologist and ask about attrcm. Nice to meet ya. My name is david. Ive been a pharmacist for 44 years mainly because i just love helping people. As i got older, it was just a natural part of aging, i felt that my memory was beginning to decline and thats when i started looking for something that would help. When i first started taking prevagen, i noticed my memory was so much better. Just stuff seemed to come together and fit like a Jigsaw Puzzle in my mind. Prevagen. At stores everywhere without a prescription. [ ] did you know, many moisturizers only hydrate your skin . For advanced science that visibly repairs signs of aging. Try Olay Regenerist microsculpting cream. It delivers 10 benefits in every jar for youngerlooking skin, visibly firming, lifting, and smoothing wrinkles. Olay regenerist penetrates the skins surface, to boost regeneration at the surface Cellular Level for continuous improvement. To visibly repair signs of aging, try Olay Regenerist. This has been medifacts for olay. Okay everyone, our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy. Yay woo hoo ensure, with 27 vitamins and minerals, nutrients for immune health. And ensure complete with 30 grams of protein. im gonna hold you forever. Ill be there. You dont. You dont have to worry. This morning fears of a mass exodus of refugees from haiti as surging Gang Violence has led to a total breakdown of law and order. The International Community is responding. The u. N. Announcing today that it will establish an air bridge between haiti and the Dominican Republic to get people out and desperately needed aid in. Also in question is how haiti will establish a Transition Government after the Prime Minister announced hes resigning over the growing violence. Nbcs Gabe Gutierrez joins us in the Dominican Republic right at the border with haiti. And gabe, youve been talking to people who want to escape the violence. You are hearing harrowing stories. Reporter thats right. And let me set the scene because theres a lot going on. Right over there is the haitian border. And if we can pan back here, these are many haitian thats are coming to this nomans land in between the border of haitir. There is an Open Air Market that is open today and theyre allowed to come over here, but no further. But as you can see, just look at how many supplies theyre bringing back into haiti. You mentioned, ana, that the u. N. Is establishing this air bridge, this humanitarian corridor to bring in much needed aid. This morning, as even more gang fueled violence erupts in haiti, a new team of u. S. Marines is on the ground in portauprince, securing the american embassy. The capital gripped by gunfire and chaos. It has been three days since haitis Prime Minister announced he would step down after relentless pressure from gangs who want him gone. Now efforts to stabilize the country may be stalling. Any delay could put the aid of a Multinational Police force led by kenya and largely funded by the u. S. In jeopardy. With gangs controlling most of the capital, many civilians are now trapped. Haitian american shahry says shes hoping to escape haiti and see her family in miami but has no way to get there. We want to come back home and get our things, theyre going to kill us. Reporter bestselling author mitch albom now safe in michigan after a Stealth Private Helicopter in the middle of the night rescued him. The u. N. Says a million haitians are now on the brink of famine, hospitals are struggling too, desperate for generator fuel. We spoke with a doctor who said armed men executed a patient inside an ambulance. Were also seeing, you know, patients who suffer from Gunshot Wounds, the previous day, who are only able to make it to our facility 12 hours later, when they feel safe. Reporter this missionary and her family are trapped at a makeshift motel near the airport. Shes frantically trying to get back to florida in time for her daughters wedding. With the airport still shut down, shes instead ducking for cover. We did hear gunfire, like, right outside at the gate. And it was very scary. We hid in our room until it went away. Reporter now, ana, back live now here to the Dominican Republic, again this is the line of haitians now trying to get back into haiti, because as i said, this is a nomansland, there is an Open Air Market open here, just today, where theyre able to come and get some supplies. Theyre not allowed to go into the Dominican Republic because this border is closed. But, ana, as you can see, the need here is overwhelming. Ana . Gabe gutierrez, so eye opening, thank you for being there for us. I appreciate your reporting. Next on ana cabrera reports, actress olivia munns important message. S olivia munn important message. ella fashion moves fast. Setting trends is our business. We need to scale with customer demand. In real time. jen so we partner with verizon. Their solution for us . A private 5g network. ella we now get more control of production, efficiencies, and greater agility. marquis with a custom private 5g network. Our customers get what they want, when they want it. jen now were even smarter and ready for whats next. vo achieve enterprise intelligence. Its your vision, its your verizon. With nurtec odt i can treat and prevent my Migraine Attacks all in one. Dont take if allergic to nurtec. Allergic reactions can occur even days after using. Most common side effects were nausea, indigestion and stomach pain. Talk to your doctor about nurtec today. Shingles. The rash can feel like an intense burning sensation, and last for weeks. Shingles could make it hard to be there for your loved ones. Over 50 . The virus that causes shingles is likely already inside you. Dont wait. Ask your doctor about shingles. All of the things that youre looking for in a pad, that is always discreet. Look at how it absorbs all the liquid. Oh my gosh and locking it right on in. Look at that totally absorbed. I got to get some always discreet. start your day with nature made. The 1 pharmacist recommended vitamin and supplement brand. When i was your age, we never had anything like this. The 1 pharmacist recommended what . Wifi . Wifi that works all over the house, even the basement. The basement. So i can finally throw that party. And invite shannon barnes. Dream do come true. Xfinity gives you reliable wifi with walltowall coverage on all your devices, even when everyone is online. Maybe well even get married one day. I wonder what i will be doing . Probably still living here with mom and dad. Fast reliable speeds right where you need them. Thats walltowall wifi on the xfinity 10g network. Today in the united kingdom, a lot of eyes will be on Prince William as he makes a public appearance as the speculation continues to swirl about his wife, the princess of wales. The prince will be at The Legacy Awards to honor Young Leaders from around the world. Princess kate, however, is not expected to join him and the palace is still not commenting on her status. Meanwhile, two celebrities are now sharing the details of their battles with cancer. Actress olivia munn and model Christie Brinkley, both going public with their stories saying they want to encourage other people to get early screenings. Nbcs Stephanie Gosk has more. Stephanie . Doctors say the key to Beating Cancer is catching it early. Olivia munn and Christie Brinkley would agree. Both women are sharing stories about their cancer diagnoses, hoping what they have gone through will remind people to make those appointments and get those exams. On the red carpet at the oscars this weekend, olivia munn and her partner john mulaney held hands and smiled for the cameras. No sign of the Serious Health battle the 43yearold actress has been waging. Munn announcing wednesday she was diagnosed with an aggressive form of Breast Cancer in both breasts last april. And underwent a double mastectomy. Writing on instagram, i went from feeling completely fine one day to waking up in a hospital bed after a tenhour surgery the next. Munn, who many know from her role on hbos the newsroom writes im lucky, we caught it with enough time that i had options. She said a doctor saved her life when she did a Breast Cancer assessment. Munns score was high. 37 according to the actress post. What does that 37 mean . In her case, 37. 3 was her Lifetime Risk for Breast Cancer. And the way i explain it to my patients, if you had a 37. 3 chance of Boarding A Plane that would crash, would you board that plane . Reporter she sent her for a breast mri and they discovered the cancer. Olivia says she wasnt going to be going in for another mammogram for a year. What would have happened in that year potentially . Her cancer would have grown, she had an aggressive cancer. Reporter along with thanking her doctor, she thanked mulaney. They have a son together. Im so thankful to john, she writes, for being there before i went into each surgery and being there when i woke up and placing framed photos by my hospital bed. Also sharing a cautionary tale, actress and model Christie Brinkley, who posted photos of the procedure she had to remove skin cancer from her face. Like munn, she writes, the good news for me is we caught the basal Cell Carcinoma early, adding i was lucky to find mine, i was accompanying one of my daughters to her checkup. She reminds people to get regular total body checkups, and slather up with sunscreen. Two different women, each with scary personal stories to tell, and Important Health messages they hope will help others. Brinkley said she had a dot on the side of her face and asked the doctor to take a look and in her words, he knew right away. Reminder that doctors can sometimes identify a problem very quickly. As for olivia munn, she has a lot of support around her. Her partner john mulaney commenting on her post saying thank you for fighting so hard to be here for us, we adore you. Back to you. Stephanie, thank you. Ladies, get those checkups. Thats going do it for us today. Thanks so much for joining us. See you back here tomorrow, same time, same place. Its friday. Almost, were so close. Dont forget you can catch our show online around the clock on youtube and other platforms. For now, im Ana Cabrera Reporting from new york. Jose diazbalart picks up our coverage right now. Good morning, it is 11 00 a. M. Eastern, 8 00 a. M. Pacific. Im jose diazbalart. We begin this very busy hour with Breaking News from here in florida, where right now former President Trump is in a federal courtroom as his legal team tries to get the classified documents case against him thrown out. The hearing is taking place in fort pierce, 120 miles north