Early, bureau chief at politico, Jonathan Lemire. I liked it. Do it every morning. John heilemann is here. Why are you here so early . I dont know. Thats a lot for us at 6 00. Me rolls in from the club. Works out well. Its like Super Tuesday, starting on a super note. I have to prepare emotionally for heilemann to be in the room. Wow. Bbc news katty kay is with us, as well. So important it is Super Tuesday. I have an announcement to make, personal. Hopson is an emotional support dog. I know you love him, joe, except for the humping problem. Wow. How do you stop that . Some dogs cant be stopped from that. I joe was still getting his mic on, so i was helping you out. Congratulations, hopson. Gosh. You could have stretched just a little bit less on that. Hes a good dog. I just do want some advice on that. No, no. Sweetheart, i may talk a lot hey, sweetie . Rapid turn. I may talk a lot, but i want you to know what comes out of my mouth scares you . Its the things that i dont say that have kept me on the air here now for 16 years. This is a very no, this is not just specific. A lot of dogs suffer from this problem. Okay. So, willie, Super Tuesday today, the stakes, well, they just couldnt be any lower. Take us through it. You know, the word that comes to mind, joe, on this Super Tuesday is not the one mika raised which totally derailed the show. It is anticlimax, i think it is fair to say. No doubt about it. Donald trump expected to roll through the states. Joe biden unopposed, as well. Im going to power through right here. Watch this. Voters can we throw in lets get to something else. Willie, theyll go to the polls, but theyre going to wake up tomorrow on hump day for the week. Oh we didnt need that. We were starting to recover. [ bell ringing ] there we go. Anyway, just come out of it. Take us through. You sucked us back in. Sorry. 16 states and one u. S. Territory, the American Samoa also on the board for Super Tuesday. Thank you. Caucuses in 15 states, 865 delegates up for grabs. Donald trump expected to sweep all the states. Trump beat nikki haley by 70 points in north dakota. Trump will likely be awarded all 29 of the delegates. In an interview with rsbn last night, conservative Media Company, donald trump expressed confidence heading into the vote, while nikki haley made her case to voters at a packed rally in ft. Worth. If youre watching, go out and vote. Its not haley, shes not a problem. I think she is very negative for the party, but shes not a problem in terms of winning because were winning by a lot. The only place we expected to lose was d. C. Because thats the swamp. Tomorrow, we could very well win every state in record numbers. Thats what were hoping for. They call it Super Tuesday for a reason, and i think it is going to be record setting. I think. I hope so. Republicans lost the vote on mayorkas. They lost the vote on israel. The rnc chair lost her job. Donald trump had his fingerprints on all of it. At some point, maybe, we should say, the reason that america keeps losing is because of donald trump. We can change all of that. But in order to change it, it is going to take a lot of courage. Courage from everybody here. Courage for me to run. Courage for every one of you to know, dont complain about what happens in a general election if you dont vote in this primary. We are blessed to live in america. And we know that america is better than this. Now, we have to do something about it. So this is what i will tell you. Tomorrow, you have a job to do. I need you to vote. And i need you to take ten people with you. Ill tell you this, john heilemann, just watching nikki haley and watching her grow on the Campaign Trail, again, mika and i have known her since she was a state legislator. She was pretty darn good as a legislator as far as her skill set as a politician. But watching that Nikki Haley On Stage and understanding that shes running in Donald Trumps party, i just cant help but look at that person and think, if she were to run as an independent candidate and access all 50 states, which, of course, i dont think she could, you know, that person, that message could do better than ross pirro, especially this year. That is somebody who could actually be a contender as an independent candidate. I dont know. I mean, theres obviously been theres a chunk of voters who are, as we know, vastly dissatisfied with the choice at the top of the presumptive tickets, right . You also have this growth in the independent segment of the electorate. Theres been a lot. The last 20, 30 years, weve seen this intense polarization. There hasnt been much space for, you know, 40 , 42 , 43 on one side or the other, didnt matter if there was candidates they liked, there wasnt space for a third party. No one opined for it. Hyperpolarized climate, the parties were generally satisfied with their respective candidates. This is a different situation. Joe, were in New Territory in terms of Voter Unsatisfaction with trump and biden, you might be right. The question isnt what would happen if nikki haley were to be an independent candidate or Third Party Candidate. The interesting question is what would have happened, which is a question that will haunt a lot of people on the republican side, what would have happened if she had found her way to the clarity shes found and the strength shes found, the voice shes found, whatever you want to call it, if shed found this position not in january of this year but a year ago january or a year ago june, in june. If shed been doing this, not necessarily this good but this clear about the space she occupied in the Republican Party, how much more of a challenge she was trying for Vice President then, i think. She has toggled between kind of trumps skeptic and trump admirer for her career since trump has been on the scene. If shed been in this place and consistently campaigned this way from the middle of last year, how much closer would the republican nomination fight have been . She found clarity way too late, and i think thats the question that hovers over what might have been and, in some sense, what happens in the future. There are still a lot of people who wonder, what will happen to nikki haley, whether shell have this clarity after she leaves the race, whether its tomorrow or some other day soon to come. Yeah. Well, and perhaps after sorry, willie. Perhaps, willie, after she after this race, after the general election, if donald trump loses again, then she has a great argument. If donald trump wins, of course, its a completely different situation. You know, the thing is, willie, a lot of people made calculations. Nikki haley and ron desantis and others, that they could ignore donald trump, push him aside. That they could pat his followers on the head. That alvin bragg or some other prosecutor was going to take care of donald trump. Thats why they didnt do it a year before. I must say, if somebody were running against a democrat in a democratic primary that was suitably damaged, they probably would try to ignore that democrat and chart their own path. So it has been a very tortured run, but theres always been this lane. I dont know how big the lane is. Liz cheney would tell you, and Adam Kinzinger would tell you, not very big. Im not so sure if you just came forward from the very beginning with the strong conviction, i can win. This guy cant, im not so sure she wouldnt be doing better right now. But we are where we are, and this is actually a strong message. Shell probably lose everything tonight, but i dont think shes playing for tonight. Shes playing for tomorrow. Shes looking over the horizon. She may have a future. I guess the question is, would it have mattered . Well never know. If she had done what john suggests last year and come out stronger and not used the vagaries of kicking sideways and no one knew what any of that meant, trying to have it both ways and keep Donald Trumps supporters, maybe that would have made a difference. Also, maybe it wouldnt have. Maybe this is just Donald Trumps party, and the loyalists are so strong in his corner, it wouldnt have mattered. We wont know. It is strange to be sitting here on the morning of Super Tuesday, something weve covered so many times before, and really to have no drama whatsoever. Not to say, okay, is this candidate going to steal this state or that state . Its just trump expected to roll through the 15 states. I guess the question is, will nikki haley drop out tonight or tomorrow morning . Will she hang in for a couple more weeks . Itll still be two more weeks before donald trump technically secures the nomination, in terms of the number of delegates. Here we are, just rolling toward this general election now as we turn the corner to a State Of The Union and everywhere. This feels like a milestone week where we can see the candidates going headtohead. The general election is upon us as of this week. President biden going to have a clean sweep on the democratic side. Republicans, nikki haleys team suggests maybe they have a shot at vermont but probably not. Therefore, trump could win everything there, too. Whats next to haley . Could she drop out tonight . Is there an event later this week in her home state . Also, she, herself, all along said im in this through Super Tuesday. She left the door open to staying in longer. Maybe until trump mathematically becomes the nominee or beyond that, that she wouldnt suspend her campaign. Trumps first criminal trial is three weeks away. Maybe she tries to suggest something could happen at the convention. She wants to keep her options open. She campaigns to truism and when they run out of money. For now, haley has enough money to keep this going for a while. What she has done, though, is she has displayed trumps vulnerabilities. Even though shes only won one contest, the one in washington, d. C. , shes put up a fairly impressive size of the vote in a couple states. New hampshire, South Carolina among them. And revealed some concerns for trump going forward. Issues hes going to have to address come november. Weve seen these polls where a lot of Haley Supporters say, ill never back donald trump even if he is the nominee. Ill either vote for joe biden or stay home. As long as she stays in the race and continues to deliver messages, the antitrump messages, shes delivering them to audiences who wouldnt otherwise hear them. Shes been covered on conserve ty media who would never play joe biden. Another thing is turnout. Yes, donald trump has a big win in iowa, but the turnout is tiny. He gets 50 of the turnout. North dakota, he won by 70 points. Sounds like a big number. He got 1,800 total votes. Wow. The margins will be huge, but people are not turning out for him in this primary season. I guess well learn a lot by what people do and how theyre feeling from the results tonight. Katty kay, to willies point, that it is interesting theres just no Drama Heading into Super Tuesday, and pointing out that, on the republican side, one of the candidates is probably one of the most controversial candidates in the world. Yet, no drama. What are you watching tonight . Nikki haley revealed two things. One thing, it is Donald Trumps party. It is his party, and nobody can make a dent on him. I dont know. If shed gone for the Chris Christie lane right from the beginning, would it have helped her . Would she have done better or worse . She made the calculation, clearly, that that was not an option to her. But shes also revealed his weaknesses. Shes revealed his vulnerabilities. The number, you know, Charlie Sykes, our friend, and sarah, who i chatted to the other day, is making the calculation, how big is the lane . How big is the group of republicans who will never vote for donald trump . Thats what ill watch tonight with the exit polls. Will we get a better sense of how many republicans there are who are voting in the primaries who like nikki haley, who like the message she started delivering robustly, and will never vote for donald trump . Thatll give us the best indication for whether joe biden has this chance, a better chance, because there are republicans who are going to vote. In the end, the election comes down to how Many Democrats wont vote for joe biden and how many republicans wont vote for donald trump . Thats what elections like todays are going to show us. Yeah. I will say, john heilemann, one of the things im looking for is what willie brought up. Thats a turnout. Because we do see every four years the turnout from parties, you know, it does make a big difference. How excited are they . How energized are they to get out and vote . Last night, can you believe you can win a republican contest, and trump is crowing about it, with 1,632 votes . Most City Council Members in midsized towns get more than 1,632 votes. Wow. Again, we keep going back to iowa. 14 of republicans in iowa voted. Thats 14 of about a third of registered voters in iowa. He got 50 of the 14 of the 33 . You keep going on and on, and he ends up with about 50,000 votes and wins the storied iowa caucuses. These numbers are way down. There are a lot of republicans that are disaffected by donald trump. If theyre voting for him, theyre doing it holding their nose. Yeah, id say, joe, that number, i think thats from north dakota you mentioned there. Its like there are probably some Condominium Association votes in the state of florida that are bigger than that. Oh, yeah. So, yes, look, whats been revealed, i think, in this period or two things. One about each party. On the democratic side, joe biden has a problem with democratic voters in the sense that he lacks enthusiasm among his pace. Donald trump is claiming the percentage of people who voted for him last time around. Joe biden has a problem with people who voted for him last time around and drifted away. He has to get the people back. Donald trump has 98 of the people who voted for him last time, but the pool is shrinking. On the republican side, there is an enthusiasm problem. Having been in iowa, New Hampshire, South Carolina, the lack of enthusiasm in all those contests for donald trump outside of his core base is palpable. It is less than it was in 2020. Its less than it was in 2016. You can feel it, that people in the Republican Party are more acquiescent to trump than enthusiastic, and thatll be a problem. He needs every Single Person if he wants to be the nominee and win in november. Still ahead on this Super Tuesday, Steve Kornacki will join us at the big board with a look at what he is watching today. Up next in 60 seconds, were going to get to the new Supreme Court ruling that donald trump cannot be kicked off colorados primary ballot. Were back in just one minute. Emergenc crystals pop and fizz when you throw them back. And who doesnt love a good throwback . emergenc crystals. The Supreme Court unanimously ruled that colorado isnt allowed to remove trump from the 2024 ballot. Out of habit, trump immediately appealed the decision. This is a oh, wait a minute. Thats right. The Supreme Court ruled that states cannot keep trump off their ballots, which means the Supreme Court remains the only place where trump can win the popular vote. Yes, the Supreme Court knows you cant just let states decide who goes on their ballots. States are too busy deciding that life begins in the freezer section. Next to the pearl onions. Yeah, okay. I dont know. I didnt like that one. But its true. Yeah, tough crowd. Okay. Donald trump will remain on the ballot despite efforts in some states to make him ineligible for the 2024 election. The Supreme Court yesterday unanimously rejected the ruling from colorados Supreme Court that removed the former president from the ballot based on section 3 of the 14th Amendment. Now, the justices ruled that a patchwork of decisions around the country could send elections into chaos if State Officials had the freedom to determine who could appear on the ballot. The decision makes clear that it is up to congress to enforce the insurrectionist clause against federal Office Holders and candidates, but the three Liberal Justices accused their conservative colleagues of going too far, by Ruling Congress must enact new legislation in order to ban a president ial candidate. They wrote that this decision will make it harder to bar, quote, An Oathbreaking Insurrectionist from becoming president. Lets bring into the conversation former u. S. Attorney and msnbc contributor chuck rosenberg. Chuck, which was wide expected. I dont know if it was expected to be unanimous, but it is at 90. Conservative Justice Amy Coney barrett wrote a concurrence, critical of some pieces of her colleagues ruling on this. This talks about federal Office Holders, which is to say, the state does not have the right to keep a federal candidate off the ballot. It can do that with State Candidate and local candidates but not federal. Are you surprised at all by anything you saw in the decision yesterday . Not really, willie. With one asterisk. If you listened to the Oral Argument last month, it was pretty clear the vote was going to be lopsided, 81, 90. Turned out to be 90. To prohibit states from determining the qualifications for candidates for federal office. So the 90 vote didnt surprise me very much. There was, as you noted, a Concurring Opinion and a disagreement, not just the three socalled Liberal Justices, but Justice Amy Coney barrett, as well, who thought the majority on the court went a bit too far. A bit too far, willie, by deciding a question not before them, which was, how do you give effect to the Disqualification Clause to the 14th Amendment . The one mika described. Do you have to do it through legislation . Five justices said yes. Four said you dont need to reach that question. But on the core question, the most important question, it was a 90 vote, prohibiting states from determining whether or not someone can stand for federal office. So conservative columnist david french writes about the decision in a piece for the New York Times, the Supreme Court just erased part of the constitution. Heres part of it. As of monday, march 4, 2024, section 3 of the 14th Amendment of the constitution is essentially a dead letter, at least as it applies to candidates for federal office. Now, section 3 is different from other sections of the amendment. It requires federal legislation to enforce its terms, at least as applied to candidates for federal office. Through inaction alone, congress can effectively erase part of the 14th Amendment. The Supreme Court has effectively replaced a very high bar for allowing insurrectionists into federal office, a Super Majority Vote by congress, with the lowest bar imaginable, congressional inaction. The fact that congress has not acted should not effectively erase the words from the constitutional page. Chaotic enforcement of the constitution may be suboptimal. But its far better than not enforcing the constitution at all. What do you make of that, joe . Well, i was going to ask chuck, his opinion on David Frenchs insights. Chuck . Joe, i read it this morning. I read his article, and he makes a really important point. That congress, by doing absolutely nothing, which is absolutely what they do best, has essentially stripped the Disqualification Clause from operation, right . Theyve essentially rendered it moot. Heres the problem. By going too far, the Supreme Court has really limited the ways in which someone can be disqualified. You need congress to pass federal legislation. Now, Amy Coney Barrett and the three socalled Liberal Justices would have said something different. A, we dont have to decide this. B, there might be other ways for congress or federal courts to breathe life into the Disqualification Clause. I think David Frenchs article is an important one to read. Like i said, i read it myself. I even understood it, which doesnt happen all that often, but hes right. Its essentially become a nullity. The ability to keep an insurrectionist from the ballot turns on congress acting, and as we discussed earlier, thats what congress does worse. You know, willie, this underline as point that we, at times, have said, about what could have happening on the left. The criticisms of alvin bragg bringing a case under a new theory or sort of piecing things together in a way that make constitutional scholars uneasy on both sides. In this case, you have the Supreme Court lurching too far to the right, making, as david french said, this part of the 14th Amendment a dead letter. You could also raise a lot of the same questions which we need to do about some of the state cases, as well. Right now in futon county, theres a mess down there with the prosecutor. What happens if there is a prosecutor in west texas that wants to, you know, charge the next democratic president . These are all questions that do need to be raised. Weve been raising them on one side, on is there overreach on the left that will impact future democratic president s. Here, you have overreach, it seems, by a conservative Supreme Court who, well, lets just face it, thats what theyve been doing best over the past year or so. Overreach by the Supreme Court in a way that, again, has nullified, effectively, as david french said, nullified an extraordinarily important clause in the 14th Amendment. Yeah. Thats why it was interesting to see the concurrence from the liberal members of the court and Amy Coney Barrett saying to her colleagues, guys, we need to turn down the temperature, not turn it up and create more chaos in the system. While voting with the majority, of course, unanimous, critical in some ways of the specifics of the ruling. Thats the legal side of it, john. Lets talk about the politics for a second. I think we all have heard from some democrats and maybe people working on other campaigns, saying this was worth pursuing, but perhaps even a little relief that it turned out this way. Yes. If hes kept off the ballot, it gives him rocket fuel for the next eight months to say, the biden administration, the Justice Department, et cetera, everything he likes to say, is trying to strip away your right to vote, to keep me off the ballot. They say, we can beat him in colorado. Put him on the ballot. A sigh of relief from democrats yesterday. The idea being, if a few blue states had taken him off the ballot, yes, itd fuel his grievances, his deep state conspiracies, and would fire up the enthusiasm. Chaos is the right word. They were right to rule the way they did. A lot of campaigns would concur on that. Donald trump, of course, appeared yesterday at maralago and praised the decision. Chuck rosenberg, we also heard trump talk about the other matter about to be in front of the Supreme Court, that of president ial immunity. Oral arguments are scheduled for next month. Give us your latest thinking as to how those arguments could go and, most importantly, when well hear from the justices in terms of their decision. That will impact whether or not any of these trials happen before the election. Let me start with the when, jonathan. The argument in the Supreme Court on the question of president ial immunity for a criminal process is april 22nd. The Supreme Court term ends at the end of june. So we will certainly have a decision, or we should have Ae A Decision the end of june, though it could be quicker. The Amendment Clause took four weeks. No later than the end of june, we should have a decision. Im still bullish. I may be the last person on the planet who believes this case could be tried before the election. The January 6th Insurrection Case in federal course in washington. The sooner the Supreme Court makes a decision, the clearer it will be, whether or not we can have the trial. To your first question, jonathan, mr. Trump lost decisively in the District Court and, again, decisively and unanimously in the Court Of Appeals on the immunity question. Its clear, a president is not immune, perhaps in narrow cases involving certain acts. Trying to thwart a fair and free election cannot possibly be a fair act. The sooner the Supreme Court gets to the decision, the better well know whether or not we can have a trial before the election. I still think we can. I may be the last person on the planet, but im somewhat bullish. Okay. Former u. S. Attorney and msnbc contributor chuck rosenberg, thank you very much for coming on the show. Coming up on morning joe, well bring the latest developments out of the middle east as Vice President Kamala Harris continues to press for a ceasefire in gaza. Plus, president emeritus from the council of foreign relations, richard haass, is joining the conversation. Morning joe is coming right back. With so many choices on booking. Com there are so many tina feys i could be. So i hired body doubles to help me out. Splurgy tina loves a hotel near rodeo drive. Oh tina wild tina booked a farm stay to ride this horse. Glenn close . with millions of possibilities you can book whoever you want to be. Thats my line booking. Com booking. Yeah some people just know that the best rate for you is a rate based on you, with allstate. Because you know that just because it fits in the cupholder doesnt make it togo. And you know how to brake, without breaking everything. And youre definitely not doing okay, i dont even know what this is, but youre definitely not doing that. With allstate youre connected to a rate based on you. what if you could go from this to this. With just one step tresemme silk serum. Time for the ultimate humidity test. Weightlessly smooth hair your turn. New tresemme keratin smooth collection. The future is not just going to happen. You have to make it. And if you want a successful business, all it takes is an idea, and now becomes the future where you grew a dream into a reality. The all new godaddy airo. Put your Business Online in minutes with the power of ai. The u. S. Is expected to drop more aid into gaza soon. President biden posted about expanding Air Deliveries by air, land, and sea, but the white house hasnt shared exact details on timing. The u. S. Dropped 38,000 readytoeat meals over central gaza other the weekend. Meanwhile, Vice President Kamala Harris is pushing israel to pause the fighting in gaza. Harris emphasized the need to secure a hostage deal and get more aid into the strip during a meeting with israeli war cabinet member benny gantz yesterday. According to the white house, the two discussed the situation in rafah. Harris wants a humanitarian plan before israel launches a Major Military operation. Gantz is expected to continue these discussions today with Secretary Of State antony blinken. Gantz is a political rival to Benjamin Netanyahu. His visit to the white house could signal wider cracks between the white house and the Israeli Government. Reporters asked gantz yesterday if the white house should deal with him instead of netanyahu, but gantz responded, quote, no, israel has a Prime Minister, and everything is okay. Joining us now, president emeritus on the council of foreign relations, richard haass. He is author of the weekly newsletter, Home And Away, available on substack. I would argue everything is not okay, joe, in the Israeli Government, losing support around the world. Israel is obviously losing support in the United States, losing support around the world, and right now, i think perhaps most importantly for them in the long run, theyre losing support among their arab neighbors. Richard, there is a real urgency, and i know youve spoken with arab neighbors and leaders and diplomats around israel, as have i over the past few weeks. They keep saying, the clock is ticking. We have to resolve this crisis. We want to help. We want to help in gaza. We want to help you toward a twostate solution. But the killing of civilians has to stop. The famine, the coming famine has to be averted. All of these things suggest a fierce urgency of now that perhaps Benjamin Netanyahu and too many in the Israeli Government just do not understand. Yeah. Joe, its hard to talk about this without almost noting the tragedy or irony of it. For decades, what was israels goal . It was to gain acceptance in the region. It was to get the arab countries to basically see israel, not as a western implant, but as part of the region. That was happening. You had all sorts of countries normalizing. Most important, you had saudi arabia, critical in the arab world, critical in energy, and critical in the islamic world, on the cusp of doing that. Whats happening now, and you eluded to what arab leaders are frustrated about, is what israel is doing is, in some ways, radicalized another generation of young arabs who, six months ago, didnt care much about the palestinians. They were open to economic and other interactions with israel. All of that has been put on hold or even reversed. Like it or not, these arab leaders, even though that are authoritarian, have to take into account the public opinion, even in authoritarian countries you cant ignore it. Israel is essentially undoing what had been, for decades, its principle Foreign Policy or National Security goal. Right now, relations with the palestinians are at a low and relations with the arab states have been frozen. This has really been, i would argue again, its not over israels right for selfdefense. It is how israel has interpreted it and implemented it. Id argue its been counter productive from any and every consideration. You look at the pictures weve been watching over the past month, and you understand. The israeli people, many should understand with bitterness that this is exactly the way hamas wanted this to play out. Just commit unspeakable acts of terror, promote or provoke netanyahus government to overreach in a way the United States did after September 11th. And raise their standing. Raise hamas own standing in gaza where hamas was fairly unpopular before this. Raise their own standing across the middle east. Raise their own standing in the United States. Willie, thats exactly what happened. You know, on the surface, the initial reaction from some israeli leaders and israelis may be, well, hamas did this to us. We have to continue the attacks for our longterm security. Weve gotten to a point now where continued attacks of civilians, continued killing of civilians undermines israels longterm security. This isnt even a close call. You know, im saying this as a conservative that believes israel has a right to protect itself, has a right to be secure. But what they are doing is undermining their support in the United States. We can show we showed the polls just about every day. Undermining their support among Arab Nay Poors that just entered into Peace Treaties with them over the past few years, undermining their support across the world. Yeah, when you consider the truth, that hamas is a terrorist death cult, and reminded the world of that on october 7th, this is precisely what it wants. You dont know more evidence than to know it hides in schools, hospitals, and behind civilians, because the death of a Civilian In Gaza, they view as a victory because it hurts israel. Thats the way they calculate it. Richard, on this question of the ceasefire. Shortterm ceasefire we keep hearing about. President biden raised it two weeks ago ahead of the michigan primary. Perhaps didnt turn up. We heard a couple days ago israel has all but signed onto a temporary ceasefire. Waiting for hamas to iron out a few details. Vice president harris calling for that, a sixweek ceasefire, again yesterday. Are we ever going to see this, or is this Wishful Thinking . Im in the minority here. Im skeptical hamas wants the ceasefire. Were less than a week away from the beginning of the holy month of ramadan. If youre hamas, what would you like . You wouldnt mind there being pictures of people trying to get mosques or people praying and being attacked, or this being the imagery in the arab world during ramadan. So i actually dont think its, shall we say, a slam dunk that hamas goes along with the ceasefire. Part of me thinks theyre actually hoping, and that would be consistent with, as you both were saying, with everything up until now. This is Station Identification for hamas. They want to show that only they can deliver. Only they are the real defenders of the palestinian cause. Think how different today would be if Israel On October 8th had taken a breath, allowed this to play out, put the Focus On Hamas, the sexual depravity, the killing of individuals, and gradually and quietly went after this leader or that leader, kept the Focus On Hamas rather than put the focus on itself . It seems to me that this has been a colossal mishandling. This was an opportunity to isolate hamas, show it for what it is, its dna. Put something out there politically. You could have said, heres a better way. If you really care about palestinians, hamas, they just want dead palestinians, heres a better way to go. I actually think this was strategically, every step of the way, a total loss or misguided. Understandable but all the same, counterproductive response, willie. Absolutely. Understand why it happened that way. Sure. Because you had Benjamin Netanyahu who had just told qatar three weeks earlier to keep funding hamas. You had Benjamin Netanyahu and donald trump who knew about hamas secret funding in 2018, and they refused to do anything to break it up. This is the same Benjamin Netanyahu whose government had the attack plans for one year before the Terrorist Attacks came. This is the same Benjamin Netanyahu that had divided his country apart by going to war against the rule of law and had extraordinarily low Approval Ratings even before the attack. This is the same Benjamin Netanyahu who has indictments leveled against him and knows if he leaves office, he is going to face the music in courtrooms across israel. This is the same Benjamin Netanyahu that knows, richard, that sort of response was a response he did not have the ability to project. Because he knew that if there was a pause, if it was measured, if they went about it in a way that would kill hamas leaders while continuing to have the world see these horrid pictures of october 7th, and actually build up support for israel and the israeli people and the cause of israel, katty kay, he knew he wouldnt survive. Because that pause would also show that it was Benjamin Netanyahu that funded hamas through qatar. It was Benjamin Netanyahu that allowed the funding of hamas to continue from 2018 forward. It was the same Benjamin Netanyahu that had the secret War Attack Plans for a year. It was the same Benjamin Netanyahu that was asleep at the switch and was so obsessed with the west bank and illegal settlements there, that, well, he kept the gates open, basically, to the raping and the killing. Katty, we didnt even get to the fact it took five, six, seven, eight, ten hours for netanyahu to get his army and get the police down to protect these people or to try to save some of these womens lives. Yeah, and by the way, thats the one fact i keep hearing from friends and colleagues and people i speak to in the middle east. Who say, why did it take the israelis so long . Why . Its been used as a Conspiracy Theory in arab countries, in the arab street, to say, actually, was this something the israelis allowed to happen in order to attack hamas in gaza . Of course, thats not true, but this is an area of the world where Conspiracy Theories run rampant. I think it exposed the vulnerabilities of the idf, of the netanyahu government. Look, this is the same netanyahu who, all those things you pointed out, joe, of what happened before the attack. Has he changed at all since the attack . Not one bit. He is the same netanyahu who allowed the who has done nothing to rein in the settlers in the west bank which stoked tensions in the west bank. Hes done nothing to say, lets look at the twostate solution, knowing that is part of The Big Picture deal that needs to be done in order to have saudi Israeli Security arrangements. He hasnt allowed food aid into gaza. He hasnt done as much as the americans have asked at all in terms of trying to protect civilians in gaza. All of the things that the white house, no wonder benny gantz is in washington today. All of the things that the white house has asked netanyahu to do, to try to protect civilians in gaza but also, frankly, to try to protect israels own security in the long term, netanyahu has decided not to do. Hes thrown cold water in the faces of washington. Now, the question for the white house as it meets benny gantz this week is, what do they do . Do they go to the u. N. And vote for a ceasefire . Do they do what richard is suggesting . Do they start attaching Conditionality To American weapons . Its not just the middle east thats fronting this. Increasingly, American Voters, younger American Voters are asking the white house to do more, as well. Thats the key there, the next generation. Richard, ill take kattys point to you. Has there been any answer to the question about the Response Time to october 7th . Many times, we and many others who have asked have been told, if i may, condescendingly, its not the time to ask. When is . Its not a big country. Why did it take seven hours . Look, what the government wants to do out of selfinterest is push off any investigations. Thats the position of, you know, the Prime Minister. Were too busy fighting this war. We dont have the luxury of doing this. The other day, there was an article in the Israeli Press about how the Israeli Intelligence had hours of warning, basically six or seven hours before the attack. Over 1,000 hamas fighters had substituted different sim cards into their phones. They had strategic warning something was up, and they didnt scramble to defend areas against them. My guess is, theres going to be a big issue, not just the timing of the investigation, mika, who carries it out, but what are the terms of reference . Is it how much do you look at the intelligence, the military Response Time . How independent is the commission . What access do they have to people and intelligence . Theres going to be a major debate about what is this investigation looking like . Theres precedence, particularly the 1973 war, but the timing, the terms of reference, the independence, all of that is being pushed down the road. Obviously, itll be politically embarrassing for the Israeli Intelligence and military establishment. Because of the domestic politics in israel matter to the world and u. S. Relations, two related questions. The question of when political accountability, when the bill was going to come due for netanyahu as someone who has been a controversial figure not just abroad but at home for quite a long time, when is that bill going to come due . Is this finally the moment . We dont know exactly when, but this is going to, in one way or another, eventually lead to the unraveling of netanyahus Prime Ministership, and is benny gantz the next Prime Minister of israel . On the former, maybe not. This war has a ways to play out in gaza. I think theres a respectable chance or all too high chance this expands to the north. 80 of israelis still cant live in their homes. That is not a tenable situation for any Israeli Government. The possibility this war spreads to the north cant be extended. Right now, benny gantz is a possibility, but i think people have been underestimating like, Bibi Netanyahu is a survivor. He has more lives than a cat. Theres a lot of selfinterest, not just his own but collective selfinterest, keeping him there. I wouldnt rule out the idea indictments. But he could look, you know, i think he is playing to november at a minimum. I wouldnt necessarily bet the house against him. Lets talk about the white house and how theyve been handling this. As discussed, theyve been pulling their punches on israel a bit. Privately, pressure. Publicly, the president hasnt broken with them. The Vice President was pushing for a ceasefire, more aimed at hamas than israel. Theyre israel to let more aid go in there. After the first few weeks of the war, President Biden really hasnt had much to say about this conflict at all. Thatll change thursday night, State Of The Union. We know this is hurting him domestically. The politics has become bad for President Biden in his own party. What does he has message need to be thursday . How should he reframe to the biggest audience hell have all year this issue . Say what israel is doing is not in israels selfinterest. Hell try to put on the table some elements of a political horizon for the palestinians. Hell talk about aid. I think the big difference, john, he is going to step up the criticism. Itll be more in sorrow than in anger. Thats where he is on this. Hell say, im the more proisraeli person, but he is also, i think, going to say this is unacceptable. What is going on is not the israel he recognizes, not the israel he knows. Hes looking at thursday night and also at a larger speech on the hill. Hell have however much percentage of the speech thursday night, but hes looking at a larger address where he walks through the issue and lays out an Alternative Path ahead. Thats still being debated at the white house. Richard haass, thank you very much for coming on this morning. Still ahead, molly jongfast says the Republican Party under donald trump has forgotten how to even pretend to be normal. Shell join us with more from her latest column. Plus, donald trump ramps up the antiimmigrant rhetoric now, comparing migrants to Hannibal Lecter. Well discuss his new remarks. Morning joe is coming right back. My moderate to Severe Plaque Psoriasis held me back. Now with skyrizi, im all in with clearer skin. Things are getting clearer. i feel free. To bear my skin, yeah thats all me. Nothing is everything with skyrizi, 3 out of 4 people achieved 90 clearer skin at 4 months. And most people were clearer even at 5 years. Skyrizi is just 4 doses a year, after 2 starter doses. Serious allergic reactions. And an increased risk of infections. Or a lower ability to fight them may occur. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms,. Had a vaccine, or plan to. Nothing and me go handinhand, nothing on my skin, thats my new plan. Nothing is everything nows the time,. Ask your doctor about skyrizi,. The number one. Dermatologistprescribed biologic in psoriasis. Learn how abbvie could help you save. Whoa, how did you defeat them . With a little kung fu strength and by connecting my devices to the most powerful force of all. Skadoosh. Hah, huh . Cool right . Amazing. Harness the power of xfinity internet and stay connected to the things you love. Ah, theyll be like this for hours. Hello dad, hello dad, hello da. Uhoh. Good bunnies. Ahh welcome back to morning joe. Foggy day at Reagan National airport in washington, d. C. Time to get up and go to work. A lot of people already are. The Austin American statesman is reporting on the decision to keep a border law from going into effect. Monday, the court said itd temporarily keep a hold on a texas law that empowers state Law Enforcement officers to detain and deport migrants entering or living in the u. S. Illegally. The Justice Department called the law flatly inconsistent with the high courts past decisions, which recognized the power to admit and remove noncitizens lies solely with the federal government. The boston globe is taking a look at how massachusetts is moving to cut funding for Gambling Addiction just a year after the state legalized Online Sports betting. Governor healeys 56 billion budget plan includes a 6 million cut from that program that helps identify the harms of addictive betting and the Research Behind its effects. Gamblers wagered nearly 5 billion on various Online Platforms since mobile Sports Betting became legal in the state. The plain dealer is reporting on the alarmingly high levels of flu cases in ohio. According to the cdc data released last week, the state has the highest level of flu activity in the nation. Overall, there were 726 hospitalizations due to confirmed cases of influenza in the state, up 15 from the previous week. This as er visits for flu symptoms continue to rise. And the advocate is covering louisianas use of Artificial Intelligence to help scores of students get back on track after falling behind during the pandemic. As the state races to ramp up tutoring for students testing below grade level, it has struggled to find welltrained professionals to fill those roles. Now, the state is turning to a. I. To fill the gaps at a fraction of the cost. While intensive Human Tutoring can run up to 3,000 per student, some a. I. Tutoring programs cost as low as 20 per child. Wow. Let me just say, there are great examples of this. By the way, such great news. I have to say, willie, im not going to lie to you, covid really set hopson back. What are you i was wondering where this was going. Do you have the certificate . He had been trying to get through his classes to be an emotional support dog. He is a good boy. Hes perfect. Turn to a. I. Here it is right here. It still hasnt really gotten him through. So cute. Some of his worst behavior. No. Some of his worst behavioral problems. Hes perfect. I guess a. I. , willie, cant fix that. Joe, i filed a challenge. Dogs are still dogs. I filed a challenge in federal court, and i think the Supreme Court will take it up. We wont hear it until june, challenging that certificate. I dont think he should have it based on some of the behavior you and mika described this morning. Oh, no, he is very deserving. He is a good boy. He is so supportive. Lets move for Injunctive Relief right now and just put that on hold. No. Man, he puts mika on hold often, and its really [ laughter ] joe. It is distracting when youre trying to walk a dog through the neighborhood. Joe, stop. Or the woods. Joe, let me tell you, this is such good news for us. He can come on our commercial flight and sit with us. Can we show that . There is a reason weve got him on a tight leash here, willie. You have to pull that thing really tight. No. Hes a good boy. Hes perfect. Like a Shetland Pony kicking out of the stall. Mika got into the commercial break some of the specifics of the behavior youre describing kind of vaguely here. It is when joe hugs me. Its savage. Just comes out. We may need a professional. I think so. Okay. Weve crossed over the top of the hour now. The bbcs katty kay is still with us, though right now barely. She wishes she werent. Yeah. Joining the conversation, we have msnbc contributor Mike Barnicle. President of the National Action network and host of msnbcs politics nation, reverend al sharpton. Special correspondent at vanity fair and host of the fast politics podcast, molly jongfast, political analyst. She likes hopson. I do. Okay. Lets leave it there. Willie, why dont you tell us whats going on in the news . Sure. It is Super Tuesday, guys. Happy Super Tuesday. Major week in politics. You wouldnt know but it is Super Tuesday. Voters going to the polls today. 16 states, one u. S. Territory. 865 delegates are at stake. Former President Trump widely expected to sweep the races on the republican side. Ahead of Super Tuesday, the former president continued to escalate his recent antiimmigrant rhetoric. In an interview yesterday with a farright outlet, he likened Foreign Languages to something from outer space. We have languages that are, like, from the planet mars. Nobody knows how to, you know, speak it. Then these students, and im not blaming them, im saying, they put the students in the place of our students, like in new york city. We have these wonderful students going to school. All of a sudden, they no longer have a seat. Theyre no longer invited to the school. Were putting migrants in who dont speak the language, have no idea what the teacher is saying, and we have children no longer going to school. Theyre coming from places unknown, and theyre rough people. In many cases, from jails, prisons, from mental institutions, Insane Asylums. Insane asylum, thats Silence Of The Lamb stuff. Hannibal lecter. Anybody know Hannibal Lecter . We dont want them in this country. Ter rerorists are coming in at numbers we havent seen in many, many decades. It is crazy what theyre doing. Doesnt make sense. What theyre doing is theyre poisoning our country by allowing people to come in by the millions. Joe, that mysterious language is spanish, as long as were keeping track. Que pasa . Yeah. What did he say . What did he say . Vamanos. What is this on my plate . Its called a fajita. Ah this is seriously. This is not different from his speech when he came down the escalator nine years ago. Yeah. This has been the foundation of his president ial runs. Here he is again, now sprinkling in Hannibal Lecter. Hes made that reference before, suggesting that, i guess, Central America and south american countries are emptying the Insane Asylums and sending them north. Hes suggesting people are coming from african prisons, if you want a dog whiswhistle ther too. The kind of people coming into the country, i guess, is not the kind we want here. Languages from outer space. Again, we said yesterday, hes not well, not doing well. But, again, you know, we bring up Ronald Reagan all the time here, mike. We talk about reagans Farewell Speech to america, and reagan talking about how when we close the door to immigrants, we close the door to America Continuing to thrive. Listen, ive said it all along, i want immigrants to come here legally. I dont want them to come here illegally. Ive always said that and always will. I think we should have more immigrants. They should come here legally. But heres the thing, mike, President Biden had that deal with senator lankford from oklahoma, one of the most conservative senators. They had the deal to do exactly that. They had the deal to do what republicans had been claiming they want done for years. Donald trump right there, the same donald trump talking about aliens, the same donald trump talking about poisoning the blood of americans, the same donald trump that is saying, oh, were letting these terrorists in from african jails, these Hannibal Lecters, well, hes lying, of course. But if we were, just for arguments sake, if we were, the only way theyd be getting through now is because of donald trump. Donald trump said, kill this bill. Itll help joe biden if we actually shut down the border. Ill take the blame. Donald, we blame you. We blame you because its your fault. You said you would take the blame. So he kills the bill, then he cynically goes out bitching about how the border is open, mike. Im just curious, how Many Americans are too stupid to tie those two things together . Its a good question. I dont know the answer. Lets stipulate that immigration is crucial to the future of this country. Its been crucial to our country since its inception. But lets also stipulate that the coverage of things like immigration is skewed. Immigration and the border is a really difficult issue, and its a problem right now, a problem that needs to be addressed. And, as you pointed out, senator lankford, along with the cooperation of Many Democrats in the senate and republicans in the senate, came up with a solution. They had a solution. Donald trump knows it was a solution and said, no, we dont want that solution because i want to use it to run against joe biden this fall. The other aspect of this was the film clip we showed coming into this segment. It gets to the way this election and these two men are covered by major newspapers. On sunday, the New York Times had a front page story about a poll that parts of it were devastating to the chances for joe biden to win reelection. On monday, again, on the front page above the fold, they had another story about joe biden referencing the poll but again referencing joe bidens age. Why is it that they dont cover things that we just saw and heard . A man who is literally losing his mind in front of audiences coast to coast. His name is donald j. Trump. Why is it that this is not covered in the similar fashion to the way joe bidens age is covered . Its a great question. Joe biden knows how old he is. Joe biden does more in one hour, in a day in the white house than donald trump has ever done in his presidency. Rev, i dont know about you. I hate to criticize print media. Im a print media guy, but this is out of control. No, it is out of control. Its really unfair to the American Public who has to vote on the facts that are presented to them. When you only give one picture, youre talking about bidens age when trump is around the same age. Youre ignoring on the front page, above the fold, the blatant racism. Were not talking about immigration alone with donald trump. Were talking about open racism. Hes mocking spanishspeaking people. He mocks africans. He called several african countries shole countries, and haiti. Its always antipeople of color. That ought to be on the front page. Then you have the nerve to let him say, when he has an opportunity to speak of the grandeur, strength, and history of the people of color, he goes in front of a black conservative group and say, you like me because of the mugshot i took you like me because i have all these indictments. So he is running what he entered into politics on. He entered on birtherism, denying a black president who was born here. Muslim ban. Hes running on the bias and racism that was always the major part of his campaign. They will not write about that. Theyre telling us about one old white man rather than another old white man who has not only lost his mind, but when he had one, it was bigoted. Its getting more bigoted and angry, the slurring of his words. On the one hand, a Family Member should step in and, i mean, this was my Family Member, i would be taking him to a memory care or something to get help. Im dead serious. Its not a joke. Its really sad. But, also, this is all baked in. We have two candidates that both have served as president. You mentioned some things that happened during Donald Trumps presidency. I mean, start with charlottesville and the list would last the whole show. Whether its racist things, bigoted things, things hes said and done toward women. In fact, his first trial, the one people say is less serious, is having sex with a porn star and using Campaign Finance funds to pay. I mean, i dont know, i think thats pretty serious. If you broke the law, you should be, you know innocent until proven guilty, but if you broke the law, it should be addressed. Everything about this man is shocking. You have his record of four years in office. Take a look at it. Yeah. Its telling us that what were seeing now isnt shocking. But it doesnt mean we shouldnt cover it. It doesnt mean that we should be desensitized and not notice that he looks demented, that he looks like he might be having a stroke, that he sounds especially cruel. We shouldnt ignore this and go, oh, joe biden is old. He walks funny. When a doctor said for years now hes had numbing in his feet or whatever, and it causes this. Hes got a stutter. We know this. Joe biden will tell you this. He will tell you this himself. Its not, like, news. Its not. Has anyone not heard this before about joe biden . Its been out there when he ran and when he was president. We have two president s and two presidencies to look at. People need to focus. Speaking of print media, molly is here. She writes in a piece in vanity fair, republicans own the ivf mess. You write, molly, in part, this, one of the ways donald trump won in 2016 was by empowering the farright republican base. Trump opened a pandoras box, and republicans are scrambling to shut it ahead of november. Unfortunately for republicans, theyve forgotten how to even pretend how to be formal. Ivf is a dumb hill for republicans to die on, but its a great example of just how hard it is to put the Toothpaste Back in the tube when youve spent years appeasing evangelicals and rejecting science. Its only a matter of time before this Fetal Personhood challenge comes back, and with it, a legal challenge to iuds and morning after pills, and maybe even Birth Control pills. Once you go down the road of religious zealotry, there is no easy offramp. Trump may have had some good political instincts, but this could be the one that cripples the Republican Party in the end. We go back to the election in virginia. We go back to midterms. Women will turn out. Not just women, men will turn out on this issue of losing 50 years of rights. Yeah. They put themselves i mean, the idea, almost no one in this country believes five frozen cells are a person. That you have to keep frozen. That five cells, thats a person. I mean, a very small section of this country believes that to be true. So youve set yourself up for disease. Republicans control one branch, barely, and they put mike johnson in charge of it. A guy with hours and hours of religious zealotry on tape. They could have picked emmers, someone who read as a paul ryan, but they went with trumps preferred candidate. Weve seen it again and again, trump is a terrible candidate picker, right . He has this love affair with the far right. So theyve really set themselves up. Ivf is wildly popular, and Birth Control, as well it should be, is also popular. Theyre setting themselves up, you know, with a real problem. Molly, Something Like 2 of american babies are born through ivf. Im sure half of them are democrats and half are republicans. Theyre not uniquely democrats. Spell out what the situation is now with the other states that are looking at limiting. Its not just alabama. There are, what, some ten other states . Then those three states, texas, louisiana, missouri, who are also looking at trying to curb iuds and the morning after pill, where do those states stand . In the ruling in alabama and the pushback from republicans against that, could those states decide, that was a bridge too far and well back away from this, or are they pushing ahead . Alabama actually did do legislation that said ivf you are not going to face Manslaughter Charges if you destroyed a fivecelled embryo. Congratulations to alabama. I mean, talk about, you know, a very, like, lame victory. So, you know, people may be able to continue ivf in the state of alabama, but think about how crazy this is. I mean, you know, mike pence had his kids through ivf. This is not a person who is a wild leftist, mike pence. The fact were even here shows what trouble republicans are in. Look, there are going to be a lot of states, a lot of challenges, but the Fetal Personhood, which should be embryonic personhood, is part of these heart beat bills, which, again, these, you know, are multicelled, you know, frozen organisms, not necessarily the idea that this is a child is wild stuff. Yeah. Let me just say, mika, just a little Southern Baptist programming note here. There is nothing wrong with mike johnson had religious studies or whatever, nothing wrong with that. You know, as we have talked about, my parents took me to church, like, two, three, four nights a week. It didnt i know what youre saying, it didnt take. But a lot of it did. The thing is, its not that mike johnson is, like, some holy, you know, some holy example who is guided by the bible. First of all, he got to power based on the biggest lie in recent american history, so jesus didnt get him there. The lie did. But theres also, again, this bears repeating because of the selfrighteousness of so many on the far, far, trump right. Theyve invented a religion. This Christian Nationalism, theyve invented a religion. It keeps getting more extreme every week. Ivf now is, i guess, the devils playhouse. Mike pence had kids through ivf. Now what, is he a heretic . Are they going to hang him . They wanted to. Is his wife a witch . Are they going to have witch trials now . You know, i will say this again, and let those who have ears to hear, hear. When i was in high school, the Southern Baptist convention was pro choice. In fact, they were pro choice from the time of jesus through the time the beatles broke up. Wait, theres more. Not only through the time the beatles broke up were these Protestant Denominations pro choice, they were pro choice through the time the eagles broke up. Yes, through the long run, all right . Through the long run. We can go the distance if our heart you know the song. Think about that for a second, as theyre waving their bibles in your face and telling you that you are insufficiently christian because you dont believe what jerry falwell, richard viguerie, and paul wyrick decided. Please stay with me. Decided in 1979 they had to do to beat a democratic president who happened to be Southern Baptist. They couldnt say he was insufficiently christian because he taught Sunday School Every sunday, basically. And he was a good and decent man. So what did they do . Stay with me i know you dont want to hear it out there, but stay with me because it is the truth. They invented the issue of abortion as a not just as a political issue. Jerry falwell, richard viguerie, a republican operative, and paul wyrick, a direct republican specialist, said, were going to create abortion not just as a political issue. Were going to make it a religious issue. Mmhmm. By making it a religious issue, again, the long run had already been released by the eagles. Theyd broken up. Elvis costellos My Aim Is True already out for three years. They decided at this point people, by the way, at this point had already thrown away their Leisure Suits and their pet rocks. This is how far removed from the birth of jesus christ this was gia pets . Still with us now. Love it. Still with us now, by the way. They decided, were going to make abortion a religious issue. That way, jimmy carter can take votes from Conservative Catholics and working class protestants. Thats what they figured out. Now, you fast forward all these years later, and talk to most of my friends, theyll tell you, abortion, thats a religious issue. You know what its like . Its like the Death Penalty is what it is like, actually. You read the bible. Your view of the bible can inform you on these issues, but the fact, the fact, mika, that they now are saying, not only is abortion a religious issue and youre going to hell if youre pro choice i wonder about my mom and my grandmom and my dad and people who went to church for week after week after week, my grandmom. This would be a shock to her, that she was insufficiently christian when she worshipped and prayed and lived one of the most devout lives ever. This would be a real shock, that since she was in the Southern Baptist convention, shes going to hell because the Southern Baptist convention was pro choice. But now, its gotten even more extreme, as these things do. Yeah. So, now, abortion is banned. If your 10yearold girl is raped by an illegal immigrant and you dont want your 10yearold girl to have to carry the Illegal Immigrants baby to term. You dont want the state to force your 10yearold girl to have a baby, there are people who think youre going to hell. Listen, i wouldnt want to be standing in front of jesus, like at the end of my life, answering for what i did to that 10yearold girl, forcing her and her parents to flee the state. Because of some religious precept that was created in 1980 in the Protestant Church by jerry falwell, richard viguerie, and paul wyrick. Now, they come for ivf. Why are we surprised . Is anybody surprised . When they took the constitutional right for a women to choose, took it away from women for the first time in 50 years, they warned us. Clarence thomas warned us. He said, now that weve looked at this, we need to look at interracial marriages. Wait, no, he didnt say that. We need to look at contraception. We need to look at marriage equality. We need to look and he went down the list. Why are we surprised . For you people out there who think it is going to end here, you are dreaming. Yeah. Because now, what they call Christian Nationalism has nothing to do with the gospel of jesus christ. And we have seen through history, reverend al, people drunk with power and using religious for political power, it always ends badly. It always ends badly. Its moving in that direction now. It always ends badly in history, but as you did this sermonette this morning, and the Church Says Amen for you because it was well delivered yeah. As you went through the litany of what theyve done, as well as saying, accurately, they made an issue that never had anything to do with the really religious bases that we believe in as baptist or as christians, this is in the bible. What did they go after jesus for that led to his trial and crucifixion . They created what they said was sinful and was good and usable, or those that defied the laws of what was appropriate. He hangs out with the ones breaking the rules of the temple. Thats what theyve done. Not only is it not like jesus, it is exactly how they tried jesus and sentenced him to death on the cross. Because he challenged those that were using false gods and false laws and rules to fit their political agenda for power. Yeah, and, molly, a great piece. Its been made very clear, as roe has been rolled back, that abortion is health care in so many ways. It saves lives. It preserves the quality of life for an abnormal fetus or for the mother who will be sterilized. It does so many more things than these, i guess, religious zealots who made it up they claim it is sin because youre doing something to kill a life. Its just not what they say it is. Ask the woman sent to wait in a parking lot until they can treat her, right, because she is having a miscarriage, which we see reporting about that everywhere. I mean, look, we have definitely seen a lot of, you know, these i mean, even you know, miscarriages are really, really common. You have women who cannot get treated, who cannot get a dnc. Come on. Right . The stories out of texas are wild. Then you have but even a larger point about this, which is, like, weve definitely seen that abortion is health care, is that republicans are running on something that is insane, right . Most voters want Birth Control to be available. This is not a controversial topic. You know, most voters want to be able to have ivf if they need it. I mean, i think this is really a hill thats going to be really hard, a political hill to survive. Really, you have voters it is like when gore went after pornography. Its a mistake. The American People do not want to lose their rights to Birth Control. Its crazy. Molly jongfast, thank you very much for coming on. Great piece. Joe, that was pretty good. I thought, i stayed with him. Stunning, absolutely stunning. He asked us to stay with him. And accurate, very accurate. Very accurate. Hey, hey, after all these things, stunningly superficial. Please dont. I feel so bad about that. What about the paradise on the Dashboard Lights fit in . That actually actually, that had been released two years no, i think, like three years before they decided abortion was a sin. So from jesus to meat loaf Bat Out Of Hell plus two, right . Im dead serious. Plus two, right . It was only two years after Bat Out Of Hell by meat loaf that they said, oh, wait, wait, wait, wait, there is a Southern Baptist in the white house and he is a democrat . Weve got to do something. We need a solution. We need salvation. Okay. Lets say this is a sin. I had a friend, like last time i brought this up, saying, joe, joe, youre forgiving a grave sin. Im like, what are you talking about . It wasnt a grave sin until 1 1980, republican operatives told you it is a grave sin. Not biblical. Ladies and gentlemen, please, please, with every head bowed and every eye closed, lets let meat loaf take us to break. All the people said amen. It is Super Tuesday. Well go live to South Carolina and florida where the haley and Trump Campaigns will be watching Super Tuesday results roll in today. Keep that music playing. Plus, well be joined by colorados Secretary Of State Jena Griswold on the heels of the Supreme Court ruling that donald trump must stay on her states primary ballot. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Im hearing different ways for me to screen for colon cancer. Its time to use my voice, ive got a choice, more than one answer. I sat down with my doc. We had a talk. Knew just what to say. I asked for cologuard and did it my way. Cologuard is a oneofa kind way to screen for colon cancer thats effective and noninvasive. Its for people 45 plus at average risk, not high risk. False positive and negative results may occur. Ask your provider for cologuard. I did it my way the all new godaddy airo helps you get your Business Online in minutes with the power of ai. With a perfect name, a great logo, and a beautiful website. Just start with a domain, a few clicks, and youre in business. Make now the future at godaddy. Com airo today, my friend you did it, you did it, you did it. Centrum silver is now clinically shown to support Cognitive Health in older adults. Its one more step towards taking charge of your health. So every day, you can say, youuu did it with centrum silver. Theres a surge of antisemitism in the United States and around the world, and its sickening. We see it across our communities, colleges, social media. They surface painful scars from millenia of hate to genocide of the jewish people. President biden speaking in december denouncing a rise in antisemitic incidents in the United States following the October 7th Hamas terrorist attack on israel. Joining us frank foer of the atlantic. The april edition of the magazine is titled, the golden age of American Jews is ending. Frank, good morning. You write, quote, in the years following world war ii and especially as the world began to comprehend the extent of the nazi genocide, a liberal consensus took hold and antisemitism receded. There was a rush of creativity. Now, jews are treated in sectors of the left as the epitome of whiteness. Any analysis that focuses on the role of privilege will be dangerously blind to antisemitism because antisemitism itself entails an accusation of privilege. In the death spiral of liberalism, extremism on the right begets extremism on the left, which begets further extremist on the right. Edge lords and trolls attempted to seize the mantle of liberty. When antisemitism takes hold, Conspiracy Theory hardens into conventional wisdom, embedding violence, thought, and deadly action. A society that holds jews at arms length is likely to be more intent on hunting down Scape Fwoegoats than addressing defects. Though its hardly an iron law of history, societies are prone to decline. If america persists on the current course, itd be the end of the golden age for jews and the country that nurtured them. Frank, ill let you flush that out more, but it feels like were on the precipice of something or that something already changed since october 7th. Where do you think it is headed from here . What were seeing began much before october 7th. There were signs. It was not just a problem that we see on the left. Its a problem we see on the left and the right. You can trace a lot back to the rise of donald trump, who winked at White Supremacists. Antisemitism had been something that had been locked up in a closet, but as the irish diplomat, connor cruz obrien once said, antisemitism is a late sleeper. When trump basically gave the green light to White Supremacists to say they were more welcome into the mainstream, you suddenly saw this tremendous surge of antisemi antisemitism. Whats important about what were witnessing now is its not just about the jews. It is a symptom of a democracy and a political culture that is failing. When were unable to resolve other differences through politics, when you see violence rising, when you see conspiracy rising, these are conditions that are ripe for the rise of antisemitism, and theyre also the conditions emblematic of the decline of a democracy. Frank, connor cruz obrienan sleeper. He could have said antisemitism is a latent sleeper. As you write in this piece, and i want you to explain this, please, the jewish vacation from history ended September 11th, 2001. It didnt seem that way, but the Terror Attacks opened an era of perpetual crisis, becoming fertile soil for the hatred of jews to take root. I was looking for where this epidemic, this recent pout of the epidemic began. When i grew up in the 1980s and 90s, it seemed antisemitism was a dead force in american society. There were scholars and sociologists who said that antisemitism was so minuscule, so fringe, it wasnt worth worrying that much about. Then the Terror Attacks of September 11th happened. You started to see these signs that antisemitism was actually surging. So you had Conspiracy Theories that blamed the fall of the twin towers on mossad, the Israeli Intelligence service. You had other theories that began to say that americas adventurism in the world was the product of jewish warmongers who had dual loyalties. This was something that was much more mainstream than the mossad theories. What you saw was that the 1990s were kind of this vacation from history. It was a time we said was the end of history. Everything seemed like it was headed on a great course. Then we have this rolling series of crises. You have 9 11, the iraq war, the financial crisis, trump, the tea party rises. Crisis really is this thing where people need to explain something that is inexplicable. Deep inside the western mind, deep inside the american mind, is this tendency to find this very convenient theory that blames the jews for everything that has gone wrong. Frank, one of the things that really interested, caught my eye in your piece, was you talked about how many of us that call ourselves progressives have been swept into this or at least give some kind of oxygen to what inadvertently is antisemitic. You can be, i am opposed to netanyahu and still embrace the fact that youre not going to be for people in israel that are civilians and children being subjected to terrorism and still denounce what is going on in gaza. Talk about how we could inadvertently go too far. Ive had to, in my life, dealt with, i shouldnt have said that because thats not how i meant. And how the left cannot give oxygen to people that are antisemitic, homophobia, islamophobia, all of it. Your piece drives that nail through the wood. Thank you for making the distinction, reverend al. If you polled most American Jews, theyd have sharp criticisms of netanyahu. Netanyahus Approval Rating among American Jews is no perso the occupation, the campaign being conducted in gaza. But this is a separate question. The way in which things get taken too far is that jews end up getting pushed out of progressive coalitions because theres a litmus test thats imposed on them. Which is, you have to be antizionist. So even if jews, American Jews, have criticisms of israel, those criticisms come ultimately of a place of love for country and a place. Theyre being told, well, if you have that love, which is so deeply embedded in your culture, in your religion, then you cant join our groups. You see this happening on college campuses. The source of the center of jewish life on campus is excluded from groups, though the rabbis and people who attend services are progressive. Sexual assault survivors groups say, if youre zionist, youre not welcome here. The term, zionist, has become this synonym almost for jews. It is where things start to go, i think, in my mind, too far. Antizionism, the use of this term, zionism, which describes jews as being conniving or controlling, exhibiting bloodlust, it really carries all of these ancient tropes with it. It seems to me as if it is a way of injecting thought and ideas that are otherwise Beyond The Pale into legitimate discourse. Staff writer at the atlantic, frank fore, thank you very coming on this morning. We appreciate it. Take care. Coming up, well talk with chris krebs about the electionrelated threats posed by foreign adversaries on this Super Tuesday. Plus, well play for you some of the emotional farewell to philadelphia from retiring eagles star jason kelce. Morning joe is back in a moment. If you spit blood when you brush, it could be the start of a domino effect. New parodontax active gum repair breath freshener. Clinically proven to help reverse the four signs of early gum disease. A new toothpaste from parodontax, the gum experts. I feel refreshed because i am not struggling with cpap anymore. She looks great. I got inspire. Great sleep at the click of a button. Did she get implants . Yeah, i got an implant, sheila its inspire. Learn more and view Important Safety Information at inspiresleep. Com why choose a sleep number smart bed . Lecan i make my side softer . T Safety Information i like my side firmer. Sleep number does that. The queen sleep number c4 smart bed is only 1,599, save 300. Shop now at sleepnumber. Com with wet amd, i worry im not only losing my sight, but my time to enjoy it. But now, i can open up my world with vabysmo. vabysmo is the first fdaapproved treatment for people with wet amd that improves vision and delivers a chance for up to 4 months between treatments, so i can do more of what i love. vabysmo works differently, its the only treatment designed to block 2 causes of wet amd. Vabysmo is an eye injection. Dont take it if you have an infection, active eye swelling, or are allergic to it. Treatments like vabysmo can cause an Eye Infection or retinal detachment. Vabysmo may cause a temporary increase in eye pressure after receiving the injection. There is an uncommon risk of heart attack or stroke associated with blood clots. Severe swelling of Blood Vessels in the eye can occur. Most common eye side effects were cataract and broken Blood Vessels. Open up your world with vabysmo. A chance for up to 4 months between treatments with vabysmo. Ask your doctor. Are you still struggling with your bra . Its time for you to try knix. Makers of the worlds comfiest wireless bras. For revolutionary support without underwires, and sizes up to a gcup, find your new favorite bra today at knix. Com welcome back. Super tuesday voting gets under way. Our next guest says foreign adversaries like china and russia are paying close attention and pushing their agendas by trying to stoke chaos through Disinformation Campaigns, cyber attack efforts, and even physical threats against Election Officials. Joining us now is the former director of the Cyber Security and infrastructure security agency, chris krebs. He is the chief Public Policy officer at the Cyber Security company sentinal one. What should we look out for today, and what are you watching . My hope is, as i said in 2020, november 3rd, just another tuesday on the internet. Where it is quiet. I do expect from a Cyber Security perspective that it will be fairly calm out there. Foreign adversaries find it difficult to make sense of primaries. They dont necessarily understand the individual state races and the actual party votes. I expect it to be from a cyber attack perspective fairly quiet. I would expect, though, some disruption out there. We joked about it and called it the advance persistence backhoe. There will likely be a Construction Crew out there somewhere in the 15 states with the republican primary that will dig up a power line and shut off power to a voting location. We should expect and anticipate it to be calm and moving forward. You mean that intentionally, the conspiracy theyre moving along. Yes. Let me ask you about, theres sort of this Disinformation Campaign that, as you taught us over the years, is ongoing. Thatll be some of that today. Then there are actual attempts that you point out to disrupt actual voting systems on the day of voting. Are those ever effective . Those are one of the things that donald trump and his supporters have pointed to, that the machines were messed with and all that. Thats never been proven. Do nations and groups that want to disrupt our elections, do they still try to do that . Theres not a whole lot of evidence that weve seen historically of state actors, whether it is russia, china, iran, or others, that would actually try to interfere with the cast, counting, and certification of the voting process. The Intelligence Community continues to assess, at least according to my understanding, that that capability is not resonant and it certainly hasnt been demonstrated over the last ten or so years. To your point, though, we do see state actors, so, again, russia and china and others, as well as cyber criminals, continue to pepper away at state and local government offices. Ransomware is on the rise. 2023 was historically a high year for so it would not be unexpected to see cyber criminal activities that overlaps into elections. These systems are resilient, decentralized, hard to have a regional sort of at scale impact. The bigger point here, is disinformation, its campaigns by the state Security Services that are still ongoing. We had just two weeks ago researchers talked about doppelganger, an ongoing russian disinformation to undermine support for ukraine in the defense of ukraine. We have seen the same actors and that was in germany. We have seen the same actors in the u. S. Sewing chaos and encouraging civil war due to the issues at the southern border. Its very, very active. Its not just russia. China is very active as well. This is where we have to, as hard as it sounds these days, we have to keep our heads on straight and look to the trusted officials, the Election Officials for whats going on out there with todays results. One way to attempt to disrupt is cyber threats, but there is also been physical threats. What more could be done to safeguard the people trying to make sure our elections are conducted free and fairly. Yeah. This is the number one request from state and local officials to federal officials on support. Its not so much about cybersecurity vulnerability assessments, its help us protect our people. There is swatting, where somebody calls into 911 and says there has been a shooting at a home of an election official and risk to Public Safety and the s. W. A. T. Teams deploy. These on the rise the last couple of years. We have seen this actually result in some pretty gruesome outcomes. But fortunately the federal Law Enforcement has the fbi has it seems disrupted some of the networks that supporting supporting swatting. We have seen Steven Richard over the weekend posted about five or six folks across the country that have threatened him and Election Officials in maricopa county. So its absolutely still a risk to Election Officials. They deserve nothing but our support and praise for their hard work. Former director of the cybersecurity and infrastructure security agency, chris krebs, thank you very much for coming on the show on Super Tuesday. Its an election day. Obviously, the economy plays a huge role in elections. Joining us now is the editorinchief of the economist. Its great to see you. I am curious, your assess of the u. S. Economy, leading indicators, how all analysts say versus how people feel, because even yesterday i was talking to young people and hearing about impossibly high prices at the Grocery Store. So the economy is in pretty good shape. Gdp is growing. Inflation is coming down faster than many other parts of the world. The reason i think people are feeling unhappy the u. S. Had a period of very high inflation. Inflation has gone up, price up about 15 . People are feeling the higher prices. And they are feeling bad about that. They dont like that. Even though now its coming down, it takes a while for that to filter through into peoples perception. I am not surprised people arent giving him credit for the strong economy. The question is over the months that come if the economy is strong and inflation keeps coming down, that changes. I am worried it wont change enough. Yeah. Will the prices go down over the next two months . Inflation will come down. Prices wont come down. Even if it comes down, prices are a lot higher than when joe biden took office. You go to the Grocery Store its incredible. I come from london and i am just i cant pick anything up off the shelf thats another thing. I am just stunned at how expensive everything is. I am, too. Everything is looked up. Thats a separate conversation. From london, from europe, where we are in our american politics as we approach a day that once we get through tonight will be, if it wasnt already, clear that dugout is the nominee and we are headed to a prematch of 2020 with the very real possibility that donald trump returns to the white house. How are markets, how are politicians and parliaments looking at that . We are all transfixed, i think. Basically, the rest of the world is obsessed with u. S. President ial elections, even more so this team because this really, really matters for the rest of the world. When i come here i am struck by i am not sure how many people realize that outside the u. S. The stakes of this election are extraordinarily high. And so were all absolutely obsessed with it. Super tuesday is kind of interesting. Its sort of super snooze day this year, right . Most other elections, everyone in london is gripped. This time it doesnt really matter. And i think there is a sort of sense of is it going to be an inextriable march of these candidates who those parties dont want to be their nominees or is something going to change that picture. The conversation outside of the u. S. Is, is anybody going to stop donald trump. In europe, this is the one thing i talk to people about, what is going to happen if donald trump is president . What does it mean for europe, the rest of the world. No matter who wins, the relationship with china is near the top of the agenda for either President Biden, who says that the next century will be defined by this competition between the u. S. And china or donald trump who is threatening a significant trade war with beijing. You have been keeping an eye on china, setting an ambition 5 growth. Their economy had stalled. Xi jinping changed that. They announced this. 5 was ter target last year after the incredible lockdown. When that was lifted, they could go back to 5 growth. They are in deflation. People lost confidence. Very ambitious. Its interesting. You mentioned it is going to be the big it was the one area there wasnt a huge amount of difference between biden and trump except President Trump is not threatening higher tariffs and more aggressive policy. Wonderful. Thank you so much. Great to see you. Nice to have you on the set with us. Thank you. From the world of sports, Center Jason Kelce has called it a career. The 36yearold delivering an emotional had 5minute speech yesterday announcing his retirement from the nfl. Thanks for coming, guys. See how long this lasts. What brings us all here today where i announce that im retiring. I announce im retiring from the nfl after 13 seasons with the philadelphia eagles. I dont know whats next, but i look forward to the new challenges and opportunities that you a wait and i know i carry with me the lessons from my time here and that forever and that forever we shall all share the bond of being philadelphians. His mother, father, brother travis were there in the front row of that announcement as well. Kelce was named to seven pro bowls in his 13 nfl seasons. Fifth center in history with six allpro selections. The other four are in the hall of fame. Wow. Mike, it was beautiful to watch. The family aspect of that, he is talking about how important it is to be a good dad, not just for him, but in our society, wants to spend time and watch his kids grow up. He made the pro bowl this year. He is still at the top of his game. You look back on a career where you bring philly the first super bowl, you go to the pro bowl seven times, thats a pretty good run. And sometimes gets overshadowed because of who travis is. Jason kelce one of the best ever. The thing that struck me the most about watching him yesterday and what he had to say, the content of what he had to say about his family and this familys influence on him and his brother is there and Everybody Knows his brother because of his brothers girlfriend, okay . He is pretty good, too. Maybe one of the best of all time. And the tears that were shed. The thing that struck me the most was the element of good parenting. Clearly, his parents and his brothers parents, they had a remarkable influence on these two guys. I dont know about you . No question. And this is not the end jason kelce. He and his brother have a very successful podcast. Its clear that he wants a media job to go along with his role as a father. He will soon have it. He is extremely well spoken. Emotional yesterday. Clearly, going to be a star that was sad. All right. Still ahead on morning joe may i ask what you wrote down with that ball point pen . Oh, nothing. An idea for a sermon. You had one just now . I get them all the time. How fortunate. I forget them so i write them down. What is the idea . Intolerance. That was a clip from the Broadway Revival of doubt, a parable, that tells the story of a sknd scandal this a Catholic School and a nun who serves to uncover the truth. We will be joined by Leiv Schreiber who plays father flynn. First, our coverage of Super Tuesday continues right now. If you are running for president , your job is to bring people in, not push people out of your club. Then the next day he went and he said that the rnc should name him the presumptive nominee. Now, we dont anoint kings in america. We have a elections. And texans deserve the right to vote. The what we are thinking about, it sends signal if you cant get out to vote tomorrow, get your husband, your wife, your friends, get their friends because we want to send a signal that were coming. This freight trains coming. We have to do that and we have to do it tomorrow. Tomorrows the big day. Welcome to morning joe on this Super Tuesday. Voters heading to the polls in 16 states and one u. S. Territory. Republican primaries and caucuses in 15 states with 865 delegates at stake. Former President Donald Trump widely expected to sweep the races in all of the States Holding contests today. Last night trump won the north dakota reason caucuses beating nikki haley by 70 points. Trump likely will be awarded all 29 of that states delegates. In an interview with conservative Media Company rsbn last night, donald trump expressed confidence heading into todays vote while nikki haley made her closing arguments to texas in front of a packed rally in fort worth. I just say to the people that are watching now if you could, go out and vote because its not haley. She is not a problem. I think she is very negative for the party. She is not a problem in terms of winning because we are winning by a lot. The only place we expect to lose is d. C. Because thats the swamp. Tomorrow we could very well win every state in record numbers. Thats what we hope for. They call it Super Tuesday for a reason. And i think its going to be record setting. I hope so. Republicans lost the vote on mayorkas, on israel, the rnc chair lost her job and donald trump had his fingerprints on all of it. At some point maybe we should say the reason that america keeps losing is because of donald trump. We can change all of that. But in order to change it, its going to take a lot of courage. Courage from everybody here. Courage for me to run and courage for every one of you to know, dont complain about what happens in a general election if you dont vote in this primary. We are blessed to live in america. And we know that americas better than this. Now we have to do something about it. So this is i will tell you. Tomorrow you got a job to do. I need you to vote and i need you to take ten people with you. I tell you this, john. Watching nikki haley and watching her grow on the Campaign Trail, and i will say, again, mika and i have known her since she was a state legislators. She was pretty darn good as a state legislators as far as her skill set as a politician. Watching that Nikki Haley On Stage and understanding that she is running in Donald Trumps party, i just cant help but look at that person and think, if she were to run as an independent candidate, lets say run as an independence candidate and get access in all 50 states, which of course i dont think she could, that person, that message could do better than ross perot, especially this year. Thats somebody who could actually be a contender as an independent candidate. I dont know. I mean, there is, obviously, there has been there is a chunk of voters as we know vastly dissatisfied with the choice at the top of the presumptive tops of both tickets, right. You have this growth in the independent segment of the electorate. For the last 20 or 30 years, we have seen intense polarization. There hasnt been much space for you have 40, 42, 43 on one side or the other. It didnt matter whether the candidates were anyone they liked. There wasnt space for a thirdparty. Hyper polarized climate, the parties of generally satisfied with their respective candidates. This is a different situation. Joe, i think its a we are in such unchartered territory in terms of voter dissatisfaction with trump and biden. You might be right. The interesting question is not what happens if nikki haley were to be in the an independent or thirdparty candidate. What would have happened the question that will haunt a lot of people on republican side, is what would would have happened if she found her way to the clarity she found and strength she found, the voice she found, whatever you want to call it, found this position not in january of this year, but last a year ago january or even a year ago june, in june, if she had been doing this not necessarily just this good, but this clear about the space shioc spied in the republican firmament, how much more i think she was trying she seemed i mean, she has toggled between kind of trump skeptic and trump admirer for her entire career since trumps been on the scene. If she had been in this place and consistently campaigning this way from the middle of last year, how much closer would this republican nomination fight have been. She came to the she got she found clarity way too late. Thats the question that hovers over what might have been and sometimes what happened in the future. There are a lot of people who wonder if she will have this clarify after she leaves the race, tomorrow or some other day soon to come. Well, and perhaps sorry, willie. Perhaps, willie, after she after this race, after the general election, if donald trump loses again, she has a great argument. If donald trump wins, of course, its completely different. The thing is, willie, a lot of people made calculations. Nikki haley and ron desantis and others, that they could ignore donald trump t that they could push him aside, they could pat his followers on the head, that alvin bragg or some other prosecutors was going to take care of donald trump and thats why they didnt do it a year before. I must say, if somebody were running against a democrat in a democratic primary that was suitably damaged, they probably would try to ignore that democrat and chart their own paths. So it has been a very tortured run, but there is always been this lane. And i dont know how big the lane is. Liz cheney would tell you. Adam kinzinger would tell you not very big. Im not so sure if you just came forward from the very beginning with the strong conviction, i can win, this guy cant, im not so sure she wouldnt be doing better now. But we are where we are and this a strong message. She will probably lose everything tonight. But i dont think she is playing for tonight. I think she is playing for tomorrow. I think she is looking over the horizon. She may have a future. I guess the question is would it have mattered . We will never know. If she had done what john suggested last year and come out stronger and not using the vagaries of kicking sideways, trying to have it both ways and keep donald trump supporters, maybe that would have made a zirchts. Maybe it wouldnt have. Maybe this is just Donald Trumps party and the loyalists are so strong in his corner, we dont know. Its strange we are sitting here on the morning of Super Tuesday, something we covered so many times before, and no drama whatsoever. Its just donald trump expected to roll through the 15 states. I guess the question is will nikki haley drop out tonight or tomorrow morning, hang in for a couple more weeks. It will be two more weeks before donald trump technically secures the nomination. Here we are just rolling towards this general election now as he turn the corner to the state the union. This feels like a milestone. The general election is upon us as of this week. President biden going to have a clean sweep on the democratic side. For republicans, nikki haleys team suggests maybe a shot at vermont but probably not. Therefore, trumps going to win everything there, too. What happens next to haley . Is there an event later this week in her home state . Her team is not saying. She herself has said i am in it to Super Tuesday. She left the door open to staying longer that, a few more weeks until trump becomes the nominee or even beyond that, wouldnt suspend her campaign. Trumps first criminal trial three weeks away, maybe she keeps her eye on that, maybe she tries to suggest something could happen at the convention, wants to keep her options open. Campaigns to truism and when they run out of money thats not an tru for haley she has enough money to keep this going for a while and what she has done is she has displayed trumps vulnerabilities. Even though she won one contest, the one in washington, d. C. , put up a fairly impressive size of the vote in a couple of states. New hampshire, South Carolina among them. And revealed some concerns for trump going forward. So issues he is going to have to address come november. We have seen those polls where a lot of Haley Supporters say its vote for joe biden or stay home. And because as long as she stays in the race and continues to deliver messages these antitrump messages, she is delivering them to audiences who otherwise wouldnt hear them. Should he is being heard on fox news and other places that wouldnt hear. Donald trump has a big win but the turnout is tiny and he gets 50 some percent of that turnout. Last night in north dakota, which he won by 70 or 72 points, sound like a big number. He got 1,800 total votes. So, yes yeah. The margins are huge but people arent turning out for him. We will 11 from the results tonight. To willies point, its so interesting there is no Drama Heading into Super Tuesday. And pointing out that on the republican side one of the candidates has probably one of the controversial candidates in the world and yet no kraum a. What are you watching tonight . Yeah, in a way nikki haley has revealed two things. That this is Donald Trumps party and really is his party, that nobody can make a dent on him. I dont know. If she had gone for the Chris Christie lane from the beginning, would it have helped her . Would she have done better or worse . She made the calculation that was not an option to her. She revealed his weakness, his vulnerabilities and the number, the team Charlie Sykes our friend and sarah who i chatted the other day, how big is that lane, how big is that group of republicans who will never vote for donald trump. Thats what im watching tonight in the exit polls. Are we going to get a sense of how many republicans there are who are voting in the primaries who will who like nikki haley, that message she started delivering so robustly and never vote for donald trump because i think that will give us a sense of november. Thats going to give us the best indication of whether joe biden has this chance because a better chance because there are republicans who arent going to in the end, the election comes down to how Many Democrats wont vote for vote by mail ballot Joe Biden Joe biden around how many wont vote for donald trump. Thats what elections like today will show us. John, one of the things im looking for is what willie brought up, the turnout. Because we do see every year, every four years, a turnout from parties, you know, does make a big difference how excited are they, how energized are they to get out and vote. The contest last night, can you believe you win a republican contest and trumps crowing about it with 1,632 votes. Most City Council Members in midsized towns get more than 1,632 votes. Again, we keep going back to iowa. 14 of republicans in iowa voted. Thats 14 of about a third of registered voters in iowa. And he got 50 of the 14 of the 33 of you just keep going on and on and he ends up with about 50,000 votes and wins the storied iowa caucuses. These numbers are way down. And there are a lot of republicans that are disaffected by donald trump. If they are voting for him, they are doing it holding their nose. Yeah, that number i think thats from north dakota you mentioned there. Its like there are probably some condominiums Condominium Association votes in the state of florida that are bigger than that. So, yes. Look, whats revealed i think in this period are two things. One is on the democratic side joe biden has a problem with democratic voters in the sense he lacks enthusiasm among the base. Donald trump is claiming almost all of the people, percentagewise of the people and polls we see, too, people who voted for him last time around. Joe biden has a problem for people who drifted away from him. He has to get those people back. Donald trump has 98 of the people would voted for him last time but the pool is shrinking. So the problem with the republican side is this enthusiasm problem. Having been there in iowa, in South Carolina, having been in New Hampshire, the lack of enthusiasm, said it on the show every single all those contests, im say it again. The lack of enthusiasm for donald trump outside his core base is palpable. Lets than 2020, less than 2016. People in the Republican Party are acquiescent to trump en masse, rather than enthusiastic about him. That will be a problem for him for sure because he needs every single one of those people if he is going to be the nominee and win in november. Coming up, live to florida where donald trump is reacting to the Supreme Courts decision on his eligibility to be on the ballot. Nbcs Vaughn Hilliard with the latest from outside maralago straight ahead on morning joe. Blan blan when trump came for our rights, the aclu showed up. Various see you in court. The aclu already making good on that promise. The aclu is currently engaged in litigation. In response to a 2018 lawsuit filed by the aclu. The aclu is prepared to preserve our democracy and hold those who threaten our freedoms accountable. We will defend everyones rights. In court, in congress, in every statehouse, and in the streets. We are the American Civil Liberties union. American Civil Liberties union, inc. Is responsible for the content of this advertising. Hi, im jason. Ive lost 228 pounds on golo. American Civil Liberties union, inc. Changing your habits is the only way that gets you to lose the weight. And golo is the plan thats going to help you do that. Just take the first step, go to golo. Com. Speaking of former President Donald Trump today, the Supreme Court ruled that colorado is not allowed to remove him from the 2024 ballot. Then out of habit trump immediately appealed the decision. This is a oh, wait a minute. Thats right. The Supreme Court ruled that states cant keep trump off the ballots. The Supreme Court remains the only place where trump can win the popular vote. The Supreme Court foes you cant just let states decide who goes on the ballots. States are too busy deciding that life begins in the feezor section. Next to the pearl onions. Yeah. Okay. I dont know. I didnt like that one. But its true. I mean tough crowd. Donald trump will remain on the ballot despite efforts in some states to make him ineligible for the 2024 election. The Supreme Court yesterday unanimously rejected the ruling from colorados Supreme Court that removed the former president from the ballot based on section 3 of the 14th Amendment. Now, the justices ruled that a patchwork of decisions around the country could send elections into chaos if State Officials have the freedom to determine who could appear on the ballot. The decision makes clear that it is up to congress to enforce the insurrectionist clause against federal officeholders and candidates, but the three Liberal Justices accused their conservative colleagues of going too far by Ruling Congress must enact new legislation in order to ban a president ial candidate. They wrote that this decision will make it harder to bar, quote, An Oathbreaking Insurrectionist from becoming president , willie. Former u. S. Attorney and msnbc contributor chuck rosenberg. Chuck, this was widely expected. I dont know if it was expected to be unanimous. But it is at 90 on the vote here. I should point out conservative justice amy conemy barrett was critical of some pieces of her colleagues ruling on this. This talks about federal officeholders, which is to say the state does not have the right to keep a federal candidate off the ballot. It can do that with State Candidate and local candidates, but not federal. Are you surprised by anything you saw in this decision yesterday . Not really, willie. With one asterisk. If you listen to the Oral Argument last month, it was pretty clear that the vote was going to be lopsided. 81. 90. Turned out to be 90, to prohibit states from determining the qualifications for candidates for federal office. So the 9 vote didnt surprise me very much. There was, as you candidates for federal office. Now section 3 is different from other sections of the amendment. It requires federal legislation to enforce its terms, at least as applied to candidates for federal office. Through inaction alone, congress can erase part of the 14th not erase the words from the constitutional page. Chaotic enforcement of the constitution may be suboptimal but its far better than not enforcing the constitution at all. What do you make of that, joe . Well, i was going to ask chuck his opinion on David Frenchs insights. Chuck . Yeah, joe, i read it this morning. I read his article and he makes a really important point that congress, by doing absolutely nothing, which is absolutely what they do best, has essentially stripped the Disqualification Clause from operation. They have essentially rendered it moot. Here is the problem. By going too far, the Supreme Court has really limited the ways in which someone can be disqualified. You need congress to pass federal legislation. Amy Coney Barrett and the three socalled Liberal Justices, a, we dont have to decide this, but, b, there might be other ways or congress or federal courts to breathe live into the Disqualification Clause. I think David Frenchs article is important to read. I read it myself. I even understood it, which doesnt happen all that often. But he is right. It has essentially become a nullity. The ability to keep an insurrectionist from the ballot turns on congress acting, and as we discussed earlier, thats what congress does worst. Willie, this underlines a point that we have at times said about what could be happening on the left, like the criticisms of alvin bragg bringing a case under a new theory or sort of piecing things together in a way that make constitutional scholars uneasy on both sides. In this case, you have the Supreme Court lunching too far to the right, making, as david french said, this part of the 14th Amendment a dead letter. Could also raise a lot of same questions, which we need to do about some of the state cases as well right now in fulton county. There is a mess down there with the prosecutor. What happens if there is a prosecutor in west texas that wants to, you know, charge the next democratic president. These are all questions that do need to be raised, and we have been raising them on one side on is there overreach on the left that will impact future democratic president s. Here you have overreach, it seems, by a conservative Supreme Court who, well, lets justice face it, thats what they have been doing best the past year or so, overreachoy the Supreme Court that in a way has nullified effectively, adds david french said, an extraordinarily important clause in the 14th Amendment. That was interesting to see, Justice Amy Coney barrett saying to her colleagues, guys, we need to turn down the temperature, not create more chaos in the system. So while voting with the majority, of course, unanimous, critical this some ways of the specks of the ruling. Thats the legal side of it, john. Lets talk about the politics for a second. I think we all have heard from some democrats and maybe people working on other campaigns saying that this was worth pursuing, but perhaps even a little relief that turned out this way. If he is kept off the ballot, it gives him rocket fuel for the next eight months to say the biden administration, the Justice Department, et cetera, et cetera, everything he likes to say, is trying to strip away your right to vote, keep me on the ballot. So they say we can beat him in colorado. Put him on the ballot. The idea if a few blue states take him off the ballot, it would fuel his grievances, his deep state conspiracies, and would fire up the enthusiasm. Chaos is the right word. They were right to rule the way they did. A lot of campaigns would concur on that. Donald trump of course appeared yesterday in maralago, praised the decision, and we heard from trump talking about the other matter thats about to be in front of the Supreme Court, that of president ial immunity. We know the Oral Arguments are scheduled for next month. Give us your latest thinking as to how those arguments could go and when, perhaps most importantly, we will hear from the justices in terms of their decision because that will impacts whether or not any of these trials happen before the election. Let me start with the when, jonathan. The argument in the Supreme Court on the question of president ial immunity from criminal process is april 22nd. The Supreme Court term ends at the end of june. So we will certainly have a decision or should have a decision which the end of the june although it could come quicker, the decision in the case we were just discussing on the 14th Amendment Disqualification Clause took about four weeks. So no later than the end of june we should have a decision. I am still somewhat bullish. I may be the last person on the planet who believes that this case could be tried before the election. The January 6th Insurrection Case in federal court in washington. The sooner the Supreme Court makes a decision, the clearer it will be whether or not we can have that trial. So to your first question, jonathan, mr. Trump lost decisively in the District Court and decisively and unanimously in federal Court Of Appeals on the immunity question. I expect he will lose again. The answer seems pretty clear. A president is not immune for conduct while president , except perhaps in a very narrow band of cases involving official acts and trying to thwart a fair and free election cant possibly be an act. The sooner the Supreme Court gets to that determination, the better we will know whether or not we can have a trial before the election. I still think we can. Like i said, i might be the last person on the planet, but i am somewhat bullish. Coming up, its Super Tuesday. That means one thing. Steve kornacki at the big board. He will break down the key states to watch as millions of head to the polls. Morning mornings coming right back. Rning mornings coming rigt back at humana, we believe your healthcare should evolve with you, and part of that evolution means choosing the right medicare plan for you. Humana can help. With original medicare youre covered for hospital stays and Doctor Office visits, but youll have to pay a deductible for each. A Medicare Supplement plan pays for some or all of your original medicare deductibles, but they may have higher monthly premiums and no Prescription Drug coverage. Humana Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug plans include medical coverage, plus Prescription Drug coverage. And coverage for dental, vision and hearing. All wrapped up into one convenient plan. Plus, theres a cap on your outofpocket costs humana has Large Networks of doctors, hospitals and specialists across 49 states. So, call or go online today and get your free decision guide. Humana a more human way to healthcare. You can make money the hard way as a bullfighter or a human cannonball. Or save money the easy way, with xfinity mobile. Existing customers can get a free line of our most popular unlimited plan for a year not only will you save hundreds but youll also be joining millions who have connected to americas most reliable 5g network. Sure is a lot safer than becoming a stuntman for money. Get a free line of unlimited intro for a year when you buy one unlimited line. Visit xfinitymobile. Com today to learn more. Weekend. Meanwhile, Vice President campus semiconductor pushing to pause the fighting in gaza. The need to secure a hostage deal and get more aid into the trip with Israeli Cabinet member gantz yesterday. Cording it the white house, they discussed the situation in rafah. He wants the role to implement a humanitarian plan before launching a Major Military operation. Gantz is expected to continue these discussions today with Secretary Of State antony blinken. Gantz is a political rival to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. His visit to the white house could signal wider cracks between the white house and the Israeli Government. Reporters asked gantz yesterday if the white house should just deal with him instead of netanyahu, but gantz responded, quote, no, israel has a Prime Minister and everything is okay. Joining us now, president emeritus on the council of foreign relations, richard haass, author of Home And Away available on substack and i would argtu that everything is not okay, joe, as it pertains to the Israeli Government. I think losing support from within israel and around the world. Well, israel is, obviously, losing support in the United States, losing support around the world, and right now i think perhaps most importantly for them in the long run, they are losing support among their arab neighbors. Richard there, as a real urgency. I know you have spoken with arab neighbors and leaders and diplomats around israel, as have i, over the past few weeks. And they keep saying the clock is ticking. This we have to resolve this crisis. We want to help. We want to help in gaza. We want to help you towards a twostate solution. But the killing of civilians has to stop. The famine, the coming famine has to be averted. All of these things suggest a fierce urgency of now that perhaps Benjamin Netanyahu and too many in the Israeli Government just do not understand. Yeah, joe, its hard to talk about this without almost noting the tragedy or irony of it. For decades, what was israels goal . Gain acceptance in the region, get the arab countries to see israel not as a western implant, but as part of the region. And that was happening. You had all sorts of countries normalizing and most importantly you had saudi arabia critical in the arab world, critical in energy, critical in the islamic world on the cusp of doing that. And whats happening now, arab leaders are so frustrated what israel is doing has radicalized a young generation of air rubs who six months ago didnt care about the palestinians. They were open to economic and other interactions with israel and all of that has been put on hold or even reversed. And like or not, these arab leaders, even those pretty authoritarian, have to take into account the public opinion, even in authoritarian countries who cant ignore it. So israel is undoing what had been for decades the principle Foreign Policy or National Security goals. So right now relations with the palestinians are at a low and relations with the arab states have been frozen. So this is really, i would argue, again, not over israels right for selfdefense. Its how israel interpret it and implemented and i would argue its been counterproductive from any and every consideration. And you look at the pictures that we have been watching over the past month and you understand. The israeli people, many should understand with bitterness that this is exactly the way hamas wanted this to play out. Just commit unspeakable acts of terror, promote provoke netanyahus government to overreach in a way the United States did after September 11th, and raise their standing, raise hamas own standing in gaza where hamas was fairly unpopular before this. Raise their own standing across the middle east. Raise their own standing in the United States. And, willie, thats exactly what happened. You know oh, nt the surface, the initial reaction from some israeli leaders and israelis may be that hamas did this to us, we have to continue the attacks for our longterm security. Weve gotten to a point now where continued attacks of civilians, continued killing of civilians actually undermines israels longterm security. This isnt even a close call. I am not saying this you know, im saying this as a conservative that believes israel has a right to protect itself, has a right to be secure, but what they are doing is undermining their support in the United States. We showed the polls just about every day. Undermining their support among arab neighbors that just entered into Peace Treaties with them over the past few years, undermining their support across the world. Yeah, i mean, when you consider that the truth that hamas as a terrorist death cult and reminded the world of that on october 7, this is what it wants. You dont need more evidence to know it hides in schools and hospitals and behind librarians have because the death of a Civilian In Gaza is a victory because it hurts israel. So on this question of the ceasefire, shortterm ceasefire we keep hearing about, President Biden raised it two weeks ago ahead of the michigan primary. Didnt furn out. We heard a couple days ago israel signed on to a temporary ceasefire. Just waiting for hamas to iron out a few details. Vice president heir calling for that, a sixweek ceasefire yesterday. Are we ever going to see this or is this Wishful Thinking . I have been a minority here. I am skeptical that hamas wants the sees fierp. We are less than a week away from the holy month of ramadan. If you are hamask going back to everything you and joe were saying, what would you like . You wouldnt mind there being pictures of people trying to get to mosque or people praying and being attacked or the imagery in the arab world during ramadan. Part of me thinks they are actually hoping. That would be consistent with, as you both were saying, everything up to now. This is Station Identification for hamas. They want to show that only they can deliver, only they are the real defenders of the palestinian just think about how different this conversation would be today if Israel On October 8th had taken a breath, allowed this to play out, put the focus hamas, the sexual and depravity that went on, the killing of individuals, and gradually and quietly went after this leader or that leader, kept the Focus On Hamas rather than put the focus on itself. It seems to me that this has been a class you will mishandling. This was an opportunity to isolate hamas, show it for what it is, its dna, put something out there politically where you could have said, hey, here is a better way. If you really care about palestinians, hamas, they to see dead palestinians, here is a better way to go. I actually think this was strategically every step of the way a total loss, misguided, understandable but all the same counterproductive response, willie. Coming up, a live report from nikki haleys headquarters in South Carolina. Nbcs ali vitali has the latest when morning joe comes right back. En morning joe comes rigt back this is our future, ma. Godaddy airo. Creates a logo, website, even social posts. In minutes how . A. I. impressed ay i like it who wants to come see the future . get your Business Online in minutes with godaddy airo were traveling all across america, talking to people about their hearts. Whwho wants to talk about their heart [honking] hows the heart . Hows your heart . Hows your heart . Its good. Is it . Aah, i dont know. Its okay. Its okay yeah. Good. You sure . I think so. How do you know . It doesnt come with a manual, and you like ooh, i got the 20,000day checkup, right . Let me show you something. Put two fingers right on those pads. Look at that thats your heart that is pretty awesome. With kardiamobile, you can take a medicalgrade ekg in just 30 seconds, from anywhere. Kardiamobile is proven to detect atrial fibrillation, one of the leading causes of stroke. And its the only personal ekg thats fdacleared to detect normal heart rhythm, bradycardia and tachycardia. How much do you think this costs . Probably in the hundreds. 79. Oh wow that could be cheaper than a tank of gas. Checking your heart anytime, anywhere has never been easier. Dont wait. Get kardiamobile today for just 79 at kardia. Com or amazon. Coming up, colorado tried and failed to remove donald trump from the primary ballot. Secretary of state Jenna Griswold reacts to the Supreme Courts unanimous decision yesterday. First, actor leave schreiber to talk about his role on broadway. That conversation is just ahead on morning joe. Po, you need to bring peace to the valley. [ choking ] the chameleon is nothing like anyone youve ever faced. She is capable of mimicking any shape. Awesome. I mean its disturbing, but its awesome. The truth makes for a bad sermon. What actually happens in life is beyond interpretation. I want you to be alert. Just the way the boy acted when he came back to class, he looked frightened. The most innocent actions can appear sinister to the poisoned mind. What happened in the rectory happened. It was a private matter. Im concerned about the relationship between father flynn and your son. I dont know, sister. You may think youre doing good, but the world is a hard place. I dont know that you and me are on the same side. You have to stop this campaign. You could stop it at any time. How . Confess and resign. That was a look at the play doubt, a parable which opens on broadway this thursday in the first revival since the plays original run nearly 20 years ago. It starred Liev Schreiber along with amy ryan. The play follows the principal of a bronx Catholic School in the 1960s, who suspected the schools new priest, father flynn, has sexually abused the schools first black student. Liev and amy join us now. Its great to have you both. Without giving away too much more, tell us about this version of doubt and what its like to work with amy, who im obsessed with from only murders in the building and the office, just to name a few. Amy and i have known each other since our early 20s, so its a treat to Work Together now. Doubt is an extraordinary play. I dont know what to say about it other than i think weve lost some ability to process nuance and complexity in this modern world. I think johns play kind of champions that complexity. The idea that doubt can be a unifying concept, i think in many ways it speaks to the strength of our democracy that we are able to disagree with each other and yet still somehow make progress. But as more and more we see people leaning more into winning than progress we see things falling apart. For me, theres so many extraordinary ideas and themes in this play, but for me, thats one of the most powerful ones. For instance, social media, the algorithms they categorize for the purposes of marketing demand that you are red or blue or israel or palestine. Right. I think that john patrick shanley, the playwright, adds some nuance to that conversation. Its a very timely play. You stepped into the role sort of late. The original actress cast had a health emergency. Tell us about that, to do so on such an accelerated timeline with such a serious and heavy topic. Yeah. It was a late evening sunday night phone call. When i came around to it monday afternoon and i was rehearsing with liev and the rest of the cast the next day and kind of running as fast as i could, getting up at 5 30 a. M. To start cramming lines. I remember saying, please give me permission to be really, really bad. It was truly being shot out of a cannon, but this incredible cast was so patient and generous with me. They had lost their leading lady, but they put trust in me somehow or they let me believe they had trust in me. It must have been so helpful that you all know each other so well and for so long. It definitely helped. The familiarity gives comfort. Although this is the first time were really working together, we have mutual friends and weve known each other. No doubt about each other. No doubt about each other. I know lievs work. Lets look at this scene where sister begins to realize she cant trust father flynn. May i ask what you wrote down with that ballpoint pen . Nothing. An idea for a sermon. What is the idea . Intolerance. Would you like a little more tea, father . Not yet. I think a message of the Second Ecumenical Council is that the church needs to take on a more familiar face, reflect the local community. We should sing a song from the radio now and then, take the kids out for ice cream. Ice cream. Take them on a camping trip. We should be friendlier. The children and parents should see us as members of their family rather than emissaries from rome. I think the pageant should be charming, like a Community Theater doing a show. But were not members of their family. Were different. Why . Because of our vows . Precisely. I dont think were so different. Mm. Wow. What you were saying earlier about shanleys work, it was written in 2004 at the height of the sex abuse scandal the Catholic Church was enduring then and enduring still today. I was thinking about what you just said and the number of times people say in life, geez, i doubt that. Just the word doubt itself and the way it plays not only in this theatrical work but the way it plays off in our life. Sure. One of the things doug hughes, the original director of the first production 20 years ago, he said they added that part a parable to the title was because there was a conversation amongst the people developing the play is that it spoke to our certitude going into the iraq war and that thing about not being able to contain doubt, that we had to make a definitive decision and the complexity and nuance of things is to important that were allowed to doubt and its actually this wonderful unifying concept that red and blue meet somewhere in the middle, which in a funny way is doubt, which is this very human quality. And to do that with such tautness and humor, im thrilled to be a part of the play. If i could touch on ukraine with you. You have ukrainian roots. You cofounded blue check ukraine. Yes. You recently wrote a piece for time entitled ukraine is fighting for the same values americans hold dear. Do all americans hold those values dear . Well, you know, this is my opinion. You can doubt it if you like. Im not doubting it. Im just asking. I do this four hours a day and i might have a little doubt. I guess what that piece was for me thinking about my grandparents generation and what was important to them. I think the generation of people who fought in the great wars and who defended democracy and whats really at stake for people who think that ukraine doesnt matter, i believe this is a front line of a war on democracy. I think that we are a nation of grandchildren. The opportunities that we have sitting around this table, i think, were provided by people who struggled to live the american way of life. And what is that . And when its at stake, what are we willing to do to defend it . If that just means going to the ballot, absolutely, you have to do that. For me, its more than that. For me, its defending a place where my grandparents came from and the idea they should be able to vote for their own leaders, that they should be able to pray in their own churches and do everything in the way we have been able to do everything in this country is extremely important. To some degree, i do believe they are fighting our fight. I certainly think thats what my grandfather would have thought. The revival of doubt, a parable opens on broadway this thursday and runs through april 14th at the todd haimes theater. Thank you. Were into the fourth hour of morning joe. Voters are beginning to head to the polls across 16 states and one u. S. Territory this morning for Super Tuesday, the busiest day on the primary calendar. Youre looking at live pictures of nashville, which does not look too busy. Tonight could be nikki haleys last stand with former President Trump leading the polls and in the number of delegates won so far. Nbc news correspondent Garrett Haake is in florida with more. Reporter this morning, the road to the white house stretching from coast to coast as Republican Voters in 15 states from alaska to alabama cast their primary ballots. Gop frontrunner donald trump, who swept the first seven states of the primary, is widely expected to pick up the lions share of the more than 800 delegates at stake today. Haley is not a problem. Shes negative for the party, but not a problem in terms of winning, because were winning by a lot. Reporter nikki haley, fresh off her first victory of the campaign over the weekend in washington, d. C. , taking aim at trump in texas, arguing since his first term hes been a drag on the party as a whole with losses at the state and federal levels. At some point, maybe we should say the reason that america keeps losing is because of donald trump. Reporter todays Super Tuesday contests come on the heels of a unanimous Supreme Court ruling monday in mr. Trumps favor, ordering his name be included on primary ballots in colorado and other states where courts or officials had tried to bar him for allegedly engaging in insurrection on january 6th. You cannot take somebody out of a race because an opponent would like to have it that way. Reporter mr. Trump praising the ruling and arguing hes been politically targeted by the Biden Department of justice. Its nonsense cases, and everybody sees it. Reporter the Biden Campaign responding, calling mr. Trumps statement unhinged, confused ramblings focused only on himself. Donald trump will remain on the ballot despite Court Decisions in some states to make him ineligible for the 2024 election. The Supreme Court yesterday unanimously rejected the ruling from colorados Supreme Court that removed the former president from the ballot based on section 3 of the 14th Amendment. Joining us now, colorados Secretary Of State Jenna Griswold. She will oversee colorados primary and is chair of the Democratic Association of secretaries of state. A twofold question, your reaction, of course, to the Supreme Court ruling, and how do you think the primaries are going to go today . Good morning. Happy Super Tuesday. Thanks for having me on. First and foremost, i would say its good the Supreme Court actually rendered their decision. In colorado, 500,000 people had already voted in the republican primary. Colorado deserves to know and america deserves to know whether donald trump is a qualified candidate. With that said, im disappointed in the decision. I think states like colorado deserve to have the choice to keep insurrectionists off of our ballot. Theres larger implications for insurrection thats running for federal office under this decision. Super tuesday, everythings going great in colorado. I assume were going to have great elections across the nation. Just encourage your voters to make their voices heard. Democracy is on the ballot this year. There are so many crucial issues that americans can weigh in on, and we do that at the polls. Madam secretary, it was noteworthy even though it was a unanimous position, some of the justices disagreed with the act that solely congress could step in and prevent an insurrectionist from running again. Do you have any faith, though, that congress will ever step forward with legislation that could safeguard this piece of our elections . I think thats one of the big concerns from this decision. The majority of the Supreme Court decided congress could act, but this congress is almost nonfunctional. So the likelihood of that is very low. That means if there is An Oathbreaking Insurrectionist running for any federal office, they basically have the freedom to run without consequence. The purpose of the 14th Amendment, in my view, is to safeguard the country from insurrectionists taking office and destroying democracy from within. I think its really concerning given that this congress is so unlikely to take any type of real action on the matter. Secretary griswold, have you had to town by town, city by city, county by county in colorado make any extra Preventive Security measures to protect poll workers . Unfortunately, in colorado we have seen a lot of threats to Election Officials and predominantly, to tell you the truth, elected officials, myself, county clerks, people in our offices. And, yes, we have really focused on physical security since actually 2021, to tell you the truth. That includes legislative changes. I led a law making it a crime to open carry close to voting. We made it a crime to dox or retaliate against election workers. I also made it a felony to compromise voting equipment. I Just Announced last week 3. 5 million for counties to further increase their physical security and access for voters. You know, seeing the threat environment is incredibly concerning. We have had 38 of our county clerks step down since 2020. Wow. That is incredible. We cant allow people who would use intimidation or threats to win that battle. What theyre trying to do is get good republicans and democrats to step down so that people who do not believe in the right to vote can step in. I will not be intimidated. Just from the Supreme Court case, ive received over 500 violent threats since it was filed initially in september. I wont be intimidated. We are ready to go in colorado. Frankly, we cannot allow people who use threats to win. Colorado Secretary Of State Jenna Griswold, thank you very much for coming on this morning and thank you for what youre doing. We appreciate it. Lets go straight to the big board with Steve Kornacki. Steve, your latest article for nbcnews. Com shows why the delegate math shows haley has little room to stop trump. Im curious, given all that, what well be looking for dig into the numbers tonight . Look in yellow. All the states on the republican side with contests today, the rules on the republican side for this primary season are designed to produce a quick and decisive nominee. Keep that in mind when you look at the rules inside of some of these states. Thats haleys first challenge. California, 169 delegates up for grabs today, the biggest of any state. In california, there are two major things working against haley. Number one, it is a closed primary. There are no independents, no democrats allowed to participate. That is the backbone of her strength in a lot of these contests weve had so far. Secondly, in california, the rules are a simple majority of the statewide vote, 50 plus one, and you get all 169 delegates. The combination of that threshold and a closed primary makes donald trump the overwhelming favorite to collect all 169 in california. The second biggest prize today is texas, 161 delegates. Rules are a little bit different than california, but again, this is a very conservative republican electorate in texas. Demographically it is very much trump friendly. It doesnt fit the profile of some of these areas in states that nikki haley has fared the best. Its winner take all for a statewide pool of delegates and winner take all in each of the congressional districts. You look at the demographics of texas, and trump is heavily favored. With those two states, you can expect trump to be north of 300 delegates just there. You add in oklahoma and arkansas and alabama, essentiallily winner take all states. That could be another target for trump to get all of the delegates here. Where would haley make a splash . Probably her best chance to win a state is vermont. Donald trump only got 32 of the vote in the vermont the first time he ran. Theres no Party Registration in vermont. Its a deeply blue state. You might have a lot of voters who dont really consider themselves republicans, but like the chance to vote against donald trump. Virginia is interesting too, especially congressional districts in the northern part of the state here just outside washington, d. C. , demographically they absolutely fit the profile of where haleys been doing well in these primary. In fact, theyre even better demographically for her. In virginia, you can collect delegates by congressional districts. There are opportunities for haley to pick some off there. Minnesota and colorado, complicated rules, but she could get a chunk of delegates there. The bottom line here is, 43 in New Hampshire is her high watermark. If youre getting 43 across the board tonight, that is going to translate into very few delegates. And meanwhile, donald trump with that lead he has over haley, he could be near a thousand delegates by the end of tonight with 1215 the magic number. Of course, the Haley Campaign has pledged shes staying in through Super Tuesday. Thats today. Beyond that, were not quite sure of the future. Trump has racked up win after win outside the district of columbia. But there have been warning signs too, whether its turnout. What are we going to look at tonight that could be more warning signs for trump even if he wins . Its interesting. Weve known since 2016 where trumps problems are, where his vulnerabilities are. Theyre in the suburbs. Typically College Educated voters in the suburbs, little more higher income. Thats where hes had his worst showing in these primaries. Haley had by far the highest concentration of educated voters. There are districts in virginia that fit that, minnesota and colorado that fit that. Youre looking for trumps weakness. But in terms of how applicable it is to the general election, i would caution on that, because weve seen in the polls consistently with four new Major National polls over the weekend that all put donald trump ahead by a slight margin. When you look at those polls, what looks like potential slippage with Republican Voters in these primaries, you do not see it in general election polls. You look at Republican Voters in general election polling, trump is getting more than 90 and losing only 2 or 3 of them. Youre seeing evidence in states that have open primaries or semiopen primaries that theres a large segment of voters who are going to vote for biden in the fall, who absolutely cant stand donald trump, and they tend to be in these suburban areas who are participating in the republican primary. I think thats added in these states to some of that nontrump total. The polling is suggesting that a lot of that haley vote is prepared to go and back donald trump. Well look at those suburbs as they come in tonight. As we were saying last night with biden in michigan with that uncommitted vote, theres reason to take it with a pretty big grain of salt. Steve kornacki, thank you so much. Well see you tomorrow morning at 6 a. M. To break down todays results. Coming up on morning joe, well get a live report from both South Carolina and florida, where nikki haley and Donald Trumps campaigns are monitoring todays Super Tuesday results. Morning joe will be back in a moment. Y results. Morning joe will be back in a moment prevagen helps your brain and actually improves memory. The secret is an ingredient originally discovered. In jellyfish. In clinical trials, prevagen has been shown to improve memory. Prevagen. At stores everywhere without a prescription. Okay everyone, our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy. Yay woo hoo ensure, with 27 vitamins and minerals, nutrients for immune health. And ensure complete with 30 grams of protein. they call it Super Tuesday for a reason. I think its going to be record setting, i think. I hope so. But that sends the signal, because what were really doing is were aiming at that november 5th date. This is not personal. This is about the fact that we have to win. We can want to change the country all day long, but if we cant win an election, we cant do any of that. I dont know why everybodys so adamant that they have to follow trumps lead to get me out of this race. You know, all of these people deserve to vote. That was former President Trump last night laying out his expectations for todays Super Tuesday contests. And nikki haley moments ago on fox news on why she is not throwing in the towel yet. Lets bring in ali vitali live in South Carolina covering the Haley Campaign, and nbc news correspondent Vaughn Hillyard live in florida covering the Trump Campaign. And joining us is Symone Sanders townsend. Ali, what are you hearing from the Haley Campaign and from voters today . Reporter mika, this is not usually what election days will look like. Vaughn and i should be at campaign headquarters, at watch parties. Instead, were probably going to be standing in pretty generic locations, because neither candidate is out on the Campaign Trail actively campaigning. Trump will be at maralago. Haley is likely to watch the results tonight come in from her home on kiawa island. They did do their final event last night in texas. That was raucous crowd in ft. Worth. Have you ever voted trump . No. What happens in 2024 if its trump versus biden . Biden probably. For you . Ive been voting since i was 18. Im a strict republican, but im not going for trump. So youll vote for biden . I want to vote for haley. Thats why im here. What happens if on wednesday morning she wakes up and tuesday was a clean sweep for trump . I think she should stay in. Reporter mika, she might. I think if were reading the tea leaves here, the Haley Campaign has been specifically vague about what happens after this mile marker of Super Tuesday. On one hand, haley has said she wants to have the strongest showing possible that she can on Super Tuesday. Shes been vague in saying shell be in this race for as long as shes competitive. Thats not exactly a specific metric that we should be looking for here. But haley could end up staying in through georgia, through louisiana. That would put her through the end of the month. The Trump Campaign doesnt expect and cant clench their bid tonight. Haley could do until he does. Its not a money problem. Haley has been a prolific fundraiser and has a lot of money still in the bank that could allow her to keep going. The other question i was asking voters is, what if she does or doesnt endorse the former president . Haley didnt seem bound by that rnc pledge to endorse the eventual nominee. Haley supporters say they would be disappointed if she endorsed him, at least right off the bat, mika. In an interview yesterday with a farright outlet, donald trump continued to escalate his anti immigrant record. We have languages from like the planet mars. Nobody knows how to speak it. They put the students in the place of our students like in new york city. We have these wonderful students going to school. All of a sudden they no longer have a seat. Were putting migrants in who dont speak the language, have no idea what the teacher is saying, and we have children no longer going to school. Theyre coming from places unknown. Theyre rough people, in many cases from jails, prisons, Insane Asylums, Silence Of The Lambs stuff like hannibal lechter. Donald trump also called into fox news this morning. What is his closing message today . Reporter donald trump clearly is not very deterred from any threat that he sees from nikki haley. For donald trump, you know the night before Super Tuesday, you might have thought hed be holding a campaign rally. Instead you see him talking to that trump loyal network at his estate maralago. He did just call into fox friends here in the last hour. He was repeatedly asked whether he would try to strike what would effectively be a peace deal with nikki haley and repeated demurred. Just 36 hours ago on his social media account he was referring to nikki haley as bird brain. I was just messaging with one trump ally here and asked what the expectations were for tonight. They said they expect to win every state, and they will have a fun night and the bird will not. Compare this to eight years ago on Super Tuesday. I was covering ted cruz in the state of texas, where ted cruz beat him by a 21 margin. He lost in oklahoma, maine and utah. Today donald trump and his team feel good and theyre ready to spend resources on joe biden and not continue to spend any money on nikki haley in this republican primary that they deem all but over. Vaughn hillyard, thank you very much. Where do begin, Jonathan Lemire . Lets fact check. What he said about new York City Schools, not true. That didnt happen. Hes doubling, tripling down on this antiimmigration rhetoric that frankly began his political career. It was the birtherism lie about barack obama, but in 2015 he talked about mexican immigrants calling them rapists and the like. Is this rhetoric going to help him at all this time around . There are lots of people that like the rhetoric donald trump is serving up. Like who are those people laughing in the room . Exactly. What was funny about that . It was disgraceful behavior. Yes. Fox should zoom in on the people on the side so we can see who they are and ask them questions. He has continued to enjoy support since he came down that escalator. People are supporting him in places across the country still. Look, i think that democrats, people in the news media, other republicans that do not agree with what donald trump is saying, they need to call it out. It is very important. You cannot let the rhetoric slide. Every time we talk about immigration, we also have to talk about the fact that there was a bill that congress negotiated that was a very Strong Border security bill that is not law right now because donald trump told republican legislators not to get on board. Donald trump doesnt care about the Immigration Crisis in this country. It has nothing to do with policy, everything to do with rhetoric and aesthetic. With all due respect to you as a member of the national media, youre missing the point. Whats that . Joe biden is 81 years old. So . Thats the story we have to cover. [ laughter ] thats the story that is in every major american newspaper, sometimes quite often on the front page above the fold. So you get the 81yearold or the potential criminal. Get the 81yearold or the bigot, the 81yearold or the racist, 81yearold or the fascist. In terms of how we lead our lives on an everyday basis, the 81yearold knows that no new York City School child is being thrown out of a seat to have someone who just crossed the border replace them in that classroom. The 81yearold who people talk about all day long in the media is the person who says i can fix the border, but they wont let me, meaning donald trump and the Republican Party. The 81yearold who people say, oh geez, he shuffles along, hes the one who stands between them and having no health insurance. The 81yearold is the guy who has presided over the healthiest, fastestgrowing economy in 30 years. The 81yearold is the guy who gets up at 7 00 in the morning and works all day to try and keep the middle east from inflaming itself even more than its inflamed. Mike has the receipts. Yes, joe biden knows how to do the job, is doing the job and has demonstrated he can do the job. Thats what its about. Its not about age. Then on the other side you have donald trump, who what he is doing is very dangerous. There are people that have acted on his rhetoric. We have example after example after example, insurrection, the folks who took up arms against the fbi offices across the country, people who have demonized and put a target on the back of lgbtq americans, paul pelosi. What happens when someone gets killed . I mean, its happened. We had the january 6th insurrection, and people died that day. I believe that people died that day at the behest of donald trump. I believe that also tens of thousands of people are dead from covid because he kept that information from the American People and then mismanaged it and misled people through that pandemic to epic proportions. Disproportionately africanamerican members of this country were hit most by covid. Now women are dying. Because of roe. This is your choice. Theres the story to tell. What mike is saying is all we seem to read about is the age and how old the current president of the United States is. I think more people need to talk about the policy, what donald trump is saying, project 2025, his trying to turn the department of health into the department of life. If joe biden is dottering, ill have what hes having. Ahead, the biggest blizzard of the season just slammed californias sierra mountains, leaving several towns buried under several feet of snow. Well show you where the blizzard is now as winter storm warnings remain in effect. And hours from now, the trial of James Crumbley, the father of the School Shooter. Father of the School Shooter only at vanguard youre more than just an investor youre an owner. That means your priorities are ours too. Our retirement tools and advice can help you leave a legacy for the ones you love. Thats the value of ownership. [bell dings] are you good . No, i think im late on my car insurance. Good thing the general gives you a break when you need it. Yeah, with flexible Payment Options to keep you covered. Just tag us in. Like right now . oh. I was talking about insurance. Ouaaaahhhh [bell dings] for a great low rate, go with the general. we come from a long line of cowboys. when i see all of us out here on this ranch, i see how far our legacy can go. heres to Getting Better with age. Heres to beating these two every thursday. Help fuel today with boost high protein, complete nutrition you need. Without the stuff you dont. So, heres to now. Boost. Californians are bracing for another storm system after a massive blizzard dumped several feet of snow on the Sierra Nevada mountains. Steve patterson has the latest. Reporter this morning, the race is onto dig out vehicles and homes from a weekend blizzard before snow from a new storm starts piling up again. We had grass in our yard on thursday and now our windows are all buried on our house. Reporter this is the aftermath of an intense multiday storm that dumped 5 to 10 feet of snow across the region. It was whiteout conditions. Reporter interstate 80 finally reopening after disrupting traffic and commerce for days. It has been a real mess. If you live in it, youre used to it. If youre not, i would say dont come up here if you dont have to. Reporter because of heavy snow and winds that reached 190 Miles Per Hour at the highest peaks, officials and locals urging caution on the roads. Weve just been taking it slow, going 25, 30 miles an hour. Reporter the storm effectively ending the seasons snow drought, bringing californias snow pack level up to 104 of normal. Lake tahoes famous ski resorted opening back up carefully. With conditions still sketchy up top and deep powder everywhere. Today were going to go and use the tree lines and hopefully avoid the avalanches. Jury selection begins this morning in the trial of James Crumbley, the father of the oxford high School Shooter. He is facing four counts of involuntary manslaughter. The trial comes after a jury found his wife guilty of the same charge last month. Nbc news correspondent Stephanie Gosk has more. We find the defendant guilty of involuntary manslaughter. Reporter James Crumbley starts jury selection for his role. His wife jennifer was the first parent in the u. S. Held criminally responsible for a School Shooting carried out by their child. Both charged with four counts, one for each student killed. Ethan used a semiautomatic handgun allegedly bought by his dad as a gift days before the shooting. Crumbleys parents were called to his high school the morning of the shooting over concerns about a drawing he made of a good morning, your honor and a message the thoughts wont t stop, help me. But jennifers defense team said her husband james was responsible for the storage and safety of the gun. I didnt feel comfortable being in charge of that. It was more his thing. I let him handle that. I didnt feel comfortable putting the lock thing on it. Reporter experts say james attorneys likely watched jennifers trial closely. The foreperson telling savannah today the testimony and evidence was pivotal for jurors. Jennifer didnt separate her son from the gun enough to save those lives that day. Reporter craig shillings son justin was among the four killed. You want accountability. You want the right verdict. Stephanie gosk with that report. Still ahead, well bring you the concerning results of a new study on Young Children and screen time. Plus, luke russert joins us to talk about the new event series msnbc live and his conversation with former republican governor larry hogan and why hes now running for senate. Morning joe will be right back. Morning joe will be right back that flea and tick medicine youve been ordering from chewy. We are very proud of you. You never stop surprising us, bailey. Right . Im great. You are great. I wonder if baileys ever done a book report. Be nice to your sister. What flea bit him . Pets arent just pets. Theyre more. This flea and tick season, get 20 off your first pharmacy order at chewy. So this is pickleball . Its basically tennis for babies, but for adults. It should be called wiffle tennis. Pickle yeah, aw whoo these guys are intense. We got nothing to worry about. With e trade from morgan stanley, were ready for whatever gets served up. Dude, you gotta work on your trash talk. Id rather work on saving for retirement. Or college, since you like to get schooled. Thats a pretty good burn, right . Got him. Good game. Thanks for coming to our clinic, first ones free. Limu emu doug bell ringing customize and save with libberty bibberty. Liberty bushumal. Libtreally blubatoo. Mark that one. That was nice i think youre supposed to stand over there. Oh am i . Thank you. So, a couple more . Well just. Well rip. Well go quick. Libu smeebo. Libu bribu. Limu bibu. And me. Doug hes an emu only pay for what you need. Jingle liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. 3, 4 only pay for what you need. Hey are you ready for me are you ready are you ready shopifys point of sale system helps you sell at every stage of your business. With fast and secure payment. Card readers you can rely on. And one place to manage it all. Whatever the stage, businesses that grow grow with shopify. Would you have supported the senate bill that would have seen President Trump effectively killed by coming out its why i ran for senate. I said a hundred times i didnt aspire to become a senator. I didnt need a job. I wasnt looking for another title. But three weeks ago on a wednesday night when i saw a real solution to secure the border and provide funding for israel, ukraine and taiwan, something that most of the republican senators had said was important. They were told to vote against what they believe in. It made me frustrated and angry enough to say, i think im going to go down there and try to do something about this. Former republican governor larry hogan explaining why he decided to jump into the Maryland Senate race. That conversation took place during msnbc live a new event series featuring conversations with newsmakers. Joining me is luke russert. Pleasure to be here, mika. Good morning. How are you . Im great. I love this concept. Tell us more about it. What are you doing . The first thing is we have to book you to appear, because you are the star power that we need. Essentially what were trying to do is have thoughtful solutionsbased conversations in person with some of the leading newsmakers of the day. We want to foster a connection to deal with some of the most vexing issues facing america. Often the most partisan ideas arent the best. When you have people in a room, they come together and they have a conversation, like happened in america for many, many years. Solutions come out of that, whether its Public Private partnerships. What can be done to solve some of these most challenging things our country faces is where our core is at msnbc live. We want to bring in some of our best talent to foster conversations with people around the country. It was an amazing event, luke. What was so great about it is bringing all of these different people together. Kornacki was at the big board giving a preview. What i heard from folks is they want to know more. Larry hogan broke a little news yesterday. I didnt know that was the impetus for him getting in. It was a really engaging conversation. You know whats so cool about this, luke, is that we have been all sort of moving to remote post covid. This is good that youre sort of like trying to promote that connection where things really can happen when were together in a room. Theres a real value, i think, post pandemic is gathering again. I was fortunate in the last year to go on a book tour for my memoir look for me there. I got to meet a lot of people around the country. We are a lot more alike than we are different. When youre in a room and you have those connections, that value and ethos comes minorities often dont get enough capital to launch successful businesses and what can be done to change that. And then you have Steve Kornacki on with the magic map and jen psaki and quintin folks about the Biden Campaign and what they have to overcome and larry hogan saying to me he will not support donald trump under any circumstances. So you really have a boat load of fascinating, interesting conversations which touches on all these Different Things that america is dealing with, but gets to a place where there are solutions and there is people who want to work to achieve real tangible positive results. Mike barnicle, the kids are all grown up. Look at this. Barnacle is hes a tough booking. Youll never get him. Not a chance. Theyre all grown up. What is the logistical plan here for this venue . Do you travel . Do you go different places . How is it going to work . I think our goal is to really get it around the country. If it worked out, i would love to have people in cleveland or buffalo be able to meet Mike Barnicle in person. Well start off in washington and new york where our talent is most easily accessible. But i think down the line, one of the more value adds is that, you know, people want to meet who they see on tv. They want to be in the same room as them and they also want to see, i think, that the thoughtful conversations that dont happen when there is a red blinking light. As you know, as mika youve done a lot of events, there is a spontaneity where people feel more comfortable, it is a lunch setting, dinner setting, maybe a cocktail setting and hear interesting stuff down the line, thats really the goal, though. Mike, i think there is real value in getting things out of d. C. , outside of the corridor and thats my goal with this project. Jonathan lemire. Lets talk more about your interview yesterday with governor hogan. He toyed with the idea of perhaps running as a Third Party Candidate for president , no labels flirting with him, but hes going for the senate instead. Tell us more about what he sees as his path. I thought it was really interesting he said that the thing that was a catalyst for him to run for senate was a phone call from former president bush saying we need more independentminded leaders and then also that he was upset that the senate gop and donald trump killed that bipartisan bill. But, jonathan, youre absolutely right, the immigration bill, youre absolutely right, maryland is a 21 democratic state. Federal races, you see a lot more tribal partisan politics. He has a real uphill battle. But he told me he will not support donald trump in any capacity. There is a sort of peace right now between donald trump and him, trump has not been publicly attacking him, it would be interesting if thats beneficial for hogan at some point if he can go more toe to toe with trump publicly. But he faces an uphill battle. That being said, when he left office, he had some of the highest Approval Ratings for any governor in the country and a lot of that had to do with the fact that maryland was so much to the left that they would bring things that didnt really strike a good core with moderates and hogan would veto them and the administration would become more moderate. It would be a very interesting race. Hes not your typical republican. Hes profunding for ukraine. He wants a bipartisan immigration bill. Maryland is a majority minority state, over 1 million foreign born residents. Somebody that if there is a republican mold like that, it certainly would probably win this president ial race. And could be beneficial in the future. Host and creative director of msnbc live, luke russert. Thank you very much, luke. You made me very happy. I cant wait to see you. Take care. You too. Another reason to limit screen time, especially for younger kids. Well bring you the finding of a new study next on morning joe. A new study next on morning joe. Heres to Getting Better with age. Heres to beating these two every thursday. Help fuel today with boost high protein, complete nutrition you need. Without the stuff you dont. So, heres to now. Boost. With so many choices on booking. Com there are so many tina feys i could be. So i hired body doubles to help me out. Splurgy tina loves a hotel near rodeo drive. Oh tina wild tina booked a farm stay to ride this horse. Glenn close . with millions of possibilities you can book whoever you want to be. Thats my line booking. Com booking. Yeah i launched our campaign at this union hall. Lets go win this thing then we hit the road and never stopped. You shared with me your frustration at working harder to barely get by and afford a place to live. Your fears for our democracy and freedoms and your dreams for yourself, your family, and the future. It is not too late to realize those dreams. Im adam schiff, and i approve this message because together we can still get big things done. A new study is showing how screen time is affecting childrens Speech Development and comprehension. Research published in the journal of the American Medical Association found the average toddler is missing out on hearing more than 1,000 words spoken by an adult each day due to screen exposure. The study tracked 220 australian families over two years, with the effects most pronounced at 3 years old. The average 3yearold is exposed to two hours and 52 minutes of screen time a day. For every extra minute of screen exposure, the toddlers in the study were hearing seven fewer words, speaking five fewer words themselves, and engaging in one less conversation. Researchers say a language rich home environment is crucial in supporting infants and toddlers language development. That is absolutely stunning. I we know this, though. Doesnt it seem obvious . If the parents and the kids are on tablets . Thats the point. We do know this. We know this. You reflect upon how children were raiseed as recently as 10, 12 years ago, completely different than today. The number of children, Young Children, Walking Around with a phone in their hand or ipad in their hand, who are impossible to eye contact is missing. We have been strict with screen time for our kids and i do worry about the ramifications decades from now, how are they going to grow up differently than everyone else . We know so much, simone. I wonder why congress doesnt or honestly why there arent regulations even from the companies who, by the way, the people who run the Tech Companies dont let their kids have phones. I think the companies dont want to have to take the responsibility. Congress doesnt want to wade into the responsibility. So, it is up to the rest of us. It is going to be cigarettes. Up to parents. It is up to parents. Wake up i like to take the ipad away from dinner. They dont like it. Im taking it ana cabrera picks up the coverage right now. Right now on ana cabrera reports, it is the biggest day on the calendar, vote areas cross the country heading to the polls on this Super Tuesday. Donald trump enters today with de
comparemela.com © 2020. All Rights Reserved.