Ortiz-Magro, 35, was arrested on April 22 for suspicion of felony domestic violence
His girlfriend Saffire Matos claimed the two were 'fine' after the arrest, but she was the one who called police, according to TMZ
Officers arrested the Jersey Shore star after they saw visible bruises on his girlfriend
The reality star is currently on probation after agreeing a plea deal in November 2019 stemming from a domestic violence arrest in Hollywood
He pleaded guilty to seven misdemeanors related to an incident involving his ex Jen Harley, with whom he shares a three-year-old daughter