Mr. Hassan hassan khani, an Economic Expert everywhere, considering the limited provision of postgraduate education courses in some fields by a number of private universities, Price Monitoring or even price prescriptions by the regulatory bodies seems necessary. That there are traces of monopoly, the Competition Council should enter, but because the university and we need to enter various services in the country. The council does not compete with the tuition fees of private universities. Mr. Seyyed abulhasan mousavi, a professor at azad university, students are free to choose which nongovernment university to go to, and this has caused some nongovernment universities to be empty of students. This means that universities are competitive. Mr. Jabar kochchinejad, a member of the Islamic Council, is currently in the Higher Education market for actors. Exist and there is no question of monopoly and this market is completely competitive and there is no need for the Competition Council to enter. Yes, the report of my colleague mohammad we saw and heard allahari together. Mr. Taheri , according to your opinion, these markets are competitive markets. Well, in our law, we have that the market is competitive with the monopoly market. You said that the entry into the monopoly market is for the Competition Council, but you said what structure do you believe in the council, so if it is true that the tuition fees of these universities, whether they are nonprofit universities or open universities , Applied Sciences and universities of all universities, which are many , i accept the Competition Council, not that i dont agree. The challenges you face the Competition Council will come to some points , not only about education, but about all subjects. Who has entered so far, i said that i do not give an acceptable grade to the councils performance. Acceptable people are justified and have a high score, but the structure has flaws. For example, what is iran . For example, one of the objections is that the technical discussion in the Competition Council is weaker than the legal discussion, which means that they are generally from the judiciary, whether it is a trial or an appeal. Even after they have a resolution, the court of justice can. Find an entrance and finally, even where they have entered, they do not have much guarantee of implementation it is in the judgment of a prosecutor who determines and this should be returned to the judicial branch. Most of the violations committed by the Competition Council have not been resolved. I think that a separate meeting is needed to review the performance of the Competition Council. Having another entry, for example, one of them was the industry in the discussion of the car, which is very important , you all have in mind, there were other topics that were included in the discussion, the internet, yes, in the discussion of the price of the phone, in your terms, yes, internet packages and other things, well, at the same time that we can really say many of these in the correct title, because the arm good funds, very good budgets, the lack of independence seen in the law, which should not be dependent on the powers, is a kind of power vacuum. Ok, these things dont exist or the performance of the Competition Council is weak. In discussions about nongovernmental centers , there is a need for a regulator and a monopoly, we must have input that the Competition Council can now with this structure, not the current law of the Competition Council, but there is definitely a need to review there are rules and structure of the Competition Council , very well, mr. Kochchi nejad, what do you think, which device should come in, you who believed in regulation , yes, look, in relation to the discussion, that is, education and the value of education, and pricing on education is a highly Specialized Task because the trainings are very diverse and different departments are also involved in these trainings. Thats why i believe that there must be a council. For example, in the entrance Examination Department , we have a special council. In the field of education, we have a council under the title of council which determines the tuition fees of students in nongovernment schools. We have Different Councils in these educational departments. I believe that combining these councils can form a complete council. You can see how the Competition Council is managing this market. In fact, there is no supervision on the car market. The people in charge are constantly complaining. I believe that this council is a specialized training council. There must be expert people. And the associate people who are involved in educational systems should be in this council. We can combine the field of the ministry of science we should have the ministry of medical sciences, the ministry of education, a combination of these, with some of the regulatory bodies and other bodies as members , let us have a council under the name of the education Supervision Council of the country, and that council will come to make policies and rates. Almost make a policy and have a floating rate for the departments that give special or extracurricular training outside of the Training Program , there should be some flexibility , this will make us in all departments that are working in education government and nongovernmental universities, universities of Applied Science and fields we can organize this training and in that organization the rates we set and the monitoring devices can monitor the set rates. Now the monitoring of the monitoring device is very weak. The revenue is from the devices. The accounts court should also have an opinion on the type of spending. There is no order in this department. I believe that this combined council can manage the Education System of the country and set the rates based on specializations based on the type of services in the departments. Various basic sciences and Sciences Humanities and sciences, arts and technical engineering departments can organize these very easily, and when people see that there is a ruling law , people will definitely welcome it. Mr. Dr. s expertise is part of the education commission, he is definitely more specialized than my colleague, but in the current situation, what is determined by the law is that anticompetitive behavior is prohibited in articles 48 to 48 of the law on the implementation of policies of article 44 of the constitution. Well, according to article 62 of this law, the Competition Council is only the authority for dealing with anticompetitive procedures is the subject of cases. It is 44 to 48, that is, where the in fact, it should be investigated and this council has the authority to make a decision about the wrongdoer in case any of the anticompetitive procedures are found in accordance with one of the clauses of article 61. That was the point here. What does he compare himself with the materials 44 to 48 later that he recognized, so to speak. He makes a decision and actually announces it, but since all the approvals of the Competition Council can be socalled revised, my next point is that in the sevenmember review, 3 of the 7 members are actually the majority. Nature and composition it has a weak technique, which means that in the end, what comes out after the revision is a sevenmember team , 3 of whom are absent. In my opinion, it is a weak combination. And by these you must mean economic. Yes , any other topic you want to talk about education. He said that there may be many small points about it. Sometimes you want to talk about the car, sometimes you want to talk about the internet. People should vote on this matter and announce the final decision in the appeal. I think this is the background of our conversation today. And many tips that maybe it was not done well in the country in terms of pricing and finally damaged the supply and demand sectors. In my opinion, the structure of the Competition Council itself needs a serious revision, so you believe in the revision of the Competition Council so that there should be a new council , yes. No, i accept the appeal , the supreme law, the socalled article 44 of the constitution. However, it seems to me that this Competition Council itself and its article 62 must be revised and if it is necessary to change the law , the law must be changed, if not with the bylaws or circulars and instructions, these can be amended. We can see more productivity from the Competition Council both in the field of education, which is our discussion now, and in other fields, which unfortunately we see less. The point that is raised regarding the receipt of these fees is the state of the Financial Statements of these universities, which is said to always be criticized that it is not transparent and it is not clear what the cost of the income of these universities is. It is necessary to investigate or make a report , because i am not used to commenting on something that i have no knowledge about. This may be the case, but i did not have any input that i received a report to confirm or deny this. Do but it is possible, yes, in any case, the tuition fees that are charged from the students are the universitys own expenses, considering that i mentioned that both in terms of quality and salaries for faculty members , their Financial Statements are now one of the the serious debates that we have in nonstate universities are the differences in the salaries of faculty members and state universities. Well, this itself has an effect on the quality of education, and unfortunately, sometimes this number may not be very accurate, but it can be approximated to the minute, which is close to half, and this is a serious damage to the quality of education as well. The injustice that is being done to these dear ones, mr. Kouchini nejad, mr. Taheri, says that we should reform the structure of the Competition Council and strengthen it, according to principle 44, you said that there was a new education Supervision Council. Let them do it in the field of economy, services, education, this is the same thing. Look at the articles and laws passed by the parliament, permanent laws, laws also have their place, and this Competition Council , when the parliament approved it, the view at that time was that it was mostly in the economic field of this council. If this council is supposed to enter in the field of education, it should also Pay Attention to the variety of education. If he enters, we should definitely fix it lets make a law, that means the law should be passed by the shogh islamic majlis again, or the government should give a bill or the house of representatives, we should be able to change the entire structure of the Competition Council and make it more flexible in order to monitor or make policies on the countrys education , i believe, considering the type of services in the service sector, in the industry sector, in the Education Sector , is diverse. If we integrate these things in a council, i believe, nothing good will come out of it, that is, the necessary expertise and the necessary finesse will not be found in these councils. For this reason, we believe that a new council should be established in the countrys education field, from the prewriting course to the doctorate course, and this council can make policies. Let him monitor the policies that he announces, the government can also write regulations and vote its own way within the framework of those policies. Yes, alhamdulillah , we have reached this good common point, that there is a need for regulation, this means that it shows that there is a monopoly, if there was no need for this, this first point is actually an understanding, the second is the 2nd issue. On exclusive one yes the issue is whether it should be a council or a Competition Council in the way that mr. Doctor said. We both agreed that if there is to be a Competition Council, its current structure is flawed and must be reformed. Now or then, the reforms in the Competition Council must be done for this and other tasks. And his entry into different departments, i am sorry that he didnt get a good average score, now that he hasnt started, or the doctors suggestion, which is a bit more specialized anyway. Be it under the supervision of the ministry of science or another department if it is the second one, it probably needs a law, but if it is under the supervision of the Competition Council, we have a higher law, and until today, the law that exists in the country is a strong law from article 44. Leave the diagnosis of monopoly and entry to the Competition Council to do this. I have no objection to the second suggestion of mr. Doctor. I think it is possible to go that way. Thank you. Mr. Cook had a point about monopoly. Please see the monopoly i would like to tell you that the custom and in science is to do something one person does it, no one else can do it, or it is in the possession of a group, there is a team, this becomes a monopoly. That we have a variety of training, from the ministry of science to the ministry of education , to the medical sciences, as a result, we do not have this monopoly, mr. Dr. Dr. Sat. But the total number of glasses they produce is 100, the countrys need is 1000. Does this have the concept of monopoly . It must have produced a variety of glasses with different qualities. A balanced market is coming because the Competition Councils monopoly has entered and because it has been produced little by little, i am training and there is a lot, mr. Doctor. If necessary, the Islamic Council or the government should enter into the discussion of regulation and give this regulation by god, according to the law , it should be given to the parliament to enact laws. And grip in the area of the city that god willing i hope that we will have more control over the quality of education. Thank you very much, mr. Taheri, and all the good viewers who have accompanied us up to this point. You or above are wherever we are today, he said. Let them eat rotten. This is the story of two palestinian mothers about the present and the day of these children. A few days ago, me and my children were forced to eat spoiled food , there is no bread. My family and my children and grandchildren are 35 people. Everyone is hungry. By god , we have nothing to eat. I do nothing i eat so that my children can eat. Its not better than them, god, these children are infants, what a sin to do, there is no milk anywhere, we ourselves eat barley, but these children cannot bear it, the child is also dying of hunger, i recently gave birth and i had to reach for dates to silence my son. Give him dates because i cant give him milk these days, from ordinary people to famous faces. No matter how you break the cage, you fly , you dont get tired, tiredness has no meaning for us, eyes, if there is no life, there is no way to the sea, higher than the oven or higher, wherever we are today. You are better tomorrow that lions heart that turns is the quality of our hearts , wherever there is a test, there we leave our footprints in the land of the heart that has no width, our story is love , love has no borders. We are higher tomorrow. Sarai khorod has an exceptional offer for buying a limited number of trucks and tractors, buying at the factory price without interest and with discounts. Get on the road and enjoy your travels. Car garage in sarai big iranian. Specialized laboratory for measuring the strength of abadan profiles. Tough in hardships. Waterresistant door and window profiles. Lets have a nice trip for the car refrigerator, how about buying it from pak shumar safar . By purchasing any of pak shumas products , there is a possibility of winning an exciting trip for you. Buying from pak shuma is a trip. Pak shuma is always with you. You are in the morning with ranchers, raw cocoa ranchers , ranchers cream, ranchers sticks with honey ranchers, cheese ranchers, cocoa milk ranchers, yogurt ranchers , fresh cheese ranchers, ranchers from morning. Hashangahan with the farmers, children , lets go to the cities right now. Why, because the city of Household Appliances now buys a vacuum cleaner for 35 million tomans, they are giving away the gifts. Oh, sweep the gifts, one by one, one by one, one by one, one by one, one by one. Each and every single macaron, single macaron, single Macaron Macaron , one by one, one by one, one by one , one by one , one by one, one by one, one by one. About the bank in sarai bozor irani in the cities of qom, isfahan and tehran, i am your host until 2 00 in the morning in the city of tehran. In the name of allah, the most merciful , the most merciful, greetings to you, dear and respected countrymen , together with my colleagues, we present the news of 4 00 p. M. To continue providing relief to the floodaffected areas of sistan baluchistan province. The red crescent of sistan baluchistan has announced so far more than 19 thousand people have been helped in 450 flooded villages of sistan baluchistan