Lets start todays economy table with a quote that says that such transactions should be discredited and if it is approved by the Iranian Parliament from the point of view of the Guardian Council, it is in the best interest of the country to finally approve this law. This is part of the leaderships talks. Regarding the invalidity of ordinary documents, something that the judiciary has repeatedly pointed out, that there are 60 of them in the courts. It is caused by normal documents and lawsuits related to it, but it has been about four months since the leadership said this. I have heard that the Expediency Council will have a meeting tomorrow and they will make a decision. We have to see what will happen in the end from this talk, from this diagnosis that was given and from this order that was given. Lets have a review together to see what the overall picture is, if we look at it together, lets see what theory the government is giving, which mr. Khandozi, the economic spokesman, has made clear. The government has said that these documents should be invalidated and removed, and these talks are the first of the first comments. Mr. Mohsenni, the head of the department, said that the challenge of the document is one of the most important inputs of the courts, and this disregard for the official document has caused a lot of misunderstandings in most of the cases. Regarding complaints regarding affidavit documents, here we also heard the opinion of the head of the department, mr. Mortezi moghadam, the president of the Supreme Court of my country, said that a written mobile letter must be an authentic one, and i am sorry for your presence, those old documents are not very good against this send me official documents. I am pleased to welcome you having said the same thing, he said that i would like to go to your presence and start using official documents. Lets do it instead of those old documents and affidavits that many of us must have witnessed and seen. The issue is not that these should be removed all at once, this naturally seems to me to be illogical and cannot happen. The issue is that these will take time they should be replaced in a way, so that the official document has a high status and becomes valuable and it is easy to use, and on the other hand , the use of ordinary documents, affidavits, and mobile letters become invalid, so that naturally someone will find it. Dont let it go to the direction of writing a mobile letter between two people, for example, writing a contract, going to the document and being arrogant, many of you must be in your distance, there are too many people here , we were starting the discussion before the program, a few of your colleagues. We ourselves have many cases that were confused because of this normal document and affidavit, and naturally, this can reduce many of these challenges , hoping to god. We also heard the last sentence given by the leader of the revolution, so naturally there is room for doubt hey, we dont want to check the different economic angles at the economic table and see how much it will benefit the people if this happens and as soon as possible. I could buy a house in niligah, but now i cant afford a house in nili. When will i get an answer to my misfortunes . These 132 units will be sold to more than 1,400 people in 2016 until eid 2018. The rezvaneh project is the place where you could bypass people. And 132 units will be sold to 1,400 people under the shadow of the law and with the use of law bugs should do this, young man, by god, he doesnt sleep from night to morning, he has worked all day long, he has worked here and there, he has gone , let someone who comes and eats powder, the heads of the three allied powers, the normal documents should be invalidated, so peoples problems are like this. Be less expediting this work as soon as possible is very important to organize the document system in the country. And it can fully guarantee the registration of ownership in the country. Unofficial documents in the law that has been going back and forth for several years between the Honorable Council of guardians and the expediency determination assembly do not recognize normal documents, and many efforts have been made. We were asked from the authorities and leadership , we were asked from shura gudjin, many times we also went before us. Going to talk to the parliament, we talked about one of the 100 items on the agenda, the parliament started work 4 years ago and approved the invalidation of the pledges, the end of the voting was approved , but this resolution has been between the parliament and the Guardian Council for 30 years. It went back and forth until 9 months ago, he finally went to the Expediency Assembly to resolve the dispute and determine the expediency of the people. Every day it is delayed for the approval of this plan, it will cause harmful economic and social effects in our society. This issue is being investigated. A new news channel for radio and television. The report of my colleague from sed and simas judicial news team was presented to you. What we have today as an excuse to address this issue is the statement made by the ministry of roads and urban development that if these official documents are found. I think we can provide credit for the 20,000 units of the National Housing movement that are pending and we will discuss how in the program. I am here in the studio of the economics desk of mr. Beizai, a housing expert. Mr. Abu tarabi, the respected representative of the islamic shura majlis, who is with us from the floor of the majlis, and we will talk with them. Greetings to all the guests, i would like to start with mr. Beizai and the question of what exactly is going to happen, sometimes a question may arise for the people, maybe they have some concerns, especially those who have land now, are living in the village, on the outskirts of the cities, basically sindh. They dont know exactly what is going to happen and what will be the benefits for the people. In the name of allah, the most merciful , the most merciful. What has happened is that two problems must be solved, two problems and problems in the country, one is to devalidate ordinary documents as opposed to official documents, this means that our judicial courts cannot invalidate our official documents anymore. Now sometimes you see that it happens that even our institutions and institutions have official documents, but now a judge can, for example , by referring to it, which can be a very ordinary document, an official document, even the courts of public and government institutions can invalidate an official document. If they invalidate people , this will cause the problem of land grabbing and if corruption occurs in the field of independent real estate in the country, the first thing that should be paid attention to is that ordinary documents are no longer valid compared to official documents. The housing should be in such a way that the official process of the country is carried out and the transactions are officially registered , so that the incidents like what you have reported do not happen where one property is sold to 10 people and 132 units are sold to 1400 people and later they say these things. We should waste their lives in the corridors of courts and prosecutors lets protect the interests of the people and protect what is the right of the people. One of the solutions is to prove ourselves. We want to prove your words. We want to see what damage this has caused to the people. For example, you mentioned selling a property to several people, government lands. It happened a lot. Bringing a normal document that now the slopes of mount damavand, for example, is for a private person. These are Natural Resources and belong to all people. These mountain robberies and land robberies that happen are too much news. This issue has a point of its own i want to tell you that this does not mean that those who in the past, now, in the old traditional way , have a letter, exchange a document between themselves , sell, buy, rent, or rent a property. Credit should be generated from it, and now it has no credit, and they should worry that their property will be taken away from them, while what is said is that if someone has an official document , someone else cannot take that property from him with an ordinary document and deprive him of his ownership. Do this is a very good condition, for example, a singlepage document i was for my land, for my blood. Tomorrow, he didnt give me a piece of paper. He said, i made a contract here, for example, 10 years ago. This normal document does not have any conditions, that is, even you can, for example, on a very small piece of paper, for example, forge a normal document and take it. Please return the case to the court. Thank you very much for your explanation, mr. Abu tarabi. Please let me know that if this cycle goes through, and now i would also like to say in parenthesis that my colleagues have tried very hard to have a relationship with the respected members of the expediency detection group, but naturally we have not been able to do so until now. They can do it in the 20 minutes that are left in the building mr. Abutarai, please tell us what is the exact situation we are in, what is going to happen if this law is finally passed and this thing that has been in dispute for three or four years and has been discussed for years. If it is passed, what exactly will happen from the day after tomorrow when this law is finally passed and approved . Yes , in the name of allah, the most merciful, the most merciful. Greetings to you and dear viewers. I say hello and thank you for the very important issue that you are pursuing today. As you said, about 55 total court cases today, it is related to ordinary documents with 11 criminal titles that in the courts of justice, in terms of ordinary documents, today the courts are involved with it, either directly or indirectly, these 11 criminal titles, of which i will mention a few examples , such as land grabbing. Fraud, denial, doubt, and similar issues , which make up 1150 of all court cases, so the issue is a very important issue after our revolution, which has been around 44 years, with the interpretation of the Guardian Council of ordinary documents , the validity of official documents has been revoked. It was dropped and the normal documents entered the courts and the judges started the decision of the body is based on the documents that, naturally, today we would have required that we give an important plan in this regard in the previous period and take a big step to prove the ownership and to register the ownership, more important, to have the registration of the ownership for the people of iran. That Foreign Investors or domestic investors, with a piece of paper called ordinary documents, can cancel the official documents of a country with the courts decision, so it does not create any more investment, there is no trust left for you to invest in the country, today, especially the issue of stocks. Justice and also what is your plan now now, let me come to that point today. I will tell you that there is an urgent need in terms of equity and voss test issues. One of the most important issues is the issue of having peoples property, peoples independence and nonpromissory property. We know that the government should know that these properties are nonpromissory today. In the discussion of peoples subsidies, it is also effective and the justice of the people. Today, they launder billions of tomans with normal documents, real estate, or suppose expensive cars, or suppose even ships, airplanes, etc. , with normal documents in our country, unfortunately, because it is not acceptable to discuss. Money laundering also happens. What is your situation now . Yes, in our case, we must First Express our regret that for several months in the systems expediency assessment, this important issue is before the judiciary, but for several months, as the popular saying goes, it was delayed for about 7 months in the system. Expediency discernment council. It even went to a stage to be rejected, which was mentioned by the Supreme Leader during the week of the judiciary among the judges as a definite expedient, but we saw the emphasis of the Supreme Leader. The main reason for determining the expediency of the system, god willing, is that this matter will be resolved in the month in about four months, yes , about four months, unfortunately, what was the reason for this slow process . You see, there is an issue, ayatollah arafi, they write a letter from the service area of the Supreme Leader and ask a new question. In this question, hazrat agha mentions three clauses, clause one and two, which were fully seen in this plan. Paragraph 3 of the article, which in paragraph 3 of dosh, as a definite expedient, is mentioned again by the Supreme Leader , because it was stated once before that it is a definite expedient, this series of statements is a definite expedient with this interpretation. We have seen in article 10 of this plan that all trusted scholars, as well as all people, in a system that is for two years, of course, one 6 months, one two years, one 5 years, for 2 years, they can show those normal documents that have a claim, so to speak, in a system that the opinion of the judiciary is to upload it and for once after these two years, we will close the file of normal documents and it will no longer be possible to present the socalled dispute and complaint in the court. Hazrat agha, so to speak , was subjected to different interpretations in the Expediency Council, and therefore a little it took time. About four months after aghas speech, it was almost because of this issue, and before that, basically, the totality of egypts nizam diagnosis decided to reject it. Thank you. The representative of the islamic shura, mr. Bayzai, now, if he wants this to happen and be realized, in any case, he needs infrastructure, which mr. Abutaleb also mentioned , the government agencies, the judiciary, the dam organization, what should they do in order for this process to be done faster , more precisely. If it is done, see now in other rules also, after this law has been discussed and discussed, the main path is the independent property registration system, which is now working under the jurisdiction of the judiciary and notary offices. The same issue was discussed again in the housing market, and now the Real Estate Companies and other actors in this field should be linked to this system, and there should be a unified procedure so that all these documents can be registered under that system. And in official and legal channels, everything from now on is current yes, this system and infrastructures currently exist in the country, so this system is under the authority of another department of the judiciary, and the cadastre system is also under the authority of the seb organization, which is under the authority of another department. Judiciary currently has the possibility of ministers to speed up the formalization of normal documents. Hopefully , we will see what happens. Mr. Nowrozi is an advisor to the minister of roads and urban planning and the head of the Housing Economics Office of the ministry of roads and urban planning on the communication line of mon. Mr. Nowrozi had talked about that if these official documents replace the documents get used to it, people are more trusting. There will be a large funding from the people for a number of about 200,000 units of the National Movement. How will this be achieved . Basically, what is the ratio of these two categories to each other . In the name of allah , the merciful, the merciful. Let me present your plan to you. Well, looking at the issue that you mentioned, one of the basic issues that we have in the field of Housing Construction and buying and selling is the lack of transparency that exists in the field of property and the lack of Property Rights problems that have arisen now. Looking at this one of the important issues in the field. Made housing is a matter of presale. Well, this capacity is very important for many countries in the world to use this presale market to build housing in the country with the small capital of the people. It is done through the field of presale, but this issue has not been done in our country, the problem is also because of the risk that has happened in this issue, for example, in some projects. Rizwan qom, many units were sold to several people with a letter of intent and a paper document. And practically, this issue increases the risk for the promoters and they cannot use this area. Well, this issue will be solved correctly in the law that is now in the Expediency Council, god willing, and if the problem of normal documents is solved, we can use lets use the capacity of presale to build housing with peoples capital like many countries in the world and trust will return to the market area before this root reform that you mentioned or this arrangement of the presale situation with the arrival of documents, i. E. With the invalidation of normal documents. It can be realized. Well, look at the point that exists now, it is possible for one person to ask for a property that has not yet been built and wants to be built , to sell this property to several people with a letter of intent. When normal documents become invalid and our transactions, these transactions become invalid and the court does not accept them, practically as a right of ownership is invalidated because right now it is possible that an ordinary promissory note can invalidate an official document , so the basic issue created in this law is that we can validate official documents against documents and the main approach that should be taken. Follow up in this plan that is being followed up the irrevocability of official documents is compared to ordinary documents. Now, the point that exists in article 1 and article 10 of this issue is that i have clearly mentioned this issue and the following issues in relation to the discussion of the law itself. The point that exists is that in this the proposal for a reform has taken a long time in the complex, so there is an expert being done there that it should be done more quickly. We are also doing it. And article 10 of this law can have very minor amendments regarding the attitude of the irrevocability of official documents should become more serious, and we cant have ordinary documents be valid against them, and official documents should be strengthened. This issue is now being followed up in the diagnosis collection, god willing, this issue will be followed seriously. That the issue of the validity of ordinary documents against official documents should be resolved in a radical way, i have news at your service about what is your situation, i will tell you now in the forum, well , there are many meetings in the specialized committees and the Legal Commission of the forum, the detection of being blocked from the system held, the representatives of various institutions are present. The opinions of University Professors experts in the legal field have been hired and it is going in this direction that, god willing, soon, god willing, this matter is well because there have been few serious discussions on legal issues , well, this plan has been going back and forth for 45 years with the Guardian Council and the islamic council, we hope. God willing, with a more serious intention , i have set a meeting tomorrow as well. God willing, this issue will be solved and this shamelessness that we have in the field of ownership in our country will be resolved. Right now, we have about 70 properties in the country, our Marginal Properties do not have documents. More than 50 of its agricultural fields are undocumented, more than 50 leather houses do not have documents. Well, one of the main goals of this law is to facilitate the official document process , which can greatly help. The merck field can help. The first part, which discusses obstacles, removal of obstacles and the education of sadul bird , which has been approved so far by the Legal Commission of these articles, with the power of alhamdulillah. And there were 10 points that, god willing, with the approach of revocation the irrevocability of official documents will be solved with some minor changes, and we can witness that an ordinary document will never be able to invalidate an official document that is published and issued from reliable sources. Thank you very much, god willing. Mr. Nowrozi, advisor to the minister of urban roads, head of the economy and Housing Office of the ministry, mr. Beizai, except for this presale that we want to mention, lets see more precisely how this presale will be solved and what other economic benefits it will have on the housing market. See first that people how much to the side asad is normal, their value will increase and this is an economic benefit for them. On the topic of pre sale, well, presale is a very good way to provide housing, which is much better than the existing methods , why what happens in presale is that these inflations or the increase in prices that is done when a person enters the presale is actually being transferred to that buyer or investor. Because of this , it is much more beneficial for people. Now, for example, there is now the provision of housing for the National Movement and others there is no presale mechanism. I want to tell you this. How can credit from normal documents in front of official documents lead to the development of presale . See , the Biggest Issue in the field of presale is the high risk of the transaction, which happens when we create lets have a unified approach, that is, let them register the transaction and specify that, for example, i presold a property to you. This criterion will be for the municipality , it will be for the food machine , and it will be the criterion for loan introduction. For example , to other people for such educational projects this issue causes what happens in that system, when i came and presold a property to you, the other property is locked and i sell it to other people. This is when this procedure is formed in the market. I want to presell, for example, a real estate. If the person or the manufacturer does not register in the system, i will understand that he wants to do something illegal and i will separate my path. When everything becomes clear, there is a possibility of corruption and fraud. Forgery will be removed from the market and peoples property will be stabilized and their ownership will be stabilized we have one minute to answer a question that we are talking about in the same conversation for 20 minutes and half an hour. We gave countless reasons why official documents are a very good thing. It has caused problems for the people. What do you think caused this law to not be implemented during this time . Look , i would like to ask you something. For the sake of my seminary friends, i am telling you what is important and now mainly looking at what has happened, the problem that exists is that now crediting and ordinary documents could be done because of the same discussion of witnesses and now two witnesses, for example, and the recommendations that came about in drinking because of this issue, the originality of the issue and the transparency you see, the issue of shahad was a tool to create transparency. Once, for example , in those societies with two witnesses, it happened to create transparency. Now it must be done based on the systems so that we can check the character. Thank you very much for your explanations, real estate experts, and explanations from all the good viewers of the economic table, like thank you for accompanying us until this moment. This issue will definitely be on our agenda and we will follow it up. God bless you in the name of allah, the most merciful, the most merciful, hello and good day to you, my dear compatriots. Stay tuned to the news of the stock market and analysis of the capital market. Refer to the systems that are introduced so that the process of transferring these shares can be determined