Frontiers | Attitudes Toward Animal Dissection and Animal-Free Alternatives Among High School Biology Teachers in Switzerland

Animal dissection has been a traditional teaching tool in biology for centuries. However, harmful animal use in education has raised ethical and environmental concerns in the last decades and led to an ongoing debate about the role and importance of animal dissection in teaching across all education levels. To understand the current status of dissection in secondary education and the attitudes towards humane teaching alternatives among the educators, I conducted a survey – for the first time – among high school biology teachers in Switzerland. The specific aims of this study were i) to explore the extent of animal or animal parts dissection in high school biology classes, ii) to understand the attitudes and experiences of high school biology teachers towards dissection and animal-free alternatives, and iii) to gain some insight into the circumstances hindering a wider uptake of alternatives to animal dissection in high school education. In total, 76 teachers participated in the online survey. The vast majority (97%) of the participants reported using animal dissection in their classes. The responses also revealed that a large proportion of the teachers consider animal-free alternatives inferior teaching tools in comparison with dissection. As the obstacles to adopting alternatives were most often listed the lack of time to research other methods, high costs, and peer pressure. In conclusion, the wider uptake of humane teaching methods would require financial support as well as a shift in the attitudes of high school biology teachers.

Related Keywords

Germany ,New York ,United States ,Spofforth ,North Yorkshire ,United Kingdom ,Netherlands ,Israel ,Argentina ,Eschulen ,Brandenburg ,South Africa ,Westport ,Washington ,Toronto ,Ontario ,Canada ,Switzerland ,London ,City Of ,South African ,German ,Swiss ,Israeli ,American ,Kennedy Instit ,Silvia Frey ,Switzerland Federal Statistical Office ,Rr Core Team ,University Of Toronto ,Methuen ,University Of Toronto Press ,Braun ,Oxford University ,Association Of Swiss Science Teachers ,Humane Society ,Rstudio Team ,Association Of Swiss Gymnasium Teachers ,Dialogues Across International Boundaries ,American Psychological Association ,Statistical Office ,University Of Georgia ,Oxford University Press ,Swiss Rectors Association ,Pearson ,Routledge ,Resolution Reaffirming Support For Research ,Swiss Animal Welfare Act ,Federal Statistical Office ,Teachers Switzerland ,Swiss Science Teachers ,Swiss Gymnasium ,Species Used ,Attitudes Toward Animal Dissection ,Animal Dissection ,Swiss High ,Animals Used ,Environmental Magazine ,Students Opting Out ,Experience With ,Attitudes Toward Animal Free ,Ethical Aspects ,Animal Welfare Act ,Shifting Toward Animal Free ,Psychological Association ,Resolution Reaffirming Support ,Med Abstract ,Crossref Full Text ,Higher Education ,Annual International Conference ,Animal Use ,Responsible Animal ,Core Team ,Integrated Development ,Humane Experimental ,Natural World ,Biology Education ,Dissection ,Umane Teaching ,Secondary Education ,Teaching Practice ,