Frontiers | A Counterfactual Baseline for Assessing Future Environmental Impact: A Case Study of the Belt and Road Initiative

The impact of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) on the environment is an important but controversial topic. But assessing it faces a significant challenge for separating its policy impact from the overall effect of economic development that will also have environmental impacts. This paper attempts to provide an evolutionary and counterfactual baseline to evaluate the environmental impact of BRI, based on the distribution dynamics approach and the mobility probability plots (MPPs). Our estimation results suggest that while the majority of BRI economies will lower their emission levels compared with the world average, there are significant differences between BRI and non-BRI countries’ emission patterns and dynamics. The majority of non-BRI economies will have lower emission levels than their BRI counterparts in the absence of BRI policy, indicating that the difference in future emissions between BRI and non-BRI countries should not be completely attributed to the environmental impact of BRI. Instead, BRI should take measures to prevent certain countries from moving upwards energy intensity paths through policy intervention, international cooperation, and an inclusive project assessment process.

Related Keywords

Suocheng , Hunan , China , Fujia , Jiangxi , Taiwan , Japan , United States , Hong Kong , Guangyi , Guangdong , Singapore , Laos , Florida , Canada , South Korea , Han , Chinese , Lao , Boca Raton , J Asia Pac , Dialogue United Nations Industrial Development Organization , Agenda For Sustainable Development , Wind Energy Production , Firm Carbon Emissions , Environmental Impacts Of The Initiative , Energy Consumption , Green Development Modes , Information Technology , Household Energy Consumption , Context Of China Initiative , Effect Of Financial Development On Ecological Footprint , Distribution Dynamics Of Energy Intensity , Impacts Of China Initiative , A Fresh Evidence From Initiative Economies , Distribution Dynamics Of Energy Intensities , Green Development Or Greenwashing , Energy Efficiency Convergence , China Contributions To Global Green Energy , Artificial Neural Networks Anns , National Science Foundation Of China No , Club Convergence , Sustainable Development Modes Of Economic Belt , Ecological Environment Monitoring For Sustainable Development Goals , Steel Industries , Economic Development , Carbon Development , Sustainable Development , Sustainable Development Goals , How Can Initiative Bring New Life , Panel Data Estimation , Initiative Hong , Environmental Challenges For The Initiative , Environmental Impacts Of Infrastructure Development , World Bank , Energy Intensities , Case Study Of Initiative Countries , Persistence In Per Capita Energy Use Among , World Bank Development Indicators , Grant For Research Ref , East Asian Miracle , Road Initiative , Central Asia , Southeast Asian , Environmental Cooperation Plans , Strategic Environmental , Social Assessments , Silk Road , Artificial Neural Networks , World Development Indicators , National Science Foundation , Environmental Pollution , One Belt Road Provinces , Per Capita , Dioxide Emissions , Fossil Fuel Source , Environmental Challenges , Financial Development , Ecological Footprint , Panel Data , Med Abstract , Crossref Full Text , Road Countries Contribute , Glocal Low Carbon , Regional Disparity , Electricity Consumption , Distribution Dynamics , Transitional Dynamics , Industrial Output , County Level Study Using , New Framework , Carbon Dioxide Emissions , Chinese Cities , Seeking Linkages , Global Environmental , Energy Policy , Per Capita Energy Use Among , Revisited Using Confidence , Carbon Emissions , Green Development , Political Ecology Perspective , Green Belt , Eurasian Geography , Jointly Building , Road Towards , Sustainable City Exhibition , United Nations Industrial Development , Identifying Key Variables , Statistical Models , Building Energy Consumption Using , Understanding China , Minimizing Environmental Impacts , Security Politics , Pair Wise Econometric , Global Green Energy , Low Carbon Development , Empirical Evidence Under , Road Economic , Ecological Environment Monitoring , Journal Remote Sens , Foreign Investment , New Machine Learning Algorithm , Utilities Policy , Transportation Infrastructure , Transportation Econ , Machine Learning Approach , Relationship Among Solar , Coal Consumption , Five Asian Countries , New Machine Learning , Machine Learning Analysis , Relationship Among Iron , Air Pollution , Economic Growth , Stochastic Convergence , Per Capita Fossil Fuel Consumption , Evaluating Economic , Environmental Value , Liner Vessel Sharing , Maritime Silk , Empirical Cross Section Dynamics , Twin Peaks , Sustainable Development Challenges , Fresh Evidence From Belt , Environ Sci , Relative Household Energy Consumption , World Economy , Prioritizing Driving Factors , Household Carbon Emissions , Energy Investment , Southeast Asia , Density Estimation , Economic Patterns , Sustainable Development Modes , Silk Road Economic , Purchasing Power Parity , Environmental Impacts , Infrastructure Development , Trade Impacts , From Resource , Conservation Recycling , Pollutant Emission , Foreign Direct Investment , New Insights , Continuous Dynamic Distribution , Energy Intensity , Heterogeneous Effects , Energy Efficiency , Divergence Influenced , Bilateral Trade , Asean Electricity Market Integration , How Can Belt , Road Initiative Bring New Life , Integrating Sustainable Development Goals , New Model , Household Consumption , Economic Policy Uncertainty , Evidence Using , China Provincial , Virtual Water Trade , Agricultural Products , New Perspective , Environmentally Sensitive Growth , Case Study , Belt And Road Initiative , Mission Convergence , Obility Probability Plots , Ounterfactual Baseline ,