A joint project of the espresso tv channel and the atp tv channel together. Beraber. My name is khrystyna yatskiv. I congratulate ayder muzhdabaev. Selyam aleykum, khrystyna khanim. Alaykum salaam. And today we are talking about the second anniversary of the Russian Federations largescale invasion of ukraine. And about, and about the tenth, in principle, already the anniversary. The dates are a little off, but its just there, its about days. The anniversary of the actual beginning, well, the war against ukraine, the beginning of the occupation of crimea, and we are nobody about it, we should remind everyone, including our foreign partners, that everything started in crimea, and everything must end in crimea as well, as she said our colleague sevil musayev, it was a long, long time ago, but it is true, ugh, and indeed 10 years of fullfledged Armed Russian federation against ukraine, and still it is quite difficult for me to accept this new language of ours from two years ago, a largescale invasion, or a fullscale aggression. That, what the russians did in crimea is an act of military aggression, and for those who lost their homes in crimea and who are now under occupation, this large scale is measured for them. Maybe not with bombs and missiles until recently, but nevertheless, exile, yes, rights violations, slavery, etc. , and i, you know, its actually good that you asked, because, and brought this up, because someone calls it a fullscale invasion , someone a total invasion, and for myself i define it as a big war, well, its just big in scale, and the essence is war. It the 14th year, the great war is the 22nd year, i think that in principle, in general, it is correct, i dont know if you will agree with me, but i say so, and actually, lets remind that ukraine continues to effectively resist to the russian occupier, we have enormous successes in the context of destroyed russians, destroyed russian equipment, and we really want these successes. And we also want the lives of our soldiers to remain as valuable as possible, and here ayder, it is certainly worth reminding about the collection that we will support you always remember and thank you to all viewers for remembering that that we in this program each time call for donations for a specific collection for a specific unit, for the 48th separate assault battalion named after noman. The commander of which is the director, head of the tv channel lenur slyamov, now he is the captain of the armed forces of ukraine and the commander of this assault unit, the socalled crimean unit, he is the only large crimean unit , ukrainians, crimeans and foreigners are fighting together there, even those who do not care about the fate of ukraine and the fate of crimea, and we are gathering just now, must be closed. The collection there is twothirds with almost a little even more assembled for night drones, you can see all the details and numbers and qr codes and paypal and absolutely everything you need for night drones, that is, for fpv drones with thermal, as it is called, television cameras, i apologize, i am not an expert, but i know for sure, they are very. Very useful, now each of these drones, they serve to protect, protect our fighters and strike the enemy, strike theirs. Equipment, these drones are a little more powerful than ordinary ones, they cost more than uah 30, but it is effective and it saves the lives of our soldiers, officers and allows us to keep where you know, it sometimes seems almost impossible to hold on, because the open space of our southern direction, there is water and steppe, and there are very few even forests and trees, it is very difficult there, and these drones are you. There are a lot of tweets that throughout the program there will be this qr code and card number, join the gathering, it is noble, it is right, if we are talking here about crimea and ukraine and about our ongoing war, we are reminding you already 10 years. Ugh. And it will probably be logical to say the same that this week, while you and i have not seen each other in ether, a rather largescale allukrainian tax on marine was launched. Which have already received the name s babyby, now the whole of ukraine is actually collecting on them, why do we mention them, because it is about the black sea itself, it hints at troubles for the black sea fleet of the Russian Federation , which has a base in crimea, and of course in we cant help but say this to our beraber project, its a cool thing, because in fact the biggest successes, here i agree with all the experts, well, who am i to agree that the military expert, no, but its just. Even an expert in quotation marks like me can see that the most effective, the most effective this past year was in the liberation of the black sea, a sea that they considered almost their internal, that is , they were, i dont know, raiding there a nato country, they felt free there, now a little not so free, and thanks to these drones, which are very effective, by the way, analogues. There are actually no such drones in the russian terrorist army, this is knowhow, in fact, and the british are already learning Something Else from us, the fact is that and the russians are actually trying to come to terms with something and promise to start serial production of not only unmanned aerial vehicles, but also naval drones, unmanned aerial vehicles, but at the same time, as they say, all the salt is in the skill of application, and here is the nation of moves in the application of various means, this is cool, and so far only the Defense Forces of ukraine can do this, cool, you know what i want to add, if it was about drones, we didnt prepare, i didnt know if the best military expert in this studio could even be there, well really add it now a professional military man, well, for me , the best military expert, the closest military expert to me, mrs. Khrystyna yatskiv, had this. Conversation, and there is such a thing, recently shuigu, the socalled, this ghoul, spoke before putin, he reported, he lied to him about the fact that they cleared the bridgehead there on the left bank of the dnieper, thats right, he lied and lied, and he said that it was special, so there is such a feature that, ah, the ukrainians use heavy drones for e e for the supply of ammunition, and. For i also for evacuation, he didnt say that, i think, but i also know about it, yes, that is, drones are used, they are bombing, heavy drones, they are also used to deliver the necessary products, water, and shells, mines, grenades, ammo, etc. , i am very proud that one of the best companies that make these heavy drones is a Company Called hurzuve defenses, thats great. Why because my friend pavel filblum, who founded this company, and he found likeminded people, inventors, very cool people who made this really cool heavy shot drone, you can watch, read, go to their facebook pages, why not subscribe to the channel, there are interesting shots, by the way, i always go to defense, ugh, why gorzov, because we are with pavel agreed to meet there, it was the last time we saw each other in the crimea there, thats why the drones. Ukrainian, it is the same beauty and strength as khrystyna yaskiv in our studio. Thank you, thank you ayder, very nice, and you also say that i am a military expert, he just mentioned about super drones, which maybe somewhere in the public space there was not enough information, but lets generally try to assess the military situation around the black sea, around the crimea with serhii bratchuk, the spokesman of the Ukrainian Volunteer Army, the south. Mr. Serhiy, congratulations, glory to ukraine. Hero, glory, glory to the armed forces, welcome to the studio. I will allow myself to begin with a very cautious piece of news that comes to us from the german bundestag. Yehor cherniev, peoples deputy of ukraine, reported yesterday that there was a vote on the recommendation to provide ukraine with longrange systems for point strikes deep in the rear of the russian aggressor. Cherniv says that we are talking about taurus, although, in my opinion, one could argue here whether this is exactly what the bundestag had in mind in its recommendations, but i will simply remind you that it is taurus that is now considered one of the main percussion forces that can inflict a truly tangible and longlasting effect. Hours of the kerch bridge, which remains the logistical artery of the russians to the crimea. Mr. Sergey, do you hope, in particular, for a similar type of weapon, or is it possible for you, in particular, as a person who already knows military affairs, another vision, what to do with the bridge . Well, what to do with the bridge, here we clearly have a common assessment, it is an illegal structure that must be destroyed. Demolished, who is so pleased, my ear is more pleased when we say that it is destroyed. Actually, if we are talking about taurus, of course, i dont want our viewers to understand that this is some kind of miraculous military toy that will appear on the battlefield and the war will immediately end. Well, first of all, indeed, we are talking about the fact that the recommendations were voted. I am like a person military, i always like the result, you know, i will compare it with the famous saying. Valery vasiliovych lobanovskyi that the game is forgotten, the result remains. Actually, i am talking about the result, about the fact that when the enemy feels the blows, including tauros , we will certainly be happy about it, we will certainly talk about it, and actually , you know, today i saw a lot, even, lets say, armed the menu, which is necessary to destroy the crimean bridge, well, first of all, they dont talk about it out loud, in fact, if they already said it, then there and. How much taurus are needed, how many atakams and so on and so on. Actually, i wouldnt be in such a hurry, first of all, because war is war, war is a cruel and serious matter, so no one will talk about it, how the bridge will be destroyed, but the most important thing is that it will be destroyed in time. And actually, returning to taurus, of course, we want them to be used as soon as possible, especially if we are talking about our native, temporarily occupied crimea, we understand very well that. We are talking not only about the bridge, we are talking about points management, command control points , we are talking about secret objects that are quite important in the system of the russian occupiers defense capability in the temporarily occupied territory of crimea, we are actually talking about the black sea fleet, which needs to be finished, there is actually a lot of work, so of course we dont need taurs harm , they will come in handy, because the command posts, and there are also underground ones, they must be destroyed and it would be a good weapon, but. Everything must be in a complex and the enemy himself must feel this work of these missiles, everything should be really integrated, and there must be drones, both heavy and light, which we are talking about, well, actually, as the saying is already known by now, there are not many drones, so we will wait for the result, we will wait for the votes there for the relevant decisions, including the chancellor of germany, but once again i want to remind the audience, perhaps and experts. Colleagues, including that no one will meet taurus at the border, for example, with the orchestra, they will start working, and then we will actually find out about it, this is absolutely correct, and if we are talking about our the sea is the enemy of course monitors that we may have something new there, and i hope that all of this in the complex will help us really bring the stage of demilitarization of crimea to a logical conclusion, it is happening today and we. We are talking about the fact that in crimea , in particular in the black sea, ukraine conducts offensive, i emphasize offensive actions, this is not a counteroffensive, a counteroffensive is a response to the corresponding offensive actions of the enemy, in the black sea we are attacking, and you can see that the rich arsenal that we have today is being used, about which we could only dream of in the 22nd year, and actually without exaggerated expectations, there is still a lot of work, there is a constant missile threat, missile carriers, they are in the sea, even in novorossiysk, there is a lot of work. But god willing, there will be taurus and everything else, and then we will meet in gurzuf, i agree and want to join you too. Oh , serhiy, i invite you, i even know approximately where, there is such a beautiful embankment, and the view is beautiful there, but lets be careful, because we already had people who wanted to drink coffee on the embankment, we still have to be more careful with our statements, we are now not about that, sergey listen to what i wanted to ask. Its not some kind of Wonder Weapon, so nothing is a Wonder Weapon in reality, and such expectations are a bit childish, but. Here, in principle , f16, multipurpose aircraft, which are not the ones that should change the course of the war, but at least, well, this week there was a meeting of the president , there was a bet dedicated to f 16 of them. The future application, the term of there delivery and the conditions of their service there, and i would like to hear from mr serhiy, what does the change in the situation along the front line look like in reality, and maybe behind it, and in connection with the fact that once again president zelensky actually said that dominance is in the air in russia. Will not be after, even local, after we receive these f16s and ours return our, our pilots, yes, but at the same time i read such information that russia has at its disposal a thousand, well there planes, fighters, there are attack planes, etc. , well , small ones, i dont mean transport ones, there are even more of them, together with them, but, that is we. Are not supplied with much, even if everyone, everything that is promised, will come and on time, and the service will be good, there will not be so much, as the russians, because, in what way do you think, sergey, we will master the air and squeeze the russians out of it, well, first of all, lets relieve the tension, im sure of that, again, without rushing ahead, everything should be and happen on the battlefield, in fact, then well see the results, the pressure. There will be russian aviation, they really have a lot of it, so the air force is doing a huge job, destroyed practically every day, if you take russian planes on average, and they are quite modern, quite powerful, so they have a lot of them, and even 710 destroyed planes there, unfortunately, do not fundamentally affect the situation with russian planes, but on the other hand were talking about the battle line, were talking about the fact that the cabs that are used, actually this well, two more trump cards actually in russia, of course, its aviation and its cannon fodder, theres a lot of it, its that russia uses, and thus pushes us out of our certain territories, that we are forced somewhere, as on the example of avdiyivka , to retreat to some other positions, and have tactical advances in other directions , unfortunately, including, again, this is without betrayal, here it is a war, the situation is dynamic, it changes, actually and literally. Including these minutes, pushing back enemy aviation, we reduce the pressure precisely with aviation weapons, precisely with those kabs that simply wipe out everything on the ground, hit our positions, and accordingly these are our losses, and in equipment, and the most important thing is people, and when there will be such parity, even if we are on we will approach him, these are the strikes of our aviation on the front edge of the enemy, i hope, these will also be strikes. A little deeper to the rear , lets say, base points, this is happening today, but this is not enough, and our pilots have proven air battles since 22, here, in particular in the south, that they can even on those old planes, of the soviets to destroy enemy pilots and enemy equipment in the sky, i hope it will be like that this time, it will still be easier, in any case , the direction is absolutely correct and it must be move, little, we need more , we need to be timely, this is the most important thing, so that the situation with artillery shells does not repeat itself, that the promises are empty , in fact, today we have, accordingly, an artillery famine in one direction or another, this is really a problem, well, what is the matter the generals took up, i am primarily talking about the general who is still performing his duties, in particular the president of the czech republic, peter pavel, he found the solution very quickly, or he has it. The body, lets say this, canada, as far as is known, will also give the money, will be funded and we will have more projectiles, at least now colleagues have calculated, which i also trust as experts, including that this amount will be enough for us there today, well, approximately 150, 160 days in order to defend ourselves, we are not talking about offensives now, these are overestimated expectations, it goes without saying that tomorrow we will receive these shells and be near moscow, unfortunately this will not happen, but actually there is a different situation. When there are a lot of military facilities on the territory of the Russian Federation, you can hit them, i am in general a strict supporter of the fact that they should be hit, actually i think, like you, there is an enemy. Even jen stoltenberg, secretary general of nato, says that if ukraine receives 16, then actually working on the territory of the Russian Federation is absolutely, as they say, legal for our country. It is absolutely true, and in fact, i am talking about this , so, well, you see, we and ensec of nato, as well as you, move our thoughts, at least in joint such movements, in a joint forward. Yes, mr. Serhiy, i still cant help but ask, in fact, such dubious information has appeared, which. The Ukrainian Military is already refuting, well, at least they say that they are not observing any superactivity there, the socalled transnistria, and this is february 28, when they supposedly, perhaps, should have turned to the Russian Federation, about joining there , you are a person who knows our ukrainian well, the odesa region, in particular, is so , that is, you and i have talked about it many times. Uh, why is this throwin, because it s actually just as much about the proximity to our black sea in general, about the situation uh, in the northwestern part of the black sea, about odesa, about our ukrainian south, why in your opinion, such information appears , and as far as it is possible, well, in my opinion , it is quite logical, strangely enough, and quite simple to explain it, these information throws to increase, again, the degree of information. Because , as far as the battlefield is concerned, we can see that the degree has already been raised to the maximum, by the way, i will now mention a certain dima medvedev, no matter how we treat him, we understand very well what is being voiced by his lips, in including putins thoughts and dreams, odessa was mentioned again, and again this topic of odessa, again transnistria, not recognized as an occupied territory of the republic of moldova. In fact, this level of information is increasing, i can even admit, although there are no such confirmations and our Main Intelligence Agency said about it that there will be a meeting of these deputies, it is unclear who they are there, thieves in law or so, that they will be there to make a decision to make, well, they will make decisions , they will shout there that putin will enter the army, i say on the contrary, we said in the 22nd year , please, there will be a landing on teraspil, how it will end, we understand perfectly well. We do not notice any special movements here in the south, in fact, to reassure everyone, my dear friends, you understand that from our side the situation is first under control, ukraine has enough forces and means to respond to any provocation, including armed react, and ukraine will act. To act within the framework of international law, this is also clear, and moldova also has a desire to resolve the issue with its temporarily occupied territories, how, this is an internal matter of the republic of moldova, but they have, i think, normal, adequate consultants who can tell you how to act and, most importantly, effectively, how effectively. Serhiy, servants, briefly , i will ask, dont you think that they are simply in this way, still diverting attention to. Whose command and simply keep us there to keep more, more troops, for example, i will answer very simply, but we understand that , including, uh, thank you, thank you very much, serhiy bratchuk, the spokesman of the Ukrainian Volunteer Army south, was in touch with us about the situation in the south of ukraine in general, a person who knows both crimea and the situation in the black sea well, i will only add that the enemy continues to use the north of our occupied peninsula for concentration of overturning. Ee forces to work on the front line in the south of the mainland in dzhankoya , the wagnerites were seen and we are very grateful to the atesh movement, which regularly informs us about rather interesting things and trends in the russian army, so they are partially integrated into it, there are also civil activists, public activists who covertly conduct surveillance, wagnerites in junkies regularly go to. To the front line, probably in order to mythically take the blame, this is what shaigu told putin himself, although i dont understand what this lie was for, listen, they live in their own world, you you will never understand this, because we welcome such lies, and there are such lies, in principle, maybe kherson was returned in this way, well, i mean, i really dont understand, im sorry, she still knows english, for sure. Uh, you cant, by the way, you cant, by the way, were following uh, lets say yes, according to the new norms of the law on language on television, and therefore we do not apply too much, exclusively ukrainian. And well, by the way, we will also mention the International Mother language day on february 21 after the break, but for now we will rest a little and give it to you. Greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. We have already approached the serpent himself. The following shots may shock you. News from the scene. Live drone attacks, kamikaze. Political analytics, objectively and meaningfully. No political season, exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest points of the front. Shot, svoboda life frankly and impartially. You draw your own conclusions. Verdict with serhiy rudenko, from now on in a new, twohour format. Even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests foreign experts, inclusion from abroad, about ukraine. The world is the front, society, and feedback. You can express your opinion on the bad day with a phone survey. Turn on and turn on. Verdict with Serhii Rudenko every weekday from 20 to 22 at espresso. Channel espresso and ukrainian pen present the project of their own names with myroslava barchuk. A series of conversations with ukrainian and western intellectuals who analyze and comment on the most pressing social issues. Discussions, what news will be analyzed by the guests of the project this week and, in fact, who will be the guest of the studio, we will find out already this sunday, clearly, the topics will be relevant, the guests will be special, their own names with myroslava barchuk. Sunday 17 10 at espresso. We continue the joint project of the tv channel and the atr tv channel together. Beraber we speak about the currently occupied crimea. Today we are talking about the second anniversary of the Russian Federations largescale invasion of ukraine. Today we are talking about the 10th anniversary of the actual start of Russias Armed aggression against ukraine. February 20, 2014. It all started with crimea. And on february 21, ukraine not only celebrates the International Mother language day, and for many people in our country , there is not only a mother tongue. Ukrainian language, for crimean tatar friends, is definitely crimean tatar language when we speak about crimea in general, it is important not to forget that the karaites and krymchaks are considered to be the Indigenous Peoples there, the preservation of their languages now actually requires maddening efforts, sometimes they, these efforts are made exclusively by that small, extremely small number of people who are representatives, well, we know we. It is a bitter truth to say that during the stay of crimea under the rule of the russian empire, the crimean people, well, to be honest, they are basically crimeanspeaking peoples, and the languages are very similar, there are nuances related to religious differences, and yes in principle, for example, a total of 25 people in the world know the karaite language, that is, in fact, it was actually killed, i read. A book, well, as i read, i saw a book in the ukrainian language, with latin graphics, and it is actually similar to the south coast dialect, or a variant crimean language, that is, i, unfortunately, have never read texts in the crimean language, but my grandmother has vosfia, who was 15 years old when they were exiled, well, they understood when and how, and yes. In the sovbazar, which now has for now i will call it biloghirsk, many karaites lived there, crimeans, crimeans, they lived together and they spoke, they didnt speak russian, that is , in big cities there was such a thing, in their small city they didnt, they communicated with each other in the crimean language, in fact it was the only one, as i say, only with some religious nuances, and to revive in principle, it is necessary, that is, the revival of the crimean language, this is the revival of the languages of the crimeans and the krymchaks. And here we just need to publish books that will mention some nuances, historical, cultural, cultural heritage, and most interestingly, what concerns the karaites through the peculiarities of the settlement of karaites in ukraine , in general, and i will remind you that the buildings of karaite cinemas can be found both in kyiv and in western ukraine, but the karaite language had both a crimean dialect and a galician dialect , and galician is considered virtually dead, unfortunately, but the crimean one is trying. Somehow keep the karaites