The record straight. Obviously our government will have to make reassess the relations with the you and also it coming up israels Prime Minister of feeling the heat as criticism grows over what he did before during and after the home off terror attacks. Ive been trusting ego and his political career and drives everything his ego and his legacy will reduce his legacy blood on his hands. Which of our viewers watching on tv, up to the United States and to all of you around the world . Welcome. We begin the day running of a fuel and running out of time, the human agency helping palestinians in gauze a warrant today that it may have to shut down parts of its operations if no fuel is allowed into the territory by the end of today, wednesday, fuel shortages are already taking a toll. The World Health Organization today confirmed that 12 of guns as hospitals are no longer open. Now that is a 3rd of all hospitals inside the territory. When dr. In gaza, put it in start terms of saying once the electricity stops his hospital will begin turning into a mass. Great. We have more now and this report relentless is really strikes on garza mean. Ever more people are trapped under the rubble. Healthcare stuff are working tirelessly, crushing injured palestinians to hospital with critical supplies, including shrouds for the dead are running low. Water pressure is so low. They are unable to operate. The central sterilization machine that we use for for several lives are a Surgical Equipment and the electricity keeps cutting out. And we were completely dependent on the fuel, which i understand is no longer coming in to, for when the doctors are under pressure to consider fuel for the generators that hospitals are now relying on a stripling into gaza. But israel is still looking fuel supplies, but they look as we are aware that thomas needs fuel, they needed badly for the military infrastructure after that. So all the fuel from going around and then it will discuss the issue of the fuel with the world. And if the hospitals are in peril across from us other 1st to on so much that how much resupplied the fuel to the hospitals and to the poor residents, the worlds must a month is from how much of the un is warning that without more fuel, it will have to hard, its a good work fuel is extremely urgent because without the fuel, the trash them go, cannot move without fuel. The generator is cannot produce electricity for hospitals, for bakeries, and for the water, the selling nation class. The white house is it is working to get fuel into gaza. The time is running out of my 1st guess. Tonight is the us diplomat. David hill. He is a former, under secretary of state for political affairs. He also served as the Us Ambassador to pakistan and 11 on and jordan, mister investor, its good to have you with this tonight. Lets talk about whats happening right now with the you. When the Un Security Council appears unable to pass a resolution calling for a ceasefire and gaza, israel is accusing the un security, or secretary general of justifying acts of terror by her moss. I want to ask you as a diplomat, how do you describe what is going on at the you with right now as well . It reminds me a little bit of the negotiations over a Security Council ceasefire in 2006, between israel and, and, and heres the law during the loving armoire. And, you know, whats important really isnt a piece of paper from the Security Council. Calling for certain steps, but actually whether the situation on the ground is going to provide an environment in which of the parties can somehow establish some stability and peace. And were not there yet. Um, you know, after the vicious attack by, im us on innocent israeli civilians is unrealistic to expect that israel just simply going to accept a series fire. Theyre going to need interview. And frankly, i would say objectively it is true to reestablish the terms and reestablish their ability to defend their country and theyre not there yet. And how do you see this impacting the possibility of negotiating of a full hostage release . We know were still talking about more than 200 people who are being held by him. Us. Yeah, i mean this of course is separate from the Security Council which, which is pretty much irrelevant, frankly, to, to that. Um, we and israel are, are working through contacts, which has relations, has come off with the wrong. And they have been able to produce the releases that weve seen so far. My suspicion is that, you know, youll see more releases. But this is designed by him. Us to sort of us to ease out slowly one by 12. 00 by 2. Perhaps the most vulnerable hostages, which is obviously a release to everyone to, to see see them liberated. But its really part of a strategy to maneuver against israel and to try to forestall the land defensive that we all expect to see the ground offensive that we all expect to see and gaza. See you as President Biden today . He called for a 2 state solution, also calling for settler violence to stop. It sounds like a reiteration of standing us policy. What should we read into it today . Yeah, thats right. I mean, no administration has deviated from those basic principles. Although President Trump uh, have a slightly different position to use whatever the parties can agree to. Its fine to make those statements. Thats fine to have those objectives. The question really is, what is the realistic path forward given the state of place since october 7th, and even before october 7 to the 2 state solution. Neither side pulsed in, nor is rarely has really invested seriously in an effort to reach that outcome. And their publics are cynical and skeptical, frankly, on both sides. That there is a big, viable path to a 2 state outcome. How would you grade us credibility right now in the region be they are those who point to us policy in the middle east, israel and the palestinians, and say that, you know, the u. S. Has largely been missing now for the past 10 years. Um, how credible is the us right now as well . I would, i would challenge the statement that weve been missing. We may not have been doing things that certain actors want us to do. But the abraham, of course, was a major historic breakthrough in relations between nerve states in europe, states and israel. So i, i wouldnt accept the, what has been missing is a realistic path toward resolving the issues that the palestinians face. And thats a long, complicated story that i dont think we can good tackle in a sound bite. And then that again, i, you know, i personally move involved and much of this and a key moments. Both sides ran away from opportunities United States offered. I dont think the us wants to ever walk away from being able to play a constructive role in bringing these parties together and establishing peace. But we cant deliver things that those leaders themselves dont wish to achieve. Do you, do you think there is some validity . There to the statement that the us had had reduced or shifted in its focus in the last few years. I mean, weve talked a lot about the pivot to asia for us foreign policy. And then youve also had the russian invasion of ukraine. Did the events on october 7th, you know, forced the United States to re focus on israel and the palestinians . Well, i never liked the phrase the, this. Obviously, china is the significant geostrategic challenge for United States. But thats a global challenge, and its not just about the pacific. Important as it is that when we re re prioritize and make sure that we have the military assets, we need to deter an attack on taiwan or an ensure the freedom of navigation in the south china seas. But the competition stopped and it includes the middle east. We need to make sure it china is not explaining the situation. And im also struck that all the parties in the middle east, at the moment of crisis like this. They look to washington and they dont look elsewhere. And finally, our own interests are at stake, our energy interest, global energy, market stability, our friendship with israel and with key arrow partners are values of anti terrorism. All of this is at stake in the middle east. We cant walk away from it, and unfortunately if we try to, we are minded at moments like this that thats not an option before the events of october 7th, the binding administration had been clear and its criticisms of netanyahus push to reform is religious tradition. Gary netanyahu, who was being called on the police, not a friend of the system of checks and balances, considering that is he now is he still a credible partner for the United States is always the Prime Minister of israel. So we dont stop for us to choose i, you know, ive seen every president during the night and you know, it was 10 year of close dealing with him and hes the israeli Prime Minister. American presence left the hate. But he selected time and time again. He will face accountability after whats happened once this cam pain is over and i suspect hes, hes going to have some difficulties, but its not for us to choose. And i was uncomfortable, whatever. Wherever you stand on the traditional question in israel, im uncomfortable when i see american officials to try to dictate to foreign officials. Mom should have democracy. How to conduct their parents or do you get the feeling that the binding ministration, secretary st. Anthony, blinking that there has been an attempt somewhat to to least set a guard rails for israel to stay with then considering whats going on. Well, in my experience, since Ronald Reagan and the seizure of a root and the big blow ups that he had but knocking big and most american presence of trying to avoid being a position of advising is rarely officials about military tactics. And sometimes israel to defend itself, we provide our friend the support they need, but not dictating the charge, the, the, the military decisions that they have to make because they dont want to own them. Thats for them. I do says that the President Biden is leading a bit forward compared to the past, and i think its, its a responsible thing for an american president asked questions you know, whats next or after this operation occurs, as it appears to be the, the plan for ground operation, whats next . Uh, what are the, whats a realistic set of objectives for this campaign because were together going to have to be dealing with the fall out from. Yeah, i think a lot of people um in the middle east and on both sides of the atlantic or posing that very question um, what is next investor, david hill, investor, we appreciate your time and your analysis tonight. Thank you. Thank you very much united these really government to any particular its Prime Minister are facing growing criticism over there. Handling of the aftermath of her mazda is terrorist attacks is really media reporting that benjamin that yahoo is at odds with his more cabinet in military generals. In the past weeks, weve seen the Prime Minister visiting troops across israel, especially the forces massing on these really gone to border ahead of unexpected ground invasion. But sources that cited by is really media claimed that there was a growing displeasure at his refusal to engage with military leaders. And thats in the all who have so far refrained from admitting that he made any mistakes before during and after the attacks by him us. Tonight we solve the 1st public show of self reflection. And, you know, whos saying that everyone will have to explain themselves, including himself as a basically citizens of israel. She bob october, the 7th was a blank, they are not history. We will get to the bottom of what happens on the southern boulder around casa. They step back a will be investigated. Everyone will have to give answers, including maintenance, the whole of the 2 vote. Gum i need. If a more now i want to bring in the ws minis, analyst ashanti was honest. So the very self aware benjamin netanyahu. Tonight, we know that the Prime Minister has come under criticism. Did he deliver the message that these really people may have been expecting . Well, 220 families of hostages were expecting to hear something about the hostages. That did not happen, but he did bring himself to as close as i think we will ever get from him to here. I am as responsible, i apologize. I take responsibility for what happened. He said, its clear to him this, this has been a great failure and theres going to be a lot of hard questions to be asked. And he will be amongst those to be answering them. So thats close enough for many israelis. And we need to keep in mind this be 19 days the penny. Oh has not have a single press conference. Hes not facing the journalist. Hes not pressing the facing the press. So hes not really answering the questions yet. Yeah. Um, so far he has support, but if he understands that he cannot last for too long, the military leaders in his real quickly acknowledged their failure to protect is released after october 7th. And he has there been any admission of political responsibility for the security failures on october 7th . Well, if you want to focus on the security failures, thats very easy for the politicians. You know, to, to put this as a feeler of intelligence, the army, thats a very safe spot for politicians. But there is of course, the need within is really probably to look at the broader picture. What role the politicians have in their deeds in securing or not securing and, and striving or not striving towards a political solution to the pasting. And the problem towards, you know, negotiating backdoor deals through, caught, are we come us, you know, this is something done by the political a, you know, a level and not by only by, by the military. So in that aspect, um, we have not seen enough of the political backbone of israel to stepping up and saying, you know, well to have that at a stake and in this failure. The consensus now is lets 1st fight and then deal with everything else. But its also is were learning that this fight will take very long time. And theres also an understanding that may be harder. Questions still need to pop up before hand and received a former chief of staff of the Israel Defense forces saying that that and yahoo should resign. Now. Others saying that the government is dysfunctional. I mean its, its not a pretty picture. I mean, what do we know about the views of active military leaders in israel . Acts of an entirely or are silent. We know about some risk regarding operational issues. For example, the ground up are, you know, invasion. Is it coming . What is coming . Should we have more uh, human terminate coming in or less, but when it comes to nothing else political future, we dont hear anything of that sort. Um we do hear amongst electricians. Even from that and the i was party, more and more voices saying it is clear that he will not be able to stay much longer in his position once the fighting is gone. But its still yet to be seen if they will live up to that or where will hit the kid. And weve seen that to know is masterful in finding his way out or even from the most our crisis or you think youll survive this more. I think this, the chances are very slim, but i also think that we all know too good in order to be too quick to say that he will not be able to survive. Thats very good for, i mean, hes been reading off too many times before. Let me ask about a biddy guns. He is a member of this emergency unity government and he is a man with a lot of military experience. All right, is he crucial to this . Were having a successful in he is crucial. I mean, the, the right wing of a parts of mr. Know, i always government, they say, well, hes part of the conception that failed. But then we, he is quite crucial because this is what we do. And we look at the americans, you know, blink, and did not make it to israel before the unit. The government was announced. Netanyahu had, you know, enlarging, the government has helped to gain the credibility from the people. But also from a big i like the us, we know that when blinking was around and he was sitting with the cabinet at the unity ministers, it was important for him to include them in the picture. We know that theyre present as a more moderate balancing act. In and thats in the Us Government is very, very important in that aspect of getting control, you know, getting support for the 20th and the, ill extra the, how much of these, these problems would you say go back pre october 7th, and im thinking about that. And yahoo, pushing for these judicial reforms, lot of people, critics, even the binding ministration, saying hes attacking the checks and balances system of government. Well, the voices within israel, its still in the margin saying that the, the enemy that im us saw the fragility of these really society and started can take advantage of it and we have seen it was quite successful. There are these voices so far still in the margins but, but its it and weve seen a, an unbelievable unity among we know from all ranks from old orthodox and app as well as everybody joining in, in these crucial moments in this term. You know, facing this, this attack, but we also know this will not list for too long. You know, uh the visions are already starting to come, you know, to the surface when it comes to the hostages, when it comes to the mentoring crisis, when it comes to policy. And then, you know, the hawks will remain hawks that does. The reno was paid ups and ends now is as a hawk, and hes surrounded by hawks shiny rules. Honest, as always, we appreciate you coming in. We appreciate your analysis. Thank you. Youre welcome. Here in germany, the cabinet has approve the draft bill to speed up the d port taishan of Asylum Seekers whose applications have been rejected. Germanys government is under pressure to tighten the asylum rules as the number of refugees, cloth. The interior minister, nancy phase, has taken the next step toward her goal of toughening germanys immigration rules. Her new draft to bill approved on wednesday 6 to make it easier and faster to deport people who are still in the country, despite not having the legal right to say. For example, because there was silent request was rejected. The feeling in the government is that the Current System desperately needs work and as an added burden to german, hes overwhelmed immigration system. Last year, all thirties failed to carry out 2 thirds of the around 36000. 00 plan deportations on the way in order to protect the fundamental rights to assign them. We must significantly limit irregular migration because those who dont have the right to state must leave our country to fill up the number of repub creations, the series already around 20000 percent taiyah and the same period last year. But there is still an urgent need for action. Comes on stuff. The people can currently be held in pre deportation, custody for up to 10 days. The plan is to extend this to 28. 00 days to allow all stories more time to repair. Police would also have greater access to a persons accommodation or phone, making it easier to confirm their identity and carry out the deportation. The government also wants to accelerate the expulsion of convicted smugglers and possibly the most controversial proposal. Members of organized crime groups could be reported even if they have not been convicted of a crime as already occurs for members of terrace groups. Experts, question whether the measures will actually have an effect the likely increase deportations of this, but i think its not going to be a game changer. Because like i said, the main reason why the dupont ations failed is the lack of corporations with countries of origins and the absence of, of legal documents in here. Its hard to, to make big changes. Parts of the governing coalition, like some members of the green party, but especially migrant and refugee are going to z ations. See the propose changes as being too severe. They ask whether the measures would even be legal, saying they are at least legally questionable. Its not unconstitutional. Well, im doing here by raphael, both song, hes a political scientist at the German Institute for international and security affairs, or mr. Both on what do you think the German Government felt that it had to do what it did or the cabinet had to do what it just it . Well this has been in the making for some time. Its the result of some consultations between the federal level and the lender level and the committed the regional states that have to actually deal with the documentation. So they asked in pressuring the government to bring the numbers down to have a more sort of restrictive implementation. And this has been discussed for several times, like over the summer and now its out in the open and politically. Obviously the top level leadership, including the sean slapping on the increasing pressure to signal that things are changing. Some critics of this new law say that its unconstitutional. I dont think you can say that in this blanket terms. There are various provisions that can be discussed and that are maybe borderline jail as well. For example, for what reasons can you be held at attention like do you need a reason . The proportion is the last measure for long . Or can you be given there sort of a sort of decision to leave just because you are a member of a potential criminal organizations. Youre not a convicted criminal, so theyre all lose come as part of that progression dollar. She questions that have to be resolved, but i think its not overall as a law, you can say its going to far. Do you think were seeing this, this new legislation being suggested or being talked about because of what weve been seeing with Political Parties right now weve been seeing the rise of the far right. If the, the alternative for germany and weve got a new party now a new left just party, which will have an anti immigration platform. While obviously this is the pressure i was talking about. Um, but we also have to say, i mean there are some fanatic useful things in there, but it is mostly political signal because even with his law, if its implemented, its going to probably increase it only by a few 100 people that are going to report and were talking with hundreds of thousands of people in germany, so it really is this kind of atmosphere that theyre trying to serve. And yes, obviously you have on the right, but also on some very conservative left now. Yeah, actors say we have to protect the well for state are, are they, are they the arguments valley you hear voters saying that the Current System of deportations is not working, that you have people here. Theyve been rejected as Asylum Seekers and yet theyre not being deported. While the answer is actually rather complex, i mean, this is an issue that any country really faces in the west. I mean, look at the us, look at also other countries with very, right . When governments, initially they all have troubles to really, you know, have a one on one. Everybody has to leave the country, leave the country, know. So having said that, um, obviously they also administrative things that it can be tightened. That can be made more efficient in germany, but it is only a relative improvement on we always have to live with the fact that there was a gap between this kind of formal legal claim and then individual circumstances why you copy to ported. Why is not proportion thats available song as always, we appreciate your time, appreciate you coming in the night. Thank you. Welcome. As well, the day is almost done, the conversation continues online. Youll find us on the x also known as twitter. Either in the w news, you can follow me a print off cv, and remember what ever happens between now and then tomorrow is another day. Well see you then everybody, the lithium from germany, Vulcan Energy resources wants to use Geothermal Energy to mind. This pressure with white gold and for the 1st time, anywhere in the world and automaker hold deep in a lithium company. In germany, on its way to engine you dependency on rob resources made in germany next on d w, neighborhood assistance instead of in some sense, especially my town north of paris, jews, muslims, and christians live peacefully side by side. Yet what consequences do the terrorist attacks by how much tab pull the co existence in friends, concerns about isnt mr tax growing focused on us being 60 minutes on the w, the de sac rubble. Oh its from kids. Do you see in the middle of the dasha, because im such a organizing reconstruction to the new houses and renewed us. Its getting cold. The rates of holding sign and the volunteers will winter Season Mission kids particular seeing rebuild jobs, move indices, dw, the, the hollywood actors have been striking since mid july. And what is become the industrys most historic strike and an end doesnt appear to be insight. Now thats the spite actors wanting to negotiate with tv and production studios. But what is the strike really about . Were going to answer that in this edition of made dw business magazine. And here