A round innovation there was a time when our country believed in science and invested in research and development so that we were in the innovation leader on the globe joe biden will use that money to invest in education so for example for folks who want to go to your Community College it will be free if you come from a family that makes less than 125000. 00 youll go to a Public University for free and across the board will make sure that if you have Student Loan Debt its cut by 10000. 00 thats how joe biden thinks about the economy which is about investing in the people of our country as opposed to passing a tax bill which had the benefit of letting american corporations go offshore to do their business. Thank you senator harris Vice President since your administration has been predicting a rapid and robust recovery but the latest economic report suggests thats not happening should americans be braced for an economic comeback that is going to take not months but a year or more you have 2 minutes to answer uninterrupted unfrozen driven i took Office America going through the slowest economic recovery since the Great Depression. When joe biden was Vice President they tried to tax and spend and regulate and bail our way back to a growing economy President Trump cut taxes across the board despite what senator harris says the average American Family of 4 had 2000. 00 in savings in taxes and with the rise in wages that occurred most predominantly for blue collar hardworking americans the average Household Income for a family of 4 increased by 4000. 00 following president terms tax cuts but america you just heard senator harris tell you on day one joe bidens going to raise your taxes its really remarkable the things that that i mean right after a time where were going through a pandemic that lost 22000000 jobs at the height weve already added back 11600000 jobs because we had a president who cut taxes rolled back regulation unleashed American Energy fought for free and fair trade and secured 4 trillion dollars from the congress of the United States to give direct payments to families say 50000000 jobs through the Paycheck Protection Program we literally have spared no expense to help the American People in the American Worker through this joe biden and kamel harris want to raise taxes they want to bury our economy under a 2 trillion dollar Green New Deal which you were one of the original cosponsors of in the United States senate they want to abolish fossil fuels and ban fracking which would cost hundreds of thousands of american jobs all across the heartland and joe biden wants to go back to the economic surrender to china that when we took office half of our International Trade deficit was with china alone and joe biden wants to repeal all of the tariffs the president trying to put into effect to fight for american jobs and American Workers joe biden says democracies on the ballot make no mistake about it susan in the American Economy the american comeback is on the ballot with 4 more years of growth thank you and opportunity in 4 more years of. Isnt donald trump 2020 when you heard the president s economic year in the history of this country thank you best president pence senator harris well i mean i thought that we saw enough of it and last weeks debate but i think this is supposed to be a debate based on fact and truth and the truth and the fact is joe biden has been very clear he will not raise taxes on anybody who makes less than 400000 youre going to hear people the trump tax credits mr Vice President speaking well im speaking be important as you said the truth joe biden says twice in the debate last week that hes going to repeal the trump tax cuts that was church votes that gave the average working family 2000. 00 in a tax break every single you had senator that is asked the hourly not true that is the only going to repeal part of the trump talks because if you dont mind letting me finish we can have a conversation ok ok joe biden will not raise taxes on anyone who makes less than 400000. 00 a year he has been very clear about that joe biden will not end fracking he has been very clear about that. Joe biden is the one who during the Great Recession was responsible for the recovery act that brought america back and now the trump hence administration wants to take credit when they ran when they rode the court coattails of joe biden success for the economy that they had at the beginning of their term of course now the economy is a complete disaster but joe biden on the one hand did that on the other hand you have donald trump. Who has reigned over a recession that is being compared to the Great Depression on the one hand you have joe biden who was responsible with president barack obama for the Affordable Care act which brought health care to over 20000000 americans and protected people with preexisting conditions and what it also did is it saved to those families who otherwise were going bankrupt because of hospital bills they could not afford on the other hand you have donald trump whos in court right now trying to get rid of he said trying to get rid of the Affordable Care act which means that you will lose protections if you have preexisting conditions and i just this is very important yes and its a that we need to give if we need to have eyes for just like he interrupted me and id like to just finish please if you have a preexisting condition Heart Disease diabetes Breast Cancer theyre coming for you if you love someone who has a preexisting condition and you think you see how many are you if you are under the age of 26 on your parents coverage theyre coming for you senator harris thank you for what i mean give you a chance to respond but i hope we have a chance to talk about health care because obamacare was a disaster the American People remember well the President Trump and i have a plan to prove health care and for present protect preexisting conditions for every american look senator harris youre youre trying to do your own opinion but youre not entitled to your own facts you yourself said on multiple occasions when you were running for president that you would ban fracking. Joe biden looked a supporter in the eye and pointed and said i guarantee i guarantee that we will abolish fossil fuels we have a 2 trillion dollar version of the Green New Deal susan that your newspaper usa today said really wasnt that very dear different from the original Green New Deal more taxes more regulation banning fracking abolishing fossil fuel crushing American Energy and economic surrendered should china is a prescription for an economic decline President Trump and i will keep america growing the v. Shaped recovery thats underway right now will continue with 4 more years of President Donald Trump with a thank you very very much Vice President has once again youve provided the perfect segue to a new topic which is Climate Change and Vice President pence id like to pose the 1st question to you this year weve seen record setting hurricanes in the south another one hurricane delta is now threatening the gulf and we have seen record setting wildfires in the west do you believe as the Scientific Community has concluded that manmade Climate Change has made wildfires bigger hotter and more deadly and it made hurricanes wetter slower and more damaging you have 2 minutes uninterrupted thank you susan 1st im very proud of our record on the environment on conservation according to all of the best estimates are our air and land are cleaner than any time ever recorded more water is among the cleanest in the world and just a little while ago the president signed the outdoors act as if the largest investment in our public lands and public parks. In a 100 years so President Trump has made a commitment to conservation and to the environment now with regard to Climate Change the climate is changing but the issue is whats the cause and what do we do about it present troubles made it clear that were going to continue to listen to the science now joe biden and kamel harris would put us back in the Paris Climate Accord theyd impose the Green New Deal which would crush American Energy would increase the energy costs of American Families in their homes and literally would crush american jobs and President Trump and i believe that the progress that we have made in a cleaner environment has been happening precisely because we have a strong free market economy you know whats remarkable is the United States has reduced c o 2 more than the countries that are still in the Paris Climate Accord but weve done it through innovation and weve done it through natural gas and fracking which senator the American People can go look at the record i know joe biden says otherwise now as you do with the both of you repeatedly committed to abolishing fossil fuel and banning fracking and so by creating the kind of American Innovation were actually steering toward a stronger and better environment with regard to wildfires and President Trump and i believe the Forest Management has to be front and center and even governor Gavin Newsome from your state has agreed weve got to work on Forest Management and with regard to hurricanes the National Oceanic administration tells us that actually is as difficult as they are and your best visit there are no more hurricanes today than there were 100 years ago thank you but many of the climate a lot of as a very canes and wildfires to try and think you guys will have to have a Green New Deal and President Trump and are going to always putting her job as their workers 1st senator harris. As the Vice President mentioned you cosponsored the Green New Deal in congress but Vice President biden said in last weeks debate that he does not support the green deal but if you look at the Biden Harris Campaign website it describes the Green New Deal as a crucial framework what exactly would be the stance of a Biden Harris Administration toward the Green New Deal you have 2 minutes uninterrupted for so 1st of all i will repeat and the American People know. That joe biden will not ban fracking that is a fact that is a fact i will repeat that joe biden has been very clear that he thinks about growing jobs which is why he will not increase taxes for anyone who makes less than 400000. 00 a year joe bidens economic plan movies which is a reputable wall street firm has said will create 7000000. 00 more jobs then Donald Trumps and part of those jobs that will be created by joe biden are going to be about clean energy and Renewable Energy because you see joe understands that the west coast of our country is burning including my home state of california joe sees what is happening in the gulf states which are being battered by storms joe has seen and talked with the farmers in iowa whose entire crops have been destroyed because of floods and so joe believes again in science ill tell you something susan i searched when i 1st got to the senate on the committee thats responsible for the environment do you know this administration took the word science off the website. And then took the phrase Climate Change off the web site this we have seen a pattern with this administration which is they dont believe in science and joes plan is about saying were going to deal with it but were also going to create jobs donald trump when asked about the wildfires in california and the question was you know the science is telling us this you know adama from set science doesnt know so lets talk about who is prepared to lead our country over the course of the next 4 years on what is an excess central threat to us as human beings joe is about saying were going to invest that in noble energy was going to be about the creation of millions of jobs we will achieve net 0 emissions by 2050 Carbon Neutral by 2035 joe has a plan this is been a lot of talk from the Trump Administration and really it has been to go backward instead of forward we will also react to the climate agreement with pride so mr harris just said that Climate Change is an existential threat Vice President pence jubilee the Climate Change poses an existential threat this is it says in the climate is changing will follow the science but once again senator harris. Is denying the fact that theyre going to raise taxes on every american joe biden said twice in the debate last week that on day one he was going to repeal the trump tax cuts those tax cuts delivered 2 1000. 00 in tax relief to the average family of 4 Cross America and with regard to banning fracking i just recommend that people look at the record you yourself said repeatedly that you would ban fracking you were the 1st senate cosponsor of the Green New Deal and while joe biden denied the Green New Deal susan thank you for pointing out the Green New Deal is on their Campaign Website and as usa today said its essentially the same plan as you cosponsored with a o c when she submitted it in the senate and you just heard the senator say that shes going to resubmit america to the Paris Climate Accord look that the American People have always cherished our environment will continue to cherish and weve made great progress reducing c o 2 emissions through American Innovation and the development of natural gas through fracking we dont need a massive 2 trillion dollar Green New Deal that would impose all new mandates on american businesses and American Families thank you joe biden wants to sink retrofit 4000000 thank you Vice President s buildings it makes no sense it will cost jobs President Trump thank you the president urkel 1st hes going to put jobs 1st and were going to take care of our environment and follow the science same thing that is you know obvious of job senator here lets talk about that you did the Vice President earlier referred to it as part of it what he thinks is an accomplishment that the president s trade war with china he lost that trade war you lost it what ended up happening is because of a socalled trade war with china america lost 300000 manufacturing jobs. Farmers have experienced bankruptcy because of it we are in a manufacturing recession because of it and when we look at where this administration has been there are estimates that by the end of the term of this is ministration they will have lost more jobs than almost any other president ial administrations and the American People know what im talking about you know i think about 20 year olds you know we have a 20 year old. 20 something year old who are coming out of high school in college right now and youre wondering is there going to be a job there for me were looking at people who are trying to figure out how theyre going to pay rent by the end of the month almost half of American Renters are worried about whether theyre going to be able to pay rent by the end of the month this is where the economy is in america right now and it is because of the catastrophe and the failure of leadership of this is ministration thank you senator harris Vice President can somebody give just 15 seconds to respond because then i want to move on to will love to respond look last to fred war with china joe biden never fought it. Your bud has been a cheerleader for communist china through over the last several decades and again some are hers your title your opinion youre not entitled to your own facts joe biden was Vice President we lost 200000 manufacturing jobs and president obama said they were never coming back he said we needed a magic wand to bring them back in our 1st 3 years after we could make you very best regulation unleashed American Energy this administration saw 500000 a Vice President jobs created and thats exactly the kind of growth were going to continue to see as we bring our nation through thank you very soon demick visited renewed a deal you guys massive have mandates repairs climate accord its going to kill jobs this time just like it killed jobs i dont i just respond very tightly lefties seconds and a few moving cue joe biden is responsible for saving americas Auto Industry and you foetid against it so lets set the record straight thank you and id like to talk about china we have as our next topic we have no more complicated our consequential foreign relationship than the one with china it is a huge market for american agricultural goods its a potential partner in dealing with Climate Change in north korea and in a video tonight President Trump again blamed it for the coronavirus saying china will pay Vice President pence how would you describe our our fundamental relationship with china competitors adversaries enemies you have 2 minutes there to susan well let me before greg leave that let me let me speak to voting records if i can you know Everybody Knows that nafta cost literally thousands of american factories to close we saw automotive jobs go south of the border President Trump fought to renegotiate nafta in the United States mexico Canada Agreement is now the law of the land American People deserve to know. Senator kamel harris was one of only 10 members of the senate to vote against the u. S. And cia it was a huge win for American Auto workers it was a huge win for American Farmers especially dairy in the upper midwest but senator you you said it didnt go far enough on Climate Change that you put your your radical environmental agenda ahead of American Auto workers and ahead of american jobs that the American People deserve to know that is probably why Newsweek Magazine said that kamel harris was the most liberal member of the United States senate and 29000 more liberal than Bernie Sanders more more liberal than any of the others in the United States senate so now with regard to china. Susan 1st and foremost china is to blame for the crime of arms in prison and trump is not happy about it hes made that very clear made it clear again today that china and the World Health Organization do not play straight with the American People. We did not let our personnel in the china to get information on the coronavirus until the middle of february fortunately President Trump in dealing with china from the outset of the summits rouge and standing up to china that have been taking advantage of america for decades in the wake of joe bidens cheerleading for china President Trump made that decision before the end of january to suspend all travel from china and again the murder people deserve no joe biden oppose President Trumps to sit and suspend all travel from china he said it was a stair release it thank you nice filled with him its a present from president s other times im going to continue to stand strong q Vice President we want to improve the relationship but were going to level the Playing Field were going to hold china and countable for what they did to america with the Coronavirus Thank you senator heres somebody ask you the same question that i asked the Vice President how would you describe our fundamental relationship with china or are we competitors adversaries enemies will have 2 minutes uninterrupted citizen the Trump Administrations perspective and approach to china has resulted in the loss of american lives american jobs and americas standing theres a weird obsession that President Trump has had with getting rid of whatever accomplishment was achieved by president obama and Vice President biden for example they created within the white house an office that basically was responsible for monitoring pandemics they got away they got rid of it not true there was a team of disease experts that president obama and Vice President biden dispatched to china to monitor what is now predictable and what might happen they pull them out. We now are looking at 210000 americans who have lost their lives lets look at the job situation we mentioned before the trade deal the trade war they wanted to call it with china it resulted in the loss of over 300. 00 manufacturing jobs and a manufacturing recession and the American Consumer paying thousands of dollars more for goods because of that failed war that they called it and lets talk about standing pew a Reputable Research firm has done an analysis that shows that leaders of all of our formerly allied countries have now decided that they hold in greater is steamin respect paying the head of the Chinese Communist party than they do donald trump the president of the United States the commander in chief of the United States this is where we are today because of a failure of leadership by this administration senator harris weve seen changes in the in the role of the United States in terms of Global Leadership over the past 4 years and to of course times do change should definition weve seen strains with china of course as the Vice President mentioned weve seen strange with our traditional allies in nato and elsewhere what is your definition of the role of American Leadership in 2020 so you know joe of i love talking with joe about a lot of these issues and you know joe i think you said it quite well he says you know Foreign Policy it might sound complicated but really its relationships just think about it as relationships and so we know this in our personal professional relationship you gotta keep your word to your friends now be loyal to your friends people who have stood with you gotta stand with them youve got to know who your adversaries are and keep them in check. But what we have seen with donald trump is that he has betrayed our friends and beatrice and embraced dictators around the world lets take for example russia so russia i serve on the Intelligence Committee of the United States senate Americas Intelligence Community told us russia interfered in the election of the president United States in 2016 and this plane in 2020 Christopher Ray the director of the f. B. I. Said the same but donald trump the commander in chief of the United States of america prefers to take the word of lattimer putin over the word of the american Intelligence Community you look at our friends at nato has walked away from agreements you can talk look at the Iran Nuclear Deal which now has put us in a position where we are less safe because they are building up what might end up being a significant Nuclear Arsenal we were in that deal guys we were in the Iran Nuclear Deal with friends with allies around the country and because of Donald Trumps unilateral approach to Foreign Policy coupled with his isolationism. He pulled us out and has made america less safe the sousa its about relationships and the thing that has always been part of the strength of our nation in addition to our great military has been that we keep our word but donald trump doesnt understand that because he doesnt understand what it means to be honest thank you thank you thank you senator harris the Vice President and some of you tends to respond well thank you will present from kept his word when we move the American Embassy to jerusalem the capital of the state of israel with joe biden as Vice President and they promise to do that than ever did we stood strong with our allies but weve been demanding nato is now contributing more to our common defense than ever before thanks to President Trumps leadership we strengthen our alliances across the asia pacific and weve stood strong. Against those who would do us harm you know when president from came into office isis had captured an area of the middle east the size of pennsylvania the President Trump unleashed the American Military and our armed forces destroyed the isis caliphate and took down their leader al baghdadi without one american casualty now baghdadi was responsible for the death of solace and. The notably americans hearts there with the family of killing nearly repair and switch are here with us tonight in Salt Lake City today 2 of the nicest killers responsible for killing millers murder were brought to justice in the United States you had a john was killed on the battlefield along with the other beatle the reality is that when joe biden was Vice President we had an opportunity to save carolyn miller. Brig smart to reflect on about the military came into the oval office presented a plan the so they knew were calleigh was dead he had held it for 18 months abused her mercilessly before they killed her but when joe biden was Vice President they has a tainted for a month when armed forces finally went in it was clear shed been moved 2 days earlier and her family says with a heart that broke the heart of every american that is President Donald Trump had been president they believe kayla would be alive today thank you guys already destroyed the isis caliphate. And you talk about reentering the Iran Nuclear Deal in the last administration transferred 1800000000 dollars to the leading state sponsor thank you very of terrorism President Donald Trump got us out of the database president and when qassam solomonic was traveling to baghdad thank you very strong arm to americans President Donald Trump to thank you guys didnt head in america is is safer our allies are safer and the American People know President Donald Trump will never hank you Vice President take action i would like to have senator harris suggest chance to respond but not at such great length because of course there are other topics we want to talk about i would like equal time yes thank you for him. First of all to the Miller Family that i know about your daughters case and im so sorry im so sorry. What happened to her is awful and it should have never happened and i know joe feels the same way and i know that president obama feels the same one. But you mentioned sawney lets lets start there so after the strike on somani there was a counter strike on our troops in iraq and. They suffered serious brain injuries and you know what donald trump dismissed the hmas headaches and this is about a pattern of Donald Trumps where he has referred to our men who are serving in our military as suckers and losers donald trump who went to Arlington Cemetery and stood above the graves of our Fallen Heroes and said whats in it for them because of course you know he only thinks about whats in it for him lets take what he said about john mccain a Great American hero and donald trump says he doesnt deserve to be called a hero because it was a prisoner of war take and this is this is very important when you want to talk about who is the current commander in chief and what they care about and what they dont care about public reporting that russia have bounties on the heads of american soldiers and you know what a bounty is its somebody puts a price on your head and they will pay if you are killed and donald trump had talked at least 6. 00 times of lattimer putin and never brought up the subject joe biden would never do that thank you oh biden would joe biden you know what hold russia to account for any threats to our nations security or to our troops who are sacrificing their lives for the sake of our democracy and our say thank you senator here is this is such an important issue but we have other important issues as well and i want to i want to make sure we have a chance to really have talk about all of that and look she has