Transcripts For DW DocFilm 20240713

Epitome of insecurity germanys minister for energy facing a crowd of protesting students drowned out by their shouting he turns back and snaps at his staff this was a terrible idea. Nearly 2 years in is the grand Coalition Just Getting Started or is it already on its way out how can the government think its getting everything right and yet have a reputation of getting it all wrong. Does the grand coalition have the capacity to deal with the pressing issues of our time. You could say that the s. P. D. N. C. D. Use current course is going to destroy our lives and our future. Why is distrust towards the government growing. C. D. U. Has suffered losses in s. P. D. Has dropped sharply. Its just that i think that its in our best interest that part of this play stay standing. Last wednesday lets leave the grand coalition. 2018 at the beginning was anything but magical negotiations for the Jamaica Coalition between the conservatives liberals and greens had failed and so the center left s. P. D. And the conservative c. D. U. C. S. U. Union decided to share power again they were worn out from endless disputes. This fish this this is a cause or could this is true that neither the s. P. D. Nor the c. D. U. That really wanted this grand coalition to do with this grand coalition was never grand from the beginning it was a union of election loses on those least issue but so i cant really say i was ever completely convinced by this government or that this was the right way to go he has been reason i know how much theyre suffering from this and its not good for the s. P. D. Party to see but i find the fact that they stepped up because the other parties including my own hadnt managed to form a coalition quite honorable and have given nobody wanted to do it but they did it anyway just now and i suppose thats what you call public service. In the summer of 2018 horse to say whole foot became the prime mover in a crisis that nearly toppled the 3 month old government hed been opposing chancellor merkels refugee policies for years then he became interior minister and so board joint responsibility for those very same policies. You can you know believe i went to berlin at the chancellors request at the o 2 that i could have gone directly from being the state premier of the very into retirement. That instead of all things right from the start i became deeply embroiled with the chancellor over her migration policy since because for me personally it was a very troubling experience for me. Up until who would come out on top the chancellor or the interior minister they were squabbling over one seemingly small detail can refugees whove already registered in other e. U. Member states be turned away at germanys borders germans are surprised how divided the government is is by chicago and it didnt happen as well in the parliamentary faction and the Party Leaders in bavaria as well as the members of parliament in berlin were all pushing me with resolutions excuse. I did nothing to enforce this idea of turning people away at the border even as a minister without approval of the chancellor its minister only its thats what i was called upon to do because those what the 040. It wasnt the coalition that was granted so much as the drama that ensued in berlin the c. D. U. Leadership rallied behind chancellor merkel and readied themselves for a falling out with their sister party sayo 1st c. S. U. If need be. To have in the minds of the old stead into the abyss one possible consequence might have been a divine within the faction that would concede to you compete country line or in but theyre in this fight and they see as you with a compete country why. This 5 pm but i sat with my closest colleagues and we started preparing new elections how quickly could we nominate a candidate for chancellor gordon because how could we set up an election platform a program of a state then one of the parties made an astonishing about face not the c. D. U. But the smaller c. S. U. Behinds a hope to get me to set out to defend the good idea of turning people away at the border if they had already claimed asylum in a different country. To those many in the party said it was the end of our credibility. Into it for some time past i was left standing alone with just a few others. Everyone else had ducked out to go some show people up 0 for as a whole and was the one who was most intent on escalating the situation not everyone in his party and especially not the leading members were willing to let that escalation come to a head they all applied to breaks while he was still charging full steam ahead to. The end of credibility forced to say over announced his withdrawal from Public Office as both head of the c. S. U. Party and federal minister of the interior with the government be doomed without him. I have announced that i will be stepping down from both of my offices effective within the next 3 days. Or so the 1st we must agree with the c. D. U. An interim measures and its right now 1st in the going through to the to. The next evening they hope for and chancellor merkel found some Common Ground after all. And they hope for withdrew his resignation. This clear understanding enables me to remain in the office of federal minister of the interior building and community by to feel the compromise itself wasnt very interesting but although the government had fallen apart its reputation had been damaged would it ever recover. The s. P. D. Had watched this internal unraveling with bewilderment its scornful commentary was worthy of an opposition party. Is a threat to europe and we will stand up to face that threat my dear comrades and us in the going to. A government at risk of fizzling out before it had ever really taken off stuck between public animosities and officials trying to raise their profiles at the expense of their colleagues nerves were wearing thin. In the capital the tone grew harsher. That some of the government risks splitting yet again when our. Denton cabinets was murdered allegedly by a syrian national. An angry mob gathered. Eyewitnesses spoke of attacks against anyone who looked foreign. Videos backing up their reports circulated throughout social media. We will not stand for this kind of ganging up and hunting down of people who look different or have different origins or the attempt to spread hatred in the streets and even if you can then out of the blue the head of germanys Security Services piped up and caused an uproar by contradicting the government in an interview with the build tabloid. Profession the federal office for constitutional protection has no reliable evidence that such manhunts took place not a 9 to its been there has been plenty of evidence many reports have been made to the police and had even been passed on one that made it all the most surprising that he claims it hadnt been any kind of manhunt. Instead of punishing germanys head of Domestic Intelligence the government decided to promote him out of office. It was a convenient bureaucratic compromise. Motions that mr massive will transfer here to this ministry as state secretary in charge of security. Solutions hypertension i dont have the best decision to make mr mohsen state secretary was the only time we called to quit the coalition over it and also to cost a quarter to 4 times that it was so symbolic of what seemed like all of the insanity this coalition at times came up with but the mood was clear this was a red light up as he can write the whole thing looked on the chancellor had misread her country sentiments and president foghat looking back i realize that when coming to last tuesdays decision i was too focused on the functionality and procedures of the interior ministry. I didnt take into account enough what truly moves people and rightly so when they hear about a promotion i regret that i let that happen. But mohsin on the other hand was not sorry he doubled down over the internet of the Intelligence Agency he ranted about a supposed conspiracy against him and was sacked but the 2 consecutive affairs had joined the publics faith in the governing parties and severely tarnished its leaders reputations and to make matters worse 2 crucial state elections were coming up. After weeks of chaos in berlin voters would have a chance to penalize their government for its behavior. Just to do this but the s. P. D. Has 12 percent of the votes whats at stake here as well its very clear that we need to redouble our efforts. To see the us this is your 1st state election as head of the s. P. D. Whats at stake for you got nothing itll come. Political earthquake has shaken bavaria the c. S. U. Has lost in a landslide at 35. 5 percent and with the partys worst result in nearly 60 years and the s. P. D. Is down by half yes. It was very good evening ladies and gentlemen this is a very bad outcome for the s. P. D. But its also a very bad outcome for all the main causes but. 2 weeks later both parties suffered the next devastating blow and the state has and. Has cost the city and has in the c. D. O. Gathered only 28 percent down by 10 points and the s. P. D. Achieved its worst results nationwide 20 percent down 10 points. Pressured by her party the c. D. U. Leader decided to tackle the consequences head on of the missing one is pathetic the next cd he has a convention in hamburg this december i will not run for the position as head of gemini see the year. Also this 4th term of office would be my last as chancellor of the federal republic of germany. It was the end of an era but who would take her place remained unclear. Merkels decision laid bare the deep crisis the popular parties found themselves in. Citizens were losing patience with her cautious leadership style and all its compromises. The keys are there folks but the crisis is the popular parties are experiencing is dramatic but i dont think it will be easy to reverse anytime soon because people are yearning for a new leadership style and a more and not seen in. The c. D. U. Did what it could to stem the tide and hold its nose dive and hamburg the party celebrated its convention with all the usual part of the regal imagery was a facade behind the scenes even a split in the party was no longer out of the question. In the end on a that comp card and bauer beat her rivals free to take math and yes spawn but only just. From then on the c. D. O. Revolved around 2 centers of power. The transition of power within the c. S. U. Party might not have been a spectacular but it wounded the incumbent rivals pride years of power struggles had taken their toll and yet forced as a whole for and his successor marcus observed a struggle to put on a show of harmony nonetheless. Thanks. But many problems that the government had shied away from tackling for now forcing their way to the 4. Plans were made to phase out coal fired power stations by 2038. But the young demonstrators who took to the streets each friday werent satisfied with their governments steps to address climate change. Too little too late. The government was stunned. And saw that as top listed they ignored us. Then they laughed at us how does it take now that they are actually taking it seriously politicians have noticed they really do have to talk to us did in india look and by spring it was clear the government was out of its depth the Youth Movement would not be appeased with cosmetic gestures this is just me im its not like we can just flip a switch energy needs to be readily available around the clock even when the sun isnt shining or the wind blowing is coming and nobody could in all honesty deny that there are and worse certain deficits sent there are ya yes of course this isnt just about the climate its also about land use and the extinction of species but these are things people care deeply about chief keef in their mention and we had overlooked that it was a. The thirtys struggle to realign themselves but 1st they had to deal with the trauma of their past as the s. P. D. Turned its back im sure does agenda 2010 reforms the c. D. U. Under calm qanbar tried taking a careful step away from merkels open refugee policies. But would that be enough. Results for the maintop you know pacis c. D. U. C. S. U. In a speedy i think lining from one election to the next and i think that we have to the green party a set a new agenda. 50 hours a week i dont think wounds and also he always said grand coalitions were an exception to the room because the parties were so powerful there would be no opposition well thats not completely wrong it no longer encapsulates the entire problem of the grand coalition has become emblematic of political status. How easy is it to throw in secure ruling parties off balance. It took a 26 year old you tube or from aachen just one video. This is video of that kind this video wont be some boring political video this is going to be a destruction video not because im trying to destroy anyone but because the facts indicate that the c. D. U. Is singlehandedly destroying itself its reputation and its election outcomes. Decisions on how and when to react when they demand is incredibly hectic schedules of fires or to the people involved basically had just fine. Minutes between Campaign Appearances to cool each other to 10 different that was fundamentally wrong and we should have responded to the video immediately. And that the i think it wouldnt even have measured how he reacted as long as we had done so i set him. Up to in the sit in the foot mission and he needs an initiative by more than 26000. 00 german scientists. I didnt even know we had that many scientists and they all say the s. P. D. N. C. T. Use current course is far too slow and if we dont make drastic changes not small changes drastic changes and then the future of young generations and all the following generations is at risk i for. A european Parliamentary Campaign meeting for the e. P. P. Party which both the c. D. U. And c. S. U. Are part of the. Reasons video has already gotten 8000000 hits but not all the candidates were impressed did you watch results you tube video i honestly know i didnt know what do you think about all the fuss over. You but its exaggerated. On the European Campaign trail in germany merkel made only one appearance it was as if her own party were no longer of any relevance to her. That he must become the strongest kaante on the euro so that money can become president of the European Commission. But even while merkel spoke a joint video by several well known you tubers was unleashing the next stories is that this is an open letter a statement from a National Times of the you to the community somebody you elections or this weekend and its important to go vote there is no clinging to any risk hierarchy of the possible destruction of our planet obviously has top priority experts clearly state that the course taken by the c. D. U. C. S. U. And s. P. D. Is totally wrong so we call upon you all dont vote for the c. D. U. C. S. U. Or the s. P. D. As it is. Collin bauer and miracle were caught off guard. As miracle was he. Handing over the reins they had expected attacks from all sides from Coalition Members or even party insiders. But from a bunch of buteux bers. Assumption many just couldnt comprehend it because they had grown up in an entirely different media landscape one where politicians are delighted if they land a great quote on the front page of the front with a ill give mine a daily paper but cant fathom the idea that an entirely new type of media capable of causing a tectonic shift is developing always this affected your case for chans all i certainly say is cost us some Percentage Points and puts it into but i dont know if thats one or 3 percent i just know it hit us to. The m. P. C. To the c. D. U. Has dropped sharply to 22 percent since c. S. Use lands a little higher than last election at 6 percent but overall the losses are devastating the s. P. D. Nosediving to 15. 5 percent safe after the if we see the result of experience lately have been very disappointing for the s. P. D. The impact of the fridays for future marches and results video was clear in the 2900. And unusually high amount of german voters chose the green party. The outcome of the european elections pushed the s. P. D. Into despair had they become a party for just Senior Citizens the new cd you leader also had her back against the wall with pressure mounting from all sides when she made an announcement that sounded like a threat. To states is looking at the issue of incitement the question arises what rules apply in the analog realm and which rules apply to the digital ground and. This is a fundamental question that we need to talk about its the how and thats why we will pursue this debate very aggressively on catastrophic. It didnt. But the entire response. Was so hopeless thats all and i dont want to hear about it anymore it was a completely hopeless. Horse who was hopeless from the. Front the everybody of course ponded people and its not all me just want me to mention names to light some nice fires. But even so im thinking of comcast and then the 2 parties tried to respond with videos of their own. That immediately. Had one from the c. D. U. And then a little later one from the c. S. U. This none of it did any good. Reports about her poor Crisis Management skills severely tarnished the new Party Leaders reputation following results video she didnt seem up to her job even allies within her party showed displeasure dislike to this at the us and i suppose its something that hasnt passed by me without leaving a mark on me personally what does that mean this comment on well you can see it in the opinion polls and you can also tell by the discussions within the policy. Naturally each party and the cd even particular ones a leader they know they can rely on who wont make any mistakes. Of the kind this was from last night and that was a mistake in the policy sense that would decide to put the. Listing on the s. P. D. Was also channeling its frustrations in work after the disastrous Election Results party leader and the panel this was in a critical situation her own Party Comrades began to openly question her the tensions were threatening to culminate in a putsch. Took the pressure was enormous in the weeks leading up to the european elections there was a new headline every day sometimes the rivals fought out in the open sometimes they were made out of sight. It was everywhere in plain sight harsh tones tempers flaring and the like of i dont indifferent god helps me when this is not what i wanted but today ive decided to grab the bull by the horns past it suits her style instead of assuring herself of the tight majority behind closed doors she said shed fight things on the open and wouldnt shy away from confrontation but its not she was challenging her critics to speak up but they didnt it looked like an attempt to let her drive herself off a cliff youre too. Exhausted it was the end of her political career. Wouldnt tackle a day i had just stepped down from the s. P. Day tashi chair and from office. So we get there but by. All that was left behind were bruised emotions and a power vacuum that could overwhelm even a seasoned politician. The man who trail man want to be as equal maybe even both together will handle business in the interim dont they trust you to do it this beautiful being both a vice chancellor and finance minister it would be completely inappropriate for me to take over like this i wouldnt have the time and it wouldnt work with ordinary Party Leadership either a big table and you dont want to leave the s. P. Day long no i dont think its manageable in combination with the office of minister of finance we have to touch the social. And so bewildered s. P. D. Floundered its way through the summer who would take over as its new leader. A few were interested but most were not. And then suddenly all of shorts came up with enough time to campaign after all this media gets what helps and weve got to say i took the mockery of the s. P. D. In the storm of criticism over the process of finding a new candidate very much to heart. See akin to the border ive been a social democrat since i was 17 years old. And i found the situation so unbearable that i decided to revise my previous decision. Disapprobation mine and i dont even do. Think i could find enough time from being the minister of finance to lead the s. P. D. And to even man into an Election Campaign she was the 1st credibility trav has shots will get into. These personnel debates kept the coalition busy for weeks if not months as chancellor merkel continued to stay out of the limelight observers started asking if she was still in charge at all. Her public silence on the pressing issues of the time was resoundingly. Merkel is very skilled when it comes to power plays. But although she managed to get was a lot on the line appointed as president of the European Commission she failed to install un spahn into found alliance former post as defense minister. In fact merkels and com current powers reshuffling of power was fraught with risks. Isnt it done now after wed agreed on it was enough underlying it we still had to continue to Work Together without too much disruption of it the other 2 forts a few in this kind of course when you know thats when i was asked if i would enter the cabinet because they were differing positions and various tensions between the posse and the state association has to put it to and when the apartheid i thought it over carefully because i knew that it would be a question of credibility. But after considering all the circumstances i decided that it was all actually down to the boss so i would do it. But months earlier while she was still campaigning for the Party Leadership compound our had actually said something rather different. These apartheids kaante deserves to be led by someone for him it is all a matter of the heart under no circumstances should we give the impression that this office is merely being used as a castle called into the next government post that would be absolutely face a ladies and gentlemen. Many were surprised that they hope for stayed on as interior minister americas cabinet. But he seemed to have had a change of heart as to how to deal with refugees and was now seeking a european solution that would save refugees from drowning in the mediterranean. That. They kept. This small mention for them if they could but its everyones duty to save people from drowning if you dont think youre missing. The here if you know what i think we need to see to it that we continue to provide this humanitarian aid without creating a pull effect and in the future if it always goes lets explain design you know he had started talking the way medical always had she too had always sought an International Solution or a bilateral german turkish one and now it was if he had arrived on the same page as medical as a member of her cabinet. But the Coalition Parties were still in trouble. In western germany they were losing voters to the green party in the east they were losing to the far right a. F. Dean. In the state elections in saxony and brandenburg exit polls were causing a wave of consternation even before the voting booths had closed. In the end the c. D. U. And s. P. D. Both slid back even more but still managed to hold on to power in their respective states. Which of course im pleased for 6 were between 26 and 28 percent of brendon versions and the a d. Is between 21 and 23 percent. And at one point we were at 17 percent in brandenburg in saxony the d. Is a 2627 percent the gap is clear were at 78 percent and. Yet the secretary general of the c. D. U. C. S. U. And s. P. D. Parties clinging on to the grand coalition at the federal level because they knew that fresh elections might see them slip even further one thing was certain the large parties were shrinking while some of the smaller parties kept growing. Didnt have the popular parties nowadays we need to invent of they are crucial to germany success in this shrinking mr z. Nick lets move on to mr kling and testify that having a stable government serves germany well when we look at our european neighbors when we see how unstable other countries are than germany really profits from the stable government we have and i say that despite all the criticism one might have for the current government and i can think of a thing or 2 as well. Come fall the government gave itself a stellar rating after tough negotiations they had reached a compromise on the basic old age pension and loudly celebrated their success. We didnt she had a number of social improvements for families for children weve raised housing in student benefits and immigration bill for skilled well because were investing millions in digitalize ing schools. Weve tightened up the migration policies the basic pension and thats what got in the blue rolling for digitalisation in the economic sector. Weve set up a huge housing program. Weve also gotten the right to return from. Part time to full time jobs off the ground often because. We saw to it the child benefits were raised along with child supplements for working parents with low income gaps to get to the good news is we do without the climate package and yet when it came to the one topic that had brought people out onto the streets around the globe the governments response seemed at best feeble. Although it had announced sweeping reforms the scant measures they managed to agree upon convinced neither the pundits nor the protestors millions demonstrated americal half heartedly defended the climate package. Thats the difference between politics and science and impatient young people but its politics is about whats possible. Yes. Well deciding whether to remain in government or join the opposition the s. P. D. Spent half a year looking for a new leaders at 23. 00 regional conferences. Each time lots were drawn for the order in which the candidates would appear. Whatever the grand coalition is thats my view the grand coalition has no future and is not able to create a future from kind of my time ive been Party Members are tired of defending compromises that turn out to be nothing more think especially now with the new climate compromise. The s. P. D. Continued its downward spiral in opinion polls and was now fighting for its survival whether or not its new leadership plan to stay in the grand coalition could seal its bait. Last let us leave the grand coalition us the remaining 2 years wouldnt be worth us risking the last bit of credibility our party has. Launched us to question the end of. I mean im not ashamed of the fact that the s. P. D. Is a party that is ready to take responsibility for our country. Yet while the Election Campaign might have seemed to electrify Top Party Officials the voter base remained on him. Pressed and the s. P. D. Continued to spiral downwards. In the run off the campaign was reduced to being for or against the grand coalition. Even then the debate threatened to split the party into. But at the following state election the grand Coalition Parties only played a supporting role. In turning in the c. D. U. Suffered severe losses and ended at just 22 percent the left party went up slightly to 30 percent the s. P. D. Lost out and is now down to 8 percent but the f. T. Captured 23 percent which is an immense gain. The left party had won the vote followed by the f. T. Which was gathered around a right wing extremist. The musty and stale air will be cleared out my friends and we will keep on taking back our country. Katsumi our general secretary of the c. D. U. Still believed his party was firmly rooted in the center of society. But after the touring and debacle it became clear that the center of society actually was. Pretty pretty to him it is thus this is a turning point for the moderate Political Center of the law this is the 1st time it was been able to form a government without either the left party or the a. F. P. To be honest i simply couldnt imagine that in the past in fucking but today it happened for the 1st time if the my disney thought it might not be representative of what has happened in a state like tooling and a fire. That evening c. D. U. Asked itself the question the s. P. D. Had struggled with in the spring of 2018 should it go against its convictions and form a coalition to demand the abyss how is the c. D. U. Find Common Ground with a party that remains unwilling to acknowledge that east germany was an unjust nation on its own not on a coalition with the left party nor with the a. F. P. Its a new thing a difficult situation entering and we have to decide what a government might look like in my eyes seem iraq is trying to take cover and shirk responsibility i consider that a difficult situation on. The battered center parties were now sandwiched between the left and far right. And all at once the c. D. U. Didnt know where to go would it abandon its principles or abandon power. That night hardly anyone was paying attention to the s. P. D. That same week the grand coalition was rocked by yet another fierce dispute perhaps the most dangerous to date. Turkey launched attacks into Northern Syria once again thousands of refugees were forced to flee. In berlin the government and party brass gathered for talks. When they touched upon the issue of syria the new defense minister was noticeably quiet. The following day she surprised both the nation and her Coalition Partners with the new initiative. I propose that we create an internationally monitored safety. Involving turkey and involving russia. And when and how did you learn about on a great trump card and ours proposal is in eternity should have 1st became known on public television. Then this one then comes when it comes to come back saying i says this would of course be a zone where the military would play a role. In visor vitesse. Im defining this approach does not match the expectations one should have of proper government on an autumn dishes to give a shambles on to the soul and might i add that this is a big country and this is here michael says but its responsibility for the boy in despair at armed forces is not a matter that should be taken lightly or do you like to put an image on it because you stuck to him from compound times column vows latest move was clearly an act of sabotage against the grand coalition it wasnt a publicist and it was an intentional disruption one directed in essence against a Coalition Partners i really do believe the pressure had mounted to the point that she thought something had to give that the grand coalition couldnt continue the way it was because i believe she wanted to drive the speed a 3rd of that out of the coalition is a core and i think she was relentless about has come out for with. The s. P. D. Felt snubbed. In honor of all places the foreign minister retaliated. Because everywhere we go were told the proposal isnt realistic. Thats why weve taken the time to deal with the topics that are important for the people in syria now yet sed. The coalition was now wrangling publicly on the international stage. Where the parties working with or against each other. This also we saw the foreign minister travel to turkey and comment on the domestic debate in germany along with his turkish colleague mchugh took 2 months of its im true i personally have never experienced anything like that and i honestly hadnt thought it was possible. I was always if there was minutes they way the foreign minister acted during his trip to turkey was simply outrageous. And it wasnt close to what happened there all i can say about the grand coalition and ive always been very cautious in my judgment is that its over and. Just imagine whats come condoms and throw this on and and ive known each other for a long time. And i thought that i can and respect each others shirts and if not even they can manage to stick together and try to stabilize the government then the whole foundation is gone you walk don is just thats one number and pick. Then in the fall of 2019 the pressure mounted even further after its electoral flop and touring in the c. D. U. Went through the same crisis the s. P. D. Had previously. The party leader was facing open opposition as you could see in the life eat the federal chair as well as the head of the young union have posed the question of leadership and whoever thinks this question needs to be answered now or this full well have an opportunity to do it at the policy conventions. For nearly 6 months comp con by. Or had tried unsuccessfully to clamp down on her rivals on the partys fringe now fade to peak matts was moving into attack not just the chance for but also the party leader. Something the federal government looks just terrible and i cant imagine this style of governing germany will last another 2 years until the end of the legislation period in 2021 that these 2 indeed these of ill tell you what it is and its just not possible dusky and for. At the convention the party leader tried to defuse the tense situation but instead revealed just how desperate she really was after just one year in office. Then you know my insight if you believe that this conflict i want to take with you is not the part you think is right then that speak as any about its mission no less and let us end this here and now. Maybe the tide would turn after all maybe even sooner than expected. A week later the s. P. D. Was busy counting votes in its leadership runoff 6 months of searching for a new leader had come to a close. An hour before the results were announced it started to seem as if this could be a critical perhaps even historic moment. To have been defeated but ive watched this Party Struggle with itself time and again we fought out a number of conflicts in the public eye at 6 pm the struggle will be over to a certain degree this is this is something that needs to be settled once and for all not only for the sake of the s. P. D. But for the entire country thats why its good that this is finally being decided to set some chalk and. And the winner was the candidates in favor of leaving the grand coalition. Those in favor of staying including finance minister orloff showed last would thats. Well the end of his career. The newly elected Party Leaders were suskind asking and nor bad boy. It was a decision that could break the coalition maybe it was even intended to but why is public feeling against the grand coalition as much but none. Because weve all seen how the s. P. D. Has exhausted itself in the grand coalition but in the party has presented a number of proposals and has made a lot happen you mentioned but people obviously dont believe that this could lead to a social democratic country in the long run. I dont believe after just 20 months the governing coalition of the 2 main parties has been deeply shaken new elections would pose a huge threat to them perhaps the government will break apart soon or perhaps it wont but at the grand coalition keeps going at all that it wont be out of conviction but for lack of any better alternative. Kick off. Another blockbuster weekend and no one is like. One pound of muscle to move in the 1st place. Like to be called on time on the 2nd. Hand glovebox scored an injury time to take all 3 points against byron munich a top of the table. I suppose and ultimately affectionately but as affectionately as you can. See that a mere putin in the middle of his a. Action campaign in the year 2000 a documentary was filmed for Russian Television but director Vitali Munson captured much more wood to turn the camera back on the look of course. The film secretly kroner gold a power grab actually everything was seriously planned instruction. Featuring tom supporting roles to the bush. Featuring a lead role like youve never seen before let me be clear with. Good manners let me a bitch do the ends justify the means. Tunes witnesses starts december 13th on d w. The be. Playing. This is due to be a news live from berlin questions mount after new zealands volcanic eruption but the death toll rising to 6 missing and dozens severely injured people are asking why the government allow tourists to visit the site in the 1st place. Also coming up after a landmark talks in paris the leaders of russia and ukraine agreed to implement a cease fire and Exchange Prisoners but their 1st face to face encounter also exposes divisions and the weather extremes are increasing my