Negotiators cannot look to pittsburgh as a mobile phone green jobs and renewable energy. Americas president delivers a scolding to the Asia Pacific Forum in vietnam telling the regions business elites that the United States will not tolerate the unfair trade practices hes previously accused china off. On the struggle for middle east a dominance heats up of conflicts across the region saudi arabia is that newly powerful crown prince seeks to boost the kingdoms prominence at home and abroad by rolling back irans influence in yemen and lebanon so how much more dangerous could this rivalry become. In france and germany today marked the truce that ended world war one but does a conflict that killed twenty Million People have any influence on europe today. Im phil gayle welcome to the program britains chief brags that negotiator david davis says the u. K. Will not create a border between Northern Ireland on the republican to the south as part of a deal with the e. U. This follows talks with his a u counterpart Michel Barnier on friday which the border with ireland was a key issue bunning meanwhile effectively set a two week deadline for britain to agree to pay its exit bill before further talks can take place this comes after britains Prime Minister to resign made unveiled a planned loss for britains departure from the you know march twenty ninth twenty nineteen eleven pm local time heres what Britains David Davis had to say after the talks. Theres no doubt we have made and continue to make including this round significant progress across a whole range of issues across the board that may prove progress towards resolving some really difficult questions and that course will continue act place between now and december. Lets hear more from a d. W. Of a soul in a brussels she has been enough following not the talks i welcome barbara its a if so is michelle body a tightening the screws this as an ultimatum. Oh definitely so phil because in brussels that have been known for a while that this would be approximately the time line where britain would have to deliver on financial commitments whoever its the first time that they usually quite diplomatic Michel Barnier said it so clearly it was you have two weeks to come up was the money bang otherwise the European Union the leaders will at the next summit mid december sort of do this lower that some of the over the british desire to continue with trade talks to get you on into the second phase of negotiations british presence a minister sounded quite a bit in parts of his speech but elsewhere the tone was quite different. Gone was the fluffiness the optimism and the sort of friendliness for the soft so more or less of only a meeting set of course there there remains a certain yes we will talk to each other and we are a professional negotiators attitude however if you listen more closely you realise that the brics to divorce negotiations the talks about the divorce of the two partners are entering the phase of bitterness where the language becomes harsher and the battle really begins so this means also that increasingly even among brussels diplomats the idea comes to the fore that in fact he could be headed for it for a train crash that during the course of the next year. Negotiations could not only run out of time but also run out of goodwill something that nobody here in brussels really wants but that is somehow now increasingly taking into account baba faisal in brussels thank you. Lets get into more than about the Economic Issues at stake over bricks it under one of the affected industries is facing a fishing again what else first can tell us more thats right fill in europe fishing is tightly controlled by brussels the e. U. Said strict rules for commercial fishing across all Member States and the socalled common fisheries policy has been controversial from its inception in one nine hundred seventy to prevent overfishing it said annual caps limits quotas that determine how many fish can be cause each country is then allocated what is considered to be its fair share the fisheries policies policy also sets controls on fishing practices such as the kind of nets that fisheries are allowed to use and regulates how fish and seafood are processed and labeled to make sure consumers can trust what they need the rules were devised to protect fishing stocks and fisherman but brags it poses a whole new set of challenges on the in this ongoing road to break serious word today looking at the maritime aspects of britains living departure from the European Union. Its a huge impact because. At least fifty percent of our fleet and thats a disaster a real disaster thanks to call me out of my bricks it came as a surprise to us and not a good surprise im worried it is like a monster emerging among the. Bricks. My name is. Im a dunce fisherman from the island and my name is representing the dutch fishing industry. They call sent by fish and british waters eighty percent of the year and if im not allowed to fish there anymore i have to go somewhere else but other colleagues are already fishing in dutch waters so if i go there we have to share what it would be like fishing on a stone. So this would have a domino effect a very bad domino effect for instance here this Auction Industry sure that if one or two or three vessels well after stop then that is no place theres an enormous need for the auction Everything Everything tumbles around. In the north sea since nine hundred fifty seven and thats a very very good sign and that is because of the joint policy of the e. U. Member states but the collective management is going to be our colleagues our friends working together in european fisheries politics and all of a sudden its turned upside down as if we are strangers and that is a very very bad feeling our friends are no longer. Friends. Are fisherman bennett. And you want to take my thing as a boy i went fishing with my father in british waters he told me where to go catch the best fish. Machines on. The plate and plate and you have nothing but his phone all these are my waters and i know them like the back of my head. Because. The reality of the exit is the reality before but exits and we have to come to an agreement together so we brits export the fish they catch and they import the fish they eat and if they want to so scottish farmed salmon langoustines etc to the confidence then they should be reasonable and its tit for tat and its a fair deal that we can keep fishing in their waters as we have done for five hundred years. So very complicated lets go back to brussels now and talk to our reporter who filed this report this socalled fisheries policy has been controversial in how far is braggs now making things worse. The idea of brakes a tears of many fishermen one has to say in the u. K. Was they claim back their territorial waters now thats of course a difficult thing to say if fish stocks actually migrate ends and dutch fisherman told me its very hard to tell you know what kind of fish actually is a british fish and therefore the common fishery policies idea was the key idea was lets manage the stocks together now that is as the representative has said with the heartbreaks it that would be gone and on top of that he said or the dutch fisherman told me the problem is really a british one that small boats in the u. K. Get only a small share of the total quote of the amount of fish the u. K. Can catch compared to big boats because after all the british fishing industry is one of the most successful in all of europe. The man youre appalled a said very strangely britain exports most of the fish catches and imports most of what it eats why is that and what impact will that have on any future deal that really is the big catch if you want in the whole fishing problem here for the u. K. Because a lot of fish they catch for instance stover soul or skate for instance are simply too exotic for british taste they rather have their cut with the for the fish and chips and so they do import a lot of fish and now the argument bred the dutch fisherman and a lot of european fishermen have put forward is you know if you want to continue doing that we will want access to the british waters to our traditional fishing grounds that are always used to be shared and if you dont give us that axes well put terrorists on the fish you have been exporting to our markets you know what is there in brussels thank you very much. And thats all from me ill have a more business for you a bit later in the show but first its back to phil i can hurt thank you so much russias the lawmakers say they will make foreign media and social networks register as foreign agents this after the countrys state funded channel r. T. Said it would comply with the u. S. Demand to do the same thing u. S. Intelligence agencies allege that r. T. Was used to interfere in last years president ial election. And afghan Officials Say one policeman has been killed and two wounded in a suicide car bombing that targeted a police compound they say a single bomber caused the blast in the southern Helmand Province the group has claimed responsibility but helmand is in taliban heartland. More than five hundred Asylum Seekers remain stranded in a decommissioned australian migrant camp in Papua New Guinea because it was officially closed on the thirty first of october and the power food and water cut off however most of the camps residents have refused to relocate because of concerns for their safety and threats they say they have received from local residents. Lets turn now to the middle east where tensions between saudi arabia and iran are on the rise and have spilled over into lebanon now hundreds of gulf states citizens are leaving the lebanese capital beirut after saudi arabia the u. A. E. Bahrain and kuwait advise their citizens to leave immediately the power struggle between saudi arabia and iran is also having a devastating effect on yemen where the two countries are engaged in a proxy war observers are increasingly worried that rising reasonal tensions could lead to even more conflict. In one corner iran still prickly despite its landmark nuclear deal with the International Community anti western forces remain strong in the shiite republic and it continues to support radical islamic movements across the region. In the other corner an increasingly us out of saudi arabia encouraged by President Trumps visit last may to expand its regional influence. On his first trip to the middle east donald trump essentially gave the saudi leadership complete freedom to do whatever it wants as long as thats us interests that has fueled tensions in the confrontation between saudi arabia and iran by the new guy its. One battleground in this regional rivalry is yemen with iran supporting huth the rebels fighting the countrys sunni government which is backed by saudi arabia. A pro rebel t. V. Station showed images of a missile it said who the rebels launched against saudi arabia the government in riyadh reacted by closing off all access to yemen. And when giants tassel its often the most vulnerable who suffer the United Nations says the saudi blockade of yemen could unleash a massive famine with millions of victims. Now lebanon is also on the front line of this Regional Power struggle speaking from saudi arabia at the weekend lebanese Prime Minister saad hariri resigned saying he feared being assassinated by iran backed forces in his country. Many lebanese however believe saudi arabia is using him as a tool in its conflict with iran. Was just. This resignation wasnt normal its an insult to the lebanese people and to the government and to society as a whole. Area. Theres a volcano about to erupt in this region we dont know what the consequences are going to be. International diplomacy is now stepping up its efforts with french president emmanuel macor making an unscheduled visit to saudi arabia earlier today in a bid to help defuse the situation. All this week d. W. Has been reporting from the United NationsClimate Summit in the german city of bonn the big topic is how to reduce Carbon Dioxide emissions you noted states has long been one of the worlds biggest emitters of Greenhouse Gases but an american says it was known for its muggy skies it showed that it is possible to cut pollution Pittsburgh Pennsylvania is undergoing a transformation as the w correspondent cotton fundament reports. This is the old image of pittsburgh a city of steel and coal where the chimney stacks never stop bedsit smoke and west read lights had to be left on twenty four hours a day because the smog blocked up the sun but todays reality is a different one the city has cleaned up its act and instead of heavy industry banks and High Tech Companies are now providing jobs for a growing population more than thirteen thousand pittsburghers are employed in the Clean Energy Sector alone in companies such as ever power which operates wind farms in pennsylvania new york and is developing projects in other states too for cofounder and were going to best ski pittsburgh is the Perfect Place for innovative businesses i think its the people you know its great town pool here young people from some of the best universities in the country. Also from a cultural standpoint you know theres a lot to offer we have three professional teams at the l. A. We have to symphony we have the opera so many things that can draw great talent for. Pittsburghs transformation as the result of a concerted effort by the City Government to attract startups and other businesses while at the same time keeping an eye on environmental and social issues one of the people working on pittsburghs turnaround is Development Analyst sarah yeager. To take a holistic approach as how can we improve pittsburgh why this is creating more jobs more low Income Housing access to Public Transportation fossil fuel free vehicles electrifying our fleet access to more bike lanes and really how can we improve the quality of life for everybody in pittsburgh. And the other key factor in the citys formula for success is pittsburghs colleges like Carnegie MellonUniversity Many who started here at cmu have established themselves in the new economy founding startups in the vicinity of the campus and turning them. Into vibrant enterprises professor jean yang a specialist for programming languages is full of praise for the almost symbiotic relationship between scientists and Tech Companies here for instance do a lingo was started by lease on and he had this Actual Office for a long time before he left for doing go all together and so a lot of the duelling of people are involved with cmu they come back here to listen to talks to speak. And everything is quite close so the people are companies theyll show up to talks here people here theyll spend some time at the companys jean yang grew up in pittsburgh when it was still a by word for the american rust belt as soon as she finished school she moved away like so many other talents and young people at the time and expected never to return now shes back in her hometown and enjoys not only great working conditions but also a new quality of life in her Old Neighborhood these are places where it was pretty sketchy to walk outside there after dark and i was just way inside for my parents to pick me up i wouldnt go outside on my own and when i came back i realize that wow there are all these bars there now there are restaurants the buildings are outside they still look pretty much the same but whats going on inside really its like night and day so pittsburgh clearly is on the way up again with young people flocking to the city and the prospect of even better times ahead for the next generation. Well pittsburgh smell is a bill to do he joins us from the u. N. The climate talks in the bondo welcome to you congratulations on your citys turnaround id like to start first of all by looking back to june when donald trump announce that he was pulling the u. S. I was of the Paris Climate Accord lets just listen to what he said i was elected to represent. The citizens of pittsburgh not paris. Thank you must get sick of hearing that cliff i wonder why did he single out youll say same which didnt even vote for him. Illiterate im not really sure but the one thing that most pittsburghers felt when they heard the was there was thirty years worth of sacrifice thirty years worth of change thirty years of watching our city die in a post industrial waste and then being born again through the investment in technology in Artificial Intelligence and medicine finance and yes a Green Economy and when he said that it went right to the heart of all those that sacrificed to bring pittsburgh back so it is interesting you paint a picture of a city that was in abyssinia stick line so im guessing in those circumstances it wasnt a big sell for you to say we have to do things differently. No i mean the actually it did take a while it took over a decade before politicians started talking about how we can bring back the mills how we can bring back the factories and start to think of what we respect our past but does our future have to be wedded to it and there are a few people who are planing seeds early on the began that process the First Robotics Program in the world the first ph d. In robotics one of the first supercomputing centers in the United States all began the transformation to a new economy in today pittsburgh stands with more jobs in green energy then in coal natural gas and oil combined and clearly that is not the haass of the message that youre presenting to the well but i wanted to after President Trump announced his plan to withdrawal from the paris climate code you announced that pittsburgh would be powered by one hundred Percent Renewable Energy by twenty thirty five. How close are you to that target. Well weve set benchmarks because you have to measure if youre not measuring youre just practicing so we are on pace of where we need to be now our next major benchmarks two thousand and twenty three than two thousand and twenty five and then two thousand and thirty were very secure that we can meet all of our goals but for this very reason that there are over a thousand city leaders from every continent right now in bonn were here to tell our governments that we can do even more than what we pledged in paris and we have to as well if we really want to see a reduction below two degrees then were going to have to do even more and it can happen at the city level but heres the thing and you know the person to tell me about this. What we often hear is that if you are going to invest in Green Technology and new technology and all the rest of it people wedded to the old way of doing things will say well where the jobs ok you can have new jobs for young people bright young people but what about may i used to be a my and i used to be thought to a what am i going to do in this bright shiny new well the feels. Right just like our sister city in dortmund or just right down the ryan in essence pittsburgh is that story pittsburgh is that industrial story we discovered the coal seam in pittsburgh we discovered oil north of pittsburgh in western pennsylvania in our jobs in coal in heavy industry help to build america but theyre not the future what we want to be able to do is change the future of work so that the investments that are coming from our federal government arent going to subsidize the jobs of yesterday but are going to build the Wind Turbines of tomorrow invest in the Turbine Technology be able to produce solar panels and solar cells teaching people how to install them in making investments for the future that will allow us to be competitive on a global basis germany gets that in theyve been doing it now its time for the United States and other countries to create our own Marshall Plan in to be able to invest in the areas that have been left behind and most importantly in the people who have been left behind. Build up potato pits but i thank you for joining. Thank you. One hundred years ago french and german soldiers were battling each other in the trenches of world will walk today the two countries are opening deficits joint museum commemorating that conflict jevon present from about the she died by french president came out home across attending the ceremonies historians from both countries develop the museum on ahead in the French Border region of alsace the hot months even a cult the sole months of fighting the on and the war and the deaths of thirty thousand people. Did of his chief Political Correspondent melinda crane she joins us from to do new south politics youre welcome linda so this is a memorial to a war that happened a hundred years ago what significance does it have for young people today. It has enormous significance it wasnt only on this particular hill during world war one but over centuries this entire region of. Which is now part of france was passed back and forth between france and germany in the context of multiple wars ongoing conflict one hundred years ago french and german soldiers killing each other on that ground that we saw in those pictures inconceivable for many young people in europe today to imagine that kind of enmity that kind of violence between these two countries but the fact is it could theoretically happen again weve seen rising nationalism in many European Countries over the course of the last few years weve heard far right Political Parties calling for countries to leave the European Union and in fact the European Union has very much been part of this reprimand between france and germany so ceremonies like the one today absolutely remind people that what we now take for granted isnt something that we should forget and that we all need to keep working to make sure that europe stays peaceful were looking at live pictures as we speak of so many front fell to shine a light under president michel so this one hundred years ago the that these two countries were killing each other today they are one of the pillars of democracy if you like. They are indeed and they are also Close Friends president macro referred to unparalleled ties of friendship now between the two countries and they are often seen together as the tandem as the motor that drives europe so very very important for the two to Work Together as they have in the past and yet at the moment how that relationship will develop in future is a bit open. The president micro has made some sweeping proposals for reform of the European Union what sort of response has he been getting from berlin well i think many people in paris would say theyre still waiting for an answer in fact the french finance minister bhutto the man who was just here in germany two days ago and he said this is a crucial window of opportunity to work on European Union reform in order to strengthen europe for all the reasons that i mentioned a moment ago to keep peace in europe to make sure people have stability and employment and yet the fact is as german Political Parties are trying to work out the next governing coalition several of the potential political issue partners have not been receptive to mr proposals and in fact arent giving paris much of a response at all although paris is very much indicated its interest in doing these reforms together with germany one of the great thank you. This is day to fly from both ends still to come the legacy of the Russian Revolution and present day you cry what does it mean for the former soviet republic as tensions with moscow reached new reach historic highs. So how about so that more of the day so worlds new sports and culture its all here on the double. When cities are engulfed by the sea. Then all the dams malls and costly protective measures with. The floods challenging our future in forty five minutes on t w. Health. And here in studio long. Solidarity. They fall by the wayside when the gap between rich and poor grows. Life in an equal societies. The divide starting november fifteenth on d w. Your children like chocolate. You cant live without your smartphone. Tomatoes the supermarket. As we go about our daily lives human rights oh often dont last long lines. In this will hands. Slavery in the twenty first century. Starting december second g. W. This is day to every news live from both and im phil gayle these are top stories at this hour the European Union has stepped up the pressure on britain over brags that europes chief pressing the go say so says the u. K. Has two weeks to clarify how much it will pay the e. U. When it leaves the block and that crucial talks on trade will look start until london delivers. And u. S. President on trump has declared that the head of the United States will no longer tolerate crony trade abuses but welcomes facts right mr trump made those remarks as a summit of Regional Economic leaders in vietnam a full stop on his first tour of asia. Take a look at one of the defining moments of the Twentieth Century one hundred years ago communist revolutionaries seize power in russia the bolshevik takeover of the seventh of november one thousand nine hundred seventy one was not masterminded by a flood in may only its own yard off better known as lenin the communist later began preparing for revolution during his years in exile in western europe and the russian money he was eventually replaced by the soviet union the lenins vision of a Classless Society soon gave way to a repressive state a century of what has become of a communist dream that is the focus of a series on the legacy of the Russian Revolution and the soviet union broke up more than two decades ago many. Its component republics i. Q. Crowd became independent countries relations between ukraine and russia are severely strained these days because of moscows support for separatists in Eastern Ukraine perhaps not surprisingly few ukrainians identify with the communist past this square and metro station are both named arsenal after this former minister factory which was at the center of a revolt by both civic revolutionaries a century ago. Today many ukrainians question the legacy of the revolution and the communist system that followed. Where seventy years behind the rest of the world because of communism europe is flourishing but we are at a standstill all because we took a step backwards that day. But yes i forgotten about the revolution even though we celebrated it every year during soviet times we were always herded to rallies and demonstrations i think. It was the start of socialism it didnt exist before then which is why i think it was good there was a step forward for the world. This used to be the lenin museum now its a memorial to the First Ukrainian peoples republic it was founded in one thousand nine hundred seventeen when the russian empire was crumbling. Its leaders wanted nothing to do with the revolution in russia. Lost in the large part of the history of the ukrainian peoples republic was spent fighting the russian empire and russian imperialism. This strengthened our sense of who we are as a people under nation. This historical footage shows the first days of the fledgling peoples republic the political turmoil of the time and the costly war with the bolsheviks are only hinted at in these shaky images when the conflict was over the bolsheviks emerged victorious and ukraine was incorporated into the soviet union the dream of democracy and autonomy was over for decades now the statues of lenin are gone and ukraine wants to shed its communist past by law. It is the grandson of a former Ukrainian Communist Party leader hed like to see the revolution officially celebrated in kiev once again. With the risque whoopsies with the october revolution gave the world a new form of civilization. That is one thing second the october revolution created the state of ukraine. It did not exist before october one thousand nine hundred seventeen. Thats a view of history not shared at the museum. Historians place a different emphasis on the events that took place one hundred years ago. Society now understands that the Russian Revolution was just one event in the reorganization of the russian empire but that it was carried out under a different flag that of communism. Ukraine was not able to accept that on any level. Today the october revolution is a distant event for the people of kiev they have more pressing issues on their minds. At the end of this past october hundreds of demonstrators camped outside parliament demanding long overdue reforms in twenty seventeen confronting the government is considered part of democracy in contrast to a century ago. Sky is coordinator of the human rights table open in russia that said Opposition Movement founded by the exiled awful oligarchy col khodorkovsky and also a political activist that has participated in the election campaigns of several opposition politicians in russia she joins us from moscow welcome to day doubly so one hundred years after the october revolution overthrew the old order how easy is it now for russians to voice their opposition. Well first of all its important to note that over russia and i myself we dont want to over for the government anymore we just wanted to basically leave and hopefully well get at some point but anyway it has always been very easy for our sins to voice not only their opposition but their position like any position at all because you may have heard in the news that there was supposed to be a rally in support of putin and bush period just this week and the local government didnt been made to it and the police has beaten like all the demonstrators and even find the organizer of this rally and it was a rally in support of putins russia government doesnt want anything that is not coordinated with them because they are afraid of like any positions and any uncontrollable to this and of course its really difficult and i can feel that the area of possibilities is shrinking constantly but still i think this iteration is not as dramatic as it used to be one hundred years ago well talk about the Russian Revolution i get in just a sec but youve piqued my interest in something you just said i wonder are organizations like yours. Like popular do rush does your average russian care the vast opposition voices are controlled and quelled or rather what topics so long as i can put bread on the table. Russia has a very difficult history especially in the Twentieth Century and i just suppose that most of russians want to leave peacefully and wants to government not to touch them and just let them live their lives and so as we are promoting that. View and they of russian people just living their lives the government. Lessening its involvement into normal speedboats life of course we get support and ive always got subordinate and the more radical members of the opposition get support because the economical situation is not so good. But its important to state that most people dont want like a revolution like it was a hundred years ago but still we get a lot of support from people because they understand that were not trying to do what bolsheviks that ok so lets just go but to the main topic that the bill to the revolution of one hundred years ago i wonder if this is something that people these days care about. Speaking for the Younger Generation i can say that for example people like me. This is just some advance that you used to take place in the boss so its not like any painful question or it doesnt set off a storm of going versation send discussions but it was a it was an important date for. Young people and they. Cared about it like online like young people do they posted means they discussed it but anyway i really hope that. Now a days this question wouldnt be as painful as it was before as if seen it before very interesting i thank you for joining us police in the middle sky. I sat with a class to fill their final european slots for next summers football world cup there was hardly drama in belfast as underdogs Northern Ireland hosted switzerland and it took a contentious penalty for a handball in the fifty eight minute to give the swiss i was nil when it turns out the hard ball was more of a shoulder ball but there was no video replay and they work but there is no video replay in the world cup playoffs so switzerland was awarded a penalty which was converted by ricardo rodriguez. There is less on the line when germany face angle and in a friendly tonight but its still a chance for players to nail down a place in the squad the world champions travel to Wembley Stadium in london after breezing through the world cup qualification is winning all ten of their games but theres always room for improvement. They say friendlys are the ideal testing ground in football fans already used to the tinkering grays of this man but germany coach you are him live hasnt had enough he had to try out some fresh ideas against england so in the four provides a one from tie he still has a few games to prepare until the world cup i think even for me its a bit of a test case this year with some players. With the tournaments in mind i want to see not only those players who play regularly but also prepare the other players. For them even of the under the top item. And hes not the only one adamant about experimenting in it may have to do without attacking midfielder del a alley and striker harry kane both out due to injury but coach Gareth Southgate wants to take this chance to try something different. This period between qualification and the finals has to be one of an element of experimentation if we dont try things in these games when are we going to try things when are we going to learn about some of these guys for germany experimentation has become part of the teams d. N. A. In recent times the world champions know that friendlys are the best stage to test new ideas without too much on the line. Well you heard her talking and not reporter shes here to tell us more about tonights friendly match actually in england to germany ive lived in britain for some time and even though its a friend from a name and theres actually phil a lot on the line especially for some of these younger players individual players because we all know one hundred percent the likes of thomas maps homos jerome boyd tang manon neuer they are all going to be on that plane heading to russia next summer but we dont know if some of these newcomers some of these not regular players like amin yunus material into moscow. Theyre not really going to get a spot and i think. I think the reason why you are has also chosen these friendlies against these tougher competitions like that the likes of england and the next week france and then in the new year we have brazil and spain is to really see if these some of these newer guys non regular guys can actually keep up against some of the best video system and referees a big trial for the first time in the u. K. For this match weve seen this in the bundesliga this season what are players making of it ahead of the this game is a lot of the criticism has been on point its it has interrupt that the game it has slowed down the game because youre watching all these replays and germany striker. For example he has said that the problem is not the fact that in essence its a great idea its great the system is great but the employer implementation has been awful its been a disaster because you know mistakes are still being made and this is just based on his own experience but it seems to be not only a problem in the bundesliga because also in syria as well germany. For example who plays for you venters he has says that you know he echoes his sentiments saying that its been the same problem that the system needs to get better that sometimes players after when they score a goal that they. Seem to be confused they dont know if that gold counts or not and that it has in a way sucked some of the passion out of the game but i think the most important point here phil is the fact that the objectivity of the refs just a few days ago we found out you know that the bundesliga v. A. All head that you know his judgment had come into question so and i find that very disturbing that he was making decisions favorable to his own Favorite Football Team so that is very disturbing and we saw some controversy in the no dance with one game last night how could i have Video Systems of how exactly so here you know thats the positive because had we seen the replay of that penalty would have seen that that would have never never should have been a penalty that the ball actually hit the shoulder of the player and not his head and so on and i think is also the problem i think we tend to focus so much on all the negative when it comes to v. A. All when it comes to the technology but theres been also numerous instances in the in three are in Major League Soccer which would haas help with the correct decisions you know where made so i think you know we should focus on always did this negative because i know it doesnt make for sixty had lines but at the end we also you know we should keep a cool head because people need to remember remember that this is still a test trial and that a final decision on the v. A. Ought to see if these leaks will continue on up would be made later in twenty eighteen and they were talking thank you. Now if you are desperate to find out what the official bowl of next years world cup will look like your white is over to organizers made a spectacle of they have a thing of course bringing in some of the caves of superstars like below messi as a hobby and because podolski to show the boy called the telstar eight hed be they had seventeen others money fighter and i did i said the black and white sign harks back to the used for the one nine hundred seventy world cup maybe its just around black and white object that can be kicked around. You decide. You have no thoughts on black white balls being kicked out of page no my use of all black and white and i quite like this one actually after so its a very Good Business on business actually for us President Trump is in vietnam as the apec summit of asia pacific leaders where hes been stressing his America First message he said hes open to bilateral free trade talks with all of the apec members but he said the u. S. Will not tolerate what he calls chronic try to be uses with the region pushing ahead with the t p p free trade deal without the us trumps policy could make him out immediately after his arrival in denying donald trump was quick to make clear his position on some players on the global markets. They ignored the rules to gain advantage over those who followed the rules causing enormous distortions in commerce and threatening the foundations of International Trade itself he went on to express his clear rejection of some free trading zones with his america such agreements were of the qods i will make bilateral trade agreements with any in though pacific nation that wants to be our partner and that will abide by the principles of fair and recept perkel trade what we will no longer do is enter into large agreements that tie our hands surrender our sovereignty and make meaningful enforcement practically impossible. Chinas president xi jinping couldnt let that law and challenge trumps comments albee it directly by expressing his support for free trade which youre forcing here over the last few decades economic globalization has contributed significantly to Global Growth indeed its become an irreversible historical trend. At the beginning of the year Trumps Administration decided not to take part in the planned transpacific partnership. But according to the countries that remain t. P. S. Is on the way regardless of the u. S. Decision. I believe that thats the best way for us to or generate wealth. And well be in for everybody concerned. Now that america has taken the position to withdraw we respect that decision but eleven countries let by japan know were trying to come up with new version. But that version will have to wait for the planned meeting of the eleven countries has now been postponed to canada revealed it was not ready to confirm its agreement exactly when or whether it will take place is not yet clear. And capital new delhi is one of the worlds most police polluted cities pollution has hit a spike this year just last week they spike is seventy five times the level considered safe by the World Health Organization some experts have compared the toxicity level to smoking several packs of cigarettes a day. In new delhi based masks are not a fashion accessory the citys inhabitants are just doing what they can to protect themselves. Body goes like that we cannot go outside without a man as there is too much small from the past forty five days he has been a lot of smaug in delhi or whatever small if you and. Only if you bought right now are fair enough people walk her. Days not your forte is not a. Boyfriend i mean everything in. The city has a Health Emergency and its hitting businesses as well authorities have halted construction restricted traffic and raised parking rates but it still doesnt look like theres a permanent solution in sight. Theyre not going to new sources of pollution inside the city so you have been a ten million day pipes in the city continues this ice cream smoke you have to have raised to burning happening. So this happens shes in a deep order for this show to do and but when it happens is you slash and burn farming is banned in india but farmers continue to burn fields to make way for winter crops many are still looking to the government for les paul eaton solutions as are inhabitants of new delhi. Every year the european cultural brand awarded to honest people and institutions that have made their mark on europes Cultural Landscape through excellence in management and marketing but found a batch this year at a ceremony and then the top prize went to a movie Guggenheim Museum bilbao a lot about the same and no in spain just celebrated its twentieth birthday over the past twenty years back garys revolutionary design has attracted a million. This is yet to a region that was once in decline and i believe its for the culture desk is here to tell us little well so its iconic now the guggenheim we all know it from around the world. Looking back was it always clear that it was going to be a success no not at all it was a huge gamble both for the city of bilbao and for the guggenheim and just the it was New Territory a building of this audacity a Cultural Institution of this size and a town that frankly a lot of people hadnt even heard of and the architect frank gehry himself so that he was shocked by the building when he first saw it he thought what have i done to the people here and the answer is that he basically saved was a town that was on hard times financially it had been the site of basque separatist terrorism it was a place that International TerrorInternational Tourists rather were not going to touch and the city asked frank gehry to turn their fate around and basically thats what he did he didnt just turn around though he actually this project created a new idea the idea that culture had the power to transform an entire place and in the spirit of that twenty years on lets take a closer look. Its a landmark a tourist draw and an economic factor. All combined in one spectacular Museum Building designed by frank gehry. No other innovative transgressive and creative get out the will be to for aspirational inspiring for the shapes are curvy straight and flat very interesting i mean there are some that. The curved and linear shapes continue in the interior the architecture is itself art. The Museum Opened in one thousand nine hundred seven after four years of construction its a joint venture between the local government and the solomon are Guggenheim Foundation the choice of bilbao was considered a daring one the spanish city had suffered from the decline of its heavy Industries Including coal and steel plus one promise cannot be a hot the for this was an old city that had been dependent on shipbuilding and other industries and that was economically totally depressed when those industries left on the side of him and there was high unemployment of his business that from a social environmental and economic point of view they had a really insidious bill today bilbao serves as a global example for the targeted regeneration of cities through investment in spectacular architecture as well as infrastructure tourists create jobs and result in greater wealth for residents the phenomenon has become known as the bilbao effect. For its twentieth anniversary in october the Museum Building was used as a projection screen by light artists