propelled trump forward. to josh's point, if cultural issues like immigration are hot button issues, immigration takes us back to jobs and the jobs issue and the wage issue doesn't get resolved by cracking down on immigration. there are jobs available in this country, and americans don't want them because they don't pay enough. there are small businesses having to shut down because they cannot get foreign workers because they can't get the approva approvals. how does immigration remain a hot button issue for trump counties when it doesn't solve anything for them? >> well, that's a question that democratic politicians ask all the time. but remember, in 2016 i don't think it was actually, stephanie, the jobs issue that got trump the votes he needed in those crucial rust belt states that got him into the white house. it was if you look at analyses of the trump coalition, it was significantly issues connected