my question to you is why did they want him back so much. >> in 12 years, we can never charge these guys. the taliban, clearly, they were affiliated with the taliban. it would make sense they would ask for them back. our legal basis to detain them is going to run out at the end of the with the close of the afghanistan war. get a soldier back with five people we couldn't haven't charged in 12 years. >> why are they no longer a danger to the united states in terms of that war front. and by the way, by your logic he could have led the general free in vietnam. he was certainly a threat to our allies and certainly a threat to our interests. >> we had no evidence -- >> these guys are an enemy of the united states. are they not? >> if we had any evidence they had committed any offense, we would have preferred charges against them. and in 12 years we couldn't do them. >> that's why we keep them in