right about that. >> i remember hearing his voice. and it sent shivers down my spine. >> as far as i'm concerned, you are a pretty piece of meat. be smart and be a survivor. have a nice day. >> the second trial judge had an entirely different view of that evidence and ruled differently than the first one. it was a very powerful piece of evidence. this was essentially a confession. >> while the audiotape was a crucial piece of evidence, the case still relied on the personal testimony of kelly van cleave. >> we tested her credibility in the fire of cross-examination and trial twice. her life must have been hell. >> i think it was harder the second time than it was the first time because i had already been there. i already had to tell my story to thousands of people i didn't