it was harmed. it was damaged in the hurricane. so you replaced it with deepwater horizon. in november of last year. tran ocean pulled out the blowout preventer buzz the sheer rams were not working. and the upper annualer had been stripped during a well control event. we know bp was aware of that. document number 12 in our binder reflect conference calls with bp about the problems with the blowout preventer. in addition, transocean records indicate, the incidents date that the estimated down time force bid the malfunction is a conservative ten days at 444,000, 111 per day. or $4.4 million as it shows. so how can you say blowout preventers are fail-safe devices when the blowout preventer had to be removed because of