progressive plans for 2020 and beyond. joining us to talk about the economic part of the debate fox news contributor and rnc committee from california harmeet dhillon, welcome tonight on night 2. >> thanks, shannon. i want to start with you. a number of candidates tonight say this administration will point to great numbers, unemployment, the stock market but most people don't own stock so unemployment down, it is because people are holding two or three jobs. that is the criticism but the president can talk about the economy working all day long but in real life people go to the voting booth. they aren't feeling it. what do you think? >> harmeet: i think it was very disappointing for the debate moderator allowed those types of shallow platitudes that are frankly falls to go unchallenged with no follow-up questions. the reality, shannon, unemployment the lowest in my entire lifetime and that goes across every specter of every