worked for the opposition research. that was up from behind the dossier project and that he gave the fbi two thumb drives, one for his wife and a second the cofounder of -- gps. >> bill: comments from rudy giuliani. what have we learned about that catherine. >> a new interview see an end with the president's personal attorney getting a lot of attention because a distinction between the president's action and those who work on 2016 team. >> i never said no collusion between the campaign or between people in the campaign. >> yes you have. >> i have not said the president of the united states there is not a single bit of evidence the president of the united states committed the only crime to conspire with the russians to hack the ncc. >> reaction divided as you expect on political lines. the president's critics suggest the interview opens the door to possible collusion allocations while supporters emphasize the prosecution to date have not dealt with any crimes connected