african-american, hispanic unemployment, lowest ever recorded. women's unemployment lowest in 65 years. youth unemployment lowest in 50 years. americans without a high school diploma lowest ever recorded. these are facts. richard. and so for me i just look at it from the perspective not campaigning on that we could look back tonight that was malpractice. >> bill: why do you think the calculation was made to go in a different direction? >> sometimes people take economic progress for granted. the president saw there was a huge blue wave. kavanaugh came along and the smear campaign happened and republicans got energized. and so he started seeing that these kinds of issues and the caravan happened. he started seeing momentum on the republican side to go into the elections and he is trying