birthday gifts, cars, clothes other jewelry. >> what if you propose on that day, if it's your birthday and you propose on the day, it's special for her, her birthday, does it make it more likely then it's locked down that it's a gift, nothing to do with the wedding? >> i think the engagement ring exception is a good one. if you look at his lawsuit, he bought other jewelry and he's not suing for that, probably because his lawyers told him that that kind of gift is not going to be recoverable. but engagement ring is a solid claim under florida law. i just think when a billionaire that's related to part of the koch family fights ore a ring there's more to the story. i think what he should be fearful of is counter claim. some salacious things can be put in a lawsuit f you go after somebody with salacious allegations put it in a law suit. >> counselor bruno, 15 seconds. >> in addition to that argument there's one more. that is there are some states