coffee spilled on her lap. anonymously rating companies on-line, have you ever done that? a poor decision could change the rules. diane macedo joins us with more on that. virginia appeals court ruled the site must reveal the identities of critical reviews of a carpet cleaning business. they argued the critiques were fraudulent because the users posting them under the description of the service they received didn't match up with the customer data base. they issued a subpoena for the names of 7 of the anonymous critics. they say yelp has to comply. he writes the opinion generally a yeltp review is protected because it's an opinion about a business they patronized. they can express themselves without the fear that anonymity will be pierced. it goes on to say the first amendment does not protect the