it didn't pass -- didn't mash up to the other acts presented. she wasn't a good performer with this. how long -- how often have we seen something like this. it's thought a substitute for skill. >> it's pretty ugly but curious. does this help her career? is that where we've come to? ultimately i actually sort of -- in a sick, twisted way, does it help it? >> i think perhaps in a way, maybe it does because it puts her name up there. all publicity is good publicity. these getting a ton of it today and certainly getting more tomorrow but in the long run though it seems like it's a flash in the pan. you have to have some substance to back this up. anybody can do shock and shock is really boring and tiring after a while and you have to follow it up with something a little bit more substantive and she doesn't have it. she doesn't have a great singing voice. she's a pretty girl but that's kind of where we are with this. >> people will remember it. they'll remember it. >> and i'm sure a lot of people