a middle eastern discussion in germany so i find both half of my personality struggling with each other. well first of all i think israel was founded not only because of the holocaust there would have been a state of israel or a kind of it is an institution entity in palestine with or without the holocaust this is important i think the lesson is much more to think we have to remember from the holocaust especially now that we are moving from remembering the holocaust as having the holocaust as a part of the human history because the last and victims and the last perpetrators are dying. is the university stick lessons it gives us. and i must say you know when you speak of the israelis only seventy years old and we have to let to give you time we have a basic construction full in the in the in the heart of this beautiful house called the state of israel and this is a failed partnership was palestinians. the great writers said a few days ago in the israel palestinian commemoration day he said israel will not be home by bait in arabic without us to be able without the palestinians having