At the newseum, you and your team have been charged with telling the story of the news media in society. We will talk today about news media and president s. When you think about that relationship from a macro standpoint, what has characterized the relationship between president s and the press throughout our history . Patty it is an interesting courtship, the relationship between the president s and the press. Early on during the campaign, the candidates want to woo the press. They want to put on the best face and they know the power of the press to get their message outside. But when i get in office and the confetti is down in the celebration is over and the , reality of governing comes in, and they realize that the role of the press is to be a watchdog, to be the peoples watchdog on government, to see how are they doing the job that they are doing. To be a check and balance on the president. Few president s enjoy being criticized. That is often the role of the press. So that relationship for people who dont understand that, it can go very badly. Susan we will talk about changing media over time, and also changing reporting styles. So, when did the tradition begin that the news media should be an impartial judge . So much of our history, news reporting was you read the side that you were attuned to. When did that shift . Patty it was a 20th century ideal. In the George Washington days, the press was highly partisan. Remember it was the publishers , and the printers who made the case for it being time to separate from Great Britain and king george iii. It was highly partisan. Highly volatile. Printers were being tarred and feathered. There presses were burned. We talk about how divided we are as a country, being an msnbc person or fox news person, but back in the early years of our country, in the first several presidencies it was very much , that way. Susan and even continued past the civil war era. Patty absolutely. Lincoln, you have to read both sets of newspapers to understand what was going on there. Thinking in general about successful president s, is there a correlation between president s who know how to work the newsmen and women of the time, and how they are viewed in history . Patty absolutely. I think president s who understand the media of their day are able to deal with it smoothly, understand the press, make friends with the press. We saw with john f. Kennedy how he had that relationship with members of the press who knew things about his private life that were perhaps not very flattering and chose to overlook it. Of course, it was a different time then. President s who understand the role of journalists who respect them for what they do, who respect the First Amendment. Freedom of the press, we were the first country to make that part of our governing laws, so it is very important to our very foundation, the dna of the country. So it is president s who are not thin skinned, who understand the role of the press as being the voice of the people, and those who understand the medium of their day and are able to project through that medium. Susan we will dig into history, but not in chronological order. I want to start with the nixon presidency. The relationship between president nixon and the press seemed strained throughout much of his public life. John farrell just did a landmark nixon biography, and if you look in the index there are 16 citations under medias mutual enmity with nixon, setting the stage for it. During the cold war as a senator, he made a name for himself as a anticommunist warrior. The media in the 1940s and 1950s looked on an in those days, looked on him in those days and when did it begin to , change . He made a name for himself with mccarthy and elder hess. It was during the red scare, where people were terrified that there might be communists in our government. There were communists in our government. And yet the republic still stands. We are here. Then he is on the ticket with eisenhower on his Vice President ial ticket, and the report surfaces that mr. Nixon has perhaps taken finances from someone he should not have done so, so he goes on television and he is in hot water with eisenhower, goes on television and gives his famous checkers speech. Probably the height of nixon in successful television. He talks about the only present he has ever gotten was his dog, checkers, and so americans thought, oh, what a good daddy is. What a good guy he is. So he becomes Vice President. In his presidency, his mistrust of the press is a landmark of his time in office. After he loses his first run, he goes back to california and then loses another race for governor in california, and at a famous press conference he says, you are not going to have me to kick around anymore. Two members of the press that is , his attitude. That is pretty much prevailing. During the white house era, he creates an enemy list of reporters who are friendly, who are not friendly, has the f. B. I. Investigating reporters. So that poor relationship with the press is never resurrected. It doesnt help when two young journalists from the Washington Post dig into the watergate breakin and he resigned from his presidency. Susan in John Farrells biography, he writes the California Press corps believed nixon was using the Governors Office as a stepping stone, and bridled at his expectation that they owed him a free pass. They met him with skepticism and sometimes hostility. He returned the favor, labeling them as prostitutes and hatchet men. Patty tough to get over that. [laughter] that kind of a conversation. How do you get past that, and of course, you have the famous kennedynixon debates, where nixon had come out of hospital, his had an infection and he doesnt look good. The first nationally televised president ial debates. John f. Kennedy, handsome in front of the camera a former , journalist himself. People who listened to the debate on the radio thought nixon had more content, but the people who saw it on television were mesmerized with kennedy. And his telegenic appeal. Susan really interesting because you cited two earlier experiences, where he seems to understand the power of the media. The televised committee hearings, and then the checkers speech. So was it more of a circumstance you think of his illness, or is it not known why he did not do so well in the kennedynixon debates . Patty i think people generally feel that they asked kennedy, did he want makeup, he said, no, i dont. Nixon thought it was perhaps not manly to put makeup on. That was probably a bad gamble on his part. Makeup makes everyone look because of course better on , television. Not you, susan. You look perfect. That was the decision he made. The illness did not help. It was a poor performance on television. But radio, better. Susan once the watergate story broke after his landslide election, when we look at what happened between the white house and how the white house that day responded to crises versus what were seeing with the white house today responding it was a , very different era in the media. What are some of the lessons on reporting around the time of watergate, and what the media was like then, versus today . Patty i think coverup is always a mistake. Whenever you are putting so much energy in a coverup, it is always a bad sign. They really circled the wagons against the press and the media. The saturday night massacre events that happened. We are seeing elements of that today with the trump presidency. The sudden people leaving office, people who have served their government and their country for decades and decades as Civil Servants and as military servants, suddenly leaving. Those are anomalies that the press is going to cover. When shocking things like that happen, the press has to give people an understanding of what is going on. Susan we have our first piece of video to share with you in the audience. This is Richard Nixon and a postwatergate story breaking news conference, november 17, 1973. Just a little glimpse of how he reacts and interacts with the media. Lets watch. [video clip]. I want to say this to the television audience. I made my mistakes, but in all of my years of public life, i have never profited from public service. I earned every cent. And in all of my years of public life, i have never obstructed justice. And i think, too, that i can say in my years of public life, that i welcome this kind of examination, because people have got to know whether or not their president is a crook. Well, im not a crook. Ive earned everything ive got. Patty those are words that would go back to haunt him. What is the headline every newspaper will say, i am not a crook, Richard Nixon. Yet he resigned his office. In ignomy. That defensive tactic you see in him on television does not play well on that medium. He comes off sounding defensive all the way through. When he says, i am not a crook, the immediate thing you think is yes, he might be. Susan from the media side, a whole generation of young people were drawn into the business of journalism after woodward and bernstein. How did newspaper reporting change and coverage of the president change as a result of watergate . Patty i think many young journalists saw it as a field that would be one where you could do good for society. You could unearth conspiracy. Correct injustice, draw attention to stories that otherwise were not being told. I think there were a whole generation of people who went into journalism because of the woodward and bernstein, and the power they had, in the important story they did. I think the relationship, the cozy relationship the press and president s had, for example, in the kennedy years, is not there much more. It became distrustful after the vietnam war, and the pentagon papers that revealed that the government had been misleading the public. About how well the word is doing. Many it was a counterculture era where young people were challenging their elders. We have a president who has gone down to resignation in shame. Many things are happening culturally that are leading people to distrust authority in general. That attitude reverberates in the press. Susan just eight years earlier in the election that nixon lost, brought kennedy to power a very , different relationship between the president and the media. The term camelot often used to refer to the time. What are the things to know about how the press and john kennedy interacted during his presidency . Patty john kennedy and his wife, jacqueline, understood the power of image, understood the power their telegenic young family would have on the American Public. We come from the eisenhower years of a much older president and first lady, suddenly, we have this first lady who is like a hollywood star. She sells magazine covers just by her presence. She is mysterious and softspoken. Those Young Children in the white house really get a generation of americans excited about, these people are going through the same thing i am going through. The baby boom generation is watching these Young Children grow up in the white house. Kennedy was very comfortable with the press, comfortable with the intellectual debate about ideas, and criticism about himself. You saw that in the days after his inauguration. He has the first live president ial conference. Press conference. You see the bantering, that sense of humor he has. He charms the American Public and the press. They admit later that they do not holding to the same standard that they might have, were he not such a personally engaging person. He had a great friend in bradley at newsweek, and a senator at the Washington Post. Those connections helped him make his way in the washington power structure. Susan another citation from john farrell on this, he wrote, kennedy could curse the press, tap their phones, keep a private blacklist and piteously crush a foe, but with the confidence of wealth, good looks and breeding, he did not let the pressure got to him. The storms past and the temp is eased by irony or humor. Nixon didnt have that quality. So is it somewhat about personality and the relationship with the press . Patty it is absolutely about personality. I think you see that. President trump has been elected, he is a Reality Television star. His personality is one that resonates with a large percent of the american population. Personality is really critical, i think and i think president s who understand the best way to get their personality across through the prevailing media of the day are often the most successful. Susan we will go back further in time in history, but before we do, a little bit about you. So people know who they are listening to. What is your job in the newseum . Patty i am the Vice President of content and exhibits. I have this wonderful job where we tell the story of the five freedoms of the First Amendment, and how americans can use them to effect change from the Civil Rights Era and onward. I have a great job. Susan how long has the newseum been open . Patty the newseum had been open for 22 years. Sadly we will close our location on december 31 to the public and go off into the future and figure out our mission for the future, because our mission has never been more important to explain to people, the five freedoms of the First Amendment, particularly the role of the freedom of the press. Susan the newseum is funded by admission fees, and how else . Patty our primary funder is the freedom forum, our parent organization. We also have donors. Who have helped sustain us throughout the years. And ticket prices from the people who come to see us. Susan i am sure many people watching have made it a part of there washington, d. C. Visits when they come to the nations , capital. Do you have plans for where all the exhibits might be going . Patty we have our first traveling exhibit scheduled, rise up, stonewall and the l bdt q movement will travel to the , museum of popculture in seattle next june. We also have a Pulitzer Prize exhibit on the road. We have 40 chances about the power of photography to uncover the causes of hunger. So we have a lot of exhibits on the road. We will be continuing our programs and a robust walk around the journalist memorial, where we highlight journalists who have given their all, given their lives to report the truth to people around the world. Susan you came to this job as a reporter and editor. Tell me about your journalism career. Patty my first job was at a small newspaper in huntington, west virginia. For the kennett chain, the hunting advertiser that folded shortly after i got there. I went to the morning paper, the herald dispatch. I worked there three years. Then i came to usa today as a founding editor. It was really exciting. It was a startup. No one knew anything about us. Then it became the largest newspaper in the country. That was a really exciting ride to have. Patty what took you to journalism in the first place . A little bit of woodward and bernstein. That passion of the 1970s to see high combined skills writing and telling stories with a desire to make the world a better place. Susan as you look at the world of journalism from when you started or even when usa today began, what are the differences today and those earlier years . Patty gosh, i wish i could be more optimistic, but there were many more journalists in the 1970s than there are right now. The losses that Mainstream Press print publications have had to the digital news era have been decimating. Particularly to local journalism. There are places where there are news deserts where there are no news outlets covering the news for a large swath of the American People. That is very troubling. We have seen the rise of Digital Media and the rise of social media. People see things on facebook and they see it as fact, when it is not reported like when journalists do fact checking. Im calling multiple sources. There really are not two sides to the story, there are multiple sides to the story. I would like to be an optimist. I would like to think the American People are going to see that members of the press are critical to our democracy, and will start supporting media. Weather is printer podcasts. Get your news from good sources, but because the truth matters. Susan in september, the Pew Organization did one of its regular surveys on Public Attitudes and at that time, they reported that only 41 of the public they surveyed saw the news media as fair arbiters, honest brokers of what is going on. And if you look to the next level, a big partisan divide, much more trusted by democrats than republicans. What is going on there, do you think . Patty we do a survey, the freedom form does an annual survey, the state of the First Amendment. And our numbers are a little better than that, people are feeling better about the press. I would say it has to do with your political point of view. The internet and Digital Media has allowed us to stay in digital bubbles of our own thought. We can go to a place where we can only see red state news, or only see blue state news, which reinforces your ideas about the world, the government and the role of the press. I think the press missed a big story in 2016 when donald trump was elected. Much of the Mainstream Media poohpoohed that possibility and said Hillary Clinton was going to win. I think perhaps the news media needed to do some soulsearching after that how can we better serve the public, how can we better do the job we are here to do . Susan we will continue and go back to the very founding. George washington, the only president elected unanimously. How long was his honeymoon . Patty not very long, sadly. [laughter] George Washington first comes to the press, he is a land owner, he uses newspapers to advertise for runaway slaves and things like that, so he is a person of that era. As a general, he is critical of the press because he sees the press as revealing the location to the enemy too often. Nevertheless, he is reading the loyalist newspapers, loyal to the crown, of course. To find out movements of the british army. And he has a rock. He is the father of a country. So when he comes into office, again, a highly Partisan Press starts sniping at him, accusing him of all sorts of malfeasance, he is taken aback by it. He is quite thinskinned about it and he does not appreciate it. Of course, later in life, he is the father of our country. His reputation stands the test of time, but in office, he does not appreciate the criticism about him. This highly Partisan Press is that saying really horrible things about him. Tough to read. Susan historians in mount vernon have an interesting statistic. They write that the popular press exploded from under 50 newspapers in 1776 to over 250 newspapers by 1800, encouraged by new federal laws that made it cheaper to send newspapers through the post. So the politicians, although they are unhappy with the coverage, still enable the growth of the news media. During that era. Patty he subscribed to 30 plus newspapers, he is a voracious newsreader of the press. Despite his smarting at the criticism he received at the hands of the press, on the night before he died, he was sitting there reading the paper, discussing the news of the day. He understood the Important Role of the press to inform the public about critical events. Susan historian ron chernow, of hamilton fame, used it to give a was asked to speak to the wash Correspondents Dinner in april 2019 and he used it to give a History Lesson on the relationship between the president and the press. We have a clip on what he said about George Washington. [video clip] Ron Washington became the victim of the most preposterous slander when the Opposition Press charged he had been a secret british agent throughout the revolutionary war. Obviously, the british had gotten a very poor return on their investment. [laughter] some of the most blistering attacks against washington came from an unexpected source, his secretary of state, Thomas Jefferson, that hired a poet as state department translator. In truth jefferson had recruited him to found a party organ called the national gazette, that would publish slashing broadsides against the very president jefferson served. The poet performed his task with such malicious gusto that he would drop off copies of his incendiary paper on washingtons doorstep everyday. It is hard to convey the anguish that seized washingtons mind as he reels from press criticism. Susan any additional comments on washington after watching that . Patty he understands the power of the press to move people during the dark moment of the revolutionary war. He has his generals gathered to read to the troops thomas , paynes crisis. He says it is time to part. Reading quotes from that the dark of the night, the terrible moment of the war when things are cold, there is not much food, he is trying to rally the troops with the words of why we need to do this. These are the times that try mens souls. Imagine how moving that would have been. And how powerfully George Washington must have thought about the people who were writing these words that were inspiring this new nation to be birthed. Susan did his successor have the same powerful feelings about the role of the press in society, john adams . [laughter] patty john adams also does not appreciate being criticized by the press. During his administration, we have the alien and sedition acts. At that point, we are kind of on the verge of war with france. So these acts are passed, one of which makes it illegal to criticize the president or the congress. This is a way that the government is saying, we dont want anyone to be undermining our government at this time of war, when were possibly at the verge of war. And that the passage of the act, just a few years after the First Amendment has been passed, is the first test of this First Amendment freedom, freedom of the press. It leads to adams being a one term president , and leads to jefferson being elected, because people did not like the idea of their freedom of the press, which they did not have under the king, being undermined in any way. Susan lets return to ron chernow for a minute. [video clip] during the administration of john adams, the country lurched into a period of reaction in the medium, rampant fear of foreigners. Congress enacted the alien and sedition acts, which made it a crime for journalists to write about the president in a scandalous or malicious fashion. At this dark moment, jefferson with his prophecy with a little patience, we shall see the reign of witches passed, their spells dissolved. Let it be known that john adams not only lost his Reelection Campaign in 1800, but his jeffersonian opponents reigned supreme for the next quarter century. Susan however, we heard Thomas Jefferson was not above using reporting to go after washingtons policies, and he also had some difficulties himself reporting about his own private life during his administration. What are the lessons of Thomas Jefferson . Patty Thomas Jefferson is an idealist. The famous quote of given the choice of government with no newspapers, or newspapers with no government, i would not hesitate to choose the latter. That quote is often used as he is a champion of the First Amendment and freedom of the press. But again, once you are in office and the long knives come out, and again a very highly , Partisan Press, the republicans versus the federalists, the debate goes on. The scurrilous charges those andthe scurrilous charges those newspapers are throwing at politicians at the time would really shock people today, the language that was used in the things that were said. He did not appreciate that. So while he likes the ideal of the First Amendment and freedom of the press, he wants the press to be available to all, he wants everyone to be literate, everyone is not literate at the time, nor are they today for that matter. He wants people to have access to the press. He wants the press to be literate. And also, even though he was a champion of the First Amendment, he thinks perhaps the states can deal with the issues of libel and press freedom on that. He doesnt see the dichotomy of so that idea that, yes, we are , for freedom of the press and its glorious openness, and yet, perhaps, there might be some ways that the states themselves can limit it somewhat. Susan we are going to fastforward to Abraham Lincoln the president facing probably , the greatest test of any president , the civil war. You have described his relationship with the press as complicated. Why . Patty he comes to office at a time with two incredible innovations are happening with mass media. One is the rise of photography, and the other is the transcontinental telegraph. People can get news more quickly than they have before. This works out well for his generals during the civil war. It also works out well for the American People getting news of the war and how it has gone much more quickly than it has before. And also photography although newspapers at the time do not have the integral capabilities to publish photography and newspapers, there were galleries on pennsylvania avenue of Matthew Bradys photographs. Famously, lincoln gives a speech at cooper union in new york. Matthew brady takes a photograph of that. It is replicated in woodcarvings in newspapers. Like harpers weekly. Abraham lincoln gives credit. He said, it was Matthew Brady and the Cooper Union Speech that made me the president today. It is the power of images that people relate to, understanding you and to see you as a person and to understand you. Lincoln was adept at that. Susan how about by the time the war was really raging . There were partisan newspapers on both sides. How did he react to the coverage of the news about him . What should we learn about his time dealing with reporters under crisis . Patty well, he is known to have hung out at telegraph offices, hung out with journalists. He invited journalists to the white house. But when the war is getting to its intense points the secretary of war stanton, has no problem dismissing certain journalists who are not reporting the news the way they want it to be. He limits access to the telegraph, which of course will kill a reporter who is trying to get the news more quickly to his readership. Journalists are arrested and charged with various treason and other things at the time. And lincoln kind of looks the other way. Susan so he always tops surveys as our greatest leader among president s. With that sort of record, and the restrictions of rights and the media, what do you think why do you think people have forgiven that and processed that and still put him at the top of , the list . Those are some pretty serious reactions to his coverage . Patty they are. But i think we found like after 9 11, people are willing to give up their First Amendment freedoms in the case of security, and i think president s play off that that sometimes to an extreme degrees of the threat of the freeflowing media and people can have. Susan we have an image from the library of congress to give a little flavor of the criticism Abraham Lincoln faced. I will explain this, because people will not be able to see on closeup, but it is a cartoon, a depiction of columbia, the united states, who is confronting president lincoln and says, mr. Lincoln, give me back my 500,000 sons. At the right, the cartoonist sits with a proclamation calling for 500,000 more troops, signed by him and his reply is, the fact is, by the way, that reminds me of a story. The archivist says, it is referring to false reports published by the new york world that lincoln had joked on the , battlefield at antietam. So a critical press, and the , president under siege, both politically and with the media around him. As we close on the lincoln era, what was changing with the news media . There is telegraph, photography, they were partisan. Are we about to enter a new age of reporting as we leave the civil war era, and come to a more stable time . Patty not quite yet. [laughter] getting a bit better. He has been criticized more by he is been criticized by both the north and the southern press. Publishers from all sides were going after lincoln. The nature ofly war at a time that is renting our country apart. Kind of like what is happening today in that very few people are pleased when hundreds of thousands of young men are losing their lives to a battle that some feel was not necessary. Of course, we now know that was a transformational moment in our nations history and that is why lincoln, more books have been written about him than any other president. He is still seen as incredibly heroic for getting the country through that horrific period. Susan as we start to grasp to progress through the later part of the 19th century we start to hear the biggest names in the newspaper world and newspaper history. Peelers are, etc. What is happening to the american consumption of the news in the latter part of the century and the people who , publish them . Patty pulitzer is a good example. The new york sun the mass media. The mass media is really happening. The penny press. More newspapers being published, more people having access to them. There is a newspaper war between pulitzer and hearst. Theyre trying for provocative coverage. Pulitzer has done a lot of things to really push coverage forward. He understands the power of the type of coverage womens coverage, making newspapers more accessible to the common man. Not everyone is highly educated at this time. So, the fact that he is making the media more open to the public is really a huge moment. Susan by the time Theodore Roosevelt comes into office at the dawn of the 20th century, big changes with how he treats the press. Tell me about some of them. Patty Teddy Roosevelt is a very big personality. He understands the power of the press to help get his image and ideas across. He makes friends with the press, if they are friendly with him, makes them feel like they are part of his work. He brings the press to the white house, very close to his office. So there is that intimacy people feel, that when he is sitting down with members of the press and saying, i am going to tell you this, but just put this on a highlevel source, or an anonymous source. It makes the reporters feel like they are in on the story, and makes them feel like they are part of the presidency, which is a tricky place for journalists to be. He is very much aware the power of the soundbite, the power of image. He does things that make news he goes down in a submarine on long island sound, he arrives on he rides on horseback for 98 miles, to prove to the first to the press that he is a robust as the military standards would have soldiers be. These are all incredible moments that the press, which is looking to grab the publics interest with things that are other than drony, zoning board reports, everybody wants to see that. A president in the submarine. That is a fun story. He understands that power. His soundbites like to softly and carry a big stick or my hat is in the ring. The early soundbites. These are things that capture the American Public, that plain speaking style. His image is a powerful part of his presidency. Susan interesting thing from his presidency, he is credited with establishing press relations as an official function at the white house. He established the first press room at the white house and elevated the press secretary to the level of cabinet position. Patty yes. Now he is understanding, this will be important to my life. I need to have members of the press on my side to sell me as at the president and to sell my programs. And he clearly understood that. Susan on the other hand, it was the age of the progressive journalist, Upton Sinclair and ,da tarbell, Lincoln Steffens they would not always buy into the Roosevelt Program or to the majority storyline at the time. How did he react to those folks . Patty in his lovely turn of phrase, he labeled them muckrakers, people who were willing to dig up dirt but not offer solutions to it. That is really casting a so negative brush against people who are doing significant journalism about the ills of our country, about lynching, and corporations that are doing things that are hurting people. He just says, no, they are not offering solutions, which is really quite painful. To the important work being done at the time. Susan the term muckraker stays with us today. Patty it does indeed. Susan what does it mean today . Patty it is a badge of courage. It is a moment of pride. Muckraker. You are bringing up stories that people dont want to be seen, shining a light on places that are dark and it shouldnt be. Susan lets move on into history and head into the fdr era. Not really too many years, but the world is changing by the time fdr and eleanor come along. In our conversations before, you said you think fdr perhaps had the best press relations during the 20th century. Why is that . Patty i think he understood the press. I think he also understood the importance of the time he was living in and the moment that he was trying to get across the American People. He used the fireside chats and people felt like he was talking to them directly. My friends, he would say, and people would be leaning into the radio. You see those wonderful photographs. He considered himself a bit of a writer. Of course, Eleanor Roosevelt had her Radio Program and wrote magazine columns as well. They had an understanding of the power of radio and newspapers to get their message across to people. He made his voice the voice that everyone would trust during times of the great depression, during the world war. That unity of message and the unity of voice really helped get americans through major crises of our history in a way that came out in a positive way. He, interestingly enough, these newspaper publishers, often republicans committed not like republicans did not like all the changes he was having because business sacrifices had to be made. So even though newspapers were not often behind him, supporting his candidacy, the American People saw through that and saw what he was doing, and those very practiced radio side chats, he would rehearse and rehearse and rehearse, so the message would get across exactly the way he wanted it to get across. Really a powerful, powerful statement. The press again, being very respectful of him. He contracted polio and as a result, he couldnt walk unaided. But there was just a general , rule that it was verboten to show him on his crutches, even though he would joke about him. Even though he would joke about it. On the rare occasion that newspapers and magazines would show an image of him, or mention his legs were useless the , American People would write back and say, dont say that about our president. Interestingly enough, magazines and publications kind of backed off on that. It is interesting, where the American Public is drawing a line in the sand out of what they expect out of their press at that moment. Susan if you had to characterize the majority attitude of reporters covering the white house at the time, were they critical of his . Olicies we are talking about image, but on a policy standpoint, where they critical or mostly supportive of what the president was trying to do . Patty mostly supportive, but there were things he couldnt get through, even with all his charm initiatives couldnt get through, but mostly supportive. Susan we should have a note about Eleanor Roosevelt, her contributions to the evolution of reporting. She actually had a press had press conference as as first lady. Is, that sheng insisted that women reporters covered her as she progressed through the white house years. How important was that in the evolution of journalism . Patty absolutely critical. Thank you, eleanor. Long overdue. It was very rare that there were women journalists at the time, and making that statement was a crucial one. Of course it is several years after that before women are more widely seen in newsrooms. Like in the 1970s is really when that happens, as well as people of color. So, putting that line in the sand is an important one. To get careers started, to get people thinking that women had a role in this industry, as in every industry. Susan we will jump from the 1940s to the 1960s and Lyndon Johnson. He comes into office under the worst circumstances, the assassination of john kennedy. Did he have a honeymoon as president after that . Patty he did. He, again, very much understood the power of image. The famous photo when he being sworn in on air force one, he makes sure that newly widowed Jacqueline Kennedy is seen. And that image. And what a horrific request that must have been for him to make that request in a horrible moment in her life, not just to say to the American People, but to send to the world, that this government will continue. There is continuity. There is no coup. I am in charge. The torch has been passed. He goes into a series of legislative successes, landmark civil rights legislation is passed. Much on the glow of the kennedy presidency and wanting to see many of kennedys ideas put forth into action. But then, as happens with many president s, the vietnam war leads to his denouement. Susan how important is it, that themselves had built their own media empire . Patty very important. In texas, Lady Bird Johnson purchased a radio station, than they had newspapers, so that really helped him on his rise in texas. We have seen lbj corralling legislatures with the fingerpointing and that very intimidating style, and that was very much his style with the press. He felt like you were either for him or against him. He was not below calling your boss if your boss was president of the network, if the story you had done if it did not please him. So he is trying to work both sides of it, trying to be friends with reporters as well as the powerful moguls who run the various Broadcasting Companies and newspapers at the time, but you can see where that doesnt play very well if you are a reporter on the beat, that he will call out on cbs if you do a story that displeases him. Which he did to morley safer when he did a famous report out of vietnam that showed marines using lighters to torch civilian villages. Of course, there were multiple sides to the story. The televised images being seen on the evening news horrified americans as well as lbj, and he called the head of the network to complain about it. Susan at this point in time, the three network newscasts were really dominant in society. Would you talk about how people were consuming news, and how president s managed to use that consumption of everyone at tuning in at the same time to watch news to their benefit . Patty the three Evening Network news shows was the way most people got their news, and it still is the way most people get their news, broadcast news. It is being rivaled by internet but it is still the way most people get their news. There was a very powerful, those three gentlemen who were sending the news to everybody each night were very powerful forces. At a moment in the vietnam war when Walter Cronkite goes to vietnam and says it appears the vietnam war will be a stalemate. Says if sees this, he ive lost cronkite, i have lost the American Public and the vietnam war. He knows the power of Walter Cronkite making on the evening news and most people tuning in is a critical moment in his presidency. Susan we have one of the famous Lyndon Johnson phone calls in 1968 to serve as an example of that relationship you talked about, about not being afraid to pick up the phone and express his anger about things. Lets listen. [audio recording] frank, i wanted to tell you about hanging my head in this hand. Particularly at cronkite and what i would say, very unfair, personalized reporting of these fellows. I think you ought to know that opinion because you would be disappointed with me down the road if i did not tell you that. I am just telling you, frankly that i think the industry is wrecking all of us. Susan reaction . Patty that is pretty heavyhanded. You can imagine what it was like for the journalist the next day. I am sure he would not call the journalist the next day that so offended him in the press conference. The fact that he says, wrecking the country, very disturbing. We are hearing that today, that the press is the enemy of the people according to President Trump. The press is not the enemy of the American People. The press is out there doing the work of the American People, trying to inform on people in power. Is your local school board spending the money the way it should, are your students being educated . How . Is the government working . How should be working . Our children being kept in cages are . Children being kept in cages these are stories that are important and critical to us, and the fact that president s question the patriotism of reporters trying to do their jobs, is very troubling. Susan during the vietnam war, there were regular press conferences that give out figures that were inaccurate about the casualties happening in vietnam, hoping, i think, to keep Public Opinion about the war at bay. What did that do to the skepticism of journalists . We talked earlier about the impact of watergate. What was the effect of the vietnamera as reporters were sitting through these press conferences and then finding out the numbers were not jiving with what was happening on the ground . Patty it leads to major mistrust. You talked about the credibility gap lbj had with the American People and the press. That phrase would really come to haunt him. Again, we see the things happening in society, changes with the counterculture. People no longer trusting the government. They lied to us about the vietnam war. 55,000 people are dead in this country because of that, and they have lied to us about this. Television news showing images of the war, there were images, the korean war was on television a bit, but each week, the drumbeat of these numbers of casualties in vietnam, it takes a toll on the American Public. The images that they see and the fact that it is not going well, and they do not understand why we are there in the first place leads to lbj deciding he will not run for reelection. Susan lets move to more current times. Earlier, you made reference to the public in the wartime the willing to give up their rights, especially to the freedom of speech. Would you talk about the aftermath of 9 11 and what happened in this country with the American Public, and the willingness to trade some of their rights for security, especially in the relationship between the press and the president . Patty i would say we saw people lashing out at people who questioned in any way the war effort or the aftermath of 9 11. People who were questioning, were we going after the right people . People were being seen as not being patriotic. The American People did not like that. They felt that we should be monolithically behind whatever the president says we should be doing. That is not the role of the press. Once again, it is the role of the press to question authority, are we doing the right thing . In the aftermath, we found out and of course that wars were , waged for really no connection to 9 11 at all. Susan by 2008, president obama was coming into office, the wars were going on. Still. At the same time, we have the historic election with americas first africanamerican president. What happened with the relationship between Obama White House and the press as he came into office . What was that like . Patty i think the president was aware of the historic nature of his presidency. Obama was not the first president ial candidate to use the power of social media, but he certainly did it very skillfully, with targeted emails and targeted radio, reports of people and Popular Culture. I mean, his yes we can, will. I. Am of the black eyed peas makes a powerful video that is seen millions of times by people. Pop culture figures weighing in on the obama presidency. Oprah winfrey, before he even throws his hat in the ring says, put your money behind barack obama. So the historic nature of his , presidency, the fact that this was a moment in this nations history that people had long longed for, leads to a bit of a long honeymoon. But then when he clashes with congress and when his Campaign Promises are not always able to be realized, things change. He is also president understands who understands understands the medium at this time. He is the first president to go on the daily show with jon stewart, a latenight satirical news program that captured the attention of young people at the time. He goes on between two ferns with zach geffen like us he goes on a crazy comedy show. But he understands the power of these people, forces in Popular Culture to get a message to people that he might not otherwise be reaching. Susan however, there were some times during his administration when he cracked down on whistleblowers. The administration actually monitored phone records, subpoenaed reporters, lets not mow notably the james rison case from the New York Times. How do we put all of that through an understanding of how this administration approached these situations with the media . Patty control of image. That is what all president s wants to do, they want to control the image. He did not like the idea that people were leaking information or trying to get information that he did not want to be made public. So barack obama is not exactly a , First Amendment champion. Up until this time, he has prosecuted more journalists and whistleblowers than any other presidency in history. Susan how have you told his story in the newseum . Patty with head photo exhibits about president obama. Photo exhibits every four years about the campaign and the press. Talk about his incredible social media clout. Clout,in, social media using it for yourself, socialmedia also bites back. There were journalists who captured unscripted moments of him on the campaign trail, that ended up reverberating as not being very flattering. Things that he said, the famous things he said about people hiding behind their guns and religion in pennsylvania. These were dings in the long history of his two terms in. Ffice nonetheless, the incredible access socialmedia lends to everyone in the world means that people have access to the moments you wouldnt them to that you would not like them to have access to as well. Susan throughout history, you have told us each president has tried to access the press to put harness that effectively, to put their own story forward. Now that we come to the 2016 election and the real rise of social media, and then we have a a president who is the first president with his own twitter account that he uses all the , time by himself, what has been the effect of having a president with direct access to the public, sort of bypassing the traditional media to speak to the public and especially his supporters . Patty it has been a powerful powerful tool that the president has. The fact that he doesnt have to go through any gatekeepers, people saying, wait a minute, that is not exactly true. That is a very powerful force. He has dozens of millions of followers who are reading exactly what he wants them to say. Theres no questioning it. Theres no secondguessing. It is just, this is what the truth is according to me. That is a very big threat of the press and the role that the press has played traditionally. Traditionally played as gatekeepers of news and information. So it is a period that the news , industry is struggling with itself, how do we counter that . How do we counter someone who goes and spews forth on his social media channels, information that we know is not true . How do you counter that . I think the press is still struggling with the best way to do that. Susan at the same time he is speaking directly to the public on his twitter account, he also regular the criticizes and strong terms the news media. ,patty he does. Susan we have one final clip we want to show. He is criticizing of the New York Times for their coverage. Lets watch, then we will wrap this all up. [video clip] pres. Trump i came from jamaica, queens. To make estates. I became president of the united states. I am sort of entitled to a great story, just one, from the from my newspaper, i mean you know . He just wanted his hometown paper to write one positive story about him. He just wants the times to that to Say Something nice about him. I am sort of entitled to just one good story in the New York Times. I started off, i ran against very smart people. A lot of them. He said that a few times. I just think i am entitled to a great story from the New York Times. I have done something nobody has ever done. Susan this was the podcast the New York Times crated after their oval Office Exchange with the president about their coverage. What do you hear in the president s voice there . Patty it is a little sad. I am entitled to something nice from my hometown newspaper. You see the validation he wants from the New York Times, which he calls the failing New York Times now. Because they have not given him that puffball of a story he wanted on the presidency. Electedn, he was not king but president of the united states. With the checks and balances peoples right to free speech. And power of assembly and protest, President Trump like all president s has endured those First Amendment freedoms. It is not always pleasant to be on the other end of that. But it is the role of the press to be challenging, to be critical, to question things for the American People, that is what the role of the press is. Susan lets bring it all the way back and put a ribbon around this conversation today. When we look back across our entire history of relationships between the president s and the reporters, journalists covering him sometimes, hack newspapers depending on the era we are in. What are the important takeaways people should have about this relationship, how it has worked, and how it has benefited society . Patty i think the important part would be for the president s to respect the role of the press, and its importance in society, and respect the fact that they will get criticism at some point. And perhaps learn from the criticism. It is important for president s to understand the power of the media. They certainly do. We have got michael bloomberg, who just threw his hat in the ring. He has got a powerful global news network. That will be interesting to see how that plays out. The press played a Critical Role in our democracy. It is why the Founding Fathers made it the First Amendment of the constitution, that the power of the press congress will not change that power of the freedom of the press. So i think it is important that president s remember that and be and respect the role of the press. I think that by that mutual respect, that comes across in the information people get in order to make important decisions about their life and their country. Susan patty rhule, you have spent the last decade and a half helping people understand how the news media works. Thank you so much force many an hour with us and helping us understand more about the evolution of the relationship between president s and the journalists who cover them. Patty thank you, susan. I appreciate it. Announcer all q a programs are available on our website, or as a podcast at cspan. Org. [captioning performed by the national captioning institute, which is responsible for its caption content and accuracy. Visit ncicap. Org] [captions Copyright National cable satellite corp. 2019] this weekend coauthors david and kayla talk about their book great wartime escapes and rescues. An illustrated talk they focus on world war ii prisoners of war and concentration camps. Heres a preview. Some of you know the story, probably parts of it from the great escape. It was pretty fictionalized account but an entertaining one nonetheless. You mentioned the cooler king and im glad you did because this is a character Steve Mcqueen was based on. He was known as the cooler king because he was captured and escaped several times. He was a native texan who had volunteered for the Royal Canadian air force in june of 1940 and earn his pilots wings and gone to britain to file i spitfires. He was shot down on a mission near calais and france. He was one of most heavily punished prisoners and will were two, spending six months in solitary confinement. His first stint came after a prank against the german guards. The guards were trying to count the prisoners, as they often did. Several men including ash started milling around. If you have ever tried to count kindergartners you can imagine, it is similar. [laughter] the guards did not find it funny, ended up in the cooler. That was his first extreme to the cooler. Then he tried to escape. That was his first experience. He was caught hiding in the shower room. He got two weeks in the cooler for that. The camp became overcrowded. He was at stall log lift three. Stalag luffe 3. The day he got there he was tried to escape again. He rolled under a train and got to the other side and ran and they caught him. And put them in the cooler again for a couple of weeks. This time he had secured a nail file and was trying to get out of his cell when they caught him , another two weeks for that. You see a pattern here. [laughter] cooler and he the tries to cut the fence with wire cutters. That time he did not get caught. His two compadres did. He also toddled out and was caught. He spent 10 days in the cooler for that one. He did escape from a camp in lithuania and was on the loose for a couple of weeks. Again, was caught, this time they said they were going to execute him because he was problematic to keep in. Back. D they sent him while he was in the clear that time is when the great escape took place. So he cannot participate in the great escape because he was in the cooler at the time. Learn more about during what were to escapes and rescues, sunday at 6 30 p. M. Eastern here on American History tv. Q a, look atht on american president s through the lens of the books they have written, with journalist and historian craig fairman. The story has often been any solomon the pearson quote. Kennedys father was the one pulling the strings behind the scene but that was not true. Jack kennedy wanted the Pulitzer Prize and there were multiple times he brought it up. He told historian i would rather win a Pulitzer Prize then be president. Because he had the strong desire for literary fame even though he did not really want to do literary work, he got himself the prize. In new york city, and washington, d. C. , people have been gossiping, kennedy really write that book . I one who really wrote that book . I wonder how much money theyre getting out of that royalty checks . The pulitzer changed the equation. It made it a moral question and an ethical question. Readers are like this too. When i was at that kennedy president ial library, i looked at the letters kennedy was receding in 1957 librarians were sending letters and School Children were sending letters, saying did you really write this book . They were responding to the interview and said you would not have accepted the prize if you do not write the book . Watch sunday night at 8 00 p. M. Eastern on cspans q a. 00 p. M. , and on eastern on afterwards. Sally pikes makes the argument against medicare for all in her latest book, a false premise cometh false promise. In december there were over 4 million britons on a waiting list to get treatment. The Cancer Treatment is not supposed to be delayed from seeing a general practitioner to getting treatment more than 62 days. They have not met in that you kate that standard for over five years. In the uk. In the World Health Organization study, brits are the bottom of the wrong in most industrialized countries. Watch sunday night on book to be on cspan2. Next, James Madison professor Andrew Witmer teaches about rural areas after the civil war. Using his hometown as a case study, he examines rural industry, such as slave mining, and the rise of country tourism aided by the expansion of railroad networks. Good afternoon. Welcome to this class. Our topic today is smalltown maine and the world. And the little2, monson in central maine has a big problem. The town has bounced back from a fire downtown, destroying many of the buildings in