Done yet, and it will be a major battle to get all parties to agree to this deal. Not the least of which would be israeli Prime Minister benjamin yahoo, aaron korsh has been staunchly opposed. All right. Thank you very much. Kylie atwood in beijing tonight and thanks so much to all of you for being with us anderson starts now good, evening welcome to our continuing special prompt time covers the fastmoving trump Hush Money Trial date eight saw three witnesses testify. Former National Enquirer publisher david pecker, wrapping up a week on the stand, former trump personal assistant or rhona graff seemingly undermining the former president is denial about faris has Stormy Daniels and Karen Mcdougal and a former executive of the bank or Michael Cohen arrange the, uh, hundred and 30,000 daniels payout . Were on a graph under defense crossexamination in meetings, she was not testifying by choice, but nonetheless, telling prosecutors that she kept Contact Information for the two women her boss had denied knowing intimately, including Stormy DanielsCell Phone Number and two addresses for Karen Mcdougal she also said she vaguely recalled one seeing daniels at trump tower on the 26th floor then when prompted by the defendant, she said it might have been in connection with the apprentice earlier. The defense tried hard to undermine former National Enquirer publisher david pecker, and upcoming witness Michael Cohen the trumps attorney, emil beauvais, asking if he believed cohen was prone to exaggeration. Pecker agreeing that he was the end of it all the president had this to say about the trials so far this is eight days that we all sitting here. This courthouse this is all night. Indictment its an honor to try and win election political opponent nothing like this has ever happened eight days. Our country is going to hell. And we sit here here day after, day after day, which is their plan well, the foreign president offer no evidence, of course, to backup any of those claims. Theres no evidence that any of what he said is true, joining us tonight, new york Criminal Defense Attorney arthur aidala, also attorney and former apprentice contestant stacey schneider, seen political commentator, earl lewis, in and legal analyst karen friedman, agnifilo and Elias The Honig and cnns Kara Scannell, who was in the courtroom today and well be going through the transcript for us throughout the night i want to ask this everybody for qarrah for you. What stood out today . Well, i had an actual Front Row Seat today, sitting just behind donald trump. And when david pecker was testifying, trump essentially maintain the whole the same position the whole time. It would seem like it was a bit tedious or boring to him. He was just sitting back in his chair with his head cocked in the direction of david pecker. Its hard to completely make out his facial expressions. But when wrote a graph took the stand, we saw his Body Language changed dramatically. You mean she was testifying pretty favorably about him . Well, under crossexamination by his lawyer. And he then had shifted his chair so we can look directly at her and then when she was leaving the stand and happened to be at a break and he stood up, which is normal and it looked as though he was trying to move toward her as if to talk to her but it didnt seem like they had made any kind of connection. But it was a long day in court and he seemed to just take it in listening, but not really even actively engaging as much as his attorneys as weve seen on other days where he was actively passing notes today, he just seemed to be taking it in two. You. What would stood out. So the banker, the third witness, is the least sensational witness that weve heard from, but also my view, the most important because when people ask, well, wheres the crime . Its really important to remember because weve just spent a week immersed in Hush Money Payments and porn stars and payouts the crime is in the financing and now were finally getting to that. This bank are basically started to establish that Michael Cohen was eager to get this line of financing set up. He felt a sense of earth urgency and there was some need to be undercover about the way they did it. And its important to keep in mind, Michael Cohen is the prosecutions star witness, but they have to show he committed a crime because if the jury does not believe Michael Cohen committed a crime, its over. Theres no way donald trump committed a crime. Lets Michael Cohen is it pretty easy to show Michael Cohen committed a crime given he spent time in prison. Yeah he pled to the federal offense, which is a little different than the falsifying documents, which is the state offense. The hilt say he committed a crime, so it wont be that hard. But you want to establish exactly how we committed the crime, which is through this financing and then tied donald trump right to that and what do i think what stood out to me this week is the entire defense is starting to take shape, are starting to understand how theyre going to present their defense. And its largely through the peoples witnesses rather than going on the attack and going on the offensive against the witnesses that have testified so far, theres sort of embracing the facts, but saying yeah, these things happened. Yeah, there was hush money paid, but weve been doing that. That was being done for everybody. It wasnt had nothing to do with the election. This is just a Business Model and this is how it went. This is, this is essentially how david pecker made his money and i just benefited from it too. So he had nothing to do with the election, nothing to do with the election interference. And the reason thats significant is because elys right, its all about the records, but thats just a misdemeanor what gets it to a felony is if it was done in furtherance of some sort of other crime, like election fraud. So i thought that was interesting because sometimes Defense Attorneys will go on the attack and theyll really attack the credibility and say this didnt happen and there was a little bit of that with david pecker, but not a lot, just a few little, a little things. It was really mostly, yes, this is what happened but nothing to see here. Its not a crime and they were on the pecker has said that this was about the election. I mean, he said hes also was concerned about his family, but the election was front and center. Yeah. Eat meat. He pointed out that more or less the family was at best a secondary consideration. I was really struck by the fact that even he had some limits. I mean, hes talking about a very unsavory enterprise, pecker. Pecker, very unsavory enterprise paying people to sort buy their stories and then buried those stories. Are putting out proactively. I thought that was also interesting. Proactive out all kinds of false stories against trumps enemies that this was a complete enterprise but then to also hear him say that there were limits to that, that he didnt want to buy a stormy day emil story. He says, im not the bank, im not going to be an endless source of money to buy off all of your mistresses are all of the people that you want to keep quiet. It was interesting to me that like even within this really distasteful enterprise that he was running, he felt like he had some limits and apparently had talked with some of the lawyers for the enquirer and was told, dont take that extra step. This could actually have some reputational harm. This could be a problem for you somewhere down the line. And thats why Michael Cohen ended up dipping into his own resources. Stacey habit for you, which to them . Well, today is interesting for me because rhona graff took the stand and i no, rhona graff from beyond the show. She is the nicest woman in the world. I always wondered how she made it through more than 30 years working for a difficult donald trump. But she literally is his gatekeeper. She knows all his schedules and even though Hur Testimony was really short, the prosecution is being strategic. They got in those nuggets that rhona knew that donald trump had Stormy Daniels and Karen Mcdougal is Phone Numbers in his directories. Rhona controls everybodys all the Phone Numbers that donald trump needs access to and the fact that Stormy Daniels was in trump tower, she has a memory of her being there and regardless of what the purpose of Stormy Daniels being there was at that time when you have Michael Cohen coming in, who the defense is going to completely argue as we all know, has credibility issues placing stones for me in the building, a trump tower isnt advantage rather than just stormy and donald trump being in a photograph together, its sort of little nuggets that eventually i think will be tied up later in the case. So that was an enrollment was also a human ising witness for donald trump incidentally, she was a prosecution witness, but shes affectionate about her boss and she always cared for him and when Michael Cohen comes in, who is the most disgruntled former employee on the planet . The defense might remind the jury and Closing Statement that hagen now, donald trump is not hu Michael Cohen says he is. That might be a strategy well see, are there anything two prosecutions or the defense is doing . Well karen has an enormous amount of experience and the other night or maybe last night when i said theres an underlying elements of jury nullification, which its like. Okay. Yeah, this all happened really, folks, a really going to put this guy in jail for this for these crimes that youre not even going to understand when the judge reads the charge to you exactly whats going on here. And we just heard from mr. Pecker that it goes on all the time with celebrities at different aspects of they live with Arnold Schwarzenegger was running for governor the biggest state in the United States of america, like this is underlying current and go to like karens point also, there are some times when you can attack and then theres other times when you like. All right theres no way i could get around this right so let me figure out a way to adopt it and make it my own and use it in the way most an to me because ill lose credibility with the jury if i tried to say that black is white and white is black. But if i figured out a way to say its either black and i loved black or its white and i loved blight or its a little gray, but not be this like a toc dog. What i was quantity sq was Susan Nicholas question this witness, correct . What was because i know i know of her. Shes like a mentor almost in that shes a very, very wellknown and well regarded Criminal Defense Attorney. What was it like in the courtroom with having a woman stand up and conducting this and shes really a skilled lawyers. So im just curious if the dynamic changed. Well, the prosecutor who did as soon as also female was Susan Hoffinger who asked her the questions and she went through she was using graft to get in these documents because they havent had stipulations on a lot of the Business Records. So were going to see a lot of these document witnesses. But when Susan Nicholas took the took the podium and she was asking rhona graff these questions. She was leaning into the humanizing factor of and ill trump and at one point, after a few questions that she got in the prosecutors objected and the judge had sustained it essentially was like, okay, we need to move on to the next topic because she was drawing out this favorable image of donald trump through the eyes of rhona graff, qarrah, you been looking out through the transcripts, which we get them late very late in the de youve been noted on the crossexamination of david pecker today, the core of his hes a vehicle by the prosecution to set the stage and talk about this august 2015 meeting in which this Kachin Kill Conspiracy as the prosecution has laid it out, began where he met with donald trump and Michael Cohen. So they were trying to go back to that meeting and suggests that it was just like businesses usual, it was Standard Operating Procedure for the National Enquirer. So aiml beauvais, one of trumps Defense Lawyers had asked pecker on the stand. I want you i want to stick with the august 2015 trump tower meeting. Pecker says yes, beauvais says, at that meeting, the constant deceptive catchandkill was not discussed, correct . Pecker said thats correct, but they asked and then there was no discussion of a financial dimension to any agreement at that meeting, correct . Pecker said, yes, thats correct. So trying to say that there was no blatant conversation about a catch and kill and that im going to buy the deals now on direct with the prosecution, they tried to put that back together with pecker saying, i talked about either someone would have to buy the magazine story if it wasnt me, it was going to be using i was going to tell Michael Cohen and Michael Cohen was going to find someone who would take care of it. So they put it back together. But this was a strategy by the defense, is that october eating. In 2015 is important for the prosecution because thats really the the origin of this arrangement that then move forward and we saw the results with the doorman and mcdougal and then later Stormy Daniels, even though national acquired by Stormy Daniel story, right . Exactly. I mean, this is the beginning of the conspiracy and it was as pecker testified, it was Donald Trumps idea to have the meeting and that donald trump asked him, what can you and your magazine do for me . So this was the piece that trumps team was trying to chip away at, that they would have published a lot of these stories about trumps opponents. Anyway, because thats what the National Enquirer does. And it was good for business for them because they would benefit their readers, was like donald trump, that was one of the things that came out in the testimony that they had prior to that meeting, they had already published negative stories, isnt that right away . They had been carson . And they went through a couple of things that they showed that the gordian had already published a lot of these stories about ben carson the National Enquirer was just recycling it and that it was coinciding with poll results. And they also establish that the National Enquirer had already done a bunch of negative stories on bill and Hillary Clinton that predated this meeting. So it wasnt something that was necessarily hatched then saying there was already a pattern here. So trying to really emphasizing this is what the National Enquirer does. And then prosecutors trying to say, but everything was different in 2015 because they did some of these things like bearing the Karen Mcdougal story that didnt benefit them. But more to talk about, including more from the Trial Transcripts up next to a point that our lewis brought up earlier, the moment on the stand when david pecker admitted there were conditions under which he would publish a story damaging to the former president will favorite this one always is going to be ready from design and products to removal and installation. Rebound this with you through every step of your remodel the color visit rebuff. Com for your free inhome Design Council takes smile. You found it the feeling of findings, psoriasis cant filter out the real you. So go ahead, live unfiltered with The One And Only so take to a oncedaily pill for moderate to Severe Plaque Psoriasis and the chance that clear or almost clear skin, its like the feeling of finding youre so ready for your closeup are finding you dont have to hide your skin. Just your background once daily. So tick two was proven better, getting more people clear skin than the leading pill. Dont take if youre allergic to so take too serious reactions can occur. So ticked, you can lower your ability to fight infections including tb, serious infections, cancers including lymphoma muscle problems, and changes in certain labs have occurred. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, liver or Kidney Problems, high triglycerides or had a vaccine or plan to tick to as a tick to inhibitor tick two as part of the jackpot emily, its not known as Though Tiktok has the same risks as Jak Inhibitors find what psoriasis has been hiding. Theres only one, so tick two. Aspirin by name so, clearly you, so tick to when you disaster restoration, how do you make like an effort even happened happen . Comes your theres a pro for that. Surf pro like it never even happened work play link relief, work, play lake really, the only three in one extended release formula for dry eyes like everybody wants super straight, super white teeth they want that Hollywood White smile. News censored in clinical white rights, two sheets, whiter teeth and 24 7 sensitive eu production. I think its a great product. Its going to help a lot of patients did you know theres no t in skechers, what you told about me is always been scheduled. These sketches slippery is ten. These sketches in brings up is done at ones killed swedes blends cap, guess i keeps it grow and strong and business. Its not a ninetofive proposition. Its all day and into the night. Its all the things that keep this world turning. The gotos that keep us going. The places we cheer. And check in. They all choose the advanced Network Solutions and round the Clock Partnership from Comcast Business. See why Comcast Business powers more Small Businesses than anyone else. Get started for 49. 99 a month plus ask how to get up to an 800 prepaid card. Dont wait call today. The raw to 369369. Today. The whole story with anderson cooper, Sunday On Cnn in a week on the stand, former tabloid publisher, david pecker gave jurors and up look at how he bought and killed stories on behalf of donald trump. This course at the center of the prosecutions theory of the case and why he was there lead witness today under crossexamination, though, he admitted there were limits to that arrangement and conditions under which you would publish something damaging to his friends specifically regarding first catch and kill stories, doormans false claim that the former president fathered a child out of wedlock. Heres the exchange between pecker and trumps attorney emil beauvais. Beauvais said so if this story was true, the doormans story, you were going to run it, correct . Pecker says yes, because you had a fiduciary obligation to do that, right . Says Beauvais Pecker says that is correct. But they said it would have made business sense to put it mildly to run such an article if it was true, correct. Twitch pecker replied, yes. Now, we should point out in testimony earlier this week, pecker did testify under oath that if he ran the story, it would have been after the election which makes the argument that this was to protect trump going into the election. But as soon as the election was over, pecker would have run that doormans story because it would have been in his words, extremely popular or not his exact words. But he said it wouldve been extremely popular among the National Enquirer audience back with the panel joining us as well as barry levine, former executive editor of the National Enquirer. Barry, im wondering, im a, you know, david pecker obviously. Well, you worked with the enquirer for a long time. You had some involvement with that doormans story. How do you what do you make of him as a witness . Well, listen, i was there anderson for 17 years. I was actually the first editorial higher for david pecker back in 1999 its certainly troubling to be to be watching this unfold in thinking back to the great years of breaking so many Great Stories, john edwards, tiger woods Jesse Jacksons paternity of a child i was i left the inquire after the doormans story two months before the Karen Mcdougal story, before they got involved with that. And the last trumps story that i did work on was the doormans story and david pecker was absolutely right. Had that story turned out to be true, and he published it, it would have been a mega sale it might have sold millions of copies. Did you know that he was going to kill it if it turned out, regardless of what it turned out. Well, listen, i mean, i remember going back to 2010 when i knew back from the early days that david was close to donald trump that they were Close Friends back in 2010. I didnt interview with donald trump when he was actually thinking about running for president in 2012 and just from the way we presented that story, im going to save america. I realized very quickly back then that this was probably the way it was going to go with donald trump 2012. Of course, never happened. Did you know he was going to kill the doormans story . Yes. Yeah. In fact we investigated the story very, very rapidly. I mean, im john edwards, i took two years, my Reporting Team to prove that story. When the doormans story came down the pike i talked to dylan howard, who was my editor and said, listen, we need some time. I said, i sense that Michael Cohen is going to find out about this and donald trump is going to eventually find out about this. But for the sake of the inquire, for the sake of our legacy in terms of breaking these types of stores, let us at least work the story and we did investigate it for a very short period of time, dispatch reporters got photos of the woman and her doctor know that you were doing that for donald trump . I mean, did you know that, you know, i i had no real idea, anderson that there had been an actual arrangement. I didnt learn that until the wires and what issue. So what was the process . I mean, obviously, the heart broke, the john edwards story got there was a nomination per pillar for that, but they also, i mean, as has been testified to, pecker said they put out this story about ted cruz, his father, which he said it was completely made up. What was that discussion like if you knew a story which just made up but were going to edit it and go with it anyway. Yeah would the door man we shut down the story after a brief period of time sensing that the story probably was false and the door man was it was paid the 30,000, which i would have liked to have had more time to investigate it. Certainly was that widely known within the company like, oh, hes being paid 30,000 . No, it was it was known among the editors. It was a very tightened, it grouped the lawyer certain certainly knew in terms of the ted cruz oswald fathers story i mean, i was ready gone from them and saw the story on the news stand and thought you know, whats going on here. The inquires entered the Twilight Zone to some degree. I mean, things have gone completely over the Over The Edge is there any other plausible explanation for pecker . Are catching and killing the Karen Mcdougal story and Teeing Up Trump and cohen for the story, daniel thing, other than to protect the campaign, i mean, you have no doubt that this do or do you do you have any doubt that this was about protecting the campaign as opposed to what some of trumps people have been saying as well, luck, he was concerned about his wife finding out. No, it was it was it was completely for the campaign. I mean, this was absolutely transactional and im left now still wondering as i listened to the reports of the david peckers testimony, why he would sacrifice the inquire, why he would sacrifice the legacy of great tabloid reporting. And he said he had donald trump had been his mentor and like the edward story the Campaign Aide andrew young had claimed falsely that he was to fathered the child to protect john edward in this particular case. It was an unhinged type of loyalty with Michael Cohen, with david pecker. And pickerels and testified he had done this with or that Arnold Schwarzenegger had approached him that other celebrities had. Were you i mean, did you know about this history and how common was this sort of catching and killing even though pecker didnt use that term i mean, i think from his testimony, it seemed like this was happening all the time. They were rare cases. We never went it out to spend time investigating stories and not running them. I mean, we had to fill the book with 40 story is a week. My interest, my Reporting Teams that i directed, we wanted to break stories. These reported because were raring to go knocking on doors, taking people out, looking at documents we were never a fan of stories that never made it into the paper. But of course it was his paper. He was the publisher and he had friends. And there were times when some good stories probably were were buried and unfortunately, the pain for stories, how did that work . I mean, when youre working a story, you know, you have reported this out staking people out, going through garbage or whatever it is, hanging outside their homes is there a set sort of like priceless for me, how do you determine what, what its worth . I mean first of all, i think its the irony is the big stories that we worked on over the years and also goes to the early days of the enquirer, the gary hart story is the oj stories most of those stories you cant write a check for. You have to investigate, you have to send reporters out. You have to do the digging, you have to knock on the doors. You have to cultivate sources who are going to trust you that went into the Great Stories we didnt, we couldnt write a check for john edwards. It took two years, but your sources, you pay sources. I mean, yeah. Theres Hello SurroundingKaren Mcdougal . Yes, theres no question for exclusively when youre a weekly publication and you need to hold someone from speaking to another Media Organization for a weeks time, youre going to put them under some type of exclusivity. It could be a couple hundred dollars, it could be several thousands of dollars. I mean, we operate in no differently. I mean, we were bowl hold about the fact that we practice Checkbook Journalism and certainly there were individuals who called the Enquirer Tip Line specifically because they were looking for money, but Television Shows would pay for video. They would pay still pay for somebodys scrapbook are still photos. It would justify some pain minutes, but they werent as direct as the National Enquirer in terms of what its become i mean, it is a shadow of its former self in terms of readership. And in terms of do you think that they, do you think it will continue . I mean, thats you know, that is so hard to say. I feel a great deal of sadness over the way pecker came forward and just talk about Checkbook Journalism, talking about routinely doing caching kills because it made it seem like no matter what you your what your personal beliefs were and the work you were doing . Yeah. So long david pecker was using this to cultivate friends and to be like a remorse fish on the shark of donald trump. I mean, to kind of be in trumps orbit. He enjoyed that. Yeah. I mean, theres theres no question about i have no ill will towards him. He was a great employer for me for 17 years. However, i do feel like so many other former employees that i see on facebook and elsewhere that he took what had been a great legacy of part of american pop culture. And he weaponized it. General. So pope who had been the original owner, who created a national inquire, his son came out in 2019 and said his father generous, who pope is rolling over and rolling over in his grave because of what david pecker did in terms of weaponizing the paper for a Political Campaign and the i had to end up writing a book, all the president s women, donald trump in the making of a predator trying to do the work that the enquirer reporters could have done over the years because it was so much on donald trump that could have been reported and had bay reported out the Karen Mcdougal story and Story Daniels it could have changed the course of the election, barely living 16, appreciate your time tonight. Thank you so much coming up next. Kara canal is continuing to go through todays courtroom transcript, the complete version. Im just out what she is fine. The next okay. Yeah, we got orders coming starting in every easy the star eight months pregnant desk different story. I couldnt slow down. We were starting a business from the ground up people were showing up left and right. And so did our Business Needs the chase econ i made it made it easy when you go for something vague like this, your kids need it and they believe they can do the same, earn a limit, 1. 5 cash back on every purchase with the Chase Business Unlimited card from chase for business, make more of whats youre now play. In making us wait must cease moving of the spring arrives. Let me come talk to you and shes like youve never seen her before. Youre saying i should be flattered intoxicating and hilarious. Why mine your car because youre stupid, stupid. I know. Im just not as disturbed by it as you are. An absolute blast not miss this Movie Challengers can i know play only beaters . Lets get the rest of these plants organic soil from miracle grow has grown me the best its garden i have ever had good soil and you get good results. This soil will blow you away. Its the Martha Stewart of Soil Deliveries happen. Ordered that this happens that happened. He get out of there are at least two back at the pitch oh, thats gonna happen be there with or more at rnc. Com choosing a treatment for your chronic migraine 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more can be overwhelming. So ask your doctor about botox looked out to prevent headaches and adults with chronic migraine before they even start. Its the number one prescribed branded chronic Migraine Treatment so far more than 5 million Botox Treatments have been given to over 850,000 chronic Migraine Patients Effects of botox may spread hours two weeks after injection causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or Muscle Weakness can be signs of a lifethreatening condition. Side effects may include allergic reactions i can injection site pain, fatigue, and headache. Dont receive botox if theres a skin infection, tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions and medications including Botulinum Toxins as the this may increase the risk of serious side effects in a survey, 92 of current users and they wish they talk to their doctor and started botox sooner so ask your doctor if botox is right for you learn how adds he could help you save on botox some things that were better together, like your Workplace Benefits and retirement savings. Lawyer provides tools that help you make the right investment and benefit choices. So you can reach todays financial go and look forward tostart your will. I trust and well dot com and make it count were learning more about a Testy Exchange and de eight and the trump Hush Money Trial today from the full transcript, just releasing it, cnns Kara Scannell has continued to go through what shes back with us. So how did David Pecker Push back on some of the defenses tax on his credibility . Voting or i guess a tax is mavi wrong. Yeah, theyre looking to try to find inconsistencies. So maybe the jury thinks his memory is not so good or its too rehearsed, but one piece of his testimony that he gave on direct was about a january 2017 meeting. He said he went to trump tower. He saw donald trump and that donald trump had the thing tim for taking care of the doormans story and Karen Mcdougal story, so then trumps lawyers saying, confronting with him some notes that an fbi agent had taken after an interview, david pecker gave to them. And in those fbi notes, the notes say the david pecker didnt recall any gratitude from Donald Trumps, so he was challenging on that, asking him about that, david pecker says, i know so what i remember, this is going back to 2018. I didnt recall back from what im saying here is that during the fbi investigation, i know what i said that yesterday happens, so i cant reconcile what the fbi interview was. If someone made a mistake or not beauvais says so you cant reconcile because what you said yesterday is inconsistent with whats in this report, correct pecker says yes, but i wouldnt be responsible for this report, but they said i understand. And so youre suggesting that the fbi made a mistake here . Pecker said, i know what the truth is. Im not i cant state what the woods here why this was written this way. I know exactly what was said to me. So interested, i dont think the Defense Style of trumps defense did much to impact david pecker is credibility. Thats a small dang right there, but they did Something Better they are using david peckers testimony to undermine Michael Cohen, the three best words that the defense has on the record four so far came today prone to exaggeration. They got david pecker to say Michael Cohen is prone to exaggeration. And so theyre going to do that by the way, with a lot of other witnesses. If Kellyanne Conway takes the stand, i bet she has its negative things to say about Michael Cohen. Maybe hope hicks two. And what you do as a Defense Lawyer, not my profession. Ards, but ive seen enough good ones inaction when it comes down for closing go folks their own witnesses. The first guy they put in front of you, david pecker, said that their star witness is prone to exaggeration if you find that he exaggerated to you this case is over. So thats a really smart and effective tactic like Michael Cohen can be restored as the star witness so easily because people forget or maybe dont forget that he pled guilty to the same scheme that trump is now being put on trial for. And people generally as a Defense Lawyer do not plead guilty to things they didnt do. That plea is locked in. He took a threeyear Jail Sentence for the acts that he claimed in open court when he entered his plea. I did this at the direction of donald trump and you just cant get around that. No at or how bad the defense makes Michael Cohen look and its going to be a slug fest when he gets on the stand, i actually cannot wait to see that happen are there how would you restored sometimes theres things you dont get around and i just want to go back to what karen said before. And also what ellie said, like in other words, youve got to pick your spots. You got to attack and question peoples credibility and questions their memory and all of that when you can and when you cant, you try to embrace it and make it your own. Obviously, prone to exaggeration is great, but another phrase i thought was Standard Operating Procedure that goes to the jury nullification, like theyre trying to make it out that would donald trump is the prosecution is is so unique. No one has ever done this before, and that went out the window, as they said, my colleague, doug judges, george grosso, whos been in the court every day. He said after his testimony and i think theres broke our last guess heart, but after his testimony, i wanted to take a shower because it shows how dirty that industry is. Enlightens all of us how you know, you shouldnt believe everything you read in the National Enquirer. Well, thats thats breaking news cnn. I think the argument that weve heard quite a bit as well, Michael Cohen already went to went to jail for this and so didnt donald trump do the same thing . Its not quite right though, because first of all, Michael Cohen pled guilty to half the crime. Donald trump is charged with here. He pled guilty to the Campaign Finance part, but not necessarily the falsifying Business Records part. So thats number one. Number two, Michael Cohen has been lets say, reticent, maybe even selfcontradictory about the circumstances of his federal plea. He has been very vocal about the fact that he feels like to put to use Michael Collins word the Southern District of new york. My former Office Michael said they put a gun to my head. They threaten my wife. I pled guilty to things i didnt actually commit. I committed perjury when i pled guilty. Thats Michael Cohen in story. Now, thats a disaster. Thats a mess. Michael cohen is now offering lies stacked upon lies. And boy, the defense crossexamination is going to be all my career long. The the Standard Operating Procedure, which are their talked about. You actually have something in the transcript about that. Yeah. This was an redirect for the prosecution. They were getting at the Karen Mcdougal story great and was it really bought for the Standard Operating Procedure line that the defense is pushing the prosecutor, joshua steinglass, asked david pecker how do you published a story about a playboy model having a year old sexual affair while he was married with a with a president ial candidate, would that have sold magazines . Do you think pecker said . Yes. Steinglass said that would be like National Enquirer gold pecker said, yes, steinglass said, but at the time you entered into that agreement, you had zero intention a publishing that story . Pecker said thats correct. And the prosecutor said and despite the fact that publishing that story would have helped your bottom line, you killed the story because it helped the candidate donald trump. Pecker said yes. So their counter and cutting against the Standard Operating Procedure, obviously, if this was National Enquirer gold and they would have made a fortune off the headline. They just decided not to publish it and that was the point prosecutors were trying to push that. This was for Donald Trumps candidacy, not for the bottom line. Thats prosecution gold. I mean, to get him to admit that i was willing to do something that was contrary to my bottom line. To help a candidate thats exactly what they need to say. And thats what the prosecutions trying to do in order to make Michael Cohen irrelevant, frankly, could you just explain to me because i dont understand how is that a crime . Hows that an element of the crimes are the elements that the judge is going to read after the summation. So this crime is a bump up crime, right . Its basically a misdemeanor plus so the misdemeanor is if you falsified Business Records, i think everybody thinks thats the easier part to prove. All right. Because he said it was for legal. I agree with. Okay. But if you did it with the intention, the general intention to either conceal or commit or aid another crime. It bumps it up to a felony. And the way i like to describe it is its like burglary, burglary is a trespass, right . Knowingly enter and remain unlawfully somewhere, which is a misdemeanor but if you add to that, the intent to commit a crime, theyre in it bumps it up to a burglary and you dont always know what the crime is in a burglary, you dont know. Okay. But the difference is with the burghley example, you just use, things are happening simultaneously. Youre entering and youre committing the crime right there in that not necessarily. You could you could have you could have a scenario where somebody is opens the door to an apartment, walks in and gets caught as he steps in the door and if that guy had a sleeping bag and a toothbrush, he was going there to sleep. Thats a misdemeanor. Thats a trespass. But if instead he had a safe cracker end, he also had when its all happening simultaneously, hes hes cracking the door, hes walking in with the sleeping bag, his Crack Walking in with the safe cracker here. Theyre saying the misdemeanor took place and somewhere down the road another crime is taking place. Thats the difference between the burglars . Yes. I am im not arguing with you. Im trying to figure this. I have i have paperwork here. It says im trying to figure it out. What im doing legal homework here. This is a conspiracy to commit burglary thats my question. So how come karen, who you gum you ran the office, you know, this stuff. Why didnt they charge a simple conspiracy . Because for two reasons, a conspiracy write stuff. You dont mind feel like im lost. We got two in joined us because because falsifying Business Records in the first degree is an e felony, thats the lowest level Felony Conspiracy to commit an e felonies and a misdemeanor. Number one, the statute of limitations had run on all the misdemeanors by the time they indicted this crime. Okay. So they couldnt have a number two so as a prosecutor, you dont charge a misdemeanor because you dont want the jury to compromise on a misdemeanor, you want them to do the felony and you dont need the conspiracy because the crime that theyre saying he used to that he intended to conceal or commit was the state election crime which is a conspiracy to commit election fraud. It has spirit see built into it. So you didnt need it. So i guess that was three reasons why they didnt charge because like it ask the professor one more question. So professor here, heres my question. Im not wise got my colleague, professor because youre actually educating us the bump up crime. I know you dont have to articulate what it is but if if the choice, the menu that theyre giving us are all misdemeanors themselves that are out of the Statute Limitations. My question is, can a misdemeanor . The false records . Thats out of this statue limitations. And another misdemeanor, which is the bump up mr. Week meter is also out of the statue of limitations. Could you put two misdemeanors both out of the Statute Limitations to those two things, equal a felony well, they have three crimes that they are saying is the bump up, right. State election tax. Yeah. So the answer is its the answer is yes. The prosecution theories, yes. But its never been done before in america. Its hasnt, been tested on appeal, but it has been done, but it has not been tested on well, how do you how would you describe this . Is it i mean novel prosecution is pie in the sky. Is it interesting how do you so the only thing, the only thing unusual about this case is the defendant. This is a bread and butter whitecollar crime in new york. This is done by its all over the state. This is the bread and butter, the manhattan das office, the feds, its like the feds who charge mail fraud and Wire Fraud For Everything and that youre like, how how does that a male or wire fraud, but its like the charge that they use all the time this is done all the time. Whats unusual is been on all go to trial. So this isnt going a lot of them are allowed to plead guilty or they plea bargain them out. And this is going to trial. And of course, who the defendant is is whats also very unusual. All right. Were gonna take a quick break that was really interesting and retired New York State Supreme Court justice and the judge in trumps Hush Money Case for more than 15 years since joining us from taking on the prosecutions claimed that the former president continues to violate the gag order and where the judge might do about it in next weeks gag order hearing, or four of you right now . They need a lawn back fast and unit scotts turf grass. It goes grass two times faster lets see the lawn given you a stronger laws, milner three, the may, its got her field a rapid grass today. Its guaranteed fee. Did not feed. I was born with wings. But psoriasis swooped into clip them. It crushed my confidence, but no longer Will Psoriasis get a piece of me . I can love my skin again with bins, alex only been zell targets and blocks is 17 a plus f to calm inflammation, i can control my plaques start getting myself back in xilinx helps adults with moderate to severe Psoriasis Control plaques to deliver clearer skin fast for results that last i will give myself back the freedom of shorts, standard where black again, from head to toe most people got 100 clear skin, saw him after the first dose serious side effects including suicidal thoughts and behavior, infections, and lowered ability to fight them, Liver Problems and Inflammatory Bowel Disease have occurred. Tell your doctor if these happening or worsen or if youve had a vaccine or plan to start to get yourself back with bim zealous. Asked your dermatologist did not give zelig today the day you get your clear choice Dental Implants, changes, your struggle with missing teeth forever it changes how you eat how you feel, and how you enjoy life. It changes your smile. And now others smile at you clear Choice Network doctors have changed over 100 thousand lives with Dental Implants and they can change yours too because a clear choice day changes every day schedule a free consultation how could anyone possibly know that every single one of these pistachios is guaranteed to be wonderful. By reading right here. Wonderful pistachios or the pistachios that are wonderful. But the word wonderful on them. Our biggest challenge uncertainty, hidden fees surcharges, who knows what to expect, turned shipping to your advantage. Keep it simple. With clear upfront pricing, with usps Ground Advantage the jinx aired bob and i spoke after every episode he wasnt nervous and i thought hes gonna run whenever theyre terrorist is helping bob make his get away i didnt set out to be his friend what do you do . When your best friend feels your other best friend trials going to be through the jinx part to streaming, excuse this is be on macs to type two diabetes. Discover the ozempic tries zone i got to Power Of Three. I learned my alias cd risk and lost some weight in studies, the majority of people reached an a1c under seven and maintained it im under seven. Simple lowers the risk of major cardiovascular events such as stroke, heart attack, or death in adults, also with known heart disease. Im laura, my risk adults lost up to 14 pounds or lost weight. I was epic. Isnt for people with type one diabetes, dont share needles or pens or reuse needles, dont take ozempic if you or your family ever had medullary Thyroid Cancer or have multiple Endocrine Neoplasia Syndrome Type or the allergic to it stop ozempic and get medical help right away. If you get a lump or swelling i mean, your neck, severe stomach pain, or an allergic reaction, serious side effects may include pancreatitis, Gallbladder Problems may occur until your provider about Vision Problems are changes taking ozempic with a sulfonylurea insulin may increase low Blood Sugar Risk side effects like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea may lead to dehydration, which may worsen Kidney Problems living with type two diabetes, us about the Power Of Three with ozempic this looks like an actual you dont meanwhile, at a vrbo, when other Vacation Rentals arent with their cracked up to be. Dry one where you know what you get . The white house correspondents dinner, live tomorrow at seven Eastern On Cnn next thursday, judge merchan has scheduled a hearing on trumps alleged 14 Gag Order Violations. The hearing comes after prosecutors say trump violated the gag order for times interest the past few days, retired New York State Supreme Court justice Joel Kahn Visor joins us once again tonight. Shes known judge merchan for more than 15 years. Are you surprised, judge, that merchan has not already ruled on the gag order . No. Im not ill tell you why originally when we first had these alleged violations, i thought it would b1 and don and well be finished. But then while this is pending and he does a hearing to which the defendant is entitled. There was no summary summary violation here when the defendant persists and continues to decide hes seen seemingly violating the order. Whats the point . Whats the point of doing it to rush it, think about it for a minute. The goal, judge merchan goal here is to make sure both sides get a fair trial and to get a verdict and to do that without with as little incident and as much grace as possible. This hearing and these get this Gag Order Violations or to a great extent, a sideshow. And there are plenty of people out there, maybe some at this table who want to get trump, no matter what they want to see him in jail, or they want to see him held responsible for this. They want his blood but i get that judge merchan is not one of them. He wants to keep this trial on track, make sure he gets the verdict at this point. The truth is even if there is a finding of contents, theres no reason why he needs to sentence him now he can wait till the end of the trial and deal with it. At that point. Quite frankly, the deal his office, im pointing to you because you are de an manhattan, the das office, regardless of what judge merchan does with the condemned, can bring criminal contempt charges against him through the penal law as opposed to the judiciary law, which is what and how judge merchan is proceeding. The das Office Brought this to judge merchans Attention Complaint Two and put in a request for an order to show cause. Very das office clearly is taking this seriously and i dont quite follow the logic of whats the rush. I mean, why leave it hanging out there, especially when trump continues . To recidivism, what would be the harm of the judge coming out . He had a hearing, as you said, and saying thats it. We had the hearing. Heres my findings. You violated and knock it off. What couldnt that only help the situation . But i dont know. I think that no matter what happens, whatever the result at this at this particular hearing is, the defendant walks out as victor or victim and thats part of the sideshow. So i dont disagree with you that having ruled is a bad idea. But at this point again, because i dont think the sentence is going to happen until after the trial maybe we need to focus on the testimony one more quick question. Would you ever, under any circumstance, if you were this was your case lockup, donald trump, based on based on violations of a gag order, if you did it eight more times, depends on what the violation is. If it keeps on posting about Michael Cohen every day, this guy is a serial perjure. Were there ever come a point where you would lock him up yes. Really . Yes. Okay. Yeah. All right. Ill been there, done it would convolve i believe it the lunch bag with me just in case i dont want the bologna sandwiches i could bring it inside, but judge kim, i just said the other night the judges in a tough spot because unlike in the civil case, i think trump was getting hit with like 10,000, finds thats that starts being a big number for no matter who you are, 10,000 and another 10,000. And here, Mike Statutes only a thousand dollars. Thats not exactly going to change Donald Trumps world. And especially if he thinks, look, anytime you represent people in the media, like trump is like a lot of other highprofile people are in my opinion, they overemphasize the Public Relations aspect of the trial. They assumed the jurors are reading it. They assume the jurors there are violating the judges orders and looking at and theyre trying so hard to influence them. I havent found that to be the case. Ive found after a verdict, juror say yeah, i was in a cab and the thing popped up or i was on my phone, but ive never found a juror after questioning them after a verdict, that layout blatantly violet, nothing could be lying to me, but i will tell you there are certain defendants who like they really emphasize on getting the message out after the jurys and paneled. When the jurys not supposed to email, see the goal might not be two, to influence the jury so much is really just to provoke a miss right . Oh, thats a win for the defense in any case case particularly, what would it take to provoke a mistrial well myriad reasons. Were related to the gag order to the gag order, i guess hadnt thought about that. Maybe if the defendants said something that completely infected the jury by saying something that was so outrageous or so agreed they couldnt be fair. I dont see that the defendant himself could do something that could end up as a mistrial than jurors could or the defendant reaching out to a juror could be. What about it . If the judge put President Trump in prison for violating the gag order, and it really got out and pictures everywhere of donald trump behind bars. And it found that that one of the jurors juror could come in. I mean, judge categorize, you could tell you they came in and some of them fess up it. Look, i did see i saw the cover that you are posing as a picture of donald trump behind bars. I dont think thats a mistrial. I think thats an instruction thats an instruction that it just just just forget about you a view if i would choose but thats not there was this report earlier that the Secret Service out of the Law Enforcement hadnt met or were meeting to discuss in this longshot thing, he was put in a in a cell. How would they actually do that . But era, i mean, thats highly, highly, highly unlikely or highly unlikely or its certainly undesirable. But if his goal, lets assume for a minute that candidate trump just wants to delay this, that the issues of guilt and innocence and whats going to happen to him and whether or not he loses his freedom is something he would like to deal with on the other side of the election he could stand up in court. He could Say Something crazy, he could come outside of court, he could Say Something crazy, he could deliberately try and push the system to the point where the trial is either delayed or you get a miss trial, you have to start over just head. Kaitlan collins joins us with an exclusive interview. The former president s attorney general, william barr about the trial, the immunity hearing, and his response to former president s mocking bars, Endorsement Millions of people have lost weight with personal life icelands from noon, like brittany, who lost 20 pounds i felt so supported by new it became an anchor for me. New has changed my life get started today and moves 15 pounds and 15 weeks are solvable. Would Psoriatic Arthritis and psoriasis . I was on a journey for a really long time to find some Relief Percentage works for me consent ics helps real people get real relief from the symptoms of Psoriatic Arthritis or psoriasis series of reactions, severe Skin Reactions that look like eczema and an increased risk of infections, some fatal have occurred. Tell your doctor if you havent section or symptoms had a vaccine or plan to poor if ibd symptoms develop or worsen. I move so much better because of Course Antics ask you rheumatologist about cassette decks. Hey, theyre brenda. Its carroll. Exactly. Which like every operating on, you mean arm its all connected asking the right question can greatly impact your future. You share your an orthopedist actually, im a sagittarius, specially when it comes to your finances, give a question a you a certified Financial Planner . Yes. Im a cfp professional Cop Professionals are committed to acting in your best interest. Thats why its gotta be a cfp. Bind your cfp professional, and lets make a plan doubt or they need the loan back fast. And union scotts turf be their grass it goes Classroom Two tells us that under see the loan given you a stronger laws, that bleeder may its got her field a rapid grass today. Its guaranteed fee. Did feeding when youre the leader is ask the cleanup and restoration. How do you make like it never even happened . Happened brandy whatever comes your way. Theres a pro for that. Serve pro. Like it never even happened and two options for you. Take a look when its time for an update or complete remodels, want yourself there is a here, guys if, everything, down to the stomach, worry about this with you, every step of the way from design and products to removal and installation. Okay . You just think what it is right . He handled the entire process to create a beautiful and functional bathroom for whatever your life needs rayban with you every step of the way. Color visit, rebirth. Com for your free inhome Design Consultation weight as coming waivers biggest sale of the year is back for three days only may 4 get excited to get up to 80 off yes on everything all way they long way day starts may 4th. So mark your calendar and start filling your card when i was your age, we never had anything like this. What . Wifi . Wifi that works all over the house, even the basement. The basement. So i can finally throw that party. And invite shannon barnes. Dream do come true. Xfinity gives you reliable wifi with walltowall coverage on all your devices, even when everyone is online. Maybe well even get married one day. I wonder what i will be doing . Probably still living here with mom and dad. Fast reliable speeds right where you need them. Thats walltowall from chavez and huerta to striking janitors in the 90s to todays fastfood workers. Californians have led the way. Now, 20 hour is here. Thanks to Governor Newsom and leaders in sacramento, we can lift workers out of poverty. Stop the race to the bottom in the fastfood industry. And build a california for all of us. Thank you governor and our california lawmakers for fighting for what matters. Kaitlan collins next 9 00. P. M. Here in new york, the eighth day of the trump Hush Money Trial. Here are busy and productive one now in the books in this hour verse special primetime continuing coverage, more details from the Trial Transcripts. We just received. The former president s latest