For joining us, cnn newsnight with abby phillip starts right now carnage and catastrophe in black and white. Thats tonight on newsnight good evening. Im abby philip in new york. What is it like to watch chaos unfold at your feet, unable to stop it, unable to do anything but watch well, tonight, the world knows this is video from the Israeli Defense forces. And thats warm, that buzzing nucleus. Those are people, Desperate Gazans surrounding aid trucks, who are carrying food and supplies now this hour, 112 of those people are now dead. Hundreds more are injured as cameras caught. A clear eyed view of what this war is doing to innocence inside of gaza. All of what youre about to watch is disturbing and its shocking. And we thought long and hard about whether to show this to you but the brutality of what happened is in escapable. This was the scene that was surrounding that aid convoy before the disaster intervene, palestinians huddled there chatter. You could hear here it there over the death of the fires that theyd set to keep warm as they waited. They just wanted to eat, they wanted to feed their kids and their parents the World Food Programme was last able to deliver aid to north gaza more than a month ago now, after a month without food and months scrambling for just the tiniest morsels this convoy, 30 trucks and all offered a rare glimmer of hope in the Pitch Darkness that is now life for palestinians in gaza. But hope is, of course, the most fragile of things and soon the bullets shattered it that crackle of idf gunfire came around 04 00 in the morning. The burst killed 20 people. And according to local journalists who were on the scene that triggered a chain reaction, a deadly stampede of people running from danger only to stumble into even more some were trampled, some were run over by the trucks themselves. Now, daylight brought clarity on the catastrophe, the painful and unnerving clarity of at all men use donkeys to card away corpses from the pictures. Its hard to discern who died from israeli gunfire and who died by stampede. When donkeys werent an option, bystanders loaded the bodies onto pallets, they drag them, carrying them men were suddenly turned into pall inside of gaza city near its already hollowed out hospitals. The scale of the slaughter gets even more obvious the floor is now a triage table and for others, they arrived simply beyond saving any able bodied person who was nearby is now a Makeshift Medic Blood Soaking through the close of those trying to help, even if helping means ferrying bodies draped in white sheets others crouched down, heads hung in sorrow at a row of people who helped could not reach in time this man whose identity cnn does not know, is already beyond the grasp of that outstretched hand seeking to give him just one more moment of comfort. Cnn cannot fully confirm the israeli account of this incident, nor can see an unconfirmed the palestinian version of events. But without question, what happened here is a stain on humanity this is how israel has described what happened in that crowd the trucks went through, they were surrounded by hundreds of people, thousands of people perhaps. And as they were trying to loot the goods on the trucks it appears that the trucks continued to move forward and this is the unfortunate reality of Mass Casualty Event that actually has very little or nothing to do with israel nothing to do with his real unfortunate is what these government says. But you cant disconnect this war. First of course, sparked by an act of brutality from hamas from the widespread famine that is currently occurring inside of gaza, where people, children are simply wasting away our children die of hunger. They went to get a bag of flour in order to be by children. Some will run over others were shot now, palestinians dont even want the help. They say they would rather starve. If it means watching their children die is the cost of eating these individuals were not injured in war, rather, they will harm to wipe, trying to provide for their families the situation is surreal and chaotic. If aid is to come to us this way, we dont want it we dont want to live on the blood of our children again, as a reminder, palestinians have lived through 145 days of near nonstop death. Theyve now had to watch more people die. The only question tonight is this a Tipping Point . Or will this get Lost In The Fog Of War is just another day, another unfortunate series of events that ended with death and without change. Joining me now, mehdi hassan, hes the founder of zaizhou news. It launches on substack next month and his book win every argument is also out now on paperback. Many thanks for joining us tonight. Its good to see you. Look israel as we just laid out in the last few hours, have tried to frame this as a tragedy, but just not one that is their fault the idf says it fired Warning Shots to try to disperse the crowd around that convoy do you lend any credibility to that explanation . And from the eyes of the world does it matter what the explanation is for what we saw unfold . All right. Well abby, thanks so much for having me on the show and thank you for that very important, very powerful intro. You did just there in terms of believing the israelis, i would say that it took multiple innocent black people to die at the hands of police in this country, whether its breonna taylor, whether its freddy gray, whether its george floyd for people in our industry ib to start saying, well, maybe we shouldnt just blindly believe Police Statements after shootings happen. And i feel like we still havent quite reached that point in the middle east with the Israeli Military, the Israeli Military tend to say things that turn out not to be true, both before gaza, when they killed shireen abu akleh, us citizen, had lied about it, or read during this conflict, so many lives, the Israeli Military has told about a terrorist godless under the Rantisi Hospital Or command and control center under the alshifa hospital. A documentary in lebanon that they claimed was palestinians face making their own wounds. So many, you cant even count. And now we are told today well actually it was just a stampede even though eyewitnesses, abby say that the israelis opened via israeli tanks open fire without warning, according to one eyewitness in the washington, both doctors say that the bodies they got at the hospital, you showed the pictures on people on donkeys well, mostly bullet wounds, not stampede wounds. The israelis open foreign hungry people trying to get flour. Its being called a Flower Massacre for that reason. And you asked is, is it a Tipping Point . I mean, in any normal world, it should be in any other conflict. It would be abby when putin did stuff like this in ukraine, we condemn them when assad did stuff like this in syria, we condemn them when israel starves Hundreds Of Thousands of people and then shoots people who go to get flower. Whereas the condemnation for the United States government, the state department spokesman, would not condemn israel today. So its a tragedy is at a Tipping Point. I wish it was as i suspect it isnt. What President Biden has said is that he has acknowledged the events that happened and says, it will likely complicate the negotiations that theyve been working on for a temporary ceasefire from bidens perspective, do you think this could be the incident that pushes him to actually rethink how he approaches this relationship with this particular Israeli Government and this war as i argued it out, guardian piece recently, joe biden has the power to pick up the phone and end this war. He can ring the israeli Prime Minister and say were cutting you off. Were cutting off a, were cutting off armaments. Israel, israelis themselves, israeli general, so we cant do this war without america. He hasnt done it. He didnt do it after 10,000 dead. He didnt do it off to 20,000 dead. Today, we cross 30,000 dead. You have to ask the question why this is a man whos seen as the great comforter in chief, the great empath has had huge personal tragedy in his own family. And yet 30,000 palestinians according it was own Defense Secretary today, 25,000 women and children. How on earth has he not stop the war till now . How another we still debating this and abbey onn on the situation on aid. I just got to point out here four out of five of the hungriest people in the world or in gaza right now, even with or without those aid trucks, people are starving a two month old baby call mahmoud fatou, starve to death earlier this week in gaza, this is not a natural disaster, this is a manmade famine. Food is plentiful. Its available, its a few miles away and yet its being blocked. In fact, at the israeli crossing abbey, i dont know how cnn viewers know people are putting up bouncy castles. Israeli protesters, and eating popcorn and candy, cotton candy and blocking the aid. That is crazy it do you think mary that there is look, i think you understand that president , you say present biden can just pick up the phone and cut it all off. You you also understand he probably wont do that. So if you were to give him advice today, knowing what he is likely to be able to get to a yes on what is the one thing that you think he should do today that would make this better marginally better tomorrow for gazans it simply it is get a ceasefire and it is within his power to get a ceasefire. Its within the power of the Un Security Council to get to see if i remember the rest of the world wants a ceasefire. Its america that is blocked this at the Un Security Council, even other western nations have backed a ceasefire its biden, blocking it so glad. Is he, if he was able to get that ceasefire that hes been discussing over the weekend, you would view that as progress . Anything at this point is progress when hundreds of people are being killed every day. But i would point out use the right word marginally better. A new study came out this week that said, even if you get a ceasefire tomorrow, 6. 5 thousand palestinians will die in the next six months from the Public Health conditions. And if you dont get a ceasefire tomorrow, 58,000 palestinians will die over the next six months once we will be complicit in that, its our weaponry, its our money, its our diplomatic support. And our president can stop this and i hope he does it real quick. I dont think he well, before you go, i mean, obviously, you know, this has become a Major Political issue for the president. Do you think that if it does cost him the presidency, that it should given his decisions on this war what i would say is that joe biden has rightly said for the last few years that donald trump poses an existential threat to our democracy. The idea that he would risk not only his own presidency but the future of american democracy for the sake of Benjamin Netanyahu and itamar ben gvir, and Bezalel Smotrich and the rest of the fascist in israel is bizarre and inexplicable to me. All right, many, hassan, thank you very much for all of that thanks, abby and up next breaking news tonight, special counsel jack smith, announcing his preferred date for Donald Trumps documents, trial as we learn what prospective jurors will be asked, plus the dual at the border, what President Biden did not announce as trump pushed fears about migrants. This is Newsnight Cnn News Night with abby phillip. Hes brought to you by. So tick two fine. Now, youve so tick to is the treatment youve been looking for. She found the feeling of finding the Psoriasis Treatment shes been looking for sheath found sertich to a oncedaily pill for moderate to Severe Plaque Psoriasis for the chance at clear are almost clear scan its like the feeling of finding your bag is back were Finding Psoriasis cant deny the splendor of these oncedaily sertich two was proven better, getting more people clear skin than the leading dont take if youre allergic to so take too serious reactions can occur. So tiktok can lower your ability to fight infections, including tb, serious infections, cancers including lymphoma, muscle problems, and changing its certain labs have occurred. Tell your dr. If you have an infection, liver or kidney problems, high triglycerides, or had a vaccine or plan to take two is a tick to inhibitor, tick to as part of the jak family, its not known as it took two has the same risks as jack inhibitors. Find what Plaque Psoriasis has been hiding theres only one subject to so ask for it by name. So clearly you, so tick to why settle for one guestimate to see the value of a home when realtor dot coms real estimate gives you up to three independent valuations. Dont all abs do that. Not really trust the number one app Real Estate Professionals trust, download well, the realtor. Com app today, its easy to get lost in investment research. Introducing jpmorgan personal advisers, hey, david, connect with an advisor to create your personalized plan. Lets find the right investments for your goals. Okay, Great JpmorganWealth Management im sorry, body for knowing about actives. But giving 100 of them to my face, the fear no more body get active serums with Hyaluronic Acid that quench vitamin c that brightened and pro sara life that even everywhere, new Dove Serum Body Washes get dove or get fomo when these Business Owners need cash fast, they turned to biz to credit to fund whats next from Fitness Studios to medical offices and every Small Business in between. Weve got your covered whether you need new equipment, funds to expand or need money to cover unforeseen business expenses, bids to credit is the trusted partner for your Small Business funding needs scan the code on your screen now or go too busy to credit. Com to apply this to credit funding. Whats next your skin is ever changing take care of it with goldmans Healing Formulations of seven moisturizers and three vitamins for all your skins called bond at Morgan StanleyOld School Hard Work meets bold new thinking to help you see untapped possibilities and relentlessly work with up for 50 over real stone. And even more during our winter sale that night out on the ice, he saw something, thought nothing he there was some as charming man, youre ever going to meet or he was your Worst Nightmare he was bad math. Youve adopted a kid and now theyre trying to kill you, want peace people to pay for what theyve done. You have to dig to get to the truth this is going to read for everybody as doubts rise, the Donald TrumpsElection Interference Case will happen at all before the election. The trial over his classified documents well that very well might, thats if jack smith gets his way. Now, tonight, the Justice Department is asking for eight july 8th start date, but with trumps immunity claims in the hands of the Supreme Court, seems thats unlikely. But were also tonight getting a look at the fight between trumps lawyers and special counsel over what questions can actually we be asked of people who might be on that jury . The first do you believe 2020, the president ial election was stolen . Prosecutors want that one. The defense does not. The next question also facing the objection from the defense . Do you have any opinions, feelings, or beliefs about the Us Department of justice or the fbi prosecutors also want to know where jurors get their news on the defense side, lawyers want to ask the jury about their personal politics. Are you registered to vote . Are you registered with a particular Party Affiliation . Did you vote in the 2020 president ial election now, jack smith doesnt like any of those questions along with this do you have any negative views about Law Enforcement including the fbi, federal prosecutors, criminal defense attorneys, judges, and politicians joining me now to discuss this. Tim parlatore, hes a former attorney for donald trump, and elie ms dahl justice correspondent and columnist for the nation, as well as host of the new podcast. Contempt of court. So elie, what do these Juror Questions tell you about the strategy on the Prosecution Side and tell us a lot. I think theyre pretty standard. I mean, at this point, asking whether or not you believe the election was stolen is a simple question of mental competence, right . No different than asking, does too plus two equal four or is the earth flat, right . Lets not, its not a big idea. Its not a big deal to try to screen out jurors who are mentally incompetent to sit in judgment of others. And at this point in our history, whether or not you know, who won the election is a basic mental competence point in terms of some of the others about the Party Affiliation and whether or not you had any negative feelings about Law Enforcement. These are fairly standard questions in any jury trial. If i am sitting on a jury and let say a cop is being prosecuted for perhaps Police Brutality or a person is suing saying that they were brutalized by the cops and i was a jury for a potential juror, they would ask me, do you have any feelings about the cops . And id have to answer truthfully, and i probably wouldnt be on the jury. And thats okay. So like most of the questions i think are pretty standard or basic questions about mental competence. I mean, tim, its an important point. Theres a clear answer to the question. Do you think david 20 2011 . Action was stolen and if you answer wrongly, even if that is 40 of the country or whatever that number is. I mean, do you think that that should be on the table here . I mean i dont think its a Mental Competency question, but it is something that you do want to know. I think that you know, it surprises me that the defense doesnt want that question on there because ultimately the point of Jury Selection is to try and weed out any prejudices that the jurors may hold it would prevent them from hearing the case fairly. And so the question, none of these questions really strike me as necessarily being absolute disqualifiers, because any one of those questions can then be rehabilitated through, well, even though you think whatever about the election, are you registered for whatever party or whoever you voted for . Can you set that aside and hear this case fairly, which is some of the questions that the defense had proposed in the final questions and really the whole point of Jury Selection. You want to try and find these things out and have a full picture because last thing you want to do is to seat a jury and then find out later that somebody had some prejudice that prevents them from hearing the case fairly. Yeah. I mean, they not just want to find it out, but i mean, Presumptively Le they also want to be able to weed people out, perhaps based on how they answer some of these questions. Given how polarized some of these questions its our, the media that you consume. Do you have a negative view of politicians the 2020 election questions, how hard do you think its going to be elie to find a jury that is acceptable to both sides on all of those fronts. Well, thats gonna be the whole ball game, right . Like it is going to be difficult in our polarized nation to find a jury that both sides that everybody thinks is fair. I think its possible, but its going to be hard. My question more, abby is like i wish we could ask these questions of the judges, right . I like to know eileen maga cannons answer to some of these questions. Id certainly like to know chief Justice John Roberts is answer to some of these questions, right . So while were sitting here investigating whether or not we can get a fair jury. I feel like were slightly missing the ball that the judges and the prosecution itself might be bias, might be painted it might be unfair based on the history that weve seen from these republican appointed justices over the past few months speaking of just add, since you brought it up, elie, youre getting some attention for what youve said recently about why you think the justices are taking up this Immunity Case. The Supreme Court justices, that is why say that they are hoping for trump to actually win because theyre doing everything they can to delay his recognition so that he has an opportunity to reinstate, install himself as president of United States. Looking at the Supreme Courts own history, we see that when they want the move fast, they move extremely fast. They heard the colorado Immunity Case within 51 days of that decision being entered in against trump. Why . Because it didnt help trump. Now, with the Immunity Case in dc, we see that its going to take them at least 130 days before they even think about hearing the case. Why . Because in that situation, delay helps trump and we can go back throughout history. We can go back to bush v. Gore. We can go back to lots of different cases. We can go back to the texas bouncing, hunting, abortion banned thing when the Supreme Court wants to move quickly, they move when they dont they dont. And it is totally fair to ask why, why is it that when it helps trump they All Of A Sudden want to slowwalk it. They move like an end. But when it helps, when it, when its something that could hurt trump, they move like a fighting or akai what do you think about all that time . Those are good political talking points, but as a lawyer, you have to look with the actual record is and in every one of those cases, you make a motion for an expedited schedule. You put out the reasoning for that. There is reasoning why the colorado case had to get expedited because of the dates of the primary and the dates of the general election. The reason why the trump case is not being expedited, the Immunity Case is because the prosecution did not articulate a reason why it needed to be expedited jack smith went through great detail saying, oh, it has to be done because its so important but he never said why and thats the problem is that you cant just say its important because jack smith says its important. You have to actually meet the legal standard. And its not any of the papers. So again, thats some great. The actual argument youve got, the Asphalt Motions go ahead, ali, is the actual argument here that Clarence Thomas and john roberts dont know why it might be important to figure out if the president has committed crimes, needs to go to jail before the primaries. Is that really the argument that were thinking here . Because i dont buy that, i dont believe that the issue here is that the Supreme Court just they didnt know how important it might be to get trumps trial moving and signed, sealed, and delivered before the primary process or before the Republican National convention, or certainly before the election. That just doesnt make a lot of sense to me and tim real quick. I mean, why exactly. Yeah. Why wouldnt accord take that into considering patient right because that is something courts are not allowed to do. Theyre not supposed to be engaging in Election Interference and really trying to figure out something to take the decision away from the wall of the people and thats the reason why jack smith didnt offer a reason he was noticeably silent on that for a reason because what elies saying may be true for what jack smith wants. But jack smith can write that because its totally impermissible to say, judge, we need this case done now before the election because if we dont do it before the election, then he might win thatd be totally improper and just cannot say just based on people, no one party wants this done and the other one doesnt. All right i want to know if senate, both Political Parties wants to know if one of the Major Party Nominees is a criminal isnt that information has been brought out through the six hearings, through Everything Else that the voters can decide because theyve seen all this. So all of that information has been out. Theres another thing jack smith, why go based on his dragon thats available jack smith dragged his feet jack smith drag his feet. You got to remember i wasnt part of this case during the investigative phases. They could have brought this indictment much earlier. They didnt at the time we had maralago, which was going very fast thats a lot of activity. January 6, which was sitting there pretty much at a standstill. All the sudden, he brings his Snap Indictment and All Of A Sudden the next few weeks realize, oh, shoot, i forgot to interview a whole bunch of witnesses. The timing of the indictment is something thats control. Another thing all right. Well leave it there doj are confusion. Like that . Well, well leave it there with the two of you on that one. Does that conversation i think it doesnt matter. Its doj i think thats a longer conversation. Well have to continue another de elie, mr. Tim parlatore. Thank you both very much thank you. And next, the dual at the border, the rhetoric, the promises, and bidens dare her to donald trump standby my best reputation is ruined. Its prime video. All my shows and movies are here. I feel joy im sick of me if youre like i was, youre tired of wornout plastic mats under your office chair. They dent in, crack in their uncomfortable to roll on. I found a premium alternative im glass chair mat by the trazodone. I liked it so much. I bought the company. Im george pardo, president of the draws are glass chair mats are made of superstrong glass and protect elected with a nano tech coding. So youll always get a smooth, easy glide and their beautiful, tired of replacing plastic, i promise this is the last chairman matt, youll need. And we give you a Lifetime Warranty comfort style, durability of a trostle glass chair. Matt will completely transform your works home office or office . Office. We stock 18 popular sizes and we ship free to anywhere in the lower 48. Get the look you deserve. I invite you to shop up online at vitro gaza. Com. Use Promo Code Tv and save 10 on any glass chair. Matt at vitro aza. Com terabytes heads makes all your moves count, whether you bought a house or starting an awardwinning tv show. Thats right. We guarantee 100 accurate taxes. Shes good i have county a county. Hi, there sometimes the lows of Bipolar Depression feel darkest Before Dawn With Cap later, theres a chance to lead in the light kept lighter is proven to deliver significant relief across Bipolar Depression. Unlike some medicines the only treat bipolar one gets lighter traits. Both bipolar 1. 2 depression and in clinical trials, Movement Disorders in weight gain were not common. Call your dr. About sudden mood changes, behaviors, or suicidal thoughts antidepressants be increased these risks and young adults, elderly Dementia Patients have increased risk of death or stroke report fever, confusion, stiff, or uncontrollable Muscle Movements, which may be lifethreatening or permanent. These arent all the serious side effects capsulated can help you lead in the light. Ask your dr. About caballito, find savings and support at kept blida. Com it his bad dad, holding back all your ambitions all in one low fixed rates, borrow up to 100 k, no fees required. So phi get your money, right . You hits a Smart Center Stage in his crushed by a Baby Grand Piano you replacing me customizing, saved with liberty. Liberty. Inspection. T even have a schedule your free inspection colleague, 33 leaf filter today, more physically filter. Com Laura Coates Live tonight at 11 eastern on cnn the general election hasnt officially started, but it definitely felt like it did today. And before i tell you about the dual that played out on the border, just keep this context in mind. There was a bipartisan bill to help undeniable crisis out there. One most called by conservative Immigration Legislation in years, one that even President Biden said that he would sign until republicans killed it because donald trump wanted them to. Now, he didnt want biden to have a win this election year. So with that in mind, the two men, they both appeared at the border hundreds of miles apart from one another to amplify their stances on this issue. Which obviously couldnt be further apart its real simple. Its time to act this is a joe Biden Invasion is, is a Biden Invasion. Bipartisan Border Security deal as a win for the american people, the United States is being overrun by the Biden Migrant Crime is time for the speakers and some of my republican friends in congress were blocking this bill to show a little spine. This is like a war its a military operation. So heres what i would say to mr. Trump. Said a plan policy issue. Join me or ill join. You. Been telling the congress to pass this bipartisan Border Security bill 20 me now is democratic congressman Joaquin Castro of texas congressman, thanks for joining us. You heard there join me or ill join you. That was President Biden essentially daring President Trump to work with him on passing the bipartisan Immigration Bill that by the way, trump torpedoed. So what message do you think it sends to voters that biden is essentially stretching out a hand to trump whos clearly much further to the right on immigration. And by the way some of the rhetoric today, pretty extreme yeah. Well, first im glad that President Biden was in texas and had a chance to visit the border and see the situation for himself. Im also glad that he pointed out that donald trump and republicans have stood in the way, not just in the last few months, but in the last several years to any kind of Immigration Reform at all that said we have today more cbp agents, more drones, more surveillance, more Law Enforcement at the border than weve ever had before. And President Biden and democrats had all have offered to do even more on Border Security and republicans, as you mentioned, have torpedo that. But i do think that the president has to be careful not to follow donald trump too far to the right. Hes rhetoric today, Donald Trumps rhetoric was absolutely extreme. It was even more dehumanizing of these immigrants. Then we heard in 2015 when he first came down that escalator at trump tower he has been talking about an invasion. Hes talking about a war. Hes making up the widespread quote, unquote migrant crime. When we know that these folks commit crime at a lower level than those of us who are native born americans. And so i appreciate that the president was in texas, that hes calling out donald trump and republicans. But also think hes gotta be careful not to give in issue that what i think right now, a once in a generation of virulent antiimmigrant rhetoric and sentiment that donald trump is pushing some of that though, is driven by the reality that there is a lot of illegal Border Crossing happening right now. I mean thats happening. People bowl who are in the country seeking asylum are now being sent far from the border you mentioned donald trump, and this migrant crime issue hes using examples from some recent highprofile cases, including last weeks murder of a georgia Nursing Student this is ground that i think a lot of candidates have have tried in the past. They do it because scaring voters generally works. Are you worried that this is actually something that can be effective and will be the frame for which republicans attack biden and democrats going into this next election . I think the politics of fear and resentment time and again, not only the United States, but in other places around the world, has shown itself to be effective. Sometimes and you can try and instill fear and resentment in people. And what folks will do is take one for a few examples of immigrants who have committed crimes and imply or outright suggest that every Single Person is like that, that every immigrant is coming to harm americans, to kill americans. That is what donald trump is doing. And that is what has been done to other groups in this country previously and so theyre trying to win elections that way. And weve gotta be careful and the media and politicians need to push back on it and tell the truth but what about President Biden . I mean, did he ms an opportunity . By not going down to the border sooner addressing these issues sooner before it got to this point ive not talked to the white house about how they made their decision on timing im just glad he had a chance to the brownsville today. What about what his role is in all of this . He talked a lot about what republicans havent done. That border bill that he discussed today is effectively dead do you think President Biden has a responsibility to use any power that he might have as the executive, the Chief Executive of this country to do more on immigration right now i think that the executive branch, whether its President Biden or another president , should always look at ways that they can be helpful, whether its an issue or another issue. And quite honestly, because the congress has been gridlocked on many big issues for awhile. Weve seen president s do who exactly that. But what Speaker Johnson and other republicans are asking of President Biden is to reissue orders that donald trump issued, which were deemed by the courts to be illegal. So if the question is, should President Biden take executive actions that were deemed illegal before . I mean, thats actually not the question. I mean, the question is should he take any i mean, whats the solution on the democratic side if you know, congress is not going to act. What is this president who is a democrat, who i think you believe is closer to your side of this issue. What is he going to do right now . The answer nothing or is it something . Well and know the president should look at what he can do legally through executive actions. But what theyre wanting him to do or not legal doing, what donald trump did was declared illegal. And so anything that he can do that is not what republicans are asking him to address. The current immigration crisis. Nothing. Well, i mean, what are you suggesting exam i mean, im asking you what what are the policies that are available to this president . Are there any or are there not . No. I mean, the republicans havent even said have not specified what exact policies they would ask him to do, except the ones that donald trump did. And those have been deemed illegal hi, congressman Joaquin Castro, we appreciate your time tonight. Thank you very much. Good to be with you next new House Speaker mike johnson is having issues with his own party yet again. But this time they say that he likes energy and i believe it or not, testosterone will speak with the House Freedom caucus chair, Congressman Bob Good about all of this the parking gate and im all out of whack is going to take a lot more than a little ticket to get out a year and if you have cut red car insurance, this could leave you all been out of shape so good all state and be better protected from may have like me, someone has broken to pow i was stuck unresolved. Depression symptoms were in my way. I needed more from my antidepressant, very large helps give it a lift adding velar to an antidepressant is clinically proven to help relieve overall Depression Symptoms better than an antidepressant alone. And in real our clinical studies, most son no substantial impact on weight elderly, Dementia Patients have increased risk of death or stroke report unusual changes in behavior or suicidal thoughts antidepressants can increase these in children and young adults report fever, stiff muscles, or confusion as these may be lifethreatening or uncontrolled Muscle Movements which may be permanent, high blood sugar, which can lead to coma or death, weight gain and high cholesterol may occur. Movement dysfunction and restlessness or common side effects, stomach and sleep issues, dizziness, increased appetite, and fatigue are also common side effects may not appear for several weeks i didnt have to change my treatment. I just gave it a lift. Ask about velar and learn how abby can help you save when these Business Owners need cash fast, they turn to bids to credit to fund whats next. From Fitness Studios to medical offices and every Small Business in between. Weve got you covered whether you need new equipment, funds to expand or need money to cover unforeseen business expenses, bus to credit is the trusted partner for your Small Business funding needs scan the code on your screen now or go to bids to credit. Com to apply this to credit funding. Whats next . Men tell us when they use just for men to eliminate gray, theres a great before and after. Then. Theres the after the after that boost you get when you look and feel your best and thats why more men shubi, just for men when migraine strikes, youre faced with a choice except the tradeoffs of treating or push through the pain and symptoms. Weve youve rally theres another option one dose quickly stops migraine in its tracks treated anytime, anywhere. Without worrying where you are or if its too late, do not take with strong cyp 3a4 inhibitors, allergic reactions to draw that can happen. Most common side effects are nausea and Sleeping Migraine Pain Relief Starts with you. Ask you about uvalde. Learn how abby could help you save no old spice you can use on your pits chest and even your toes oh, thats fresh hi, my name is kim and i am 41 years old. Ive been given the opportunity to work from home. So that means lots of video calls. I see myself more and i definitely see those deeper lines im still kim and i got Botox Cosmetic. I wanted to keep the expressions that i would normally have your rent. Youre on camera and the only person they can look at as you i was really happy with results. I looked like me just with fewer lines Botox Cosmetic is fda approved to temporarily make frown lines, proceed. And for headlines looked better, the effects of Botox Cosmetically spread hours to weeks after injection causing serious symptoms. Alert your dr. Right away as difficult hes swallowing, speaking, breathing. I problems for muscle weakness, maybe a sign of a lifethreatening condition, do not receive Botox Cosmetic if you have a skin infection, side effects may include allergic reactions, injection site pain headache, eyebrow, eyelid, drooping eyelid swelling. Tell your dr. About your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions and medications including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects. See for yourself, like botox, cosmetic decay im eva mckend in washington and this is cnn tonight Speaker Mike Johnson decided to pass another shortterm Spending Bill with the help of democrats. It is the third time that hes done this despite the fact fact that he got his job after members took the gavel away from Kevin Mccarthy for doing exactly the same thing joining us tonight, republican congressman from virginia, bob, good congressman. Thank you for staying up for us tonight. Yet again, the house is worked with democrats to pass a shortterm Spending Bill. The senate has done the same its now headed to President Bidens desk whats your reaction to the fact that congress is going down this path again with another shortterm extension well, this is a reflection on the failures of the previous speaker. We have the House Majority had a stronger majority in terms of numbers. Last year, a year ago, and he you made a commitment to pass all spend or bring, at least all 12 Spending Bills to the floor for a vote. He failed to do that. He only brought one before the last week of september. Then he brought through that final weeks. So he brought in for before he was removed as speaker at the end of september, where 1 october. And so that was the breaking of the pledge that he made to become speaker. It left the current speaker in a tough situation. However, we are now some 14 months after we were given majority of control and weve still got the Biden Pelosi Schumer policies in place and the spending levels that are bankrupting the country. And so the era of crs that dont make any change or even increase spending needs to end. We should pass a yearlong cr that thats about 100 billion triggers the caps. If we run it through september 30 that were voted into law last summer with the effort. But how is this Kevin Mccarthys fault . I mean, this speaker, mike johnson, hes been in the job for several months. Hes now done this. What, three times. Pass a shortterm extension. How is that on . Kevin mccarthy at this point . Well, literally by the time Speaker Johnson was elected speaker at the end of october, he was a month after the deadline for all 12 Spending Bills to have been brought to the floor for a vote when only four had been brought to a vote before he became speaker. So my point is that he inherited a difficult situation that we should not have been in when it became speaker however, we should not have been passing vcrs. I voted against all of these sees, all the rs of course. Ive condemned or criticize this currency are that we should have done a cr that goes through september 30. All republicans should have voted for that. We should have sent it to the senate with Border Security attached to it. And then if the senate want to shut down the government rather than later at the caps go into place that they voted to approve. And in president signed a year ago and they refused to secure the border. Let that be on the center of a shutdown the government. So some of your other colleagues are not quite as patient as it sounds like you are with the current speaker. Chip roy and matt gaetz both accused mike johnson of punting and kicking the can down the road and in their words acting as if republicans dont have the majority. In fact, gaetz said, all republicans offer is quote, low energy and low t. T stands for testosterone. Do you agree with anything that they said there . Well, i do agree with those statements and thats why i said i i voted against the cr. We shouldnt and the cr we shouldnt be passing major Spending Legislation was predominately democratic votes. They would never do that if they had the majority have you ever have done that when theyve had the majority . So i believe that is a failure for us to continue to do that. And again, i would not have brought this bill to the floor. I would have sent the Senate Something that triggered again the spending caps, 100 billion in savings if he did a cr through september 30. And i would have attached hr to our Border Security provision for president says he wants to secure the border. Laptop, havent tell Chuck Schumer to pay pass our bill. So congressman look, mike johnson now has done theres pass the cr with democratic support three times. Kevin mccarthy did do it once is the speakers job in jeopardy . Well, the precursors to the pleasure of 218 members, the only people that i hear talk about him not serving that capacity. Our Media Members who asked me that question almost every today. But i am confident that if the previous speaker was here, we would have already done an omnibus or the end of the year, like like what happened two years ago or a year . Before that, i should say so again, we should not be we need to cut our spending when you do a full year cr through september 30, we need attach Border Security to it. I would also attach funding for israel paid for and fisa reforms that protect americans constitutional right. Thats what i would do. Thats what the speaker should sounds like. Thats why i voted against the cr today. I spoke, on the house floor and the debate before the vote against the bill, just along with side my colleagues that youve mentioned, chip roy, matt gaetz. Sounds like it sounds like what youre saying is no, hes not job is not in jeopardy as of right now. You and your colleagues doesnt take very much a view to put it on the line, are not willing to do that at this moment. Is that right . Well, i didnt flippantly or cavalierly talk about removing the previous speaker before that action took place. And im not flippantly or cavalierly talking about it now, the speaker again serves a pleasure to an 18 members as long as he has his word to 90 members, hill we the speaker. Im not aware that anyone is planning to try to remove him as speaker. However, this job is Performance Base is not personal and we need to begin to start delivering wins for the the american people. The majority that we have, the senate has require 60 votes to advance legislation. Theyve only got 51 democrats. We can pass our legislation with a simple republican the majority we ought to get at least half of what we want in a negotiations with the senate. Unfortunately, weve not been doing so. However, im encouraged with the recent resignation of the Democrat Money now already leader, Mitch Mcconnell and no, i didnt misspeak there. But who was working with Chuck Schumer against mike johnson as the speaker of the house. I think were going to get a new leader in the senate sometime in the next few months, which will be a more Conservative Leader that a better work with our House Majority. What what happens if the senate picks one of the johns barrasso, cornyn or through and to replace him or any of those names acceptable choices to you. Why would love to see someone like rick scott who challenged Mitch Mcconnell most recently . I think youll see more senators willing to vote for a conservative option. Someone has to get 25 votes if the republicans have the majority, or actually with a 49 votes right now so let the minority leader, so id like to see someone like rick scott. I think mike lee, ron johnson ran paul, ted cruz or also will be outstanding candidates. But the center is going to do it the center is going to win. Do unfortunate, i dont have a vote on that all right. Congressman bob. Good. Thank you. We appreciate you answering our questions tonight. Thank you. Next on newsnight, tonights oped s e cupp is going to tell us her take on the state of today his Republican Party and alternative to pills volterra. Is a clinically proven Arthritis Pain Relief Gel which penetrates deep to target the source of pain with nonsteroidal antiinflammatory medicine directly at the source, volterra and the joy of movement when you buy or sell your car, exactly how you want with car gurus, you might begin to wonder, what if you could do things your way all the time some do come true get your car, your way, get it with gurus whats your sap thats why vision works, makes it simple to schedule an eye exam that works for you, even if you have a big trip to play playing around. Meghan, see you right now. Thats convenient. Vision works. See the difference sometimes i imagine, but id write today for my dear friend martin id remind people that all he thrives on one thing silence the people who will change the nation are those who speak out, who refused to be bystanders, who raised their voices against injustice when we stand up to silence, we stand up to all hate power, etrade, awardwinning trading app makes trading easier with its customizable options chain, easy to use tools and Paper Trading to help sharpen your skills. You can stay on top of the the market from wherever you are. Etrade, from Morgan Stanley. If youre living with moderate to Severe Plaque Psoriasis or active psoriatic arthritis. Symptoms can sometimes take you out of the moment. Now, theyre sky rosie so you can show off with clear skin and show it off with sky rizzi. You could take step with 90 clearer skin and if you have psoriatic arthritis, sky rosie can help you get moving with less joint pain, stiffness, swelling, and fatigue and the sky rosie is just four doses a year after to starter doses, serious allergic reactions and an increased risk of infections or a lower ability to fight them may occur. Tell your dr. During if you have an infection or symptoms had a vaccine or plan to thanks this guy rizzi, theres nothing. We were skin and less joint pain and that means everything your dr. Half of what i paie go to harrys. Com slash shave to claim your 7 trial. Laura coates live next on cnn close captioning brought to you by mesobook. Com our firm has offered a free book about mesothelioma for over ten years. Mesothelioma is really all we do. 80087 to 4901 how would you describe the state of todays gop party . Well, cnn Political Commentator and Conservative Se Cupp has a few words in tonights oped, just a few words. So lets just call them the no solutions party. Republicans have gone from pushing limited government to no government at all. It seems todays gop lawmakers seem utterly convinced that among their many expectations as members of congress, solving problems simply isnt one of them. Division, purity tests, owning the libs keeping their base angry and afraid, Prostrating To Former president donald trump, unleashing the culture wars and getting reelected are just some of the things that republicans have decided are far more important than governing on immigration. Republicans infamously just passed on a bipartisan deal that would have given them more than theyve ever ive gotten on Border Security, including things that theyve insisted on an urgent matter of national security. After trumps Supreme Court overturned roe v. Wade, republican lawmakers had no plan for addressing the Reproductive Health concerns of millions of women and families and now as that ruling also threatens to throw ivf access into a state of limbo. Republicans still have no answers other than fend for yourselves on gun violence. Republicans have blamed everything but guns to avoid bringing any Real Solutions to the table. On Climate Change and issue which many younger Republican Voters are worried about. Gop lawmakers are more interested in removing the issue from federal oversight completely rather than on any solutions that the Public Sector might be able to offer. Now we can blame trump for a lot of this, but the party is now responding to voters that just want their grievances amplified being angry at the problem. And explicitly not solving it has become the Republican Party platform. Its a strategy that hasnt resulted in many electoral wins over the past few years. But in running trump again and digging in their heels, it seems the no solutions gop is tripling down on its commitment to proudly do nothing well, i see first of all, i buy it. How does that track how you ever i mean, it hasnt been huge electoral wins for republicans, but it hasnt been a full denunciation either. I mean, this is a 50, 50 country sales. This president ial race is virtually tied. If voters were punishing republicans for it, would we see that theyre not, and thats a really important point. You can blame the gop and theyre intransigent, intransigents, theyre responding to their voters. Their voters are not demanding solutions to problems. If you look at someone like Marjorie Taylor greene, right, georgia, whats your claim to fame . Impeaching joe biden, 7,000 sometimes you look at matt gaetz, florida. Whats his claim to fame ousting Kevin Mccarthy. How is this serving . Their folks at home in their districts and get the folks at home in their districts are not demanding better. Like i said, they want their grievances amplified, but theyre not demanding solutions for them. So what will it take for that to change . I mean for actual issues to be on the table for actual solutions, for actual compromise, which by the way is required if you are going to get things done. Yes. I mean, compromise. Thats way too lofty goal at this point. At this point, what voters need to start demanding is solved some problems for me at home. And the Immigration Battle is a perfect example of republicans screaming about a problem, a real problem, by the way. And rightly concentrating on it for years, months. And then when given the opportunity to solve it, they punch, they pass on it because its too politically profitable to leave things broken. Its really disappointed. Yeah, i mean, look, but is there a structural problem here . We were just in the break talking about the new york race. Tom okay. If if there were more districts where both sides had to actually fight for the actual middle . Yes. What would happen in theres theres that thats great. Theres the problem with redistricting is i think serious, but theres also the primary problem. The primaries dont draw a lot of middle of the roads. The extreme voters when out to the extreme by nature . Yes. And listen, this problem is asymmetrical. Im not bothsidesing, but i do we want to say on the left, democrats for a long time pretended that the economy, the border and crime were all fine. And its only recently that theyve started to realize no, these are problems and we need to Start Talking about them. Thats a different thing. Republicans are fetishizing inaction. Theyre absolutely fetishizing not governing because thats not what theyre there to do, is also a question about like are republicans talking about reality or things that are not real . Like, was the election real . And by joe biden won or was it not real . Some of that belongs in the category of just whether its grievance or whatever you want to call it, its not actually talking about the things that affect peoples lives. Its outrage and keeping if people angry and afraid has become the bread and butter. And as long as theyre angry and afraid, which theyll stay if you dont solve problems, then theyre going to line up to vote for these figures. So its sort of a cycle that kind of neverending vicious, vicious cycle. And s e