Process. Carol and we hit the red carpet to celebrate the bloomberg 50. Our annual list of those that have measurable accomplishments. But first, the biggest ipo, saudi aramco. Shares surge to a market value of 2 trillion. At the peak. Carol a culmination of a fouryear effort from the kingdom. We are in wanted to talk about this. A lot of questions. Now it is publicly traded and it is an ipo but it is only a small there ine, 1. 5 is out the public in terms of the company. Reporter the ipo has not turned out the way they expected it to happen. Back to 2016er when the initially announced plans for the ipo, the plan was to sell shares of the company. What we really have to look at is what is the purpose of the ipo . It is seen as a means of diversifying saudi arabia away from its Oil Dependent economy, to raise money from International Investors and to deploy that on projects outside of the core energy industry. Theevaluation did valuation did not get close to what they wanted but it is at attracting International Investors into the kingdom. This is probably a great opportunity to showcase what they have. And also to attract in anational investors skill that has not been seen before. Having said that, the objective has not hit the mark. Saudi arabia managed to complete the ipo with the help of local investors with families in saudi arabia and also neighborhood countriesolitically that are close to the kingdom in the gulf region. It is still a way from what they wanted. Jason thank you so much. Carol let us bring in joel weber. Reporter a combination of amazing coverage from the abouterg team this year the listening devices. Americans in particular really love these things. Carol we really love these things. Joel there have been some privacy concerns that the tech team has done and we bring it together in the cover story. Jason the bloomberg 50 was this week. What a night. You guys looked great. Joel this is a gala meant to celebrate the people on the list and their accomplishments in 2019. Carol the remember having conversations at my table and we did a broadcast from there. People were loving the eclectic names. Way ofloomberg 50 is a using what we use better than anybody else, data. Looking out across the various worlds of finance and entertainment to see who has had real impact. Jason we will hear from some of those honorees later in the show. I have to ask you about the new red scare. Our is a story that caught attention. And once you get into it, it is a little terrifying. Wallman has really delivered on this line of reporting. We did it as a cover story earlier in the year especially around what is happening in the medical and hospital worlds where we have seen chineseamericans get driven out of the country. That particular research is around cancer. And now, it turns out and this is the latest story in the u. S. Ics section, the government has targeted people that work in military and in particular there is one wasleman we found that wrongfully accused and pushed out of the government and army and had to retire. There was never a case to be made against him. Carol really troubling. Another great issue. Editor of the magazine, joel weber. Let us get more on that mistrust in the department of defense and how ties to china could prove fatal to the security. This is a continuation of work i have been doing all year long on the whole question of whether we are overreacting in this country to the threat of chinese as be a notch. Specifically the threat of the theft of international property. Weekeeks business story is about an Army Engineer threatened by a military intelligence from the army. This is a civilian engineer. And ultimately his security clearance was taken away after over 20 years of stellar performance including developing that the nsaem uses for communications and eavesdropping and things like that. Lost hislar scientist, security clearance forcing him to retire. He was of retirement age. Not the biggest body blow but he was humiliated. He was accused of disloyalty. , friendslot of ties and neighbors who were asked many times if he was ace eye for china. He is a chineseamerican individual and he suffered a great deal as a result of this. The end of the story is that ultimately the pentagon decided he was not a spy and was innocent of their suspicions. It is kind of a sad story. Thethis individual question is and this goes to how you can it off, are we overreacting . Is this an isolated incident . Are people being targeted in the wrong way . Is a lot of this happening . Peter the distrust level and that is the keyword the level of distrust of Chinese Americans has soared in recent years and a colleague in the bloomberg Data Analytics department, andre tartare, did an enormous job of filtering and analyzing some 26,000 cases in the government database of security clearance decisions, who gets it and who does not. He found that in the past decade, the rate of rejections of chineseamericans essentially for security clearances has gone from Something Like 44 which was the average of all the countries including other nonchinese countries to over 60 for chinese. It is a real growth in the rate of rejection for that which is a kind of barometer of suspicion, distrust, and essentially difficulty for these american citizens. Alexa,coming up, privacy . Listening devices. Jason is the new applecart really a late . Really elite . Why the answer matters especially at places where you shop. Carol this is bloomberg. Carol welcome back to Bloomberg Businessweek. Im carol massar. Jason and im jason kelly. You can also catch up on our daily show i checking out our podcast. Carol and you can find us online and our mobile lab. Privacy one of the major themes of 2019. Jason and the cover story for this week focuses on how silica and valleys Biggest Companies have fooled millions of people into allowing them to listen in on their stories. This is a big story about how these devices like amazon echo and their Virtual Assistant alexa or siri if you have these devices in your home or on your phone, this is a story about how these things work. These Tech Companies in Silicon Valley presented these topics presented these tools as automated. Vastrns out there is a apparatus of human listeners improving the services. When voice commands are submitted to their service, they are sometimes rerouted to data centers where humans are transcribing your words to improve speech recognition. Carol there was an assumption that there is a robot listening. Tell me about these humans. What kinds of conversations are they listening to . What are they hearing . To dozens of contractors, people that are placed everywhere from ireland to india. In the case of apple, they rely cork, irelandm in where dozens of contractors will be listening in on peoples recordings and they told us they feel deeply uncomfortable listening to this information. Calling children in many cases. They heard couples engaging in sexual activity. Very private conversations in your kitchen and bedroom. The alarming ring is how invasive this is and the people on the front lines are often the most lowpaid workers in the supply chain and they found this very disturbing and emotionally unethical. Jason this has been a story you have been covering through the year. One of the defining stories in many ways of 2019. Broadly speaking. The discomfort we are starting to have with the relationship with technology. What do the Companies Say . One of the most profound things to us was the disparity between the contract ors and how this was more late dubious versus what the tech engineers and executives were telling us. When we started reporting this, it was like they did not think it was a big deal. They did not anticipate this. It was him was like it was par for the course. Fixing Quality Assurance issues. They described it as best you know when your app crashes on your mac, do you want to report this bug . They described it as a voice bug. Theseroadly, it was fyi, systems are only recording when you activate them and the vast majority of voice commands are handled by computers with a small number of them needing human inputs. Whether that makes you feel more comfortable using the services, there is no doubt that millions of recordings are still being transcribed by humans. Carol the applecart. Jason it is exciting for apple and its users, perhaps not so much for the retailers. What we spoke to jenny on premium plastic means for consumers as well as retailers. Visa and mastercard have several different tears. Tiers. Visa signature or mastercard world and then the premium tier. Carol we are constantly being ranked in society. This is note different. For mastercard it is world elite. Every time you swipe, it costs the retailer a little more in fees and it has been years of this huge rewards war going on with banks. Retailers are like we have had enough and they are ready to take the visa and mastercard. Jason and here comes apple joining the party. Carol it is an elite card. It is expensive for retailers. It had a huge launch. 10 billion dollars in line extended to consumers in the first month it was out. A very popular part. Is justs feel it another think they have to spend money on. It is holiday season. They are trying their best to compete with the amazons of the world and this is one more thing in the negative rocket. Carol what negative bucket. Carol when we talked about this on our radio show, we did not know there was this incredible set of tiers with credit cards. Is anhe elite card, there assumption that they make more money and will spend more. You will win in the end is the thinking. I think historically that is what visa and mastercard have thought. These people come in and have way more buying power. Their ticket sizes are on average larger. That is that has been the justification. Retailers are coming back and saying if im a gas station or a grocer, people with these high rewards are not necessarily spending more on gas or groceries. Wese retailers are saying are reaching our breaking point. Our margins are already thin. Carol turning lemons into lemonade at lululemon again. Jason we speak to the ceo and the private Equity Investor who wins big on the retailer and comes back to fix it. Carol great story. This is bloomberg. Carol welcome back to Bloomberg Businessweek. Jason you can also listen to us on the radio. Including on am 11 in new york. The bay area. 0 in and always on the Bloomberg Business app. Lululemon earnings are out this week and although the stock dropped shares, it is a remarkable turnaround. And it also has to do with the bostonbased investment equity. Sweat equity. Jason interesting. This is a never before told story of the money behind one of the most Influential Brands of our time talking about lululemon. Million,t invested 74 not that much in private equity, and they got eight times as much from that 2005 deal. Lot014, another deal and a more money. I sat down exclusively with David Rutherford and calvin mcconnell, the ceo at a store right here in new york city. The business had its challenges but at its core, the issue was alignment. Part of the power that private equity can bring is that alignment. Case, we had a situation where the founder was not aligned with the lord and the Management Team so you sell some turnover of the senior management. You also did not have the with the ability to make investments. Streetre following wall and thinking about what they needed to do that quarter. And so, i feel like what we saw was this fundamental opportunity to help regain that alignment and put the platform in place of the company could establish a really strategic opposition and not just the here and now. But part of the real opportunity is to help them get out of the any a share game penny a share game and make some of these it some of these investments that had been deferred. Jason i want to get to the moment when calvin came into the company but leading up to that you do have a series of ceos. Leadership becomes something you have to deal with in terms of the various issues you have to address. Firstly, we had a situation where the board really loves this company and wanted to see it succeed. And so, in that regard, when we came back in in 2014, we were able to create some of that alignment. Pretty easily. And help create the ability to put some of these ideas in place. The idea of a longer term plan. But, you are right, i think some of those challengers with the founder made it hard. Foundert that the exited the company in 2015, we were able to begin assembling a worldclass Management Team. And so, with a cfo who initially was stuart now coo and a talent along the way leading to people sun glenn and calvin and and a host of really worldclass business leaders. And the exciting part is that this business had that potential it just needed the opportunity and the framework from this point and beyond. It really feels like the business is just getting started. And seeing what calvin and the team have already done with the manifestation of this next step vision in chicago and the membership and loyalty program, you are already beginning to see the seeds of thinking about what the Broader Vision might look like. Jason what does that look like Going Forward . It seems like we are in an interesting moment in retail growth. We have a huge runway growth. We have doubledigit growth. And new categories. Into our womens category and on the guest category. Guest category. This is an emotional branch. And expanding into markets. We still have a lot of opportunity in north america not to mention what is happening in International Markets including europe and china. Doubleing to met our mens business. Proving that this business resonates with men as much as women. For our category it is a dual category. Carol borrowing money is easy for american reparations. Jason some of the riskiest bar borrowers. A carol let us get to this weeks Bloomberg Businessweek explainer. It is called earnings before amortization. It is a metric that became popular in the 1980s and it gave corporate raiders like carl icahn and Saul Steinberg a way to evaluate potential targets. It even would measure the ability of a company to generate cash. But it does not take into consideration the impact of debt on the bottom line. And companies are finding more ways to tweak the numbers. L a 350 million for the 12 months prior. Based on generally accepted accounting principles, the company lost almost 48 billion in the same perio. Used acently, Wework Community adjusted metric. Positive loss in two a earnings segment after the adjustments. Critics worry about what it is doing to the 2. 5 trillion market for jump wants saying it blurs the picture of Americas Health and creating false perceptions of safety. Bloomberging up, the 50. Politicsom finance and , we talk to those that shape that is shaped 2019 in unexpected ways. Carol this is Bloomberg Businessweek. Beyond the routine checkups. Beyond the notsoroutine cases. Comcast business is helping doctors provide care in whole new ways. All working with a new generation of technologies powered by our gigspeed network. Because beyond technology. There is human ingenuity. Every day, comcast business is helping businesses go beyond the expected. To do the extraordinary. Take your business beyond. Jason welcome back to Bloomberg Businessweek. Look at a dataa nerds guide to do good. Jason you have to give away some money this season. Plus, provocative remarks. Why Companies Run by women are not always fair to them. Carol first, we have to talk about the bloomberg 50. Is all the people whose accomplishments merit recognition. Carol we caught up with a bunch of these names on the list, two of them on the red carpet. Media. Ounders of gimlet it made it the biggest deal in the broadcast industry. Started the company in 2014, and we were coming at it from separate perspectives. I was working at this american planting i had started money with my cofounder. I was seeing this excitement building around this ondemand way that audio was getting delivered by people. Somebody should make more of these. Then matt was on the others of looking and seeing the same sort of thing. Carol is that true, matt . Matt if you look over the whole history of media, every time a m comes about, a new Media Company is built. The new media was radio, and that is when nbc got built. Build the defining brand for this new medium. Carol isnt it fascinating, because it is like radio in terms of listening to Great Stories being told. I think it is such a simple thing. It harkens back to radio. Alex even further back t than that. What we are doing is one of the oldest forms of media in human existence, telling stories. We have been telling stories to one another before there was any other media available. Many of the oldest stories in Human History were oral stories before they were ever written down. They were telling them before human written language was invented. It is very deep and very primal, and i think that was one of the issues when we were first starting. It is just talking, right . No, it is also on the back of new technology and all these new tools. Jason so where are we in the evolution here . You guys, as we said, were early. A lot of people have piled in, it feels like. Everybody has a podcast, everyone standing around the subway has a podcast. Where does it go next . Matt we are just at the very beginning. The term that i think you have we are at the dawn of the second golden age of radio. The first golden age of audio was in the 1930s and 1940s. It was when broadcast news we as born, it was when you saw fiction, like the shadow with orson welles. Audio has not evolved that much in the last 60, 70 years until now. Now you have a couple Big Technology changes. You have smartphones in every pocket, connected cars coming online. And you have smart home devices that people are listening at home, and even talking when they are in their car. All of these things have kindsed to this all new of listening experiences and new source of storytelling. It is like radio, but more intimate. Carol there is something about putting on your headphones and going into a different world. Matt it feels like you are listening to your best friend hang out with you or tell you a story just made for you. Carol someone else that made this years list, boris jordan. Jason he is the executive chairman of curaleaf, one of the worlds most valuable cannabis companies. It has a market cap of 2. 8 billion. Carol jason and i spoke with him and talked about a lot of things, including the future of cannabis. Boris i was very surprised. Opened up the russian privatization market, but the last thing i thought was a Cannabis Company listed in the bluebird 50 in the bloomberg 50. It reflects the fact that people are starting to accept the fact that cannabis is going to be a part of our lives. That have states legalized cannabis in one form or another. More and more people are using it. The fact that bloomberg has recognized that is a big deal. It shows it is becoming mainstream. Carol for a while, we talked about the Canadian Cannabis companies. I feel 2019 was more about the u. S. Companies, yours included. What do you think 2020 is going to be when it comes to the cannabis story . We are waiting for regulations to come out from the government. I am curious what you think. Boris if we get over impeachment, which i hope we will at some point in time, i think it will be a continuation of the u. S. Story. That is not to say anything negative about canada, it is just a bigger market. You are starting to see more and more of them. The numbers will be quite big and staggering. I think that will get recognized not only by washington, but also by the markets at large. I think the Mainstream Investors that largely avoided cannabis until today, you will see more of them getting involved as they see these Companies Put up significant numbers. Jason talk about the Big Companies getting involved because there has been some twists and turns with the bigger u. S. Companies dipping their toe in, making investments. Goodses the consumer park market get involved in this . How important is it they get involved in order to grow this business in a meaningful way . Boris just this evening, bloomberg announced we hired someone who ran dr pepper or snapple. Was at another company. Builtare guys who have and run very big businesses, the understand brands and supply chain. You are starting to see more of those people into this market. That is the first sign. The reason they are coming before the Big Companies is because we are still legal. I think you will get the safe banking act and the states act. When you get the states act is when you will see the multinationals take a look at cannabis because it fits so well with everyone of their other products they sell today, whether it be beverages or food or different additives. The Pharma Companies will be the last because they are waiting for synthetic cannabis. Carol what does that mean for your Financial Model next year . If we get those pieces of legislation, the numbers will take off, is that true . Boris the cost of capital for our company, but not to the industry. We are growing at 300 a year, and we will grow from 300 billion. Carol but you cant do that across states . Boris you will still be sideload in the states siloed in the states. It is like gambling in the u. S. You cannot go crossborder come across state lines in gambling. You have to be siloed in the state you are in. It is not federally legal. Jason coming up, more from the bloomberg 50 red carpet. Chainrn about a supply tech Company Worth almost 1 billion querrey it carol plus the economist. Jason this is Bloomberg Businessweek. Jason welcome back to Bloomberg Businessweek. Carol join Bloomberg Businessweek every day on the radio starting at 2 00 p. M. Wall street time. Catch up on our daily show by this and into our podcast. Jason you can also find us online at businessweek. Com, and our mobile app. Total ubiquity. Carol we want to get back to the bluebird 50 red carpet. Jason after a trick to bangkok, startedceo ankiti bose a market. Ankiti the Balance Sheet is almost 5 of global gdp, so it is huge. Besides that, very little technology has really touched the entire industry, which is remarkable. The way yourrials, iphone is made, unlike any of that, that is very little really anyy, or amount of transparency and apparel. That leads to all these problems that fashion is accused of, that we are filling up the landfills, that there are children working in factories making close for you. Hes for or that the children are cannibals, people are buying too much. All of that can be solved with technology, creating a lot of transparency. That is where we come in. We provide a Technology Platform for mills, factories, to attract the brand that wants products made by these people and make sure it is done in a sustainable, transparent way. Jason i love the transparency piece. If we think about our big themes of 2019, fashionopolis, the great book about fashion and everything bad that has done, and all the bad will it has engendered in the whole category of the population. I have to think that lack of transparency existed for a reason. People didnt want you to know. How hard was this to crack into it . Ankiti you are exactly right. Today, the fashion supply chain has 30 players, and you only need five of them. So 15 of those guys or girls are just there jason they are all guys. [laughter] ankiti even the traders are not adding a lot of value. Jason im sorry, i just want to go back. There are 20, and their need to be five. Incredible. We are adding an immense amount of value to their business, making sure they are held accountable. Jasons carol to point, how difficult was it to make inroads . Established an chain out there. How tough was it to do this . Ankiti actually, once you go beyond the big manufacturers and go into the world of asian manufacturing or south American Manufacturing or he even here in the u. S. , it is quite fragmented. Most fashion is made within a very fragmented manufacturing place. Once you start giving them technology and bringing them online, it becomes much more easy for them to find their suppliers and buyers. Maybe it is hard in the newnning to get in a country or a new area or a new subcategory, but once you do it, there is so much of a network effect. Jason more from the bloomberg 50 now. Google searches for modern monetary theory more than iadrupled in early 2019, think largely because of us trying to understand why this was such a thing. It turns out, a lot because of our next guest. Carol everyone wanted to know about it. Economist Stephanie Kelton has promoted it for years. She helped raise the theorys profile this year. Stephanie it is kind of astonishing. In a lot of ways, what is happening is people are coming to some sort of terms with the idea that when the next downturn comes, policymakers are not going to be able to reach for the usual toolkits and do what they have done in the past, that we are going to have to start thinking more creatively, more ambitiously, about what policymakers can do in response to a growing weakness in the economy. It isk for many people, increasingly viewed as that alternative that can help us think about ways to be more have the so we dont long, protracted recession we had last time. Jason were you surprised that this was a year where a lot of people from alexandria ocasiocortez to Bernie Sanders, they introduced it . We talk about the overton window all the time, the move in mcs favor. Carol i love when you say overton. It makes me so proud. [laughter] jason it was a moment. It entered into the political and even the mainstreams nest zeitgeist mainstream business zeitgeist. Were you surprised . Stephanie yes and no. When you have been pushing hard to get that breakthrough moment for a set of ideas and you have really worked as a scholar and an academic and with a number of other people as well, this is a team effort. We put heart and soul into this product for more than two decades now. At some point, you expect this to pay off. But when you have that moment and you have politicians like you are talking about giving oxygen to these ideas, it really is remarkable. Carol for everyone like a Bernie Sanders and others who are supporting it, you have had a lot of highprofile names. I am curious if you are having more and more conversations with more folks who maybe were against this that are starting to say, you have an idea here. Thehanie for me, some of most fun conversations and communications i have are with people in public are not in public. It is people who reach out to me privately. If it was known, i think the shockwaves would reverberate in a much more dramatic fashion. But it is encouraging to know there are people who are really out there willing to take the scholarship seriously, ask russians when they are not sure, do the ideas ask questions when they are not sure, do the ideas justice. Are sensible and sound economic principles. Jason coming up, a provocative thought. The problem with female ceos is not that they are female. It is arguably that they are ceos. We will tell you why. Carol and how two individuals are showing the world how to be better at being a billionaire. Jason this is Bloomberg Businessweek. Carol welcome back to Bloomberg Businessweek. Jason listen to us on the radio on sirius xm, channel 119. Also a. M. 1130 in new york, 106. 1 in boston, 99. 1 f. M. In washington, d. C. Carol a. M. 960 in the bay area. In london on dab digital, and of course, always on the Bloomberg Business app. Jason provocative remarks in the magazine this week. Carol with the headline, the problem with female ceos is not that they are female, it is that they are ceos. Jason we caught up with rebecca greenfield. She has the remarks. Rebecca i noticed something that was happening, which is there were a lot of Companies Run and founded by women, but they also have these missions that we offer gender equality and our products will create this gender equality, and thats great. But then there would be these scandals where employees would say, actually, i am a woman who works at this company and you are not practicing what you preach. We saw this happen for a few years. We saw this happen at thinx, a company that makes under wear for women to wear in their period. We saw this happen at nasty gal. More recently, i wrote about how it is happening at the wing right now, the coworking space. There is a huge backlash because there is irony happening, you are not practicing what you are preaching. I am exploring that phenomenon in this piece and saying, yeah, thats going to happen because women, when they become ceos, act a lot like men when they become ceos. Carol so many are young startups. You are a startup, you are constantly putting out fires. That is an element of it. Rebecca definitely. Startup, you are under a lot of constraints. You have a lot of money and you are learning to grow quickly. What they are learning is when you startup, you scale, it is he feminism your mission. That doesnt square with creating a big successful company, and maybe it shouldnt have to, or why would we accept that . Jason one of the things i took away from this, there is a distinct difference in the telling of this between the benefits of having women on a board or women in management versus diversity. That seems to be at the core of what you are arguing here, right . Rebecca i think there is this fallacy that we want more women to lead companies because women are more compassionate than men, they are more ethical, they are more moral, they create safer workplaces, and that is just not true. The research has found that is not true. In fact, that is just another gender stereotype. I talked to a researcher who put it out there and said, women are not that different from men in the way they lead. And that is the reality. The benefits of diversity come not because women are different from men, because they are not that different from men, but because they are divers and they are different they are diverse and they are different from the 10 men in the room. We want a mixture of different type of people, different point of views, to push back on the homogenous thinking that leads to bad decisions. Jason this week in our pursuits section, two individuals are showing the world how to be better at being a billionaire. Carol lets get more from editor chris rovzar. Chris the arnolds were very private until this year. They made their money first through enron then sentaras, and john arnold is a they made theirlegendary trader. They are on the billionaires index. They have a couple billion dollars of their own, and a couple billion with their foundation. They have set out to reform criminal justice. Also the pharmaceutical industry. And they do it by doing a ton of research. They are not liberal and they are not conservative, or they try not to be. They just do studies until they find the inequalities in the system. Carol hence the data, right . They are datadriven. Ands they hire experts, they really dont go after something it is really important if you have that kind of money that you dont try to address everything that someone asks you to address, so they picked the things they focused on. Through studies, they are really obsessed with that. They did this one thing where they really did 100 different studies from psychological journals to see if they could be reproduced, and only 40 of them could. They are really testing theses. One of the things they are focused on is criminal Justice Reform and bail and parole. They think the criminal Justice System is one of the systems that knows the least about itself so they are trying to get some stability into that. Carol there is a section about venice. Chris venice had its highest last month, and it did serious damage, not just because places were flooded, but the force of the waters moved some stonework. Save venice, a Great Organization working to save the treasures of venice ends spent 1966 flood, works to explain what they spend money on if you give money to them. 500 will get you a days work from a conservator, on experts, not just a cleaning person, who figures out the issues. For 1. 1 million, you can renovate the whole basilica. It is everything in between. There are old mansions that have been damaged. There is a lot to do, and the money is ready to be spent. Jason Bloomberg Businessweek is ready on business stands now. Carol what is your mustread . Jason the cover story. That is the latest in a series of stories. Bloomberg has been ahead on this idea that people are listening to us. Carol i think we dont realize the extent they are. It is definitely a must read. What youead, i love did. I think this story has gone through so much the last 10 years, and you really get to where we are. Jason that is what i found most interesting, the coalition of things i am really interested in. The private equity story has never been told before. If you want to hear more on that story, check out our extra podcast this week. It is a longform conversation with the director and the ceo together for the first time. Carol once you listen to the podcast, check it out. More Bloomberg Television starts now. Taylor im taylor riggs in for emily chang and this is the best of Bloomberg Technology where we bring you all of our best interviews from the week. Up next, Silicon Valley is listening to your most intimate moments. Smart speaker craze and how vulnerable users are. Google drop out of the top 10 places to wo