Transcripts For BBCNEWS HARDtalk 20240912

Thank you very much For the invitation. Its nice to be here. Its great to have you on the programme. For the past 1a years, your boss, Prime Minister viktor orban, has been waging a political war against what he calls the liberal elite in brussels. Do you think hes winning that war . No, its a. Its a long war. We still have time, but we have to take the war because. Because its about our freedom. And, you know, i think in european culture, we respect freedom. The hungarian people are very much freedom loving people. They want to decide how to live their own life, what to do what is their purpose, what are the rules they want to follow . And from a historical point of view, also, We Hungarians dont like to be dictated from outside. It doesnt matter from which direction it comes. UnFortunately, the current Progressive Liberal Elite likes to dictate to the others how to live their life and what to do, what to think about the World Order or anything else, so its a. Its a long battle. Thing is. But were still standing. Yeah, youre still standing, and youre still members of the club. I mean, if youre in a club, youd like to think that all members were committed to consensual politics, to Finding Solutions together. But it seems you and your boss, viktor orban, have given up on that approach. Im just seeing something you wrote recently the era of peaceful coexistence with liberal Forces is over. With liberal Forces is over. Does that mean you see a new era of total political confrontation in brussels . UnFortunately, if you follow the news which are coming from the western World Notjust from my country, notjust from brussels, but from london or from washington, dc you see that this peaceful coexistence is everywhere over. UnFortunately, things are very much polarised. Like, politicians are getting shot, they want to sentence to jail, huge riots, rebels and so on and so on, huge confrontation, huge violation of Freedom Of Speech and rights and so on. So unFortunately, the west has lost its way, and. But Hang On a minute. The people youre talking about who adopt violent means, theyre not democrats. I mean, youre supposed to be a democrat. In the European Union, For example. Yeah, violation is not a democratic value. Its an undemocratic value. Im just talking about the symptoms. And, you know, the post cold war golden Age Period of time is over. Everybody knows that in your country, in germany, in hungary and we have to react. And We Hungarians, we are members of the club. We sign up For the rules. But there is nowhere in the rules that you cant have your opinion, you cant suggest an Alternative Direction For europe. I mean, we believe in democracy, we believe in european cooperation. We even believe in nato, which is a. Well, you dont, to be honest with you. Im just looking at the reaction of prime Minister Orban to the reappointment of Ursula Von Der Leyen to be president of the European Commission For a second term. Your boss said, we cannot work together with her. It is clear that hungary intends, over the next few months, years, to be a blocking Force inside brussels. We are dissatisfied with Ursula Von Der Leyen� s policies and last term, so our recommendation For europe was not to choose her as a candidate. But the rest, the other Member States, they made a different decision. But The Point now is that the European Politicians see how hungary operates inside the European Union, and they do not like it. Theres deep frustration with your country, particularly. Lets get to the specifics particularly over your strategy, your approach to the war in ukraine. According to lithuanias Foreign minister, gabrielius landsbergis, Hungary Has blocked 41 of the different approaches, resolutions that the eu has tried to adopt on the ukraine war. He says, this has gone too far. We as a community, the European Union, the club, we have to find a way around hungarys determination to block. I mean, its very transparent what were doing. We have a Minority Opinion in the last two and a half years. I think that we are on the good side of history, so history will prove that what we were saying from Day One about the war, it will come. It will become a truth, because what we were saying its obvious that russia is taking responsibility, has to take responsibility For this violation of international law, act against ukraine. So, russia attacked ukraine. This is out of question. But the important part of it, what to do, how to solve the conflict, and the European Leaders and the western liberal leaders in the last two and a half years were saying that we should support the ukrainians, push the warfurther, dont do any kind of diplomatic actions, not engage with russia, push further the war and support the ukrainians. And what happened . More than 500,000 people died. Ukraine lost more territory than they had beFore. Ukraine as a country, from an economic point of view, collapsed. There is a serious daily risk of escalation. So i dont see it as a sound and logical strategy on the western side. And We Hungarians are criticising this strategy from Day One. We have an alternative vision about that. And they want to silence us In The Name Of European whatsoever unity. I think the most important value in europe is democracy, is plurality, where every Member State can be heard. Europe hears you. Europe hears what many regard as Putins Apologist sitting in budapest, because when you say that the only solution here is to stop the war, you, in essence, are saying to vladimir putin that he can keep what he currently holds, which is almost 20 of ukraines. But sorry to say that. Sovereign territory. Why is the case that all the liberals, the same kind of people. There is a conflict in the Middle East and they know how to solve the conflict. They talk about how to solve the conflict in the Middle East every day first, restore communication channels, then put together a short Term Ceasefire and try to figure out a long term peace agreement. The same kind of people, they dont know this in the case of Ukraine And Russia wars. You say there is no question that russia invaded ukraine, that international law, international justice, requires russia to leave ukraines sovereign territory. You agree with that, right . Yes. So why do you say that that cannot be achieved by Ukraine Fighting A War Of National Resistance . Because its. Forfirst, its realpolitiks. You have to see what is Going On the front line. Second, i dont want to risk the third world war. I dont know what you think about this, but i dont want to risk the third world war. But The Point about your position is. So. Hang on. The point about your position is, youre saying ukraine cannot win, but you then thwart europes efForts to help ukraine with financial and military assistance, thereFore becoming a self perpetuating circle. You say ukraine Cant Win because you are one of the countries blocking giving ukraine the means to win. Separate the two things from each other. We support ukraine in many senses humanitarian support, Energy Support and so on and so on. We are providing. We hungarians, hungarian taxpayers, are providing money For the functioning of ukrainian state. Its about the ukrainian nurses. Its about the ukrainian teachers and so on. But right now, right now, you are. As we speak to each other, you are still. Inside the European Unions processes, you are still blocking more than 6 Billion euros worth of aid that the rest of the eu wants to send. Military aid. To ukraine, and you are refusing. Because we dont want to be part of it. I just. I just want to stop killing people For nothing. It happens. It happens For no reason. I mean, why dont we stop it . If you portray those who disagree with the Mainstream Policy of the west as putins puppet, then, intellectually, all discussions are immediately becoming dead. Many countries in the eu have weaned themselves off russian oil and gas. Youve chosen to go to moscow and actually sign new agreements which deepen your dependency on russian gas in particular. But also, you still want to use russian oil. We want to use oil which helps For the hungarian economy. Its a decision which is based on National Interests, and we have every right to do so. If its western oil or gas, or if it comes from the east, then its all good For us because its a practical question on our side. And i dont know why it makes sense that europe is giving up its cooperation on field of Energy Policy with russia. And there is one kind of dependency, and then they change and turn it to another kind of dependency. And the Energy Prices are skyrocketing, inflation was on a very high peak and the middle class of europe is suffering, and russia has no problem to find alternative routes. Why . It makes sense. Youre also getting loans of more than 12 Billion euros to build a nuclear Power Plant using russian technology, russian construction workers. You have actually just fast tracked a new Visa System to allow more russians to come into your country. These are all signs that when it comes to the strategic choice to be made in europe, budapest has made its choice. Its going with putin. I respectfully disagree with you For many reasons and mainly on a factual basis. We have to dig down into the things. Its obvious that we dont want to give up our sovereignty. We want to decide with whom we cooperate on the field of Energy Policy. And we have our energy resources. You are dependent on russia. Yes, yes. But For us. Its not cooperation, its dependency. No, no, no, no. But we have alternative channels. I dont know if you have time, we can go into the details. I can show you all the interconnectors, the development, and i can explain you why a nuclear Power Plant means For a small country, a small, Landlocked Country like hungary, means more independence in the field of energy, not less independence. So its very important For us. Its true. We want to maintain our pragmatic, energy based cooperation because its important For us. We would be insane to give it up. But the hungarian position is always based on the hungarian interests, and we dont care if we are criticised For that. We are ready to cooperate with our European Partners on all fields where its an equal basis of law. We have to do our best, but we want to maintain our sovereign Foreign policy. And, actually, ithink in this new World Order, more and more countries should do the same. When you talk about and we discussed it at the beginning of this interview this war that you believe has to be fought against the values, the ideology of the liberal elite in brussels, you talk about ukraine being one key, specific factor in all of this, but you also talk about migration. Is hungary. Determined to continue to violate European Law in its pursuit of the toughest anti Migration Policy . 0r defend European People against illegal migration. No, im talking about law at the moment. As you know very well. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The European Court has ruled repeatedly that your policies of summarily removing those who try to get into your country to seek asylum, your policy is out and out illegal. Yes. But the problem is with the European Law, it has to be changed. But we go back to The Point you signed up to this club, you signed up to uphold europes laws. You cant suddenly decide that the law is illegitimate. Yeah, but why dont we get an opt out on the Migration Policy . And then the European Union. Thats not what you signed up to. Well, denmark can have it and hungary cannot have it. So its a. Its a technique which exists. Sorry. You have to operate under the rules which you signed up to and youre refusing to do so. You are serially violating European Law. Are you going to continue that or will you stop . We will keep continue to protect the hungarian people. And i personally and the Prime Minister and all the right wing politicians, we will not let hungary down through illegal migration, as it happened with many western countries. We dont want to change our society. We dont want the violation. We dont want a serious mess, what it is in other countries. We try to respect European Law, but with all due respect, European Union law is not fitting For this problem. Its not good enough. It doesnt help the countries who are protecting its borders. It actually makes our life more miserable. We spend 2 Billion euros in the last eight years to defending our borders. It means we kept out hundreds and hundreds of thousands of illegal migrants, kept out. Yeah, the European Court of human rights has ruled that your treatment of unauthorised migrants has involved arbitrary detention, excessive use of Force, and it is a fundamental violation. Youre telling me all of that will continue . No. I mean, im telling you that we have an effective system which keeps illegal migrants out. So all those politicians who are saying that its impossible, they are lying. They are lying to you. They are lying to your voters. Its possible. You just have to stick the regulation. The regulation is very simple. If you dont have the right to enter a territory of the country, we dont let you in. You can apply For asylum from outside. And if the Asylum Application is decided and you get the green light, then you can enter the country. Its so simple. Imean. The funny thing is that this position you take is part of a wider point that Viktor 0rban has been making For the last decade about hungary not needing, not wanting migrants to come into the country. This is what he said in 2016, quote, hungary does not need a single migrant For our economy to work or the population to sustain itself or For our country to have a great future. Eight years later, today, we see that hungary, because it is short desperately short of labour, is inviting Guest Workers from a list of 15 non eu countries to come into the country, to come and work on three Year Work visas. You d0 need migrants. You just wont admit it. Again details, details, details. If you look on how hungarian Asylum Law looks like or the regulation about the Guest Workers, its very tough. Its the toughest in europe. Probably its more closer to the qatari regulation than to other European Countries regulation, because the idea is if we have hungarians who are willing to take the job, then we dont need migrants. This argumentation, you know, our Prime Ministers quote, was a reflection on that. Its not acceptable. We dont need migration. We need family. Your population is expected to fall from 9. 6 million to 8. 5 million by 2050. You, just like the italian government of giorgia meloni, have had to recognise that, For all your Anti Immigrant rhetoric, you need immigrants. No, its like. We need Family Policy and we need families. Your Family Policy that is, giving Tax Breaks to mothers who have more than four children, all that sort of thing it hasnt worked. Your Birth Rate is nowhere near the Replacement Level For your population. Yes, but may i give you some figures . The Fertility Rate went up from 1. 2 to 1. 5, 1. 6. And its now gone down again. The last year, its gone down again. We will see. Lets see. Well, no. Weve already seen its gone down again. Lets see the results of The End of the year. The second number of marriages went up, number of divorces went down. Number of abortions went down, without changing any kind of regulation. And the living standards of the households with kids are much better than in 2010, when we started to govern. I agree with you that more things should be done, but i disagree with all the liberals who are saying that, 0k, we couldnt achieve success in just ten years time lets give up and lets invite people from other side of the world. Its going to be destroying european societies. We dont want to follow that pattern, hungarians. We still believe that Family Policy can work. We have some achievements. Its notjust about incentives. Its a complex system where you respect the families, respect people with kids, try to help them in many, many, many ways. This. Weve talked migration. I hope that all conservative governments in Western Societies will recognise, and we can work together to figure out how to make it done. Yes, except they look at you violating Eu Law and many of them dont want to violate the law in the way you do. But lets move on, because. Sorry to say. The point. Theres a big point here which is important. When it comes to your policies toward migrants, when it comes to your policy toward independent media in your own country, your policy toward the Rule Of Law, the Independence Ofjudiciary in your own country, the eu has looked at what youve been doing over the last few years, and it has decided that you are not in accord with the eus fundamental values. To quote the European Parliament declaration from 2022, your government is not a democracy. It is a Hybrid Regime of electoral autocracy. And you have been punished For these violations of eu values with massive financial ramifications. In terms of the cohesion fund, the Post Covid Recovery fund, you have lost billions of euros because of your stand. Are you now prepared to say that, in future, hungary is going to have to modify its position . Try to understand whats happening. In the European Parliament, there is a liberal majority. You know it. We all know it. And they accept a resolution against all conservative governments that, you know, what you are doing. Sorry. You are the only country who has been punished in this way. No, no, no. There was poland. Yeah, but poland has never suffered the financial penalties that you have. They were. They suffered. They suffered very heavily. And surprise, surprise liberals won the Polish Election and there is no more problem with polish democracy, although the liberals are openly saying that they have to restore democracy against Rule Of Law its a temporary violation of Rule Of Law, but we have to do it because it was so horrible, the previous thing. The same things happening everywhere in the western world. Look at whats Going On in the united states. Everybody, all the republicans, are accused of being anti democratic. In the meantime, the liberals are doing Everything Everything to cause financial, physical problems For the conservatives. We hungarians, together with some other partners, organised a conference in brussels where there were some national conservative people, mps all over the world, and they wanted to talk about why its important For. Nation states family, religious values and so on and so on and brussels liberals, they want to ban this conference and they did everything to ban it. I mean, it became such a big scandal that some Prime Ministers had to actively engage. And then immediately, which is the most Funniest Part of it, when the Prime Minister of belgium engaged and tweeted something that probably its too much then the court immediately changed its mind and they let the conference Going On. Your government right now has much more in common with russia, close ties that youve developed with china as well, very close ties that you continue to maintain with Donald Trump and your boss has said he wants Donald Trump to win the us president ial election. That is where your government sits today. Your ideological brothers, if you like, are in beijing, in moscow, and certainly Donald Trump as well. We want to have good relationships and we will put energy into making good relationships with all western powers. But now it seems that the west is going to bad direction. 0bviously from political reasons, For us, its easier to talk and to discuss things and to figure out with new ideas with all conservative governments, united states. Well, authoritarian governments. Imean. Sorry, but again, you make the conversation impossible if you say that Donald Trump and the republicans in the united states are authoritarian. Well, i was thinking of your close ties now with china, with moscow. I understand. You know, like, its the liberal Fukuyama Type of dividing the world between democracies and autocracies. I think its false. If the west wants to keep its dominant position, we have to get rid of this liberal interpretation of the world. We cannot divide the world. We have to find our way to cooperate on a pragmatic, National Interest based type of cooperation with everybody. There are sovereign countries and powerhouses, and we in europe, we have to figure out how to deal with them, whether we like it or not, whether we morally agree with them or not. This is the new reality. Balazs 0rban, thank you very much Forjoining me on hardtalk. Thank you very much For having me. Hello. On wednesday, we had a chilly Northwesterly Airflow across the uk and that brought us a mixture of sunshine and showers. Some of those showers really dramatic. A beautiful strike of Foot Lightning there in nottinghamshire and in the same county. So much hail late afternoon that it completely covered the roads and pavements in newark on trent. The showers then were particularly widespread. Im showing you this because weve got a similar look to the Forecast'>Weather Forecast as we head into thursday, so here we go. Weve got that Chilly Flow Of Northwesterly Air coming down from polar regions, and as that cold air gets heated by the seas, well, thats what makes the showers. So as long as this Cold Feed of air continues to work in, so too will the showers. For the time being, though, most of the showers are actually draped around coastal areas. Inland areas at the moment largely dry with clear spells and its cold temperatures starting off the day in the coldest spots down to around about two Degrees Celsius. Cold enough even For a nip of ground frost. So a really cold start For a September Morning thursday morning, but loads of Sunshine Showers from The Word go around coastal areas as we go through the day in those temperatures rise, so the showers will start to break out across Inland Areas from the late morning and into the afternoon. Some of the showers will be heavy with Hail And Thunder and theyll be very widespread. So most places will see a downpour or two through the day. Temperatures about ten to 16 degrees and probably the heaviest showers come the afternoon, i think across the midlands and eastern england. By friday we see an area of high Pressure Build across the uk. So thats going to kill the showers. Its going to be another very cold start to the day. Lots of morning sunshine. But this time were going to start to see some Rain Move into Northern Ireland towards The End of the day. Another cold day For the time of year. Temperatures about four Degrees Celsius below average For september. All change though, into the weekend. An area of low pressure is going to be bringing some wet and windy weather. Could get gusts of wind of around 50 to 60 miles an hour For the North West of scotland. With the Rain Piling in here and really accumulating, southern and eastern areas should stay dry with some sunshine. And with the winds coming in from a Southwesterly Direction and windy weather. Could get gusts of wind of around 50 to 60 miles an hour For the North West of scotland. With the Rain Piling in here and really accumulating, southern and eastern areas should stay dry with some sunshine. And with the winds coming in from a Southwesterly Direction across the uk. So temperatures are going to leap upwards closer to average For the time of year with highs of 16 to 19 degrees. And it looks as we head into next week, High Pressure is going to dominate. So loads of dry weather around next week with temperatures close to or perhaps even running a little bit above average with some warm sunshine. Welcome to newsday, reporting live from singapore im Katie Silver the headlines. Less than 2 months beFore the us election the president ial hopefuls traded insults in a live debate watched by more than 57 Million people us secretary of state, antony blinken, and the british Foreign secretary, David Lammy Visit Kyiv Mr Blinken said theyd been hearing how to better help ukraine defend itself. Thousands are evacuated from the vietnamese capital, as the Red River surges to its highest level in two decades, flooding the streets. A new statue in memory of the late Queen And Prince philip receives a mixed reception, well hear from a sculptor about the challenges of capturing that likeness. Welcome to Bbc News thanks Forjoining us. Initial polls in the united states suggest Vice President Kamala Harris outperFormed Donald Trump in the president ial debate. But few expect tuesdays encounter to significantly shift the balance of whats expected to be a tight race. Ms harris received another boost on wednesday with