More than 1,000 palestinians, including many children, have been killed. My guest is former israeli Prime Minister ehud barak. Unimaginable horror has been unleashed. Where will it end . Ehud barak, in tel aviv, welcome to hardtalk. You have fought in many of israels wars. Youve led the country as Prime Minister. Have you ever experienced a mood in the country as you see it and feel it right now . This is the most severe blow that israel suffered since its establishment some 75 years ago. And the death toll of a devastating 1,200 within the first 2a, 30 hours, its something that never happened in our history. And in this case, its not a war. These are notjust soldiers. There are many citizens, many civilians, women, young babies, elderly people, even some holocaust survivors. And we still have 150, so to speak, in their hands. So its very tough. Great, huge failure of our Early Warning system, of our operational system. But we, the israelis, we are a defiant kind of species. We know how to unite under pressure. And im confident that we will win this battle once again. And we are fighting now, we have a war on the hamas, we intend to paralyse it. Any kind of military or operational capability. This is notjust a fight against israel. Its a barbarian, murderous terror of the like of daesh, as we call it, The Middle East isis. In the course of that answer, you referred to what is evident a massive intelligence and Security Failure in israel. Is it incumbent on israel to address that failure now . There are some immediate lessons or consequences, taken within hours. But any profound clarification of what exactly happened will have to wait until this clash either ends or declines to a level that enables this investigation. Its. |ts very painful. Its extremely painful and quite shocked. But i can tell you with a sense of proportion, israel is Strong Enough to fight the hamas, and even if it spread over to hezbollah, and even if some dormant cells will wake up injudea and samaria, or some iranian agents will try to killjews abroad, israel is strong. There is no existential threat to israel and we will win. When binyamin netanyahu, in that first day of reaction to hamas� s brutal assault, netanyahu said, israel is at war. This is a war that we will fight to the end. We will destroy hamas and it will change The Middle East forever. But to fight and win that kind of a war, israel needs to trust its leadership. Do you trust mr netanyahu to lead israel in this war . Look, it is not a secret that im probably the harshest critic on the public arena of netanyahu, and very deeply involved in the protests. But this terrible disaster basically united us. I dont think that its proper to deal now with my personal assessment of neta nyahu. He carries with him certain doubts, because in a certain way hes responsible. He was at the top of the hierarchy during the last ten months. And he was warned more than once by professionals in the intelligence, in the defence forces, that this judicial reform that he calls it, the reform, quote unquote, we call it a judicial coup detat, that the responses within the public are risking the security of israel, and he basically ignored it. So there is some responsibility, but we have a responsibility on him. And just in the last few hours, he added to his cabinet, which is basically very weak one as of now, he added gantz and eisenkot, the two gentlemen who are serious, serious professionals and it makes it a little bit better. As you say, in the last few hours, weve learned that there is going to be an emergency government, a War Management Threesome at the top of that government, which will include benny gantz, leader of one of the opposition parties, the National Unity party. So, complete siege, the defence minister, says of gaza. No electricity, no food, no water, no fuel allowed into that territory of 2. 3 million people. Is that acceptable . Now, for the time being, its acceptable. I dont think thats a policy to the end of time. And every statement, every operation during such a war, which has both tactical and somewhat more strategic intentions, and a lot to do with the perception of the situation. At this stage, i fully back this step, facing the atrocities of these crimes against humanity. What happened is unbelievable, i dont even want to dive into it right now. For the time being, its ok. And time will tell how it continues, dependent on other things. We in the outside world, we have seen the extent of the brutality, the nature of the atrocities committed by hamas on israeli soil. We have seen that. But what we also see and hear now, and it has to be said, and im sure you see it and think about it, too, is that gazas hospitals are already running out of vital supplies of anaesthetics, medicines, airway tubes for children. We know that the death toll in gaza has already passed 1,000, and that includes many children. And the question obviously has to be asked. This looks like collective punishment of a people in pursuit of a particular group. And there are International Laws and norms which say that civilians cannot be targeted in pursuit of waraims. You know, thats the difference between hamas and the state of israel. We are part of the enlightened world. The difference is that they came deliberately in order to cruelly slain. Slaughter basically, innocent civilians. When you fight against terror, which deliberately deploy itself within civilian society, there is certain amount, sometimes painful, but part of reality of collateral damage, people, the civilians, are sometimes killed as a result of it. Yeah, the evidence doesnt speak to israel right now making a distinction between hitting hamas and hitting civilian targets. Weve seen that 18 unrwa schools run by the un, and acting as shelters for civilians, have already been damaged in the bombing. And we know from the idf spokesman that right now, as he put it, this bombing is about causing damage. It is not about precision. The reality is that every target that where a bomb is launched, is a target that has to do with hamas. In all targets, even certain neighbourhoods is going to be attacked to get rid of the hamas deployment within it, the idf issue, several hours before then, a general kind of announcement to the public to leave these areas. Probably, if deliberately, hamas headquarters try to get immunity through deploying their offices or some installation or rocket launching kind of operations close to schools. It becomes a kind of a danger to whoever is in the school. And we basically announced many times since the beginning, some 100 hours ago, everyone to know that if you have any hamas installation or operation in your immediate vicinity, get out of there. Because every operation and activity and office or housing of hamas people is a target, and we will hit it. I have no doubt that humanitary kind of materials to treat wounded people in hospitals will not be blocked by israel. Well, they are being blocked right now. And when you tell me that people must get out, im wondering where they get out to, in one of the most densely populated places on earth, where it seems neighbourhoods across the strip are currently being targeted with ferocious bombardment. And when we know that israeli tanks are massing on the Boundary Fence and it seems inevitable they will go in, where are these people supposed to go . Look, there is still enough places in gaza which are not in the immediate vicinity. And if you look at a picture, you might see that probably 99 of the buildings in the city of gaza are Still Standing on their place. And those who are hitted are those where we know from our intelligence, and im sure that people who are living there know from what they see every day, that they are deployments of hamas. If i may, mr barak, youre an experienced politician as well as a military man. You know that in the course of the next hours, days and weeks, as that Palestinian Death toll rises, and its already gone beyond 1,000, you know that, for all of the massive sympathy that is felt for israel around the world, there will also be a clear line from many in the european union, from europe, from the United Nations and elsewhere, saying israel must adhere to the basics of International Law when it comes to protecting civilians. So my question to you is, at what point are the politicians of israel going to have to say to themselves, this death toll as it rises is becoming unacceptable . Look, im confident that the new kind of inner cabinet, im confident they understand without having a need to listen to this programme, or to you, or to me, they are fully aware of the International Law and they understand the dynamic that you have just described. And im confident it will be taken into account. But having said that, i can tell you that you have to think on what would have happened in any european country if they have isis or daesh operation on a huge scale, not on the other side of the world or thousands of miles apart, but on their. Half a mile from their border and operating inside their population. I cannot ignore that there will be Human Suffering there. It should be taken the context, we cannot afford stopping before it become clear and inevitable that hamas wont be able, not just for the next two years, but the next 20 years, to repeat such a disastrous attack as the last one, just last saturday. There is one other complicating factor in the Military Operation that weve begun to discuss. That is the fact that we believe around 150 israelis, including children, women and men, are currently held captive inside the gaza strip by hamas. I want to read to you words reportedly said by mr smotrich, a far right member of netanyahus cabinet, who said a couple of days ago regarding the hostages, we have to be cruel now and not consider the captives overmuch. As a military man and a politician in israel, are those words difficult but true . Or is that actually misrepresenting the hostages as a factor . This is a marginal messianic nut that netanyahu, for reasons that i can. I know, but i cannot really accept, brought into his his government this smotrich together with his partner ben gvir. And im fully confident that. What about what he said about the hostages . Does the israeli army effectively have to ignore the reality of those captives and their fate when it is prosecuting this Military Operation . After the entering into the inner cabinet of gantz and eisenkot, two former heads of the Israeli Defence forces and one of them even former minister of defence, im confident that every Cabinet Meeting and smotrich want to be part of this inner cabinet will take these constraints, basically, even without smotrichs statement, its still a very subtle constraint on our operation, and it will be taken into account seriously. Does the coming ground force invasion, and im assuming its going to happen because those tanks are gathered on the edge of gaza for a very clear reason, and netanyahus stated aim is the complete destruction of hamas. Does that Ground Invasion to you mean there is bound to be a long term Military Reoccupation of gaza . You know, you put yourfinger, stephen, on the real, real constraints on the whole operation. One is following the International Law. Another is the hostages. And third one is what to do once you take over the gaza strip. The Israeli Armed forces, ground forces. And i cannot accept the idea that its inevitable, nothing is inevitable, but its very highly probable that at a certain point, we will enter into the gaza. Israel can take over the main part of the gaza strip, except the city itself, probably within two days. And if they have to go into the heavily built area of the city itself, it might take probably a week or ten days. And then to clean it from every spot where the hamas left their infrastructure, probably another four weeks. So within five to six weeks, i believe the whole area could be under our control. And there is a question that the inner cabinet will have to contemplate seriously if it decides to enter. In fact, it had to contemplate it before it actually enters, ordered the incursion into the strip. What is the next step . What are we going to do with it . The ideal situation is that israel will pass the torch of control of this area, once its clearfrom hamas, to certain arab force made from egyptians, emiratis, moroccans, qataris, who will keep an order and arrange bringing back the palestinian authority, namely abu mazen, to control it. But thats idealistic picture. I. Im farfrom being sure that its possible, and well have to consider what to do next. Yeah, it clearly matters a great deal, what next. And i want to actually end on the bigger picture, if i may. I was reporting on you when you tried to make peace with yasser arafat, based on a two state solution, at the beginning of this century. You failed. But the truth is that we still have two peoples locked in close proximity on one strip of land between the Mediterranean Sea and the jordan river. You believed in territorial compromise then. You did not believe in Permanent Military occupation. You did not believe in the expansion ofjewish settlements. So i ask you right now how does this end . Netanyahu talks about changing The Middle East forever. But in your view, how does israel ensure long term peace and security now . Im not against changing The Middle East forever in the right direction. There might be a dispute about what the right direction looks like. But at least the first step are fully agreed among israel they need to destroy. Its not taking revenge, just to make this behaviour erased and eliminated from the region. For sure, from israel. I do not swear that our experience with hamas will cancel the possibility of emergence of such daesh like, or nazi like if you want, behaviour on our part or other part of the world. But we cannot accept it in our neighbourhood. So basically we agree on what has to be done now. We have to kind of paralyse any possibility of hamas, the terror, murderous, barbarian organisation, to stand once again. And this is it. Now, even the military before we go to the political vision for the long term even the military part of it might not end in gaza. Even during an incursion into gaza if it happens, or even without incursion into gaza, it might deteriorate in the north with hezbollah, and probably the iranians might be interested. You know, some people say that even the disaster in saturday was aimed at blocking the way for the triangular political deal between america. The united states, saudi arabia and israel. And this triangular deal is delayed for the foreseeable future. It can deteriorate into two fronts, into a clash in gaza, at the same time with the hezbollah. And i do not recommend. Isnt the simple truth, mr barak, and were almost out of time, but isnt the simple truth, just very briefly, that israel has contemplated living without a peace with the palestinians, of turning the palestinians somehow into a sideshow and making peace with all the other arabs . It is quite clear now that wont work. And to be honest with you. You, in your heart of hearts, have surely known for a long time that wont work. Ok, so its a grave mistake of the present government and in a way of the right political side, the right wing in israel. But as i mentioned, its not the issue right now. This dispute will have to be decided after this effort to paralyse the hamas has been successful. And i still stick to everything that i believed in. Im confident that we will have at the end. It might take a long time, its not practical immediately. When i left camp david that you have mentioned, i said five, 15, or 50 five zero years, when the time come to have an agreement, it will be about two state solution, about about keeping 80 of the settlers within several percent of the whole area, and having an independent israel well secure with all its strategic assets, side by side with a demilitarised, viable palestinian state. Thats the vision. Its not actually ourjob now. And when it become practical, i will be ready to give you another interview. All right. Ehud barak, thank you for joining me from tel aviv. We need to leave it there. Thank you. Hello. Some fresh autumn weather on the way. Chilly even for some of us in Northern Parts of the uk, but certainly nothing out of the ordinary. Its been so mild across many parts of the country so far this month. So were back to really where we should be this time of the year. So this is whats happening on thursday. This is the air mass, the temperature of the atmosphere. So still some warmth and humidity across the south. In fact, temporarily thursday into friday, well see a resurgence of that warmth as the Wind Direction changes temporarily from the southwest. But then come saturday and sunday, its a northerly and that autumn chill arrives touch of frost across Northern Areas by night, chill arrives, touch of frost across Northern Areas by night, even a little bit of wintry ness across the scottish hills. So lets have a look at the forecast then through the early hours, really quite cloudy and wet across some southern parts of the uk. But to the north of that, its generally clear and chilly. In the glens of scotland, temperatures barely above freezing, but most of our northern towns and cities around three to four degrees celsius. In the south, on the south coast, its still really quite mild sort of remnants of that warmth left over, but a lot of cloud during the day, little dribs and drabs of rain. And then i think across much of yorkshire, Northern Ireland, the bulk of scotland, a bright if not sunny day, just scattered fairweather clouds, 13, 1a, still 18 in the south. But then come the evening, widespread heavy rain sweeps into many parts of england and wales, a really wet thursday night into friday, really complicated weather map here. 0n the one hand, we have a Weather Front coming in, a low pressure from the south and weve got a cold front coming in from the north. You can just about see it here. So i think for a time wet in the morning on friday, temporarily, that warmth, it literally clips the southeast with temperatures up to 20 in london, 19 in norwich. But the colder autumn air arrives in scotland, Northern Ireland and Northern England as well. So its a northerly temporarily, but northerly, but then into next week, High Pressure builds and were right in the middle in the centre of this area of High Pressure. So that means the winds will be generally light, therell be a lot of sunshine around. So its going to feel very, very pleasant indeed. I think a lot of crisp autumn sunshine on the way. Thats it for me. Bye bye. Welcome to newsday, reporting live from singapore, im arunoday mukharji. The headlines. Israel pounds gaza into a fifth night as gazas only Power Station runs out of fuel. Top us diplomat Antony Blinken is bound for tel aviv, as President Biden again weighs in. I would argue it is the deadliest day for the jewish people since the holocaust. The deadliest day since the holocaust. Israel says 12 hundred people are now known to have killed in the attacks by hamas as shocking details continue to Emerge Of A Massacre in the kfar aza kibbuttz. And israel continues to mass soldiers and hardware close to the gaza border ahead of a possible Ground Invasion
comparemela.com © 2020. All Rights Reserved.