Stand in dignity together as a nation i feel that i need to send an apology to the lebanese people because we failed to achieve their ambitions due to the difficulties i have worked with my colleagues in the cabinet according to the directions of the Prime Minister who is following all the details with a lot of was done in order to respond to the demands of the people but no way does the reality go parallel with the ambitions after the bare root earthquake that has shaken the nation and due to the displaced the martyrs those who are still hungry i respect all of this and i submit my resignation to the government and i wish all the best to lebanon and stability and unity long live lebanon. Fana has more now from malta square in beirut. This is a blow to the Prime Minister has son who has been struggling for his government to have credibility and legitimacy not just at home but abroad but what we understand is that the Prime Minister as we speak is holding a meeting with his ministers and the possibility of a resignation is on the table so you mentioned the information minister resigning earlier this morning there were unconfirmed reports that other ministers are going to tender their resignation the government has not been able to cope with this disaster just look behind me the desperation among people theyve come to Martyrs Square just to get any help that they can receive from volunteers from n. G. O. S from Civil Society groups the government is absent the government is cash strapped so you can see water sandwiches people have lost so much 300000 people were made homeless by this blast and calls for a government resignation are growing louder now the optics may look good if the government indeed does resign i mean this is the demand of the people who have been demanding this for some time now even before the blast but many believe that behind the scenes a political deal is in the making especially after the visit of the french president to beirut he did talk about a Political Initiative and the french president was not just speaking on behalf of france he came here on behalf of the International Community so it seems behind the scenes there are negotiations possibly to form of what is known in lebanon as a National Unity government what that means Political Parties from across the political spectrum come together but thats exactly what protesters dont want. A board explosion is amazing to have caused billions of dollars worth of damage a virtual donors conference seeking to raise money for a rebuild is due to begin any time now its being hosted by france and the u. N. Afghanistans president is backing the release of 400. 00 taliban prisoners ashraf ghani says he respects the decision of the loya jirga consultative body to approve freeing socalled hardcore taliban fighters the. Group today i will sign the decree that i did not have the authority to sign before now i will sign the decree to authorize the release of the 400 taliban prisoners based on the request of the loya jirga and they will be released people are saying in better reeses president ial election as its longtime leader seeks a 6th term the main opposition candidate has gone into hiding hours before the vote after her top aides were detained by police. And his Health Secretary alex as ours arrived in taiwan for the 1st high level visit by a top american official in 4 decades is expected to meet taiwans president china claims sovereignty over taiwan and says the trip threatens stability in the region. Now with all the headlines more news on aljazeera after aljazeera what. Abu dhabi capital of the United Arab Emirates and the location of a financial controversy of huge fortunes won and lost. Its a story that revolves around the man on the left the indian billionaire tycoon doc to be our shetty. For several months time around this howl of aljazeera arabic channel follow the money trail in which the numbers involved are quite staggering. He looked into a man who owes millions and in one case over a 1000000000 u. S. Dollars. At the center of this debt crisis is an m c health an Abu Dhabi Based hospital provider with a global reach. It seemed that mc was riding the crest of a wave Health Care Spending in the u. A. E. Was high with patient numbers in the millions. The company had expanded into spain saudi arabia and the u. K. With some 20000 medical staff operating around 200 facilities. And n cs charismatic founder b. R. Shetty was well connected in the u. A. E. Counting among his friends the under secretary of the crown prince called dubey Mohamed Mubarak our mother away. The aljazeera arabic team discovered cover. Spondon between the 2 men at a time when the true scale of venom seized debts was starting to become public knowledge. It was january 2020 and shetty was seeking a meeting with his friend the advisor to the crown prince about the double. As shetty revealed the nature of n n cs debt crisis the advisor said that he was out of town but they agreed to meet the following week at an m r r t ocean palace. Meeting with at the end of january was targeted at a higher level shetty needed to engage with Shaikh Mohammed bin desired the crown prince of abu dhabi. The discussion at that meeting is known only to those who took part but what is certain is that shortly afterwards b r shetty flew to india and did not return. A series of outwardly friendly messages followed between shetty and al mazrui including reference to a private letter from shetty to the crown prince. Aljazeera wrote to the undersecretary of the crown prince cordova dubey Mohamed Mubarak al masri wanting to discover more about his january meeting with b r shetty it also asked to see the letter from dr shetty to the crown prince. But no reply was received. But by that time shetty s. And m. C. M. Car had begun tumbling down the 1st rumblings of financial trouble were in december 29th seen but by march 2020 Global Confidence in n m c was in freefall as was the companys openly traded share price. N n c announced that it had discovered suspected fraud and that hidden debts amounted to over 4000000000. 00 u. S. Dollars. The aljazeera arabic team has spoken to those close to shetty questioning former associates and Financial Experts in this program they pieced together the evidence which now reveals the previously untold story of the rise and fall of a selfmade indian billionaire. The men at the thought of the r. C. T. How can it have the and they had. I was never expected never never i fall from the clouds dr shittier saw was a big philanthropist he helped thousands of people and organizations recently 2 years ago he played charles bill got his asian of merely the gates to give half of his fortune she was given back to the society. For example they say she has. 2 floors of bush alley she bought 2 for yet but why he bought what. Fingal itll be by panic when shes giving back to the governor. Wanted to know how shes empire fell so far leaving a long trail of debt in its wake. The child who was clearly well connected and had a long track record of Business Success so where did it all go wrong. Because he had been as i broke a bar and still had our home a woman in the heart of the law and it had been that i mean the family. Ok if. There are. Just of the stuff and broke the law and. So i sort of bank. And actually what outfit. That are the similar. Themes are 30 years she took folk for a start went through what were up to me no food while at the hostel my with an f. N. Think fellows that their shitty and yet for. Doing it with not a damned one of food many of them with an if in the end. d d but who is beyond. Growing up in india he trained as a pharmacist d in the western city of money. Then in 1973 he traveled to the United Arab Emirates to as it were seek his fortune. 2 years later he founded new Medical Center health n m c responding to the demand for Quality Health care in the u. A. E. Very quickly the business expanded as new clinics opened across the country. With large numbers of Foreign Workers in the u. A. E. Sending their earnings back home also saw an opportunity in Money Transfer and opened a chain of outlets called u. A. E. Exchange. Business was booming and shetty was in the right place at the right time. Building relationships with the u. A. E. As all powerful shapes appeared to open doors for shetty and his ambition knew no bounds a tycoon was born and thanks to his highness save that missile from the land peace be upon his soul and hes given open welcome to anybody so when they came here nor Job Opportunity Program or pharmacist when they came here my brother mother advised me so go whatever you want to do do something good to the Community Give the community in mind and when they came here his highness exact better breckenridge t. V. He was telling Quality Health care for all at the affordable cost so i started the 1st to protect in the my way of being the doctor 1st doctor and then mc and one broome clinic we started as and today we have 200 facilities 208 for that is in 1000 countries 3000 doctors 8500000 patients a year until today it is 1. 00 to you 8000000000. 00 which is im very happy and what the what the capital. Bisect bank the money and the blessing for the right. Time around this hal and his team obtained documents that show how close shetty was to senior political figures in the u. A. E. One name the former Justice Minister abdullah homemade almas through a appears in these documents says a shetty business partner. Government ministers having private business interests in the middle east is not unusual or illegal and the partnership proved profitable for both men. Another associate is now here on bin mubarak. The current a minister of tolerance. This power of attorney document reveals that as culture minister he authorized shetty to be is official representative in shetty is pharmaceutical business neo pharma. To find out more about chechens business methods tamar almas how to track down one of his Close Associates in the u. A. E. A long time observer of b. R. Shetty. Agreed to be interviewed on condition that he remain anonymous and his voice be disguised said can you tell me about what do you know about mr b r city and how did he manage to reach this musician in the u e r r. R r b r. Known. Call at the moment. In terms of relationships. But hes still not as a doctor. You are. Free will. You know is wrong but you know. And so over time. And certainly no doubt was. Down. In 2011 there were changes at the top of the n. M. C. Group abdullah who made. The former Justice Minister was removed. Through a wood lathe to say that the amount he received for his shareholding was less than it was actually worth. In his place came to young investment specialists from a Company Called century and partners investments. They were hairy on the left and saeed out kobe c. There were plans to float the n. N. C. Health care group internationally a move that would bring in new investors from across the globe. In 2012 and mc became the 1st i would be company to be listed on the London Stock Exchange the initial Public Offering or i. P. O. Raised 186000000. 00 u. S. Dollars. Investors from across the world sort a slice of the action. But what was the significance of n m cs London Stock Exchange listing. For n m c its very important it gains against credibility it gains access to Institutional Investors it gains access to individual investors Retail Investors and as the company grew in this case it becomes part of the footsie 100 index and as it does that it gathers assets from index invest investors around the world clearly this company had enormous influence in the United Arab Emirates government it was branded as one of the most successful firms that the United Arab Emirates ever spawn off it was touted around the world as a shining success story. But the former Justice Minister no longer involved following the london listing the new amorality power brokers within the shetty empire with saeed al could they see as a hiding but some question that suitability for the job. Jasim. And even in haiti was a look at this is michelle aka mother shitty then hell you had a new plane with many a model for others she said. The atoll and the home. And they dont you has will have a list of modern a woman or a will that have i book that can let me a little think about them what i want with a home and what it will but. I also know im not im sorry about. That so i thought it was nothing since the tally. Lesser as sarah and they were not at that and. They help us regarding mr. Harry and said look how do they fit in to that relationship so the way it works in a new email. Is that they dont like to have. You know people are shot and documents they dont want this baby her you know trust nonroyal 2 signatures and. You know the. Goal. But these people are doing our proxy solution to mary and you know they are their world was acting on behalf of all. Was only. For you for. All your. So. Far nor are. The real. Shakman soul been desired are not often referred to simply as shipments or is the deputy Prime Minister of the United Arab Emirates. But did the billionaire shaikh play an unseen role in the shetty empire. And what was his connection to the new n m c power brokers alcoa basi and elmore early. Aljazeera roads to schekman so asking if he would comment on the allegation that saeed elka basi and harry of censuring investments acted as proxy directors on his behalf and that their shareholding was managed for his benefit giving him effective ownership of n n c else. But no reply was received shakman saw hold several other positions at the very top of m r r t politics and society his business interests are vast estimates put his net worth as high as 20000000000. 00 us dollars. And what i do want to business what would happen if i thought a thing about this deficit is there as either a lot of us ever did. And i thought i thought the theme with some of you had a lot to do with a. Poor. Brain to apply for cool well class. The 3rd and the one minute in a minute a 1000000 or less and. If you have your whole washed out and feel the hand but it was. There how bitterly to help. Where you went. At it and the lack thereof that what their religion who are. How are your feet. Badenhorst is a. Well thought that. Said what. Was in a molly out of a mobile home with. Her loved one much of them all the. More up a bit of it all then and then a bit all what the new year and they have been all generally. Fear and the not. Now one has. And now say hello. To one what will you. Let the have a lathe and the bill for my thoughts on the. Shanties business interests were huge. At their core was the n. M. C. Health care group providing hospital facilities in the u. A. E. And several other countries. Then theres fin a blood a Global Platform for payments and Foreign Exchange with millions of Foreign Workers in the middle east sending money back to their own countries this is a lucrative Business Travel x. And exchange to offend the ablest flagship brand. Theres also neo pharma a Factory Manufacturing prescription medication. Other parts of shut his Business Empire include companies a no man under morocco. An investment in 1000000000 marks of the muscles have been this you want to be a little more mystic what are. The i dont know what they were not that. So was shetty made the scapegoat for the decline of his Business Empire or was he the architect of his own misfortune. A search of registered companies in abu dhabi reveals an intricate web of different organizations some in chechens name others on the shetty and his Business Partners of these legitimate Trading Companies or is there a different explanation for the claims or the nyquil connemara mail is a machete cant be any so you know men who are american hockey can have it and then my at the other was laid out. Havent hama a shot be it as you have. This you have the show we can have a show because that would be i leave. A hurried where clearly they him what are our hearts. Because you know while. The show is a focus for hell him our. Live in amman and then realize that i mena. If i see the i will mushroom has a. Ladder we have and to kill jews and women feel hard but the feel. They have. To let you can and to at the less they will face he didnt have the hear you have had to work theres been business relationships not just in n. M. C. But in other companies as well i think whats evident is that the problems i dont im see may be replicated in other companies such as for neighbor with each also has had on the player that so there is definitely questions around you know how this relates to some of the other companies and where theres the you know where does the rot spread how far does the rot spread because it certainly doesnt seem to be just. You know specific and him seem like it when you tell around this whole must be a shit shes former colleague about the expansion of the u. A. E. Based companies particularly in health care. Let me of the west so on what interested him was the pace of this expansion and therefore whether there was any one of influence behind this exponential growth i understood from some things but by the it was actually thrown away for no reason. For example i was working in a hospital that a 2 bed hospital. It was never fall and suddenly 2070 they decided to beat another horse with the next 3400 at bats 400000000 of live for what we dont get we dont feel up there one we have why. How and why the shitty empire fell so spectacularly is a story in itself. It was 2018 and it seemed that she could do no wrong. The n. M. C. Group was riding high on the London Stock Exchange and investors queued up to buy shares. Its market value was more than 8000000000. 00 u. S. Dollars it showed more than 200. 00 for cillit is including hospitals and clinics in over 19 countries and its annual profits for the year were over 2000000000. 00 what could go wrong. Coming up in part to the spark that sent doc to be our shut his Business Empire into freefall amid allegations of a 1000000000. 00 fraud a tycoon flees to india. I believe but he was probably the real. Claims innocence in the events that have taken place he is portraying himself as a victim you suggesting that 3rd parties have fraudulently represented him and have forced his signature. Once welcome and now fear. And dividing a nation. Aljazeera explores germanys long Term Economic strategy of pursuing immigrants from the arab world i feel more german and syrian. A much money does a richer get those people you would think that. One german and im the new germans on aljazeera. The island of sardinia a famously adelie college a spot. Less well known as a proving grounds for war. Investigating claims that years of military training and arms testing. Triggered cancer last effects of me to the local population. Secret sardinia people in power on aljazeera. There are more call in doha the top stories on aljazeera lebanons information minister has become the 1st Senior Member of government to resign since the explosion in beirut on tuesday 158 people were killed when 2700 tons of Ammonium Nitrate exploded so no one has more from martyr square in beirut we understand is that the Prime Minister as we speak is holding a meeting with his ministers and the possibility of a resignation is on the table so you mentioned the information minister resigning earlier this morning there were unconfirmed reports that other ministers are going to tender their resignation the government has not been able to cope with this disaster just look behind me the desperation among people theyve come to Martyrs Square just to get any help that they can receive from volunteers from n. G. O. S from Civil Society groups the government is absent the government is cast strapped so you can see water sandwiches people have lost so much on the port explosion is estimated to have caused billions of dollars worth of damage and at the start of a virtual donors conference french president and. Other World Leaders to act quickly and efficiently he says lebanons future is at stake afghanistans president is backing the release of 400. 00 taliban prisoners ashraf ghani says he respects the decision of the loya jirga consultative body to approve freeing socalled hardcore taliban fighters their release is a taliban precondition for talks over the future of the war battered country. People have a saying in bellerose says president ial election as a long time leader seeks a 6th term the main opposition candidate has gone into hiding hours before the vote after top aides were detained by police u. S. Health secretary alex as ours arrived in taiwan for the 1st high level visit by a top american official in 4 decades is expected to meet taiwans president china claims sovereignty over taiwan and says the trip threatens to billets in the region. Linda rajapaksa has been sworn in as frank as Prime Minister for the 4th time his Wedding Party won the parliamentary election in a landslide and been serving as interim Prime Minister. As all your headlines im back with more news after we return to aljazeera laugh. And count 56 and its. What its. Like to see a childs face. To. See. The indian billionaire doc to be our shetty made his fortune in the early 2000 building a vast Business Empire encompassing hospitals pharmacies and money exchanges but it did not last. Tomorrow miss howl of al jazeera arabic has established that at the core of shanties Financial Success was his Health Care Business based in the United Arab Emirates and n. C. L. But that it also included the currency firms travelex and u. A. E. Exchange and a medication manufacturer neo pharma. However the blow that caused it all to full term in 2020 came not from the middle east but from an unexpected source in the United States. The American Investment firm muddy waters takes its unusual name from a chinese proverb that says muddy waters make catching fish easy. The Company Seeks out publicly listed companies that appear outwardly in good health but which in reality a deeply unstable. Then they whats call short the stock betting that when the financial truth comes out the share price will tumble so making a healthy profit from muddy waters. Muddy waters found a carson blow is whats known as a short seller that is he speculates on the future decline of a companys share price. So a lot of people here are short and they think that you or your bad guy or youre doing something wrong part and lock up like the water is the investing moment ounce of the shore and short seller at carthage we had from the n. Y. S. E. President this weekend he said that short selling against a company feels kind of taking on american been called a lot of nasty names ive been called a financial terrorist ive been called a fraud so you have no regrets. Why would i. In december 29th seen muddy waters published a damning report into the state of emcees finances. It said the middle East Hospital chain had grossly understated its debt and overstated its cash. And mc shares plummeted by 48 percent wiping 1500000000. 00 of the shetty family fortune. Muddy waters claim that an emcees performance was quote too good to be true and the market believed them. The money it was a report is an interesting document its quite low key but its very specific in terms of its accusations it identifies issues with revenue recognition it identifies issues with the prices paid for certain assets at the same time the report questions the margins the operating margins of the company the company was reporting margins in its 1st half 2018 results of 24. 26. 62 percent in the 1st half of 2019 and it was reporting year on year growth of 32. 6 percent in revenue and muddy waters simply looked at the peer group that was operating in the same markets and the numbers that were coming or being thrown off by the peer group and says those numbers are not possible it also suggests that the company was. The company was declaring costs of debt which were inconsistent with the size of debt that was on the Balance Sheet it identifies on the cleared leases. And on top of that it points at issues of governance specifically of independence. The muddy waters report also affected a number shetty company. Its a large payments and money trading business the Umbrella Firm for 2 big high street brands travelex an exchange. Aljazeera us carson block why exactly he had targeted an im scene he replied. It was a fraud with a whole host of issues what we were surprised about was how massive the fraud was we knew that there was more debt at an mc than reported for the company to reveal that there was in fact 6600000000. 00 instead of the 2100000000. 00 was remarkable. When i come in its that. Time around this held us to Financial Times journalist power and mc was able to hide what was going on inside the company and many is the 1000000. 00 question you know there were certainly red flags there was red flags that in the case of muddy waters they picked up certain. Red flags within the accounts and broadly analysts were actually very supportive of the company its clear that the Financial Statements produced by the company for some period have been a pack of lies. Its also clear that there is collusion between a group of executives inside and outside the company in manipulating those accounts to be a pack of lies but the most concerning thing of all is that these accounts are audited by one of the most well known Accounting Firms in the world ernst and young boy whose responsibility it was to check the accounts of m. M. C. And to identify a fraud like this a long time before it reached the proportions of the it eventually. So why did mcs auditors ernst and young fail to flag the financial black holes in the companys accounts and was there a potential conflict of interest with former instant young staff serving on the board of one of shechita companies. For their part the auditor said in july 2020 that theyd flagged problems a 10 m. C. As early as march 29th seen in their audit memo called on an m c to quote strengthen its internal control process in dealing with banks and i think a y is going to be under a lot of pressure as a result of whats happened here. You know again its an issue when you look at you look at the company you can see that there are a couple of former a y. Employees on the board of an m. Say or so various points that i was making quite a lot of money out of work for the company as well as doing you want it for the company what we do know is that in the u. K. The Financial Reporting council which is kind of the regulator for Financial Reporting is all really instigate an invented investigation into the wise order thing of the most recent set of accounts are suspect this is going to be this is not going to be a pleasant experience for the audit and certainly. Aljazeera asked instant young to comment on the allegations that there were shortcomings in their 2018 audit procedure and the 2 former partners serving on the fin a black board was a conflict of interest. They replied saying it was not their policy to comment on the companies that they audit they added quote the wire has policies and procedures in place to ensure we comply with the relevant ethical standards. What had been a rising star of the London Stock Exchange to come crashing down to earth shares were suspended and an independent panel was appointed to inquire into the companys finances. Saeed al kobe see. Harry and be a shetty all resigned from the board. Also asked tom powdrill about the impact of the n. M. C. Case on the London Stock Exchange i think if it wasnt for the fact that there was a Global Health emergency under way this would be an enormous story and it has been hugely embarrassing to london as the market i mean again i think is worth a restating you know there are 2 Companies Involved here and emcees the 1st 100 this has gone down and then for neighbors a foot c 250 our been working in this field for almost 20 years and ive never seen a story like this where 2 Companies Similar tenuously involving the same group of people have failed at the same time its been enormously damaging to our reputation that we you know we repeatedly trump as icon of luck bastion of good Corporate Governance so its been its been hugely damaging i dont think you can you know i cant think of a previous case like it but equally i do think were going to have to look again at listing. You know there are certain features of Companies Like this that i just dont think really are. Through to a Public Market and i think therefore you do have to again look at regulation at some point it is the biggest scandal on the Stock Exchange one of the biggest scandals on the Stock Exchange since our see the Natural Resources company and boomy and other Natural Resources companies earlier in the decade so i think its too early to say i think we need to have the evidence and the information we are all only seeing snippets and not the full picture and i think thered be a lot more to come the United Arab Emirates has become a magnet for capital and investment from around the world its trying to become another singapore another london and its been very successful but clearly there are some problems if you look at the n. M. C. Scandal its very disturbing that the executive committee didnt catch it the fact that it was bankrupt 2000000000. 00 and debt became 6000000000. 00 in debt the banks didnt catch it the auditors ernst and young didnt catch it and its created a massive scandal that will impact the United Arab Emirates because you know the Arab Emirates prides itself on having the best functioning the best managed and the most sophisticated legal system in the middle east for Corporate Governance clearly it failed spectacularly here. On the surface this looks like a complex financial story business failure on a grand scale but its actually a simple matter of governance the ethics of how Companies Manage the money that passes through their hands aljazeera wrote to one of the leading figures involved in the rise in the full of the shetty empire shake now. The current minister of tel. And its. It does tend to confirm that as a full much chairman of the medical Manufacturing Business neo foma the minister had authorized chetty to be his official representative. The ministry replied but only to say that aljazeera is email had been received and had been sent to the relevant departments. Around this hell wanted to know if they had been clear alarm bells over n n cs governance at a time when the u. A. E. Was warned as recently as april 2020 of the risks of a weak financial regulator a framework has a clear much michael im in mali for the feel here with me and that we could have lost my footing. They have been much more i am headed with this. With them we have a well what do you have of me from one half of the nominee yet the. Im wild with me from the us and i think. 3000000 more. Than we have. Where would that be so football by hey ally leave me in money and welcome but one head will come to me a duel he had withheld from and we left him with the head that that the more a company with the fam. I mean how the. European. Be set up which would hike america as i would have them what i think americas money was the flooding him by had the. The 3rd more october the Financial ActionTask Force Report which has recently come out is a comprehensive look at the Money Laundering and terrorist financing problems around the world and these problems are in every country but certainly the middle east is a focal point for that and the u. A. E. Says falling down on properly policing these this leads to International Scrutiny internet. National concern it means the you know he is not always the best partner in the region in terms of security concerns and other concerns and that the u. A. E. Continues to be at the top of the concerns that many people have that Money Laundering can still beat down there which threatens its future as a Financial Center because if the Money Laundering problem is not eventually solved eventually there will be sanctions from other countries because this kind of thing cannot go on indefinitely. So what of the man at the center of this story of fortunes won and lost at the height of his success. Was said to have had a net worth of around 3500000000. 00 u. S. Dollars though today his wealth is only a fraction of that figure. On the 8th of april 2020 his company n n c health went into administration in the u. K. Due to insolvency. Later that month on the 27th of april the central bank of the u. A. E. Ordered the seizure of his familys assets in the country. Tom around this hell approached by now in india for comment he directed aljazeera to a Statement Issued 2 days after his assets had been seized in the u. A. E. The statement read. The series of events is this number 21000 have shocked me as much as anyone else including the ellis fraud and misconduct at n m c as well as their existence and extent of Undisclosed Company debts. To see everything that my family and i have a strived to build over the past 45 years eroded over the course of a few short months and mainly due to the misconduct and wrongdoing of people i put so much trust in saddens me beyond words. I intend to work tirelessly to clear my name and assist any authorities in getting to the truth and help them in sewer that misappropriated are missing funds returned by the perpetrators to their rightful owners. On the 24th of july 2020 aljazeera email dr shetty to see if he had any further comment but he did not reply. Dr shetty claims innocence in the events that have taken place he is portraying himself as a victim he is suggesting that 3rd parties have fraudulently represented him and have forged his signature and effectively have have defrauded him of assets. I think its not possible until the investigation is complete to identify the roles of the individuals but i think it is there is a saying that there is no smoke without fire are some of the other shareholders have made no comment so far and we dont know what their position is cynthia omeara who was referring to harry and sidled kobe c. They have not made any Public Comments apart from i believe mr. Has made comments just to say that you know e was not involved in any wrongdoing but other than that they have not commented. And they have you know they have kept out of the picture sure how old are you at the moment dr. Thomas williams will be men and you know how the chefs shop 2700000 are. You on the methadone. Thought of what. It will be a c. 2. 7000000 that is fossil so im really up with limb here 1700000 are. To help him and i thought that he and. Wendy williams are juma then every one of my did not appreciate the hobby shop so the. Lemony are out and i kept out of the committee not done so by many others that have submitted that home and then. Think i dont know how to hold. A hassle so i shake up with the woman he then minhinnick of her that. She had to call the out of the unit and hold her. 6 of the theater will politely and he shops at that and have them all the dolly yanni here. And mischka that in. A letter he had she known can and. The and this yes most or whoever is there at the mouth of it will be by his out admirable hobby aljazeera roache to shakman saw through u. A. E. Company of which he is a board member. It just him if as patron of sent you an investment he was aware of the high debt position of an mc health. It also asked if shakman saw could comment on dr his assertion that quote Serious Fraud and wrongdoing appears to have taken place at denham see shipman saw did not reply. Oh that that i love been hacking me how you judge who knock on about what the hell you are to not. Be a limit out there on and to have to 3 have the hell you sure do not 1000 and then the other highly likely jet hell you had to knock down my brain and imre what do an awful crash and how off of the sling home i had at the hack a coffee. Yet it will emerge out of my father so giving that relationship why do you think mr b r shitty chose to leave the country i mean you eat and head to india. Are i believe that. He was probably human. However you know were. Wrong. While the b r shetty empire is today a shadow of its former self it is still partly intact whether the shuttle family can recover remains to be seen. From the day in december 29th that the american short selling firm muddy waters revealed emcees vast debts and overstated profits confidence in the 1st u. K. Publicly listed company collapsed. Many questions remain. Did it ever exist in the 1st place. There are other broader questions about the Corporate Governance of this vast Business Empire. But ultimately the true power behind this huge collapse. Been identified. Until those missing links at the highest level of fully revealed there may be no satisfactory conclusion to the dramatic story of the rise and fall of. Sweat tears and sometimes blot but for them its what they dreams i mean dont. Just tells a story of. Im humble background or training my life. On the former champion who gives his old. Casablanca. On his ear. The pencil case guys across much of south america. To the north im trying to plot in the south the rain pushing into Central Chile but mostly fine and drawn to the north east of 1001 is areas the winds are coming out from the southwest so should stay dry i dont want to shout. Coast of brazil to find a ray of wall one as well with a high of. Bunty of a scottish across Central America some heavy developing late in the day honduras nicaragua and then we watching this and they should become a Tropical Storm but the good news is through monday it continues to head away from mexico taking away that the very heavy rain but its a more of that certainly through will Central Regions elsewhere throughout the caribbean wanted to scattered showers and then up into the United States plenty of scattered thunderstorms across the upper midwest the southeast as well and then also as we won in colorado on it is dry the humidity is very low and has been very strong often in winds and this just continuing to fuel this one particular 9000 have now been will stay wholesome dry again those winds quite strong you can see by anything of course in the forecast but to the north through sunday theyve got quite a mass of rain showers working their way through the Northern Plains and all of that will spread east as we head on into monday. Mean its just 6. Hours born in a family of 11 sloughed i did it. Because of. My money and wanted but still everybody has one you know its life so thats how i came to bear. Serious matter we had to go bust city center at least to get ahead begging for food and not just walking. In the lead in a 2 metre thats. Where you all come. And youve been up a class act towards detecting to me is just silly