promising, there were nine who were part of the discussions that didn t agree with these proposals. and i think this is really significant and important because what it would mean is companies would have to pay more tax than other countries where they are selling their products or services, and our existing system is totally rotten, there s all kinds of innovation going on in terms of there s all kinds of accounting tricks that go on that mean there s all sorts of avoidance. when these proposals were initially announced by the 620, there were two key criticisms from tax justice campaigners. one is that it s too low, 15%, joe biden adjusted to 21% but the bigger problem is, if these planes are similar, we need to see the details still, is that they ll potentially primarily benefit richer countries, and it ignores where production is. that