giffords. shortly after the times editorial ran, the number published a construction, quote, an editorial on thursday about the shooting. representative steven scalise incorrectly stated that a link existed between political rhetoric and the 2011 shooting of representative gabby giffords. in fact, no such link was established. the editorial link also established a map by the committee before the shooting, it depicted electoral districts, not individual democratic lawmakers unique crosshairs, does sarah palin have a case? joining me a professor of professor yarl practice at columbia. he wrote how the new york times editorial page got sued by sarah palin. professor, thank you for being here. clearly, they screwed up. the issue, right, is whether it