miliband. you talk about the cost of living issues, you are going to put forward a motion in parliament today, one of the things the labour party are proposing is this vat, the removal of that on labour energy bills removal of that on energy bills. the prime minister says this will be a blunt instrument which gives savings to rich people who don t need help, do you accept that? i don t, and the prime minister spent a large part of the brexit referendum and after saying he would do this if brexit happened. this is one of the benefit of brexit. 0ur position is this, we are proposing a windfall tax on the oil and gas producers who have made billions during this crisis. that will help fund vat cuts for all families. the package of measures will give £200 to all families facing a very steep rise in bills, and most help for the poorest. most help for those who need it most. that s the right thing to do. we can help about a third of